Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
Abstract—Electric arc furnaces (EAFs) are nonlinear and time- cation for VIC is the main factor of accuracy. Harmonic voltage
variant loads that cause severe fluctuations of current, voltage, and source method [5], [6] is based on the harmonic study of a cer-
current harmonics, voltage flicker, frequency changes, etc. The re- tain kind of arc voltage waveform. The problem is that under
quirement is to present an accurate model to analyze the function
of these types of loads. In this paper, a new model based on hidden this voltage waveform, the arc furnace system does not operate
Markov model theory is presented for an electric arc. For this pur- at the maximum power transfer condition.
pose, the characteristic of the arc voltage-current is divided into Another group of models is based on the frequency domain
four regions. Then, on the basis of actual measured samples of an that is often used for harmonic analysis of the system [7]–[9].
electric arc in several functioning cycles of EAF, different operating The frequency-domain solution of nonlinear differential equa-
points are generated in the form of statistical probability, corre-
sponding to hidden Markov theory in the aforementioned four re- tions depends on the system topology and operating condition.
gions. The arc model is designed in the form of a current-dependent Some of the other models are based on stochastic characteristics
voltage source. Therefore, the proposed model is without linear ap- of the EAF which are mainly suitable for voltage flicker anal-
proximation and corresponds to the actual state. Also, in order to ysis [9], [10]. Another method for analyzing the arc model in
be accurate in flicker modeling, a voltage is randomly considered time domain is based on the Cassie-Mayer [11]. In this method,
for the arc model. After designing the aforementioned model, the
effects resulting from this electric load in the power system are Cassie and Mayer equations are used in cases of low and high
studied and analyzed. The simulation results are compared with arc current, respectively. There are some restrictions, such as
the measured arc to show the accuracy and soundness of the model. need for the initial conditions, for solving the differential equa-
Index Terms—Electric arc furnace (EAF), flicker, hidden tions in these methods.
Markov model (HMM), power quality (PQ). The proposed models have not been able to exhibit the be-
havior of electric arc furnaces properly. Some even do not ex-
hibit the random states of the arc correctly. Also, most of these
I. INTRODUCTION models have modeled the electric arc on the basis of a specific
mathematical equation. The characteristic of the arc is therefore
HE EAFs are normally among the largest electrical loads limited within a totally specific framework in contrast to the un-
T in power systems. Due to the fast and intensive deviations
of electric power in these, the bus voltage of these furnaces be-
predictable behavior of the arc. Therefore, presenting a suitable
model for the analysis of the arc furnace in order to study the
comes unbalanced and can fluctuate very largely. Moreover, the random nature of the arc and to provide the desired conformity
EAFs disturb power quality (PQ), voltage flicker, voltage and with the actual state is required.
current unbalance, and odd and even harmonics in power sys- In this paper, at first, the properties of the electric arc are
tems. To study this field and improve the aforementioned issued, studied. Then, a new model that obtained through sampling from
an exact and complete design of the power system with arc fur- the voltage and current of an actual arc is proposed by adopting
naces should be made. Therefore, it is necessary to find a suit- hidden Markov theory on the basis of electric arc identifica-
able model for EAFs. In this regard, numerous models have been tion. Hence, the arc voltage-current characteristic is severed into
presented to describe the EAF [1]–[8]. Some of these models four regions. Then, different operating points are created in the
are based on the voltage–current characteristics (VIC) method form of statistical probability under hidden Markov theory in
[1]–[4]. This kind of model is simple and direct which can sat- the aforementioned four regions where these points are found
isfy a certain operating condition, and in this way, the simplifi- upon the actual measured samples of an electric arc during sev-
eral working cycles of furnace. In the next stage, the arc model
is made of plans in the the form of a current-dependent voltage
Manuscript received July 02, 2011; revised November 15, 2011, January 23, source, and the voltage across source terminals corresponds to
2012, and May 09, 2012; accepted June 24, 2012. Date of publication August 27, the input current of the arc. From now on, the presented model
2012; date of current version September 19, 2012. Paper no. TPWRD-00565-
2011.
is less linear approximation and matches to the measured state.
