ST. MARY’S COLLEGE, INC.

COLLEGE OF LAW
OBLIGATIONS AND CONTRACTS
SY 2018-2019

I. GENERAL PROVISIONS (Article 1156 to 1162)

1. Makati Stock Exchange vs Campos et al GR 138814, April 16, 2009
2.Ang Yu vs CA, GR 109125, December 2, 1994
3. Metropolitan Bank vs Rosales et al, GR 183204, January 13, 2014
4. Daisy Tiu vs Platinum Plans, GR 107207, November 23, 1995
5. Deiparine vs CA, GR 96643, April 23, 1993
6. Metropolitan Bank & Trust Company vs Absolute Management Corp, 688 SCRA 255, (2013)
7. Borromeo vs CA, 550 SCRA 269 (2008)
8. Garcia vs CA, 258 SCRA 446 (1996)

II. NATURE AND EFFECT OF OBLIGATIONS (Article 1163 to 1178)

1. Nakpil & Sons vs CA, 160 SCRA 334 (1988)
2. PFIC Inc. vs Wallem, 582 SCRA 457 (2009)
3. Yao vs Matela, 500 SCRA 136 (2006)
4. PEFLGC vs VP Eusebio, 434 SCRA 202 (2004)
5. J Plus Asia vs Utility Assurance, 700 SCRA 134 (2013)
6. Gil vs CA, 411 SCRA 18 (2003)
7. Omengan vs PNB, 512 SCRA 305 (2007)
8. Spouses Giano vs Makati Shangri-La, 641 SCRA 591 (2011)
9. Vazquez vs Ayala Corporation, 443 SCRA 231 (2004)
10. FGU Insurance vs GP Sarmiento Trucking, 386 SCRA 312 (2002)
11. International Corporate Bank vs Gueco, 351 SCRA 516 (2001)
12. BPI vs Lifetime Marketing, 555 SCRA 373 (2008)
13. Tiu vs Arriesgado 437 SCRA 426 (2004)
14. Rodzssen Supply vs Far East Bank 357 SCRA 618 (2001)
15. Philippine Realty vs Ley Construction, 651 SCRA 719 (2011)

III. DIFFERENT KINDS OF OBLIGATIONS

1. Insular Life vs Toyota Bel-Air, 550 SCRA 70 (2008)
2. Insular Life vs Young, 373 SCRA 626 (2002)
3. Rayos vs CA, 434 SCRA 356 (2004)
4. Heirs of Sandejas vs Lina, 351 SCRA 183 (2001)
5. Buot vs CA, 357 SCRA 846 (2001)
6. Republic vs Holy Trinity, 551 SCRA 303 (2008)
7. Heirs of Gaite vs The Plaza, 640 SCRA 576 (2011)
8. Fil-Estate Gold vs Vertex Sales, 698 SCRA272 (2013)
9. Sandoval Shipyards vs PMMA, 695 SCRA 560 (2013)
10. Reyes vs Rossi, 691 SCRA 571 (2013)

