Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
Introduction...................................................................................................................................4
What is an LCR meter?............................................................................................................4
Benefits of an LCR meter.........................................................................................................4
Example applications................................................................................................................5
Constructing an RC filter......................................................................................................5
Characterizing an induction motor.......................................................................................5
Impedance....................................................................................................................................7
The physical nature of reactance...........................................................................................10
Dissipation factor D and quality factor Q................................................................................12
Lumped parameter models....................................................................................................12
Series and parallel models.....................................................................................................14
Should I use the series or parallel model?.........................................................................15
Measurement of impedance with an oscilloscope.................................................................16
Bridge circuits.........................................................................................................................19
Some formulas related to impedance....................................................................................20
Capacitance.......................................................................................................................21
Inductance..........................................................................................................................22
Using a reactance chart.........................................................................................................23
LCR Meter Features...................................................................................................................25
Meter types.............................................................................................................................25
Selectable test frequencies....................................................................................................25
Selectable test amplitudes.....................................................................................................26
Relative mode.........................................................................................................................26
Tolerance mode......................................................................................................................27
4-wire measurements.............................................................................................................27
ESR measurements...............................................................................................................28
Connectivity............................................................................................................................28
Voltage and current measurements.......................................................................................29
Lead slots and surface mount tweezers.................................................................................30
Making LCR Measurements.......................................................................................................31
Safety......................................................................................................................................31
Test frequency........................................................................................................................31
Open/short calibration............................................................................................................31
2-, 3-, and 4-wire measurements...........................................................................................34
2-wire measurements.........................................................................................................34
3-wire measurements and guarding..................................................................................35
4-wire measurements.........................................................................................................36
Range and accuracy of LCR meters......................................................................................36
Measurement uncertainty...................................................................................................37
Measurement standards....................................................................................................37
Measurement discrepancies..................................................................................................38
Good practices.......................................................................................................................40
FAQ.............................................................................................................................................43
What is admittance?...............................................................................................................43
Why do I get a negative reading?...........................................................................................43
1 Be careful with permanent magnet motors as they could generate a DC voltage that could damage your LCR
meter.
Shorted turn
B
LAB LB
For a new motor, the inductance of the three windings should be approximately equal. A useful
strategy is to measure the winding(s) when the motor is new and have those measurements for
comparison to later measurements when troubleshooting a problem or looking for degradation.
Measuring a good winding's inductance on a new motor also lets you use the change in inductance
to troubleshoot a single phase motor in the future. You'd also want to measure and record the
inductance periodically.
A shorted turn will have a lower inductance than an equivalent non-shorted turn. Thus, we have the
following relationships for a motor with a shorted turn:
Wye L AC ≈ LAB LBC
Delta LB L A ≈ LC
For the wye connection, we also have the relationships:
L AB = L ALB
L AC = LALC
LBC = LBLC
If you measured the phase-to-phase inductances for a wye-connected motor and found that two of
the inductances were about equal and less than the third, you'd suspect a shorted turn. For a delta-
connected motor, you'd suspect a shorted turn if one of the inductances was less than the other two,
which should be nearly equal. One metric is to calculate the mean inductance and then examine the
% deviation from the mean to identify an inductive imbalance.
Shorted turns can occur when the insulation in a winding fails to insulate the winding wire sufficiently
(i.e. hot spots, physical damage, manufacturing defect, etc.).
2 More general waveforms and responses are handled using Fourier series and integrals.
The convention is to use the real part of equation (3) to give the sinusoidal function of time. The real
part is V 0 cost , i.e., equation (1). This is why the cosine is used for the sinusoid instead of the
sine. A cosine curve is a sine that is shifted by a right angle.
Combining the exponents, using Euler's formula, and taking the real part results in the sinusoid
function given in equation (1), the phasor is a time-independent complex constant that encodes
j t
the amplitude and phase information of the sinusoidal voltage. As the e term is common to
each sinusoid, we can combine sinusoids via addition, subtraction, multiplication, and division using
phasors and/or Euler's formula.
