Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
Benzene
HILLIS O. FOLKINS, RETIRED (Union Oil Company of California), Claremont, California
91711, United States
indicate that this simple picture cannot explain intermediates for the production of a host of
the true nature of benzene or related molecules. commercial products. Benzene is thermally sta-
For instance, when benzene is formed from ble and its formation is kinetically and thermo-
cyclohexane, less energy (151 kJ, 36 kcal) is dynamically favored at temperatures 3 500 C.
required than is needed for the formation of three Therefore elevated temperatures are required for
double bonds. The NMR spectrum of benzene its thermal decomposition or for condensation or
shows the protons at lower field than would be dehydrogenation reactions to occur. As an exam-
expected for simple vinylogous ones. Spacing ple, at ca. 650 C in contact with iron, lead, or
between the neighboring carbon atoms is con- over other catalytic materials, such as vanadium,
stant (0.139 nm), which is less than single-bond condensation reactions take place to form diphe-
spacing (0.154 nm), and more than, but close to, nyl and other polyaromatic compounds.
double-bond spacing (0.134 nm); C – H bond Benzene is quite stable to oxidation, but under
spacing is 0.108 nm. Benzene is thermally sta- severe conditions it is oxidized to water and
ble. It does not react as a compound having carbon dioxide. With a deficiency of air or oxy-
typical double bonds; however, it is more reac- gen under oxidizing conditions, partial decom-
tive than simple hydrocarbons. position and deposition of soot occur. Oxidation
Tables 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, and 6 give important with air or oxygen in the vapor phase at 350 –
physical data for benzene and for related aromat- 450 C over a V–Mo catalyst produces maleic
ic compounds. anhydride in yields of 65 – 70 % [2]. The use of
pure oxygen offers no advantage over air [3].
Phenol can be obtained in low yield from
3. Chemical Properties the high-temperature oxidation of benzene with
air [4].
Benzene is the basic unit of the aromatic class of Substitution reactions of benzene are of pri-
compounds. It is one of the largest volume or- mary importance. Depending on reaction condi-
ganic chemicals, with the United States being the tions one or more of the hydrogen atoms in the
largest producer. Benzene is the source of a benzene ring may be exchanged for nitro or
variety of organic chemicals, many of which are sulfonic acid radicals, for amine or hydroxyl
Benzene [71-43-2] 78.11 0.87901 þ 5.533 80.099 1.50112 0.309 48.9 288.9 11
Toluene [108-88-3] 92.13 0.86694 94.991 110.626 1.49693 0.291 40.7 319.9 4.0
Ethylbenzene [100-41-4] 106.16 0.8669 94.975 136.186 1.49588 0.286 37.4 346.4 15
o-Xylene [56004-61-6] 106.16 0.88020 25.182 144.411 1.50545 0.288 36.6 357.9 17
m-Xylene [108-38-3] 106.16 0.86417 47.872 139.104 1.49722 0.286 37.0 353 23.2
p-Xylene [41051-88-1] 106.16 0.86105 þ 13.263 138.351 1.49582 0.286 36.5 343 25
Temp., Vapor Specific Specific Heat of Thermal Viscosity, Dielectric Miscibility of water
K pressure, heat, heat, vaporization, conductivity, mPa s constant and benzene
kPa liquid, vapor, J/g W m1K1
J/g J/g
% water % benzene
in benzene in water
groups, or for atoms, such as chlorine or bromine. carried out at 40 – 100 C, gauge pressure < 0.7
Products include phenol, nitrobenzene, chloro- MPa. With less active catalysts higher tempera-
benzene, benzenesulfonic acid, and others. ture and pressure are employed [6].
For disubstituted benzene three isomers are pos- The production of cumene by the vapor-phase
sible: catalytic alkylation of benzene with propene is
another important primary addition reaction of
benzene. The reaction takes place at 200 –
250 C and gauge pressure of 2.7 – 4.2 MPa
over active catalysts, such as phosphoric acid or
kieselguhr, with yields of ca. 95 % [7].
Hydrogenation is also an addition reaction.
One of the most important is the hydrogenation of
benzene at elevated temperature and pressure to
Other important reactions of benzene involve produce cyclohexane. The reaction may be car-
addition and include alkylation and hydrogena- ried out in the liquid phase [8] or in the vapor
tion. These reactions generally take place at phase at higher temperatures.
elevated temperature and pressure, sometimes The dehydrogenation of ethylbenzene to
requiring active catalysts. Ethylbenzene results form styrene is an important commercial reaction
from the alkylation of benzene with ethylene in (! Styrene). High temperature is necessary
the presence of a catalyst, such as aluminum both kinetically and thermodynamically for this
chloride [5] (! Ethylbenzene). The reaction is endothermic reaction to proceed.
240 Benzene Vol. 5
Table 3. Binary azeotrope mixtures of benzene Table 5. Volume (or cubic) expansion coefficient of benzene
Table 7. Analysis of crude oil fractions Table 8 contains an analysis of the C5 – 150 C
naphtha fraction from a conventional crude and
Property Saudi Thistle, Saudi that of a synthetic naphtha derived from Atha-
Arabian U.K. Arabian
mixed light
basca tar sands [11]. The naphtha from the tar
sands has lower contents of aromatics and
Crude gravity, API 34 – 34.9 37.4 34.1 naphthenes than does the fraction from the con-
Sulfur, wt % 1.63 0.31 1.72
C5 and lighter, vol % 1.6 3.3 1.5
ventional crude. However, when the higher
Light naphtha, yield, naphtha fractions are compared the synthetic
vol% (debutanized) 13.7 13.23 9.3 crude has a considerably higher aromatic content
T.b.p.* range, C C5 – 126** 31 – 105 C5 – 93** (32 versus 19 %), although the naphthene content
End point, C 132
Gravity, API 72.5 71.3 75.0
is lower in the synthetic crude. The higher aro-
Sulfur, wt % 0.02 0.04 0.03 matic content of the heavier fraction can be
Aromatics, vol% 5 3.1 2.4 explained on the basis of dealkylation or of ring
Naphthenes, vol% 5 30.5 12.3 opening of the higher molecular mass aromatics
Paraffins, vol% 90 66.4 85.3
*
in the bitumen.
T.b.p. is true boiling point distillation. The commercial sources of benzene, as well
**
C5 – t refers to C5 plus content of the light naphtha.
as toluene and xylenes in primary products, are
242 Benzene Vol. 5
Table 8. Properties of naphthas from synthetic and conventional During the 1930s catalytic cracking made its
crudes
debut, first as fixed-bed processing and later as
Synthetic Conventional moving-bed processes. Cracked light naphthas
contained a considerable aromatic content in
Boiling range C5 – 150 C
Density, g/cm3 0.697 0.718 contrast to the low concentrations found in virgin
Sulfur, ppm 1 30 light naphthas. During this period catalytic re-
Hydrocarbons, vol%* forming of virgin naphthas also became a reality.
Aliphatics 69 43 Aromatics, such as benzene, were made by de-
Naphthenes 25 46
Aromatics 6 11 hydrogenation of cyclohexane or by isomeriza-
Benzene 1.1 1.4 tion and dehydrogenation of methylcyclopen-
Toluene 2.7 4.3 tane. n-Hexane was converted to benzene in
Xylenes 2.0 0.5 smaller yields and under modified reaction
*
By GC analysis
conditions.
coal and petroleum. Historically benzene pro- 5.1. Production from Coal
duction has been a byproduct of the carboniza-
tion of coal to produce coke for the steel industry. Light oils from the carbonization or coking of
More recently petroleum has become the primary coal have long been sources of BTX (! Coal
source as catalytic and thermal methods have Pyrolysis). The carbonization process also pro-
been developed for producing aromatic or related duces a C5 and lighter fraction and a heavier coal
compounds. These materials are used to improve tar fraction. In the coking of coal, the yields and
gasoline quality or as feedstocks to produce composition of the light oils depend on the type
petrochemicals. For example, catalytic refor- of coal being processed and on the carbonization
mates, pyrolysis gasoline, and alkylated aro- temperature. Low-temperature coking was for-
matics, such as toluene and xylenes, provide merly employed to produce gas for heating and
sources for the commercial production of lighting. Low-temperature (< 700 C) carboni-
benzene. Production methods are discussed in zation was important, especially in industrialized
Chapter 5. Europe before the advent of natural gas, petro-
leum, and other forms of energy. The benzene
content of the BTX is lower in this case than
5. Production when coking is carried out at a higher tempera-
ture. Low carbonization temperatures produce a
Until World War II, the coal industry supplied rather low-density, clean burning coke.
most of the commercial benzene in the United High-temperature carbonization was devel-
States and other countries. The pyrolysis of oped to produce a hard coke for use in blast
coal to yield metallurgical coke produced by- furnaces of the steel industry. High-temperature
product gas and aromatic liquid from which coking is done at 3 900 C. A typical composi-
benzene and related aromatics were recovered tion of light oils produced in coke-oven operation
by extraction and distillation. The small concen- is (vol%): benzene (63), toluene (13), xylenes
trations of benzene, toluene, xylene, etc., in crude (8), higher aromatics (10), nonaromatics (6) [8].
oil fractions made this potential source Typical yields of liquid products obtained
noneconomic. from slot-type coke-oven operations are 11 –
New processes discovered and commercial- 15 L of light oil and 30 – 38 L of coal tar pitch
ized in the petroleum industry during the 1930s per ton of coal charged [12]. About 1 % of
and 1940s and the greatly increased demand for ammonium sulfate and around 2800 L of coke-
aromatics over this period changed the situation. oven gas per ton of coke are produced. Coke and
Petroleum became more important as a raw coke breeze yields are about 75 %.
material for the production of benzene and its Whereas the benzene content of light oils
homologues in the United States. Today, petro- derived from coke-oven operation is 3 65 wt %,
leum is the main source of the BTX aromatics – the concentration is much lower (ca. 45 %) in
benzene, toluene, and xylenes. light oils derived from vertical retort operations.