Article 1191
11. Reyes vs Tuparan, 650 SCRA 283, 2011
12. De Leon vs Ong, 611 SCRA 381, 2010
13. Luzon Devt Bank vs Enriquez, 639 SCRA 332, 2011
14. Peralta vs Raval, GR 188467 and 188464, 2017
15. Nolasco vs Cuerpo, GR 210215, December 9, 2015
16. Sta. Fe Realty vs Sison, GR 199431, 2016
17. EDS Manufacturing vs Health Check, GR 162802, October 9, 2013
18. Buenviaje vs Spouses Salonga, GR 216023, 2016
19. PEZA vs Pilhino, GR 185765, 2016
20. Spouses Tumibay vs Spouses Lopez, GR 171692, 2013
21. FF Cruz vs HR Construction, GR 187521, 2012
22. Spouses Viloria vs Continental, GR 188288, 2012
23. Goldloop vs GSIS, GR 171076, 2012
24. Fong vs Duenas, GR 185592, 2015
OBLIGATIONS WITH A PERIOD
1. MIAA vs Olongapo Maintenance, GR 146184-85, 2008
Article 1197
Article 1198
2. DBP vs Sta Ines, GR 193068 and 193000, 2017
Section 3-ALTERNATIVE OBLIGATIONS
Section 4-JOINT AND SOLIDARY OBLIGATIONS
3. Ruks Consult vs Adworld Sign, GR 204866, 2015
4. AFPRSBS vs Sanvictores, GR 207586, 2016
5. R Transport vs Yu, GR 174161, 2015
6. Spouses Ibanez vs James, GR 194272, 2017
Section 5-DIVISIBLE AND INDIVISIBLE OBLIGATIONS
7. Government vs CFI, GR L-32162, 1984
Section 6-OBLIGATIONS WITH A PENAL CLAUSE
8. RS Tomas Inc vs Rizal Cement, GR 173155, 2012
9. Spouses Poon vs Prime Savings Bank, GR 183794, 2016
Article 1227
10. Heirs of Liong vs Castillo, GR 176425, 2013
Article 1229
11. Lo vs CA, 411 SCRA 523, 2003
12. State Investment House vs CA, GR 112590, 2001
13. DBP vs CA, GR 137557, 2000
14. Spouses Solangon vs Salazar, GR 125944, 2001
15. Ligutan vs CA, 138667, 2002
16. Louh vs BPI, GR 225562, 2017

IV. CHAPTER 4-EXTINGUISHMENT OF OBLIGATIONS

1. Reyna vs Soria, GR 167219, 2011
Section 1- Payment or Performance
2. Go Tong vs BPI Family, GR 187487, 2015
3. Multi-International vs Martinez, GR 175378, 2015
4. IHC vs Joaquin et al, GR 158361, 2013
5. MIAA vs Avia Filipinas, GR 180168, 2012
6. MIAA vs Ding Velayo Sports Center, GR 161718, 2011
7. Osmena-Jalandoni vs Encomienda, GR 205578, 2017
8. Spouses De La Cruz vs Concepcion, GR 172825, 2012
9. NPC vs Ibrahim et al, GR 175863, 2015
10. Tan Shuy vs Spouses Maulawin, GR 190375, 2012
11. Spouses Tan vs China Banking Corporation, GR 200299, 2016
12. Sinamban vs China Banking Corporation, GR 193890, 2015
13. Marquez vs Elisan Credit Corporation, GR 194642, 2015
14. Hernandez-Nievera vs Hernandez, 642 SCRA 646, 2011
15. Co vs Admiral United Savings Bank, 551 SCRA 472, 2008
16. G&M Philippines vs Cuambot, 507 SCRA 552, 2006
17. Ramos vs Sarao, 451 SCRA 103, 2005
18. Towne & City Dev’t Corp vs CA, 434 SCRA 356, 2004
19. Republic vs De Guzman, 652 SCRA 101, 2011
20. Luzon Development Bank vs Enriquez, 639 SCRA 332, 2011
21. Fort Bonifacio vs Yllas Lending, 567 SCRA 454, 2008
22. ASJ Corporation vs Evangelista, 545 SCRA 300, 2008
23. Almeda vs Bathala, 542 SCRA 470, 2008
24. Uniwide Holdings vs Jandecs, 541 SCRA 158, 2007

MIDTERM
Subsection 2-Payment by Cession
1. Insular Life vs Bel-Air, 550 SCRA 70, 2008
2. Dalton vs FGR, 640 SCRA 92, 2011
3. Pasricha vs Don Luis, 548 SCRA 273, 2008
 4. BE San Diego vs Alzul, 524 SCRA 402, 2007
5. Ramos vs Sarao, 451 SCRA 103, 2005
6. Spouses Villaluz vs LBP, GR 192602, 2017
7. Yulim International vs International Exchange Bank, GR 203133, 2015

