Sei sulla pagina 1di 7

Gkionakis

The refugee crisis in Greece: training


border security, police, volunteers
and aid workers in psychological
first aid
Nikolaos Gkionakis

As the Syrian refugee crisis continues unabated, Organisation for Migration (IOM) and
Greece remains one of the ¢rst ports of sanctuary. local, Greek nongovernmental organisations
While the country is still gripped by one of the worst (NGOs) to provide training.
¢nancial and societal crises of the past 40 years, little From my perspective, the refugee crisis
attention or funding was available to provide mental began in Greece many years ago, before
health and psychosocial support to migrants or refu- 2000. The Greek state had a history of not
gees. In 2007, Nikolaos Gkionakis, along with other providing due care for the refugees that
colleagues, founded the Babel Day Centre to provide had arrived years ago from Kurdistan,
mental health care and psychosocial support for Turkey and African countries. Usually, these
migrants and refugees. When the current crisis asylum seekers had to wait for an extremely
began, he was perfectly placed as one of the trainers long time (10^15 years) before their appli-
for a project training border security, police, volun- cations were even examined. In the mean-
teers and aid workers in psychological ¢rst aid and time, no social care was provided and
self care for carers in Greece.This personal re£ection living conditions available were very bad.
gives context and background to the crisis, discusses Several factors have contributed to this over
the Babel Day Centre, and highlights and details the years: (1) the fact that most of the refugees
the psychological ¢rst aid project, which was follow a di¡erent, and for many, hostile
supported by both the WarTrauma Foundation and religion; (2) they have a completely di¡erent
the United Nations High Commission for Refugees. and ‘distant’ ethno-cultural background;
and (3) Greece (still) has a very obsolete
Keywords: Greece, psychological ¢rst aid, social state unable to face the challenges
refugee, Syria represented by the in£ux of refugees. Four
years ago, the country entered one of the
most severe ¢nancial and societal crises of
Introduction the past 40 years, with the arrival of refugees
I am a psychologist with an MSc degree in becoming overwhelming in 2015.
Social Psychiatry and have participated in In terms of those with mental health issues or
the creation of quality improvement meth- disorders, the lack of resources discouraged
odology and tools for psychosocial rehabili- many professionals from even attempting
tation units in Greece. Additionally, I am to meet the complex and multiple needs of
an experienced trainer of mental health these migrants and refugees. This lack of
professionals, and since 1998 I have collabo- resources not only a¡ected them, but also
rated with several international organis- created unsustainable situations. When
ations, such as World Health Organization working on mental health reform in the
(WHO), United Nations High Commission country, my colleagues and I noted this lack
for Refugees (UNHCR), International in migrants’and refugees’mental health care.

73
Copyright © War Trauma Foundation. Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited.
The refugee crisis in Greece: training border security, police, volunteers and aid workers in psychological first aid,
Intervention 2016, Volume 14, Number 1, Page 73 - 79