The authors are with the Department of Electrical Engineering, Amirkabir One of the unique features of the designed model is to show
University of Technology, Tehran 1591634311, Iran (e-mail: m_tora- actual flicker which this model needs with fewer special equa-
bian@aut.ac.ir; vahidi@aut.ac.ir). tions for flicker modeling. It should be noted in this paper that a
Color versions of one or more of the figures in this paper are available online
at http://ieeexplore.ieee.org. simple equation is considered to modulate flicker function with
Digital Object Identifier 10.1109/TPWRD.2012.2206408 the arc model for producing different operating states of EAF
0885-8977/$31.00 © 2012 IEEE
1894 IEEE TRANSACTIONS ON POWER DELIVERY, VOL. 27, NO. 4, OCTOBER 2012
Area4 (4) Therefore, in order to specify an HMM model into the number
of states, there is a need for the number of observations and
Equation (1) is similar to (4), and (2) is similar to (3). How- values of . An HMM is usually depicted by the com-
ever, the sign of voltage and current in the similar ones is oppo- pressed symbol of .
site. Thus, the arc voltage can be expressed as a function of the By having HMM model parameters, it can be con-
arc current in its own region. sidered as a data generator (sequence of observations)
TORABIAN ESFAHANI AND VAHIDI: NEW STOCHASTIC MODEL OF ELECTRIC ARC FURNACE BASED ON HMM 1895
, where is one of the members Therefore, with regard to the later equation, it is possible to
of set and is the number of observations. calculate the probability for observation occurrences and their
The trend of output generation in HMM is as follows. soundness.
1) Selection of the initial state on the basis of initial The second problem is the estimation of the past states by
state distribution function . having the observations and the model parameters. Optimiza-
2) Set . tion standards can be used to solve this problem. One of these
3) Selection of on the basis of random distribu- optimization standards is the selection of states (which are
tion functions of observations corresponding to the system individually very similar to each other). This optimization stan-
present state. dard increases the percentage of the correctness of the separate
4) Transit to the new state of transfer matrix of the states. Therefore, the following variable is defined to solve this
states corresponding to state i. problem:
5) If conditions of and return to step 3 are
satisfied; otherwise, end of the work. (15)
With regard to the expressed characteristics and the fact that
the electric arc is unstable and random, there are three basic The percentage for being in state at time is to present the
problems for the application of HMM model in the design of the observation sequence and model. Equation (15) is simply
arc. The first problem is the evaluation of occurrence probability calculable as recessive variables as follows:
of the sequence observed in the electric arc (i.e., the manner
of calculating the percentage and probability of arc occurrence
(16)
over different time periods). The occurrence probability of ob-
servations string of for Markov models is
calculable as follows:
Since is as the partial observation
(8) sequence and state is at time and as the remaining
observation sequence and state is at
The best way to solve this problem is to take all possible cases time, the normal factor is written as follows:
over the time period of into consideration (the number of ob-
servations). Consider one fixed state sequence
(17)
(9)
Therefore, the probability size is written as follows:
where is also the initial state. The probability for the sequence
observation of O for state sequence of Q is as follows:
(18)
(10)
Now, with the use of , it is possible to insert the separate
And with regard to independence among observations, we states similar to into time
have
(11) (19)
Therefore, the Q state sequence probability can be written as Also, the above equation increases the number of the expected
correct states (by increasing the similar separate states at time).
(12) Therefore, this problem is also solved on the basis of the
recent relations. The third and the most difficult problem of
The probability of O and Q occurring simultaneously the HMM is the distinction of a method for the adjustment of
parameters to maximize the observation se-
(13) quence probability. It is required to mention that there is a spe-
cific model to maximize the observation sequence probability
The probability for observing O appears along with a set of and there is no way for estimating the model parameters. How-
probabilities for all sequences of possible states of ever, can be selected in a way that is
maximized. To approve and define the HMM parameters, it is
embarked on the definition of , probability at state at
, and state at . Therefore, the model and observations
sequence are considered as the following equation:
(14) (20)
1896 IEEE TRANSACTIONS ON POWER DELIVERY, VOL. 27, NO. 4, OCTOBER 2012
By the use of the definition of recessive variables, can able relations for are written as follows, as shown in the
be written as follows: equation at the bottom of the page.
