Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
In 1987 Congress authorized the Stewart B. McKinney Homeless Assistance Act to protect the
rights of homeless students and to ensure that they receive the same quality and appropriate
education that other students receive. This article summarizes key aspects of the 2001
reauthorization of the act, now known as the McKinney-Vento Act, outlines how school
social workers can become more involved in the implementation, and offers suggestions for
expansion of services and further evaluation of service provision effectiveness.
KEY WORDS: education; homelessness; McKinney- Vento; school social work practice; students
I
being strong and resilient, as well as possessing spiri-
numerous educational barriers that homeless tual values.
children and adolescents face, including lack of This article looks at the problem of homeless-
transportation, residency restrictions, lack of per- ness in the United States, particularly for children
sonal and school records, guardianship problems, and youths and presents the needs and strengths of
and a lack of resources such as clothing and school homeless students. In addition, we explore key pro-
supplies (Rafferty, 1995; U.S. Department of Edu- visions of the 2001 McKinney-Vento Act (P.L. 100-
cation, 2001; Wall, 1996). Academically, homeless 628), which was designed to address these concerns.
and runaway students face increased risk of school Finally, we propose several pathways to greater in-
dropout, grade retention,low test scores,low grades, volvement of school social workers in the imple-
educational disabilities, and school behavior prob- mentation of the legislation as well as how they
lems (Israel, Urberg, & Toro, 2001; Jozefowicz- might augment the services they provide and evalu-
Simbeni, 2003; Masten, MiUotis, Graham-Bermann, ate the efEcacy of their work.
Ramirez, & Neemann, 1993; Ziesemer, Marcoux,
& Marwell, 1994). HOMELESSNESS IN THE UNITED STATES
Such conditions do not develop in a vacuum, Homelessness is an extreme condition of poverty
but are nested in a complex web of structural and that has been a long-standing concern of the social
environmental conditions. Homeless children ex- work profession. Although single adult men make
perience emotional and behavioral disorders, physi- up the majority of the homeless population, grow-
cal health problems, and developmental delays.The ing numbers of children, youths, single mothers,
problems are compounded by family circumstances and poor or working poor families are experienc-
of financial troubles, substance abuse, and mental ing homelessness in the United States (Swick, 2004;
and physical health issues. Furthermore, the nature U.S. Conference of Mayors, 2001). In a study of
of homelessness lends disturbingly well to parenting homelessness among urban women of childbear-
distress. AU of these forces conspire to nearly elimi- ing age, 11.4 percent of the 44,430 women in the
nate the homeless child from public school educa- study reported at least one episode of homelessness
tion. Yet, burgeoning research has begun looking in a seven-year period surrounding the birth of
into the strengths of homeless students and has found theirfirstchild (Webb, Culhane, Metraux, Robbins,
such youths to possess numerous qualities that can & Culhane, 2003). Mothers who were African
lead to positive adaptation to adulthood, including American, who had less education, and who had
HERNANDEZ JOZEFOWICZ-SIMBENI AND ISRAEL / Services to Homeless Students and Families: The McKinney-Vento Act 39
• waiting for a foster care placement or being dispute resolution (National Law Center on Home-
abandoned in a hospital lessness & Poverty, 2002) .Second, McKinney-Vento
• staying in a shelter, abandoned building, or indicates that services should be provided in a way
motel that allows homeless children to remain in the
• staying at a campground or inadequate trailer mainstream setting with their peers to avoid being
park ostracized, segregated, and harassed (U.S. Depart-
• living out of a car or in a bus or train station ment of Education, 2004).
• staying with friends or relatives as a result of States receive a minimum allotment of
no housing McKinney-Vento funding, which was $150,000 in
• staying in any public or private space not 2003 (U.S.DepartmentofEducation,2004).Grants
designed for or used as a regular sleeping place are given to all states, the District of Columbia, and
for human beings Puerto Rico depending on the amount of Title I
• staying in any of the described locations be- funds they receive. Grants also are given to the
cause they are from migratory families (U.S. outlying areas including the Virgin Islands, Ameri-
Department of Education, 2004). can Samoa, Guam, and the Commonwealth of the
Northern Mariana Islands. Funds also go to the
It is important to note that McKinney-Vento Bureau of Indian Affairs (U.S. Department of Edu-
included reference to preschool-age children, an- cation, 2004). States with a minimum allotment can
other group of homeless students that are often spend 50 percent of the funds on state-level activi-
more difficult to identify and pull into the main- ties performed by the state Office of Coordinator
stream educational system. Also, the law refers to for Education of Homeless Children and Youth.
special populations of homeless students that may States with more than the minimum allotment must
have unique needs, such as those living in domestic award 75 percent of their federal dollars to LEAs
violence shelters (U.S. Department of Education, through competitive grants.
2004).
