Compelete File

CERTIFICATE
DECLARATION
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
ABSTRACT
LIST OF FIGURES
LIST OF TABLES
LIST OF CHARTS
Contents
CHAPTER-1: INTRODUCTION ............................................................................................... 1
1.1. GENERAL ....................................................................................................................... 1
1.2. The structural systems of tall buildings............................................................................ 2
1.3. Outriggered Frame Systems ............................................................................................. 2
1.3.1. The behavior of outriggered frame systems.............................................................. 4
1.3.2. Advantages of outriggers .......................................................................................... 7
CHAPTER-2:LITERATURE REVIEW .................................................................................... 8
2.1 GENERAL ......................................................................................................................................................8
2.2 Previous research work on outrigger and Belt trusses ........................................................................8
CHAPTER-3:OBJECTIVES OF THE STUDY ...................................................................... 12
3.1 OBJECTIVES...............................................................................................................................................12
CHAPTER-4:METHODS OF ANALYSIS .............................................................................. 13

4.1 GENERAL ....................................................................................................................................................13
CHAPTER-5:ANALYTICAL MODELLING ......................................................................... 14

5.1 INTRODUCTION ............................................................................................................... 14
1.2 5.2 METHOD OF MODELLING .................................................................................. 14
5.3 MODEL DESCRIPTION .................................................................................................... 15
5.3.1 Building Models Studied .............................................................................................. 24
5.3.2 Design data ................................................................................................................... 24
1.3 5.4 DESIGN PROCEDURE ........................................................................................... 25
5.4.1. Equivalent Static Method ............................................................................................ 25
5.4.2. Static wind Analysis: ................................................................................................... 25
5.4.3. Response Spectrum Method ........................................................................................ 26
5.4.4. Gust Effectiveness Factor Method .............................................................................. 26
CHAPTER-6:ANALYSIS RESULTS AND DISCUSSIONS ................................................. 47
1.4 6.1 GENERAL ............................................................................................................... 47
1.5 6.2 PARAMETERS STUDIED ...................................................................................... 47
i
6.2.1 Lateral displacement ..................................................................................................... 47
6.2.2 Storey drift .................................................................................................................... 63
6.2.3 Base shear ..................................................................................................................... 78
6.2.4 Fundamental time period .............................................................................................. 92
CHAPTER-7CONCLUSION .................................................................................................. 100
REFERENCES .......................................................................................................................... 101
ii
List of figures
Fig.1. 1:Outriggered frame system ............................................................................................................... 3
Fig.1. 2: Outrigger to perimeter column connections: (a) rigid connection, (b) hinged connection ............ 5
Fig.1. 3: Outriggered frame system under lateral loads and analytical model ............................................. 5
Fig.1. 4: Superposition of analytical model ................................................................................................... 6
Fig.1. 5: Diagram of the effect of the outrigger on the moment .................................................................. 6
Fig.1. 6: Axial deformation of the perimeter columns on two facades perpendicular to the bending
direction ........................................................................................................................................................ 7
Fig.5. 1: Plan layout ..................................................................................................................................... 15

Fig.5. 2: Sectional Elevation of building (Model 1) ..................................................................................... 17
Fig.5. 3: 3D view of building (Model 1) ....................................................................................................... 17
Fig.5. 6: Perspective view of a storey outrigger location (Model 2) ........................................................... 18
Fig.5. 9: Perspective view of a storey showing outrigger and Belt truss (Model 3) ................................... 19
Fig.5. 10: Sectional Elevation of building (Model 4) ................................................................................... 20
Fig.5. 11: 3D view of building (Model 4) ..................................................................................................... 20
Fig.5. 12: Perspective view of a storey showing outrigger (steel) and concrete core wall (Model 4) ........ 20
Fig.5. 15: Perspective view of a storey showing outrigger & belt truss (steel) and concrete core wall
(Model 5)..................................................................................................................................................... 21
Fig.5. 18: Perspective view of a storey showing outrigger (steel) and Brace core wall (Model 6) ............. 22
Fig.5. 21: Perspective view of a storey showing outrigger and belt truss (steel) and Brace core wall
(Model 6)..................................................................................................................................................... 23
Fig.5. 22: Force coefficient for Rectangular Clad building .......................................................................... 28
Fig.5. 23: Showing value of gfr and L(h) ...................................................................................................... 29
Fig.5. 24: Background Factor, B .................................................................................................................. 30
Fig.5. 25: Size reduction Factor S ................................................................................................................ 31
Fig.6. 1: Mode 1, Mode 2, Mode 3 for Model 1 .......................................................................................... 93

iii
iv
List of tables
Table 5. 1 Details of wind load calculations as per IS: 875 (Part-3) 1987 with gust factors in Longitudinal
direction for Model 1 .................................................................................................................................. 33
Table 5. 2 Details of wind load calculations as per IS: 875 (Part-3) 1987 with gust factors inTransverse
Table 5. 3 Details of wind load calculations as per IS: 875 (Part-3) 1987 with gust factors in Longitudinal
Table 5. 4 Details of wind load calculations as per IS: 875 (Part-3) 1987 with gust factors in Transverse
Table 5. 5 Details of wind load calculations as per IS: 875 (Part-3) 1987 with gust factors in longitudinal
direction for Model 3. ................................................................................................................................. 37
Table 5. 6 Details of wind load calculations as per IS: 875 (Part-3) 1987 with gust factors in transverse
Table 6. 1: Lateral displacements for Load case (G-X) for various models ................................................. 48
Table 6. 2: Lateral displacements for Load case (G-Y) for various models ................................................. 49
Table 6. 3: Lateral Displacements for RSA along longitudinal Direction for Zone V ................................... 51
Table 6. 4: Lateral Displacements for RSA along transverse direction for Zone V ..................................... 52
Table 6. 5: Lateral Displacements for wind along longitudinal direction ................................................... 54
Table 6. 6: Lateral Displacements for wind along transverse direction...................................................... 55
Table 6. 7: Lateral Displacements for EQ along longitudinal direction....................................................... 56
Table 6. 8: Lateral Displacements for EQ along transverse direction ......................................................... 58
Table 6. 9: Maximum Displacement by Response Spectrum Analysis and Dynamic Wind ........................ 62
Table 6. 10: Story drift for Load case (G-X) for various models .................................................................. 64
v
Table 6. 11: Story drift for Load case (G-Y) for various models .................................................................. 65
Table 6. 12: Story drift for Response spectrum analysis along longitudinal direction for Zone V ............. 67
Table 6. 13: Lateral Displacements for Response spectrum analysis along transverse direction for Zone V
.................................................................................................................................................................... 68
Table 6. 14: Storey drift for wind along longitudinal direction ................................................................... 70
Table 6. 15: Storey drift for wind along transverse direction ..................................................................... 71
Table 6. 16: Storey drift for EQ along longitudinal direction ...................................................................... 73
Table 6. 17: Storey drift for EQ along transverse direction ........................................................................ 74
Table 6. 18: Maximum Storey Drifts by Response Spectrum Analysis and Dynamic Wind ........................ 77
Table 6. 19: Base shear for Load case (G-X) for various models ................................................................. 79
Table 6. 20: Base shear for Load case (G-Y) for various models ................................................................. 80
Table 6. 21: Story drift for Response spectrum analysis along longitudinal direction for Zone V ............. 82
Table 6. 22: Story drift for Response spectrum analysis along transverse direction for ZoneV ................. 83
Table 6. 23: Base shear for wind along longitudinal direction ................................................................... 85
Table 6. 24: Base shear for wind along transverse direction ...................................................................... 86
Table 6. 25: Base shear for EQ along longitudinal direction ....................................................................... 88
Table 6. 26: Base shear for EQ along transverse direction ......................................................................... 89
Table 6. 27: Base Shear by Response Spectrum Analysis and Dynamic Wind Analysis along .................... 90
Table 6. 28: Fundamental period and participation for Model 1 ............................................................... 93
vi
List of Charts
Chart 6. 1: Comparison of Lateral Displacement for Load case (GUST-X) for Models. .............................. 50
Chart 6. 2: Comparison of Lateral Displacement for Load case (GUST-Y) for Models. .............................. 50
Chart 6. 3: Lateral Displacement for Load case (RSA-Y) for various Models .............................................. 53
Chart 6. 4: Lateral Displacement for Load case (RSA-X) for various Models. ............................................. 53
Chart 6. 5: Lateral Displacement for Load case (WIND-Y) for various Models ........................................... 56
Chart 6. 6: Lateral Displacement for Load case (WIND-X) for various Models ........................................... 56
Chart 6. 7: Lateral Displacement for Load case (EQ-X) for various Models ................................................ 59
Chart 6. 8: Lateral Displacement for Load case (EQ-Y) for various Models ................................................ 59
Chart 6. 9: Comparison of Top Storey Displacement by Response Spectrum Analysis .............................. 62
Chart 6. 10: Comparison of maximum storey displacement for all Models ............................................... 63
Chart 6. 11: Story drift for Load case (GUST-X) for various Models. .......................................................... 66
Chart 6. 12: Story drift for Load case (GUST-Y) for various Models............................................................ 66
Chart 6. 13: Story drift for Load case (RSA-X) for various Models. ............................................................. 69
Chart 6. 14: Storey drift for Load case (RSA-Y) for various Models. ........................................................... 69
Chart 6. 15: Storey drift for Load case (WIND-X) for various Models ......................................................... 72
Chart 6. 16: Storey drift for Load case (WIND-Y) for various Models ......................................................... 72
Chart 6. 17: Storey drifts for Load case (EQ-X) for various Models ............................................................ 75
Chart 6. 18: Storey drifts for Load case (EQ-Y) for various Models ............................................................ 75
Chart 6. 19: Comparison of Maximum Storey Drifts by Response Spectrum Analysis and Dynamic ......... 77
Chart 6. 20: Comparison of maximum storey drifts for all Models ............................................................ 78
Chart 6. 21: Base shear for Load case (GUST-Y) for various Models. ......................................................... 81
Chart 6. 22: Base shear for Load case (GUST-X) for various Models. ......................................................... 81
Chart 6. 23: Base shear for Load case (RSA-Y) for various Models. ............................................................ 84
Chart 6. 24: Base shear for Load case (RSA-X) for various Models. ............................................................ 84
Chart 6. 25: Base shear for Load case (WIND-Y) for various Models .......................................................... 87
Chart 6. 26: Base shear for Load case (WIND-X) for various Models.......................................................... 87
Chart 6. 27: Base shear for Load case (EQ-X) for various Models .............................................................. 90
Chart 6. 28: Base shear for Load case (EQ-Y) for various Models............................................................... 90
Chart 6. 29: Comparison of Base shear by Response Spectrum Analysis and Dynamic ............................. 91
Chart 6. 30: Comparison of Base shear for all Models ............................................................................... 92
7
CHAPTER 1
INTRODUCTION
1.1.GENERAL
Today it is almost impossible to visualize a major city without tall buildings. As the most
vital signs of today’s cities, high rise building has become a source of faith in knowledge and
nationwide pleasure, and has changed the concept of the contemporary city along with its scale
and appearance. In the past, the forms used in design were restricted but currently freedom in
propose of tall buildings has significantly increased, along with a contemporary widening of the
form spectrum in design. Tall buildings today, calculated through the support of highly
developed computer technologies, are built through exceptionally audacious architectural and
structural designs that are more or less not at all bring into being in their predecessors. The
mainly significant factors enabling the creation of high rise buildings are developments and
innovations in the subsequent areas: resources, building techniques, working (mechanical)
systems, structural system and investigation, but by the side of the identical time, the raise in the
elevation of buildings makes them vulnerable to wind speed and seismic activity induce lateral
loads.
When it comes to structural point of view height-rise buildings, the unexpected elevation
is an issue wind-seismic loads will affect easily when compared to low-rise building. Calculating
the lateral loads more difficult than the gravity loads.
Earthquake masses is direct proportional to structure mass, on the other hand wind loads
depend on the height of building as the height increases the wind forces will increase, in height
rise buildings wind loads are dominant while mid & low rise buildings wind loads are generally
an unimportant issue. Consequently, the residence reassure takes eminence in the design of
structural system in high building, & it is essential to control the structure lean. In high building,
this is able to be described as perpendicular cantilever beam, According to the government
department of IS 875:1987 Part III, satisfactory boundary for peak deflection in elevated
structure for wind study is 1/500 of structure altitude
To defeat lateral load owed to seismic activity & wind speed, core wall have been
provide by the side of middle of structure.
Core wall (steel or concrete) is a incredibly efficient & realistic structural scheme which is
cooperative in plummeting the deflection owed to earthquake and wind loads. Though, as
Department of Civil, LIET 1

structure increase in elevation, rigidity of core wall merely is not enough to defend against wind
force and earthquake load. This complexity creates require of modernization of different recent
structural systems. For every composite form group, tall buildings are designed with a variety of
structural system, such as braced tube, dia-grid and outrigger systems.
1.2.THE STRUCTURAL SYSTEMS OF TALL BUILDINGS

Structures can be classified on the origin of the equipment used in their structural systems
[structural materials of the columns, beams, shear trusses (braces), shear walls and outriggers] as:
 Steel
 Reinforced concrete
 Composite
Tall building structural systems:
 Rigid frame systems
 Flat plate/slab systems
 Core systems
 Shear wall systems
 Shear-frame systems
 Shear trussed frame (braced frame) systems
 Shear walled frame systems
 Mega column (mega frame, space truss) systems
 Mega core systems
 Outrigger frame systems
 Tube systems
 Framed-tube systems
 Trussed-tube systems
 Bundled-tube systems
1.3. OUTRIGGERED FRAME SYSTEMS

The outriggers are structural rudiments linking the core to the edge columns at single or
additional level all the way through the elevation of the structure so as to strengthen the

constitution (Fig.1.1). An outrigger consists a horizontal shear truss. To create them adequately
efficient, outriggers are at slightest single storey deep, and have a high flexural and shear
rigidity. Because the outriggers affect the interior space, they are generally located at the
mechanical equipment floors in order not to hinder the use of normal floors.
Fig.1. 1:Outriggered frame system
At the level of the outriggers, connecting the boundary columns to all other with belts,
improve the effectiveness of the structure by equalizing the axial column loads along the
perimeter. In this manner, the column, which is linked to the middle by the outrigger, distributes
the axial weight consequence of the outrigger to further column via belt. A belt is made up of a
horizontal shear truss and of equal depth to the outrigger (Fig.1.1).
In this way, all outside columns are joined collectively to participate in supporting the
outriggers. Belts are used not only in the aforementioned conservative outrigger systems, but
also used in the “virtual” outrigger systems. Virtual outriggers idea takes benefit of base
diaphragms to get rid of straight link of center and boundary column through outriggers. A
virtual outrigger consists of strap, & story slab occupied by strap. In this manner, the problem
associated with the gap engaged by the conventional outriggers is avoided. Efficiency of the V.O
depends on the inflexibility of the girdle and story slab at belt levels.

In cases where an outrigger is used at a single level all the way through the altitude of the
structure, the most effective most advantageous position for the outrigger is approximately 40–
60 % of the structure elevation. (Smith and Coull, 1991; Taranath, 1998) (Section 3.9.2).
There is a relation between the number of levels where outriggers are used throughout the
height of the building and their optimum locations. The best possible position of “n” quantity
of outriggers used at level all through the elevation of the construction can be given
approximately by the formula 1/(n+1), 2/(n+1) … n/(n+1)n(Smith and Coull, 1991) (Section
3.9.2). The optimum locations for outriggers at single or two levels all the way through the
altitude of the structure using various assumptions are calculated in Sections 3.9.1 and 3.9.2.
Addition of each new outrigger level increases the solidity of the construction, however by a
lesser quantity than the increase at the preceding level (Smith and Coull, 1991) (Section 3.9.2)..
1.3.1. THE BEHAVIOR OF OUTRIGGERED FRAME SYSTEMS
outriggers cantilevered starting the middle are allied unbendingly to the outer limits
column (Fig.1.2a), these columns are subject to additional twisting moment & axial loads
transferred from the outriggers, & the structure cannot completely benefit from the moment
hauling ability of the shear core. In additional, as soon as outriggers are linked by hinge to the
boundary column (Figure 1.2b), by overcrowding the shift of the twisting moment preliminary
the outriggers to the columns, the column axial weight ability is improved and the structure
totally benefits from the moment carrying capability of the shear core. For this reason, hinged
connections between outriggers and perimeter columns increase the effectiveness of the
construction by maximizing the utilization of not only the moment resisting ability of the shear
core but also the axial capability of the columns.
In a easy analytical model, the behavior of an outrigger frame system under lateral loads
(Fig.1.3 can be divided into 2 as a perpendicular beam core beneath lateral load & as the similar
core by way of restoring moment shaped by the outrigger’s lever outcome (Fig.1.4).
The outrigger transfer the restoring instant to the center, performing as a hinge, with the lever
result controlled by the outer limits column and resist the turning round of the center underneath
sideways.

Fig.1. 2: Outrigger to perimeter column connections: (a) rigid connection, (b) hinged
connection
Fig.1. 3: Outriggered frame system under lateral loads and analytical model

Fig.1. 4: Superposition of analytical model
Fig.1. 5: Diagram of the effect of the outrigger on the moment

Fig.1. 6: Axial deformation of the perimeter columns on two facades
perpendicular to the bending direction
1.3.2. ADVANTAGES OF OUTRIGGERS

 Outrigger structure is able to be integrated into steel, concrete or combined structures.
 inflexible framework links can be avoided on the exterior frame of the structures,
bringing Out economies
 significant decrease or total removal in the net tension forces in the columns
And foundations
 The exterior line spacing is not govern by structural thoughtfulness & be able to
effortlessly Spaced as of visual and practical point of view

CHAPTER 2
LITERATURE REVIEW
2.1 GENERAL
Various research works and experiments have been approved out since a long era all in
excess of the globe to appreciate or to estimate the end product of earth quake loads on presented
R.C.C building in sky-scraping earthquake zone and in hilly terrains. The concept of modeling
and analysis techniques used for this purpose has also been getting improved with advancement
of engineering and technology as well as with past experience.
2.2 PREVIOUS RESEARCH WORK ON OUTRIGGER AND BELT TRUSSES
A study carried by Po SengKian, Frits TorangSiahaan on ''The use of outrigger and belt
truss system for high-rise concrete buildings'' This paper studies the use of outrigger and belt
truss system for high-rise concrete building subjected to wind or earthquake load. Eight
40−storey two dimensional models of outrigger and belt truss system are subjected to wind load;
and five 60−storey three dimensional models are subjected to earthquake load, analyzed and
compared to find the lateral displacement reduction related to the outrigger and belt system
location. There are some factors affecting the effectiveness of outrigger system. They are the
stiffness and location of the outrigger and belt truss system, the geometry, the core, and floor to-
floor height of the building. This paper proposed to study the use of diagonal outrigger and belt
truss placed at different location subjected to wind or earthquake load, The design of wind load
was calculated based on CP 3, British Standard and the earthquake load obtained using was
Indonesian response spectra zone 4. With computer analysis program, the locations of outrigger
and belt truss for reducing lateral displacement, building drift, and core moment, can be
obtained. The GT-Strudl package program is used to analyze the structure subjected to wind load
in two-dimensional analysis, while ETABS software program is selected to perform three-
dimensional structure subjected to earthquake load in static and dynamic analysis (modal
analysis). The results found shows that the use of outrigger and belt truss system in high-rise
buildings increase the stiffness and makes the structural form efficient under lateral load. For
two-dimensional model, single outrigger provided at the middle of the structure height reduces
the maximum displacement by 56 %, while providing first outrigger at the top and second
outrigger at the middle of the structure height reduces displacement by 65%. For three

dimensional structural model subjected to the earthquake load, about 18% reduction in lateral
displacement can be achieved with optimum location of the outrigger truss at the top and 33rd
level. (In order to improve the performance of the structural aspect, the maximum displacement
at the top floor becomes one of the most important factors affecting the occupant’s comfort) (Po
Seng Kian, 2001).
A study carried by P.M.B.Raj Kiran, on ''Optimum Position of Outrigger System for High-
Rise Reinforced Concrete Buildings Under Wind And Earthquake Loadings'' The reason of
the current effort is to revise the application of outrigger and belt truss located at diverse position
applied to wind or Seismic forces. The design of wind force was premeditated base on I.
Standard 87.5 (Part--3) & the earthquake load obtained using IS 1893 (Part-1): 2002. The place
where outrigger and restraint tie up for dropping displacement, construction drifts and center
moments is able to be obtained. The ETABS software program is preferred to carry out study.
The current revision is restricted to (RC) multi-storied equal structure. All the construction
models analyze in the revision have 30storeys with steady storey elevation of 3m.
The final results show that the exercise of outrigger and belt tie scheme in tall buildings increases
the rigidity and makes the structural shape well-organized beneath sideways forces. The highest
drift at the peak of constitution once only middle is working is approximately 70.63 mm and this
is condensed by correctly selecting the side scheme. The preface of outrigger at peak storey as a
restrict bind is 4.8.20 mm and 407.63 mm with and with no strap tie up correspondingly. In this
reason there are not numerous reductions in float with belt up tie. In terms of the following
outrigger by limit tie up gives the decrease of 18.55% and 23.01% by means of and not including
belt up bind.
A study carried by Syed RizwanNasir, Amaresh S. Patel on ''Lateral Stability Analysis of High
Rise Building with the Effect of Outrigger and Belt Truss System''The outrigger and belt truss
system is one of the most efficient systems used to effectively control the excessive drift due to
lateral load, so that, during small or medium lateral load due to either wind or earthquake load,
the risk of structural and non-structural damage can be minimized. This paper studies the
efficient use of outrigger and belt truss system for high-rise concrete building subjected to wind
or earthquake load.

Objectives of the study were the following:
1. To study the effect of introduction of Outriggers in high rise building subjected to dynamic
wind loading.
2. To study the influence of core wall and braced core wall with X braced outriggers.
3. To study the parameters with different types of Outriggers, i.e. X Bracings and V Bracings and
Inverted V Bracings.
4. To study the influence of steel outrigger in comparison with concrete outrigger.
5. To study the effect of Outriggers with and without Peripheral Belt Truss.
it was observed through the research that the X-braced Outriggers is very much effective; as it
shows minimum lateral displacement followed by Inverted V-braced Outriggers and V-braced
Outriggers. The steel outriggers are found least effective compared to Concrete one. Although
Steel outriggers can be employed as the light weight substitute for concrete
From the study it can be concluded that wind is a dominating factor and outriggers are effective
in reducing wind effect as compared earthquake forces and also Steel Outriggers can be used as
an alternative to the other strengthening techniques available as the total weight of the existing
building will remain almost same (Nasir & Patil, 2016).
Abdul KarimMulla and Shrinivas B.N (2015) had carried out research on ‘’Outrigger System
in a Tall R.C Structure with Steel Bracing’’ Objectives of the study was the following:
1. The use of outriggers in a regular and vertical irregular building under earthquake forces.
2. The buildings with and without outrigger are compared.
3. The outriggers are introduced at two levels in buildings.
4. The behavior of outriggers introduced as a steel bracing in a R.C tall structure.
5. The outrigger location in building is obtained for reducing lateral displacements.
6. To compare the effect of outriggers by both Equivalent static method and Dynamic Analysis
method (Response spectrum method).
7. The results of base shear, storey drift are studied.
According to author the major reason of earthquake was vertical irregularities though it
can be avoided by providing outrigger to increase lateral stiffness. In this article researchers have
performed the comparative analysis of 3 dimensional regular and vertically irregular shaped
symmetrical plan 20 storey structures with and without providing outrigger beam subjected to

earthquake load. The analysis of structure was done by equivalent static method and response
spectrum method as per the Indian standard code practice. To measure the efficiency of the
structure authors have considered parameters such as lateral displacement, story drift, base shear
and fundamental natural period. On the same line authors have also examined the response of the
structure with varying seismic zones as well as the behaviour of outrigger by equivalent static
and response spectrum method by incorporating concrete and steel outrigger. Further they have
also focused on the determination of optimum location of outrigger beam to lower the lateral
displacement.
It was observed through this research that there is considerable reduction in Time period
when outrigger was introduced in regular and irregular building structure which will improve the
overall stiffness of the structure. Base shear will reduce and minimize the inter story drift by
incorporating outrigger. Geometric vertical irregularity was more effective due to reduction of
self-weight compared to regular building and Concrete outrigger are more effective than steel
outrigger with X bracing type in reducing lateral story displacement (Mulla, 2015).
Thejaswini R. M. and Rashmi A. R. have carried out a comparative study and analysis of
different lateral load resisting structural systems to understand the realistic performance of
the building during earthquake and under the excessive wind pressure as well as to select
structural system of tall building to stay in good condition with effect of gravity, live load and
external lateral load, moment, shear force and torque with acceptable strength and stiffness. For
this research work they have modelled a geometrically irregular RCC high rise building with
different forms of structural system, such as Rigid frame structure, Core wall structure, and
Shear wall structure with different configurations of shear
wall location, Tube structure and outrigger structure. Results of the analysis reveal that the
values of displacement were less in tube structure and outrigger structural system. The authors
have also stated that in geometrically irregular structure; stability of structure
will boost and the columns sway can be reduced by implementing L-shaped shear wall along the
corners of the structure. One important conclusion that the researchers have drawn from this
study is that when outrigger structural system is provided at a story which has maximum drift, it
can perform as a maximum drift controller (Thejaswini & Rashmi, 2015).

