Tabel 1.

Analisis Artikel Jurnal Internasional

N Judul Artikel Nama Penulis, Nama Jurnal, Tujuan Jenis Instrume Analisi Hasil Pembahasan (yang Simpulan
o Volume, No, halaman riset riset; n yang s data dalam mana hasil riset
Populas digunak yang bentuk milik peneliti lain
i, besar an diguna Pernyataan yang
sampel, (nama kan mendukung/bers
jenis semua esuaian dengan
sampel, instrume hasil AJI tersebut
dan n yang dan yang mana
teknik digunak hasil riset milik
samplin an, peneliti lain yang
g; jumlah bertentangan
item, dengan hasil AJI
pilihan tersebut) dalam
jawaban bentuk pernyataan
,
penskor
an)
1 Emergy Hindawi Publishing Finding Kind of a Analys The large- All of them have The large-
Analysis of Corporation new researc liquidga is andmediu achieved good andmediu
Biogas Advances in Agriculture energy h is s varians m-sized economic, social, m-sized
Systems Volume 2014, Article ID sources study storage biogas and other biogas
Based on 542703, 11 pages to literatur integrate projects comprehensive projects
Different http://dx.doi.org/10.1155/20 replace e, the d tank wheremate benefits [6]. wheremate
Raw 14/542703 fossil populat rials rials
Materials fuels is
ion is are corn are corn
raw straw and straw and
an
materia feces both feces both
urgent ls, the have high have high
task for sample ecological- ecological-
China is kind economic economic
[1–5]. of raw benefit. benefit. In
Anaerobi materia this
c ls, kind research,
digestion of the
is one of sample ecological-
the most is economic
appropri probabi values of
lity BPF
ate
sample, system and
technolo
techniq BPC
gies to ue of system are
solve sample $28,300/yr
these is and
problem random $8,100/yr,
s. There sample respectivel
are y.
large According
biomass to the
resource monetary,
s in environme
China, nt, and
especiall human
y crop production
straw, factors,
both of the
forest
two types
residue,
of biogas
livestock projects
and own great
poultry developme
manure, nt
and potential.
 various
kinds of
municipa
l and
industria
l organic
wastes
and
waste
water [2]
2 Ecological Hindawi Publishing Corporation However Kind of Molecul Analys As Spurr Seed treatment of As Spurr
Complexity Advances in Agriculture , the researc ar and is and pea and other crops and
and the Volume 2014, Article ID 542703, biocontr h is Microsc varians Knudsen with T. Knudsen
Success of 11 pages ol agents study opic [99] noted, harzianumcontroll [99] noted,
Fungal http://dx.doi.org/10.1155/2014/ literatur the search ed Pythiumseed rot the search
themselv Tools
Biological 542703 e, the for a and/or for a
es are
Control also populat “silver preemergence “silver
Agents ion is bullet,” damping-off [25– bullet,”
subject
fungal a 27]. a
to the
biologi biological biological
same cal, the control control
types of sample organism organism
interacti is kind that can that can
ons, of simply be simply be
which fungal applied applied
may biologi as if it as if it were
reduce cal, were a a chemical
or in kind of chemical pesticide,
some sample pesticide, is unlikely
cases is is unlikely to succeed
enhance probabi in an
their lity to succeed ecologicall
efficacy sample, in an y
against techniq ecologicall complexmi
target plant ue of y lieu.
pathogens. sample complexm Ecological
is ilieu systems, as
random described
sample by Levin
[110], are
the
prototypica
l complex
adaptive
systems
(CAS) “in
which
macroscop
ic system
properties
such as
trophic
structure,
diversity-
productivit
y
relationshi
ps, and
patterns of
nutrient
flux
emerge
from
 interaction
s among
component
sand may
feed back
to
influence
the
subsequent
developme
nt
of those
interaction
s.”
3 Tide Hindawi Publishing Dredging is Kind of Hambur Analys This study High tidal This study
Managemen Corporation currently researc g is has energy erodes has utilized
used as
t in the Elbe Advances in Ecology h is habitats varians utilized sediments from the several
ameasure
River and Volume 2016, Article ID to control
study maps several sea/coast and methods
Changes in 9519637, 13 pages sediments literatur and methods transports and
Ecosystem http://dx.doi.org/10.1155/20 at the port e, the species and them to the upper techniques
Services 16/9519637 basin populat distribut techniques estuary whereas together
ion is ion together weak ebb tidal and
ecosyst maps of and currents analyzed
em German analyzed take less sediment and
service, y and and back to the interpreted
the Europe interpreted sea/coast [27] informatio
sample informatio n about
is kind n about Kreetsand’
of Kreetsand’ s habitats,
ecosyst s habitats, ecological
em ecological integrity,
service, integrity, and
kind of and ecosystem
sample ecosystem services
is services over two
probabi over two periods,
lity periods, that is,
sample, that is, before and
techniq before and after the
ue of after the shallow
sample shallow water area
is water area was
random was created.
sample created. Generally,
results
show that
there will
be an
increase in
the
ecological
integrity of
Kreetsand’
s area
after the
creation of
the shallow
water.The
increase is
due to
the
transforma
tion of
poor
 quality
inhabitable
habitats
(rank
2), namely,
ruder
grass,
shrubs
species,
and poor
intensively
cultivated
willows to
the high
quality
habitats
(ranks 4 to
5).
4 Water Arjen Y. Hoekstra Water Kind of green, Analys The papers provide the first In the past,
Footprints Footprint researc blue, is in this review of research various
and Assessm h is grey varians Special on the water global
Sustainable ent study water Issue and footprint WFAs
Water (WFA) is literatur footprint the of cities. They have been
Allocation a quickly e, the developme observe that a published
growing populat nt of the range of methods [11–17]. In
research ion is WFA field for estimating the this Special
field. water in general WF of Issue, the
This footpri show consumption is study
Special nt, the that a being by Roson
Issue sample major used. As set out in and Sartori
contains is kind challenge Hoekstra et al. [4] [18]
a of remains provides a
selection water the first effort
of papers of bridging of to consider
advancin footpri different inter-
g the nt, kind spatial annual
field or of levels of changes in
showing sample analysis. the WF of
innovativ is production
e probabi and
applicati lity consumpti
ons sample, on, for
techniq forty
ue of countries
sample over the
is period
random 1995-2009.
sample In
particular,
they find
that the
physical
and
economic
impact of
economic
growth on
water
resources
has been
significantl
y
lower than
what it
 could have
been.
Schwarz et
al. [19]