Vol. 5 Benzene 243
much shorter cycles, depending on the feedstock, swing reactors, or continuous regeneration are
the process conditions, and the severity of oper- employed. The version of platforming [26]
ation. Pretreatment of the naphtha feedstock by shown in Figure 3 employs continuous catalyst
catalytic hydrotreating is required to remove regeneration. Another design developed by Stan-
sulfur compounds. Commercial catalytic reform- dard Oil of Indiana uses a swing reactor in which
ing processes include: catalytic reforming (In- the fixed-bed catalyst in one reactor is regener-
stitut Français du Petrole), magnaforming (En- ated and brought back onstream, with the cata-
gelhard Industries), platforming (UOP), power- lysts in each of the remaining reactors being
forming (Exxon Research & Engineering), rhe- regenerated in rotation. Gauge pressures of ca.
niforming (Chevron Research Co.), and 0.7 – 2.4 MPa are employed in the different
ultraforming (Standard Oil of Indiana). processes. For gasoline production, naphthas
Operating conditions cover a considerable used have boiling ranges of around 80 – 210 C.
range: temperatures vary from 425 to 525 C If reforming is carried out for the production of
and gauge pressures from 0.7 to 3.5 MPa. Hy- aromatic charge stocks, the composition and
drogen recycle rates depend on whether long boiling range of the naphtha may be altered. The
process cycles or whether frequent or continuous reformate may have RON clear octane rating as
catalyst regeneration is employed. Naphtha feed- high as 100 and may contain up to 70 vol%
stocks vary but generally are in the gasoline aromatics. Typical compositions of reformate at
boiling range. Narrower boiling range stocks different levels of reforming severity are shown
may be used if aromatics are the desired end in Table 9.
products. Regenerative-type products generally Over the years, the process has been made
allow lower pressures, less recycle hydrogen, and more effective. Reforming catalysts have been
higher severity operation. Naphthene conver- modified. Water in small amounts was found to
sions approach 100 %. Cyclization of paraffins enhance benzene yields with certain catalysts
is much lower. For example, for benzene pro- when producing BTX [27]. Higher xylene yields
duction from C6 and higher stocks, methylcyclo- have resulted from operating at increased space
pentane is isomerized to cyclohexane and dehy- velocities.
drogenated to benzene. Conversion of n-hexane
to benzene is limited.
Catalytic reformer units may be operated at 5.2.2. Aromatics from Pyrolysis Gasoline
relatively high pressures with a series of fixed-
bed reactors, the catalyst being regenerated at Pyrolysis gasoline (dripolene), produced as a
defined intervals. Units designed for higher con- byproduct from the high-temperature, short-
version operate at lower pressure with more residence time cracking of paraffin gases,
frequent catalyst regeneration. Shorter cycles, naphthas, gas oils, or other hydrocarbons used
Figure 3. Continuous platforming process a) Catalyst regeneration; b) Reactors; c) Product separation; d) Stabilizer
Reproduced with permission from [26]
246 Benzene Vol. 5
to produce ethylene, is another excellent source Table 11 gives an analysis of pyrolysis gaso-
for BTX. The quantity of byproduct pyrolysis lines by carbon groups [30], [32]. Pyrolysis
gasoline produced is a function of feedstock and gasoline is quite unstable because of the appreci-
operating conditions [28], [29]. Although the able amount of diolefinic material. Lower boiling
amount may be small with ethane and other diolefins may be removed by distillation al-
gaseous paraffins as the ethylene charge stocks, though their tendencies to polymerize and depo-
it increases when heavier charge stocks are used. lymerize may cause difficulties. Therefore a two-
On a once-through basis, amounts may be 20 % stage hydrotreating is generally employed. In the
in the high-severity cracking of a medium range first stage a mild selective hydrotreating converts
naphtha. As the boiling point of the feed in- diolefins to olefins. If this gasoline is to be used as
creases, a larger yield of toluene and xylene, a fuel, further treatment may not be necessary.
relative to that of benzene, is produced. Table 10 However, if the gasoline is a source of aromatics,
shows a typical composition of pyrolysis gaso- a second stage is employed to saturate olefins and
line [30]. The BTX content of the pyrolysis to remove residual sulfur.
gasoline is > 60 %. Because of the high temper-
ature necessary for ethylene production, the py-
rolysis gasoline contains other unsaturates and 5.3. Methods of Increasing Production
diolefins. Diolefin content is typically 3 5 % as
is the total content of cyclic olefins and cyclic Depending on demand, benzene production from
diolefins [31]. other aromatic compounds can be increased,
Table 10. Cracking severity and product composition from pyrolysis gasoline (mass fractions in %)
Table 11. Composition of pyrolysis gasoline according to carbon Other alkylbenzenes, such as ethyl- and pro-
groups
pylbenzene, dealkylate in a single step and form
Substances by the corresponding alkanes. Both catalytic and
type (mass Groups thermal processes are used. The catalytic pro-
fractions in %) cesses, e.g., Detol (Air Products & Chemicals)
C5 C6 C7 C8 C9þ Total
[33] and Hydeal (UOP) [34], operate at 575 –
650 C and 2.5 – 6 MPa. The temperature of
Diolefin 8 4 1 1 0 14 this exothermic reaction is controlled by recy-
Monoolefin 2 2 1 3 0 8
Saturates 1 1 1 2 0 5
cling cold hydrogen.
Aromatics 0 34 12 12 12 73 Thermal dealkylation processes, such as HDA
Aromatics (Arco and Hydrocarbon Research) and THD
by type 0 81.9 83.3 66.7 100 73 (Gulf Oil), operate at higher temperatures than
the catalytic, but yields and reaction systems are
similar in both types. For a comparison of the
different processes see [35].
particularly from the BTX fractions obtained The amount of toluene in BTX from catalytic
from catalytic reformate, pyrolysis gasoline, or reformate is greater than that of benzene. Wheth-
light oils from coal carbonization. Among the er or not hydrodealkylation is used is related
methods used are hydrodealkylation, dispropor- directly to the demand and price of benzene
tionation, or combination processes. relative to toluene. If the relative demand for the
two products changes, the dealkylation units may
5.3.1. Hydrodealkylation be placed on standby.
Detol Process [33], [36]. This catalytic deal-
Hydrodealkylation of alkyl aromatics is a source kylation process is illustrated in Figure 4. Ben-
of benzene. Toluene is the usual charge stock, zene is produced from a feed consisting of tolu-
although higher alkylated aromatics may be used: ene or mixtures of toluene and other alkylated
benzenes. The alkylated aromatics and hydrogen
pass at elevated temperature and pressure over a
fixed-bed dealkylation catalyst, generally dis-
persed in more than one reactor in series. Heat
With more highly alkylated benzenes, the exchangers cool the reactor products and con-
reaction proceeds stepwise: dense benzene, unreacted toluene, and the heavi-
er unreacted alkylated benzenes. A high-pressure
flash drum separates recycle hydrogen and
Figure 4. Detol process a) Reactor I; b) Reactor II; c) Furnace; d) Separator; e) Hydrogen purification; f) Stabilizer;
g) Clay treater
248 Benzene Vol. 5
product gas. The gas is split into streams for fuel to that of the catalytic processes, with benzene
gas, for hydrogen purification if needed, and for yields of 99 mol%. The small amounts of diphe-
recycle hydrogen. nyls formed are recycled and a low-equilibrium
The product gas from the flash drum is con- concentration is maintained, permitting high
densed and the liquid pumped to a stabilizer, benzene yields.
where remaining gas and low-boiling hydrocar- THD Process [40]. This Gulf process is simi-
bons are driven off and utilized as fuel gas. The lar to the other thermal processes.
bottoms from the stabilizer are clay treated and MHC Process [41], [42]. Mitsubishi Petro-
passed to a column where the benzene is distilled chemical Co. has described a thermal dealkyla-
overhead. Unreacted toluene and heavier aro- tion process known as MHC. Methods are
matics are recycled. The benzene produced in emphasized for controlling condensation
yields of around 99 mol% is highly pure, typi- reactions and coke formation. The following
cally 99.95 %, with a freezing point of 5.45 C. advantages are claimed for the MHC process.
Minor side reactions, such as hydrocracking and Feedstocks containing up to 30 % of nonaro-
hydrogenation, occur and produce small amounts matics can be handled without resorting to
of light hydrocarbons and also eliminate sulfur aromatic extraction and fractional distillation
compounds (e.g., thiophene). Catalyst cycle life steps. The process will operate on low-purity
in these dealkylation processes is long, as it is in hydrogen, thus reducing the amount of makeup
other high-pressure reactions carried out in the hydrogen required. Benzene of 99.95 % purity is
presence of hydrogen. As of 1981 twelve com- readily achieved. Figure 6 is a flow sheet of the
mercial Detol plants had been licensed. MHC process.