CHAPTER 3
OBJECTIVES OF THE STUDY
3.1 OBJECTIVES
 The most important purpose of the project is to evaluate the response of high rise
structural R.c frames when subjected sever lateral force
 To understand the modeling of high rise building in ETABS with F.E.M modeling
technique.
 To compute the reaction of the structure when a vertical stiffener in the form of middle
shear barrier been worn in the construction.
 To perform linear stationary study (Equivalent static) ,static wind analysis, linear active
study (Response spectrum analysis).
 To recognize the recital of building when outriggers and restraint truss worn in the
building at different locations at different high.
 To realize the effect of unlike equipment such as concrete, structural steel when they
have been use to build outriggers and belt truss.
 To know the performance of the construction by studying following parameters
 Lateral displacement
 Story drift
 Base Shear

CHAPTER 4
METHODS OF ANALYSIS
4.1 GENERAL
In common, for design of tall buildings both wind as well as earthquake loads need to be
considered. The main aim of seismic analysis is to make the building earthquake resistant rather
earthquake proof. The building designed for this purpose will resist the actions of ground
shaking although the building may get damaged but will not collapse during the severe seismic
effects. In the other sense the main objective of earthquake analysis is to evaluate the forces
developed, their remedies and to calculate the ability of structure and their elements against these
forces, Also When wind interacts with a building, both positive and negative pressures occur
simultaneously, the building must have sufficient strength to resist the applied loads from these
pressures to prevent wind induced building failure.
The analysis methods that are adopted are as follows,

1. Linear static analysis (Equivalent static method)
2. Static Wind analysis
3. Linear dynamic analysis (Response spectrum analysis)
4. Dynamic Wind Analysis
In this study a 36 storey Moment resisting frame building is analyzed by Equivalent static
method, static wind analysis, Response Spectrum method as well as Dynamic Wind Analysis as
per Indian standard codes of practice IS 1893(Part 1):2002 and IS 875(Part 3):1987. The
performance of building is noted in terms of lateral displacement, storey drift, base shear and
time period for structure.

CHAPTER 5
ANALYTICAL MODELLING
5.1 INTRODUCTION
The majority of the older structures, which are far above the ground, average to low
RC.C frame, were not calculated to oppose main or reasonable EQs. The plan of such building is
more often than not complete by means of magnitude load with no bearing in mind the seismic
masses, which makes these structures susceptible throughout the occasion of Seismic.
Consequently it is necessary to think the seismic forces whilst designing such building to
alleviate the effects of main earthquake.
In the current study the gravity load analysis and lateral load analysis for the RC frame
building with the provision of introduction of outriggers as per seismic codes for zone is carried
out and an effort is made to study the effect of seismic loads on them and thus assess their
seismic vulnerability by performing analysis. The static and dynamic analysis is carried out using
ETABS software.
1.2 5.2 METHOD OF MODELLING

The ETABS software is utilized to create 3D model and to carry out the analysis. The software is
able to predict the behavior of space frames under static or dynamic loadings, taking into account
material in elasticity. The software accepts static loads as well as dynamic loads and has the
ability to perform static and dynamic analysis.

5.3 MODEL DESCRIPTION
Fig.5. 1: Plan layout
Models geometry
No of No. of bays Bay width No. of bays Bay width Bottom Storey
Storey in in X in in Y storey height
X direction direction Y direction direction height
36 5 4 7 5 3.5 3

The models that were selected for the study are listed as follows;
MODELS
 Model 1 – A Bare frame model
 Model 2 – Model with Concrete Core wall and concrete outriggers Extending from core
wall to the extreme edges of the building [forward and backward outriggers]
 Model 3 – Model with Concrete core wall and belt truss (concrete) throughout the story
 Model 4 – Model with Concrete Core wall and box section Steel outriggers Extending
from core wall to the extreme edges of the building [forward and backward outriggers]
 Model 5 – Model with Concrete core wall and belt truss (box section Steel) throughout
the story
 Model 6 – Model with Steel wall and box section Steel outriggers
 Model 7 – Model with Steel wall and belt truss (box section Steel) throughout the story

Fig.5. 2: Sectional Elevation of
building (Model 1)
Fig.5. 3: 3D view of building
(Model 1)

(Model 2)
building (Model 2)
Fig.5. 6: Perspective view of a storey

outrigger location (Model 2)

(Model 3)
building (Model 3)
Fig.5. 9: Perspective view of a storey showing

outrigger and Belt truss (Model 3)

Fig.5. 10: Sectional Elevation of Fig.5. 11: 3D view of building
building (Model 4) (Model 4)
Fig.5. 12: Perspective view of a storey showing

outrigger (steel) and concrete core wall (Model 4)

Fig.5. 15: Perspective view of a storey showing outrigger &

belt truss (steel) and concrete core wall (Model 5)

`
Fig.5. 18: Perspective view of a storey showing outrigger
(steel) and Brace core wall (Model 6)

building (Model 7) Fig.5. 19: 3D view of building
(Model 7)
Fig.5. 21: Perspective view of a storey showing outrigger

and belt truss (steel) and Brace core wall (Model 6)

5.3.1 BUILDING MODELS STUDIED
The plan layout of the RC SMRF building as shown in figure 5.1 The elevation and 3D view of
different building models are also shown above. In this study, the plan is same for all the models.
Each building model is of 36 storeys with storey height equal to 3.2m. The height of bottom
storey is kept as 4m for all the different building models. And seismic zone V is considered for
the study. While calculating the seismic weight, exactly half (50%) of the floor live load is
considered (IS 1893-2002, clause 7.3.1 and 7.3.2). The design data given for all the different
building models is given below.
5.3.2 DESIGN DATA

Material Properties:
Young’s modulus of (M40) concrete = 31622.78 Mpa
Young’s modulus of (M50) concrete = 35355.34 Mpa
Density of Reinforced Concrete = 25 KN/m3
Poisson’s ratio of concrete = 0.2
Modulus of elasticity of brick masonry = 3500x103 KN/m2
Density of brick masonry = 20 KN/m3
Poisson’s ratio of masonry = 0.15
Assumed dead load intensities
Floor finishes = 1.5 KN/m2
Live load = 3 KN/m2
Member Properties:
Thickness of RC slab = 125mm
Interior Column size = 500mmX1000mm (M50)
Column size = 500mmX 750mm (M50)
Beam size = 400mmX600mm (M40)
Thickness of brick masonry wall = 230mm
Thickness of RC shear wall = 400mm (M40)
Outriggers:
Concrete bracings = 300mmX1000mm (M40)
Steel bracings = ISA 150X150X14mm
Load Calculations:

Wall load on roof level = 1x0.15x20 = 3 KN/m
Wall load on all other levels = (3-0.6)x0.23x20 = 11 KN/m
Earthquake live load on slab as per clause 7.31 and 7.3.2 of IS 1893 (Part-1) - 2002 is calculated
as:
Roof (clause 7.3.2) =0
Floor (clause 7.3.1) = 0.5x3 =1.5 KN/m2
Seismic Data:
Zone factor (table 2 of IS 1893-2002) = 0.36 (Zone V)
Importance factor (table 6 of IS 1893-2002) = 1.5 (Important office building)
Response reduction factor (table 7 of IS 1893-2002) = 5 (SMRF)
Soil type (figure 2 of IS 1893-2002) = Type II (Medium soil)
1.3 5.4 DESIGN PROCEDURE

5.4.1. EQUIVALENT STATIC METHOD
The equivalent static method is considered to be the simplest method for analysis of multi-storied
building. In equivalent static method, when the structure is contacted with the static-force, it is
considered elastic. In this method the lateral-force are placed in two principal axis i.e. (x and y
axis) and the results of interior-force are mixed up by using the combination method. The
building which has to be analyzed by linear static method should have some criteria for its
geometrical-regularity and firmness.
1. The member which are used for resisting lateral- load (column and wall) should move from
down to up
2. The weight and lateral stiffness does not vary-suddenly from down to up.
3. For geometrical asymmetries or in layout plans the certain values should be maintained.
5.4.2. STATIC WIND ANALYSIS:
Design wind speed (vz): The basic wind speed (Vb) for any site shall be obtained
From Fig. 1(IS 8875-3-19887) and shall be modified to include the following effects to get
design wind velocity at any height (Vz) for the chosen structure:
a) Risk level;
b) Terrain roughness, height and size of structure and
c) Local topography.
It can be mathematically expressed as follows:

Vz= Vb. K1. K2. K3
5.4.3. RESPONSE SPECTRUM METHOD
This method is used to show the interaction between the structural system and acceleration of
ground for the several record of ground motion. In this method analysis of earthquake force is
done IS 1893(part1-2002)(Bureau of Indian Standards, 2002).
Following procedure is generally used for the spectrum-analysis:
1. Select the design spectrum.
2. Determine the mode shapes and periods of vibration to be included in the analysis.
3. Read the level of response from the spectrum for the period of each of the modes considered.
4. Calculate the participation of each mode corresponding to the single degree of freedom
response read from the curve.
5. Add the effect of modes to obtain combined maximum response.
6. Convert the combined maximum response into shears and moments for use in design of the
structures.
7. Analyze the building for the resulting moments and shears in the same manner as static loads.
5.4.4. GUST EFFECTIVENESS FACTOR METHOD
Design Wind Speed: Wind speed in the atmospheric boundary layer increases with height from
at ground level to maximum at a height called the gradient height. The building is assumed to be
in Hyderabad region, and basic wind speed as per IS 875(Part 3) 1987(Standards, 1987) will be
44m/s. The basic wind speed shall be modified to include risk level, terrain roughness, height of
the structure and local topography to get the design wind velocity Vz is given as:
Vz= Vb. K1. K2. K3
Where, VZ= Design wind speed in m/s at any height 'z' m
Vb = Basic wind speed for various zones
K1= Probability factor (risk coefficient)
K2 = Terrain roughness and height factor
K3= Topography factor
Risk coefficient (K1): suggested life period to be assumed and the corresponding K1 factor for
different class of structures as per IS: 875 (Part 3).
Terrain and height factor (K2): Selection of terrain categories shall be made with due regard to
the effect of obstruction, which constitute the ground surface.

Topography Factor (K3): The effect of topography will be significant at a site when the upwind
slope is greater than about 3°, and below that, the value of K3 may be taken to be equal to 1.0.
The value of K3 is confined in the range of 1.0 to 1.36 for slopes greater than 3°.
Design Wind Pressure: The design wind pressure at any height above mean level shall be
obtained by the following relationship between wind pressure and wind velocity:
PZ=0.6 VZ2
Where, PZ= Design wind pressure in N/m2 at height ‘z’ m
VZ = design wind velocity in m/s at height ‘z’ m
Gust Factor
A gust factor, defined as the ratio between a peak wind gust and mean wind speed over a
period of time can be used along with other statistics to examine the structure of the wind. Gust
factors are heavily dependent on upstream terrain conditions.
Constants and Parameters:
(1) Force coefficient for Clad Building
a=35m b=20m h=108.5m
ℎ 108.5
Ratio 𝑏= = 5.43
20
𝑎 35
= = 1.75
𝑏 20
As per IS 875 (Part 3) 1987 (Fig. 4, Page 39), Cf=1.4

Fig.5. 22: Force coefficient for Rectangular Clad building
(2) Peak Factor and Roughness Factor

gf = peak factor defined as the ratio of the expected peak value to the root mean value of a
fluctuate load.
r = roughness factor which is depends on the size of the structure in relation to the ground

roughness, therefore gf r =1.10(Fig-8, page-50) for Category 3 and building height 108.5m.
Fig.5. 23: Showing value of gfr and L(h)

Fig.5. 24: Background Factor, B
(3) Background Factor (B)
B = background factor indicating a measure of slowly varying component of fluctuating wind
load.
Cy.b
λ = Cz.h(From Fig. 9, Page 50)
Along X Axis: λ=0.221

Where, Cy = lateral correlation constant = 10 (Page 52)
Cz = longitudinal correlation constant = 12 (Page 52)
b = breadth of the structure normal to the wind stream.
h = height of the structure.
Along Y Axis: λ=0.221

L(h) = 1500, A measure of turbulence length scale (Fig. 8)
Cz.h
Ration, L(h) = 0.868
The Background Factor B is determined from the Fig.9 of IS 875 (Part 3)

(4) Size Reduction Factor (S)
Cz.fo.h
Reduced Frequency, Fo = Vz
1
Where, f o = natural frequency of the structure in Hz=𝑇

Vz = hourly mean speed at height ‘z’.
From Fig. 10 of IS 875 (Part 3), Size Reduction Factor along x and y direction is determined.
Fig.5. 25: Size reduction Factor S

(5) Gust energy factor (E)
Fo.L(h)
Gust energy factor ‘E’ in determined from Fig. 11 of IS 875 (Part 3) and depends on Vz
fo = natural frequency of the structure.

Vz = hourly mean speed at height ‘z’.
(6) Damping coefficient (β)
Damping coefficient of the structure- As per Table 34 of IS 875 Part 3, For R.C.C. β=0.016
(7) Constant (Ø)
Ø is to be accounted only for the buildings less than 75m high in terrain category 4 and for
buildings less than 25m high in terrain category 3, and is to be taken as zero in all other cases.
Therefore Ø =0.
(8) Gust Factor (G)
It is stated as peak load divided by mean load, and is given by
(9) Along Wind Load (F)
Along wind load on the structure on a strip area Ae, at any height z is given by
Fz = Cf Ae Pz G
Where,
Fz = along wind load on the structure at any height ‘z’ corresponding to strip Ae.
Cf = force coefficient for the building.
Ae = effective frontal area considered for the structure at height z.
Pz = design pressure at height z due to hourly mean wind obtained as 0.6 Vz2 (N/m2)

Table 5. 1 Details of wind load calculations as per IS: 875 (Part-3) 1987 with gust factors in
Longitudinal direction for Model 1
STOREY HEIGHT ELEVATION WIDTH VB(m/s) K2 VZ PZ(KN/m2) G Cf FX (KN)
(m) (m) in Y (m) (m/s)
36 3 108.5 20 50 1.1085 59.859 2.14985993 2.73 1.3 457.7912

35 3 105.5 20 50 1.1055 59.697 2.13823909 2.73 1.3 455.3166
34 3 102.5 20 50 1.1025 59.535 2.12664974 2.73 1.3 452.8488
33 3 99.5 20 50 1.0992 59.3568 2.11393782 2.73 1.3 450.1419
32 3 96.5 20 50 1.0944 59.0976 2.0955158 2.73 1.3 446.2191
31 3 93.5 20 50 1.0896 58.8384 2.07717439 2.73 1.3 442.3135
30 3 90.5 20 50 1.0848 58.5792 2.0589136 2.73 1.3 438.4251
29 3 87.5 20 50 1.08 58.32 2.04073344 2.73 1.3 434.5538
28 3 84.5 20 50 1.0752 58.0608 2.0226339 2.73 1.3 430.6997
27 3 81.5 20 50 1.0704 57.8016 2.00461498 2.73 1.3 426.8627
26 3 78.5 20 50 1.0656 57.5424 1.98667668 2.73 1.3 423.0429
25 3 75.5 20 50 1.0608 57.2832 1.968819 2.73 1.3 419.2403
24 3 72.5 20 50 1.056 57.024 1.95104195 2.73 1.3 415.4549
23 3 69.5 20 50 1.0512 56.7648 1.93334551 2.73 1.3 411.6866
22 3 66.5 20 50 1.0464 56.5056 1.9157297 2.73 1.3 407.9355
21 3 63.5 20 50 1.0416 56.2464 1.89819451 2.73 1.3 404.2015
20 3 60.5 20 50 1.0368 55.9872 1.88073994 2.73 1.3 400.4848
19 3 57.5 20 50 1.032 55.728 1.86336599 2.73 1.3 396.7852
18 3 54.5 20 50 1.0272 55.4688 1.84607266 2.73 1.3 393.1027
17 3 51.5 20 50 1.0224 55.2096 1.82885996 2.73 1.3 389.4374
16 3 48.5 20 50 1.0155 54.837 1.80425794 2.73 1.3 384.1987
15 3 45.5 20 50 1.0065 54.351 1.77241872 2.73 1.3 377.4188
14 3 42.5 20 50 0.9975 53.865 1.74086294 2.73 1.3 370.6994
13 3 39.5 20 50 0.9885 53.379 1.70959058 2.73 1.3 364.0402
12 3 36.5 20 50 0.9795 52.893 1.67860167 2.73 1.3 357.4414
11 3 33.5 20 50 0.9705 52.407 1.64789619 2.73 1.3 350.903
10 3 30.5 20 50 0.9615 51.921 1.61747414 2.73 1.3 344.4249
9 3 27.5 20 50 0.9475 51.165 1.57071434 2.73 1.3 334.4679
8 3 24.5 20 50 0.9325 50.355 1.52137562 2.73 1.3 323.9617
7 3 21.5 20 50 0.9175 49.545 1.47282422 2.73 1.3 313.6232
6 3 18.5 20 50 0.898 48.492 1.41088444 2.73 1.3 300.4337
5 3 15.5 20 50 0.874 47.196 1.33647745 2.73 1.3 284.5895
4 3 12.5 20 50 0.845 45.63 1.24925814 2.73 1.3 266.017
3 3 9.5 20 50 0.82 44.28 1.17643104 2.73 1.3 250.5092
2 3 6.5 20 50 0.82 44.28 1.17643104 2.73 1.3 250.5092
1 3.5 3.5 20 50 0.82 44.28 1.17643104 2.73 1.3 250.5092
Base 0 20 50 0.82 44.28 1.17643104 2.73 1.3 0
TOTAL 13620.29

Table 5. 2 Details of wind load calculations as per IS: 875 (Part-3) 1987 with gust factors
inTransverse direction for Model 1
STORE HEIGH ELEVATIO WIDTH VB(m/s) K2 VZ (m/s) PZ(KN/m G Cf FY (KN)
Y T (m) N (m) in Y (m) 2)
36 3 108.5 35 50 1.1085 59.859 2.14986 2.74 1.3 804.0691

35 3 105.5 35 50 1.1055 59.697 2.138239 2.74 1.3 799.7228
34 3 102.5 35 50 1.1025 59.535 2.12665 2.74 1.3 795.3883
33 3 99.5 35 50 1.0992 59.3568 2.113938 2.74 1.3 790.6339
32 3 96.5 35 50 1.0944 59.0976 2.095516 2.74 1.3 783.7439
31 3 93.5 35 50 1.0896 58.8384 2.077174 2.74 1.3 776.884
30 3 90.5 35 50 1.0848 58.5792 2.058914 2.74 1.3 770.0543
29 3 87.5 35 50 1.08 58.32 2.040733 2.74 1.3 763.2547
28 3 84.5 35 50 1.0752 58.0608 2.022634 2.74 1.3 756.4853
27 3 81.5 35 50 1.0704 57.8016 2.004615 2.74 1.3 749.746
26 3 78.5 35 50 1.0656 57.5424 1.986677 2.74 1.3 743.0369
25 3 75.5 35 50 1.0608 57.2832 1.968819 2.74 1.3 736.358
24 3 72.5 35 50 1.056 57.024 1.951042 2.74 1.3 729.7092
23 3 69.5 35 50 1.0512 56.7648 1.933346 2.74 1.3 723.0906
22 3 66.5 35 50 1.0464 56.5056 1.91573 2.74 1.3 716.5021
21 3 63.5 35 50 1.0416 56.2464 1.898195 2.74 1.3 709.9437
20 3 60.5 35 50 1.0368 55.9872 1.88074 2.74 1.3 703.4155
19 3 57.5 35 50 1.032 55.728 1.863366 2.74 1.3 696.9175
18 3 54.5 35 50 1.0272 55.4688 1.846073 2.74 1.3 690.4496
17 3 51.5 35 50 1.0224 55.2096 1.82886 2.74 1.3 684.0119
16 3 48.5 35 50 1.0155 54.837 1.804258 2.74 1.3 674.8105
15 3 45.5 35 50 1.0065 54.351 1.772419 2.74 1.3 662.9023
14 3 42.5 35 50 0.9975 53.865 1.740863 2.74 1.3 651.1001
13 3 39.5 35 50 0.9885 53.379 1.709591 2.74 1.3 639.404
12 3 36.5 35 50 0.9795 52.893 1.678602 2.74 1.3 627.8138
11 3 33.5 35 50 0.9705 52.407 1.647896 2.74 1.3 616.3297
10 3 30.5 35 50 0.9615 51.921 1.617474 2.74 1.3 604.9515
9 3 27.5 35 50 0.9475 51.165 1.570714 2.74 1.3 587.4629
8 3 24.5 35 50 0.9325 50.355 1.521376 2.74 1.3 569.0097
7 3 21.5 35 50 0.9175 49.545 1.472824 2.74 1.3 550.851
6 3 18.5 35 50 0.898 48.492 1.410884 2.74 1.3 527.6849
5 3 15.5 35 50 0.874 47.196 1.336477 2.74 1.3 499.8559
4 3 12.5 35 50 0.845 45.63 1.249258 2.74 1.3 467.235
3 3 9.5 35 50 0.82 44.28 1.176431 2.74 1.3 439.997
2 3 6.5 35 50 0.82 44.28 1.176431 2.74 1.3 439.997
1 3.5 3.5 35 50 0.82 44.28 1.176431 2.74 1.3 439.997
Base 0 35 50 0.82 44.28 1.176431 2.74 1.3 0
TOTAL 23922.82

Longitudinal direction for Model 2
STORY HEIGHT ELEVATION WIDTH in VB(m/s) K2 VZ (m/s) PZ(KN/m2) G Cf FX (KN)
(m) (m) Y (m)
36 3 108.5 20 50 1.1085 59.859 2.14986 2.63 1.3 441.0223

35 3 105.5 20 50 1.1055 59.697 2.138239 2.63 1.3 438.6384
34 3 102.5 20 50 1.1025 59.535 2.12665 2.63 1.3 436.2609
33 3 99.5 20 50 1.0992 59.3568 2.113938 2.63 1.3 433.6532
32 3 96.5 20 50 1.0944 59.0976 2.095516 2.63 1.3 429.8741
31 3 93.5 20 50 1.0896 58.8384 2.077174 2.63 1.3 426.1116
30 3 90.5 20 50 1.0848 58.5792 2.058914 2.63 1.3 422.3655
29 3 87.5 20 50 1.08 58.32 2.040733 2.63 1.3 418.6361
28 3 84.5 20 50 1.0752 58.0608 2.022634 2.63 1.3 414.9231
27 3 81.5 20 50 1.0704 57.8016 2.004615 2.63 1.3 411.2267
26 3 78.5 20 50 1.0656 57.5424 1.986677 2.63 1.3 407.5469
25 3 75.5 20 50 1.0608 57.2832 1.968819 2.63 1.3 403.8835
24 3 72.5 20 50 1.056 57.024 1.951042 2.63 1.3 400.2367
23 3 69.5 20 50 1.0512 56.7648 1.933346 2.63 1.3 396.6065
22 3 66.5 20 50 1.0464 56.5056 1.91573 2.63 1.3 392.9928
21 3 63.5 20 50 1.0416 56.2464 1.898195 2.63 1.3 389.3956
20 3 60.5 20 50 1.0368 55.9872 1.88074 2.63 1.3 385.815
19 3 57.5 20 50 1.032 55.728 1.863366 2.63 1.3 382.2509
18 3 54.5 20 50 1.0272 55.4688 1.846073 2.63 1.3 378.7033
17 3 51.5 20 50 1.0224 55.2096 1.82886 2.63 1.3 375.1723
16 3 48.5 20 50 1.0155 54.837 1.804258 2.63 1.3 370.1255
15 3 45.5 20 50 1.0065 54.351 1.772419 2.63 1.3 363.594
14 3 42.5 20 50 0.9975 53.865 1.740863 2.63 1.3 357.1206
13 3 39.5 20 50 0.9885 53.379 1.709591 2.63 1.3 350.7054
12 3 36.5 20 50 0.9795 52.893 1.678602 2.63 1.3 344.3483
11 3 33.5 20 50 0.9705 52.407 1.647896 2.63 1.3 338.0494
10 3 30.5 20 50 0.9615 51.921 1.617474 2.63 1.3 331.8086
9 3 27.5 20 50 0.9475 51.165 1.570714 2.63 1.3 322.2163
8 3 24.5 20 50 0.9325 50.355 1.521376 2.63 1.3 312.095
7 3 21.5 20 50 0.9175 49.545 1.472824 2.63 1.3 302.1352
6 3 18.5 20 50 0.898 48.492 1.410884 2.63 1.3 289.4288
5 3 15.5 20 50 0.874 47.196 1.336477 2.63 1.3 274.165
4 3 12.5 20 50 0.845 45.63 1.249258 2.63 1.3 256.2728
3 3 9.5 20 50 0.82 44.28 1.176431 2.63 1.3 241.3331
2 3 6.5 20 50 0.82 44.28 1.176431 2.63 1.3 241.3331
1 3.5 3.5 20 50 0.82 44.28 1.176431 2.63 1.3 281.5552
Base 0 20 50 0.82 44.28 1.176431 2.63 1.3 0
TOTAL 13161.6

Transverse direction for Model 2
STOREY HEIGHT ELEVATIO WIDTH in VB(m/s) K2 VZ (m/s) PZ(KN/m2) G Cf FY (KN)
(m) N (m) Y (m)
36 3 108.5 35 50 1.1085 59.859 2.1498599 2.41 1.3 707.2287