Therefore, with proper application of the HMM model on the
basis of the expressed explanations and the use of the actual
measured data of the electric arc, it is possible to have access to
a new model on the basis of the actual data. In order to model
(21) this arc, the proposed arc is modeled in the form of a voltage
source dependent on the input current and the voltage value of
its two ends is related to the arc input current.
To make modeling more accurate and create different states
where the numerator is in form of arc function, the voltage flicker is also considered for the
and division calculates the desired probability value by . proposed model according to
Previously, was defined as the probability of being in state
at time. Now, with the use of observation sequence and (24)
model, a relation between and can be obtained by
collecting it on . The above equation is as follows: In this equation, is the voltage modelled with flicker.
is also the sampled voltage dependent on current by
HMM, where is also the function of flicker and depending
(22) on the type of flicker, it can vary sinusoidally and randomly.
If the produced flicker varies randomly, this function operates
If this set is performed on , an accessible value will be found according to
which shows the number of state appearance or in a similar (25)
way it is the expected transition probability matrix value from
state . In this equation, is bandlimited white noise with zero
In short, the total of on time can mean and variance of 1 and with a flicker limit to 4 14 Hz,
be the expected transition probability matrix value from the and is the variation factor in flicker intensity.
state to state. Therefore, it can be written as Briefly, Fig. 2 shows the block diagram of the proposed
model.
The expected number from IV. POWER SYSTEM MODELING WITH EAF
probability matrix (23a) In order to analyze the proposed model, the power supply
of the arc furnace should be modeled in the actual state. Fig. 3
The expected number from shows the single-line diagram of an electric system. In this
figure, bus 1 indicates the point of common coupling (PCC),
probability matrix to (23b) which is the supplying bus of the EAF transformer. In order
to change the input active power of the EAF, the transformer
With the use of the above relations, it is possible to create a (MV/LV) is used. This transformer is equipped with a tap
method for the improvement of HMM parameters. The reason- changer located at the secondary winding to have the ability
TABLE I
MSC SYSTEM PARAMETERS
Fig. 7. Curve for the cumulative distribution function changes in terms of clas-
sification.
TABLE II
RESULTS OF P CALCULATIONS RELATED TO THE 9TH SECOND
Fig. 6. Electric arc voltage and current changes in the random flicker state:
A-voltage curve; B-current curve; C-V-I characteristic. In the performed simulations, the IFL curve was evaluated for
15 s, so with regard to the IFL curve at that second, the is
obtained for each second, ultimately having 15 points. By plot-
measured voltage flicker as well; initial transient states are re- ting the points, the flicker rate is observed. For example, Table II
moved in the arc HMM model as can be seen in the comparison shows different levels of flicker at the ninth second. Also, Fig. 7
between Fig. 6(c) and Fig. 4. Also, in the following cycles, the depicts the curve for CPF function changes. Therefore, Fig. 8
accuracy of the model is better than the first cycle. According describes a comparison of the short-time flicker in measured and
to Fig. 2, HMM pursues the voltage and current variations with simulated states.
less approximation. The proposed model has properly been able to generate the
The proposed model is properly capable of producing voltage flicker in bus 1 of the power system. On the one hand, the de-
flicker. Now, in order to study the voltage flicker in bus 1, the signed flickermeter has properly measured the generated flicker.
short-term index of flicker severity with regard to the IEC stan- To study the effects of voltage fluctuations, Fig. 9 shows the
dard and (26) is considered as follows: curve for the changes of voltage a-phase profile on bus 1 in
the measured and simulated models. It should be noted that the
voltage flicker is measured by the power quality analyzer PQA
(27) HIOKI3196 at the PCC bus.