Tabel 2. Jabaran Variabel Penelitian

No. Variabel Subvariabel/Dimensi Indikator Skala Variabel dan Pilihan Instrumen atau Alat
Jawaban untuk Mengukur
Variabel
1 Emergy Analysis of The kind of Emergy  Study Site  Raw date a liquidgas storage
Biogas Systems Based Analysis of Biogas  BPF System.  Transformity integrated tank
and Different Raw Systems Based and  Emergy  References
Materials The kind of Different Accounting  Solar emergy
Raw Materials  Emergy  Em
Evaluation Index
 Purchase Emergy
Ratio (PER)
 Natural
Emergy/Purchase
Emergy
 Emergy
Investment Ratio
(EIR)
 Emergy Yield
Ratio (EYR)
 Emergy Self-
Sufficiency Ratio
(ESR)
  Ratio of Waste
Treatment (%W)
 Environmental
Loading Ratio
(ELR)
 Feedback Yield
Ratio (FYR)
 Renewable Ratio
(%R)
 Emergy
Sustainability
Ratio (ESR)
2 Ecological Complexity The kind of Ecological  Molecular and areas in ecology, namely, Molecular and
and the Success of Complexity and the Microscopic food (trophic)webs, patch Microscopic Tools
Fungal Biological kind of the Success of Tools dynamics
Control Agents Fungal Biological  Spatial and spatial structure, and
Control Agents Complexity of population fluctuations
Soil Biocontrol
Systems
 Geostatistical
Analysis as a Tool
to Evaluate
Spatial
 Complexity
 Simulation
Modeling of
Biocontrol Agent
Performance
 Trophic
Complexity
 Influences the
Success of Fungal
Biocontrol
 Agents
3 Tide Management in The jind of Tide  Habitat  Tidal riparian Hamburg habitats
the Elbe River and Management in the Identifications forest maps and species
Changes in Ecosystem Elbe River and  Habitats Quality  Tide reeds (reed distribution
Services The kind of Changes in Assessment and flats) maps of Germany
Ecosystem Services Ranking  Deep zone creeks and Europe
 Identification of  Shallow water area
Potential  Tidal creeks
Indicators for  Thin sand area
Assessment of  Modified river
 Ecological section
Integrity and  Rip-raps
Ecosystem  Mudflats
Services  Paved areas
 ssessment of  Dike
Habitats
Ecological
Integrity and
Relevant
 Capacity for the
Ecosystem
Services
Provision.

4 Water Footprints and The kind of Water  green, blue, grey  Water footprint green, blue, grey
SustainableWater Footprints and the kind water footprint around in the world water footprint
Allocation  water scarcity
of SustainableWater  water pollution
Allocation  sustainability
efficiency
 water
stewardship