35 3 105.5 35 50 1.1055 59.697 2.1382391 2.41 1.3 703.4058
34 3 102.5 35 50 1.1025 59.535 2.1266497 2.41 1.3 699.5933
33 3 99.5 35 50 1.0992 59.3568 2.1139378 2.41 1.3 695.4116
32 3 96.5 35 50 1.0944 59.0976 2.0955158 2.41 1.3 689.3514
31 3 93.5 35 50 1.0896 58.8384 2.0771744 2.41 1.3 683.3177
30 3 90.5 35 50 1.0848 58.5792 2.0589136 2.41 1.3 677.3105
29 3 87.5 35 50 1.08 58.32 2.0407334 2.41 1.3 671.3299
28 3 84.5 35 50 1.0752 58.0608 2.0226339 2.41 1.3 665.3758
27 3 81.5 35 50 1.0704 57.8016 2.004615 2.41 1.3 659.4482
26 3 78.5 35 50 1.0656 57.5424 1.9866767 2.41 1.3 653.5471
25 3 75.5 35 50 1.0608 57.2832 1.968819 2.41 1.3 647.6725
24 3 72.5 35 50 1.056 57.024 1.9510419 2.41 1.3 641.8245
23 3 69.5 35 50 1.0512 56.7648 1.9333455 2.41 1.3 636.003
22 3 66.5 35 50 1.0464 56.5056 1.9157297 2.41 1.3 630.208
21 3 63.5 35 50 1.0416 56.2464 1.8981945 2.41 1.3 624.4396
20 3 60.5 35 50 1.0368 55.9872 1.8807399 2.41 1.3 618.6976
19 3 57.5 35 50 1.032 55.728 1.863366 2.41 1.3 612.9822
18 3 54.5 35 50 1.0272 55.4688 1.8460727 2.41 1.3 607.2933
17 3 51.5 35 50 1.0224 55.2096 1.82886 2.41 1.3 601.6309
16 3 48.5 35 50 1.0155 54.837 1.8042579 2.41 1.3 593.5377
15 3 45.5 35 50 1.0065 54.351 1.7724187 2.41 1.3 583.0637
14 3 42.5 35 50 0.9975 53.865 1.7408629 2.41 1.3 572.683
13 3 39.5 35 50 0.9885 53.379 1.7095906 2.41 1.3 562.3955
12 3 36.5 35 50 0.9795 52.893 1.6786017 2.41 1.3 552.2012
11 3 33.5 35 50 0.9705 52.407 1.6478962 2.41 1.3 542.1002
10 3 30.5 35 50 0.9615 51.921 1.6174741 2.41 1.3 532.0924
9 3 27.5 35 50 0.9475 51.165 1.5707143 2.41 1.3 516.71
8 3 24.5 35 50 0.9325 50.355 1.5213756 2.41 1.3 500.4793
7 3 21.5 35 50 0.9175 49.545 1.4728242 2.41 1.3 484.5076
6 3 18.5 35 50 0.898 48.492 1.4108844 2.41 1.3 464.1316
5 3 15.5 35 50 0.874 47.196 1.3364774 2.41 1.3 439.6543
4 3 12.5 35 50 0.845 45.63 1.2492581 2.41 1.3 410.9622
3 3 9.5 35 50 0.82 44.28 1.176431 2.41 1.3 387.0046
2 3 6.5 35 50 0.82 44.28 1.176431 2.41 1.3 387.0046
1 3.5 3.5 35 50 0.82 44.28 1.176431 2.41 1.3 451.5054
Base 0 35 50 0.82 44.28 1.176431 2.41 1.3 0
TOTAL 21106.1

longitudinal direction for Model 3.
STOREY HEIGH ELEVATI WIDTH VB(m/s K2 VZ (m/s) PZ(KN/m2) G Cf FX (KN)
T (m) ON (m) in Y (m) )
36 3 108.5 20 50 1.1085 59.859 2.14986 2.71 1.3 454.4374

35 3 105.5 20 50 1.1055 59.697 2.138239 2.71 1.3 451.981
34 3 102.5 20 50 1.1025 59.535 2.12665 2.71 1.3 449.5312
33 3 99.5 20 50 1.0992 59.3568 2.113938 2.71 1.3 446.8442
32 3 96.5 20 50 1.0944 59.0976 2.095516 2.71 1.3 442.9501
31 3 93.5 20 50 1.0896 58.8384 2.077174 2.71 1.3 439.0731
30 3 90.5 20 50 1.0848 58.5792 2.058914 2.71 1.3 435.2132
29 3 87.5 20 50 1.08 58.32 2.040733 2.71 1.3 431.3702
28 3 84.5 20 50 1.0752 58.0608 2.022634 2.71 1.3 427.5444
27 3 81.5 20 50 1.0704 57.8016 2.004615 2.71 1.3 423.7355
26 3 78.5 20 50 1.0656 57.5424 1.986677 2.71 1.3 419.9437
25 3 75.5 20 50 1.0608 57.2832 1.968819 2.71 1.3 416.169
24 3 72.5 20 50 1.056 57.024 1.951042 2.71 1.3 412.4112
23 3 69.5 20 50 1.0512 56.7648 1.933346 2.71 1.3 408.6706
22 3 66.5 20 50 1.0464 56.5056 1.91573 2.71 1.3 404.9469
21 3 63.5 20 50 1.0416 56.2464 1.898195 2.71 1.3 401.2404
20 3 60.5 20 50 1.0368 55.9872 1.88074 2.71 1.3 397.5508
19 3 57.5 20 50 1.032 55.728 1.863366 2.71 1.3 393.8783
18 3 54.5 20 50 1.0272 55.4688 1.846073 2.71 1.3 390.2228
17 3 51.5 20 50 1.0224 55.2096 1.82886 2.71 1.3 386.5844
16 3 48.5 20 50 1.0155 54.837 1.804258 2.71 1.3 381.384
15 3 45.5 20 50 1.0065 54.351 1.772419 2.71 1.3 374.6539
14 3 42.5 20 50 0.9975 53.865 1.740863 2.71 1.3 367.9836
13 3 39.5 20 50 0.9885 53.379 1.709591 2.71 1.3 361.3733
12 3 36.5 20 50 0.9795 52.893 1.678602 2.71 1.3 354.8228
11 3 33.5 20 50 0.9705 52.407 1.647896 2.71 1.3 348.3323
10 3 30.5 20 50 0.9615 51.921 1.617474 2.71 1.3 341.9017
9 3 27.5 20 50 0.9475 51.165 1.570714 2.71 1.3 332.0176
8 3 24.5 20 50 0.9325 50.355 1.521376 2.71 1.3 321.5884
7 3 21.5 20 50 0.9175 49.545 1.472824 2.71 1.3 311.3256
6 3 18.5 20 50 0.898 48.492 1.410884 2.71 1.3 298.2328
5 3 15.5 20 50 0.874 47.196 1.336477 2.71 1.3 282.5046
4 3 12.5 20 50 0.845 45.63 1.249258 2.71 1.3 264.0682
3 3 9.5 20 50 0.82 44.28 1.176431 2.71 1.3 248.674
2 3 6.5 20 50 0.82 44.28 1.176431 2.71 1.3 248.674
1 3.5 3.5 20 50 0.82 44.28 1.176431 2.71 1.3 290.1197
Base 0 20 50 0.82 44.28 1.176431 2.71 1.3 0
TOTAL 13561.95

transverse direction for Model 3
STORE HEIGH ELEVATIO WIDTH VB(m/s) K2 VZ (m/s) PZ(KN/m2) G Cf FY (KN)
Y T (m) N (m) in Y (m)
36 3 108.5 35 50 1.1085 59.859 2.14986 2.41 1.3 707.2287

35 3 105.5 35 50 1.1055 59.697 2.138239 2.41 1.3 703.4058
34 3 102.5 35 50 1.1025 59.535 2.12665 2.41 1.3 699.5933
33 3 99.5 35 50 1.0992 59.3568 2.113938 2.41 1.3 695.4116
32 3 96.5 35 50 1.0944 59.0976 2.095516 2.41 1.3 689.3514
31 3 93.5 35 50 1.0896 58.8384 2.077174 2.41 1.3 683.3177
30 3 90.5 35 50 1.0848 58.5792 2.058914 2.41 1.3 677.3105
29 3 87.5 35 50 1.08 58.32 2.040733 2.41 1.3 671.3299
28 3 84.5 35 50 1.0752 58.0608 2.022634 2.41 1.3 665.3758
27 3 81.5 35 50 1.0704 57.8016 2.004615 2.41 1.3 659.4482
26 3 78.5 35 50 1.0656 57.5424 1.986677 2.41 1.3 653.5471
25 3 75.5 35 50 1.0608 57.2832 1.968819 2.41 1.3 647.6725
24 3 72.5 35 50 1.056 57.024 1.951042 2.41 1.3 641.8245
23 3 69.5 35 50 1.0512 56.7648 1.933346 2.41 1.3 636.003
22 3 66.5 35 50 1.0464 56.5056 1.91573 2.41 1.3 630.208
21 3 63.5 35 50 1.0416 56.2464 1.898195 2.41 1.3 624.4396
20 3 60.5 35 50 1.0368 55.9872 1.88074 2.41 1.3 618.6976
19 3 57.5 35 50 1.032 55.728 1.863366 2.41 1.3 612.9822
18 3 54.5 35 50 1.0272 55.4688 1.846073 2.41 1.3 607.2933
17 3 51.5 35 50 1.0224 55.2096 1.82886 2.41 1.3 601.6309
16 3 48.5 35 50 1.0155 54.837 1.804258 2.41 1.3 593.5377
15 3 45.5 35 50 1.0065 54.351 1.772419 2.41 1.3 583.0637
14 3 42.5 35 50 0.9975 53.865 1.740863 2.41 1.3 572.683
13 3 39.5 35 50 0.9885 53.379 1.709591 2.41 1.3 562.3955
12 3 36.5 35 50 0.9795 52.893 1.678602 2.41 1.3 552.2012
11 3 33.5 35 50 0.9705 52.407 1.647896 2.41 1.3 542.1002
10 3 30.5 35 50 0.9615 51.921 1.617474 2.41 1.3 532.0924
9 3 27.5 35 50 0.9475 51.165 1.570714 2.41 1.3 516.71
8 3 24.5 35 50 0.9325 50.355 1.521376 2.41 1.3 500.4793
7 3 21.5 35 50 0.9175 49.545 1.472824 2.41 1.3 484.5076
6 3 18.5 35 50 0.898 48.492 1.410884 2.41 1.3 464.1316
5 3 15.5 35 50 0.874 47.196 1.336477 2.41 1.3 439.6543
4 3 12.5 35 50 0.845 45.63 1.249258 2.41 1.3 410.9622
3 3 9.5 35 50 0.82 44.28 1.176431 2.41 1.3 387.0046
2 3 6.5 35 50 0.82 44.28 1.176431 2.41 1.3 387.0046
1 3.5 3.5 35 50 0.82 44.28 1.176431 2.41 1.3 451.5054
Base 0 35 50 0.82 44.28 1.176431 2.41 1.3 0
TOTAL 21106.1

STOREY HEIGHT ELEVATION WIDTH in VB(m/s) K2 VZ (m/s) PZ(KN/m2) G Cf FX (KN)
(m) (m) Y (m)
36 3 108.5 20 50 1.1085 59.859 2.14986 2.63 1.3 441.0223

35 3 105.5 20 50 1.1055 59.697 2.138239 2.63 1.3 438.6384
34 3 102.5 20 50 1.1025 59.535 2.12665 2.63 1.3 436.2609
33 3 99.5 20 50 1.0992 59.3568 2.113938 2.63 1.3 433.6532
32 3 96.5 20 50 1.0944 59.0976 2.095516 2.63 1.3 429.8741
31 3 93.5 20 50 1.0896 58.8384 2.077174 2.63 1.3 426.1116
30 3 90.5 20 50 1.0848 58.5792 2.058914 2.63 1.3 422.3655
29 3 87.5 20 50 1.08 58.32 2.040733 2.63 1.3 418.6361
28 3 84.5 20 50 1.0752 58.0608 2.022634 2.63 1.3 414.9231
27 3 81.5 20 50 1.0704 57.8016 2.004615 2.63 1.3 411.2267
26 3 78.5 20 50 1.0656 57.5424 1.986677 2.63 1.3 407.5469
25 3 75.5 20 50 1.0608 57.2832 1.968819 2.63 1.3 403.8835
24 3 72.5 20 50 1.056 57.024 1.951042 2.63 1.3 400.2367
23 3 69.5 20 50 1.0512 56.7648 1.933346 2.63 1.3 396.6065
22 3 66.5 20 50 1.0464 56.5056 1.91573 2.63 1.3 392.9928
21 3 63.5 20 50 1.0416 56.2464 1.898195 2.63 1.3 389.3956
20 3 60.5 20 50 1.0368 55.9872 1.88074 2.63 1.3 385.815
19 3 57.5 20 50 1.032 55.728 1.863366 2.63 1.3 382.2509
18 3 54.5 20 50 1.0272 55.4688 1.846073 2.63 1.3 378.7033
17 3 51.5 20 50 1.0224 55.2096 1.82886 2.63 1.3 375.1723
16 3 48.5 20 50 1.0155 54.837 1.804258 2.63 1.3 370.1255
15 3 45.5 20 50 1.0065 54.351 1.772419 2.63 1.3 363.594
14 3 42.5 20 50 0.9975 53.865 1.740863 2.63 1.3 357.1206
13 3 39.5 20 50 0.9885 53.379 1.709591 2.63 1.3 350.7054
12 3 36.5 20 50 0.9795 52.893 1.678602 2.63 1.3 344.3483
11 3 33.5 20 50 0.9705 52.407 1.647896 2.63 1.3 338.0494
10 3 30.5 20 50 0.9615 51.921 1.617474 2.63 1.3 331.8086
9 3 27.5 20 50 0.9475 51.165 1.570714 2.63 1.3 322.2163
8 3 24.5 20 50 0.9325 50.355 1.521376 2.63 1.3 312.095
7 3 21.5 20 50 0.9175 49.545 1.472824 2.63 1.3 302.1352
6 3 18.5 20 50 0.898 48.492 1.410884 2.63 1.3 289.4288
5 3 15.5 20 50 0.874 47.196 1.336477 2.63 1.3 274.165
4 3 12.5 20 50 0.845 45.63 1.249258 2.63 1.3 256.2728
3 3 9.5 20 50 0.82 44.28 1.176431 2.63 1.3 241.3331
2 3 6.5 20 50 0.82 44.28 1.176431 2.63 1.3 241.3331
1 3.5 3.5 20 50 0.82 44.28 1.176431 2.63 1.3 281.5552
Base 0 20 50 0.82 44.28 1.176431 2.63 1.3 0
TOTAL 13161.6

transverse direction for Model 4
STOREY HEIGHT ELEVATION WIDTH in VB(m/s) K2 VZ (m/s) PZ(KN/m2) G Cf FY (KN)
(m) (m) Y (m)
36 3 108.5 35 50 1.1085 59.859 2.14986 2.53 1.3 742.4434

35 3 105.5 35 50 1.1055 59.697 2.138239 2.53 1.3 738.4302
34 3 102.5 35 50 1.1025 59.535 2.12665 2.53 1.3 734.4279
33 3 99.5 35 50 1.0992 59.3568 2.113938 2.53 1.3 730.0379
32 3 96.5 35 50 1.0944 59.0976 2.095516 2.53 1.3 723.6759
31 3 93.5 35 50 1.0896 58.8384 2.077174 2.53 1.3 717.3418
30 3 90.5 35 50 1.0848 58.5792 2.058914 2.53 1.3 711.0355
29 3 87.5 35 50 1.08 58.32 2.040733 2.53 1.3 704.7571
28 3 84.5 35 50 1.0752 58.0608 2.022634 2.53 1.3 698.5065
27 3 81.5 35 50 1.0704 57.8016 2.004615 2.53 1.3 692.2838
26 3 78.5 35 50 1.0656 57.5424 1.986677 2.53 1.3 686.0889
25 3 75.5 35 50 1.0608 57.2832 1.968819 2.53 1.3 679.9218
24 3 72.5 35 50 1.056 57.024 1.951042 2.53 1.3 673.7826
23 3 69.5 35 50 1.0512 56.7648 1.933346 2.53 1.3 667.6712
22 3 66.5 35 50 1.0464 56.5056 1.91573 2.53 1.3 661.5877
21 3 63.5 35 50 1.0416 56.2464 1.898195 2.53 1.3 655.532
20 3 60.5 35 50 1.0368 55.9872 1.88074 2.53 1.3 649.5041
19 3 57.5 35 50 1.032 55.728 1.863366 2.53 1.3 643.5041
18 3 54.5 35 50 1.0272 55.4688 1.846073 2.53 1.3 637.532
17 3 51.5 35 50 1.0224 55.2096 1.82886 2.53 1.3 631.5876
16 3 48.5 35 50 1.0155 54.837 1.804258 2.53 1.3 623.0915
15 3 45.5 35 50 1.0065 54.351 1.772419 2.53 1.3 612.0959
14 3 42.5 35 50 0.9975 53.865 1.740863 2.53 1.3 601.1983
13 3 39.5 35 50 0.9885 53.379 1.709591 2.53 1.3 590.3986
12 3 36.5 35 50 0.9795 52.893 1.678602 2.53 1.3 579.6967
11 3 33.5 35 50 0.9705 52.407 1.647896 2.53 1.3 569.0927
10 3 30.5 35 50 0.9615 51.921 1.617474 2.53 1.3 558.5866
9 3 27.5 35 50 0.9475 51.165 1.570714 2.53 1.3 542.4383
8 3 24.5 35 50 0.9325 50.355 1.521376 2.53 1.3 525.3995
7 3 21.5 35 50 0.9175 49.545 1.472824 2.53 1.3 508.6325
6 3 18.5 35 50 0.898 48.492 1.410884 2.53 1.3 487.2419
5 3 15.5 35 50 0.874 47.196 1.336477 2.53 1.3 461.5458
4 3 12.5 35 50 0.845 45.63 1.249258 2.53 1.3 431.4251
3 3 9.5 35 50 0.82 44.28 1.176431 2.53 1.3 406.2746
2 3 6.5 35 50 0.82 44.28 1.176431 2.53 1.3 406.2746
1 3.5 3.5 35 50 0.82 44.28 1.176431 2.53 1.3 473.987
Base 0 35 50 0.82 44.28 1.176431 2.53 1.3 0
TOTAL 22157.03

STOREY HEIGHT ELEVATION WIDTH in VB(m/s) K2 VZ (m/s) PZ(KN/m2) G Cf FX (KN)
(m) (m) Y (m)
36 3 108.5 20 50 1.1085 59.859 2.14986 2.63 1.3 441.0223

35 3 105.5 20 50 1.1055 59.697 2.138239 2.63 1.3 438.6384
34 3 102.5 20 50 1.1025 59.535 2.12665 2.63 1.3 436.2609
33 3 99.5 20 50 1.0992 59.3568 2.113938 2.63 1.3 433.6532
32 3 96.5 20 50 1.0944 59.0976 2.095516 2.63 1.3 429.8741
31 3 93.5 20 50 1.0896 58.8384 2.077174 2.63 1.3 426.1116
30 3 90.5 20 50 1.0848 58.5792 2.058914 2.63 1.3 422.3655
29 3 87.5 20 50 1.08 58.32 2.040733 2.63 1.3 418.6361
28 3 84.5 20 50 1.0752 58.0608 2.022634 2.63 1.3 414.9231
27 3 81.5 20 50 1.0704 57.8016 2.004615 2.63 1.3 411.2267
26 3 78.5 20 50 1.0656 57.5424 1.986677 2.63 1.3 407.5469
25 3 75.5 20 50 1.0608 57.2832 1.968819 2.63 1.3 403.8835
24 3 72.5 20 50 1.056 57.024 1.951042 2.63 1.3 400.2367
23 3 69.5 20 50 1.0512 56.7648 1.933346 2.63 1.3 396.6065
22 3 66.5 20 50 1.0464 56.5056 1.91573 2.63 1.3 392.9928
21 3 63.5 20 50 1.0416 56.2464 1.898195 2.63 1.3 389.3956
20 3 60.5 20 50 1.0368 55.9872 1.88074 2.63 1.3 385.815
19 3 57.5 20 50 1.032 55.728 1.863366 2.63 1.3 382.2509
18 3 54.5 20 50 1.0272 55.4688 1.846073 2.63 1.3 378.7033
17 3 51.5 20 50 1.0224 55.2096 1.82886 2.63 1.3 375.1723
16 3 48.5 20 50 1.0155 54.837 1.804258 2.63 1.3 370.1255
15 3 45.5 20 50 1.0065 54.351 1.772419 2.63 1.3 363.594
14 3 42.5 20 50 0.9975 53.865 1.740863 2.63 1.3 357.1206
13 3 39.5 20 50 0.9885 53.379 1.709591 2.63 1.3 350.7054
12 3 36.5 20 50 0.9795 52.893 1.678602 2.63 1.3 344.3483
11 3 33.5 20 50 0.9705 52.407 1.647896 2.63 1.3 338.0494
10 3 30.5 20 50 0.9615 51.921 1.617474 2.63 1.3 331.8086
9 3 27.5 20 50 0.9475 51.165 1.570714 2.63 1.3 322.2163
8 3 24.5 20 50 0.9325 50.355 1.521376 2.63 1.3 312.095
7 3 21.5 20 50 0.9175 49.545 1.472824 2.63 1.3 302.1352
6 3 18.5 20 50 0.898 48.492 1.410884 2.63 1.3 289.4288
5 3 15.5 20 50 0.874 47.196 1.336477 2.63 1.3 274.165
4 3 12.5 20 50 0.845 45.63 1.249258 2.63 1.3 256.2728
3 3 9.5 20 50 0.82 44.28 1.176431 2.63 1.3 241.3331
2 3 6.5 20 50 0.82 44.28 1.176431 2.63 1.3 241.3331
1 3.5 3.5 20 50 0.82 44.28 1.176431 2.63 1.3 281.5552
Base 0 20 50 0.82 44.28 1.176431 2.63 1.3 0
TOTAL 13161.6

in transverse direction for Model 5
STORY HEIGHT ELEVATION WIDTH in VB(m/s) K2 VZ (m/s) PZ(KN/m2) G Cf FY (KN)
(m) (m) Y (m)
36 3 108.5 35 50 1.1085 59.859 2.14986 2.51 1.3 736.5743

35 3 105.5 35 50 1.1055 59.697 2.138239 2.51 1.3 732.5928
34 3 102.5 35 50 1.1025 59.535 2.12665 2.51 1.3 728.6221
33 3 99.5 35 50 1.0992 59.3568 2.113938 2.51 1.3 724.2668
32 3 96.5 35 50 1.0944 59.0976 2.095516 2.51 1.3 717.9551
31 3 93.5 35 50 1.0896 58.8384 2.077174 2.51 1.3 711.6711
30 3 90.5 35 50 1.0848 58.5792 2.058914 2.51 1.3 705.4147
29 3 87.5 35 50 1.08 58.32 2.040733 2.51 1.3 699.1859
28 3 84.5 35 50 1.0752 58.0608 2.022634 2.51 1.3 692.9847
27 3 81.5 35 50 1.0704 57.8016 2.004615 2.51 1.3 686.8112
26 3 78.5 35 50 1.0656 57.5424 1.986677 2.51 1.3 680.6652
25 3 75.5 35 50 1.0608 57.2832 1.968819 2.51 1.3 674.5469
24 3 72.5 35 50 1.056 57.024 1.951042 2.51 1.3 668.4562
23 3 69.5 35 50 1.0512 56.7648 1.933346 2.51 1.3 662.3932
22 3 66.5 35 50 1.0464 56.5056 1.91573 2.51 1.3 656.3577
21 3 63.5 35 50 1.0416 56.2464 1.898195 2.51 1.3 650.3499
20 3 60.5 35 50 1.0368 55.9872 1.88074 2.51 1.3 644.3697
19 3 57.5 35 50 1.032 55.728 1.863366 2.51 1.3 638.4171
18 3 54.5 35 50 1.0272 55.4688 1.846073 2.51 1.3 632.4922
17 3 51.5 35 50 1.0224 55.2096 1.82886 2.51 1.3 626.5949
16 3 48.5 35 50 1.0155 54.837 1.804258 2.51 1.3 618.1658
15 3 45.5 35 50 1.0065 54.351 1.772419 2.51 1.3 607.2572
14 3 42.5 35 50 0.9975 53.865 1.740863 2.51 1.3 596.4458
13 3 39.5 35 50 0.9885 53.379 1.709591 2.51 1.3 585.7314
12 3 36.5 35 50 0.9795 52.893 1.678602 2.51 1.3 575.1141
11 3 33.5 35 50 0.9705 52.407 1.647896 2.51 1.3 564.594
10 3 30.5 35 50 0.9615 51.921 1.617474 2.51 1.3 554.1709
9 3 27.5 35 50 0.9475 51.165 1.570714 2.51 1.3 538.1503
8 3 24.5 35 50 0.9325 50.355 1.521376 2.51 1.3 521.2461
7 3 21.5 35 50 0.9175 49.545 1.472824 2.51 1.3 504.6117
6 3 18.5 35 50 0.898 48.492 1.410884 2.51 1.3 483.3902
5 3 15.5 35 50 0.874 47.196 1.336477 2.51 1.3 457.8972
4 3 12.5 35 50 0.845 45.63 1.249258 2.51 1.3 428.0146
3 3 9.5 35 50 0.82 44.28 1.176431 2.51 1.3 403.0629
2 3 6.5 35 50 0.82 44.28 1.176431 2.51 1.3 403.0629
1 3.5 3.5 35 50 0.82 44.28 1.176431 2.51 1.3 470.2401
Base 0 35 50 0.82 44.28 1.176431 2.51 1.3 0
TOTAL 21981.88

in longitudinal direction for Model 6.
STORY HEIGHT ELEVATION WIDTH in VB(m/s) K2 VZ (m/s) PZ(KN/m2) G Cf FX (KN)
(m) (m) Y (m)
36 3 108.5 20 50 1.1085 59.859 2.14986 2.72 1.3 456.1143

35 3 105.5 20 50 1.1055 59.697 2.138239 2.72 1.3 453.6488
34 3 102.5 20 50 1.1025 59.535 2.12665 2.72 1.3 451.19
33 3 99.5 20 50 1.0992 59.3568 2.113938 2.72 1.3 448.493
32 3 96.5 20 50 1.0944 59.0976 2.095516 2.72 1.3 444.5846
31 3 93.5 20 50 1.0896 58.8384 2.077174 2.72 1.3 440.6933
30 3 90.5 20 50 1.0848 58.5792 2.058914 2.72 1.3 436.8191
29 3 87.5 20 50 1.08 58.32 2.040733 2.72 1.3 432.962
28 3 84.5 20 50 1.0752 58.0608 2.022634 2.72 1.3 429.122
27 3 81.5 20 50 1.0704 57.8016 2.004615 2.72 1.3 425.2991
26 3 78.5 20 50 1.0656 57.5424 1.986677 2.72 1.3 421.4933
25 3 75.5 20 50 1.0608 57.2832 1.968819 2.72 1.3 417.7046
24 3 72.5 20 50 1.056 57.024 1.951042 2.72 1.3 413.9331
23 3 69.5 20 50 1.0512 56.7648 1.933346 2.72 1.3 410.1786
22 3 66.5 20 50 1.0464 56.5056 1.91573 2.72 1.3 406.4412
21 3 63.5 20 50 1.0416 56.2464 1.898195 2.72 1.3 402.7209
20 3 60.5 20 50 1.0368 55.9872 1.88074 2.72 1.3 399.0178
19 3 57.5 20 50 1.032 55.728 1.863366 2.72 1.3 395.3317
18 3 54.5 20 50 1.0272 55.4688 1.846073 2.72 1.3 391.6628
17 3 51.5 20 50 1.0224 55.2096 1.82886 2.72 1.3 388.0109
16 3 48.5 20 50 1.0155 54.837 1.804258 2.72 1.3 382.7914
15 3 45.5 20 50 1.0065 54.351 1.772419 2.72 1.3 376.0364
14 3 42.5 20 50 0.9975 53.865 1.740863 2.72 1.3 369.3415
13 3 39.5 20 50 0.9885 53.379 1.709591 2.72 1.3 362.7067
12 3 36.5 20 50 0.9795 52.893 1.678602 2.72 1.3 356.1321
11 3 33.5 20 50 0.9705 52.407 1.647896 2.72 1.3 349.6177
10 3 30.5 20 50 0.9615 51.921 1.617474 2.72 1.3 343.1633
9 3 27.5 20 50 0.9475 51.165 1.570714 2.72 1.3 333.2428
8 3 24.5 20 50 0.9325 50.355 1.521376 2.72 1.3 322.7751
7 3 21.5 20 50 0.9175 49.545 1.472824 2.72 1.3 312.4744
6 3 18.5 20 50 0.898 48.492 1.410884 2.72 1.3 299.3332
5 3 15.5 20 50 0.874 47.196 1.336477 2.72 1.3 283.5471
4 3 12.5 20 50 0.845 45.63 1.249258 2.72 1.3 265.0426
3 3 9.5 20 50 0.82 44.28 1.176431 2.72 1.3 249.5916
2 3 6.5 20 50 0.82 44.28 1.176431 2.72 1.3 249.5916
1 3.5 3.5 20 50 0.82 44.28 1.176431 2.72 1.3 291.1902
Base 0 20 50 0.82 44.28 1.176431 2.72 1.3 0
TOTAL 13612

in transverse direction for Model 6.
STORE HEIG ELEVATION WIDTH VB(m/s) K2 VZ (m/s) PZ(KN/m2 G Cf FY (KN)
Y HT (m) (m) in Y (m) )
36 3 108.5 35 50 1.1085 59.859 2.14986 2.52 1.3 739.5088