McKinney-Vento also increased the scope of BARRIERS TO MCKINNEY-VENTO
policies and potential services to assist homeless IMPLEMENTATION
students in gaining access to and succeeding in their Although awareness, implementation, and funding
education. There are explicit prohibitions against of the McKinney-Vento Act have been expanding,
segregating students into a separate program or evidence suggests that barriers to its implementa-
school solely on the basis of homelessness, a pre- tion still exist (U.S. Department ofEducation, 2001).
sumption of school of origin as the placement in In a 2000 Congressional report based on a survey
the best interests of the student unless otherwise of state coordinators, respondents indicated that
indicated by the student or family, an immediate difficulty identifying homeless students, lack of
and continued enrollment in school of choice re- awareness of the needs of homeless students and
gardless of pending disputes, a required designation families, staff turnover, high staff to student ratios,
of a liaison for every LEA, and transportation to and limited funding were the primary barriers to
and from school of choice (U.S. Department of implementing the act at that time. There is also
Education, 2004). evidence that low levels of awareness of the act
Two main ideas pervade the act. First, school more generally remain problematic. In a study of
mobility should be minimized to mitigate school homeless liaisons in one county in Illinois,Thomp-
disruption and its effect on academic success. Fed- son and Davis (2003) found that significant num-
eral guidelines for implementing McKinney-Vento bers of liaisons were not aware that they were des-
apply a "One Child, One School, One Year" policy ignated as homeless liaisons by their LEAs, and they
and spell out requirements regarding enrollment, had little or no knowledge of the McKinney-Vento
transportation, and dispute resolution that include Act. Such ignorance could reflect school districts'
immediate enrollment in school without proof of own lack of knowledge or unwillingness to devote
residency, school records, or immunization records; resources to training and outreach. A lack of train-
choice between school attended before loss of hous- ing and outreach to parents, however, could be
ing, last school enrolled, or school affiliated with viewed as passive ways to deny services to these
present living arrangement; and a process for timely students and families.
HERNANDEZ JOZEFOWICZ-SIMBENI AND ISRAEL / Services to Homeless Students and Families: The McKinney-Vento Act 41
Overcoming Barriers months) and rarely were able to obtain services the
To increase knowledge and compliance, schools law designates. Possibly as a result of this, parents
need to identify local liaisons, educate them about perceived schools as being inadequately prepared
their function and roles, and advocate for training to deal with their needs or their children's needs.
and real support for these individuals.To overcome However, a strength of the mothers was that they
barriers to appropriate service delivery and facili- also stated a willingness to become and to stay in-
tate parental involvement, key roles homeless liai- volved with their children's education. School so-
sons and school social workers can play are those of cial workers could build on such strengths by link-
parent and staff educator and system advocate.They ing parents with the resources necessary to facilitate
can educate and sensitize school staff, other fami- their involvement in their child's education.
lies and students, and community agency workers Based on the findings, key recommendations to
(for example, shelter staff, protective service work- the district included hiring sufficient staff to effec-
ers) to the needs and rights of homeless children tively implement all aspects of the district's Educa-
and families. Concerted awareness-raising efforts tion of Homeless Student Plan, developing a sys-
would help increase compliance with McKinney- tem to identify and track homeless students and
Vento requirements, as well as decrease stereotyp- families, providing in-service training to educate
ing and other negative attitudes toward homeless staff about the McKinney-Vento Act, and conduct-
students and families that impede children's and ing outreach efforts to local shelters to provide in-
adolescents' emotional and academic growth formation to homeless students and families regard-
(Reganick, 1997). Furthermore, a strengths-based ing the act and their rights (Israel et al., 2003). In
approach that emphasizes homeless mothers' posi- addition, the study made recommendations regard-
tive views of their children (Israel & Jozefowicz- ing expanded school and social services to improve
Simbeni, 2004) and homeless students' high aspira- educational access and the academic success of
tions and positive views of themselves (Reganick) homeless students from preschool through high
could lead to more construcdve views, supports, school. Key recommendations in such reports have
and service provision for this population. broad applicability and can be used not only to
Because of a lack of knowledge and implemen- inform local program efforts, but also to inform
tation surrounding the McKinney-Vento Act, pro- efforts in other districts and states more generally.
grams designed to increase knowledge and com- Wider dissemination of program descriptions and
pliance continue to emerge and expand, and public evaluations, therefore, should be attempted, and
awareness of such programs is beginning to grow. school social workers can be instrumental in writ-
For instance, an article that appeared in the Chicago ing and publishing such reports. In addition to
Tribune described several programs for homeless stu- increasing knowledge, staffmg, and outreach to
dents that are run by the Regional Education Of- shelters, McKinney-Vento and reports on
fice and the Illinois Coalition to end Homelessness McKinney-Vento also suggest the importance of
(Mastony, 2003). One program involves four social linking homeless students and families to existing
workers who serve as centralized contacts to ad- services and school programs, including programs
dress student enrollment and problems that home- such as the free and reduced lunch program, after-
less students and families face. They also perform school programs, tutoring, special education. Tide
outreach to schools and shelters, educate schools I, and adult and vocational education (U.S. Depart-
about the act, and attempt to identify local liaisons ment of Education, 2001). One important area in
for each local school district (Mastony). need of more attention is the underrepresentation
In an attempt to develop and evaluate services to of homeless preschoolers in early education pro-
homeless students and families in an urban, high grams (U.S. Department of Education, 2001). Early
poverty district in Michigan, a quantitative and intervention and education is critical for both
qualitative needs assessment was conducted with remediation of early childhood delays and the pro-
50 elementary students and their mothers staying motion of school readiness, particularly for poor
in homeless shelters (Israel, Toro, & Jozefowicz- preschoolers (McLoyd, 2000). Early childhood pro-
Simbeni, 2003). Preliminary analyses of interview grams can serve as stable forces in the lives of home-
data revealed that these children were highly mo- less preschoolers who experience homelessness
bile (moving an average of four times in the past 12 (Douglass, 1996). Putting families of preschoolers
HERNANDEZ JOZEFOWICZ-SIMBENI AND ISRAEL / Services to Homeless Students and Families: The McKinney-Vento Aa 43
homeless families: Risks to mental health and Philadelphia, Pa. American fournat ofPubtic Health, 93,
development._/oMraa/ ofConsutting and Clinical 1895-1896.