To ¢ll this gap we collectively prepared and is almost a stereotype. Yet, the migration
submitted a proposal to the Greek Ministry condition is common in human history.
of Health, which was approved. In 2007, There is a plethora of di¡erent reasons for
we founded the Babel Day Centre, a mental these movements; they can be coercive or
health unit for migrants and refugees. mass movements (as in the case of refugees).
The migration condition comprises a
reality of particular complexity, uniqueness
Babel Day Centre and totality (Papadopoulos, 2002), therefore
Babel receives requests from anyone regard- any approach that explores and/or inter-
less of age, gender, ethnicity, religion and/ venes must acknowledge such character-
or residence status (legal residence or not) istics. Not identifying these complexities
who lives in Athens. It also receives requests can render many interventions designed
pertaining to couples and families. From for this purpose as ine¡ective, giving results
January 2008, when clinical work began, far from what had been expected
until December 2014, Babel received 2,593 (Losi, 2006).
requests, 1,481 of which were undertaken as
‘cases’, for people from 74 di¡erent countries.
Many were seeking asylum and have been Current crisis
waiting for years for their request to be Tounderstandtheextentofthecurrentcrisis,it
examined, some needed particular attention is important to look at some of the data: as of
such as unaccompanied minors, survivors 30 September 2015, 390,814 people are
of torture and victims of tra⁄cking. Others reported to have arrived in Greece sinceJanu-
were identi¢ed as refugees or granted with ary, compared to 43,500 during the whole of
humanitarian protection status. Many wish 2014; 72,946 people out of 390,814 entered by
to request asylum, but not to live in Greece, sea during the ¢rst two weeks of September
so they do not apply for asylum and live in 2015 only, bringing the average daily arrivals
the country without o⁄cial status or regis- to 4,500. Top nationalities include Syrians
tration. Some have arrived and are willing (70%), Afghans (19%) and Iraqis (4%). By
to stay, but soon discover that things are the end of November 2015, according to the
not quite as expected and realise they must UNHCR, the statistics were as follows: total
either go back or proceed to another arrivals from January to November 2015
destination. reached 703,374, with 101,736 arriving in
The starting point of psychosocial support November alone, reaching a daily average of
and care for this group of people is the pre- 5,100.This had gone down from the daily rates
mise that migrants and refugees with mental inOctober2015ofapproximately 6,800people
health issues and/or mental disorders per day. The top nationalities from October/
(who can be characterised by their triple November, respectively, are as follows: Syrian
otherness: the migration condition, di¡erent (51/54%); Afghans (30/25%); Iraqi (11/8%);
ethno-cultural origins, mental disorder and Iranian (3/4%). Most people arrive on
experience) are occupying particularly the islands of the eastern Aegean Sea. Over
vulnerable positions. At the same time, they the course of 2015 (until15 November) deaths
also have su⁄cient reserves of resilience, so due to shipwrecks were listed at 199, with
the overall goal of Babel is to provide the 110 persons listed as missing (UNHCR, 2015).
appropriate care and support services to These huge, unprecedented numbers have
underpin this resilience. made it impossible for reception mechanisms
It is very easy to fall into the trap of seeing to meet needs. The severe lack of hosting
every migrant as ‘traumatised’ by adverse con- facilities, an inadequate registration system,
ditions, especially in the case of refugees. It and the lack of a proper identi¢cation and

74
Copyright © War Trauma Foundation. Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited.
Gkionakis

referral system for the most vulnerable after registration that they were allowed to
among the newly arrived have all been leave the island and reach the mainland by
major issues of concern. In September 2015, ship. At the registration centre, Syrians had
no First Reception Centre (FRC) nor been prioritised, creating a lot of anger and
Mobile Unit (FRMU) had been operating con£ict with refugees of other nationalities,
in Chios, Kos, Leros or Rhodes, while Samos sometimes becoming violent and requiring
was still only equipped with a FRMU, which the intervention of the police (The Guardian,
was completely unequipped to meet the 21 November 2015). On days the weather
needs of the numbers of refugees arriving prevented ships from sailing to Piraeus, the
daily (Asylum in Europe, 2015). problems grew and intensi¢ed as more and
It also became evident very quickly that more people gathered, creating a bottle-
people entering Greece in such massive neck. After registration, for those entering
numbers were moving to other countries. by Lesvos, most refugees headed to Athens.
Perhaps this facilitated the creation of a If they remain in Athens for a stop-over, they
strong solidarity movement willing to sup- can ¢nd shelter in one of the two shelters that
port this large population. Many Greek are open. In one of them (Elaionas) there
and international NGOs, single citizens, was no warm water for over one month,
informal groups of volunteers and collective which meant 500 of the 700 places were
initiatives are involved in helping refugees empty. After a short stay in Athens, they
as they move through Greece. The press proceed to Idomeni, near the border with
has also supported these initiatives or, at the FormerYugoslav Republic of Macedonia
least, has not reacted in a negative way. (FYROM), from which place they can enter
other, neighbouring countries.
It is important to note that there are few
Reception is lacking in dignity and provisions concerning the so-called vulner-
respect able groups. While things are better for
However, despite superhuman e¡orts made unaccompanied minors, there is no particu-
mainly by volunteers, NGOs and the islands’ lar concern nor care provided for the rest.
inhabitants, the reception for these refugees However, it must also be understood that,
remains lacking in dignity and respect. even if such provisions existed, almost no
When I visited Lesvos in October 2015, one would likely bene¢t from them as all
during what locals referred to as ‘the worst people try to pass through Greece as soon
weather of the past 30 years’, refugees kept as possible, despite any particular needs.
coming, without interruption. The day we visited Moria, it was raining
It was well known that these refugees heavily. As we arrived by taxi from Myti-
were the poorer ones, as due to the terrible lene, the capital of the island, we observed
conditions on the sea, the crossing cost was the registration site: a place situated far away
less than half of the‘usual’price ($600 instead from any residential area, high wire fences
of $1500^1700). As they arrived, there were completely surrounded the site, people com-
groups of volunteers and NGOs waiting to ing and going. There was some agitation;
o¡er ¢rst aid and immediate support to we were told that in the morning Afghan
them, however, there was no coordination refugees had ‘invaded’ the ‘Syrian sector’, pro-
and no cooperation between the groups. testing there should be equal treatment.
The refugees were guided to Moria, where The police had intervened and used tear
there is a registration centre. There they gas to ward o¡ the ‘invaders’. Small children
had to wait to be registered, sometimes for were crying while their parents were trying
days, depending on the number of new to protect them from the heavy rain, cover-
arrivals.They had little choice, as it was only ing them with blankets. Garbage was