35 3 105.5 35 50 1.1055 59.697 2.138239 2.52 1.3 735.5115
34 3 102.5 35 50 1.1025 59.535 2.12665 2.52 1.3 731.525
33 3 99.5 35 50 1.0992 59.3568 2.113938 2.52 1.3 727.1523
32 3 96.5 35 50 1.0944 59.0976 2.095516 2.52 1.3 720.8155
31 3 93.5 35 50 1.0896 58.8384 2.077174 2.52 1.3 714.5064
30 3 90.5 35 50 1.0848 58.5792 2.058914 2.52 1.3 708.2251
29 3 87.5 35 50 1.08 58.32 2.040733 2.52 1.3 701.9715
28 3 84.5 35 50 1.0752 58.0608 2.022634 2.52 1.3 695.7456
27 3 81.5 35 50 1.0704 57.8016 2.004615 2.52 1.3 689.5475
26 3 78.5 35 50 1.0656 57.5424 1.986677 2.52 1.3 683.377
25 3 75.5 35 50 1.0608 57.2832 1.968819 2.52 1.3 677.2344
24 3 72.5 35 50 1.056 57.024 1.951042 2.52 1.3 671.1194
23 3 69.5 35 50 1.0512 56.7648 1.933346 2.52 1.3 665.0322
22 3 66.5 35 50 1.0464 56.5056 1.91573 2.52 1.3 658.9727
21 3 63.5 35 50 1.0416 56.2464 1.898195 2.52 1.3 652.9409
20 3 60.5 35 50 1.0368 55.9872 1.88074 2.52 1.3 646.9369
19 3 57.5 35 50 1.032 55.728 1.863366 2.52 1.3 640.9606
18 3 54.5 35 50 1.0272 55.4688 1.846073 2.52 1.3 635.0121
17 3 51.5 35 50 1.0224 55.2096 1.82886 2.52 1.3 629.0912
16 3 48.5 35 50 1.0155 54.837 1.804258 2.52 1.3 620.6286
15 3 45.5 35 50 1.0065 54.351 1.772419 2.52 1.3 609.6766
14 3 42.5 35 50 0.9975 53.865 1.740863 2.52 1.3 598.822
13 3 39.5 35 50 0.9885 53.379 1.709591 2.52 1.3 588.065
12 3 36.5 35 50 0.9795 52.893 1.678602 2.52 1.3 577.4054
11 3 33.5 35 50 0.9705 52.407 1.647896 2.52 1.3 566.8433
10 3 30.5 35 50 0.9615 51.921 1.617474 2.52 1.3 556.3788
9 3 27.5 35 50 0.9475 51.165 1.570714 2.52 1.3 540.2943
8 3 24.5 35 50 0.9325 50.355 1.521376 2.52 1.3 523.3228
7 3 21.5 35 50 0.9175 49.545 1.472824 2.52 1.3 506.6221
6 3 18.5 35 50 0.898 48.492 1.410884 2.52 1.3 485.316
5 3 15.5 35 50 0.874 47.196 1.336477 2.52 1.3 459.7215
4 3 12.5 35 50 0.845 45.63 1.249258 2.52 1.3 429.7198
3 3 9.5 35 50 0.82 44.28 1.176431 2.52 1.3 404.6687
2 3 6.5 35 50 0.82 44.28 1.176431 2.52 1.3 404.6687
1 3.5 3.5 35 50 0.82 44.28 1.176431 2.52 1.3 472.1135
Base 0 35 50 0.82 44.28 1.176431 2.52 1.3 0
TOTAL 22069.45

in longitudinal direction for Model 7.
STOREY HEIGHT ELEVATION WIDTH VB(m/s) K2 VZ PZ(KN/m2) G Cf FX (KN)
(m) (m) in Y (m) (m/s)
36 3 108.5 20 50 1.1085 59.859 2.14986 2.67 1.3 447.7298

35 3 105.5 20 50 1.1055 59.697 2.138239 2.67 1.3 445.3097
34 3 102.5 20 50 1.1025 59.535 2.12665 2.67 1.3 442.8961
33 3 99.5 20 50 1.0992 59.3568 2.113938 2.67 1.3 440.2487
32 3 96.5 20 50 1.0944 59.0976 2.095516 2.67 1.3 436.4121
31 3 93.5 20 50 1.0896 58.8384 2.077174 2.67 1.3 432.5923
30 3 90.5 20 50 1.0848 58.5792 2.058914 2.67 1.3 428.7893
29 3 87.5 20 50 1.08 58.32 2.040733 2.67 1.3 425.0031
28 3 84.5 20 50 1.0752 58.0608 2.022634 2.67 1.3 421.2337
27 3 81.5 20 50 1.0704 57.8016 2.004615 2.67 1.3 417.4811
26 3 78.5 20 50 1.0656 57.5424 1.986677 2.67 1.3 413.7453
25 3 75.5 20 50 1.0608 57.2832 1.968819 2.67 1.3 410.0262
24 3 72.5 20 50 1.056 57.024 1.951042 2.67 1.3 406.324
23 3 69.5 20 50 1.0512 56.7648 1.933346 2.67 1.3 402.6385
22 3 66.5 20 50 1.0464 56.5056 1.91573 2.67 1.3 398.9699
21 3 63.5 20 50 1.0416 56.2464 1.898195 2.67 1.3 395.318
20 3 60.5 20 50 1.0368 55.9872 1.88074 2.67 1.3 391.6829
19 3 57.5 20 50 1.032 55.728 1.863366 2.67 1.3 388.0646
18 3 54.5 20 50 1.0272 55.4688 1.846073 2.67 1.3 384.4631
17 3 51.5 20 50 1.0224 55.2096 1.82886 2.67 1.3 380.8784
16 3 48.5 20 50 1.0155 54.837 1.804258 2.67 1.3 375.7548
15 3 45.5 20 50 1.0065 54.351 1.772419 2.67 1.3 369.1239
14 3 42.5 20 50 0.9975 53.865 1.740863 2.67 1.3 362.5521
13 3 39.5 20 50 0.9885 53.379 1.709591 2.67 1.3 356.0393
12 3 36.5 20 50 0.9795 52.893 1.678602 2.67 1.3 349.5856
11 3 33.5 20 50 0.9705 52.407 1.647896 2.67 1.3 343.1909
10 3 30.5 20 50 0.9615 51.921 1.617474 2.67 1.3 336.8552
9 3 27.5 20 50 0.9475 51.165 1.570714 2.67 1.3 327.117
8 3 24.5 20 50 0.9325 50.355 1.521376 2.67 1.3 316.8417
7 3 21.5 20 50 0.9175 49.545 1.472824 2.67 1.3 306.7304
6 3 18.5 20 50 0.898 48.492 1.410884 2.67 1.3 293.8308
5 3 15.5 20 50 0.874 47.196 1.336477 2.67 1.3 278.3348
4 3 12.5 20 50 0.845 45.63 1.249258 2.67 1.3 260.1705
3 3 9.5 20 50 0.82 44.28 1.176431 2.67 1.3 245.0035
2 3 6.5 20 50 0.82 44.28 1.176431 2.67 1.3 245.0035
1 3.5 3.5 20 50 0.82 44.28 1.176431 2.67 1.3 285.8374
Base 0 20 50 0.82 44.28 1.176431 2.67 1.3 0
TOTAL 13361.78

in transverse direction for Model 7
STOREY HEIGHT ELEVATION WIDTH VB(m/s) K2 VZ PZ(KN/m2) G Cf FY (KN)
(m) (m) in Y (m) (m/s)
36 3 108.5 35 50 1.1085 59.859 2.14986 2.56 1.3 751.2471

35 3 105.5 35 50 1.1055 59.697 2.138239 2.56 1.3 747.1863
34 3 102.5 35 50 1.1025 59.535 2.12665 2.56 1.3 743.1365
33 3 99.5 35 50 1.0992 59.3568 2.113938 2.56 1.3 738.6944
32 3 96.5 35 50 1.0944 59.0976 2.095516 2.56 1.3 732.257
31 3 93.5 35 50 1.0896 58.8384 2.077174 2.56 1.3 725.8478
30 3 90.5 35 50 1.0848 58.5792 2.058914 2.56 1.3 719.4668
29 3 87.5 35 50 1.08 58.32 2.040733 2.56 1.3 713.1139
28 3 84.5 35 50 1.0752 58.0608 2.022634 2.56 1.3 706.7892
27 3 81.5 35 50 1.0704 57.8016 2.004615 2.56 1.3 700.4927
26 3 78.5 35 50 1.0656 57.5424 1.986677 2.56 1.3 694.2243
25 3 75.5 35 50 1.0608 57.2832 1.968819 2.56 1.3 687.9841
24 3 72.5 35 50 1.056 57.024 1.951042 2.56 1.3 681.7721
23 3 69.5 35 50 1.0512 56.7648 1.933346 2.56 1.3 675.5883
22 3 66.5 35 50 1.0464 56.5056 1.91573 2.56 1.3 669.4326
21 3 63.5 35 50 1.0416 56.2464 1.898195 2.56 1.3 663.3051
20 3 60.5 35 50 1.0368 55.9872 1.88074 2.56 1.3 657.2058
19 3 57.5 35 50 1.032 55.728 1.863366 2.56 1.3 651.1346
18 3 54.5 35 50 1.0272 55.4688 1.846073 2.56 1.3 645.0916
17 3 51.5 35 50 1.0224 55.2096 1.82886 2.56 1.3 639.0768
16 3 48.5 35 50 1.0155 54.837 1.804258 2.56 1.3 630.4799
15 3 45.5 35 50 1.0065 54.351 1.772419 2.56 1.3 619.354
14 3 42.5 35 50 0.9975 53.865 1.740863 2.56 1.3 608.3271
13 3 39.5 35 50 0.9885 53.379 1.709591 2.56 1.3 597.3993
12 3 36.5 35 50 0.9795 52.893 1.678602 2.56 1.3 586.5706
11 3 33.5 35 50 0.9705 52.407 1.647896 2.56 1.3 575.8408
10 3 30.5 35 50 0.9615 51.921 1.617474 2.56 1.3 565.2102
9 3 27.5 35 50 0.9475 51.165 1.570714 2.56 1.3 548.8704
8 3 24.5 35 50 0.9325 50.355 1.521376 2.56 1.3 531.6295
7 3 21.5 35 50 0.9175 49.545 1.472824 2.56 1.3 514.6637
6 3 18.5 35 50 0.898 48.492 1.410884 2.56 1.3 493.0195
5 3 15.5 35 50 0.874 47.196 1.336477 2.56 1.3 467.0187
4 3 12.5 35 50 0.845 45.63 1.249258 2.56 1.3 436.5408
3 3 9.5 35 50 0.82 44.28 1.176431 2.56 1.3 411.0921
2 3 6.5 35 50 0.82 44.28 1.176431 2.56 1.3 411.0921
1 3.5 3.5 35 50 0.82 44.28 1.176431 2.56 1.3 479.6074
Base 0 35 50 0.82 44.28 1.176431 2.56 1.3 0
TOTAL 22419.76

CHAPTER 6
ANALYSIS RESULTS AND DISCUSSIONS
1.4 6.1 GENERAL
In this chapter, the results of the selected buildings are presented and discussed in detail. The
results of base shear, lateral displacements, storey drifts, and natural period of vibration and
overall performance for the different building models are presented and compared.
1.5 6.2 PARAMETERS STUDIED

6.2.1 LATERAL DISPLACEMENT
The lateral displacement for Models Bare frame, concrete outrigger, concrete outrigger
and belt truss, steel outrigger, steel outrigger and belt truss both concrete and steel core wall for
seismic zone V in longitudinal and transverse direction by Response Spectrum and Dynamic
Wind Analysis, Equivalent Static Analysis and Static Wind analysis are found out. These results
are compared. The analysis values are tabulated in table 6.1 to 6.8.

Table 6. 1: Lateral displacements for Load case (G-X) for various models
STORY LOAD
MODEL 1 MODEL 2 MODEL 3 MODEL 4 MODEL 5 MODEL 6 MODEL 7
LEVEL CASE
36 Gust-X 191.137 136.529 133.58 146.678 142.335 170.623 163.526

35 Gust-X 187.883 132.977 130.21 143.037 138.844 167.405 160.452
34 Gust-X 184.672 129.655 126.969 139.597 135.53 164.235 157.185
33 Gust-X 181.085 126.262 123.626 136.149 132.153 160.713 153.747
32 Gust-X 177.299 122.783 120.197 132.605 128.678 157.019 150.15
31 Gust-X 173.337 119.222 116.676 128.966 125.108 153.177 146.409
30 Gust-X 169.204 115.583 113.078 125.233 121.45 149.195 142.531
29 Gust-X 164.902 111.878 109.421 121.41 117.711 145.077 138.535
28 Gust-X 160.437 108.103 105.726 117.492 113.9 140.828 134.459
27 Gust-X 155.812 104.272 102.014 113.489 110.038 136.55 130.446
26 Gust-X 151.032 100.848 98.813 109.63 106.357 132.625 126.806
25 Gust-X 146.103 96.849 94.939 105.425 102.299 128.09 122.539
24 Gust-X 141.028 92.718 90.881 101.103 98.096 123.321 117.955
23 Gust-X 135.816 88.488 86.709 96.681 93.779 118.427 113.198
22 Gust-X 130.472 84.174 82.441 92.168 89.368 113.42 108.317
21 Gust-X 125.003 79.81 78.123 87.581 84.891 108.313 103.339
20 Gust-X 119.416 75.434 73.807 82.943 80.377 103.121 98.304
19 Gust-X 113.719 71.054 69.535 78.26 75.852 97.855 93.286
18 Gust-X 107.92 66.716 65.372 73.556 71.365 92.719 88.546
17 Gust-X 102.026 63.337 62.261 69.28 67.342 88.444 84.666
16 Gust-X 96.039 58.93 58.026 64.483 62.763 83.165 79.781
15 Gust-X 89.97 54.41 53.602 59.618 58.061 77.607 74.472
14 Gust-X 83.836 49.842 49.096 54.72 53.296 71.989 69.017
13 Gust-X 77.65 45.248 44.545 49.805 48.502 66.331 63.497
12 Gust-X 71.424 40.688 40.027 44.91 43.729 60.657 57.961
11 Gust-X 65.169 36.23 35.621 40.074 39.026 54.992 52.469
10 Gust-X 58.897 31.896 31.395 35.32 34.44 49.353 47.125
9 Gust-X 52.606 27.765 27.457 30.686 30.04 44.022 42.282
8 Gust-X 46.323 25.142 25.061 26.804 26.414 40.062 38.772
7 Gust-X 40.067 21.211 21.295 22.413 22.224 34.828 34.007
6 Gust-X 33.841 17.313 17.464 18.152 18.073 29.346 28.798
5 Gust-X 27.664 13.548 13.715 14.097 14.061 23.929 23.529
4 Gust-X 21.564 9.975 10.128 10.312 10.271 18.619 18.324
3 Gust-X 15.61 6.729 6.85 6.915 6.829 13.505 13.3
2 Gust-X 9.857 3.97 4.053 4.054 3.96 8.75 8.62
1 Gust-X 4.67 1.897 1.944 1.921 1.893 4.57 4.5

Table 6. 2: Lateral displacements for Load case (G-Y) for various models
STORY LOAD
MODEL 1 MODEL 2 MODEL 3 MODEL 4 MODEL 5 MODEL 6 MODEL 7
LEVEL CASE
36 Gust-Y 309.28 143.13 137.147 170.836 169.157 225.239 223.078

35 Gust-Y 306.686 140.839 134.969 168.032 166.44 223.322 221.191
34 Gust-Y 303.902 138.43 132.689 165.19 163.719 221 218.669
33 Gust-Y 300.495 135.873 130.227 162.272 160.808 218.135 215.774
32 Gust-Y 296.65 133.155 127.618 159.183 157.729 214.935 212.552
31 Gust-Y 292.397 130.286 124.859 155.921 154.477 211.429 209.022
30 Gust-Y 287.741 127.279 121.966 152.487 151.056 207.629 205.193
29 Gust-Y 282.687 124.154 118.958 148.885 147.475 203.549 201.081
28 Gust-Y 277.24 120.92 115.859 145.115 143.737 199.232 196.766
27 Gust-Y 271.405 117.606 112.75 141.193 139.922 194.909 192.662
26 Gust-Y 265.187 115.174 110.526 137.621 136.591 191.812 189.969
25 Gust-Y 258.592 111.52 107.09 133.285 132.361 186.909 185.277
24 Gust-Y 251.626 107.579 103.296 128.689 127.796 181.425 179.774
23 Gust-Y 244.296 103.412 99.281 123.862 122.991 175.6 173.888
22 Gust-Y 236.609 99.053 95.078 118.824 117.973 169.483 167.704
21 Gust-Y 228.572 94.562 90.746 113.607 112.782 163.105 161.252
20 Gust-Y 220.193 90 86.347 108.245 107.458 156.498 154.574
19 Gust-Y 211.479 85.406 81.936 102.759 102.03 149.747 147.818
18 Gust-Y 202.439 80.857 77.687 97.198 96.658 143.285 141.749
17 Gust-Y 193.081 78.024 75.156 92.434 92.318 139.285 138.482
16 Gust-Y 183.406 73.222 70.659 86.566 86.632 132.348 131.928
15 Gust-Y 173.425 68.102 65.723 80.468 80.58 124.635 124.19
14 Gust-Y 163.158 62.775 60.578 74.206 74.341 116.603 116.058
13 Gust-Y 152.621 57.304 55.286 67.822 67.967 108.344 107.69
12 Gust-Y 141.825 51.79 49.948 61.38 61.528 99.908 99.141
11 Gust-Y 130.786 46.335 44.667 54.947 55.102 91.351 90.472
10 Gust-Y 119.515 41.018 39.537 48.578 48.752 82.794 81.896
9 Gust-Y 108.01 35.963 34.809 42.358 42.699 74.835 74.471
8 Gust-Y 96.302 33.277 32.448 37.384 38.186 70.389 71.028
7 Gust-Y 84.416 28.366 27.842 31.397 32.315 62.246 63.399
6 Gust-Y 72.353 23.339 22.957 25.501 26.336 53.277 54.381
5 Gust-Y 60.138 18.373 18.112 19.836 20.52 44.126 45.074
4 Gust-Y 47.799 13.6 13.436 14.523 14.996 34.944 35.72
3 Gust-Y 35.405 9.215 9.122 9.736 9.948 25.859 26.451
2 Gust-Y 23.003 5.446 5.403 5.686 5.75 17.036 17.435
1 Gust-Y 11.071 2.556 2.543 2.626 2.681 8.74 8.94

36
35
34
33
32
31
30
29
28
27
26
25 M-1
24
STOREY LEVEL
23
22 M-2
21
20
19 M-3
18
17
16 M-4
15
14
13 M-5
12
11 M-6
10
9
8 M-7
7
6
5
4
3
2
1
0 50 100 150 200 250
DISPLACEMENTS IN MM
Chart 6. 1: Comparison of Lateral Displacement for Load case (GUST-X) for Models.
36
35
34
33
32
31
30
29
28
27
26
25
24 M-1
STOREY LEVEL
23
22
21 M-2
20
19
18 M-3
17
16 M-4
15
14
13 M-5
12
11
10 M-6
9
8 M-7
7
6
5
4
3
2
1
0
0 50 100 150 200 250 300 350
DISPLACEMENTS IN MM
Chart 6. 2: Comparison of Lateral Displacement for Load case (GUST-Y) for Models.

Table 6. 3: Lateral Displacements for RSA along longitudinal Direction for Zone V
STORY LOAD CASE MODEL MODEL MODEL MODEL MODEL MODEL MODEL
LEVEL 1 2 3 4 5 6 7
36 RSA-X 76.993 70.624 69.944 72.012 71.071 73.823 73.067

35 RSA-X 75.521 68.79 68.197 70.239 69.328 72.27 71.545
34 RSA-X 73.964 66.863 66.28 68.381 67.484 70.619 69.9
33 RSA-X 72.319 64.89 64.304 66.481 65.591 68.884 68.156
32 RSA-X 70.588 62.875 62.279 64.536 63.65 67.073 66.331
31 RSA-X 68.778 60.821 60.213 62.547 61.664 65.194 64.434
30 RSA-X 66.897 58.737 58.121 60.518 59.642 63.254 62.478
29 RSA-X 64.952 56.635 56.018 58.456 57.592 61.262 60.478
28 RSA-X 62.951 54.516 53.915 56.364 55.523 59.225 58.459
27 RSA-X 60.9 52.397 51.838 54.25 53.45 57.202 56.499
26 RSA-X 58.804 50.538 50.078 52.242 51.505 55.379 54.754
25 RSA-X 56.67 48.362 47.938 50.068 49.373 53.276 52.707
24 RSA-X 54.501 46.143 45.727 47.862 47.191 51.089 50.53
23 RSA-X 52.303 43.901 43.482 45.634 44.978 48.875 48.301
22 RSA-X 50.078 41.646 41.219 43.389 42.748 46.641 46.045
21 RSA-X 47.83 39.397 38.966 41.136 40.512 44.394 43.779
20 RSA-X 45.562 37.172 36.748 38.885 38.287 42.14 41.518
19 RSA-X 43.278 34.972 34.579 36.638 36.082 39.883 39.296
18 RSA-X 40.978 32.82 32.496 34.402 33.918 37.71 37.225
17 RSA-X 38.665 31.162 30.953 32.39 31.996 35.923 35.549
16 RSA-X 36.34 28.996 28.844 30.142 29.816 33.726 33.446
15 RSA-X 34.005 26.784 26.654 27.874 27.59 31.432 31.178
14 RSA-X 31.661 24.555 24.427 25.598 25.339 29.128 28.862
13 RSA-X 29.31 22.318 22.185 23.318 23.081 26.819 26.531
12 RSA-X 26.952 20.1 19.965 21.049 20.833 24.513 24.203
11 RSA-X 24.588 17.933 17.805 18.807 18.618 22.214 21.9
10 RSA-X 22.218 15.823 15.731 16.598 16.455 19.928 19.666
9 RSA-X 19.844 13.814 13.806 14.441 14.378 17.778 17.656
8 RSA-X 17.464 12.588 12.682 12.645 12.678 16.204 16.224
7 RSA-X 15.081 10.643 10.801 10.577 10.675 14.066 14.217
6 RSA-X 12.698 8.691 8.864 8.557 8.674 11.807 11.998
5 RSA-X 10.321 6.787 6.945 6.623 6.727 9.562 9.737
4 RSA-X 7.959 4.965 5.093 4.807 4.876 7.347 7.489
3 RSA-X 5.633 3.291 3.384 3.165 3.182 5.19 5.294
2 RSA-X 3.392 1.845 1.901 1.762 1.749 3.139 3.204
1 RSA-X 1.376 0.714 0.738 0.677 0.676 1.308 1.335

Table 6. 4: Lateral Displacements for RSA along transverse direction for Zone V
STORY LOAD CASE MODEL MODEL MODEL MODEL MODEL MODEL MODEL
LEVEL 1 2 3 4 5 6 7
36 RSA-Y 72.304 56.336 56.098 60.49 59.189 64.895 64.079