For example, the addition of two sinusoid voltages of angular frequency , amplitudes V1 and V2,
and phases 1 and 2 is:
j 1 j 2
V t = V
1e V
2e e j t = V
sum e
j j t
e
V1 V2 V
Note that the time-dependent part can be ignored as long as we remember these phasor
relationships are always associated with the implicit frequency . Then the resulting phasor V is the
sum of the two phasors V1 and V2. This is just addition of two complex numbers, which you would
calculate by converting to rectangular components and adding the corresponding components. This
is the same as vector addition in the two-dimensional Cartesian plane, which is why phasors are
sometimes called vectors.
j axis
V
V2
V1
Real axis
R
Figure 2: Sum of two phasors
|Z|
X = |Z| sin θ
Real axis
R = |Z| cos θ
Because of the phasor term, you can see the voltage across an inductor leads the current by 90°
and the voltage's frequency-dependent magnitude is L i 0 .
The inductor's impedance from the definition of impedance as the ratio of the voltage to current is:
V j
ZL = = L e 2 (8)
i
Since this is an ideal inductor with no DC resistance, the reactance (imaginary part of the
impedance) increases linearly with frequency. A pure inductor's impedance has a phase angle of
+90°.
At low frequencies, the impedance magnitude is numerically small, so the inductor behaves like a
short. As the frequency increases, the voltage across the inductor increases. If you can make the
current change rapidly enough, you can get any desired instantaneous voltage across the inductor.
This is the cause of inductive voltage spikes.
We can conclude:
♦ Voltage across an inductor leads the current through the inductor.
♦ Inductors look like shorts at low frequencies.
♦ Inductors look like open circuits at high frequencies.
Braided Center
shield conductor
Dielectric
insulation
Insulating
cover Model
Ci Ci Ci Ci
C RESR Ls
RDA CDA
The suitability of this model would have to be established empirically and the effort to measure each
of the contributing factors of the model could be significant.
The series and parallel circuits measured by LCR meters are lumped parameter models of a
measured impedance.
Rp
Rs
A X B
The following table translates this approximate rule into inductance and capacitance values:
i
R VR
Function
generator ~
C VC
Function i
generator
~ V0 R VR
A Scope ground
C VC
Channel 2
5 Nearly any small transformer should work. It is suggested that you use one that does not introduce much
distortion of the sinusoid from the function generator.
6 These measurements were made with a B&K Precision 2542B-GEN oscilloscope, a convenient tool for such
tasks because it contains a built-in function generator.
=
2.48
10
360° = 89.28 °
The voltage across the capacitor and the current through it are:
V C = 0.904 V∢0°
i C = 52.8 A∢89.28°
We thus have the three needed numbers mentioned above from direct measurement. The
capacitor's impedance is the ratio of the voltage across the capacitor to the current through the
capacitor:
0.904 V∢0 °
Z= = 17.1 k ∢−89.28 °
52.8 A ∢89.28°
The capacitor's measured impedance is 17.1 k ∢−89.3 °.
Two B&K Precision LCR meters were used to measure the impedance of this capacitor at 100 Hz.
The results of the three measurements rounded to three significant figures are:
Method |Z|, kΩ Angle, °
B&K 886 17.3 -89.5
B&K 879B 17.6 -89.5
B&K 2542B-GEN (scope) 17.1 -89.3
The discrepancy between the two meters is a few tenths of a percent larger than would be
suggested by their accuracy specifications. If you needed an accurate impedance measurement,
more investigation might be warranted.
A conservative estimate of the uncertainty of the impedance measured using the scope is about 9%
of the measured value for the magnitude and 0.25% for the phase7. Measurement equipment with
lower uncertainties would result in lower impedance uncertainties.