Psychology, 61,2,35-343. Ziesemer, C , Marcoux, L., & Marwell, B. E. (1994).
Masten,A. S., Sesma, A., Jr., Si-Asar, R., Lawrence, C , Homeless children: Are they different from other
Miliotis, D , & Dionne,J.A. (1997). Educational low-income children? Sociat Work, 39,658-^68.
risks for children experiencing homelessness. JowrMd/
of School Psychology, 35, 27-46.
Mastony, C. (2003,July 2). Education program to aid Debra M. Hernandez Jozefowicz-Simbeni, PhD, is
homeless suburban kids. Chicago Tribune, p. Al.
assistant professor, Schoot of Sociat Work, Wayne State
McKinney-Vento Homeless Assistance Act of 1988, PL.
100-628,101 Stat. 482. University, 4756 Cass Avenue, Thompson Home, Room
McLoyd,V. C. (2000). Poverty: Childhood poverty. In 314, Detroit, MI 48202; e-mail: debj-s@wayne.edu.
A. E. Kazdin (Ed.), Encyctopedia of psychology (Vol. 6, Nathaniel Israel, MA, is Visiting Assistant in Research,
pp. 251—257). Washington, DC: American Psycho-
logical Association and Oxford University Press. Department ofChitd & Family Studies, Louis de la Parte
National Law Center on Homelessness & Poverty. (2002). Florida Mental Health Institute, University of South
Education of chitdren & youth in hometess situations. Ftorida, Tampa.
Washington, DC: Author. Available at http://
www.nlchp.org/content/pubs/Edu-new- Accepted June 7, 2005
children%20in%20homeless%20situations.doc
No Child Left Behind Act of 2001 (NCLB), PL. 107-
110, 115 Stat. 1425.
Rafferty,Y. (1995).The legal rights and educational
problems of homeless children and youth. Educa-
tional Evaluation and Policy Analysis, 17, 39—61.
Reganick, K. A. (1997). Prognosis for homeless children
and adolescents. Childhood Education, 73, 133—135.
Ringwalt, C. L., Greene, J. M., Robertson, M., &
McPheeters, M. (1998).The prevalence of homeless-
ness among adolescents in the United States.
American fournat of Public Health, 88, 1325-1329.
Schmitz, C L., Wagner, J. D , & Menke, E. M. (2001).The
interconnection of childhood poverty and home-
lessness: Negative impact/points of access. Families in
Society, 82,69-77.
Stewart B. McKinney Homeless Assistance Act of 1987,
PL. 100-77,101 Stat. 1425.
Swick, K.J. (2004). The dynamics of families who are
homeless: Implications for early childhood
educators. Childhood Education, SO, 116-120.
Thompson, J. A., & Davis, S. M. (2003, June). Educating
homeless children: Perceptions of school homeless tiaisons.
Poster presented at the 9th Biennial Conference,
Society for Community Research and Action, Las
Vegas.
United States Conference of Mayors. (2001, December).
A status report on hunger and homelessness in America's
cities, 2001:A 27-city survey. Retrieved May 18,
2004, from http://www.usmayors.org/uscm/
hungersurvey/2001/hungersurvey 2001.pdf
United States Conference of Mayors. (2003, December).
A status report on hunger and homelessness in
America's cities, 2003:A 25-city survey. Retrieved
May 18, 2004, from http://www.usmayors.org/
uscm/hungersurvey/2003/onlinereport/
HungerAndHomelessnessReport2003.pdf
US. Department ofEducation. (2001, December).
Education for hometess chitdren and youth program:
Report to Congress fiscat year 2000. Retrieved
October 24, 2004, from http://www.ed.gov/
programs/homeless/rpt2000.doc
U.S. Department ofEducation. (2004,July). Education for
hometess chitdren and youth program: Non-regutatory
guidance. Retrieved October 24,2004, from http://
www.ed.gov/programs/homeless/guidance.pdf
Wall,J. C. (1996). Homeless children and their families:
Delivery of educational and social services through
school systems. Sociat Work in Education, 18,135—
144.
Webb, DA., Culhane,J., Metraux, S., Robbins,J. M., &
Culhane, D. (2003). Prevalence of episodic
homelessness among adult childbearing women in