Hydeal Process [34], [37]. This process was
developed jointly by Ashland Oil and UOP. The
process is similar to the Detol one described 5.3.2. Disproportionation
previously. Toluene alone or in mixtures contain-
ing xylenes and other alkylated benzenes is Processes have been developed to disproportion-
charged to the catalytic reactor, which contains ate or transalkylate alkylated aromatics to pro-
a chromia – alumina catalyst. Hydrogen is added duce benzene and alkylated benzenes. For exam-
along with the alkyl aromatics. Nitration-grade ple, the Tatoray process (UOP and Toray Indus-
benzene is obtained in yields of ca. 98 mol%. tries, see Fig. 7) [43–45] produces benzene and
Unreacted aromatic charge material from the equilibrium xylenes from toluene or from a
once-through operation is recycled to obtain mixture of toluene and C9 aromatics:
practically complete conversion. The process is
also used to hydrodealkylate alkylnaphthalenes. 2 C6 H5 CH3 ! C6 H6 þC6 H4 ðCH3 Þ2
HDA Process [38], [39]. This process, devel-
oped by Arco and Hydrocarbon Research, oper- C6 H5 CH3 þC6 H3 ðCH3 Þ3 ! 2 C6 H4 ðCH3 Þ2
ates at 600 – 660 C and at gauge pressures of
3.45 – 6.9 MPa (see Fig. 5). Operation is similar The reaction proceeds with a high H2 recycle
rate over a noble-metal or rare-earth catalyst.
Operating conditions are 350 – 525 C and
1 – 5 MPa.
Benzene of high purity (fp 5.45 C) and xy-
lenes containing < 109 parts of saturated hydro-
carbons are produced. When the feedstock is
limited to C9 and C10 aromatics, a mixture of
benzene, toluene, and xylenes results. Typical
yields with toluene as the charge are about
97 %. Yields for both a pure toluene feed and a
mixed feed of toluene and C9 þ aromatics are
shown in Table 12.
Figure 5. HDA process a) Heater; b) Reactor; c) Separator; Four commercial units were in operation in
d) Stabilizer; e) Clay treater; f) Distillation 1981 and others were being designed or built.
Vol. 5 Benzene 249
Figure 6. MHC process a) Heater; b) Reactor; c) Waste-heat boiler; d) Hydrogen regeneration; e) Aromatic recovery;
f) Fractionation; g) Vacuum columns; h) Clay treaters; i) Benzene column
Figure 8. Pyrotol process a) Distillation; b) Vaporizer; c) Prereactor; d) Heater; e) Pyrotol reactor; f) Stabilizer; g) Clay treater;
h) Hydrogen purification
light oil obtained from coal carbonization [48]. and ethylbenzene. The primary, or heavier frac-
This process, as the Pyrotol process, utilizes two tion of the light oil, has a typical boiling range of
catalytic reaction stages. After prefractionation 180 – 260 C and is composed mainly of C9 and
of the raw light oil to remove C5 and lighter heavier aromatics. Pilot plant operation indicates
fractions overhead and C9 and heavier as bot- that a 50 – 50 mixture of the lower and higher
toms, the C6 – C8 fraction is vaporized. boiling range light oils can be processed.
At the first stage diolefins and styrene are Mitsubishi Petrochemical Co. described a
hydrogenated. The effluent then contacts the Litol process [50] for producing benzene from pyrol-
chromia – alumina catalyst at 500 – 600 C, ysis gasoline by a combination method similar
where desulfurization, hydrocracking, and deal- to those discussed previously. After a two-stage
kylation occur. Benzene purity of 99.97 % with hydrogenation a solvent was used to extract
freezing point of 5.5 C and a thiophene content of the aromatics. Alternatively, the hydrogenated
less than 0.5 ppm are typical. material was reacted in Mitsubishi’s MHC pro-
In 1968 a modified Litol process was devel- cess [42], [51], [52]. Advantages of the process
oped [49]. This modified process is designed to are low-temperature liquid-phase operation of
include a heavier fraction of the light oil, mostly the first stage with no need for hydrogenated
C9s and heavier, along with the secondary light product recycling, and a reactor design incorpo-
oil (C6 – C8) normally used in the process. rating an improved method for controlling tem-
The lighter fraction typically contains around perature of the exothermic reactions.
70 % benzene, 20 % toluene, and 6 % xylenes Mobil Chemical Co. has developed an aro-
matics processing catalyst and a process for the
liquid-phase disproportionation of toluene to
Table 13. Pyrotol yield data and material balance, wt % form benzene and xylenes (Fig. 9) [53], [54].
This low-temperature – disproportionation pro-
Component Dripolene Fresh feed Benzene
raw to pyrotol product
cess (LTD) employs a zeolite-based catalyst
charge reactors of high activity which permits the reaction to
proceed at temperatures as low as 260 C; gauge
C5s 7.1 0.2
Benzene 48.3 54.4 99.92
pressure is 4.5 MPa. No hydrogen recycle is
Cyclohexane 2.4 2.7 required in this liquid-phase process. An hourly
Toluene 16.2 18.3 0.08 mass-space velocity is standard. A catalyst life of
Other C7s 8.7 9.8 1.5 years is claimed with infrequent regenera-
Ethylbenzene 1.8 2.0
Xylenes 9.2 10.2
tions. With fresh or regenerated catalyst the
Other C8s initial reactor temperature is 260 C. As the
and heavier 6.3 2.4 catalyst slowly deactivates, the temperature is
Total 100.0 100.0 100.0 raised in increments to 315 C; then the catalyst
wt % of charge 100.0 88.63 68.88
is regenerated by burning accumulated coke.
Vol. 5 Benzene 251
Table 16. Hydrogenation of C5 – 205 C pyrolysis gasoline (Institut carried out in the presence of a high-boiling
Français du Petrole)
solvent having great solubility for aromatics and
Feed- After After little or no solubility for paraffins and
stock first second naphthenes. The solvent enters the distillation
stage stage column near the top and above the point at which
Specific gravity 0.815 0.813 0.860 the BTX feed is introduced. The nonaromatics
Diene value 30 1 0 are distilled from the top of the column and the
Bromine number g/100 g 75 56 0.1 aromatic-rich solvent is withdrawn as a bottoms
Sulfur, ppm 400 400 0.5
product. The aromatics are then distilled or
stripped from the solvent in a second column
completely separated by close fractionation at and the lean solvent is recycled. Separation of the
atmospheric pressure. In some cases distillation different aromatic components is carried out in
under elevated pressure will change the respec- subsequent distillation steps. Solvent to BTX
tive vapor – liquid equilibria so that separation feed ratios are generally in the order of 2 : 1 to
may be improved. 6 : 1 and conditions vary according to the nature
of the solvent, column efficiency, and properties
of the feedstock.
6.2.1. Azeotropic Distillation Extraction and extractive distillation methods
as well as liquid – liquid extraction methods
Naphthenes and paraffins are separated from depend upon the use of very selective polar
aromatics by azeotropic distillation. Olefins in substances. Most of these compounds or solvents
the charge mixture are generally detrimental to are high-boiling but some, such as SO2 , are not.
efficient separation. Usually the light ends from
the crude BTX material are removed, followed
by distillation of the benzene fraction from the 6.2.3. Liquid – Liquid Extraction
toluene-xylene mixture. Examples of azeotrope
formers include acetone and methanol with Liquid – liquid extraction in itself or in conjunc-
added water. Acetone is particularly suitable for tion with other separation processes is the most
the benzene fraction. widely used method for the isolation of aromatic
The azeotropic mixtures of nonaromatics and fractions. All these processes involve the extrac-
promoting agent are distilled. The nonaromatics tion of aromatics from nonaromatic material by
are recovered by breaking the azeotropic mixture the use of a polar solvent having a high-selective
with water. In the benzene application, benzene affinity for the former compounds.
is removed as a bottom product, washed, and The solvent, which is generally a high-boiling
distilled. Methanol is effective as an azeotrope polar liquid, enters the top of the extractor vessel.
forming agent in the treatment of the toluene – Various designs of extractors have been used,
xylene fractions. By the azeotropic method, ben- including packed columns, sieve tray types, and
zene with fp 5.5 C is recovered in 98 % yield. others. A rotating disk contactor (RDC) has
Pure toluene is separated in 95 % yield. Generally been used in some processes. The crude BTX
the process is limited to materials containing or other aromatic-containing material enters near
< 12 % nonaromatics. Azeotropic distillation the middle of the extractors and thus contacts
has found limited application but is not as effec- the solvent countercurrently in the column, or
tive as other methods, such as extractive distilla- intimate contact is effected by other means.
tion and liquid-liquid extraction, in the isolation The nonaromatic raffinate leaves at the top of
of high-purity aromatic compounds. the extractor, whereas the aromatic-rich solvent
is withdrawn at the bottom and passes to a
6.2.2. Extractive Distillation distillation column, where the aromatics are tak-
en overhead. The denuded solvent is then re-
Extraction and extractive distillation are com- cycled to the extractor. The overhead aromatic
monly used to separate aromatics from crude stream is distilled to separate benzene and other
BTX feeds. Extractive distillation is distin- aromatic components. The fundamentals of
guished from normal distillation in that it is liquid – liquid extraction, extractive distillation,
254 Benzene Vol. 5
and various methods of aromatic recovery by from coal tar, light oil, and pyrolysis gasoline.
extraction are discussed in [67], [68]. The first commercial installation was in conjunc-
tion with the UOP platforming unit at Cosden
Petroleum Corp. [73].