Once the impedance of the device is known, other parameters can be calculated using the formulas
given in the section, Some formulas related to impedance. As an example, we'll calculate the
parameters of the series model for this capacitor:
Rs Cs
1
Z = Rs
j Cs
The oscilloscope-measured impedance was 17.1 k ∢−89.28 °. Converting to rectangular
3
coordinates gives 215−17.1×10 j. The real part gives us R s = 215 . Since the frequency was 100
Hz, we can calculate:
1 1
Cs = 3
= 3
= 93.1 nF
17.1×10 17.1×10 2 100
The two LCR meters measured series capacitance values close to this number.
7 These numbers were calculated using linear uncertainty propagation, no correlation, and defining the
uncertainty to be the half-width of the DC measurement accuracy given in the scope's specifications.
Bridge circuits
Historically-important methods of measuring impedance are based on the Wheatstone bridge.
However, bridge circuits are not used much in modern LCR meters.
A
Z
2
Z
1
V
C D
Z
X
Z
3
~
E
Figure 11: Wheatstone bridge
The measurement procedure is to set the sinusoidal voltage E to a suitable value and adjust the
three impedances Z1, Z2, and Z3 so that the voltages at points A and B are equal (i.e., V is 0). This is
called nulling or balancing the bridge. In balance, the current through the arm CBD of the bridge is
E/(Zx + Z3) and the current through the arm CAD is E/(Z1 + Z2). Since the voltages at A and B are
equal with the bridge balanced, the voltage drop across Z2 is the same as the voltage drop across
Z3. Similarly, the voltage drops across Z1 and Zx are equal to each other.
0 e h 0 m h d d
C= L= ln ≫ 1 and h≫r
d −r r r (13)
ln
r
where
h = length of the conductors in m
d = distance between the centers of the conductors in m
r = radius of the conductors in m
Capacitance
Capacitive reactance is 2 f C −1 where f is frequency in Hz and C is the capacitance in F. If you
−1
memorize that 2 = 0.159, you'll be able to make capacitive reactance calculations easier by
hand, especially for decade values of frequency.
For example, a 125 pF capacitor at 105 Hz has a reactance of:
0.159
1
1
125×10
−12
1
10
5
= 0.159
109
0.125
−5
4
10 = 0.159810 = 12.72 k
2 1 1
C f
2
2 )
C s = C p (1+D )
Rp = Rs
( ) 1+D2
D
2
=
ω
1
C pD
( )
2
D D
Rs = Rp =
1+D 2
ω Cs
Inductance
Inductive reactance is 2 f L where f is frequency in Hz and L is the inductance in H. If you
memorize that 2 = 6.28, you'll be able to make inductive reactance calculations easier by hand,
especially for decade values of frequency.
For example, a 125 μH coil at 105 Hz has a reactance of:
62.8
6.28
105
125×10−6 = 6.28 105 0.125×10−3 = 101 = 78.5
2 L
8
f
Lp = Ls
( )
1+Q 2
Q2
= Ls (1+D 2)
(15)
R R
ω2 = s p
Ls L p
Rs = Rp
( 1
1+Q 2
= D ωL s
)
R p = R s (1+Q 2) = Q ω L p
Relative mode
The relative measurement mode allows a standard part to be measured and then have
subsequently-measured parts displayed relative to the standard's value. This makes it easier to
compare measured values.
As an example of the use of relative mode, a B&K Precision 879B LCR meter was set to measure
parallel capacitance at 1 kHz. The meter's open/short calibration was used to zero out the effects of
the measurement leads.
A 100 nF nominal capacitor (actual value was 90.05 nF) was used as a standard. This standard
capacitor was connected to the meter and the REL button was pressed. Then five capacitors from
the same lot were measured relative to this standard capacitor; the results were (sorted by value):
Capacitor ΔC, nF % deviation
1 0.18 0.2
3 2.54 2.8
5 2.55 2.8
2 6.87 7.6
4 7.81 8.7
Note all five capacitors were larger than the standard (you'd expect about half to be less than and
about half to be greater than the standard). The % deviation column shows the calculated deviation
from the reference capacitor's value. These numbers can be compared to the % deviation measured
in the following section.