Section 2-Loss of the Thing Due

8. Osmena vs SSS, 533 SCRA 313, 2007
9. Reyna vs COA, 642 SCRA 210, 2011
10. DBP vs Clarges Realty, GR 170060, 2016
11. Iloilo Jar Corporation vs Comglasco, GR 219509, 2017
12. Comglasco vs Santos Car Check Center, 202989, March 25, 2015
13. Spouses Poon vs Prime Savings Bank, GR 183794, 2016
14. Tagaytay Realty vs Gacutan, GR 160033, 2015

Section 3-Condonation or Remission of the Debt

15. Biala vs CA, GR 43503, 1990
16. FIBIC vs Isnani, GR 70246, 1989

Section 4- Confusion or Merger of Rights

17. Dela Cruz vs People, 436 SCRA 641, 2004

Section 5-Compensation
18. Nisce vs Equitable PCI Bank, 516 SCRA 231, 2007
19. United Planters Sugar Milling vs CA, 527 SCRA 336, 2007
20. Citibank vs Sabeniano, 514 SCRA 441, 2007
21. Trinidad vs Acapulco, 491 SCRA 179, 2006
22. IITC vs COEC and Planters Dev’t Bank, GR 183308, 2012
23. Union Bank vs DBP, GR 191555, 2014
24. California Manufacturing Company vs Advanced Technology System, GR 202454, 2017
25. Philippine Trust Company vs Roxas et al, GR 171897, 2015
26. Mondragon Personal Sales vs Sola, 174882, 2013

Section 6-Novation
27. SSS vs DOJ, 529 SCRA 426, 2007
28. Ong vs Bognalbal, 501 SCRA 490, 2006
29. Reyes vs BPI Family Savings Bank, 486 SCRA 276, 2006
30. Tecnogas vs PNB, 551 SCRA 183, 2008
31. Lorenzo Shipping vs Chubb and Sons, 431 SCRA 266, 2004
32. SM Systems vs Camerino, GR 178591, 2017
33. Odiamar vs Valencia, GR 213582, 2016
34. BPI vs Domingo, GR 169407, 2015
35. Y-1 Leisure Philippines vs Yu, GR 207161, 2015
36. Ever Electrical vs PBC, GR 187822-23, 2016
37. Figuera vs Ang, GR 204264, 2016
38. Liam vs UCPB, GR 194664, 2016

V. CONTRACTS
A. General Provisions
1. IPMSI vs De Vera et al, GR 205703, 2016
2. Mora vs Belmonte et al, GR 171146, 2011
3. PSB vs Spouses Castillo, GR 193178, 2011
4. Buenaventura vs MBTC, GR 167082, 2016
5. Integrated Packaging Corporation vs CA, GR 115117, 2000
6. Games and Garments vs ABC, GR 181426, 2015
7. Dona Adela vs TIDC, GR 201931, 2015
8. Spouses Pontigon vs Heirs of Sanchez, GR 221513, 2016
9. Inocencio vs Hospicio de San Jose, GR 201787, 2013
10. Heirs of Ureta vs Heirs of Ureta, GR 165748, 2011
B. Essential Requisites of Contracts
 11. Kabisig Real Wealth vs Young Corporation, GR 212375, 2017
12. Manzano Jr vs Garcia, GR 179323, 2011
B.1 Consent
13. Spouses Gironella vs PNB, 194515, 2015
14. Limson vs CA, GR 135929, 2001
15. Tan vs Planters Product, GR 172339, 2008
16. Malbarosa vs CA, GR 125761, 2003
17. Limson vs CA, GR 135929, 2001
18. Roman Catholic Church vs Pante, GR 174118, 2012
19. Swift Foods vs Spouses Mateo, GR 170486, 2011
20. Calicap-Asmeron vs DBP, GR 157330, 2011
21. Talampas vs Lodex Realty, GR 170134, 2015
22. Security Bank vs Great Wall, GR 219345, 2017
23. Tankeh vs DBP, GR 171428, 2013
24. Spouses Tongson vs Emergency Pawnshop, GR 167874, 2010
25. Valerio et al vs Refresca et al, GR 163687, 2006
26. Heirs of Ureta vs Heirs of Ureta, GR 165748 and 165930, 2011
27. Reyes vs Asuncion, GR 196083, 2015
B.2 Object of Contracts
B.3 Cause of Contracts
28. Sta. Fe Realty vs Sison, GR 199431, 2016