35 RSA-Y 71.617 55.471 55.249 59.515 58.254 64.272 63.477
34 RSA-Y 70.806 54.366 54.147 58.373 57.144 63.425 62.64
33 RSA-Y 69.877 53.189 52.96 57.171 55.962 62.456 61.667
32 RSA-Y 68.831 51.945 51.706 55.908 54.717 61.38 60.584
31 RSA-Y 67.676 50.641 50.393 54.583 53.41 60.204 59.4
30 RSA-Y 66.417 49.288 49.033 53.201 52.047 58.938 58.125
29 RSA-Y 65.063 47.898 47.64 51.766 50.637 57.591 56.77
28 RSA-Y 63.619 46.481 46.223 50.283 49.182 56.183 55.365
27 RSA-Y 62.09 45.053 44.831 48.761 47.719 54.794 54.052
26 RSA-Y 60.48 44.024 43.854 47.396 46.463 53.82 53.211
25 RSA-Y 58.794 42.476 42.334 45.755 44.878 52.271 51.73
24 RSA-Y 57.035 40.831 40.683 44.037 43.19 50.558 50.01
23 RSA-Y 55.206 39.116 38.96 42.258 41.437 48.763 48.196
22 RSA-Y 53.31 37.349 37.186 40.427 39.632 46.904 46.317
21 RSA-Y 51.35 35.555 35.386 38.554 37.789 44.992 44.385
20 RSA-Y 49.33 33.759 33.588 36.652 35.922 43.038 42.412
19 RSA-Y 47.251 31.974 31.807 34.728 34.041 41.066 40.443
18 RSA-Y 45.117 30.228 30.118 32.797 32.199 39.201 38.698
17 RSA-Y 42.929 29.149 29.117 31.156 30.722 38.06 37.77
16 RSA-Y 40.691 27.32 27.335 29.144 28.796 36.084 35.905
15 RSA-Y 38.403 25.381 25.393 27.065 26.756 33.905 33.72
14 RSA-Y 36.068 23.372 23.375 24.938 24.661 31.654 31.441
13 RSA-Y 33.688 21.317 21.31 22.777 22.528 29.355 29.114
12 RSA-Y 31.264 19.251 19.235 20.601 20.379 27.021 26.752
11 RSA-Y 28.799 17.214 17.191 18.431 18.239 24.667 24.371
10 RSA-Y 26.29 15.231 15.209 16.284 16.125 22.323 22.028
9 RSA-Y 23.739 13.354 13.393 14.19 14.114 20.156 20.016
8 RSA-Y 21.145 12.37 12.501 12.519 12.621 18.959 19.099
7 RSA-Y 18.506 10.529 10.709 10.495 10.661 16.728 17.013
6 RSA-Y 15.825 8.639 8.805 8.498 8.661 14.266 14.541
5 RSA-Y 13.103 6.767 6.91 6.577 6.714 11.751 11.985
4 RSA-Y 10.348 4.965 5.08 4.774 4.864 9.225 9.416
3 RSA-Y 7.572 3.307 3.389 3.148 3.171 6.718 6.862
2 RSA-Y 4.806 1.873 1.922 1.764 1.755 4.264 4.358
1 RSA-Y 2.159 0.748 0.769 0.696 0.697 1.95 1.993

36
35
34
33
32
31
30
29
28
27
26
25
24 M-1
STOREY LEVEL
23
22
21 M-2
20
19
18 M-3
17
16 M-4
15
14
13 M-5
12
11
10 M-6
9
8 M-7
7
6
5
4
3
2
1
0
0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90
DISPLACEMENTS IN MM
Chart 6. 4: Lateral Displacement for Load case (RSA-X) for various Models.
36
35
34
33
32
31
30
29
28
27
26
25
24 M-1
STOREY LEVEL
23
22
21 M-2
20
19
18 M-3
17
16 M-4
15
14
13 M-5
12
11
10 M-6
9
8 M-7
7
6
5
4
3
2
1
0
0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80
DISPLACEMENTS IN MM
Chart 6. 3: Lateral Displacement for Load case (RSA-Y) for various Models

Table 6. 5: Lateral Displacements for wind along longitudinal direction
STORY LOAD MODEL MODEL MODEL MODEL MODEL MODEL MODEL
LEVEL CASE 1 2 3 4 5 6 7
36 WIND-X 116.85 86.84 82.419 93.29 90.566 104.503 101.832

35 WIND-X 114.895 84.805 80.557 91.246 88.583 102.54 99.929
34 WIND-X 112.841 82.714 78.577 89.123 86.51 100.494 97.92
33 WIND-X 110.68 80.573 76.533 86.951 84.382 98.356 95.807
32 WIND-X 108.408 78.381 74.435 84.721 82.195 96.126 93.596
31 WIND-X 106.024 76.136 72.28 82.43 79.947 93.803 91.291
30 WIND-X 103.53 73.839 70.078 80.076 77.64 91.388 88.896
29 WIND-X 100.927 71.497 67.838 77.66 75.278 88.885 86.421
28 WIND-X 98.219 69.107 65.567 75.181 72.866 86.296 83.893
27 WIND-X 95.407 66.683 63.285 72.644 70.418 83.687 81.399
26 WIND-X 92.494 64.501 61.306 70.192 68.08 81.283 79.129
25 WIND-X 89.484 61.956 58.915 67.518 65.498 78.503 76.464
24 WIND-X 86.381 59.324 56.408 64.765 62.821 75.575 73.596
23 WIND-X 83.187 56.626 53.822 61.945 60.067 72.566 70.616
22 WIND-X 79.906 53.871 51.176 59.062 57.25 69.482 67.554
21 WIND-X 76.544 51.08 48.498 56.129 54.387 66.332 64.426
20 WIND-X 73.104 48.28 45.821 53.16 51.497 63.125 61.258
19 WIND-X 69.592 45.474 43.164 50.158 48.598 59.869 58.098
18 WIND-X 66.012 42.696 40.577 47.14 45.719 56.691 55.113
17 WIND-X 62.37 40.528 38.641 44.394 43.137 54.047 52.669
16 WIND-X 58.671 37.696 36.002 41.311 40.194 50.776 49.587
15 WIND-X 54.921 34.791 33.244 38.183 37.171 47.333 46.238
14 WIND-X 51.128 31.852 30.428 35.03 34.104 43.849 42.792
13 WIND-X 47.299 28.893 27.584 31.863 31.016 40.337 39.302
12 WIND-X 43.441 25.955 24.758 28.706 27.938 36.812 35.798
11 WIND-X 39.561 23.08 22.004 25.585 24.904 33.288 32.318
10 WIND-X 35.668 20.283 19.357 22.514 21.942 29.779 28.932
9 WIND-X 31.77 17.623 16.897 19.524 19.104 26.474 25.877
8 WIND-X 27.877 15.939 15.406 17.021 16.768 24.029 23.675
7 WIND-X 23.998 13.401 13.049 14.184 14.061 20.78 20.665
6 WIND-X 20.144 10.885 10.652 11.432 11.381 17.381 17.376
5 WIND-X 16.328 8.458 8.305 8.816 8.793 14.031 14.056
4 WIND-X 12.566 6.158 6.063 6.378 6.351 10.752 10.783
3 WIND-X 8.885 4.065 4.012 4.186 4.13 7.581 7.609
2 WIND-X 5.352 2.27 2.246 2.324 2.263 4.582 4.602
1 WIND-X 2.175 0.875 0.869 0.891 0.873 1.909 1.918

Table 6. 6: Lateral Displacements for wind along transverse direction
LEVEL CASE 1 2 3 4 5 6 7
36 WIND-Y 61.892 32.512 31.145 38.823 36.926 48.889 47.592

35 WIND-Y 61.405 32.08 30.734 38.295 36.43 48.482 47.2
34 WIND-Y 60.838 31.546 30.23 37.682 35.851 47.956 46.687
33 WIND-Y 60.19 30.978 29.685 37.034 35.232 47.358 46.097
32 WIND-Y 59.456 30.374 29.104 36.349 34.576 46.691 45.437
31 WIND-Y 58.637 29.735 28.49 35.624 33.882 45.956 44.709
30 WIND-Y 57.735 29.064 27.845 34.858 33.149 45.153 43.913
29 WIND-Y 56.749 28.365 27.173 34.052 32.38 44.288 43.054
28 WIND-Y 55.681 27.639 26.476 33.206 31.574 43.367 42.149
27 WIND-Y 54.531 26.895 25.776 32.323 30.75 42.443 41.285
26 WIND-Y 53.302 26.343 25.272 31.517 30.027 41.777 40.716
25 WIND-Y 51.994 25.516 24.496 30.535 29.108 40.719 39.719
24 WIND-Y 50.608 24.621 23.636 29.493 28.114 39.533 38.547
23 WIND-Y 49.146 23.674 22.722 28.395 27.065 38.27 37.291
22 WIND-Y 47.608 22.682 21.765 27.248 25.968 36.941 35.968
21 WIND-Y 45.998 21.657 20.777 26.058 24.831 35.551 34.585
20 WIND-Y 44.315 20.615 19.773 24.832 23.663 34.11 33.151
19 WIND-Y 42.563 19.565 18.764 23.577 22.47 32.635 31.697
18 WIND-Y 40.742 18.525 17.79 22.303 21.289 31.222 30.392
17 WIND-Y 38.854 17.876 17.211 21.21 20.333 30.349 29.691
16 WIND-Y 36.901 16.773 16.18 19.863 19.08 28.828 28.277
15 WIND-Y 34.886 15.597 15.047 18.461 17.744 27.136 26.607
14 WIND-Y 32.811 14.372 13.863 17.02 16.366 25.373 24.849
13 WIND-Y 30.679 13.112 12.645 15.55 14.957 23.557 23.039
12 WIND-Y 28.492 11.842 11.415 14.065 13.532 21.701 21.187
11 WIND-Y 26.254 10.584 10.199 12.581 12.109 19.816 19.307
10 WIND-Y 23.967 9.358 9.015 11.111 10.701 17.931 17.447
9 WIND-Y 21.634 8.194 7.924 9.676 9.361 16.181 15.842
8 WIND-Y 19.259 7.577 7.383 8.529 8.362 15.21 15.106
7 WIND-Y 16.847 6.443 6.322 7.146 7.06 13.417 13.453
6 WIND-Y 14.4 5.283 5.195 5.784 5.735 11.443 11.499
5 WIND-Y 11.924 4.138 4.077 4.477 4.446 9.43 9.485
4 WIND-Y 9.425 3.038 2.999 3.252 3.223 7.413 7.461
3 WIND-Y 6.911 2.026 2.005 2.147 2.104 5.411 5.451
2 WIND-Y 4.401 1.15 1.14 1.206 1.168 3.447 3.475
1 WIND-Y 1.983 0.462 0.459 0.478 0.466 1.584 1.597

36
35
34
33
32
31
30
29
28
27
26
25
24 M-1
STOREY LEVEL
23
22
21 M-2
20
19
18 M-3
17
16 M-4
15
14
13 M-5
12
11
10 M-6
9
8 M-7
7
6
5
4
3
2
1
0
0 20 40 60 80 100 120 140
DISPLACEMENTS IN MM
Chart 6. 6: Lateral Displacement for Load case (WIND-X) for various Models
36
35
34
33
32
31
30
29
28
27
26
25
24 M-1
STOREY LEVEL
23
22
21 M-2
20
19
18 M-3
17
16 M-4
15
14
13 M-5
12
11
10 M-6
9
8
7 M-7
6
5
4
3
2
1
0
0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70
DISPLACEMENTS IN MM
Chart
Table 6. 6.
7: 5: LateralDisplacements
Lateral Displacement for
for Load case (WIND-Y)
EQ along fordirection
longitudinal various Models

LEVEL CASE 1 2 3 4 5 6 7
36 EQ-X 116.183 109.41 108.023 111.367 109.798 111.505 110.227

35 EQ-X 113.924 106.588 105.344 108.632 107.113 109.143 107.916
34 EQ-X 111.519 103.61 102.388 105.752 104.259 106.611 105.398
33 EQ-X 108.958 100.544 99.327 102.791 101.314 103.93 102.708
32 EQ-X 106.244 97.393 96.17 99.743 98.276 101.114 99.872
31 EQ-X 103.385 94.159 92.926 96.605 95.148 98.169 96.905
30 EQ-X 100.392 90.854 89.614 93.381 91.938 95.107 93.82
29 EQ-X 97.275 87.494 86.259 90.08 88.66 91.939 90.641
28 EQ-X 94.044 84.082 82.879 86.706 85.327 88.675 87.41
27 EQ-X 90.71 80.645 79.52 83.271 81.966 85.416 84.261
26 EQ-X 87.284 77.648 76.694 80.003 78.806 82.493 81.473
25 EQ-X 83.776 74.083 73.2 76.431 75.309 79.076 78.161
24 EQ-X 80.198 70.421 69.565 72.784 71.709 75.497 74.609
23 EQ-X 76.558 66.699 65.847 69.083 68.038 71.859 70.953
22 EQ-X 72.87 62.932 62.078 65.338 64.319 68.174 67.239
21 EQ-X 69.141 59.156 58.303 61.57 60.581 64.459 63.494
20 EQ-X 65.384 55.41 54.572 57.802 56.853 60.73 59.753
19 EQ-X 61.607 51.706 50.919 54.044 53.162 56.999 56.075
18 EQ-X 57.822 48.092 47.421 50.32 49.55 53.412 52.65
17 EQ-X 54.039 45.299 44.82 46.978 46.354 50.472 49.891
16 EQ-X 50.266 41.725 41.349 43.291 42.777 46.912 46.487
15 EQ-X 46.515 38.123 37.793 39.612 39.166 43.23 42.855
14 EQ-X 42.793 34.538 34.224 35.967 35.563 39.575 39.186
13 EQ-X 39.111 30.988 30.676 32.367 31.997 35.96 35.541
12 EQ-X 35.478 27.518 27.209 28.841 28.501 32.402 31.953
11 EQ-X 31.903 24.177 23.883 25.415 25.114 28.918 28.459
10 EQ-X 28.394 20.982 20.738 22.104 21.866 25.521 25.124
9 EQ-X 24.961 17.998 17.868 18.941 18.808 22.374 22.155
8 EQ-X 21.611 16.051 16.07 16.311 16.307 20.048 20.015
7 EQ-X 18.353 13.318 13.426 13.427 13.508 17.105 17.241
6 EQ-X 15.195 10.677 10.816 10.688 10.8 14.108 14.299
5 EQ-X 12.146 8.187 8.321 8.137 8.238 11.226 11.404
4 EQ-X 9.217 5.878 5.991 5.807 5.868 8.478 8.621
3 EQ-X 6.425 3.822 3.905 3.755 3.755 5.888 5.992
2 EQ-X 3.815 2.096 2.147 2.048 2.018 3.503 3.568
1 EQ-X 1.528 0.789 0.811 0.766 0.76 1.435 1.462

Table 6. 8: Lateral Displacements for EQ along transverse direction
LEVEL CASE 1 2 3 4 5 6 7
36 EQ-Y 105.271 84.376 83.695 91.185 88.8 94.613 93.341

35 EQ-Y 104.193 83.066 82.414 89.684 87.366 93.665 92.429
34 EQ-Y 102.895 81.363 80.72 87.905 85.645 92.327 91.108
33 EQ-Y 101.386 79.533 78.88 86.02 83.797 90.774 89.548
32 EQ-Y 99.67 77.583 76.918 84.022 81.834 89.031 87.792
31 EQ-Y 97.759 75.521 74.845 81.91 79.757 87.112 85.857
30 EQ-Y 95.666 73.363 72.68 79.689 77.576 85.03 83.758
29 EQ-Y 93.403 71.13 70.444 77.368 75.3 82.804 81.513
28 EQ-Y 90.981 68.837 68.156 74.953 72.939 80.466 79.177
27 EQ-Y 88.413 66.518 65.9 72.462 70.554 78.158 76.996
26 EQ-Y 85.709 64.871 64.344 70.233 68.514 76.573 75.641
25 EQ-Y 82.881 62.353 61.883 67.534 65.923 74.02 73.209
24 EQ-Y 79.94 59.665 59.196 64.705 63.154 71.192 70.374
23 EQ-Y 76.897 56.855 56.383 61.771 60.275 68.233 67.385
22 EQ-Y 73.762 53.953 53.477 58.75 57.309 65.178 64.297
21 EQ-Y 70.546 51.003 50.526 55.667 54.284 62.049 61.134
20 EQ-Y 67.258 48.052 47.578 52.546 51.229 58.867 57.92
19 EQ-Y 63.909 45.129 44.667 49.407 48.166 55.678 54.729
18 EQ-Y 60.506 42.293 41.925 46.28 45.188 52.685 51.917
17 EQ-Y 57.06 40.547 40.308 43.648 42.824 50.873 50.439
16 EQ-Y 53.58 37.667 37.514 40.473 39.795 47.81 47.554
15 EQ-Y 50.073 34.66 34.516 37.237 36.634 44.479 44.217
14 EQ-Y 46.549 31.589 31.447 33.975 33.436 41.084 40.784
13 EQ-Y 43.014 28.493 28.349 30.71 30.227 37.669 37.329
12 EQ-Y 39.476 25.426 25.28 27.476 27.045 34.258 33.877
11 EQ-Y 35.944 22.445 22.3 24.304 23.926 30.875 30.455
10 EQ-Y 32.422 19.593 19.455 21.221 20.901 27.567 27.143
9 EQ-Y 28.919 16.939 16.889 18.271 18.073 24.558 24.33
8 EQ-Y 25.44 15.52 15.595 15.945 15.991 22.902 23.039
7 EQ-Y 21.992 13.05 13.201 13.214 13.359 19.98 20.309
6 EQ-Y 18.58 10.581 10.728 10.579 10.734 16.842 17.161
5 EQ-Y 15.209 8.194 8.325 8.095 8.229 13.717 13.988
4 EQ-Y 11.886 5.945 6.053 5.81 5.894 10.655 10.875
3 EQ-Y 8.618 3.914 3.993 3.785 3.793 7.684 7.85
2 EQ-Y 5.428 2.188 2.237 2.093 2.068 4.836 4.944
1 EQ-Y 2.423 0.859 0.881 0.811 0.808 2.195 2.245

36
35
34
33
32
31
30
29
28
27
26
25
24 M-1
STOREY LEVEL
23
22
21 M-2
20
19
18 M-3
17
16 M-4
15
14
13 M-5
12
11
10 M-6
9
8
7 M-7
6
5
4
3
2
1
0
0 20 40 60 80 100 120 140
DISPLACEMENTS IN MM
Chart 6. 7: Lateral Displacement for Load case (EQ-X) for various Models
36
35
34
33
32
31
30
29
28
27
26
25
24 M-1
STOREY LEVEL
23
22
21 M-2
20
19
18 M-3
17
16 M-4
15
14
13 M-5
12
11
10 M-6
9
8
7 M-7
6
5
4
3
2
1
0
0 20 40 60 80 100 120
DISPLACEMENTS IN MM
Chart 6. 8: Lateral Displacement for Load case (EQ-Y) for various Models

From the Table 6.1 to 6.8 the following observations are noted:-
 The lateral displacement is maximum at the roof level and minimum at the base.
Response Spectrum and Dynamic wind analysis
 The Concrete Outrigger with belt truss Model shows minimum lateral displacement than
the Steel Outrigger with belt truss Model.
 By providing concrete outriggers with concrete core wall (M-1), the lateral displacement
of building is reduced up to 8.27% & 22.08% in longitudinal and in transverse direction
respectively in case of RSA and reduced up to 28.57% & 53.72% in longitudinal and in
transverse direction respectively in case of DWA.
 By providing concrete outriggers and belt truss with concrete core wall (M-2), the lateral
displacement of building is reduced up to 8.27% & 22.08% in longitudinal and in
transverse direction respectively in case of RSA and reduced up to 9.15% & 22.41% in
longitudinal and in transverse direction respectively in case of DWA.
 Using Box section steel outrigger with concrete core wall (M-3), it shows that the lateral
displacement of the building is reduced up to 6.46%&16.33% in longitudinal and in
transverse direction respectively in case of RSA and reduced up to 23.26%&44.76% in
longitudinal and in transverse direction respectively in case of DWA.
 By providing Box section steel outrigger and belt truss with concrete core wall(M-4), it
shows that the lateral displacement of the building is reduced up to 7.69%&18.13% in
longitudinal and in transverse direction respectively in case of RSA and reduced up to
25.53%&45.30% in longitudinal and in transverse direction respectively in case of DWA.
 Using Box section steel outrigger with Steel core wall (M-5), it shows that the lateral
transverse direction respectively in case of RSA and reduced up to 10.73%&27.17% in
longitudinal and in transverse direction respectively in case of DWA
 By providing Box section steel outrigger and belt truss with steel core wall, it shows that
the lateral displacement of the building is reduced up to 5.09%&11.37% in longitudinal
and in transverse direction respectively in case of RSA and reduced up to
14.44%&27.87% in longitudinal and in transverse direction respectively in case of DWA
Static wind and earthquake
 The Concrete Outrigger with belt truss Model shows minimum lateral displacement than
 By providing concrete outriggers with concrete core wall (M-1), the lateral displacement
of building is reduced up to 5.829% & 19.84% in longitudinal and in transverse direction
respectively in Case of Static Earthquake and reduced up to 25.68% & 47.46% in
longitudinal and in transverse direction respectively in case of Static Wind.
 By providing concrete outriggers and belt truss with concrete core wall (M-2), the lateral
displacement of building is reduced up to 7.02% & 20.50% in longitudinal and in
transverse direction respectively in Case of Static Earthquake and reduced up to 29.46%
& 49.67% in longitudinal and in transverse direction respectively in case of Static Wind.
 Using Box section steel outrigger with concrete core wall (M-3), it shows that the lateral
transverse direction respectively in case of Static Earthquake and reduced up to
20.16%&37.27% in longitudinal and in transverse direction respectively in case of Static
Wind.

 By providing Box section steel outrigger and belt truss with concrete core wall (M-4), it
longitudinal and in transverse direction respectively in case of Static Earthquake and
reduced up to 22.50%&40.33% in longitudinal and in transverse direction respectively in
case of Static Wind.
 Using Box section steel outrigger with Steel core wall (M-5), it shows that the lateral
transverse direction respectively in case of Static Earthquake and reduced up to
10.56%&21% in longitudinal and in transverse direction respectively in case of Static
Wind.
 By providing Box section steel outrigger and belt truss with steel core wall (M-6), it
longitudinal and in transverse direction respectively case of Static Earthquake
 By providing Box section steel outrigger and belt truss with steel core wall, it shows that
the lateral displacement of the building is reduced up to 12.85%&23.10% in longitudinal
and in transverse direction respectively in case of Static Wind.

Table 6. 9: Maximum Displacement by Response Spectrum Analysis and Dynamic Wind
Analysis along Longitudinal and Transverse direction
MODEL Model description
Response Spectrum Dynamic Wind
Analysis Analysis
RSA-X RSA-Y GUST-X GUST-Y
1 Bare Frame 76.993 72.304 191.137 309.28
2 Concrete Core Wall & Outrigger 70.624 56.336 136.529 143.13
Concrete Core Wall, Outrigger
3 and Belt truss 69.944 56.098 133.58 137.147
Concrete Core Wall,
4 Outrigger(steel) 72.012 60.49 146.678 170.836
Concrete Core Wall,
Outrigger(steel) and Belt
5 truss(steel) 71.071 59.189 142.335 169.157
6 Steel Core Wall, Outrigger(steel) 73.823 64.895 170.623 225.239
Steel Core Wall, Outrigger(steel)
7 and Belt truss(steel) 73.067 64.079 163.526 223.078
350
300
TOP STOREY DISPLACEMENT
250
200
RSA-X
RSA-Y
150
GUST-X
100 GUST-Y
50
0
0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7
MODEL NO.
Chart 6. 9: Comparison of Top Storey Displacement by Response Spectrum Analysis

and Dynamic Wind Analysis along Longitudinal and Transverse direction.