75
Copyright © War Trauma Foundation. Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited.
The refugee crisis in Greece: training border security, police, volunteers and aid workers in psychological first aid,
Intervention 2016, Volume 14, Number 1, Page 73 - 79

everywhere. The place exhaled misery. We sea. The survivors, including the father and
had come to the site for an appointment, his two older children were rescued by the
but were, in the end, unable to meet. We Hellenic Coast Guard. One day later, the
needed to leave and called for a taxi, waiting body of the little girl was found. The young
30 minutes in the rain. It was a very di⁄cult boy is still missing. All sta¡ involved in the
situation, but our hotel was waiting for us management of this case, at ¢rst rescue and
at the end of the taxi ride.The refugees could later on in Athens, were shocked. Sadly,
do nothing but stay there, exposed to the this was not the only case of survivors
heavy rain. needing aid.
Recognising the impact of this skills gap, the
War Trauma Foundation (WTF), in collab-
Project: Psychological First Aid oration with the UNHCR, took the initiative
for police, border security, Coast to provide training on psychological ¢rst
Guard, NGO and UNHCR aid (PFA) through a series of seminars
personnel, translators, local aimed at those on the ‘front line’. The project:
partners and volunteers in ‘PFA assistance for Police, Border security, Coast
Greece Guard, NGO, UNHCR personnel, translators, local
The massive and continuous in£ux of refu- partners and volunteers in Greece’, was scheduled
gees since January 2015, and the circum- to last one month (October 2015). The objec-
stances under which they were received in tive was twofold: (1) to train uniformed
Greece, provoked a mass solidarity reaction (Border Security and Police), NGO and
from all over the world. Many people came UNHCR sta¡, as well as volunteers to
to Athens, and even more to the islands, to develop PFA skills to provide practical care
help either as volunteers or under the initia- and support to arriving refugees; and (2) to
tive of national and international NGOs. support sta¡ involved (stress management,
The vast majority had no previous experi- self care). The training was to be provided
ence nor skills in providing care for refugees, for 320 participants, half English speaking
often arriving with nothing more than good and half of Greek speaking, at the following
will and availability. In particular, they sites: Athens, Lesvos, Kos, Samos, Chios
had no experience in shipwreck response or and Kilkis (near the border of FYROM).
in dealing with survivors of shipwrecks.
I had the‘opportunity’to understand what that
means, for both those aiding survivors of Preparation for the training seminars
shipwrecks, and the challenges facing survi- Before training began, two experienced
vors themselves. In Athens, I met a family WTF o⁄cers visited sites to assess needs,
of survivors.The father of the family had £ed involve local actors in the organisation of
with his four children, 4, 6, 9 and 10 years- the seminars and prepare the ¢eld. This
old, two boys and two girls. His wife had died assessment and preparation phase lasted
some months before their departure, so he one week. In the meantime, trainers were
was alone with the children. At the time of contacted, three of whom were Greek speak-
departure from the Turkish coast, he did ing (Prof. dr. Renos Papadopoulos,
not want to embark as he found the boat Amina Moskof, MSc and myself) and two
was too old and unsafe. He says a gun was international, English speaking, PFA experts
put to his head, so he had no choice but to (Margriet Blaauw, MD and JellyVan Essen,
enter the boat with his children and 80^90 PhD). Other preparations included: trans-
other people in total. The boat capsized lation of the relevant training material into
and they all fell into the sea. Two of the chil- Greek (the slides to be used for the presenta-
dren, the youngest ones, were lost to the tions, role play and other exercises, the PFA