6.3. Processes for Aromatic The Udex process (see Fig. 10) uses diethy-
Separation lene glycol [111-46-6], 2-hydroxyethyl ether,
(HOCH2CH2)2O, Mr 106.12. The glycol contains
Numerous methods and processes have been about 8 % water to increase aromatic selectivity.
proposed and developed for the separation of This combination is effective as a solvent for
pure aromatics from BTX feedstocks [69], separating aromatics from paraffins in the same
[70]. The following are discussed in this article: boiling range. For aromatics production, a refor-
mate fraction of 65 – 150 C is charged to the
Process Solvent liquid – liquid extractor where a multistage,
countercurrent extraction takes place. The sol-
Edeleanu sulfur dioxide
Udex diethylene glycol and others
vent enters at the top of the extractor column and
Sulfolane sulfolane passes countercurrent to the hydrocarbon feed,
Arosolvan 1-methyl-2-pyrrolidone which is charged at an intermediate point. The
IFP dimethyl sulfoxide raffinate passes overhead from the extractor.
Formex N-formylmorpholine
Morphylane N-formylmorpholine
The aromatic-rich solvent is withdrawn from the
bottom and passes to the solvent stripper, where
the BTX material passes overhead and the de-
nuded solvent is recycled to the extractor. The
Edeleanu Process. This process uses as sol- BTX mixture is washed with water and treated
vent liquid sulfur dioxide [7446-09-5], SO2 , Mr with clay before being separated into the ben-
68.06. It was developed in 1908 primarily for the zene, toluene, and xylene by precise fraction-
removal of aromatics from kerosine lamp oil and ation. Compounds of nitration grade specifica-
is of historical interest only. Liquid sulfur dioxide tions are obtained with only a small amount of
is effective in extracting of aromatics but is now xylene from the xylene distillation being lost
used only for special purposes. This process is not from the bottoms. Typical results in the proces-
competitive for aromatic removal in stocks with a sing of catalytic reformate are shown in Table 17.
high-aromatic content. Improvements have been made in the Udex
process in terms of solvent and of operating
Udex Process (UOP-Dow). One of the early conditions. Aromatics recovery was improved
liquid – liquid extraction processes for the re- and capacity was increased by using a solvent
covery of BTX aromatics from catalytic refor- mixture of triethylene glycol and diethylene
mate was the Udex process [71], [72]. The pro- glycol or tetraethylene glycol. Pilot-plant studies
cess is also effective for recovering aromatics carried out at Union Carbide showed that, where
Figure 10. Udex extraction process a) Extractor; b) Stripper; c) Water and solvent distillation; d) Water; e) Clay treater
Vol. 5 Benzene 255
Table 17. Results of Udex extraction (U-2) Sulfolane Process. Shell Development Co.
Properties of Udex Benzene Toluene Xylene
and Royal Dutch Shell have developed an aro-
products charge mixture matic extraction process based on the use of
sulfolane as a selective solvent [76–79].
Distillation
initial bp, C 66 79.7 110 Sulfolane [126-33-0], tetramethylene sulfone,
50 % 99 80.1 110.8 C4H8O2S, Mr 120.17, is made by reacting sulfur
end point 150 80.3 111.0 dioxide and butadiene to form sulfolene, which is
fp, C 5.49 then hydrogenated to give sulfolane (! Sulfones
% Aromatics 51.3 99.9 99.8 >99.8
and Sulfoxides):
Yields Vol% Vol% % Recovery
of of in extract
charge extract
Benzene 7.6 15.3 >99
Toluene 21.2 42.5 95 Some of the advantages of the sulfolane pro-
Xylenes and cess are high selectivities and high yields. Also
ethylbenzene 20.0 40.0 94
C9 þ Aromatics 0.9 1.8 75
sulfolane has suitable physical properties, such as
high density, low-heat capacity, and a boiling
point high enough to permit easy separation for
recycling. One disadvantage is thermal instabili-
a solvent to feed ratio > 10 was required for ty at the boiling point. However, this shortcom-
high-aromatics recovery with diethylene glycol ing is met by adding small amounts of water,
as the solvent, the ratio could be reduced to which depresses the boiling point.
around 6 with the ethylene glycol – propylene The sulfolane process (see Fig. 11) is similar
glycol mixture. With tetraethylene glycol as to other aromatic extraction processes but differs
the solvent, the ratio could be reduced to as low in some operational procedures. The BTX con-
as 4 [74]. Operation at Sun Oil’s Corpus Christi, taining feed is charged to a rotating disk con-
Texas, plant [75] was improved when tetraethy- tactor or extractor. Aromatics are extracted with
lene glycol was substituted for propylene gly- a countercurrent flow of the sulfolane solvent.
col – ethylene glycol. Solvent/feed ratio was The aromatic-rich solvent from the bottom of the
decreased with a resulting increase in capacity. extractor passes to an extractive stripper. The
Although the original process was based on the overhead from this stripper is returned to the
use of diethylene glycol as the solvent, most extractor as a backwash stream, for recovery of
plants now use other more effective solvents, any residual aromatics. The aromatic – solvent
such as a tetraethylene glycol – water mixture. mixture is charged to a recovery column where
Figure 11. Sulfolane extraction process a) Extractor; b) Extract stripper; c) Preheater; d) RDC washer; e) Rectifying column
256 Benzene Vol. 5
the aromatic product passes overhead. The lean Table 19. Comparison of properties of different aromatic solvents
solvent from the bottom of the column is re- Property 1-Methyl-2- Sulfolane Diethyl-
cycled to the extractor. pyrrolidone ene glycol
A comparison of sulfolane with diethylene
bp, C 206 287 245
glycol [111-46-6] in the treating of light catalytic fp, C 24 27.9 8
reformate to separate and produce nitration Refractive index
grades of benzene, toluene, and xylenes is sum- n20
D 1.4703 1.447
marized in Table 18. n30
D 1.481
Density, g/mL
Yields and amounts of nonaromatic impuri- 20 C 1.033
ties (in parentheses) are: benzene, 99.9 % 30 C 1.024 1.261 1.11
(0.01 %); toluene, 99.5 % (0.02 %); xylenes, 200 C 1.116
98.0 % (0.10 %). Viscosity (mPa s)
30 C 1.017 10.2 2.7
As of 1980, over 55 sulfolane units were in 100 C 0.97 2.5 2.5
operation with capacities ranging from a few 200 C 0.97
hundred to over 45000 barrels/d [78]. Interfacial surface
tension, mN/m
30 C 8.2
Arosolvan Process. The Arosolvan process 120 C 2.0 8.5
[81–83], licensed by Lurgi, uses an aqueous 1-
methyl-2-pyrrolidone solvent. The water content
ranges from 10 to 20 %, but is generally 12 to matics, and a trace of solvent, passes overhead
14 %. Aromatics are extracted at 30 – 35 C and from the extractor. The aromatic-rich solvent is
at about atmospheric pressure. A comparison of passed to the first stripper, where pentane and
properties of 1-methyl-2-pyrrolidone [872-50-4] some benzene passes overhead and, after joining
and other solvents is shown in Table 19. Advan- with the overhead from the depentanizer, serves
tages of the Arosolvan process include operation as a recycle stream to the bottom of the extractor.
of the extraction tower at atmospheric pressure In the second stripper, high-purity aromatics and
and at room temperature, and low consumption water are taken overhead while aromatics-free
of solvent (< 0.09 mg/L) [82]. Feedstocks may solvent is withdrawn from the bottom for recycle.
contain considerable unsaturates, and depenta- The raffinate from the bottom of the depentaniz-
nization of the feedstock is not required because ing tower is separated from the solvent by water
of the low-temperature operation of the extractor. washing, and is removed from the process for
Other advantages are clay treating of recovered fuel blending or other uses. The aromatic fraction
aromatics is not necessary and waste disposal is from the overhead of the second stripper is
not a problem because wash water is recycled. separated by precise distillation.
Figure 12 is a simplified flow sheet of the Table 20 shows data obtained in the operation
process. The BTX feedstock is fed to the middle of two early commercial plants using the Aro-
of the extractor where the aromatics are removed solvan process. The Japanese plant operation
by countercurrent extraction with the solvent. involved the recovery of benzene, toluene, and
The raffinate, containing pentane, other nonaro- xylene fractions from a feedstock composed of
hydrogenated coal-gas and oil-gas benzene. The
Table 18. Comparison of sulfolane and diethylene glycol extraction
German operation used a hydrogenated pyrolysis
[77], [80] gasoline as the feedstock.