350
300
STOREY DISPLACEMENTS
250
M-1
200 M-2
M-3
150 M-4
M-5
100
M-6
50 M-7
0
RSA-X RSA-Y GUST-X GUSTY
ANALYSIS
Chart 6. 10: Comparison of maximum storey displacement for all Models
6.2.2 STOREY DRIFT

Drift is generally defined as lateral displacement of one story relative to story below. The
permissible storey drift according to IS 1893(Part 1):2002 is limited to 0.004 times the storey
height, so that minimum damage would take place during earthquake and pose less psychological
fear in the minds of people. The maximum storey drifts for various building models along
longitudinal and transverse direction obtained from response spectrum and dynamic wind
analysis from ETABS are shown in tables below.
The Storey drift for Models with and without Outriggers, different types of outriggers and
steel outriggers for seismic zone V in longitudinal and transverse direction are found out. The
analysis value are tabulated in table 6.7 to 6.12

Table 6. 10: Story drift for Load case (G-X) for various models
STORY LOAD MODEL MODEL MODEL MODEL MODEL 5 MODEL MODEL
LEVEL CASE 1 2 3 4 6 7
36 Gust-X 0.001113 0.001092 0.001036 0.00111 0.001077 0.001097 0.00102

35 Gust-X 0.001143 0.001112 0.001099 0.001128 0.001102 0.001129 0.001089
34 Gust-X 0.001198 0.001132 0.001119 0.001151 0.001132 0.001176 0.001142
33 Gust-X 0.001256 0.001158 0.001146 0.001181 0.00116 0.001225 0.001192
32 Gust-X 0.001313 0.001185 0.001172 0.001211 0.001189 0.001273 0.00124
31 Gust-X 0.00137 0.001211 0.001199 0.001242 0.00122 0.00132 0.001285
30 Gust-X 0.001426 0.001233 0.001229 0.001272 0.001255 0.001365 0.001327
29 Gust-X 0.001481 0.001258 0.001262 0.001305 0.001297 0.001409 0.00136
28 Gust-X 0.001534 0.001291 0.001262 0.001342 0.001309 0.001423 0.00135
27 Gust-X 0.001586 0.001253 0.001125 0.001338 0.001252 0.001411 0.001241
26 Gust-X 0.001636 0.001351 0.001324 0.001411 0.001373 0.001511 0.001434
25 Gust-X 0.001684 0.001377 0.001379 0.00144 0.001426 0.001582 0.001529
24 Gust-X 0.00173 0.001408 0.001401 0.001472 0.001446 0.001624 0.00158
23 Gust-X 0.001774 0.001436 0.001422 0.001502 0.001468 0.001662 0.00162
22 Gust-X 0.001816 0.001453 0.001438 0.001527 0.001492 0.001695 0.001652
21 Gust-X 0.001855 0.001458 0.001457 0.001544 0.001521 0.001723 0.001675
20 Gust-X 0.001892 0.001463 0.001478 0.001561 0.001556 0.001748 0.001681
19 Gust-X 0.001926 0.001473 0.001425 0.001585 0.001532 0.001714 0.001606
18 Gust-X 0.001957 0.001347 0.001142 0.001527 0.001389 0.001629 0.001353
17 Gust-X 0.001986 0.001513 0.001465 0.001619 0.001555 0.001765 0.001647
16 Gust-X 0.002011 0.001508 0.001516 0.00162 0.00161 0.00184 0.00177
15 Gust-X 0.002032 0.00152 0.001517 0.001629 0.0016 0.001859 0.001809
14 Gust-X 0.002049 0.001528 0.001514 0.001635 0.001594 0.001873 0.001828
13 Gust-X 0.002063 0.001517 0.001503 0.001628 0.001588 0.001879 0.001833
12 Gust-X 0.002072 0.001484 0.00149 0.001609 0.001585 0.001875 0.001824
11 Gust-X 0.002078 0.001448 0.001476 0.001584 0.001588 0.001866 0.001789
10 Gust-X 0.002079 0.001412 0.001359 0.001562 0.001506 0.001771 0.001638
9 Gust-X 0.002075 0.001178 0.000934 0.001425 0.00127 0.0016 0.001244
8 Gust-X 0.002065 0.001378 0.001325 0.00149 0.001421 0.001749 0.001599
7 Gust-X 0.00205 0.001299 0.001317 0.001416 0.001431 0.001802 0.001727
6 Gust-X 0.002029 0.001248 0.001257 0.001344 0.001342 0.001775 0.001729
5 Gust-X 0.001999 0.001181 0.001185 0.001251 0.001253 0.001736 0.001702
4 Gust-X 0.001954 0.001074 0.001084 0.001124 0.00114 0.001678 0.001648
3 Gust-X 0.001875 0.000921 0.000934 0.000955 0.000959 0.001589 0.001564
2 Gust-X 0.0017 0.000736 0.000747 0.000758 0.000747 0.001426 0.001405
1 Gust-X 0.001003 0.000403 0.00041 0.000412 0.000403 0.000882 0.00087

Table 6. 11: Story drift for Load case (G-Y) for various models
LEVEL CASE 1 2 3 4 5 6 7
36 Gust-Y 0.00092 0.000708 0.000656 0.000857 0.000835 0.000688 0.000672

35 Gust-Y 0.001008 0.000837 0.000801 0.000944 0.00093 0.000849 0.000838
34 Gust-Y 0.001138 0.000863 0.000834 0.00098 0.000982 0.000957 0.000961
33 Gust-Y 0.001274 0.000905 0.000871 0.001029 0.001026 0.001061 0.001067
32 Gust-Y 0.00141 0.000954 0.000918 0.001085 0.001082 0.001161 0.001169
31 Gust-Y 0.001544 0.001 0.000962 0.001142 0.001138 0.001259 0.001269
30 Gust-Y 0.001676 0.001042 0.001004 0.0012 0.001195 0.001354 0.001365
29 Gust-Y 0.001808 0.001101 0.001077 0.001269 0.001281 0.001435 0.00144
28 Gust-Y 0.001937 0.001188 0.001121 0.001355 0.001329 0.001447 0.001372
27 Gust-Y 0.002065 0.000903 0.00083 0.00124 0.001171 0.00117 0.000932
26 Gust-Y 0.00219 0.001301 0.001231 0.001494 0.001467 0.001642 0.001569
25 Gust-Y 0.002314 0.001337 0.001305 0.001545 0.001557 0.001824 0.001836
24 Gust-Y 0.002435 0.001389 0.001341 0.001608 0.001602 0.001936 0.001957
23 Gust-Y 0.002554 0.001451 0.0014 0.001677 0.001671 0.002031 0.002054
22 Gust-Y 0.002671 0.001495 0.001443 0.001737 0.001729 0.002119 0.002143
21 Gust-Y 0.002785 0.001523 0.001471 0.001788 0.001778 0.002198 0.002223
20 Gust-Y 0.002897 0.001572 0.001546 0.001853 0.001873 0.002251 0.002262
19 Gust-Y 0.003005 0.001663 0.001557 0.001941 0.001889 0.002173 0.002037
18 Gust-Y 0.003111 0.001103 0.000998 0.001675 0.001553 0.001578 0.00114
17 Gust-Y 0.003214 0.001746 0.001641 0.002044 0.001991 0.00233 0.002198
16 Gust-Y 0.003313 0.001747 0.001715 0.002055 0.002079 0.002566 0.002583
15 Gust-Y 0.003408 0.001775 0.001719 0.002085 0.00208 0.002667 0.002701
14 Gust-Y 0.003498 0.00182 0.001762 0.002124 0.002121 0.00274 0.002776
13 Gust-Y 0.003584 0.001835 0.001777 0.002144 0.002143 0.002799 0.002836
12 Gust-Y 0.003666 0.001819 0.001763 0.002142 0.002143 0.002843 0.002881
11 Gust-Y 0.003742 0.00182 0.001801 0.002151 0.002196 0.00285 0.002869
10 Gust-Y 0.003814 0.001861 0.001742 0.002177 0.002133 0.00267 0.002486
9 Gust-Y 0.00388 0.001087 0.000974 0.001761 0.001633 0.001791 0.001183
8 Gust-Y 0.00394 0.001816 0.001707 0.002102 0.002074 0.002733 0.002556
7 Gust-Y 0.003993 0.001722 0.00171 0.001989 0.002065 0.002975 0.003002
6 Gust-Y 0.004038 0.001648 0.001612 0.00188 0.001931 0.003021 0.003074
5 Gust-Y 0.004074 0.001581 0.001549 0.001761 0.001831 0.003025 0.003082
4 Gust-Y 0.004096 0.001454 0.00143 0.001588 0.001676 0.003 0.003061
3 Gust-Y 0.004087 0.001259 0.001242 0.001352 0.001402 0.002944 0.003009
2 Gust-Y 0.003953 0.000998 0.000988 0.001055 0.001068 0.002832 0.002899
1 Gust-Y 0.002789 0.000581 0.000577 0.000603 0.00061 0.002058 0.002108

36
35
34
33
32
31
30
29
28
27
26
25
24 M-1
STOREY LEVEL
23
22
21 M-2
20
19
18 M-3
17
16 M-4
15
14
13 M-5
12
11
10 M-6
9
8
7 M-7
6
5
4
3
2
1
0
0 0.0005 0.001 0.0015 0.002 0.0025
DIRFT
Chart 6. 11: Story drift for Load case (GUST-X) for various Models.
36
35
34
33
32
31
30
29
28
27
26
25
24
STOREY LEVEL
23 M-1
22
21
20 M-2
19
18 M-3
17
16
15 M-4
14
13
12 M-5
11
10
9 M-6
8
7
6 M-7
5
4
3
2
1
0
0 0.0005 0.001 0.0015 0.002 0.0025 0.003 0.0035 0.004 0.0045
DIRFT
Chart 6. 12: Story drift for Load case (GUST-Y) for various Models.

Table 6. 12: Story drift for Response spectrum analysis along longitudinal direction for
Zone V
STORY LOAD MODEL MODEL MODEL MODEL MODEL MODEL 6 MODEL
LEVEL CASE 1 2 3 4 5 7
36 RSA-X 0.000519 0.000646 0.000624 0.000633 0.000623 0.000541 0.000527

35 RSA-X 0.000557 0.000688 0.000688 0.000666 0.000661 0.000586 0.000585
34 RSA-X 0.0006 0.000711 0.000719 0.000688 0.00069 0.000628 0.000631
33 RSA-X 0.000643 0.000735 0.000743 0.000713 0.000713 0.000666 0.000672
32 RSA-X 0.000682 0.000757 0.000762 0.000735 0.000734 0.000701 0.000707
31 RSA-X 0.000716 0.000773 0.00078 0.000755 0.000754 0.00073 0.000737
30 RSA-X 0.000746 0.000784 0.000796 0.00077 0.000775 0.000755 0.00076
29 RSA-X 0.00077 0.000794 0.000812 0.000785 0.000797 0.000775 0.000774
28 RSA-X 0.000791 0.000805 0.000793 0.000801 0.000793 0.000773 0.000754
27 RSA-X 0.000808 0.000761 0.000679 0.000785 0.00074 0.000749 0.000667
26 RSA-X 0.000821 0.000828 0.000814 0.000823 0.000812 0.000801 0.000782
25 RSA-X 0.000832 0.000831 0.000846 0.000827 0.000837 0.000831 0.000831
24 RSA-X 0.000841 0.000838 0.000847 0.000833 0.000834 0.00084 0.000847
23 RSA-X 0.000848 0.000842 0.000846 0.000837 0.000833 0.000846 0.000854
22 RSA-X 0.000852 0.000839 0.000842 0.000836 0.000832 0.000848 0.000856
21 RSA-X 0.000855 0.000827 0.000838 0.000831 0.000833 0.000846 0.000853
20 RSA-X 0.000856 0.000815 0.000834 0.000826 0.000837 0.000843 0.00084
19 RSA-X 0.000856 0.000804 0.000791 0.000824 0.000811 0.000812 0.000788
18 RSA-X 0.000855 0.000724 0.000623 0.000781 0.000723 0.000757 0.00065
17 RSA-X 0.000853 0.000802 0.000781 0.000816 0.000797 0.000807 0.000778
16 RSA-X 0.000851 0.000788 0.000803 0.000806 0.000815 0.00083 0.000826
15 RSA-X 0.000847 0.000786 0.000795 0.000801 0.000801 0.000827 0.000833
14 RSA-X 0.000843 0.000783 0.000785 0.000796 0.00079 0.000823 0.000831
13 RSA-X 0.000839 0.000772 0.000774 0.000787 0.000782 0.000816 0.000824
12 RSA-X 0.000833 0.000752 0.000763 0.000773 0.000776 0.000807 0.000812
11 RSA-X 0.000828 0.00073 0.000753 0.000759 0.000774 0.000796 0.000791
10 RSA-X 0.000822 0.00071 0.00069 0.000747 0.000732 0.000751 0.000719
9 RSA-X 0.000816 0.000591 0.000471 0.00068 0.000614 0.000675 0.000542
8 RSA-X 0.000811 0.000695 0.000671 0.000713 0.000692 0.000738 0.000697
7 RSA-X 0.000805 0.000661 0.00068 0.00068 0.000701 0.000762 0.000756
6 RSA-X 0.000799 0.000639 0.000653 0.000649 0.000661 0.000754 0.000761
5 RSA-X 0.000791 0.00061 0.00062 0.000608 0.000619 0.000741 0.000752
4 RSA-X 0.000777 0.00056 0.000572 0.000549 0.000567 0.00072 0.000733
3 RSA-X 0.000747 0.000483 0.000496 0.000469 0.00048 0.000687 0.000699
2 RSA-X 0.000672 0.000391 0.000402 0.000376 0.000378 0.000617 0.00063
1 RSA-X 0.000402 0.000217 0.000223 0.000207 0.000206 0.000374 0.000382

Table 6. 13: Lateral Displacements for Response spectrum analysis along transverse
direction for Zone V
LEVEL CASE 1 2 3 4 5 6 7
36 RSA-Y 0.000258 0.000332 0.000326 0.000378 0.000361 0.000234 0.000227

35 RSA-Y 0.000311 0.000431 0.000431 0.000443 0.00043 0.00032 0.000315
34 RSA-Y 0.000371 0.000453 0.000461 0.000466 0.000461 0.000379 0.00038
33 RSA-Y 0.000429 0.000479 0.000484 0.000491 0.000484 0.000431 0.000433
32 RSA-Y 0.000481 0.000507 0.000511 0.000518 0.000511 0.000477 0.00048
31 RSA-Y 0.000526 0.000529 0.000533 0.000543 0.000535 0.000517 0.000521
30 RSA-Y 0.000566 0.000546 0.00055 0.000565 0.000556 0.000551 0.000555
29 RSA-Y 0.0006 0.000569 0.00058 0.00059 0.000589 0.000575 0.000576
28 RSA-Y 0.000629 0.000603 0.000585 0.00062 0.000599 0.000565 0.000532
27 RSA-Y 0.000655 0.000434 0.000414 0.000549 0.00051 0.000434 0.000332
26 RSA-Y 0.000678 0.000638 0.000624 0.000657 0.000637 0.000614 0.000583
25 RSA-Y 0.000699 0.000642 0.000654 0.000664 0.000664 0.000673 0.000677
24 RSA-Y 0.000719 0.000654 0.000658 0.000676 0.000667 0.0007 0.000707
23 RSA-Y 0.000737 0.00067 0.000673 0.00069 0.000681 0.000718 0.000726
22 RSA-Y 0.000754 0.000676 0.000679 0.0007 0.00069 0.000733 0.000741
21 RSA-Y 0.00077 0.000674 0.000677 0.000706 0.000696 0.000744 0.000752
20 RSA-Y 0.000785 0.00068 0.000694 0.000716 0.000716 0.000745 0.000749
19 RSA-Y 0.000798 0.000701 0.000678 0.000735 0.000708 0.000705 0.000661
18 RSA-Y 0.000811 0.000458 0.000431 0.000623 0.000571 0.0005 0.000359
17 RSA-Y 0.000823 0.000711 0.00069 0.000748 0.00072 0.000726 0.000682
16 RSA-Y 0.000834 0.000701 0.000715 0.000741 0.000741 0.000788 0.000792
15 RSA-Y 0.000844 0.000703 0.000707 0.000742 0.000732 0.000807 0.000816
14 RSA-Y 0.000854 0.000714 0.000717 0.000748 0.000739 0.000817 0.000827
13 RSA-Y 0.000862 0.000714 0.000717 0.000749 0.00074 0.000824 0.000834
12 RSA-Y 0.00087 0.000702 0.000706 0.000743 0.000735 0.000826 0.000836
11 RSA-Y 0.000877 0.000698 0.000716 0.000742 0.000748 0.000819 0.000823
10 RSA-Y 0.000883 0.000709 0.000685 0.000748 0.000724 0.00076 0.000707
9 RSA-Y 0.00089 0.000412 0.000383 0.000602 0.000551 0.000505 0.000333
8 RSA-Y 0.000897 0.00069 0.000669 0.000719 0.000701 0.000766 0.000714
7 RSA-Y 0.000905 0.000655 0.000674 0.00068 0.000698 0.000832 0.000838
6 RSA-Y 0.000914 0.000627 0.000636 0.000643 0.000653 0.000844 0.000857
5 RSA-Y 0.000922 0.000602 0.000612 0.000602 0.000619 0.000844 0.000859
4 RSA-Y 0.000927 0.000554 0.000565 0.000543 0.000566 0.000837 0.000852
3 RSA-Y 0.000923 0.000479 0.00049 0.000462 0.000473 0.000819 0.000836
2 RSA-Y 0.000887 0.000379 0.000389 0.00036 0.00036 0.000783 0.0008
1 RSA-Y 0.000617 0.000219 0.000225 0.000205 0.000204 0.000557 0.00057

36
35
34
33
32
31
30
29
28
27
26
25
24 M-1
STOREY LEVEL
23
22 M-2
21
20
19 M-3
18
17
16 M-4
15
14
13 M-5
12
11 M-6
10
9
8 M-7
7
6
5
4
3
2
1
0 0.0001 0.0002 0.0003 0.0004 0.0005 0.0006 0.0007 0.0008 0.0009
DIRFT
Chart 6. 13: Story drift for Load case (RSA-X) for various Models.
36
35
34
33
32
31
30
29
28
27
26
25 M-1
24
STOREY LEVEL
23
22 M-2
21
20
19 M-3
18
17
16 M-4
15
14
13 M-5
12
11
10 M-6
9
8 M-7
7
6
5
4
3
2
1
0 0.0001 0.0002 0.0003 0.0004 0.0005 0.0006 0.0007 0.0008 0.0009 0.001
DIRFT
Chart 6. 14: Storey drift for Load case (RSA-Y) for various Models.

Table 6. 14: Storey drift for wind along longitudinal direction
LEVEL CASE 1 2 3 4 5 6 7
36 WIND-X 0.000657 0.000683 0.000633 0.000689 0.000669 0.000657 0.000635

35 WIND-X 0.000685 0.000698 0.000665 0.000708 0.000692 0.000682 0.000672
34 WIND-X 0.00072 0.000713 0.000684 0.000724 0.000712 0.000712 0.000705
33 WIND-X 0.000757 0.000731 0.000702 0.000744 0.000731 0.000744 0.000737
32 WIND-X 0.000795 0.000749 0.000718 0.000765 0.00075 0.000775 0.000769
31 WIND-X 0.000831 0.000766 0.000736 0.000785 0.000771 0.000805 0.000799
30 WIND-X 0.000868 0.000781 0.000755 0.000805 0.000795 0.000834 0.000826
29 WIND-X 0.000903 0.000798 0.000777 0.000827 0.000823 0.000863 0.000849
28 WIND-X 0.000937 0.00082 0.000776 0.000853 0.000831 0.000874 0.000844
27 WIND-X 0.000971 0.000798 0.000695 0.000852 0.000797 0.000868 0.000778
26 WIND-X 0.001003 0.000861 0.000812 0.000899 0.000875 0.00093 0.0009
25 WIND-X 0.001035 0.000879 0.000853 0.000918 0.00091 0.000976 0.000961
24 WIND-X 0.001065 0.0009 0.000868 0.00094 0.000924 0.001003 0.000995
23 WIND-X 0.001093 0.000919 0.000882 0.000961 0.000939 0.001028 0.001021
22 WIND-X 0.001121 0.00093 0.000894 0.000978 0.000956 0.00105 0.001043
21 WIND-X 0.001147 0.000934 0.000907 0.00099 0.000975 0.001069 0.001059
20 WIND-X 0.001171 0.000939 0.000921 0.001002 0.000999 0.001085 0.001063
19 WIND-X 0.001193 0.000947 0.000888 0.001019 0.000985 0.001066 0.001017
18 WIND-X 0.001214 0.000866 0.000712 0.000983 0.000893 0.001013 0.000857
17 WIND-X 0.001233 0.000974 0.000909 0.001042 0.001002 0.001099 0.001045
16 WIND-X 0.00125 0.000972 0.000948 0.001045 0.001038 0.001148 0.001125
15 WIND-X 0.001264 0.000981 0.00095 0.001051 0.001033 0.001161 0.001151
14 WIND-X 0.001277 0.000987 0.000949 0.001056 0.00103 0.001171 0.001164
13 WIND-X 0.001286 0.00098 0.000942 0.001053 0.001027 0.001175 0.001168
12 WIND-X 0.001293 0.00096 0.000936 0.001041 0.001026 0.001174 0.001164
11 WIND-X 0.001298 0.000937 0.000928 0.001026 0.001029 0.001169 0.001143
10 WIND-X 0.001299 0.000915 0.000854 0.001013 0.000976 0.001111 0.001047
9 WIND-X 0.001298 0.000764 0.000586 0.000924 0.000823 0.001004 0.000795
8 WIND-X 0.001293 0.000893 0.000829 0.000967 0.000922 0.001098 0.001023
7 WIND-X 0.001285 0.000844 0.00083 0.000919 0.00093 0.001133 0.001106
6 WIND-X 0.001272 0.000811 0.000794 0.000873 0.000873 0.001116 0.001109
5 WIND-X 0.001254 0.000768 0.000748 0.000814 0.000815 0.001093 0.001091
4 WIND-X 0.001227 0.000699 0.000685 0.000732 0.000742 0.001057 0.001058
3 WIND-X 0.001178 0.0006 0.00059 0.000622 0.000625 0.001003 0.001005
2 WIND-X 0.001059 0.000482 0.000476 0.000497 0.00049 0.000901 0.000904
1 WIND-X 0.000635 0.000268 0.000265 0.000274 0.000268 0.000546 0.000548

Table 6. 15: Storey drift for wind along transverse direction
LEVEL CASE 1 2 3 4 5 6 7
36 WIND-Y 0.000169 0.000154 0.000145 0.000185 0.000173 0.000145 0.000142

35 WIND-Y 0.000189 0.000184 0.000176 0.000208 0.000197 0.000176 0.000171
34 WIND-Y 0.000216 0.000192 0.000185 0.000217 0.000209 0.000199 0.000197
33 WIND-Y 0.000245 0.000202 0.000194 0.000229 0.000219 0.000223 0.00022
32 WIND-Y 0.000273 0.000213 0.000205 0.000242 0.000231 0.000245 0.000243
31 WIND-Y 0.000301 0.000224 0.000215 0.000255 0.000244 0.000267 0.000265
30 WIND-Y 0.000329 0.000234 0.000225 0.000269 0.000257 0.000289 0.000287
29 WIND-Y 0.000356 0.000248 0.000242 0.000286 0.000277 0.000308 0.000304
28 WIND-Y 0.000383 0.000268 0.000251 0.000306 0.000288 0.000312 0.000291
27 WIND-Y 0.00041 0.000205 0.000188 0.000281 0.000254 0.000253 0.000199
26 WIND-Y 0.000436 0.000295 0.000277 0.000339 0.000319 0.000356 0.000335
25 WIND-Y 0.000462 0.000304 0.000296 0.000351 0.00034 0.000396 0.000393
24 WIND-Y 0.000487 0.000316 0.000305 0.000366 0.00035 0.000421 0.000419
23 WIND-Y 0.000512 0.000331 0.000319 0.000383 0.000366 0.000443 0.000441
22 WIND-Y 0.000537 0.000342 0.000329 0.000397 0.000379 0.000463 0.000461
21 WIND-Y 0.000561 0.000348 0.000336 0.000409 0.000391 0.000481 0.000479
20 WIND-Y 0.000584 0.00036 0.000354 0.000425 0.000412 0.000494 0.000488
19 WIND-Y 0.000607 0.000382 0.000355 0.000446 0.000416 0.000477 0.00044
18 WIND-Y 0.000629 0.000253 0.000229 0.000385 0.000343 0.000347 0.000246
17 WIND-Y 0.000651 0.000401 0.000375 0.00047 0.00044 0.000513 0.000476
16 WIND-Y 0.000672 0.000402 0.000394 0.000473 0.00046 0.000566 0.000561
15 WIND-Y 0.000692 0.000409 0.000396 0.000481 0.000461 0.000589 0.000587
14 WIND-Y 0.000711 0.00042 0.000406 0.00049 0.00047 0.000605 0.000604
13 WIND-Y 0.000729 0.000424 0.00041 0.000495 0.000475 0.000619 0.000617
12 WIND-Y 0.000746 0.00042 0.000407 0.000495 0.000476 0.000629 0.000628
11 WIND-Y 0.000762 0.000421 0.000417 0.000498 0.000488 0.000631 0.000625
10 WIND-Y 0.000778 0.000431 0.000401 0.000504 0.000474 0.000592 0.000542
9 WIND-Y 0.000792 0.000251 0.000225 0.000408 0.000363 0.000397 0.000258
8 WIND-Y 0.000804 0.000421 0.000394 0.000487 0.000462 0.000607 0.000558
7 WIND-Y 0.000816 0.0004 0.000397 0.000462 0.00046 0.000661 0.000656
6 WIND-Y 0.000825 0.000383 0.000374 0.000436 0.000431 0.000672 0.000673
5 WIND-Y 0.000833 0.000367 0.00036 0.000409 0.000408 0.000672 0.000674
4 WIND-Y 0.000838 0.000338 0.000332 0.000369 0.000374 0.000667 0.00067
3 WIND-Y 0.000837 0.000292 0.000289 0.000314 0.000313 0.000655 0.000659
2 WIND-Y 0.00081 0.000232 0.00023 0.000246 0.000239 0.000631 0.000636
1 WIND-Y 0.000569 0.000138 0.000137 0.000144 0.000139 0.000453 0.000456

36
35
34
33
32
31
30
29
28
27
26
25 M-1
STOREY LEVEL
24
23
22 M-2
21
20
19 M-3
18
17
16 M-4
15
14
13 M-5
12
11
10 M-6
9
8
7 M-7
6
5
4
3
2
1
0 0.0002 0.0004 0.0006 0.0008 0.001 0.0012 0.0014
DIRFT
Chart 6. 15: Storey drift for Load case (WIND-X) for various Models
36
35
34
33
32
31
30
29
28
27
26
25
24 M-1
STOREY LEVEL
23
22 M-2
21
20
19 M-3
18
17
16 M-4
15
14
13 M-5
12
11 M-6
10
9
8 M-7
7
6
5
4
3
2
1
0 0.0001 0.0002 0.0003 0.0004 0.0005 0.0006 0.0007 0.0008 0.0009
DIRFT
Chart 6. 16: Storey drift for Load case (WIND-Y) for various Models

Table 6. 16: Storey drift for EQ along longitudinal direction
LEVEL CASE 1 2 3 4 5 6 7
36 EQ-X 0.000756 0.000952 0.000918 0.000924 0.00091 0.000788 0.000771

35 EQ-X 0.000802 0.000996 0.000992 0.000961 0.000954 0.000844 0.000843
34 EQ-X 0.000854 0.001022 0.001029 0.000987 0.000988 0.000894 0.000898
33 EQ-X 0.000905 0.001052 0.001057 0.001018 0.001017 0.000939 0.000946
32 EQ-X 0.000953 0.001079 0.001082 0.001048 0.001045 0.000982 0.000989
31 EQ-X 0.000998 0.001102 0.001107 0.001076 0.001073 0.001021 0.001029
30 EQ-X 0.001039 0.001121 0.001133 0.001101 0.001104 0.001056 0.001062
29 EQ-X 0.001077 0.00114 0.001159 0.001126 0.00114 0.001088 0.001085
28 EQ-X 0.001111 0.001164 0.001145 0.001155 0.001143 0.001092 0.001068
27 EQ-X 0.001142 0.001116 0.001002 0.001142 0.00108 0.00107 0.000961
26 EQ-X 0.001169 0.00121 0.001188 0.001202 0.001186 0.001145 0.00112
25 EQ-X 0.001193 0.001223 0.001241 0.001217 0.001227 0.001193 0.001191
24 EQ-X 0.001213 0.001242 0.001251 0.001234 0.001233 0.001213 0.001221
23 EQ-X 0.00123 0.001256 0.001257 0.001249 0.001241 0.001228 0.001238
22 EQ-X 0.001243 0.001259 0.00126 0.001256 0.001248 0.001238 0.001248
21 EQ-X 0.001252 0.00125 0.001262 0.001256 0.001257 0.001243 0.00125
20 EQ-X 0.001259 0.001239 0.001264 0.001255 0.00127 0.001243 0.001237
19 EQ-X 0.001262 0.001229 0.001204 0.001256 0.001235 0.001202 0.001166
18 EQ-X 0.001261 0.001112 0.000954 0.001195 0.001105 0.001125 0.000967
17 EQ-X 0.001258 0.00123 0.001196 0.001247 0.001217 0.001197 0.001154
16 EQ-X 0.001251 0.001205 0.001223 0.001228 0.001242 0.001227 0.00122
15 EQ-X 0.001241 0.001196 0.001205 0.001216 0.001215 0.001218 0.001225
14 EQ-X 0.001227 0.001184 0.001183 0.0012 0.00119 0.001205 0.001215
13 EQ-X 0.001211 0.001157 0.001156 0.001176 0.001166 0.001186 0.001196
12 EQ-X 0.001192 0.001115 0.001128 0.001143 0.001144 0.001161 0.001168
11 EQ-X 0.00117 0.001069 0.001098 0.001106 0.001124 0.001132 0.001125
10 EQ-X 0.001145 0.001022 0.001001 0.001069 0.001051 0.001056 0.001016
9 EQ-X 0.001117 0.000851 0.000693 0.000963 0.000877 0.000939 0.000767
8 EQ-X 0.001086 0.000963 0.000929 0.000983 0.000953 0.000995 0.000942
7 EQ-X 0.001053 0.000886 0.000902 0.000915 0.00094 0.000999 0.00099
6 EQ-X 0.001016 0.000832 0.000844 0.000851 0.000865 0.00096 0.000967
5 EQ-X 0.000976 0.000771 0.000778 0.000777 0.00079 0.000916 0.000927
4 EQ-X 0.000931 0.000686 0.000696 0.000685 0.000706 0.000863 0.000876
3 EQ-X 0.00087 0.000576 0.000587 0.00057 0.000581 0.000797 0.00081
2 EQ-X 0.000762 0.000449 0.000459 0.000442 0.000441 0.000696 0.000709
1 EQ-X 0.000446 0.000239 0.000245 0.000234 0.000231 0.00041 0.000418