4-wire measurements
Some LCR meters use a 4-wire connection to the device under test. As explained in the section, 2-,
3-, and 4-wire measurements, this is a measurement method that uses separate jacks/connectors
for the current measurement and the voltage measurement. The benefit is that the lead resistance is
not part of the measurement, allowing low-value impedances to be measured. Most bench LCR
meters use a 4-wire connection measurement to the device under test.
For example, the B&K Precision 885 can use a 4-wire measurement to measure DC resistances
down to 1 mΩ. Contrast this to the typical digital multimeter that uses leads that add around 0.2 Ω to
a low-resistance measurement. These 4-wire LCR meters are especially convenient when used with
Kelvin clips that allow easy connection to the device under test.
ESR measurements
The ESR is the real part of the impedance when the series model is used. As the capacitor is
probably the lowest impedance device in the circuits electrically connected to the capacitor, the LCR
meter should be able to distinguish capacitors with unusually high ESR. Such measurements are
typically made at 10 kHz or 100 kHz for best sensitivity.
Connectivity
Some LCR meters allow connection to a computer via USB, GPIB, and serial interfaces. An
advantage of such a computer connection is that special measurement situations can be
accommodated. For example, B&K Precision provides software with their 878B and 879B LCR
meters, which allows the instrument to be configured remotely. The software also gives users the
ability to log measurements on the computer and export the data to an Excel or text file.
You'll find you use these lead slots a lot if you use components with leads. If you use a lot of surface
mount devices, make sure to get surface mount tweezers as it will also make measurements easier.
Test frequency
A common question is what frequency should be used to measure a component or circuit. The short
answer is to use the frequency at or near where the component or circuit will be used.
Large electrolytic capacitors are often used as power supply filters, so they should be tested at twice
the line frequency. This is the frequency seen from full-wave rectified sine waves. Smaller capacitors
are more likely to be used at higher frequencies, so they should be tested at those frequencies.
Large inductors are often used as chokes and can be tested at line frequencies. Smaller
inductances less than 1 mH are often used at higher frequencies and should be tested at the
frequencies they will be used at.
In general, an LCR meter measurement at one frequency does not allow you to predict behavior at
another frequency, especially as the frequency goes up. If your LCR meter can only measure at
frequencies up to 10 or 100 kHz and you need to know the impedance at 1 MHz or above, you can
extrapolate using the measured value and the equation for the reactance, but your extrapolation will
probably be in error because of the effects of parasitic reactances. Viable options in this case are to
find an LCR meter with a wider frequency range or measure the impedance with a function
generator and oscilloscope.
Open/short calibration
There are two types of calibration in the context of LCR meters:
♦ Instrument calibration to allow traceability to national standards (see the section Range and
accuracy of LCR meters for more details).
♦ Open and short calibration (also called compensation) to correct for lead/fixture parasitic
impedances.
For the best realizable accuracy in your LCR meter's measurements, you should perform an
open/short calibration when changing the excitation signal level, frequency, or parameter being
measured.
A schematic model of an LCR meter making a measurement is:
Rs Ls
LCR
Cp Rp DUT
meter
Zs
LCR
meter Zp ZDUT
Zm
Figure 21: Total impedance measurement
−1
Zm =
[ 1
Z DUT
1
Zp ] Z s
2-wire measurements
A 2-wire connection between an LCR meter and a DUT is:
LCR
meter ZDUT
This is the easiest way to connect a DUT to an LCR meter. However, it suffers from the drawback
that the impedance of the leads and devices to connect to the DUT are included in the
measurement. An equivalent circuit of the real measurement situation could be:
R L
LCR
C ZDUT
meter
The resistance of the leads is modeled by R and the lead inductance is modeled by L. Because the
leads may be relatively close in space and separated by a dielectric, this forms a capacitor C. These
impedances are called parasitic because, like a parasite, they are unwanted and can be hard to get
rid of.