Figure 12. Arosolvan process a) Extraction column; b) Stripper I; c) Separator; d) Pentane column; e) Stripper II; f) Recovery
of 1-methyl-2-pyrrolidone (NMP)
atmospheric pressure in countercurrent fashion retical stages. The paraffin – aromatic mixture
with the dimethyl sulfoxide solvent (containing from the second stage is separated by distillation
< 9 % water). To maximize aromatic purity a and the paraffin is recycled to the second con-
mixture of aromatics and paraffins is fed to the tactor. The small amount of DMSO that remains
bottom of the first extractor, countercurrent to the in the paraffin phase may be recovered by water
solvent flow, so as to combine reflux and back- washing. The DMSO is separated from the wash
wash effects. The aromatic – solvent mixture water by vacuum distillation.
passes from the first contactor to the second Some of the advantages of this process are:
extractor where the DMSO solvent is recovered DMSO has high selectivity for aromatic extrac-
by re-extraction of the aromatics with a paraffin tion; this selectivity is increased by the addition
solvent. Extraction and re-extraction are carried of small amounts of water; extraction and re-
out at room temperature and atmospheric pres- extraction are carried out at room temperature
sure in rotating disk contactors of 10 – 12 theo- and atmospheric pressure; and DMSO is
Plant A Plant B
Japan Germany
Properties of fractions B T X B T
fp, C 5.50 – – 5.50
density, g/mL 0.884 0.871 0.870 0.884 0.872
benzene, wt % 99.99 <0.1 – 99.99 <0.01
toluene, wt % 0.0 >99.9 0.1 0.01 99.99
C8 aromatics, wt % – <0.1 99.8 – <0.01
nonaromatics, wt % 0.01 0.01 <0.1 0.01 <0.01
258 Benzene Vol. 5
Figure 13. DMSO process a) Extractor I; b) Extractor II; c) Washer for DMSO residue; d) Column for removal of pentane;
e) Vacuum column for dehydration of DMSO; f) Raffinate container
noncorrosive and is chemically stable under pro- for the removal of small amounts of aromatics
cess conditions. from paraffinic hydrocarbon mixtures.
Yield data for benzene, toluene, and xylene in N-Formylmorpholine [4394-85-8], 4-formyl-
the treatment of a catalytic reformate and a morpholine, 4-morpholinecarboxaldehyde,
pyrolysis gasoline, after hydrogenation of olefins C5H9NO2, Mr 115.13, has the following structure
and diolefins, are presented in Table 21. (! Amines, Aliphatic):
involved in these regulations include OSHA, EPA, same increase in benzene production over the
DOT, NIOSH, and others. The regulations dealing period before 1970 occurred in many other coun-
with handling and shipping are updated and pub- tries, especially those of Western Europe. For
lished each year in the CFR. Other countries have example, 1965 benzene production in the Federal
regulations and safety practices quite similar to Republic of Germany was ca. 330103 t, but this
those in the United States. Although specific reg- had increased to ca. 820103 t by 1970. Since the
ulations must be met for manufacture, laboratory early 1970s the rate of growth in the quantities of
testing, storage, handling, and transporting of benzene produced has leveled off somewhat,
benzene, the safety rules are similar to those for with downtrends apparent during periods of in-
other flammable and toxic liquids or gases. dustrial recession. Because of decreased use of
Benzene is stored and transported in steel tetraethyllead in gasolines over the past several
drums or tanks. Adequate ventilation is neces- years, the demand for BTX aromatics in gasoline
sary. Workers must be protected from skin con- has increased. This may affect the overall de-
tact or inhalation of fumes. Periodic physical mand and hence price level for benzene. Gener-
examinations are recommended for those who ally about 50 % of the benzene produced by
work in areas where there is probable exposure to petroleum refiners is retained for use as a gasoline
benzene. The handling of gasoline has caused component.
concern because of its toxic components, which Benzene production by country over the past
include benzene. Either CO2 or dry chemical several years is shown in Table 24. Benzene
extinguishers are recommended for combatting production in 1980 for the non-communist
benzene fires. world was over 13106 t, with the United States
producing about 40 % of the total [101]. An
estimated annual growth of 2.0 – 2.5 % is pre-
9. Economic Aspects dicted over the next years. The amount of ben-
zene available from light oils produced in coal
The demand for benzene as a raw material for the carbonization has not increased for some years,
manufacture of petrochemicals has increased especially in the United States, for several rea-
dramatically since the 1950s. Before World War sons. Depression of the steel industry and the
II, light oil from coal carbonization was the main adoption of more modern steel processing meth-
source for the production of benzene and the ods have resulted in decreased coke production
other BTX compounds. The development of new and hence decreased amounts of light oil. In
processes in the petroleum industry, such as addition, much of the light oil formed is not
catalytic reforming, provided a new raw material segregated but is burned as fuel in the steel
source for benzene. The rapid growth in the industry. Petroleum refiners, however, purchase
demand and production of benzene during and refine this material because of its high con-
1950 – 1970, using United States production tent of benzene and appreciable amounts of the
figures as an example, is shown in Table 23. The other BTX components. Table 25 shows the
decline in coal-derived benzene in the United
States since the 1950s. In 1953, 77 % of the
Table 23. Benzene production, United States benzene produced was derived from coal, but in
1981 this had decreased to 7 %. A further decline
Year Amount, Refer- Year Amount, Refer-
1000 t ence 1000 t ence is projected. As mentioned earlier the change
from coal-derived benzene to that produced by
1953 911 [95] 1974 4970 [97]
1955 1031 [95] 1975 3420 [97]
petroleum refiners came at a later date in Europe
1960 1539 [95] 1976 4760 [97] because of the greater dependency on coal. Thus
1965 2770 [95] 1977 4866 [97] in the Federal Republic of Germany in 1970,
1968 3340 [96] 1978 4970 [97] 38 % of the benzene produced was coal derived,
1970 3788 [96] 1979 5588 [97]
1970 3812 [95] 1980 5294 [97]
as compared to about 10 % in the United States.
1971 3594 [96] 1981 4472 [97] About 50 % of the light oils produced in the
1972 4182 [97] 1982 3583 [97] United States is processed into BTX materials
1973 4853 [97] 1983 4175* [98] for use as petrochemical charge stocks or as a
*
Projected motor fuel component.
262 Benzene Vol. 5
United States 5102 5048 5769 4980 4494 3585 4175 [95], [96], [98], [100]
United Kingdom 1020 883 1144 897 816 625 –
Federal Republic of Germany 824 892 1004 917 919 1024 1333 [94], [98], [100]
Japan 1951 2015 2178 2060 1899 1814 1750 [94], [98], [100]
Canada 383 555 493 604 571 504 580 [94], [96], [97], [100]
Mexico – 79 71 79 77 96 139 [97], [100]
Italy – – 528 449 423 392 518 [95], [100]
Brazil 145 172 260 309 336* 336* – [98], [99]
France – – 631 546 499 514 623 [97], [100]
*
Estimates based on six-month values
Table 26 gives benzene production and sales Demand is expected to increase moderately
by coke-oven operators and by petroleum refi- during the 1980s and the ratio may improve. On
ners. The petroleum refinery figures include ben- the other hand, with projected increase in de-
zene derived from light oils purchased from mand, production capabilities may increase, es-
coke-oven operators and processed by the petro- pecially in industrial developing countries and in
leum refiners. The differences between the pro- countries with excess hydrocarbon supplies. Il-
duction and sales figures are indicative of the lustrative of this projected increase in capacity
benzene retained by the petroleum refiners for are the benzene projects planned or under con-
use as fuel components. struction in late 1981 [102]. The survey showed
Except for short intervals, production of ben- that 32 projects were being considered or under
zene approximates demand. After a rapid growth construction. In North America there were five
in production facilities, the United States and units and in Western Europe four units. Eastern
other countries have production capacity far Europe with eight units and the Asian area with
greater than demand. For the years shown, the seven units indicate a rather sizable expansion.
ratio of benzene production to existing capacity Eight units were planned for other areas.
was approximately [101]: Because toluene and xylenes are related com-
ponents of BTX feedstocks and because the
United States 1980 0.62
alkylated benzenes may serve as feedstocks for
1981 0.56 benzene production, the amounts of toluene
Western Europe 1980 0.59 and xylenes produced are of direct significance.
Japan 1980 0.71 Table 27 contains production figures for toluene
and xylenes.
The prices of the BTX chemicals in the United
States are documented annually by the United
Table 25. United States benzene production from petroleum and from States International Trade Commission (USITC)
coal, 1000 t
Year Production from Total % From Refer- Table 26. Benzene production and sales of synthetic organic chemi-
coal ence cals (USITC)
petro- coal
leum Year Production, 1000 t Sales, 1000 t
1953 211 702 913 76.9 [95] Petro- Coke- Petro- Coke-
1955 332 699 1031 67.8 [95] leum oven leum oven
1960 1034 495 1529 38.4 [95] refiners operators refiners operators
1965 2335 435 2770 15.7 [95]
1970 3415 402 3817 10.5 [95] 1977 4580 216 1983 217
1978 4573 398 4971 8 [101] 1978 4793 179 2347 181
1981 4170 314 4484 7 [101] 1979 5383 204 2817 200
1986* 4930 315 5245* 6 [101] 1980 6535 170 3661 169
1981 4368 105 2190 107
*
Projected
Vol. 5 Benzene 263
Table 27. Toluene and xylene production in different countries, 1000 t Germany as published by SRI International [101]
[96–99]
showed roughly equivalent prices, with the Unit-
Country 1976 1978 1979 1980 1981 1982 ed States price range of $ 0.40 – 0.41/L; Japan,
$ 0.40 – 0.42/L; and the Federal Republic of
Toluene
United States 3279 4195 5379 5111 4680 3478
Germany $ 0.38 – 0.40/L.