Table 6. 17: Storey drift for EQ along transverse direction
LEVEL CASE 1 2 3 4 5 6 7
36 EQ-Y 0.000369 0.000469 0.00046 0.000525 0.000502 0.000337 0.000328

35 EQ-Y 0.000433 0.000592 0.000591 0.000605 0.000588 0.000446 0.000441
34 EQ-Y 0.000503 0.000618 0.000626 0.000633 0.000626 0.000518 0.000521
33 EQ-Y 0.000572 0.000651 0.000656 0.000667 0.000656 0.000582 0.000586
32 EQ-Y 0.000637 0.000687 0.000691 0.000704 0.000692 0.00064 0.000645
31 EQ-Y 0.000698 0.00072 0.000722 0.00074 0.000727 0.000694 0.0007
30 EQ-Y 0.000754 0.000747 0.000749 0.000775 0.000761 0.000743 0.00075
29 EQ-Y 0.000807 0.000784 0.000796 0.000816 0.000812 0.000782 0.000785
28 EQ-Y 0.000856 0.000838 0.000812 0.000865 0.000835 0.000778 0.000734
27 EQ-Y 0.000901 0.000617 0.000587 0.000778 0.000721 0.000609 0.000472
26 EQ-Y 0.000943 0.000901 0.00088 0.000934 0.000903 0.000859 0.000818
25 EQ-Y 0.00098 0.000915 0.000929 0.000953 0.000948 0.000945 0.000951
24 EQ-Y 0.001014 0.000939 0.000941 0.000979 0.000962 0.000987 0.000998
23 EQ-Y 0.001045 0.000968 0.000969 0.001007 0.000989 0.001018 0.001029
22 EQ-Y 0.001072 0.000984 0.000984 0.001028 0.001009 0.001043 0.001054
21 EQ-Y 0.001096 0.000987 0.000987 0.001042 0.001022 0.001062 0.001073
20 EQ-Y 0.001117 0.001001 0.001017 0.001061 0.001057 0.001067 0.001072
19 EQ-Y 0.001134 0.001036 0.000999 0.001092 0.001048 0.00101 0.000948
18 EQ-Y 0.001149 0.000679 0.000637 0.000927 0.000847 0.000718 0.000519
17 EQ-Y 0.00116 0.00105 0.001015 0.001109 0.001063 0.001033 0.000972
16 EQ-Y 0.001169 0.00103 0.001046 0.001094 0.00109 0.001114 0.00112
15 EQ-Y 0.001175 0.001026 0.001027 0.001089 0.001069 0.001133 0.001146
14 EQ-Y 0.001178 0.001033 0.001033 0.001088 0.00107 0.001138 0.001152
13 EQ-Y 0.001179 0.001023 0.001024 0.001079 0.001061 0.001137 0.00115
12 EQ-Y 0.001178 0.000996 0.000998 0.001059 0.001042 0.001129 0.001143
11 EQ-Y 0.001174 0.000977 0.000997 0.001042 0.001046 0.001107 0.001113
10 EQ-Y 0.001168 0.000976 0.00094 0.001034 0.000998 0.001017 0.000949
9 EQ-Y 0.00116 0.000571 0.000531 0.000825 0.000754 0.000672 0.000452
8 EQ-Y 0.001149 0.000916 0.000885 0.000962 0.000933 0.000988 0.000922
7 EQ-Y 0.001137 0.000851 0.000871 0.000893 0.000912 0.001051 0.001058
6 EQ-Y 0.001124 0.000798 0.000804 0.000828 0.000837 0.001043 0.001059
5 EQ-Y 0.001108 0.00075 0.000758 0.000762 0.000779 0.001021 0.001038
4 EQ-Y 0.001089 0.000678 0.000688 0.000676 0.000702 0.00099 0.001008
3 EQ-Y 0.001064 0.000576 0.000587 0.000565 0.000576 0.000951 0.00097
2 EQ-Y 0.001007 0.000447 0.000456 0.000431 0.000429 0.000893 0.000913
1 EQ-Y 0.000692 0.000252 0.000258 0.000239 0.000237 0.000627 0.000642

36
35
34
33
32
31
30
29
28
27
26
25
24 M-1
STOREY LEVEL
23
22
21 M-2
20
19
18 M-3
17
16 M-4
15
14
13 M-5
12
11
10 M-6
9
8 M-7
7
6
5
4
3
2
1
0
0 0.0002 0.0004 0.0006 0.0008 0.001 0.0012 0.0014
DIRFT
Chart 6. 17: Storey drifts for Load case (EQ-X) for various Models
36
35
34
33
32
31
30
29
28
27
26
25
24 M-1
STOREY LEVEL
23
22 M-2
21
20
19 M-3
18
17
16 M-4
15
14
13 M-5
12
11 M-6
10
9
8 M-7
7
6
5
4
3
2
1
0 0.0002 0.0004 0.0006 0.0008 0.001 0.0012 0.0014
DIRFT
Chart 6. 18: Storey drifts for Load case (EQ-Y) for various Models

Response Spectrum and Dynamic wind analysis
 The Storey drift is minimum at the Outrigger levels.

 The Concrete braced Outrigger with belt truss and concrete core wall shows
maximum storey drifts reduction than the other kind of Outriggers studied.
 The concrete braced Outrigger with concrete core wall model shows maximum storey
drift reduction next to The Concrete braced Outrigger with belt truss and concrete
core wall model.
 The Steel Outrigger model shows least storey drift reduction than the other models
 By providing Concrete braced Outrigger with belt truss and concrete core wall, the
storey drift of building is reduced up to 42.27% and 56.96% in longitudinal and
transverse direction in case of RSA.
storey drift of building is reduced up to 54.98% and 74.36% in longitudinal and
transverse direction in case of DSA.
Static wind and earthquake
storey drift of building is reduced up to 95.48% and 71.59% in longitudinal and in
transverse direction in case of Static earthquake.
storey drift of building is reduced up to 37.95% and 54.22% in longitudinal and in
transverse direction in case of Static Wind Analysis.

Table 6. 18: Maximum Storey Drifts by Response Spectrum Analysis and Dynamic Wind
Analysis along Longitudinal and Transverse direction.
MODEL Model description Response Spectrum Dynamic Wind

Analysis Analysis
1 Bare Frame 0.000856 0.000927 0.002079 0.004096
Concrete Core Wall & Outrigger

2 0.000842 0.000714 0.001528 0.001861
3 and Belt truss 0.000847 0.000717 0.001517 0.001801
Concrete Core Wall,
4 Outrigger(steel) 0.000837 0.000749 0.001635 0.002177
Concrete Core Wall,
5 truss(steel) 0.000837 0.000748 0.00161 0.002196
6 0.000848 0.000844 0.001879 0.003025
0.0045
0.004
0.0035
MAX STOREY DRIFT
0.003
0.0025 RSA-X
0.002 RSA-Y
0.0015
GUST-X
GUST-Y
0.001
0.0005
0
0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7
MODEL NO.
Chart 6. 19: Comparison of Maximum Storey Drifts by Response Spectrum Analysis and
Dynamic
Wind Analysis along Longitudinal and Transverse direction.

0.0045
0.004
0.0035
MAX STOREY DRIFT
0.003 M-1
M-2
0.0025
M-3
0.002 M-4
0.0015 M-5
M-6
0.001
M-7
0.0005
0
ANALYSIS
Chart 6. 20: Comparison of maximum storey drifts for all Models
6.2.3 BASE SHEAR

Base shear can be defined as the maximum lateral force which will occur at base of structure
because of seismic ground motion. The base shear for different models of moment resisting RC
frame structure for seismic zone 5 in longitudinal and transverse direction by Response Spectrum
Method and Dynamic Wind Analysis is found out. These results are compared with the building
with different types of braced outriggers. The analysis values are tabulated in table 6.1

Table 6. 19: Base shear for Load case (G-X) for various models
LEVEL CASE 1 2 3 4 5 6 7
36 Gust-X 457.7912 441.0223 454.4374 441.0223 441.0223 456.1143 447.7298

35 Gust-X 913.1078 879.6606 906.4184 879.6606 879.6606 909.7631 893.0395
34 Gust-X 1365.957 1315.922 1355.95 1315.922 1315.922 1360.953 1335.936
33 Gust-X 1816.099 1749.575 1802.794 1749.575 1749.575 1809.446 1776.184
32 Gust-X 2262.318 2179.449 2245.744 2179.449 2179.449 2254.031 2212.596
31 Gust-X 2704.631 2605.56 2684.817 2605.56 2605.56 2694.724 2645.189
30 Gust-X 3143.056 3027.926 3120.03 3027.926 3027.926 3131.543 3073.978
29 Gust-X 3577.61 3446.562 3551.4 3446.562 3446.562 3564.505 3498.981
28 Gust-X 4008.31 3861.485 3978.945 3861.485 3861.485 3993.627 3920.215
27 Gust-X 4435.172 4272.712 4402.68 4272.712 4272.712 4418.926 4337.696
26 Gust-X 4858.215 4680.259 4822.624 4680.259 4680.259 4840.42 4751.441
25 Gust-X 5277.456 5084.142 5238.793 5084.142 5084.142 5258.124 5161.468
24 Gust-X 5692.911 5484.379 5651.204 5484.379 5484.379 5672.057 5567.792
23 Gust-X 6104.597 5880.986 6059.875 5880.986 5880.986 6082.236 5970.43
22 Gust-X 6512.533 6273.978 6464.822 6273.978 6273.978 6488.677 6369.4
21 Gust-X 6916.734 6663.374 6866.062 6663.374 6663.374 6891.398 6764.718
20 Gust-X 7317.219 7049.189 7263.613 7049.189 7049.189 7290.416 7156.401
19 Gust-X 7714.004 7431.44 7657.491 7431.44 7431.44 7685.748 7544.466
18 Gust-X 8107.107 7810.143 8047.714 7810.143 7810.143 8077.41 7928.929
17 Gust-X 8496.544 8185.316 8434.298 8185.316 8185.316 8465.421 8309.807
16 Gust-X 8880.743 8555.441 8815.683 8555.441 8555.441 8848.213 8685.562
15 Gust-X 9258.162 8919.035 9190.336 8919.035 8919.035 9224.249 9054.686
14 Gust-X 9628.861 9276.156 9558.32 9276.156 9276.156 9593.591 9417.238
13 Gust-X 9992.901 9626.861 9919.693 9626.861 9626.861 9956.297 9773.277
12 Gust-X 10350.34 9971.209 10274.52 9971.209 9971.209 10312.43 10122.86
11 Gust-X 10701.25 10309.26 10622.85 10309.26 10309.26 10662.05 10466.05
10 Gust-X 11045.67 10641.07 10964.75 10641.07 10641.07 11005.21 10802.91
9 Gust-X 11380.14 10963.28 11296.77 10963.28 10963.28 11338.45 11130.03
8 Gust-X 11704.1 11275.38 11618.36 11275.38 11275.38 11661.23 11446.87
7 Gust-X 12017.72 11577.51 11929.68 11577.51 11577.51 11973.7 11753.6
6 Gust-X 12318.16 11866.94 12227.91 11866.94 11866.94 12273.04 12047.43
5 Gust-X 12602.75 12141.11 12510.42 12141.11 12141.11 12556.58 12325.76
4 Gust-X 12868.76 12397.38 12774.49 12397.38 12397.38 12821.63 12585.93
3 Gust-X 13119.27 12638.71 13023.16 12638.71 12638.71 13071.22 12830.94
2 Gust-X 13369.78 12880.05 13271.84 12880.05 12880.05 13320.81 13075.94
1 Gust-X 13620.29 13161.6 13561.95 13161.6 13161.6 13612 13361.78

Table 6. 20: Base shear for Load case (G-Y) for various models
LEVEL CASE 1 2 3 4 5 6 7
36 Gust-Y 804.0691 707.2287 707.2287 707.2287 736.5743 739.5088 751.2471

35 Gust-Y 1603.792 1410.635 1410.635 1410.635 1469.167 1475.02 1498.433
34 Gust-Y 2399.18 2110.228 2110.228 2110.228 2197.789 2206.545 2241.57
33 Gust-Y 3189.814 2805.639 2805.639 2805.639 2922.056 2933.698 2980.264
32 Gust-Y 3973.558 3494.991 3494.991 3494.991 3640.011 3654.513 3712.521
31 Gust-Y 4750.442 4178.308 4178.308 4178.308 4351.682 4369.02 4438.369
30 Gust-Y 5520.496 4855.619 4855.619 4855.619 5057.097 5077.245 5157.836
29 Gust-Y 6283.751 5526.949 5526.949 5526.949 5756.283 5779.216 5870.95
28 Gust-Y 7040.236 6192.325 6192.325 6192.325 6449.268 6474.962 6577.739
27 Gust-Y 7789.982 6851.773 6851.773 6851.773 7136.079 7164.509 7278.232
26 Gust-Y 8533.019 7505.32 7505.32 7505.32 7816.744 7847.886 7972.456
25 Gust-Y 9269.377 8152.992 8152.992 8152.992 8491.291 8525.121 8660.44
24 Gust-Y 9999.086 8794.817 8794.817 8794.817 9159.747 9196.24 9342.212
23 Gust-Y 10722.18 9430.82 9430.82 9430.82 9822.14 9861.272 10017.8
22 Gust-Y 11438.68 10061.03 10061.03 10061.03 10478.5 10520.24 10687.23
21 Gust-Y 12148.62 10685.47 10685.47 10685.47 11128.85 11173.19 11350.54
20 Gust-Y 12852.04 11304.17 11304.17 11304.17 11773.22 11820.12 12007.74
19 Gust-Y 13548.96 11917.15 11917.15 11917.15 12411.63 12461.08 12658.88
18 Gust-Y 14239.41 12524.44 12524.44 12524.44 13044.13 13096.1 13303.97
17 Gust-Y 14923.42 13126.07 13126.07 13126.07 13670.72 13725.19 13943.05
16 Gust-Y 15598.23 13719.61 13719.61 13719.61 14288.89 14345.82 14573.53
15 Gust-Y 16261.13 14302.67 14302.67 14302.67 14896.14 14955.49 15192.88
14 Gust-Y 16912.23 14875.36 14875.36 14875.36 15492.59 15554.31 15801.21
13 Gust-Y 17551.63 15437.75 15437.75 15437.75 16078.32 16142.38 16398.61
12 Gust-Y 18179.45 15989.95 15989.95 15989.95 16653.44 16719.78 16985.18
11 Gust-Y 18795.78 16532.05 16532.05 16532.05 17218.03 17286.63 17561.02
10 Gust-Y 19400.73 17064.15 17064.15 17064.15 17772.2 17843.01 18126.23
9 Gust-Y 19988.19 17580.86 17580.86 17580.86 18310.35 18383.3 18675.1
8 Gust-Y 20557.2 18081.33 18081.33 18081.33 18831.6 18906.62 19206.73
7 Gust-Y 21108.05 18565.84 18565.84 18565.84 19336.21 19413.25 19721.39
6 Gust-Y 21635.74 19029.97 19029.97 19029.97 19819.6 19898.56 20214.41
5 Gust-Y 22135.59 19469.63 19469.63 19469.63 20277.5 20358.28 20681.43
4 Gust-Y 22602.83 19880.59 19880.59 19880.59 20705.51 20788 21117.97
3 Gust-Y 23042.83 20267.59 20267.59 20267.59 21108.57 21192.67 21529.06
2 Gust-Y 23482.82 20654.6 20654.6 20654.6 21511.64 21597.34 21940.16
1 Gust-Y 23922.82 21106.1 21106.1 21106.1 21981.88 22069.45 22419.76

36
35
34
33
32
31
30
29
28
27
26
25
24 M-1
STOREY LEVEL
23
22 M-2
21
20
19 M-3
18
17
16 M-4
15
14 M-5
13
12
11 M-6
10
9
8 M-7
7
6
5
4
3
2
1
0 2000 4000 6000 8000 10000 12000 14000 16000
BASE SHEAR
Chart 6. 22: Base shear for Load case (GUST-X) for various Models.
36
35
34
33
32
31
30
29
28
27
26
25
24 M-1
STOREY LEVEL
23
22 M-2
21
20
19 M-3
18
17
16 M-4
15
14 M-5
13
12
11 M-6
10
9
8 M-7
7
6
5
4
3
2
1
0 5000 10000 15000 20000 25000 30000
BASE SHEAR
Chart 6. 21: Base shear for Load case (GUST-Y) for various Models.

Table 6. 21: Story drift for Response spectrum analysis along longitudinal direction for
Zone V
LEVEL CASE 1 2 3 4 5 6 7
36 RSA-X 430.9553 643.9798 718.4651 565.3104 575.8074 465.9842 471.6408

35 RSA-X 885.3964 1326.754 1477.311 1165.802 1193.63 960.329 974.7096
34 RSA-X 1296.813 1866.379 2011.373 1691.545 1725.396 1403.817 1422.388
33 RSA-X 1658.734 2328.076 2468.247 2138.005 2178.053 1793.484 1816.414
32 RSA-X 1968.146 2711.133 2847.224 2506.944 2553.001 2126.126 2153.128
31 RSA-X 2226.063 3019.38 3151.863 2804.452 2855.88 2402.797 2433.227
30 RSA-X 2437.29 3260.781 3389.536 3040.189 3095.792 2628.397 2661.291
29 RSA-X 2609.518 3446.533 3570.608 3226.125 3284.12 2810.866 2845.067
28 RSA-X 2751.927 3589.656 3707.357 3374.848 3433.052 2960.141 2994.729
27 RSA-X 2873.552 3719.321 3847.489 3499.437 3558.536 3088.937 3126.198
26 RSA-X 2981.847 3838.966 3989.258 3609.802 3673.943 3207.433 3251.249
25 RSA-X 3081.849 3932.442 4089.212 3706.284 3773.309 3314.224 3362.79
24 RSA-X 3176.171 4011.132 4171.677 3791.094 3858.899 3410.979 3462.326
23 RSA-X 3265.744 4076.502 4238.537 3865.451 3932.405 3498.862 3551.034
22 RSA-X 3350.909 4131.428 4293.069 3931.538 3996.482 3579.323 3630.789
21 RSA-X 3432.391 4181.028 4340.559 3993.372 4055.532 3654.584 3704.33
20 RSA-X 3511.776 4232.612 4388.239 4056.759 4115.659 3727.887 3775.416
19 RSA-X 3591.375 4294.671 4444.46 4128.326 4183.778 3803.392 3848.826
18 RSA-X 3673.604 4388.457 4545.991 4215.313 4269.737 3887.191 3933.153
17 RSA-X 3760.208 4520.482 4703.531 4322.892 4382.121 3984.202 4035.138
16 RSA-X 3851.748 4662.124 4853.971 4446.695 4510.749 4089.158 4144.848
15 RSA-X 3947.606 4818.829 5016.753 4584.357 4653.04 4199.592 4259.253
14 RSA-X 4046.553 4985.952 5187.56 4732.654 4805.792 4313.409 4375.852
13 RSA-X 4147.627 5160.497 5363.793 4889.257 4966.719 4429.634 4493.755
12 RSA-X 4250.94 5341.635 5544.866 5053.426 5135.041 4548.745 4613.75
11 RSA-X 4358.009 5530.31 5731.711 5225.815 5311.224 4672.653 4738.124
10 RSA-X 4471.382 5728.085 5925.732 5407.46 5496.002 4804.219 4870.195
9 RSA-X 4593.575 5963 6187.556 5600.544 5694.749 4948.376 5017.863
8 RSA-X 4725.634 6218.231 6483.853 5803.18 5907.533 5106.989 5183.819
7 RSA-X 4865.829 6447.001 6720.289 6003.864 6115.758 5271.259 5354.007
6 RSA-X 5009.016 6661.484 6939.608 6194.151 6311.767 5434.429 5522.002
5 RSA-X 5146.935 6849.814 7130.572 6363.354 6484.88 5587.323 5678.296
4 RSA-X 5269.424 7002.136 7284.076 6501.839 6625.583 5720.093 5813.159
3 RSA-X 5366.266 7112.271 7394.554 6602.965 6726.607 5823.532 5917.699
2 RSA-X 5429.496 7178.876 7461.141 6664.572 6787.345 5890.786 5985.422
1 RSA-X 5457.222 7206.919 7489.115 6690.629 6813.233 5920.561 6015.331

Table 6. 22: Story drift for Response spectrum analysis along transverse direction for
ZoneV
LEVEL CASE 1 2 3 4 5 6 7
36 RSA-Y 382.6856 654.3037 732.3928 574.389 583.9959 424.7314 428.641

35 RSA-Y 795.9281 1372.75 1530.6 1196.864 1225.888 890.4158 900.6648
34 RSA-Y 1178.119 1950.212 2100.468 1747.192 1784.043 1318.18 1330.534
33 RSA-Y 1521.311 2456.399 2599.565 2222.35 2267.925 1702.812 1717.67
32 RSA-Y 1821.028 2891.159 3028.131 2625.056 2680.041 2039.863 2057.393
31 RSA-Y 2076.814 3257.624 3389.107 2961.243 3025.618 2329.071 2349.202
30 RSA-Y 2292.087 3562.636 3689.054 3239.904 3313.008 2573.958 2596.35
29 RSA-Y 2473.357 3815.838 3937.263 3471.9 3552.557 2781.086 2805.148
28 RSA-Y 2628.902 4027.578 4143.206 3668.001 3754.22 2959.152 2984.314
27 RSA-Y 2767.148 4232.65 4368.584 3840.116 3932.597 3121.534 3150.895
26 RSA-Y 2895.153 4439.214 4607.559 4002.808 4107.728 3283.304 3321.581
25 RSA-Y 3017.623 4604.435 4778.281 4147.944 4261.427 3433.636 3478.492
24 RSA-Y 3136.749 4748.292 4925.789 4277.757 4397.254 3572.439 3621.739
23 RSA-Y 3252.818 4872.415 5052.219 4393.546 4517.114 3700.362 3752.074
22 RSA-Y 3365.238 4979.38 5160.165 4497.273 4623.206 3818.368 3870.879
21 RSA-Y 3473.532 5073.965 5254.372 4592.525 4719.464 3927.998 3980.157
20 RSA-Y 3577.924 5162.911 5341.528 4684.361 4811.386 4031.557 4082.635
19 RSA-Y 3679.359 5253.464 5428.486 4778.178 4904.523 4132.096 4181.802
18 RSA-Y 3779.062 5367.591 5553.991 4880.324 5007.437 4235.666 4286.368
17 RSA-Y 3877.916 5516.008 5727.761 4999.28 5132.964 4350.439 4406.149
16 RSA-Y 3975.983 5662.357 5879.987 5126.789 5265.849 4465.891 4525.835
15 RSA-Y 4072.461 5816.43 6037.621 5261.825 5405.764 4578.922 4642.148
14 RSA-Y 4166.115 5975.729 6198.556 5402.709 5551.208 4687.824 4753.163
13 RSA-Y 4256.047 6138.558 6361.249 5548.355 5700.992 4792.197 4858.603
12 RSA-Y 4342.478 6304.868 6525.838 5698.968 5855.259 4893.178 4959.868
11 RSA-Y 4427.199 6475.894 6693.728 5855.769 6015.177 4993.414 5059.906
10 RSA-Y 4513.396 6652.701 6865.801 6019.81 6181.425 5096.64 5162.762
9 RSA-Y 4604.799 6859.594 7093.776 6192.989 6358.218 5209.082 5277.055
8 RSA-Y 4704.307 7090.25 7357.326 6377.27 6550.663 5337.082 5410.04
7 RSA-Y 4812.541 7295.038 7565.443 6558.772 6737.439 5471.059 5547.724
6 RSA-Y 4926.849 7485.856 7757.786 6730.107 6912.518 5605.83 5685.214
5 RSA-Y 5041.171 7652.927 7925.287 6881.968 7066.787 5734.467 5815.464
4 RSA-Y 5146.874 7787.695 8059.82 7005.83 7191.655 5848.912 5930.596
3 RSA-Y 5234.319 7884.912 8156.518 7096.003 7280.765 5941.025 6022.794
2 RSA-Y 5294.852 7943.894 8215.022 7151.084 7334.42 6003.946 6085.541
1 RSA-Y 5323.984 7969.511 8240.381 7175.112 7358.032 6034.398 6115.835

36
35
34
33
32
31
30
29
28
27
26
25
24 M-1
STOREY LEVEL
23
22
21 M-2
20
19 M-3
18
17
16 M-4
15
14 M-5
13
12
11 M-6
10
9 M-7
8
7
6
5
4
3
2
1
0 1000 2000 3000 4000 5000 6000 7000 8000
BASE SHEAR
Chart 6. 24: Base shear for Load case (RSA-X) for various Models.
36
35
34
33
32
31
30
29
28
27
26
25
24 M-1
STOREY LEVEL
23
22 M-2
21
20
19 M-3
18
17
16 M-4
15
14
13 M-5
12
11 M-6
10
9
8 M-7
7
6
5
4
3
2
1
0 2000 4000 6000 8000 10000
BASE SHEAR
Chart 6. 23: Base shear for Load case (RSA-Y) for various Models.