FINALS
VI. FORMS OF CONTRACTS
1. Cruz et al vs Gruspe, GR 191431, 2013
2. Pontigon vs Heirs of Sanchez, GR 221513, 2016
VII. REFORMATION OF INSTRUMENTS
3. Tuason vs CA, GR 119794, 2000
4. Rosello-Bentir vs Leanda, GR 128891, 2000
5. Emilio vs Rapal, GR 181855, 2010
VIII. INTERPRETATION OF CONTRACTS
6. Ramos et al vs PNB, GR 178218, 2011
7. The Wellex Group vs U-Land Air Lines, GR 167519, 2015
8. International Exchange Bank vs Spouses Briones, GR 205657, 2017
9. Tan vs Planters Products, GR 172239, 2008
10. Century Properties vs Babiano et al, GR 220978, 2016
11. Felsan Realty vs Commonwealth of Australia, GR 160656, 2007
12. Allied Banking vs Yujuico, GR 163166, 2015
13. Werr International vs Highlands Prime, GR 187543 and 187580, 2017
14. Spouses Wong Choi and Chua vs UCPB, GR 207747, 2015
IX. RESCISSIBLE CONTRACTS
15. Ada et al vs Baylon, GR 182435, August 13, 2012
16. Rosencor vs Inquing, GR 140479, March 8, 2001
17. Khe Hong Cheng vs CA, GR 144169, March 28, 2001
18. Lee et al vs Bangkok Bank, GR 173349, February 9, 2011
X. VOIDABLE CONTRACTS
19. Miailhe vs CA, GR 108991, March 20, 2001
20. Spouses Viloria vs Continental Airlines, GR 188288, January 16, 2012
21. Malabanan vs Gaw Ching, GR 74938-39, January 17, 1990
22. Armentia vs Patriarca, GR L-18210, December 29, 1966
XI. UNENFORCEABLE CONTRACTS
23. Berg vs Magdalena, GR L-3784, October 17, 1952
24. Limketkai Sons vs CA, GR 118509, December 1, 1995
25. Babao vs Perez, GR L-8334, December 28, 1957
26. Paterno vs Jao Yan, GR L-12218, February 28, 1961
27. Reiss vs Memije, GR 5447, March 1, 1910
28. Hermosisima vs CA, GR L-14628, September 30, 1960
29. Martinez vs CA, GR 123547, May 21, 2001
30. Estate of Gonzales vs Heirs of Perez, GR 169681, November 5, 2009
 31. Cenido vs Apacianado, GR 132474, November 19, 1999

XII. VOID AND INEXISTENT CONTRACTS

32. Manzano vs Garcia, GR 179323, November 28, 2011
33. Pena vs Delos Santos, GR 202223, March 2, 2016
34. Marubeni Corporation vs Lirag, GR 130998, August 10, 2001
35. Prudential Bank vs Rapanot, GR 191636, January 16, 2017
36. Guillermo et al vs PIA, GR 223751, March 15, 2017
37. Penalosa vs Santos , GR 133749, August 23, 2001
38. Spouses Abella vs Spouses Abella, GR 195166, July 8, 2015
39. Spouses Mallari vs Prudential Bank, GR 197861, June 5, 2013
40. Spouses Jonsay vs Solidbank, GR 206459, April 6, 2016
41. Aujero vs PCSC, GR 19384, January 18, 2012
42. Irao vs By the Bay, GR 177120, July 14, 2008
43. Arsenal vs IAC, GR L-66693, July 14, 1986
44. Heirs of Injugtiro vs Casals, GR 134718, August 20, 2001
45. Delos Santos et al vs Abejon, GR 215820, March 20, 2017
46. Lita Enterprises vs IAC, GR L-64693, April 27, 1984
47. Jose vs Chelda Enterprises, GR L-25704, April 24, 1968
48. Spouses De Guzman vs CA, GR 185757, March 2, 2016
49. Olea vs CA, GR 109696, August 14, 1995