Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
OF
NON-CIRCULAR SHAFTS
INTRODUCTION
Generally for power transmission, circular shafts are used because there is
uniform stress distribution along any radius of the shaft. Plane sections of the
shaft remain plane after the application of twisting moment, as a result there is
no distortion in the sections of shafts and change in volume of the shaft is zero.
For stationary torque application, non-circular shafts of different sections such
as square, rectangular, triangular, elliptical solid, or hollow are used.
The assumption that transverse sections of the shaft remain plane after the
applications of torque does not hold good for shafts of non-circular section. Only
the lines of symmetry remain straight; all other lines in the section go out of
plane and the section gets severely distorted. Figure 1 shows the undeformed
shaft of square section and deformed shape after the application of a twisting
moment along the axis of the shaft.
L r
T
,
L Tr
G
r J G
Tr r T
, G L unit length Figure 5 Rectangular section
JG L J L
The values of K for various ratios of
b are given in tables, such as
a
presented here.
Tr
Maximum shear stress, [for circular sections ]
K1 Ta
J
J
where K1 is another constant again depending upon the ratio of
b .
a
Table Values of constants for rectangular section
or
where
where
For the sake of comparison let us take
b =1.5.
a
From tables K = 3.136, K1 = 1.696, K2 = 0.541
If we compare the results of maximum shear stress and angular twist, from
two analyses, we can find only negligible difference between the two analysis.
The maximum intensity of shear stress, , occurs at the centre of the longer side
for rectangular cross section as shown in Figure 6. Figure 7 shows the distortion of
the ends of a shaft of square section.
θ =
where
Exercise 6.1
For the elliptical section shaft, the expressions for maximum shear stress and
angular twist per unit length are
and
A shaft of elliptical section with minor axis 2a and major axis 2b is subjected
to a torque of 2 kNm. If the maximum shear stress in the shaft is not to
exceed 80 N/mm2, determine the major and minor axes, if b = 1.5a. What will
be the angular twist in a meter length in this shaft under the given torque?
G = 80000 N/mm2.
or a3 =
Minor axis = 44 mm
Major axis = 66 mm
G = 40 kN/mm2.
TORSION OF A SHAFT WITH EQUILATERAL TRIANGULAR SECTION
G = 80000 N/mm2.
= 100 N/mm2
Side, a = 40 mm
Angular twist per meter length,
θ =
Determine (i) maximum shear stress developed in shaft and (ii) angular
twist per meter length of the shaft.
G = 84 kN/mm2.
PRANDTL’S STRESS FUNCTION FOR TORSION
The stress function approach is also useful when dealing with torsion on a
prismatic element with a noncircular cross section. Airy’s stress function cannot
be used here since the general torsion problem does not fall into the category
of a plane elastic problem. Thus, for pure torsion, the equations of equilibrium
and compatibility must be reformulated.
xy zx
0
y z
s x xy zx
Fx 0
x y z
If a stress function (y, z), called the Prandtl’s stress function, exists such
that
xy zx
xy 0 or
y z
z
2 2
zx 0
y yz zy
The equilibrium equation is automatically
satisfied.
w xy
v xz
For noncircular cross sections, the surface warps,
and in general the point will also deflect in the x
directon u. However, this is independent of x and
u = u (y, z). The strains xy and zx are
v u u
xy
z
x y y
w u u
zx y
x z z
Since = [E/2(1+n)],
E u
xy
z
21 y
E u
zx y
21 z
2 2 E E
2 (x -1)
y 2
z 1 y y z z 1
This equation is called the Poisson’s equation, it is the governing
equation for the torsional stress function .
At the boundary, the net shear stress must be tangent to the boundary.
Thus,
net
xy dy xy
or zx dy xy dz 0 zx
zx dz dy
dz
Substituting in xy zx results in
z y
dy dz 0
y z
However, since = (y, z), the above equation can be written
d 0
Since this requirement applies to the boundary, is constant along the
boundary of the cross section. The value of this constant is arbitrary
and is normally chosen to be zero. If the boundary of the cross section
is a well-behaved function of y and z such as a circle, ellipse, etc., the
equation of the boundary becomes an excellent stress function.