Table 6. 23: Base shear for wind along longitudinal direction
LEVEL CASE 1 2 3 4 5 6 7
36 WIND-X 146.4631 146.4631 146.4631 146.4631 146.4631 146.4631 146.4631

35 WIND-X 438.333 438.333 438.333 438.333 438.333 438.333 438.333
34 WIND-X 728.6204 728.6204 728.6204 728.6204 728.6204 728.6204 728.6204
33 WIND-X 1017.082 1017.082 1017.082 1017.082 1017.082 1017.082 1017.082
32 WIND-X 1303.121 1303.121 1303.121 1303.121 1303.121 1303.121 1303.121
31 WIND-X 1586.656 1586.656 1586.656 1586.656 1586.656 1586.656 1586.656
30 WIND-X 1867.699 1867.699 1867.699 1867.699 1867.699 1867.699 1867.699
29 WIND-X 2146.26 2146.26 2146.26 2146.26 2146.26 2146.26 2146.26
28 WIND-X 2422.351 2422.351 2422.351 2422.351 2422.351 2422.351 2422.351
27 WIND-X 2695.981 2695.981 2695.981 2695.981 2695.981 2695.981 2695.981
26 WIND-X 2967.164 2967.164 2967.164 2967.164 2967.164 2967.164 2967.164
25 WIND-X 3235.908 3235.908 3235.908 3235.908 3235.908 3235.908 3235.908
24 WIND-X 3502.227 3502.227 3502.227 3502.227 3502.227 3502.227 3502.227
23 WIND-X 3766.129 3766.129 3766.129 3766.129 3766.129 3766.129 3766.129
22 WIND-X 4027.627 4027.627 4027.627 4027.627 4027.627 4027.627 4027.627
21 WIND-X 4286.732 4286.732 4286.732 4286.732 4286.732 4286.732 4286.732
20 WIND-X 4543.454 4543.454 4543.454 4543.454 4543.454 4543.454 4543.454
19 WIND-X 4797.804 4797.804 4797.804 4797.804 4797.804 4797.804 4797.804
18 WIND-X 5049.794 5049.794 5049.794 5049.794 5049.794 5049.794 5049.794
17 WIND-X 5299.391 5299.391 5299.391 5299.391 5299.391 5299.391 5299.391
16 WIND-X 5545.633 5545.633 5545.633 5545.633 5545.633 5545.633 5545.633
15 WIND-X 5787.571 5787.571 5787.571 5787.571 5787.571 5787.571 5787.571
14 WIND-X 6025.202 6025.202 6025.202 6025.202 6025.202 6025.202 6025.202
13 WIND-X 6258.565 6258.565 6258.565 6258.565 6258.565 6258.565 6258.565
12 WIND-X 6487.697 6487.697 6487.697 6487.697 6487.697 6487.697 6487.697
11 WIND-X 6712.638 6712.638 6712.638 6712.638 6712.638 6712.638 6712.638
10 WIND-X 6933.162 6933.162 6933.162 6933.162 6933.162 6933.162 6933.162
9 WIND-X 7147.572 7147.572 7147.572 7147.572 7147.572 7147.572 7147.572
8 WIND-X 7355.248 7355.248 7355.248 7355.248 7355.248 7355.248 7355.248
7 WIND-X 7556.216 7556.216 7556.216 7556.216 7556.216 7556.216 7556.216
6 WIND-X 7748.743 7748.743 7748.743 7748.743 7748.743 7748.743 7748.743
5 WIND-X 7930.957 7930.957 7930.957 7930.957 7930.957 7930.957 7930.957
4 WIND-X 8101.524 8101.524 8101.524 8101.524 8101.524 8101.524 8101.524
3 WIND-X 8263.25 8263.25 8263.25 8263.25 8263.25 8263.25 8263.25
2 WIND-X 8423.832 8423.832 8423.832 8423.832 8423.832 8423.832 8423.832
1 WIND-X 8597.797 8597.797 8597.797 8597.797 8597.797 8597.797 8597.797

Table 6. 24: Base shear for wind along transverse direction
LEVEL CASE 1 2 3 4 5 6 7
36 WIND-Y 83.6932 83.6932 83.6932 83.6932 83.6932 83.6932 83.6932

35 WIND-Y 250.476 250.476 250.476 250.476 250.476 250.476 250.476
34 WIND-Y 416.3545 416.3545 416.3545 416.3545 416.3545 416.3545 416.3545
33 WIND-Y 581.1899 581.1899 581.1899 581.1899 581.1899 581.1899 581.1899
32 WIND-Y 744.6407 744.6407 744.6407 744.6407 744.6407 744.6407 744.6407
31 WIND-Y 906.6608 906.6608 906.6608 906.6608 906.6608 906.6608 906.6608
30 WIND-Y 1067.257 1067.257 1067.257 1067.257 1067.257 1067.257 1067.257
29 WIND-Y 1226.434 1226.434 1226.434 1226.434 1226.434 1226.434 1226.434
28 WIND-Y 1384.2 1384.2 1384.2 1384.2 1384.2 1384.2 1384.2
27 WIND-Y 1540.561 1540.561 1540.561 1540.561 1540.561 1540.561 1540.561
26 WIND-Y 1695.522 1695.522 1695.522 1695.522 1695.522 1695.522 1695.522
25 WIND-Y 1849.091 1849.091 1849.091 1849.091 1849.091 1849.091 1849.091
24 WIND-Y 2001.272 2001.272 2001.272 2001.272 2001.272 2001.272 2001.272
23 WIND-Y 2152.074 2152.074 2152.074 2152.074 2152.074 2152.074 2152.074
22 WIND-Y 2301.501 2301.501 2301.501 2301.501 2301.501 2301.501 2301.501
21 WIND-Y 2449.561 2449.561 2449.561 2449.561 2449.561 2449.561 2449.561
20 WIND-Y 2596.259 2596.259 2596.259 2596.259 2596.259 2596.259 2596.259
19 WIND-Y 2741.602 2741.602 2741.602 2741.602 2741.602 2741.602 2741.602
18 WIND-Y 2885.596 2885.596 2885.596 2885.596 2885.596 2885.596 2885.596
17 WIND-Y 3028.224 3028.224 3028.224 3028.224 3028.224 3028.224 3028.224
16 WIND-Y 3168.933 3168.933 3168.933 3168.933 3168.933 3168.933 3168.933
15 WIND-Y 3307.184 3307.184 3307.184 3307.184 3307.184 3307.184 3307.184
14 WIND-Y 3442.973 3442.973 3442.973 3442.973 3442.973 3442.973 3442.973
13 WIND-Y 3576.323 3576.323 3576.323 3576.323 3576.323 3576.323 3576.323
12 WIND-Y 3707.255 3707.255 3707.255 3707.255 3707.255 3707.255 3707.255
11 WIND-Y 3835.793 3835.793 3835.793 3835.793 3835.793 3835.793 3835.793
10 WIND-Y 3961.807 3961.807 3961.807 3961.807 3961.807 3961.807 3961.807
9 WIND-Y 4084.327 4084.327 4084.327 4084.327 4084.327 4084.327 4084.327
8 WIND-Y 4202.999 4202.999 4202.999 4202.999 4202.999 4202.999 4202.999
7 WIND-Y 4317.838 4317.838 4317.838 4317.838 4317.838 4317.838 4317.838
6 WIND-Y 4427.853 4427.853 4427.853 4427.853 4427.853 4427.853 4427.853
5 WIND-Y 4531.976 4531.976 4531.976 4531.976 4531.976 4531.976 4531.976
4 WIND-Y 4629.442 4629.442 4629.442 4629.442 4629.442 4629.442 4629.442
3 WIND-Y 4721.857 4721.857 4721.857 4721.857 4721.857 4721.857 4721.857
2 WIND-Y 4813.619 4813.619 4813.619 4813.619 4813.619 4813.619 4813.619
1 WIND-Y 4913.027 4913.027 4913.027 4913.027 4913.027 4913.027 4913.027

40
35
30
STOREY LEVEL
25
20
M-1,M-2,M-3,M-4,M-5,M-
6,M-7
15
10
0
0 2000 4000 6000 8000 10000
BASE SHEAR
Chart 6. 26: Base shear for Load case (WIND-X) for various Models
40
35
30
STOREY LEVEL
25
20
M-1,M-2,M-3,M-4,M-5,M-
15 6,M-7
10
0
0 1000 2000 3000 4000 5000 6000
BASE SHEAR
Chart 6. 25: Base shear for Load case (WIND-Y) for various Models

Table 6. 25: Base shear for EQ along longitudinal direction
LEVEL CASE 1 2 3 4 5 6 7
36 EQ-X 416.2694 547.1754 624.8537 473.988 489.8313 447.229 458.162

35 EQ-X 863.258 1144.886 1295.79 999.9061 1032.928 927.6219 949.5346
34 EQ-X 1285.187 1649.914 1799.459 1497.082 1535.463 1376.704 1403.633
33 EQ-X 1682.779 2125.811 2274.076 1965.581 2009.012 1799.884 1831.539
32 EQ-X 2056.757 2573.444 2720.504 2406.254 2454.436 2197.929 2234.031
31 EQ-X 2407.844 2993.677 3139.607 2819.954 2872.595 2571.611 2611.886
30 EQ-X 2736.763 3387.376 3532.246 3207.532 3264.351 2921.697 2965.883
29 EQ-X 3044.236 3755.406 3899.286 3569.841 3630.564 3248.958 3296.8
28 EQ-X 3330.987 4098.633 4241.589 3907.731 3972.097 3554.163 3605.414
27 EQ-X 3597.739 4455.331 4641.987 4224.934 4296.203 3840.849 3898.653
26 EQ-X 3845.213 4786.253 5013.45 4519.215 4596.888 4106.818 4170.7
25 EQ-X 4074.134 5060.26 5286.72 4788.962 4869.543 4350.472 4417.075
24 EQ-X 4285.224 5312.924 5538.704 5037.698 5120.96 4575.146 4644.26
23 EQ-X 4479.206 5545.11 5770.265 5266.274 5352 4781.612 4853.031
22 EQ-X 4656.803 5757.684 5982.268 5475.544 5563.525 4970.638 5044.169
21 EQ-X 4818.737 5951.512 6175.573 5666.357 5756.396 5142.994 5218.45
20 EQ-X 4965.732 6127.457 6351.045 5839.567 5931.473 5299.449 5376.652
19 EQ-X 5098.51 6286.386 6509.547 5996.025 6089.617 5440.772 5519.554
18 EQ-X 5217.795 6445.893 6688.595 6137.871 6234.55 5568.971 5650.683
17 EQ-X 5324.309 6588.322 6848.473 6264.53 6363.966 5683.445 5767.773
16 EQ-X 5418.775 6701.393 6961.24 6375.843 6476.478 5783.99 5869.442
15 EQ-X 5501.915 6800.908 7060.488 6473.811 6575.502 5872.481 5958.921
14 EQ-X 5574.454 6887.734 7147.079 6559.287 6661.899 5949.688 6036.991
13 EQ-X 5637.113 6962.734 7221.877 6633.121 6736.529 6016.38 6104.427
12 EQ-X 5690.616 7026.774 7285.745 6696.165 6800.253 6073.326 6162.01
11 EQ-X 5735.686 7080.72 7339.546 6749.272 6853.933 6121.296 6210.515
10 EQ-X 5773.044 7125.436 7384.142 6793.294 6898.428 6161.059 6250.722
9 EQ-X 5803.415 7166.048 7429.729 6829.409 6935.329 6193.699 6284.109
8 EQ-X 5827.521 7198.282 7465.912 6858.074 6964.618 6219.607 6310.608
7 EQ-X 5846.085 7220.502 7488.073 6879.948 6986.729 6239.365 6330.588
6 EQ-X 5859.83 7236.954 7504.48 6896.144 7003.099 6253.995 6345.38
5 EQ-X 5869.478 7248.502 7515.998 6907.513 7014.591 6264.264 6355.764
4 EQ-X 5875.753 7256.013 7523.488 6914.907 7022.064 6270.943 6362.518
3 EQ-X 5879.377 7260.351 7527.815 6919.178 7026.346 6274.8 6366.418
2 EQ-X 5881.074 7262.382 7529.84 6921.178 7028.346 6276.606 6368.244
1 EQ-X 5881.576 7262.986 7530.442 6921.772 7028.946 6277.14 6368.785

Table 6. 26: Base shear for EQ along transverse direction
LEVEL CASE 1 2 3 4 5 6 7
36 EQ-Y 419.5708 658.6491 749.1491 542.441 565.9691 478.9297 490.6192

35 EQ-Y 870.1044 1378.129 1553.548 1144.312 1193.483 993.374 1016.802
34 EQ-Y 1295.38 1986.043 2157.405 1713.289 1774.131 1474.288 1503.069
33 EQ-Y 1696.125 2558.893 2726.433 2249.448 2321.286 1927.464 1961.289
32 EQ-Y 2073.069 3097.72 3261.664 2753.763 2835.945 2353.724 2392.294
31 EQ-Y 2426.941 3603.566 3764.134 3227.209 3319.101 2753.893 2796.918
30 EQ-Y 2758.468 4077.472 4234.878 3670.761 3771.75 3128.794 3175.993
29 EQ-Y 3068.38 4520.479 4674.929 4085.394 4194.887 3479.252 3530.352
28 EQ-Y 3357.405 4933.63 5085.322 4472.082 4589.506 3806.091 3860.829
27 EQ-Y 3626.272 5362.997 5565.367 4835.096 4963.991 4113.098 4174.841
26 EQ-Y 3875.71 5761.336 6010.721 5171.877 5311.413 4397.92 4466.161
25 EQ-Y 4106.446 6091.165 6338.349 5480.58 5626.448 4658.844 4729.99
24 EQ-Y 4319.21 6395.303 6640.458 5765.238 5916.944 4899.444 4973.268
23 EQ-Y 4514.73 6674.792 6918.081 6026.825 6183.897 5120.544 5196.83
22 EQ-Y 4693.736 6930.673 7172.255 6266.317 6428.301 5322.969 5401.508
21 EQ-Y 4856.954 7163.987 7404.013 6484.688 6651.151 5507.542 5588.135
20 EQ-Y 5005.115 7375.777 7614.389 6682.913 6853.441 5675.086 5757.545
19 EQ-Y 5138.946 7567.084 7804.42 6861.967 7036.167 5826.427 5910.57
18 EQ-Y 5259.177 7759.087 8019.084 7024.297 7203.627 5963.713 6050.989
17 EQ-Y 5366.536 7930.533 8210.766 7169.249 7353.159 6086.301 6176.374
16 EQ-Y 5461.751 8066.639 8345.964 7296.637 7483.16 6193.973 6285.245
15 EQ-Y 5545.551 8186.428 8464.953 7408.754 7597.576 6288.737 6381.064
14 EQ-Y 5618.665 8290.942 8568.77 7506.573 7697.402 6371.417 6464.663
13 EQ-Y 5681.821 8381.221 8658.447 7591.07 7783.632 6442.836 6536.878
12 EQ-Y 5735.748 8458.308 8735.019 7663.22 7857.262 6503.818 6598.539
11 EQ-Y 5781.175 8523.244 8799.522 7723.997 7919.285 6555.188 6650.481
10 EQ-Y 5818.83 8577.07 8852.989 7774.375 7970.697 6597.77 6693.536
9 EQ-Y 5849.442 8625.956 8907.644 7815.706 8013.333 6632.724 6729.288
8 EQ-Y 5873.739 8664.757 8951.025 7848.511 8047.175 6660.468 6757.665
7 EQ-Y 5892.45 8691.504 8977.593 7873.545 8072.722 6681.627 6779.059
6 EQ-Y 5906.304 8711.307 8997.264 7892.08 8091.637 6697.293 6794.9
5 EQ-Y 5916.029 8725.208 9011.073 7905.091 8104.915 6708.29 6806.02
4 EQ-Y 5922.353 8734.249 9020.054 7913.553 8113.551 6715.442 6813.251
3 EQ-Y 5926.007 8739.472 9025.241 7918.44 8118.498 6719.574 6817.429
2 EQ-Y 5927.717 8741.916 9027.669 7920.728 8120.808 6721.508 6819.384
1 EQ-Y 5928.222 8742.643 9028.391 7921.408 8121.502 6722.079 6819.962

36
35
34
33
32
31
30
29
28
27
26
25
24 M-1
STOREY LEVEL
23
22 M-2
21
20
19 M-3
18
17
16 M-4
15
14
13 M-5
12
11
10 M-6
9
8 M-7
7
6
5
4
3
2
1
0 1000 2000 3000 4000 5000 6000 7000 8000
BASE SHEAR
Chart 6. 27: Base shear for Load case (EQ-X) for various Models
36
35
34
33
32
31
30
29
28
27
26
25 M-1
STOREY LEVEL
24
23
22
21
M-2
20
19 M-3
18
17
16 M-4
15
14
13 M-5
12
11
10 M-6
9
8
7 M-7
6
5
4
3
2
1
0 1000 2000 3000 4000 5000 6000 7000 8000 9000 10000
BASE SHEAR
Chart
Table 6. 6.
27:28: Base
Base shear
Shear byfor Load case
Response (EQ-Y)Analysis
Spectrum for various
andModels
Dynamic Wind Analysis along
Longitudinal and Transverse direction

MODEL Model description Response Spectrum Dynamic Wind
Analysis Analysis
1 Bare Frame 5457.222 5323.984 13620.29 23922.82
2 Concrete Core Wall & Outrigger 7206.919 7969.511 13161.6 21106.1

3 and Belt truss 7489.115 8240.381 13561.95 21106.1
Concrete Core Wall,
4 Outirgger(steel) 6690.629 7175.112 13161.6 21106.1
Concrete Core Wall,
5 truss(steel) 6813.233 7358.032 13161.6 21981.88
6 Steel Core Wall, Outrigger(steel) 5920.561 6034.398 13612 22069.45

30000
25000
20000
BASE SHEAR
RSA-X
15000
RSA-Y
GUST-X
10000
GUST-Y
5000
0
0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7
MODEL NO.
Chart 6. 29: Comparison of Base shear by Response Spectrum Analysis and Dynamic
Wind Analysis along Longitudinal and Transverse direction.

30000
25000
20000 M-1
BASE SHEAR
M-2
15000 M-3
M-4
10000 M-5
M-6
5000 M-7
0
ANALYSIS
Chart 6. 30: Comparison of Base shear for all Models
The table shows the comparison of base shear for different models by response spectrum analysis
and dynamic wind analysis in longitudinal and transverse direction. It is observed from the table
that base shear reading noted from dynamic wind analysis has the larger values compared to the
base shear reading noted by response spectrum analysis. From the graph it is also observed that
model 1 has less base shear compared to different models in longitudinal and transverse direction
for RSA and for DWA it is highest amongst all.
6.2.4 FUNDAMENTAL TIME PERIOD

All objects including buildings and the ground have a natural period, i.e. the time it takes to
swing back and forth, from point A to point B and back again. Seismic waves when travels under
the ground it also moves at its natural period. It will pose a problem if the period of both ground
an building resting on ground is same. When these two vibrate at the same rate, they resonate
which leads to disaster. Height is also one of major factors affecting the period.
The fundamental natural period, frequency and percentage of mass participated in X, Y and Z
direction has been tabulated in the table 6.13 to 6.19

Table 6. 28: Fundamental period and participation for Model 1
Mode Period Participation in X Participation in RZ
sec (%) Y
(%)
1 2.953 0.7442 0 0
2 2.93 0 0.789 0
3 2.392 0 0 0.7939
Fig.6. 1: Mode 1, Mode 2, Mode 3 for Model 1

sec (%) Y
(%)
1 2.619 0.7036 0 0
2 2.176 0 0.7397 0
3 2.002 0 0 0.8044

sec (%) Y
(%)
1 2.603 0.7019 0 0
2 2.171 0 0.7384 0
3 1.927 0 0 0.8167

sec (%) Y
(%)
1 2.68 0.7054 0 0
2 2.339 0 0.7344 0
3 1.994 0 0 0.8023

sec (%) Y
(%)
1 2.648 0.7021 0 0
2 2.292 0 0.7327 0
3 1.9 0 0 0.807

sec (%) Y
(%)
1 2.783 0.7357 0 0
2 2.599 0 0.7853 0
3 2.361 0 0 0.7951

sec (%) Y
(%)
1 2.75 0.7369 0 0
2 2.569 0 0.7881 0
3 2.216 0 0 0.8079
Fig.6.7: Mode 1, Mode 2, Mode 3 for Model 7
After the provision of bracings the frequency increases and time period goes on decreasing. By
the provision of the bracings there will be increase in stiffness of the member. The natural period
decreases as the stiffness of the building increases and thereby leading to increase in frequency

CHAPTER 7
CONCLUSION
CONCLUSIONS
The following Conclusions were drawn based on the Observations made:
1. The provision of outriggers and belt trusses in high rise buildings increases the stiffness
and stability of the building when compared to the building without outriggers under the
action of lateral loads (wind and earthquake loadings)
2. The Concrete Outrigger with belt truss Model shows minimum lateral displacement than
3. The Storey drift is minimum at the Outrigger levels
4. Bare frame model is flexible among all the models therefore to make a conventional RC
structural frames more effective to resist lateral forces in the form of seismic waves and
wind forces, some lateral structural members has to be in cooperated in the building
model in the form of shear walls, core walls, bracings.

REFERENCES
1) BS Taranath. (2012). Analysis and Design of Tall Buildings.
2) Bureau of Indian Standards. (2002). Indian Standard Criteria for Earthquake Resistant
Design of Structures, IS: 1893 (Part 1). New Delhi, India. Retrieved from
https://ia801902.us.archive.org/1/items/gov.law.is.1893.1.2002/is.1893.1.2002.pdf
3) Günel, M. H., & Ilgin, H. E. (2014). Tall buildings: Structural systems and aerodynamic
form. Tall Buildings: Structural Systems and Aerodynamic Form.
https://doi.org/10.1007/9781315776521
4) Mulla, A. K. (2015). a Study on Outrigger System in a Tall R.C Structure with Steel
Bracing. International Journal of Engineering Research & Technology, 4(07), 551–557.
5) Nanduri, P. . M. B. R. K., Suresh, B., & Hussain, I. (2013). Optimum position of
outrigger system for high-rise reinforced concrete buildings under wind and earthquake
loadings. American Journal of Engineering Research, 02(08), 76–89. Retrieved from
http://www.ajer.org/papers/v2(8)/J0287689.pdf
6) Nasir, S. R., & Patil, A. S. (2016). Lateral Stability Analysis of High Rise Building with
the Effect of Outrigger and Belt Truss System, 1948–1955.
7) Po Seng Kian. (2001). the Use of Outrigger and Belt Truss System for High-Rise
Concrete Buildings. Civil Engineering Dimension, 3(1), 36–41. Retrieved from
http://puslit2.petra.ac.id/ejournal/index.php/civ/article/view/15536
8) Stafford-Smith, B., & Coull, A. (1991). Tall Building Structures Analysis and Design.
9) Standards, B. of I. (1987). Indian Standard Code of Practice for Design Loads (other
than earthquake) For Buildings and Structures, Part – 3 Wind Loads, (IS: 875 (P). New
Delhi, India. Retrieved from http://abhashacharya.com.np/wp-
content/uploads/2017/01/is-875-3-1987.pdf
10) Thejaswini, R. M., & Rashmi, A. R. (2015). Analysis and Comparison of Different
Lateral Load Resisting Structural Forms, 4(07).

Compelete File

Caricato da

Informazioni sul documento

Copyright

Formati disponibili

Condividi questo documento

Condividi o incorpora il documento

Opzioni di condivisione

Hai trovato utile questo documento?

Questo contenuto è inappropriato?

Copyright:

Formati disponibili

Compelete File

Caricato da

Copyright:

Formati disponibili

CERTIFICATE

CHAPTER-4:METHODS OF ANALYSIS .............................................................................. 13

CHAPTER-5:ANALYTICAL MODELLING ......................................................................... 14

Fig.5. 1: Plan layout ..................................................................................................................................... 15

Fig.6. 1: Mode 1, Mode 2, Mode 3 for Model 1 .......................................................................................... 93

Department of Civil, LIET 1

1.2.THE STRUCTURAL SYSTEMS OF TALL BUILDINGS

1.3. OUTRIGGERED FRAME SYSTEMS

Department of Civil, LIET 2

Fig.1. 1:Outriggered frame system

Department of Civil, LIET 3

1.3.1. THE BEHAVIOR OF OUTRIGGERED FRAME SYSTEMS

Department of Civil, LIET 4

Department of Civil, LIET 5

Fig.1. 5: Diagram of the effect of the outrigger on the moment

Department of Civil, LIET 6

1.3.2. ADVANTAGES OF OUTRIGGERS

Department of Civil, LIET 7

2.2 PREVIOUS RESEARCH WORK ON OUTRIGGER AND BELT TRUSSES

Department of Civil, LIET 8

Department of Civil, LIET 9

Department of Civil, LIET 10

Department of Civil, LIET 11

Department of Civil, LIET 12

The analysis methods that are adopted are as follows,

Department of Civil, LIET 13

1.2 5.2 METHOD OF MODELLING

Department of Civil, LIET 14

Fig.5. 1: Plan layout

Department of Civil, LIET 15

Department of Civil, LIET 16

Department of Civil, LIET 17

Fig.5. 6: Perspective view of a storey

Department of Civil, LIET 18

Fig.5. 9: Perspective view of a storey showing

Department of Civil, LIET 19

Fig.5. 12: Perspective view of a storey showing

Department of Civil, LIET 20

Fig.5. 15: Perspective view of a storey showing outrigger &

Department of Civil, LIET 21

Department of Civil, LIET 22

Fig.5. 21: Perspective view of a storey showing outrigger

Department of Civil, LIET 23

5.3.2 DESIGN DATA

Department of Civil, LIET 24

1.3 5.4 DESIGN PROCEDURE

Department of Civil, LIET 25

Department of Civil, LIET 26

Department of Civil, LIET 27

(2) Peak Factor and Roughness Factor

Department of Civil, LIET 28

Fig.5. 23: Showing value of gfr and L(h)

Department of Civil, LIET 29

Along X Axis: λ=0.221

Along Y Axis: λ=0.221

The Background Factor B is determined from the Fig.9 of IS 875 (Part 3)

Department of Civil, LIET 30

h = height of the structure.

Fig.5. 25: Size reduction Factor S

Department of Civil, LIET 31

fo = natural frequency of the structure.

(6) Damping coefficient (β)

(7) Constant (Ø)

(8) Gust Factor (G)