Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
net/publication/6833223
CITATIONS READS
36 146
4 authors:
Some of the authors of this publication are also working on these related projects:
Olajide TG, Olajuyin O. A Review and Outcome of Adenoidectomy performed in resource limited settings. Indian J Otolaryngol Head and Neck surg View project
All content following this page was uploaded by Adekunle David Dunmade on 06 April 2016.
Ó The Author 2006. Published by Oxford University Press. All rights reserved. doi:10.1093/deafed/enl019
For Permissions, please email: journals.permissions@oxfordjournals.org Advance Access publication on September 6, 2006
Profound Bilateral Sensorineural Hearing Loss in Nigerian Children 113
In a retrospective review of 105 patients with pro- developed countries in which some parents show in-
found sensorineural hearing loss, aged 1.5–5 years at- difference and occasionally preference for a deaf child
tending otorhinolaryngology clinic in Ghana between (Anstey, 2002; Levy, 2002). In our society, the attitude
1979 and 1984, Brobby (1988) observed 21% had con- of the hearing and seeing members of the community
genital unknown causes. Of the 79% with acquired toward the deaf is partially discriminatory and suspi-
causes, the main factors were measles (30%), febrile cious (Lasisi & Ajuwon, 2002; Owoeye, Ologe, &
illness (19%), birth trauma (9.5%), meningitis (8.5%), Akande, in press).
rubella (3.8%), mumps (3.5%), and neonatal jaundice There is better awareness, availability, and use of
(1.9%). hearing aids in Nigeria today. In fact, an impressive
Mc Pherson and Holborrow (1985) in a 2-year local technology has resulted in small-scale production
(1981–1983) fieldwork undertaken throughout the of much more affordable individual and group hearing
Gambia observed 41.3% congenital causes of severe aid, which is being used with some benefit. An otorhi-
to profound sensorineural hearing loss among 259 chil- nolaryngologist, with interest in audiology, is carrying
dren aged 2–10 years, 33.2% unknown, and 8.1% out this project. Local electronics-oriented technolo-
familial. Of the acquired causes, meningitis and men- gists assist him. The individual hearing aid is body
been spent for educational training and rehabilitation, (Impedance audiometer AT 235) in accordance with
in search of traditional healers (Ijaduola, 1982; Mc standard procedure (O’Connor, 1997; Ologe, Okoro, &
Pherson & Holborrow, 1985). Oyejola, 2005). Patients less than 5 years old had free
Situation may be only slightly better now, espe- field hearing assessment by observing their response
cially for those who have means. There is probably to various sounds (the loudness of the sounds were
no kind of hearing aid, irrespective of the sophistica- measured using a sound level meter, Testo 815 [Testo
tion, that is not found among wealthy Nigerians. To GmbH & Co., Lenzkirch, Germany]), duly calibrated
this date, National Health Service does not distribute with a sound level meter calibrator (Testo 0554.0009).
hearing aids. Hearing aids are excluded from areas Older children had pure tone audiometry using a clin-
covered by the newly established (2005) National ical audiometer (Danplex AS 67), equipped with well-
Health Insurance Scheme. fitting standard headphones (TDH 39). Equipment
Results of work done in West Africa showed that was calibrated with sound level meter (Testo 815)
much of the sensorineural deafness could be prevented initially and periodically to ensure accuracy of mea-
(Brobby, 1988; Holborow et al., 1982; Ijaduola, 1982; surements. Testing was carried out in a double-walled
Mc Pherson & Holborrow, 1985; Wright, 1991). Thus, soundproof booth in accordance with standard proce-
Table 1 Age and gender distribution of the children (3.5%), and cerebral palsy 3 (2.6%). This is compa-
Age (years) Male (%) Female (%) Total (%) rable, in fact higher than the previous quoted studies
1–3 15 (13.0) 18 (15.7) 33 (28.7) except the study from Ghana (Brobby, 1988).