United Kingdom 293 190 179 169
Federal Republic 233 225 298 260 262 268
of Germany
Japan 858 861 925 889 821 803
10. Uses
Canada 493 560 569 504
Mexico 124 108 125 132 138 With the exception of its use as a motor fuel
Italy 366 286 278 268 component and with the restrictions on its use as
Brazil 72 82 104 60 69 a solvent, the three main applications for benzene
France 86 64 56 31
are production of ethylbenzene, cumene, and
Xylenes cyclohexane. These three products account for
United States 2363 2794 3125 2902 2916 2399 75 – 80 % of the benzene consumed as a chemi-
Federal Republic 477 414 492 355 486 459 cal feedstock. Table 29 gives 1980 benzene
of Germany
Japan 1169 1248 1317 1195 1202 1225
consumption by product [101]. A distribution of
Mexico 93 82 93 103 115 products and end uses of benzene in the United
Italy 323 283 256 268 States is shown in Table 30.
Brazil 117 134 Most of the primary products of benzene may
be classified as intermediates. For example, ben-
[103]. Prices have fluctuated but in general have zene is alkylated with ethylene to form ethylben-
increased over the years (see Table 28). The zene, which in turn is dehydrogenated to styrene
values given in this table are for all grades and (! Ethylbenzene, ! Styrene). Styrene is the
include values assigned to the aromatics retained monomer employed for the production of several
and used as components in fuel blends. Some important polymeric or copolymeric products.
small variations in price are evident depending These include acrylic – butadiene – styrene re-
on the source and quality of the aromatic. For sins, styrene – butadiene rubber, and others
benzene in 1981, the all-grades average price was [105].
$ 0.45/L. Benzene from coke-oven sources com- Cumene, another large-volume product made
manded $ 0.44/L and 1 C and 2 C benzene from benzene, is used as a charge stock for the
from petroleum refiners averaged $ 0.45/L. Spot production of phenol and acetone. Cumene is
prices for benzene, toluene, and xylenes are made by the vapor-phase alkylation of benzene
published regularly in technical and trade jour- with propene. Most of the phenol produced in the
nals. In the August 17, 1983 issue of Chemical United States and non-communist countries is
Week [104], the price of benzene was $ 0.41/L or derived from the hydroperoxidation of cumene.
less, with toluene and xylenes endeavoring to
command $ 0.29/L and $ 0.30/L, respectively. A Table 29. Benzene consumption in various countries (1980), 1000 t
[101]
comparison of benzene prices in July, 1982 for
United States, Japan, and the Federal Republic of United Western Canada Mexico Japan
States Europe
Table 30. Benzene consumption in the United States aftereffects, such as anemia and probably leuke-
Year 1975 1977 1980 1986 * mia. Brain damage and damage to the urinary
tract, mucous membranes, and other body parts
Demand, 1000 t 3596 4886 5170 5610 were found in postmortem studies of acute and
Consumption, wt %
Ethylbenzene 52 55 48 51 51 fatal poisoning [107].
Cumene 17 17 20 21 24 Inhalation of benzene at different concentra-
Cyclohexane 17 16 17 14 14 tions in air is the most common source of benzene
Nitrobenzene/aniline 4.7 5 5 5 5 poisoning because benzene is rapidly absorbed
Detergent alkylate 3.4 2.8 – 3 2.7
Chlorobenzenes 4.5 2.9 – 2.6 2.1 by the lungs. Ingestion by mouth causes irritation
Maleic anhydride 3.2 2.9 4 2.8 – of the mouth, esophagus, and stomach. Absorp-
Other – – 6 0.8 0.8 tion of benzene by the blood may follow, with
Reference [101] [101] [2] [101] [101] resultant chronic or acute poisoning. Absorption
*
Projected of benzene through the skin is not a major source
of benzene poisoning [108].
The potential toxicity of benzene has been the
Phenol is used mainly for the production of subject of numerous studies [109], [110]. Ben-
phenolic resins. zene is selectively absorbed by the lungs [111].
Cyclohexane is the third largest volume inter- About 80 % of the benzene inhaled by breathing
mediate product derived from benzene. It is air containing 3000 – 5000 ppm of benzene is
produced by the direct hydrogenation of benzene retained. The benzene is absorbed by the blood
[106]. Cyclohexane is oxidized to form inter- and can become fixed in bone marrow, fatty
mediates, such as adipic acid, and thus serves as tissues, and the liver. It is slowly metabolized
the starting point for the production of nylons. to phenols and related compounds before being
About 5 % of the benzene produced is nitrated eliminated. Removal of benzene from the body
to form nitrobenzene, which in turn is hydroge- by metabolism is determined by the presence of
nated to form aniline. phenols in the urine. The phenols may act as toxic
The oxidation of benzene is an established intermediates. The relationship between metab-
process for the production of maleic anhydride olism and benzene toxicity has been the subject
but it is receiving stiff competition from other of many studies [112], [113]. If benzene metab-
processes, notably those involving the oxidation olism is inhibited by the addition of toluene, the
of butane and butenes. Maleic anhydride serves destruction of red cell production is reduced
as a precursor for polyester resins. [114]. Some inhaled benzene is slowly removed
Other products of benzene include the halo- by exhalation. People breathing air containing
genated benzenes and the linear alkylbenzenes. 100 ppm benzene exhaled benzene 24 h after
The latter are a source for the production of they ceased inhaling the benzene-contaminated
detergents. air [115].
Susceptibility to benzene poisoning varies
with the individual. Women, especially pregnant
11. Toxicology and Occupational women, reportedly are more susceptible than
Health men, but this has not been substantiated in other
studies [116]. Individual susceptibility probably
Benzene has long been recognized as a toxic results from the natural resistance of the person or
compound with both acute and chronic effects. from the state of health at the time of exposure.
Poisoning occurs through inhalation, ingestion, Cases have been cited where workers, generally
and by rapid absorption through the skin. Man- unconscious as a result of exposure to benzene
ifestations of acute benzene poisoning include fumes in enclosed areas, have recovered, where-
headaches, confusion, loss of muscular control, as members of the rescue teams have died [117].
and irritation of the respiratory and gastrointes- The literature is replete with references con-
tinal tract. Greater concentrations may result in cerning the potential toxicity of benzene or that
unconsciousness and even in death. Exposure to of its metabolized products and the various ef-
long-term chronic poisoning or shorter term ex- fects on the body. NTIS Report PB-289189 [118]
posure at higher concentrations may have drastic reviews research findings of the effects of
Vol. 5 Benzene 265
benzene poisoning at environmental exposure exposure to benzene has been studied. Partial
levels. Potential effects considered include leu- recovery of blood and bone marrow damage may
kemia, especially acute myelogenous leukemia, result on cessation of exposure if the damage has
and pancytopenia (including aplastic anemia and not been too great.
chromosomal effects) and may result from long- An EPA report [118] discusses the health
term exposure. Again indications suggest that effects caused by benzene at relatively low levels
benzene toxicity and damage occur because of a of concentration in terms of leukemia and blood
toxic metabolite of benzene. disorders. Studies were made on humans and on
A group of chemical workers from seven animals.
industrial plants who had been exposed for 30 Some investigations suggest that chromo-
years to benzene for extended periods of time, but some rearrangement may be caused by chronic
not necessarily continuously, were studied [119]. exposure to benzene [110], [124]. Chromosomal
The incidence of various forms of cancer and the damage of both stable and unstable nature can
mortality rate of these workers was higher than, occur after benzene exposure. The stable effect
but not significantly above, those of the national was found to remain for several years. Alkylated
norm. benzenes did not cause this effect. These chro-
Although conflicting reports have been issued mosome aberrations might result in the develop-
over the years, it is generally believed that inha- ment of leukemia.
lation of benzene in occupational environments Although benzene has been universally rec-
is potentially a cause of leukemia. An early ognized as a very toxic chemical compound with
indication of this relation was contained in a chronic and acute poisoning effects, questions
1928 report [120]. In 1939, several cases of still remain regarding its carcinogenicity. For
leukemia were reported in patients who had been instance, much research continues to determine
chronically exposed to benzene [121]. In 1973, whether benzene exposure results in leukemia.
chronic benzene poisoning was thought to be Studies have been done on animals and on groups
responsible for four cases of acute leukemia. of workers exposed to benzene vapors under
These patients had worked in an atmosphere varying operational conditions. Two examples
containing 150 – 200 ppm benzene. According of studies relating to leukemia indicate that
to other studies the connection between benzene much additional work is needed to sort out
poisoning and leukemia and other malignant the complexities associated with the problem
conditions is much less certain. A 1974 survey and to determine the quantitative level of expo-
included 38000 petroleum workers from eight sure [125], [126].
refineries in Europe [122]. The purpose of the Exposure to benzene emissions may occur
study was to determine if the incidence of leuke- from many sources. A major source of evapora-
mia could be related to workers chronically tive benzene emissions is from motor gasoline,
exposed to benzene at low-concentration levels. both in exhaust gases from automobiles and from
The conclusion was that the incidence of leuke- handling of gasoline during transport to service
mia in the chronically exposed workers was not stations and from the filling of automobile tanks.
significantly different from that of the general Gasolines generally contain from 3 – 5 vol%
population as a whole. However, this work has benzene. Depending on control of emissions, a
been criticized because of the different variables concentration of up to 3.2 ppm of benzene in the
and assumptions made in the study. The results of air may exist in the vicinity of the operation
other investigations indicate that benzene is sus- [127].
pected as a potential cause of leukemia. Another source of benzene emissions is in the
Benzene toxicity has been related also to manufacture of benzene and gasolines. Efficient
pancytopenia or destruction of elements in the process control in refineries, however, maintains
blood. A related effect of benzene exposure is evaporative losses at a minimum. Historically, a
aplastic anemia in which bone marrow is dam- major source of benzene emissions was in the use
aged or destroyed. One early investigation stud- of benzene or benzene-containing solvents in the
ied workers in the printing industry who had been formulation of paints, thinners, and adhesives.
exposed for a long period to benzene vapors Because of the high-toxic characteristics of
[123]. More recently the long-term effect of benzene its use in these applications has been
266 Benzene Vol. 5
practically eliminated. Regulations state that Indicative of the activity and studies related to
substitute solvents should be used wherever pos- the toxicity of benzene and other poisonous
sible. At one time alkylated mononuclear aro- materials, the following may be cited. A report
matics, such as toluene and xylene, were consid- on different carcinogens and methods for defin-
ered to have toxic effects equal to that of benzene. ing their risk factors has been issued by the
However, benzene is unique in most of its toxic Interagency Regulatory Liaison Group (IRLG)
effects. Earlier reports on the toxic effects of listing 26 substances, including benzene, and
toluene and xylene may have overlooked the fact relating these to occupations that show high
that benzene was present in these compounds cancer rates [134].
