Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
RESEARCH/DEVELOPMENT/RESEARCH/DEVELOPMENT/RESEARCH/DEVELOPMENT/RESEARCH/DEVELOPMENT
Surface oxidation enhances the absorption of laser energy significantly
and has little influence on the mechanical properties of laser welds
ABSTRACT. The joining of thin sheet because of several advantages: low heat laser beams by the sheet surface and
steel generally involves conduction input, little distortion, small heat-affected strict requirement for workpiece fitup,
mode welding, in which the reflection of zone (HAZ), good mechanical properties limit the applications of laser welding in
the laser beam by the sheet surface is and excellent repeatability of welds. It industries. The effect of multiple reflec-
high. The absorption of laser energy by has been reported that laser welds de- tions of the laser beam in the keyhole,
the workpiece increases significantly creased sheet formability by 10–18%, which increases the absorption of laser
during keyhole laser welding, in which a while mash-seam welds decreased energy by more than 90% in keyhole
vapor-plasma-filled cavity is formed. The formability by 29–35% (Ref. 1). Fatigue welding, is not observed in conduction
reflectivity of cold-rolled thin sheet steel life performance of laser welds was in- mode welding. A small portion of the
was found to be in the range of 65–80% creased by 36–126% over resistance laser energy is absorbed by the surface
in CO2 laser welding. The reflectivity de- welds (Ref. 2). Therefore, in the future, it and the rest is reflected in laser conduc-
creased to about 30% when the sheet is expected that laser welding will be tion welding. This process is known as
surface was oxidized before laser weld- used more widely to join a variety of ma- Fresnel absorption (Ref. 4).
ing. In the laser welds with surface terials in industries. A number of investigations on the re-
oxidation, the oxygen inclusions and Most thin sheet steels are cold-rolled flection of laser beams by metal surfaces
porosity were not found, but the grain low-carbon or mild steels. The weldabil- was carried out, but most work was for
size was large. However, the tensile ity of such materials is usually excellent polished metals (Refs. 5–8). Theoretical
strength of all welds — with or without and lasers can be utilized to achieve values of reflectivity of polished metals
surface oxidation — was higher than the good quality welds. The conduction were usually estimated based on Drude
base metal. The toughness of the welds welding mode (rather than the typical theory. Some theoretical and experi-
with surface oxidation degraded, be- keyhole welding mode) is likely to be en- mental data for both CO2 and Nd:YAG
cause of the small amount of oxygen con- countered in the laser welding of thin lasers listed in Tables 1 and 2 show that
tent, but it was still comparable to the sheet steel (Ref. 3), when the laser beam although the reflectivity was quite high
toughness of the welds without surface spot size is generally comparable to the for polished metals, it decreased with an
oxidation. The oxygen content in the thickness of the sheet or laser intensity is increase in temperature. It was also
welds with surface oxidation was found insufficient to boil the materials. Con- found that the reflectivity of AISI 4340
to be slightly higher than in the welds duction welding has been reported to be steels for CO 2 lasers decreased from
without surface oxidation. The mechani- well suited to weld materials under ap- 93.1 to 88.3% in the temperature range
cal properties of the welds with surface proximately 0.5 mm (Ref. 3). However, a of 20–500°C (68–932°F) at an argon
oxidation were found to improve when few problems in laser welding of thin flow rate of 25 L/min (Ref. 9). Changes of
steel powders consisting of manganese sheet steel, such as the high reflection of reflectivity with CO2 laser intensity for
and silicon were used during welding. 35NCD16 steels in solid, liquid, vapor
and plasma states were studied (Ref. 10).
Introduction The reflectivity of polished steels de-
creased continuously from 95% in solid
Thin steel sheets are extensively used KEY WORDS state to 85% in liquid, 70% in vapor and
in industries producing products such as Laser Welding 60% in plasma, at a laser intensity of 105
washer bodies, medical and electronic Conduction Mode W/cm 2. When the laser intensity
components. Laser welding is consid- Surface Oxidation changed from 105 W/cm2 to 106 W/cm2,
ered to be a suitable manufacturing pro- Sheet Steel the reflectivity of the polished steels de-
cess for thin sheet steel structures Cold Rolled clined from 95 to 55% in solid state,
CO2 Laser from 85 to 52% in liquid and from 70 to
Reflectivity 45% in vapor (Ref. 10). Incident angles
J. XIE is with Edison Welding Institute, Colum- of the laser beam have little influence on
bus, Ohio. A. KAR is with Center for Research Powder
Mechanical Property reflectivity if the angle is less than 20 deg
and Education in Optics and Lasers (CREOL)
and Department of Mechanical, Materials and Oxygen (Ref. 4).
