Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
utilization in Cayo.
Project Management
Project Title: Assessment of the suitability of Banana flour for domestic food utilization in Cayo.
Sector: NGO
Country: Belize
Estimated budget Year One: $1,185,000; Year Two: $190,000 Total: $1,375,000
Executive Summary:
Based on the statistics and the increasing awareness of the importance of Food and Nutrition
security there is need to reduce the quantity of food imported into the region. While there are
many imported items that may be classified as “luxury” items such as specialty foods, fruits of
temperate or subtropical origin and alcoholic beverages. Much is spent on specific commodities
that are used in large quantities throughout the region. These include essential carbohydrate
sources such as wheat, rice, pasta and corn are the major staples of the diet. Belize imports
7,915,734 pounds of flour amounting to $6,485,565 BZE currency from 2015 to present. (Belize
This research investigation was designed to convert banana into flour, utilize the flour in a
composite with wheat flour to produce selected products that form common items of the
Caribbean diet, and conduct basic sensory evaluation exercises to determine appropriate levels of
substitution for the wheat flour that would yield products of acceptable organoleptic properties,
this will be done using a public survey. Selected products will be muffin, and Bread.
While this recommendation is useful for general guidelines in the use of banana flour for similar
products, it must be emphasized that future work must be conducted for the different banana
cultivar across the region because of the inherent difference in biochemical content of these
cultivars that impact sensory quality. Evaluations will also have to be conducted to determine the
extent to which factors of the growing environment influence biochemical composition and thus
flour quality.
Acknowledgement:
We owe a great many thanks to a great many people who helped and supported us during the
conducting of this research project. Our deepest thanks to Mr. Ervin Gentle manager of Ministry
of Agriculture Processing lab and his staff for facilitating the processing of the banana flour and
We would also like to thank Mr. Jorge Cawich for giving us this challenge and guidance to
venture into a new project for the Cayo district. We have learned many valuable lessons and life
experience in the course of this project. The main objective of this project was to add value to a
fruit that does not has a long shelf life, with this process of the banana flour the fruit becomes
Worldwide awareness of the need to focus on food and nutrition security has increased due to the
current climatic conditions. Food and nutrition security is another way to combine elements of
both food security and nutrition security (Security, Committee on World Food, 2012). The
implanting of nutrition among food and security emphasizes that nutrition must be of importance
as not only to have food but to also have food of substances nutrition. The combined food import
bill (FIB) for the 14 Caribbean Community member states sky-rocketed from US$2.08 billion in
2000 to US$4 billion in 2008, and surpassed the US$4.25 billion mark in 2011 (FAO, 2013).
While there are many imported items that may be classified as “luxury” items such as specialty
foods, fruits of temperate or subtropical origin and alcoholic beverages much is spent on specific
commodities that are used in large quantities throughout the region. These include essential
carbohydrate sources such as wheat, rice, pasta and corn that constitute major staples of the
Caribbean diet.
For food and nutrition security it is imperative that the region addresses its dependency on
imported carbohydrate foods or energy foods. The challenge is to reproduce these quality
properties in food made from locally produced alternate flours. One way to do this is to increase
the use of food of a particular type. Fresh use will be limited hence the way to go is through
value addition through production of flour to make what would normally be made from wheat
flour.
This project work focused on the production of banana flour the use as composite flour with
wheat flour to make products such as bread and muffins that are traditionally made with wheat
flour alone. For such products, the levels of substitution are critical to ensure their acceptability.
The objective being the reduction of the quantity of wheat flour being imported and the increase
production of the local alternate flour in order to stimulate the economy in a beneficial manner.
