Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
Micah Harlan
Research Paper
On August, 6, 1945, the United States Air Force bomber, named the “Enola
Gay”, dropped a bomb that weighed five tons on Hiroshima, Japan. Three days later, on
August 9th, another nuclear bomb was dropped on Nagasaki, Japan. A couple Days
after both bombs were dropped the Japanese surrendered to the United States Military,
ending World War II. 140,000 people were killed due to both atomic bombs. 80,000
people were killed on impact and 60,000 people died just days after from all the
radiation (Kramer “Nuclear Age”). The whole country was exposed to a nuclear fallout,
radioactive dust that spreads hundreds of miles, that can later cause more deaths due
the increased risk of cancer. Nuclear weapons have been a big problem ever since the
end of World War II. There are two ways to prevent a nuclear war: build more nuclear
weapons or get rid of them all. The Cold War was a nuclear weapon standoff between
the U.S.S.R and the United States. The Cold War lasted from 1945-1991. It ended
because the U.S.S.R collapsed. During that time people in the United States were
arguing over how they were going to get rid of the threat of an all out nuclear war from
occurring.
There are three communities who have slightly different views on the use and
production of nuclear weapons: the science community, the military community, and the
political community. In the 1930’s all the scientists knew that it was possible to make a
nuclear bomb. They did not have the technology to make a nuclear weapon yet. During
Harlan 2
World War II the United States began researching nuclear weapons when they
discovered that German Military or Nazis were trying to develop a weapon of mass
destruction (Mitcham, “Nuclear Ethics”). In 1945 the United States had received
information that the Nazis were not close to making a nuclear weapon. The scientists
then began to question the ethics behind using a nuclear bomb, before they even had
one. Only the scientists knew how powerful the bomb was. They saw no use in creating
it now it was not a worry, but the U.S Military thought of the bombs as a quick way to
end the war. After the United States Military dropped the bombs on Hiroshima and
Nagasaki all the nuclear scientists created the Federation of American Scientists
(Mitcham, “Nuclear Ethics”). The Federation was created to lobby elected officials and
educate them about the effects of using nuclear weapons. They also pushed for using
science only for good. Only the scientists knew the harmful effects of testing nuclear
weapons. When a nuclear weapon is tested it creates a nuclear fallout that spreads for
hundreds of miles and can even affect neutral nations. Some scientists had a radical
view of a full disarmament of all nuclear weapons the United States Military had. The
science side of the nuclear weapon argument sees more into the ethics than any other
group.
The politics and military’s view on nuclear weapons is similar. Both communities
believe keeping the nuclear weapons for strategic purposes is necessary. For example,
during the Cold War the United States was on the brink of a nuclear war with Soviet
Russia, what kept both countries from using any nuclear weapons was the fact that they
had nuclear weapons. This was known as nuclear deterrence, threatening a nuclear
during the Cold War was the massive buildup of arms, known as the arms race. The
military uses nuclear weapons as a way to exercise superiority over other countries.
The military faces questions if using nuclear weapons is ethical, and when it is okay to
use such a powerful weapon. The military decides when it is ethical to use a nuclear
weapon. The military also faces issues about targeting their nuclear weapons, civilian or
military targets. All three communities can agree using a nuclear weapon at the least
should be a last resort (“Nuclear Weapons”). The United States formally stated using a
There have been many efforts from treaties to nuclear defense systems to try to
prevent a nuclear war from occurring. An effort made by the U.S and the U.S.S.R to
stop the Cold War was the 1963 Limited Test Ban Treaty. This treaty limited both
countries from testing nuclear weapons in the atmosphere and underwater (“Nuclear
Weapons”). The limited test ban treaty was the first agreement between the two
superpowers during the Cold War. A peace group in the U.S called “Nuclear freeze”
proposed if the United States stops all production of nuclear warheads so the U.S.S.R
will stop producing them as well (Columba, “Strategic Defense”). Nuclear Freeze’s goal
was to end the nuclear arms race and stop the production of nuclear weapons. Nuclear
Freeze pushed the public's attention on defense spending. On March, 23, 1983
President Ronald Reagan proposed a new strategy that he stated would “Change the
course of mankind” (Columba, “Strategic Defense”). His proposal went against what the
people wanted, but was supposed to have the same outcome. This strategy was called
the Strategic Defense Initiative also known as SDI. The purpose of the SDI was to make
nuclear weapons obsolete and ineffective, by making a space laser system that can
shoot down any incoming missile. Reagan’s main goal of the Strategic Defense Initiative
Harlan 4
was to make nuclear weapons ineffective and almost impossible to be used against the
United States. Reagan's plan went against a treaty with the U.S.S.R to ban researching
systems that can block nuclear attacks to keep nuclear deterrence between both
countries (Columba, “Strategic Defense”). If the U.S was able to build the nuclear
defense system it would make an imbalance in nuclear deterrence. The imbalance
would mean that the U.S would be more likely to use nuclear weapons against Russia
knowing they could defend against a nuclear retaliation. Reagan's strategic defense
system never worked out due to budget cuts, but the United States is still developing a
The world witnessed what nuclear weapons can do to a country at the end of
World War II. The United States government faces many problems with nuclear
weapons. Some people think the solution to avoid nuclear war is to keep building more
disarmament is too unsafe for the United States security. Before the United States even
built an atomic bomb the scientists were thinking about if it was even ethical to use one
against another country. The politicians and military use nuclear weapons to influence
other countries. The main issue with the military and nuclear weapons is in what
nuclear weapon they face the questions about which targets they can attack. All the
proposed solutions of solving the nuclear weapon problem have the same outcome,
Works Cited
Franklin, Delano R. "Experts Warn of Risk of Nuclear War During Panel." UWIRE Text,
link.galegroup.com/apps/doc/A524223500/GPS?u=va_s_128_0030&sid=GPS&xid=d42
Kramer, Mark. "Nuclear Age." New Dictionary of the History of Ideas, edited by
Maryanne Cline Horowitz, vol. 4, Charles Scribner's Sons, 2005, pp. 1646-1649.
link.galegroup.com/apps/doc/CX3424300548/UHIC?u=va_s_128_0030&sid=UHIC&xid=
link.galegroup.com/apps/doc/CX3434900469/OVIC?u=va_s_128_0030&sid=OVIC&xid=
Viewpoints in Context,
link.galegroup.com/apps/doc/PC3021900119/OVIC?u=va_s_128_0030&sid=OVIC&xid=
Peoples, Columba. "Strategic Defense Initiative (Star Wars)." America in the World,
by Edward J. Blum, vol. 2, Charles Scribner's Sons, 2016, pp. 977-978. U.S. History in
Context,ink.galegroup.com/apps/doc/CX3630800486/UHIC?u=va_s_128_0030&sid=UH
Labeling Key
verb form
verb tense
strong word choice
poor word choice
spelling error
awkward phrasing
capitalize word
lower case - do not capitalize
Provide an example to support your point
sentence fragment
run-on sentence
repetitive
Punctuation error
_
get rid
get rid
had.
not capitalize
Military,
Military
Military
Military
Mutually
run-on sentence For example, during the Cold War the United States was on the brink of
a nuclear war with Soviet Russia, what kept both countries from using
any nuclear weapons was the fact that they had nuclear weapons
Punctuation ,
error
time
1930’s
II
Nagasaki
tested
system
Russia
bomb
weapon
The military
he military
The military
The military