4–6 16 (13.9) 10 (8.7) 26 (22.6) A few years ago, there was a report from Sierra
7–9 16 (13.9) 9 (7.8) 25 (21.7) Leone demonstrating an inverse relationship between
10–12 9 (7.8) 9 (7.8) 18 (15.7)
the incidence of measles-induced sensorineural hear-
13–15 8 (7.0) 5 (4.3) 13 (11.3)
Total 64 (55.6) 51 (44.3) 115 (100.0) ing loss and the increased immunization coverage
(Wright & Leigh, 1995). But authors add that the
evidence linking the sharp decline in the incidence
(13.9%), meningitis (8.7%), mumps (6.9%), and se-
of measles-induced sensorineural hearing loss with
vere birth asphyxia (4.3%).
the decline in the number of reported measles cases
could be circumstantial. They suggest that more direct
Discussion evidence of the linkage could accrue to a survey for
sensorineural hearing loss in the relevant population
About two thirds of the causes of deafness in this
(Wright & Leigh, 1995).
Table 3 Summary of reports of studies done two decades ago in West Africa
Holborrow Brobby Mc Pherson Ijaduola Wright Ilorin
(1977–1979) (1979–1984) (1981–1983) (1981) (1975–1985) (1977–1979)
(%) (%) (%) (%) (%) (%)a
Congenital unknown 36 21 33.2 36.2 28 59.7
Measles 20.5 30 1.9 13 45 8.1
Febrile illness 11.4 19 21.2 5 3 21.0
Meningitis 18 8.5 31.7 11 15 8.1
Mumps 1.5 3.5 — 3 2 —
Rubella 1.5 3.8 1.5 2 3 —
Malaria 0.4 — — — — —
Familial 3.2 — 8.1 13.1 — 4.8
Birth trauma 4.3 9.5 — 1.7 — —
Jaundice 0.6 1.9 — 5.7 — —
Trauma 0.6 — — — 4 —
Tetanus — 2.5 — — — —
Ototoxicity — — — 9 — —
factors in deafness in several studies in the West Africa Fifteen percent of patients who survive acute bacterial
subregion (Bondi, 1992; Chukuezi, 1991; Holborow meningitis develop neurological sequelae, and perma-
et al., 1982; Wright & Leigh, 1995). Malaria causing nent sensorineural hearing loss account for approxi-
deafness in children needs to be investigated further. It mately 75% of these cases (Barton, Court, & Walker,
is thought that malaria infection may cause deafness 1962; Brobby, 1988; Holborow et al., 1982; Mc
either by local action with microvascular changes in Pherson & Holborrow, 1985).
the end arteries of the cochlea or in a general way by One child was suspected to have congenital rubella
lowering resistance to disease and thus enhancing the syndrome. There was a positive history of fever and
adverse effects of other infections. rashes while the mother was pregnant. The child also
Hereditary and congenital causes of sensorineural had other associated congenital problems such as
hearing loss are poorly studied and hardly diagnosed squint and cataract. However, no serological confirma-
early in our environment. In Gambia 8% and in South tion was done. Brobby (1988) was unable to validate
Africa 11% of childhood hearing loss has been attrib- the diagnosis of rubella in his series because there was
uted to heredity (Mc Pherson & Holborrow, 1985; no serological evidence. However, the clinical history
Sellars & Beighton, 1983). Family tracing is difficult was clear and typical, and the children had distinct
because of the associated stigma. We were unsuccess- clinical signs of the syndrome (Brobby, 1988). Rubella
ful in this study to identify specific familial hearing is an apparently minor disease with tragic sequelae.
loss. This is probably due to the aforementioned rea- The diagnosis of rubella depends largely on the retro-
son. Genetic studies are close to nonexistent in most spective history from the mother, and in circumstances
health care delivery centers. This is not peculiar to where minor fevers are common, the incidence of
Nigeria (Brobby, 1988). The attitude of parents to moderate cervical lymphatic glandular enlargement
prenatal diagnoses of deafness is yet to be studied. unremarkable, and a faint skin rash unnoticeable, it
Because unknown causes accounts for a third of the is no wonder that rubella occurring during pregnancy
etiological factors, there is need to be more rigorous may go entirely unrecorded (Holborow et al., 1982).