1900 IEEE TRANSACTIONS ON POWER DELIVERY, VOL. 27, NO. 4, OCTOBER 2012
TABLE III
HARMONIC ORDERS AT THREE PHASES IN THE PCC BUS
VI. CONCLUSION
Fig. 9. Curve for changes of the voltage three-phase profile in bus 1.
In this paper, a stochastic model for electric arc based on
samples of voltage and current measurements was presented.
The prominent qualities of this model are nonapproximation
and accuracy in modeling because of experimental samples
and applied HMM. This model can be used in power system
studies with EAFs and investigated types of compensator as
SVC, STATCOM, etc. Other features of the model are flicker
generation with different functions and intensities. Therefore,
the model can create all melting stages, such as scrap, DRI
charging, plating, and refining. The designed model was probed
under the most unfavorable conditions. The simulation results
and comparison with measured data described the advantages
of the proposed method in modeling the EAF.
REFERENCES
Fig. 10. Curve for changes of the power factor in bus 1. [1] M. Alonso and M. Donsion, “An improved time domain arc furnace
model for harmonic analysis,” IEEE Trans. Power Del., vol. 19, no. 1,
pp. 367–373, Jan. 2004.
[2] M. A. Golkar and S. Meschi, “MATLAB modeling of arc furnace for
flicker study,” in Proc. IEEE Int. Ind. Technol. Conf., 2008, pp. 1–6.
Fig. 10 exhibits the power factor of bus 1 in the measured and [3] I. Vervenne, K. Van Reusel, and R. Belmans, “Electric arc furnace mod-
simulated model. The power factor in bus 1 is about 0.6. This eling from a “power quality” point of view,” in Proc. IEEE Int. Conf.
value is changed according to voltage changes and has satisfac- Elect. Power Quality Utiliz., 2007, pp. 1–6.
[4] Y. F. Wang and J. G. Jiang, “A novel chaotic model of ac electric
tory conformity with actuality. arc furnace for power quality studies,” in Proc. IEEE Int. Conf. Elect.
It should be noted, according to Fig. 3, that the length and Mach. Syst. , 2007, pp. 1795–1803.
impedance of lines, transformers ( and ), and buses 1 and [5] W. Ting, S. Wennan, and Z. Yao, “A new frequency domain method
for the harmonic analysis of power systems with arc furnace,” in Proc.
2 cause the error in simulated and measured results in Figs. 9 and IEEE Int. Conf. Adv. Power Syst. Control Oper. Manage., 1997, pp.
10. It should be noted that those errors trace only on the power 552–555.
TORABIAN ESFAHANI AND VAHIDI: NEW STOCHASTIC MODEL OF ELECTRIC ARC FURNACE BASED ON HMM 1901
[6] G. Chang, C. Hatziadoniu, W. Xu, P. Ribeiro, R. Burch, W. M. Grady, [17] E. Altιntas, O. Salor, I. Cadirci, and M. Ermis, “A new flicker contri-
M. Halpin, Y. Liu, S. Ranade, D. Ruthman, N. Watson, T. Ortmeyer, bution tracing method based on individual reactive current components
J. Wikston, A. Medina, A. Testa, R. Gardinier, V. Dinavahi, F. Acram, of multiple EAFs at PCC,” IEEE Trans. Ind. Appl., vol. 46, no. 5, pp.
and P. Lehn, “Modeling devices with nonlinear voltage-current char- 1746–1754, Oct. 2010.
acteristic for harmonic studies,” IEEE Trans. Power Del., vol. 19, no. [18] G. W. Chang, I. Chen, and Y.-L. Huang, “A digital implementation of
4, pp. 1802–1811, Oct. 2004. flickermeter in the hybrid time and frequency domains,” IEEE Trans.
[7] L. F. Beites, J. G. Mayordomo, A. Hernandes, and R. Asensi, “Har- Power Del., vol. 24, no. 3, pp. 1475–482, Jul. 2009.
monics, interharmonic, unbalances of arc furnaces: A new frequency
domain approach,” IEEE Trans. Power Del., vol. 16, no. 4, pp.