Aerospace Engineering, University of Central Surface conditions of metals influ-
Florida, Orlando, Fla. ence the reflection of laser beams signif-
RESEARCH/DEVELOPMENT/RESEARCH/DEVELOPMENT/RESEARCH/DEVELOPMENT/RESEARCH/DEVELOPMENT
temperature. Reflectivity generally de- strate surface, the
creases as resistivity increases (Refs. 4, reflectivity is found
11, 14). The temperature-dependent re- to be in the range of
flectivity for polished metals has been 20–35%, because
theoretically obtained in an earlier work of the irregular re-
(Ref. 14), as shown in Table 4. It has been flections of the
found that the absorptivity of Nd:YAG laser beam by the
lasers is about 3.16 times higher than that steel powders.
of CO2 lasers and the reflectivity of pol- In the laser con-
ished metals for both CO2 and Nd:YAG duction welding of Fig. 1 — An experimental setup for measuring reflectivity.
lasers is quite high — even at the melting thin sheet steel,
temperatures. Therefore, most of the strong reflection of
laser energy is reflected away during the CO2 laser beam
laser conduction welding. results in the waste deg
200 µm
Fig. 6 — Oxygen content in laser welds. Fig. 7 — Typical stress-strain curves obtained in tensile tests.
Fig. 8 — Ultimate tensile strength of laser welds and base metal. Fig. 9 — Toughness of laser welds and base metal.
RESEARCH/DEVELOPMENT/RESEARCH/DEVELOPMENT/RESEARCH/DEVELOPMENT/RESEARCH/DEVELOPMENT
Wavelength (µm) 10.6 1.315 1.06 10.6 1.315 1.06
33–40. and welding power absorption. International of CO2, Nd:YAG and chemical oxygen-iodine
4. Steen, W. M. 1991. Laser Materials Pro- Communication in Heat and Mass Transfer 17: lasers. Journal of Laser Applications 9: 77–85.
cessing. New York N.Y., Springer-Verlag, pp. 147–154. 15. Kou, S. 1987. Welding Metallurgy,
47–48. 10. Fabbro, R., Bermejo, D., Orza, J., p. 66, John Wiley & Sons, New York, N.Y.
5. Johnson, P. B., and Christy, R. W. 1975. Sabatier, L., Leprince, L., and Granier, V. 1990. 16. Jorgensen, M. 1980. Increasing en-
Optical constant of copper and nickel as a CO2 Laser and Application II, Proc. ECO3, ergy absorption in laser welding. Metal
function of temperature. Physical Review B: SPIE Vol. 1276, 461–467. Ed. by H. Opower. Construction 12(2): 88.
Solid State (11): 1315. The International Society for Optical Engi- 17. Abbott, D. H., and Albright C. E.
6. Walters, C. T., Tucker T. R., Ream, S. L., neering, the Netherlands. 1994. CO2 shielding gas effects in laser weld-
Clauer, A. H., and Gallant, D. J. 1981. Ther- 11. Arata, Y., and Miyamato, I. 1972. ing mild steel. Journal of Laser Applications
mal coupling of CO2 laser radiation to metals. Some fundamental properties of high power 6: 69–80.
Ed. by K. Mukherjee and J. Mazumder in Laser laser beam as a heat source (report 2). Trans-
in Metallurgy, 195–206. Presented at Pro- action of Japan Welding Society 3: 152–162.
ceedings of the 110th AIME Annual Meeting, 12. Hopkins, J. A., Semak, V. V., and
Chicago, Ill. McCay, M. H. 1994. Calorimetric measure-
7. Duley, W. W. 1985. Laser materials in- ments of the influence of surface preparation
teractions of relevance to metal surface treat- on the absorption of 10.6 µm radiation. Ed. by
ment, edited by C. W. Draper and P. Mazzoldi, T. O. McCay, A. Matsunawa and H. Hugel,
3–16. Presented at Proceedings of NATO Ad- 838–845. Presented at Proceedings of the In-
vanced Study Institute on Laser Surface Treat- ternational Conference on Lasers and Electro-
ment of Metals, Italy. Optics (ICALEO ‘94), Laser Institute of
8. Stern, G. 1990. Absorptivity of CW America, Orlando, Fla.
CO2, CO and YAG-laser beams by different 13. Patel, R. S., and Brewster, M. Q. 1990.
metallic alloys, 25–35. Presented at Pro- Effect of oxidation and plum formation on low