By performing an open/short calibration, you may be able to remove much or most of this parasitic
impedance -- it depends on your needs and what you're measuring.
There are situations where the measurement is negligibly influenced by the lead/fixture impedance.
For example, measuring the capacitance of a 1 mF capacitor can be done with a 1 m coaxial cable
and an alligator clip breakout, which adds less than 100 pF capacitance to the measurement. The
lead/fixture impedance only contributes 0.00001% to the measured value, which is far smaller than
the measurement uncertainty.
However, if you were measuring a 100 pF capacitor, the lead/fixture stray capacitance could be
significant and would introduce a large systematic error if you didn't compensate for it.
LCR Guard
meter ZDUT
-
Figure 24: 3-wire impedance measurement
This type of connection can help remove some parasitic capacitance and improve the ability of the
LCR meter to measure high impedances such as resistances on the order of 10 MΩ or above.
4-wire measurements
The 4-wire measurement is well-known in the context of measuring resistance and is often referred
to as a Kelvin measurement. The same connection topology can be used for making LCR meter
measurements, although your LCR meter needs to support such connections. The schematic
diagram is:
a
c
A
LCR
meter V ZDUT
~
d
b
Figure 25: 4-wire impedance measurement
The current circuit (shown in red) applies an AC current to the DUT and the ammeter measures the
current. The voltmeter measures the voltage drop across the DUT. A key feature of a 4-wire
connection is that the voltmeter connections “c-d” to the DUT are inside the ammeter connections “a-
b”. This means that any contact resistance at a or b that could cause a voltage drop (and thus be
measured by a 2-wire measurement) is ignored by the 4-wire measurement procedure.
The 4-wire measurement is useful for low impedance and low DC resistance measurements, as the
effects of the leads are eliminated. If you are performing AC resistance measurements, make sure
you use open/short calibration to compensate for the parasitic impedances in the leads for best
measurement accuracy.
4-wire measurements can also be done with shielded cables where the shield is connected to a
guard terminal (this is sometimes called a 5-wire measurement). This can reduce noise and
measurement uncertainty.
Measurement standards
To be able to trust the readings from your LCR meter, it is advisable to have various standards that
are stable over time.
Purchased commercial standards: If you require traceability to a national standards organization,
then purchasing commercial standards and having your instrument calibrated on a regular basis is a
good approach. Because such standards and calibration services can be expensive, it may make
economic sense only if you can spread these costs over numerous LCR meters in the organization
or if the cost of a mistake exceeds the standards and calibration costs.
Standards constructed in-house: You can construct your own standards. A parallel-plate
capacitor can be constructed with a suitable dielectric material between the plates. If the permittivity
of the dielectric is , the separation of the plates, t, is in m, and the area of the plates is A in m2, the
capacitance is A/t in F. A rigid design with stable materials should result in a robust and stable
standard. Such parallel plate capacitors will likely have capacitances on the order of a few hundred
pF. If constructing coils with a desired inductance, using a ferromagnetic core can increase the
inductance. Such coils can be in the 10 μH to 1 mH range.
You may also be able to use existing items as standards. For example, a transformer with one
primary and one secondary can provide two standard inductance values once they are calibrated
and mounted in a container with suitable connectors.
Measurement discrepancies
LCR meter measurements are more involved than digital multimeter measurements and at some
point, you'll probably encounter measurement discrepancies. These can be confusing and
frustrating, especially if you can't discover the cause of the discrepancy. In this section, we'll look at
some of the things that can cause measurement discrepancies.