This will reduce the current importation of flour to 50% and have a huge impact on the health of
According to Mr. Giovanny Canto, data analysist personnel, from the Belize Agriculture Health
Authority (B.A.H.A) reported that the total importation of wheat for the period of 2015-2018
was seven million nine hundred fifteen thousand seven hundred and thirty four pounds
(7,915,734) with a total cost of six million four hundred eight five thousands five hundred and
sixty five (6,485,565). For food and nutrition security it is imperative that Belize addresses its
dependency on imported carbohydrate foods or energy foods. There are many imported items
that may be classified as “luxury” items such as specialty foods, fruits of temperate or
subtropical origin and alcoholic beverages. Much is spent on specific commodities that are used
in large quantities such as essential carbohydrate sources such as wheat, rice, pasta and corn
The challenge is to reproduce these quality properties in food made from locally produced
alternate flours. One way to do this is to increase the use of food of a particular type. Fresh use
will be limited hence the way to go is through value addition through production of banana flour
Banana is a major food crop globally and is grown and consumed in more than a hundred
countries in the tropics and sub-tropics (INIBAP 2000). In developing countries they are the
fourth most important food crop after rice, wheat and maize (INIBAP 2000). The banana plant is
tall arborescent monocotyledon with a false stem (pseudostem) consisting of leaf sheaths and an
underground true stem (Corm) that is able to produce suckers in which the plant can reproduce
vegetatively. Banana (Musa spp.) has been a commercial crop in Belize from the late 1800s. It is
an important crop to Belize because it was one of the first crops that the descendants of Africans
slaves turned to in order to earn money. Cultivation of this crop was learnt by trial and error
because the Government never arranged for empirical experiments to carry out. However, it
became clear to small farmers that the soils in the south of Belize could be used for Banana
Many researchers have prepared products using green banana flour in order to increase the non-
digestible fraction, represented by resistant starch and fibers when unpeeled bananas are used
(JUAREZ et al., 2006; APARICIO et al., 2007; RODRIGUEZ et al., 2008; MARTINEZ et al.,
2009). The scientific evidence of non-digestible fraction as functional food is strong. (SHIH et
al.,2007) demonstrated the positive effect of resistant starch intake in reducing the levels of
diabetic rats due to the increase in superoxide dismutase activity and decreased levels of
with fewer macroscopic and microscopic lesions, suggesting that introducing green banana flour
into the diet can be a complementary strategy in the treatment of patients with intestinal
Banana is a tropical fruit that easily rot; fruit color has changed rapidly by physical influences
such as sunlight and cuts, and influence of biological (fungus). On the other hand, the current
banana production is relatively abundant, especially in Belize in the southern region of the
cultivation is essential to prolong the shelf, so it can be a value-added product. In addition, the
diversification of food is a way out which is currently considered the most rational way to solve
the problem of meeting the needs of food especially carbohydrates. Through compliance with a
diet that does not originate from a single food source, allowing people to define their own food
choices, food security raise their families, which leads to an increase in national food security.
Bananas can be processed and preserved to various forms of processed products such as banana
flour, banana sale, banana juice, banana wine, banana chips, banana sauce and banana jam and
other processed. Presently the fruit can be picked up in the southern region of the country at the
processing facilities for free which are known as the “reject banana” and can be purchase all over
the country for $1 BZE for 10. (The Belize Ag Report 2017)
Materials and Methods:
The banana was purchased from San Ignacio market. The process of obtaining the raw material
being banana was quite easy due to the abundance of the fruit all year around. The source of the
banana was from the southern region of the country, the market vendor (Mr. Valdez) explained
to us that 2 times per week personnel deliver the fruit to him. After the banana was inspected
physically, a few bananas were selected at random to be cleaned and peeled. The banana were
then washed hand peeled using knives, sliced with the Hobart Slicer at 5/32” thickness then the
slices were placed in the food dehydrator for 11hours at 57⁰C. The dried slices were grounded
into a fine powder using the Meadows Mill Stone Burr Mill. The powder was sieved using 0.5
microns sieve to separate the larger particles allowing the powder to be collected. The sieved
particles were then passed through the mill for a second milling. Finally the banana flour was
stored in double plastic bags at room temperature in a dry cool area. The process was done at the
Appendix 1:
3g Yeast minutes
18g Brown Sugar 6. Grease two 9" round cake tins with a
minutes
1. Sift flour in a large bowl
9. Preheat oven to 350 degrees and
2. Add yeast, sugar, salt, margarine
place tins in oven to cook for 30-35
and combine ingredients until well
minutes or until tops of bakes are
incorporated
lightly browned.
3. Add water, 1 cup at a time, and mix
1 3 Yield: 12 muffins
Ingredients Directions:
250g white flour 1. Preheat the oven to 250°F.
125g banana flour 2. Butter muffin pans.
18g baking powder 3. Mix 1 flour, baking powder, salt,
yeast and sugar in a large bowl.
3g salt (Bowl 1)
85g sugar 4. In another bowl (bowl 2) mix 1 cup
of banana flour and 300ml boiling
2 eggs, slightly beaten
water, once mixed let it stand for 10
250ml milk mins.
15-20 minutes
Research Design:
The banana flour was used to make various baked products as fruit muffin and bread that were
tasted to determine the level of irritation the taster received. This was done as a preliminary
investigation due to the organoleptic properties of the banana. The baked products were made
using the banana flour at fifty (50%) percentage and the texture, taste, aroma, and appearance
were recorded by a small panel of tasters. All products had great acceptability for appearance,
taste, texture, aroma, and preference, but there was a problem with accreditation experienced by
some tasters. The main objective of the preliminary tasting was to determine significant
The study was conducted in the Central Farm area, where workers got to taste the final product.