[128]. The lower relative volatility of these al- The International Register of Potentially Toxic
kylated aromatics is another factor in their favor. Chemicals (IRPTC) represents an international
Coal carbonization, for the production of coal agency that is studying and registering the various
coke for steel mill use, produces large amounts of effects of toxic chemicals under different condi-
aromatic compounds with benzene present in tions for each material. These conditions include
high concentrations. factors related to production sampling, carcino-
Treatment for acute benzene poisoning is genicity, treatment of poisoning, and others [135].
similar to that used for many cases of poisoning The IRPTC was initiated in 1971 and is plan-
from toxic volatile chemicals. These steps in- ning to publish its findings. The initial list of
clude removing the person from the source, chemicals and products number 300 and more are
artificial respiration, if necessary, and other stan- to be added each year. The register is hoped to
dard first-aid procedures. bring an international uniformity of information
Good laboratory and plant practices are para- and control.
mount in preventing benzene poisoning. These
involve minimum concentrations of benzene,
either in liquid or vapor form, in work areas.
Nonpermeable gloves have been suggested and References
tested as a means of preventing skin contact.
Viton rubber or poly(vinyl alcohol) materials Specific References
were found to be the best of those tested. How- 1 M. Faraday, Trans. R. Soc. (London) 115 (1825) 440.
ever, these gloves are expensive and gloves are 2 L. H. Hatch, S. Matar, Hydrocarbon Process. 57 (1978)
no. 11, 291 – 301.
not always a guarantee of protection [129], [130]. 3 R. Maux, Hydrocarbon Process. 55 (1976) no. 3, 90.
The TLVs for benzene adopted by the ACGIH 4 Hydrocarbon Process. 60 (1981) no. 11, 196.
for 1983 – 1984 are: TWA 10 ppm, 30 mg/m3; 5 A. C. MacFarlane, Oil Gas J. 74 (1976) no. 6, 99 – 102.
and STEL 25 ppm, 75 mg/m3. Benzene is listed 6 Hydrocarbon Process. 56 (1977) no. 11, 144.
as a class A 2 industrial substance suspected of 7 P. R. Pujado, Hydrocarbon Process. 55 (1976) no. 3,
carcinogenic potential for humans (10 ppm) 91 – 96.
[131]. 8 F. Treeny, Erd€ol Kohle 20 (1967) no. 9, 629 – 634.
The DFG does not give a MAK for benzene 9 Oil Gas J. 61 (1963) no. 15, 125.
10 L. Aalund, Oil Gas J. 74 (1976) no. 27, 98 – 108.
but lists it in Section III A 1 under working 11 D. E. Steeve, W. A. MacDonald, D. H. Stone, Hydro-
materials which have been unequivocably carbon Process. 61 (1981) no. 9, 263 – 268.
proved carcinogenic. It is a compound capable 12 M. Sittig: Aromatic Hydrocarbons, Manufacture and
of inducing malignant tumors as shown by expe- Technology, Noyes Data Corp., London 1976, p. 73.
rience with humans [132]. 13 Bethlehem Steel Co., US 3312749, 1967 (C. J. Hess,
With the spotlight on the toxicity of benzene, W. M. Perry).
tighter restrictions will probably be imposed on 14 Air Products, US 3564067, 1971 (W. C. Brenner,
the use, the handling, and the exposure limits of L. C. Doelph).
15 Bethlehem Steel Co., US 3623973, 1971 (M. O. Tarhan).
benzene. The new regulations may be in the 1- 16 M. O. Tarhan, L. H. Windsor, Chem. Eng. 1966 (March
ppm range. Recently the EPA has issued stan- 28) 96 – 98.
dards mostly aimed at benzene, projected to 17 J. M. Duffalo, D. C. Spence, W. A. Schwartz, Chem.
reduce emissions of volatile organic compounds Eng. Prog., 77 (January 2, 1981) 56 – 62.
by 70 %. This would apply to petroleum refiner- 18 D. McNeil: Coal Carbonization Products, Pergamon
ies and chemical plants [133]. Press, 1966, p. 54.
Vol. 5 Benzene 267
19 E. J. Houdry, W. F. Burt, A. E. Pew, W. A. Peters, Pet. 55 T. Wett, Oil Gas J. 78 (June 16, 1980) 55 – 61.
Refiner 17 (November 1938) 574 – 582. 56 R. Serrurier, Hydrocarbon Process. 55 (1976) no. 9,
20 Houdry Chemical, US 2078945, 1937 (E. J. Houdry). 253 – 257.
21 Socony, US 2384942, 1945 (M. M. Marisic). 57 R. G. Nene, Hydrocarbon Process. 60 (1981) no. 11,
22 E. V. Murphree et al., Pet. Refiner 24 (1945) 97 – 100. 287 – 290.
23 R. T. Sebulsky et al., Oil Gas J. 66 (1968) no. 21, 103 – 58 R. C. Robinson, D. H. Broderick, H. A. Frumkin,
109. Hydrocarbon Process. 61 (1982) no. 11, 102 – 108.
24 A. N. Sachanen: Conversion of Petroleum, Reinhold 59 H. Hiller, O. L. Garkisch, Hydrocarbon Process. 59
Publ. Co., New York 1948, pp. 345 – 350. (1980) no. 9, 238 – 242.
25 Hydrocarbon Process. 61 (1982) no. 9, 164 – 169. 60 J. J. Wise, A. J. Silvesti, Oil Gas J. 74 (1976) no. 47,
26 E. A. Sutton, A. R. Greenwood, F. H. Adams, Oil Gas 140 – 142.
J. 70 (1972) no. 21, 52 – 56. 61 M. Steinberg, P. T. Fallon, Hydrocarbon Process. 61
27 Oil Gas J. 65 (1967) no. 8, 70 – 75. (1982) no. 11, 92 – 96.
28 S. B. Zdonik, E. J. Green, L. P. Hallee, Oil Gas J. 64 62 Oil Gas J. 82 (May 14, 1984) 76 – 80.
(1966) no. 51, 75 – 80. 63 J. B. O’Hara et al., Hydrocarbon Process. 57 (1978)
29 J. G. Freiling, A. A. Simone, Oil Gas J. 71 (1973) no. 1, no. 11, 117 – 121.
25 – 31. 64 Hydrocarbon Process. 61 (1982) no. 9, 126.
30 W. Kronig, 7th World Petroleum Congress, 4 (1967) 65 p. 125.
235. 66 R. Lester, Hydrocarbon Process. 40 (1961) 175.
31 D. J. Griffiths, D. M. Luntz, J. L. James, Oil Gas J. 66 67 K. H. Eisenlohr, Erd€ ol Kohle 16 (1963) no. 6, 523 –
(1968) no. 8, 107 – 108. 533.
32 S. Field, Am. Pet. Inst. Proc. Refining Division 50 (1970) 68 J. A. Gerster, Chem. Eng. Prog. 65 (1969) no. 9, 43 –
340 – 365. 46.
33 A. H. Weiss, J. A. Marker, R. Newwirth, Oil Gas J. 60 69 M. Sittig: Aromatic Hydrocarbons, Manufacture and
(1962) no. 4, 64 – 71. Technology, Noyes Data Corp. N.J., London 1976,
34 G. F. Asselin, R. A. Erickson, Chem. Eng. Prog. 58 pp. 104 – 141.
(1962) no. 4, 47 – 52. 70 E. G. Hancock: Benzene and its Industrial Derivatives,
35 Ind. Eng. Chem. 54 (1962) no. 2, 28 – 33. J. Wiley & Sons, 1975, Chaps. 2, 3.
36 Hydrocarbon Process. 60 (1981) no. 11, 138. 71 H. W. Grote, Chem. Eng. Progress. 54 (1958) no. 8,
37 Hydrocarbon Process. 46 (1967) no. 11, 184. 43 – 48.
38 p. 187. 72 Hydrocarbon Process. 49 (1970) no. 9, 248.
39 S. Feigelman, C. B. O’Connor, Hydrocarbon Process. 73 D. P. Thornton, Jr., Pet. Process. 8 (March 1953) 384 –
45 (1966) no. 5, 140 – 144. 387.