To relate the stress function to the transmitted torque T, as seen in the
figure, the net torque about the x axis due to the stresses on the dydz
element is (yzx – zxy)dydz. Thus, the total torque is
T y zx z xy dydz
Substitution of
xy zx z
z y
gives
T y z dydz y
y z
Let’s consider the first term in the integral. Integrating this with respect to
y by parts gives
y y dydz y y dy dz y y1 dy dz
y2
where y1 and y2 are boundary points for the dz slice. However, as stated
earlier, is zero at the boundary. Thus is zero at y1 and y2, and the first
term within the integral disappears, resulting in
y y dy dz dy dz
In a similar manner, the second integral gives identical results, so that we
have
T 2 dy dz
Example
k y 2 z 2 ro2
z
ro
0
r
Integrating and solving for k results in
T
k
p ro4
The polar moment of inertia of a circular cross section is J = (p/2)ro4. Thus,
T
k
2J
Substituting k into the stress function, we get
T 2
2J
y z 2 ro2
The shear stresses are determined as
Tz Ty
xy zx
J J
We should note that at any given point, the net shear stress is given by
T Tr
x ( net ) z y
2 2
J J
which is identical to that used in
elementary strength of materials.
For the angle of twist, substitution of the stress function
T 2
2J
y z 2 ro2
into 2 2 E
2 yields
y 2
z 1
T T E
J J 1
21
T
EJ
If the total length of the bar is L, the angle of twist across the entire
length is L , and thus,
G
21
TL
E
EJ 21
zy
x
zx
y
yz
yz
xz
xz yz
yz
(from page 57)
yz
yz
yz
yz
xz
yz
T
T
T
T T
T T
T T
T T
T
TORSION OF
THIN WALLED
SECTIONS
t1 dl 1 − τ2dl 2 = 0
or
dT = hdQ = hq ds
This equation T = 2q A is
generally known as Bredt-Botha
equation.
Shear strain,
dL
Strain energy for the small element =
Shear stress
But shear strain,
G Shear modulus
1
Shear strain energy tdsdL
2
but
Moreover,
T2 ds
du 2 dL
8A G t
Let us take dL = 1, so that we can find out strain energy per unit length
where integral
The figure shows the thin walled section 3a × 2a × t and a solid circular
section of diameter d.
Maximum shear stress in circular section,
But
or
or
where
but d = 2a
So,
But θ = θ′
So,
Exercise 6.4
G = 80000 N/mm2.
TORSION OF THIN RECTANGULAR SECTIONS
δl
T1 = 2 q1 A1
where A1 = area enclosed by the centre line of cell 1.
Twisting moment T2 about O due to q2 in cell 2:
For continuity, the angular twist per unit length in each cell will be the
same. For closed thin sections
For cell 1,
For cell 2,
Shear flow q1, q2, and angular twist θ can be worked out using the equations
derived.
Example The figure shows the dimensions of a double walled cross-
section in the form of a rectangle and a triangle. A torque of 4 kNm is
applied. Calculate the shear stress in each part and the angle of twist per
meter length. G = 82 kN/mm2.
Say,
shear flow in rectangular cell= q1 and shear flow in triangular cell = q2
Area,
Line integrals,
Now torque,
T = 2q1 × A1 + 2q2 × A2
4000 × 103 Nmm = 2 × 15 × 103 × q1 + 2 × 7.5 × 103 × q2 (i)
2000 = 15q1 + 7.5q2
But θ in cell 1 = θ in cell 2
So,
But
Substituting in Eq. (ii), we get
A steel girder of the section is shown in the figure. It has a uniform thickness
of 12 mm throughout. What is the allowable torque if maximum shear stress
is not to exceed 30 MPa? What is the angular twist per meter length of the
girder? What is the shear stress in middle web of the section?
G = 82 kN/mm2.
Example
A shaft of rectangular cross section is subjected to a torque of 0.8 kNm
and the maximum permissible shear stress in the shaft is 40 N/mm2. If
the ratio of breadth to depth is 1.5, determine the size of the shaft and
the angle of twist in a length of 4 m.
G = 78.4 kN/mm2.
where
Example
A closed tubular section of mean radius R and radial thickness t and a
tube of the same radius and thickness but with a longitudinal slit are
subjected to the same twisting moment T. Compare the maximum shear
stress developed in both and also compare the angular twist in these
tubes.
Mean radius = R
Thickness = t
T T
1
2At 2p R 2 t
TL ds T 2pR
Angular twist per unit length
4GA 2 t L 1m
4Gp 2 R 4 t
Tubular section with a small slit. This can be treated as a thin rectangular section
of width 2pR and thickness t.
It is seen that the closed tubular section is much more stronger and stiffer than
the open tubular section with a slit.
Example
A shaft made of plastic is of elliptical cross-section as shown in the figure. If
it is subjected to torsional loading as shown, determine the shear stress at
point A. Also determine the angle of twist at the end B. Gplastic = 15 GPa.
2T
2 2 90 10 3
2.86 N / mm2
pa b p 20 50
2
Torque for 2 m length, T1 = 60 Nm
Torque for another 2 m length, T2 = 60 + 30 = 90 Nm
Angular twist,
So,
Exercise 6.7