The conversion of the raw banana to banana flour then unto muffin and bread was conducted in
the Food Processing lab using resources from within the lab to ensure that quality was
maintained and proper recording of data was done. The sampling group was a total number of
ten (10).
Data Collection:
Data were collected using sensory evaluation in order to determine the relative acceptability of
the products made. The approach used was as detailed in the following section.
Research Procedures:
1. The food samples were prepared using the methods and procedures as shown in the appendix.
Samples were served in plastic plates with each sample being in separate plates having a random
2. Each taster tasted each sample and placed a tick in the box, from '1 Dislike very much' to '5
Like very much' to indicate their preference. See appendix 3 for sample data collection sheet.
3. The results were analyzed with the highest/lowest scores in each of the various categories for
each product, the mean, mode and median as well was generated.
Data Analysis:
The data obtained from the sampling was analyzed using the Statistical Package for the Social
Science (SPSS) software where a descriptive statistic data was generated. The results obtained
were the frequency, distribution (mean, variance, standard deviation). Descriptive statistics is the
term given to the analysis of data that helps describe, show or summarize data in a meaningful
way for example, patterns emerged from the data. It does not, however, allow us to make
conclusions beyond the data we have analyzed. The method is used simply to describe our data.
The measure of distribution was used to summarize how distributed the scores were. To describe
the spread, a number of statistics was made available, including the range, variance and standard
deviation. The descriptive statistics used allowed for the summarization of the group of data by
using a combination of tabulated description such as tables, graphical description (i.e., graphs
and charts) and statistical commentary (discussion of the results). The mean, median, and mode
were generated where the mean is the average, the median is the middle score for a set of data,
and the mode is referred to as the most frequent score from the data set.
Chapter Summary:
In summary general method and materials used in the production of the banana flour such as the
sampling the products were conducted to ensure acceptability among a small panellist.
Results:
The quality of the banana flour was acceptable. The appearance of the flour was an off white
colour with a very fine particle size. The total weight of the banana was 40kg, weight of the
waste was 2.89kgs; the weight of the cleaned banana was 37kgs; therefore the dressing
percentage of the banana was calculated by taking the weight of the waste of banana divide by
the total weight of the banana times 100. (wt waste/total wt) X 100 (2.89kg/40kg) x 100= 7.25%.
The weight of the dried banana slices was 10.69kgs. The drying percent was calculate as follows;
weight of the dried slices divided by the total weight of the clean banana banana times 100. (wt.
After the successful manufacturing of the banana flour the next step was to make the muffin and
bread. The results of the hedonic testing and the descriptive analysis conducted on the data yield
Appendix 2
Table 2: The above that shows the values obtained after conducting statistical analysis of the muffin. Displayed in the table are
values for number of sample, the mean, standard deviation, standard error mean and the significant figure. All the values in the
table are important but the key values that will be used in the discussion are the significant figures.
5.00
4.00
Mean appearance
3.00
2.00
1.00
0.00
M1 M2 B1 B2
Mean 4.53 3.76 4.47 3.53
Figure 1: Displays the mean of the baked products, muffin and bread. The primary parameter tested was appearance.
Taste of baked products
4
Mean taste
0
M1 M2 B1 B2
Mean 4.12 3.71 4.53 3.41
Figure 2: Displays the mean values for the baked products under the parameter of taste.
4.5
4
3.5
Mean aroma
3
2.5
2
1.5
1
0.5
0
M1 M2 B1 B2
Mean 3.88 3.53 4.24 3.94
Figure 3: displays the mean values of the bake products under the parameter of aroma.
Texture of bake products
4.5
4
3.5
Mean texture
3
2.5
2
1.5
1
0.5
0
M1 M2 B1 B2
Mean 4.29 3.76 4.24 3.53
Figure 4: displays the mean values of the bake products under the parameter of texture.
4.5
4
3.5
Mean preference
3
2.5
2
1.5
1
0.5
0
M1 M2 B1 B2
Mean 4.18 3.82 4.41 3.65
Figure 5: displays the mean values of the bake products under the parameter of overall preference.