40 Hydrocarbon Process. 44 (1965) no. 11, 277. 74 G. S. Somekh, B. I. Friedlander, Hydrocarbon Process.
41 S. Masamune et al., Hydrocarbon Process. 46 (1967) 48 (1969) no. 12, 127 – 130.
no. 2, 155 – 158. 75 T. S. Hoover, Hydrocarbon Process. 48 (1969) no. 12,
42 S. Masamune, T. Kawatani, Hydrocarbon Process. 47 131 – 132.
(1968) no. 12, 111 – 117. 76 H. G. Staaterman, R. C. Morris, R. M. Stager,
43 Hydrocarbon Process. 61 (1981) no. 11, 139; 50 (1971) G. J. Pierotti, Chem. Eng. Prog. 43 (1947) no. 4,
no. 11, 133. 148 – 151.
44 S. Otani, Jpn. Chem. Q. 4 (1968) no. 6, 16. 77 G. H. Deal, Jr., H. D. Evans, E. D. Oliver, M. N.
45 E. G. Hancock (ed.): Benzene and Its Industrial Deri- Papaopoulos, Pet. Refiner 38 (1959) no. 9, 185 – 192.
vatives, J. Wiley & Sons, New York 1975, pp. 66, 67. 78 Hydrocarbon Process. 59 (1980) no. 9, 203.
46 R. G. Craig, C. E. Fowler, M. L. Raczynski, ACS 79 D. B. Broughton, G. F. Asselin: 7th World Petroleum
Meeting, Minneapolis, April 13 – 18, 1969. Congress, Mexico City, April 2 – 8 1967, Section 4,
47 Hydrocarbon Process. 61 (1982) no. 9, 153. pp. 65 – 73.
48 M. O. Tarhan, L. H. Windsor, Chem. Eng. 73 (March, 28, 80 Ullmann, 4th ed., 8: 395, 398.
1966) 96 – 98. 81 p. 52.
49 W. Lorz et al., Erd€ ol Kohle 21 (1968) 610. 82 Oil Gas J. 64 (1966) no. 29, 83 – 84.
50 H. Kubo, S. Masamune, R. Sako, Hydrocarbon Process. 83 K. H. Eisenlohr, W. Grosshans, Erd€ ol Kohle 18 (1965)
49 (1970) no. 7, 111 – 113. no. 8, 614 – 618.
51 S. Komatsu, Ind. Eng. Chem. 60 (1968) no. 2, 36. 84 J. Lautier, J. Durandet, C. Raumbault, M. Viguier, Rev.
52 Mitsubishi Petrochemical Co., US 3400168 1968 (F. Inst. Fr. Pet. 20 (1965) 181 – 190.
Fukudaetal). 85 B. Choffe, C. Raumbault, F. P. Navarre, M. Lucas,
53 P. Grandio: 162nd ACS Annual Meeting, Washington, Hydrocarbon Process. 45 (1966) no. 5, 188 – 192.
D.C., September 12 – 17, 1971. 86 Hydrocarbon Process. 51 (1972) no. 9, 185.
54 P. Grandio, F. H. Schneider, A. B. Schwartz, J. J. Wise, 87 E. Cinelli, S. Noe, G. Paret, Hydrocarbon Process. 51
Oil Gas J. 69 (1971) no. 48, 62 – 69. (1972) no. 4, 141 – 144.
268 Benzene Vol. 5
88 K. H. Eisenlohr: 6th World Petroleum Congress, Frank- 118 Report PB 289–789, National Technical Information
furt/Main, June 19 – 26, 1963, Section 4, Paper 8. Service, Sept., 1978, p. 47.
89 Hydrocarbon Process. 61 (1982) no. 9, 182. 119 O. Wong: ‘‘An Industry-Wide Mortality Study of Chem-
90 J. Morrison, Oil Gas J. 68 (1970) no. 47, 49 – 64. ical Workers Occupationally Exposed to Benzene,’’
91 F. Trefny, Erd€ol Kohle 23 (1970) no. 6, 337 – 340. Report to Chemical Manufacturers Assoc., Environmen-
92 M. Stein, Hydrocarbon Process. 52 (1973) no. 4, 139 – tal Health Assoc., Berkely, Calif. Dec. 8, 1983.
141. 120 P. Delore, Borganamo, J. Med. Lyon 9 (1928) 227 – 233.
93 Hydrocarbon Process. 61 (1982) no. 9, 186. 121 T. B. Mallory, E. A. Gall, Brickley, J. Ind. Hyg. Toxicol.
94 Hydrocarbon Process. 61 (1982) no. 9, 187. 21 (1939) 355 – 393.
95 Ullmann, 4th ed., 8: 384. 122 J. J. Thorpe, J. Occup. Med. 16 (1974) 375 – 382.
96 ‘‘Facts and Figures, ’’ Chem. Eng. News 57 (June 11, 123 L. J. Goldwater, Tewksbury, J. Ind. Hyg. 26 (1941) 957–
1979) 32. 973.
97 ‘‘Facts and Figures, ’’ Chem. Eng. News 61 (June 13, 124 E. Vigiliani, A. Forni, J. Occup. Med. 11 (1969) 148 –
1983) 26. 149.
98 Chem. Eng. News 60 (Dec. 20, 1982) 48. 125 Chem. Eng. News 59 (September 7, 1981) 68.
99 ‘‘Facts and Figures’’, Chem. Eng. News 60 (June 14, 126 Chem. Eng. News 54 (April 26, 1976) 7.
1982) 81. 127 G. S. Parkinson, Ann. Occup. Hyg. 14 (1971) 145 – 153.
100 ‘‘Facts and Figures’’, Chem. Eng. News 62 (June 11, 128 J. Aryanpur: Tenth World Petroleum Congress, Buchar-
1984) 32. est, 1979, vol. 5, p. 237.
101 C. S. Hughes, A. B. Abshire: ‘‘Benzene,’’ Chemical 129 E. B. Sansone, V. B. Tewari, Am. Ind. Hyg. Assoc. J. 39
Economics Handbook, SRI International, February, (1978) no. 2, 169 – 174.
1983, 300.7000 I, J. 130 Chem. Week 125 (October 31, 1979) no. 18, 20.
102 T. Wett, Oil Gas J. 80 (1982) no. 13, 81 – 84. 131 ACGIH (ed.): Threshold Limit Values (TLV)1983 –
103 ‘‘Synthetic Organic Chemicals (U.S. Production and 1984, ACGIH Cincinnati, Ohio 1984.
Sales)’’ U.S. International Trade Commission Publica- 132 DFG (ed.): Maximum Concentrations at the Workplace
tions 920 (1977), 1099 (1979), 1183 (1980) ,1292 (MAK), Verlag Chemie, Weinheim, Germany 1982.
(1981). 133 Chem. Eng. News 62 (June 4, 1984) 5.
104 Chem. Week 133 (1983) no. 7, 29. 134 Chem. Eng. News 60 (Feb. 12, 1982) 4.
105 T. C. Ponder, Hydrocarbon Process. 56 (1977) no. 7, 135 Chem. Eng. News 60 (May 10, 1982) 25.
135 – 138.
106 Hydrocarbon Process. 60 (1981) no. 11, 147, 148.
107 H. W. Gerarde: Toxicology and Biochemistry of Aromatic
Hydrocarbons, Elsevier, New York 1960, pp. 97 – 98. Further Reading
108 H. E. W. Publication, NIOSH, Washington, D.C., 1974,
pp. 74 – 137. L. Ackermann (ed.): Modern Arylation Methods, Wiley-
109 ‘‘Assessment of Benzene as a Potential Air Pollution VCH, Weinheim 2009.
Problem,’’ Report P. B. 258–356 National Technical G. C. Bond: Metal-Catalysed Reactions of Hydrocarbons,
Information Service, vol. 4, 1976. Springer, Boston, MA 2005.
110 ‘‘Health Effects of Benzene,’’ Report P. B. 254–388, G. Centi, F. Trifiró, S. Perathoner, F. Cavani: Sustainable
National Technical Information Service, June, 1976. Industrial Processes, Wiley-VCH, Weinheim 2009.
111 ‘‘Metabolism versus Toxicity of Benzene,’’ Report P. B. G. P. Chiusoli, P. M. Maitlis (eds.): Metal-Catalysis in
289–789, National Technical Information Service, Sept. Industrial Organic Processes, Royal Society of Chemis-
1978, p. 8. try, Cambridge 2006.
112 A.Stulmann, C.P. Stewart:Toxicology of VolatileLiquids, H. Dodziuk (ed.): Strained Hydrocarbons, Wiley-VCH,
vol. 1, Academic Press, New York 1960, pp. 61 – 63. Weinheim 2009.
113 P. C. Parke, R. T. Williams, Biochem. J. 54 (1954) W. Fruscella: Benzene, ‘‘Kirk Othmer Encyclopedia of
231 – 238. Chemical Technology’’, 5th edition, vol. 3, p. 596–624,
114 L. S. Andrews, E. W. Lee, C. M. Witmer, J. J. Kocsis, John Wiley & Sons, Hoboken, NJ, 2004, online DOI:
Biochem. J. 1977 243. 10.1002/0471238961.0205142606182119.a01.pub2
115 C. G. Hunter, Proc. R. Soc. Med. 61 (1968) 913 – 915. Y. P. Yampolskii, I. Pinnau, B. D. Freeman: Materials
116 F. T. Hunter, J. Ind. Hyg. Toxicol. 21 (1939) 331. Science of Membranes for Gas and Vapor Separation,
117 G. L. Winek, W. D. Collom, J. Occup. Med. 13 (1971) Wiley, Chichester 2006.
250 – 261.