Many LCR meters start with a measurement of impedance8. As discussed elsewhere in this
document (refer to the experiment Measurement of impedance with an oscilloscope), the
impedance is calculated by dividing the voltage measured across the DUT by the measured current
through the DUT -- and remember these are AC measurements made at a particular frequency.
Frequency: Since reactance is a function of frequency, one of the first things to do is make sure
you are measuring at the same frequency. A factor of 10 error in the frequency leads to a factor of
10 error in the measured reactance. The effect on the impedance depends on the size of the real
part. If we suppose that the reactance X is transformed into the reactance X by a mistake in test
frequency, then the magnitude of the impedance will be transformed to R 2 2 X 2 and the tangent
of the phase angle of the impedance will become X /R.
As a numerical example, assume R and X are both 1 Ω. Then the magnitude of the impedance is 2
Ω and the phase angle is 45°. If the reactance is reduced by a factor of = 0.1, then the magnitude
of the impedance becomes 1.005 Ω and the phase angle is 5.7°. If the reactance is increased by a
factor of = 10, then the magnitude of the impedance is 10.05 Ω and the phase angle is 84.3°.
Here's a to-scale plot of these impedance phasors to give you a feel for how big the effect of a 10X
frequency mistake is:
Original reactance of 1 + j
8 There are actually a variety of impedance measurement methods for different frequency regimes.
Good practices
This section contains tips and suggestions to help you get the most out of your LCR meter.
Calibrated and Ensure the LCR meter is in calibration and functioning correctly. Double
properly functioning check the calibration with your working standards.
Appropriate Use the series model for reactances less than about 100 Ω and the
measurement model parallel model for reactances larger than 100 Ω.
9 S stands for the SI unit of siemens and is 1 ampere per volt. The word siemens is both singular and plural in
English usage, so it's proper to say “one siemens”.
Note the negative inductance and capacitances. Since the impedance is behaving like an inductor at
low frequencies and a capacitor at high frequencies, here's an equivalent circuit model that might
explain this behavior:
Figure 28
10 If it happens with an air-core inductor, it may lead you to believe that the LCR meter may not be working
correctly or you're measuring near the meter's physical measurement capabilities.
Bethel, N. (n.d.). Identifying motor defects through fault zone analysis. ReliablePlanet.com. Retrieved
Jul 30, 2013, from http://www.reliableplant.com/Read/4288/motor-defects-fault-zone.
Callegro, L. (2013). Electrical Impedance: Principles, Measurement, and Applications. New York: CRC
Press.
Feynman, R., Leighton, R., and Sands, M. (1964). The Feynman Lectures on Physics. Volumes 1-3.
Addison-Wesley.
Grover, F. (2004). Inductance Calculations. Dover Publications. (Original work published 1946).
Hemenway, C. and Caulton, M. (1962). Physical electronics. Wiley.
Kundert, K. (2008, June). Modeling dielectric absorption in capacitors. Version 2d. The Designer's
Guide Community. From http://www.designers-guide.org.
McKinnon, D. and Smolleck, H. (2004). Influence of rotor residual flux on the measurement of
inductance and its possible use as an impending fault indicator. PdMA Corporation. From
http://www.pdma.com/pdfs/Articles/Influence_of_Residual_Flux_on_the_Measurement_of_Inductan
ce.pdf.
Rose, R., Shepard, L., and Wulff, J. (1966). The structure and properties of materials, vol. 4: electronic
properties. Wiley.
Steinmetz, C. (1916). Theory and Calculation of Alternating Current Phenomena. 5th ed. McGraw-Hill.
Working Group 1 of the Joint Committee for Guides in Metrology. (2008). Evaluation of Measurement
Data - Guide to the Expression of Uncertainty in Measurement. 1995 version with minor corrections.
Bureau International des Poids et Mesures. From
http://www.bipm.org/en/publications/guides/gum.html.
Yavorsky, R. and Detlaf, A. (1975). Handbook of Physics. 2nd ed. MIR Publishers.