To summarize the results obtained, the values are showing that few parameters are in close
range. When comparing each product is compared to each other in the parameters using the
significant figures in table 1, the results indicate that there is a difference in various
characteristics of the quality parameter. The assumption at the initial start of the test was that no
difference existed between flour samples (Ho : M1 = M2). The alternative to the hypothesis is
that within the flour samples there are differences (HA : M1 ≠ M2). The rule of thumb is as
follows: If P-value is less than 0.05 we reject the null hypothesis (Ho); there are no differences
between flour. Therefore the values in table 1 in the column labelled significant figure (Sig. Fig)
are then used to determine if the null hypothesis remains or if it’s excluded. The values in table 1
indicate that the bread variables that are governed by the rule of thumb are appearance, taste,
preference which each had a value of 0.004, 0.003 and 0.019 respectively. The next product
muffin rejected the null hypothesis in the variable of appearance with a p-value of 0.014.
Discussion:
The data in the results indicated that there are indeed differences between B1 and B2 in variables
such as taste, preference and appearance. In the bake product, the bread was said to be too light
in colour in appearance thus reflecting the high composite of the flour which retains more water,
increases baking time and also prevents the change of colour on the surface of the bread to occur.
The taste being the second variable indicated a difference; the texture of the flour was recognized
as the single most factors affecting the taste of B2 which had both 50% composite and wheat
flour. Both variables also affected the preference which was different after the statistical study.
The majority of the samplers pointed out the appearance and taste are the leading senses that
With the research being done we want to focus mainly in the Central part of the Cayo district to
focus on the demand of the banana flour. We want to open a factory to produce the flour so that
it can be readily available to consumers. This will entail of a facility, machineries, delivery
trucks and workers so that the factory of the flour can be up and running for the consumers. We
want apply for a Fiscal Incentive, this is because the equipment needed for the factory are not
Gantt chart
Activities Total
Budget
Jan Feb Mar Apr May Jun Jul Aug Feb Dec
$1,375,000 2019 2019 2019 2019 2019 2019 2019 2019 2021
Task 1: $500,000
Construction of
Building
Resistance to
diseases and pests
Appendix 5
Log Frame
Produces Banana flour, eligible 20 Percent of district Data from BAHA and
to mix with wheat flour as to population accept product custom shows decline District people
Purpose
improve health quality. due to health aspect with in wheat flour entry. accept and adapt
12 months of production. to local produces
Improve human health life
flour.
fields. Agriculture.
The single building will consist of office, restroom, and storage room and most important the processing
room as shown in drawing. The processing room will be highly equipped to food standards and potential
Appendix 6
Date:
Place a tick in the box that best suits your response. Thank you for your time
Sex: and honest response :)
Appearance Taste Aroma Texture Overall Preference
B1 B2 B1 B2 B1 B2 B1 B2 B1 B2
Like Very Much(5)
Like Moderately(4)
Neither Like or Dislike(3)
Dislike Moderately(2)
Dislike Very Much(1)
In main objective of this project was to raise the awareness of food and nutrition security within
the region as the Caribbean region is more than 60% dependent on imported goods. With the
increase in fuel prices and climate change, food transportation cost will increase and the
imported products will increase in cost with a ripple effect of cash flow movement slow down.
The region is known for its large group of carbohydrates storage crops with can be utilized as a
substitute for the traditional wheat flour. Trials in the project presented focus on a specific level
which was half composite flour to half traditional flour. Reason being in case of emergency food
shortage these crops can be used to produce one of the most consumed products in the region.
The product will not solely be beneficial in terms of food and nutrition security but also in
stimulating the economy by job creation in the field of production, processing, and utilization of
the composite flour. After analysing the data it is evident that the small samples are undecided as
whether they like or dislike the products. A few areas were pointed out for improvement
appearance, taste of the bread, and the appearance of the muffin of 50% composite flour and
50% wheat flour, this will be adjusted from seeking international consultancy expertise. The
availability of the banana in the quantity required for manufacturing of the flour is heavily
One of the major limitations during the project while being conducted was the availability of the raw
material being the banana in district. As the banana industries are settled on the southern part of the
country, therefore it increases the cost of the banana transportation from industry to processing facility.
Secondly we encounter problems due to the unavailability of personal equipment and facility. Lastly,
another limitation was that of the quantity required to produce the required amount of banana flour
needed to conduct the experiments. However, when requesting quantity, it might affect the quality.
Therefore, if the quality of the banana is affected it will affect the end produce being banana flour and
Recommendations:
Due to the high health benefits that the banana flour offers it is recommended for the Ministry of Health
and Agriculture sector to assist in promoting this new and valuable product in feeding programs for the
needy and to educate the public about the health value the product has to offer. This can be done in