concerning studies in this area. The proportion of our patients with profound sen-
In the current study, meningitis maintained its sorineural hearing loss secondary to mumps was at
traditional pride of place as one of the top three causes least twice the proportion reported two decades ago
of profound sensorineural hearing loss in children. in West Africa (see Table 3) (Brobby, 1988; Holborow
Profound Bilateral Sensorineural Hearing Loss in Nigerian Children 117
et al., 1982; Ijaduola, 1982; Mc Pherson & Holborrow, toward prevention. Prevention is by far cheaper and
1985; Wright, 1991). Mumps is known to commonly better than rehabilitation. Prevention will also reduce
cause unilateral sensorineural hearing loss (Brobby, the number of patients competing for the scarce
1988). And becausechildren can cope well with one resources required for rehabilitation.
functioning ear, there may be underreporting of sen-
sorineural hearing loss secondary to mumps (Brobby, References
1988).
Alberti, P. W. (1997). Noise and the ear. In S. Daffyds & A. G.
Rubella, measles, mumps, and viruses that produce Kerr (Eds.), Scott Brown’s otolaryngology. Adult audiology.
a similar pathology are believed to infiltrate the stria (6th ed., pp. 2/11/1–2/11/28). London: Butterworth/
vascularis of the cochlea during the viremic stage, and Heinemann.
Anstey, K. W. (2002). Are attempts to have impaired children
from there they either enter the endolymph directly or
justified? Journal of Medical Ethics, 28, 286–288.
damage the metabolic functions of the stria vascularis Barton, M. E., Court, S. D., & Walker, W. (1962). Causes of
in some way (Brobby, 1988). severe deafness in school children in Northumberland and
The male preponderance in this study is consistent Durham. British Medical Journal, 1, 351–355.
Bondi, F. S. (1992). The incidence and outcome of neurological
with previous similar studies in West Africa
O’Connor, A. F. (1997). Examination of the ear. In A. G. Kerr & Sellars, S., & Beighton, P. (1983). Childhood deafness in south-
J. B. Booth (Eds.), Scott Brown’s otolaryngology: Otology ern Africa. An aetiological survey of 3,064 deaf children.
(6th ed., pp. 3/1/1–3/1/29). Oxford, England: Journal of Laryngology & Otology, 97, 885–889.
Butterworth/Heinemann. World Health Organization. (1997). Prevention of noise induced
Ologe, F. E., & Akande, T. M. (2003). Pattern of disabilities hearing loss. Report of WHO-PDH Informal Consultation,
in a residential school of the handicapped in Ilorin, Geneva 28–30 October 1997, Strategies for Prevention of
Nigeria. The Nigerian Postgraduate Medical Journal, 10, Deafness and Hearing Impairment, 3, WHO/PDH/98.5.
208–210. Geneva, Switzerland: Author.
Ologe, F. E., Okoro, E. O., & Oyejola, B. A. (2005). Hearing Wright, A. D. O. (1991). The aetiology of childhood deafness
function in Nigerian children with a family history of type 2 in Sierra Leone. The Sierra Leone Medical and Dental
diabetes. International Journal of Pediatric Otorhinolaryngol- Association Journal, 6, 31–45.
ogy, 69, 387–391. Wright, A. D. O., & Leigh, B. (1995). The impact of the
Owoeye, J. F. A., Ologe, F. E., & Akande, T. M. (in press). expanded program on immunization on measles induced
Medical students’ perspectives of blindness, deafness, and sensorineural hearing loss in the western area of Sierra
deafblindness. Disability and Rehabilitation. Leone. West African Journal of Medicne, 14, 205–209.
Sellars, S., Beighton, G., Horan, F., & Beighton, P. H. (1977).
Deafness in black children in South Africa. South African Received February 2, 2006; revisions received August 1, 2006;
Medical Journal, 51, 309–312. accepted August 15, 2006.