661–668, Oct. 2001.
[8] J. G. Mayordomo, L. F. Beites, R. Asensi, M. Izzeddine, L. Zabala,
and J. Amantegui, “A new frequency domain arc furnace model for Mehdi Torabian Esfahani was born in Isfahan, Iran,
iterative harmonic analysis,” IEEE Trans. Power Del., vol. 12, no. 4, on December 18, 1982. He is currently pursuing the
pp. 1771–1778, Oct. 1997. Ph.D. degree in electrical engineering at Amirkabir
[9] F. Wang, Z. Jin, Z. Zhu, and X. Wang, “Application of extended University of Technology, Tehran, Iran.
Kalman filter to the modeling of electric arc furnace for power quality He was with the Esfahan Regional Electrical Com-
issues,” in Proc. IEEE Int. Conf. Neural Netw. Brain., Beijing, China, pany (EREC), Isfahan, Iran. His research interests
2005, pp. 991–996. are power-electronic applications for the topology
[10] L. F. Pak, V. Dinavahi, G. Chang, M. Steurer, and P. F. Ribeiro, and control of active harmonic filters, power factor
“Real-time digital time-varying harmonic modeling and simulation correction, power-quality analysis, and the study of
techniques,” IEEE Trans. Power Del., vol. 22, no. 2, pp. 1218–1227, electrical arc furnaces in power systems and system
Apr. 2007. modeling.
[11] H. Mokhtari and M. Hejri, “A new three phase time-domain model for
electric arc furnaces using MATLAB,” in Proc. IEEE Transm. Distrib.
Conf., 2002, pp. 2078–2083.
[12] S. Jazebi, B. Vahidi, S. H. Hosseinian, M. Shafiee, and R. A. Behrooz Vahidi (M’00–SM’04) was born in
Naghizadeh, “A combinatorial approach based on wavelet transform Abadan, Iran, in 1953. He received the B.S. degree
and hidden markov models in differential relaying of power trans- in electrical engineering from Sharif University of
formers,” in Proc. Univ. Power Eng. Conf., Padova, Italy, 2008, pp. Technology, Tehran, Iran, in 1980, the M.S. degree
1–7. in electrical engineering from Amirkabir University
[13] F. Sotiropoulos, P. Alefragis, and E. Housos, “A hidden Markov of Technology, Tehran, Iran, in 1989, and the Ph.D.
models tool for estimating the deterioration level of a power trans- degree in electrical engineering from the University
former,” in Proc. IEEE Emerging Technol. Factory Autom. Conf., of Manchester Institute of Science and Technology,
Patros, Greece, 2007, pp. 784–787. Manchester, U.K., in 1997.
[14] A. M. Gonzalez, A. M. S. Roque, and J. Garcia-Gonzalez, “Modeling From 1980 to 1986, he was a Chief Engineer in
and forecasting electricity prices with input/output hidden Markov the high-voltage in industry field. Since 1989, he has
models,” IEEE Trans. Power Syst., vol. 20, no. 1, pp. 13–24, Feb. been a Professor with the Department of Electrical Engineering, Amirkabir Uni-
2005. versity of Technology. He has authored and coauthored 250 papers and five
[15] T. K. Abdel-Galil, E. F. El-Saadany, A. M. Youssef, and M. M. A. books on high-voltage engineering and power systems. His main fields of re-
Salama, “Disturbance classification using hidden Markov models search are high voltage, electrical insulation, power system transients, lightning
and vector quantization,” IEEE Trans. Power Del., vol. 20, no. 3, pp. protection, and pulse power technology.
2129–2135, Jul. 2005. Prof. Vahidi was selected as Distinguished Researcher of Iran by the Ministry
[16] Testing and Measurement Techniques—Flickermeter, Functional and of Higher Education of Iran and by the Iranian Association of Electrical and
Design Specifications, IEC Standard, IEC 61000-4-15, Aug. 2010. Electronics Engineers (IAEEE).