76
Copyright © War Trauma Foundation. Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited.
Gkionakis

pocket guide, evaluation sheets, etc.), which requested to keep their mobile phones
was to facilitate participation of the broadest switched o¡.
groups of Greek and international sta¡, They were all committed, motivated and
and volunteers. The UNHCR undertook exhausted. One said, at the very beginning
responsibility for the venue and availability of the ¢rst session: ‘for me to participate in this
of audio-visual equipment, as well as all training is as if I have taken a day o¡.’All of the
communications concerning training ses- participants mentioned an appreciation
sions. The UNHCR also undertook the task that the sessions began with each person
of identifying and inviting trainees. introducing themselves, it was often the ¢rst
It was not easy to organise these seminars, opportunity to get to know people they
especially on the islands. In fact, as no one had been working with all along. Also, they
was able to ascertain what would happen were often unaware of each other’s responsi-
day-by-day (for example, new shipwrecks), bilities. They all said they had been over-
it was di⁄cult to identify the most suitable whelmed by their work and experiences,
days for the roll-out. Other practical issues, struggling through on their own, without
such as accommodation availability, also any support to face the challenges of the situ-
had an impact on how things were organ- ation. Some of them, working in crucial
ised. In the end, the seminars took place positions, lacking any other appropriate
from 10th to 30th October. First in Chios means of communication, had to resort to
and Samos, then in Athens, Kilkis and texting in order to manage emergency issues
Lesvos, and ¢nally in Kos. In total, 238 pro- such as reception of new arrivals or ship-
fessionals and volunteers participated in the wrecks. During the breaks in the training
training sessions carried out in both Greek sessions, they often updated each other
and English. The sessions on all locations in regard to new shipwrecks, losses and
were carried out according to the PFA Facil- drownings.
itator’s Guide. However, facilitators, based on They participated actively in the sessions
their experience and sensitivity, were £exible and managed very well, especially during
and adapted the sessions according to needs the third session, which began with initial
presented during the training. simulations. In PFA training, there is an
initial simulation of an emergency, where
trainees are asked to act either as survivors
A training example: Greek language or helpers, following a concrete scenario
seminars in Lesvos concerning response to di¡erent crisis
In total, 35 people participated in three events.
Greek language PFA training sessions in Participants requested more time to learn
Lesvos, where I facilitated the training. what the others did, and so this became part
Some trainees (two in each session) only of the ‘preparation’ phase of the seminar
participated in one day of the one and a and, in particular, was added to ‘obtaining
half day sessions. Participants came from information on available resources’. Additionally,
various NGOs, the Hellenic police, the as a result of feedback from the participants
Hellenic coast guard and the UNHCR, on improving e¡ective collaboration with
both paid sta¡ and volunteers. They were the interpreters and on culturally sensitive
lawyers, psychologists, sociologists, social issues, some changes were introduced in the
workers, administrative sta¡, o⁄cers and training package. For example, issues such
interpreters. Due to the importance of their as how to approach people coming from
work and the need for continuous availabil- ‘collective cultures’, what are cultural factors
ity in case of emergency, it was also a series in£uencing responses to adversity, loss and
of seminars in which trainees could not be how grief is expressed were also discussed.

77
Copyright © War Trauma Foundation. Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited.
The refugee crisis in Greece: training border security, police, volunteers and aid workers in psychological first aid,
Intervention 2016, Volume 14, Number 1, Page 73 - 79

Personally, I was astonished by the lack of help to o¡er relief, and to recognise when
prior training for most of participants, as well specialist intervention is required. It was an
as the lack of supervision or any form of sup- e¡ective manner to resolve the situation, as
port for carers, with very few exceptions. much as it was possible to ‘resolve’, and
One of the participants mentioned that they additionally o¡ered a unique opportunity
had been asking for PFA training for more for training participants to put training prin-
than a year before it had been realised. ciples into practice.
Another important facet of the training was
that it o¡ered participants the opportunity
Concluding comments
to share experiences among themselves. In
During the Greek speaking seminars in Les-
some cases, they discussed their experiences
vos, there was frequent discussion on the
with the facilitator during breaks. The train-
need to provide ongoing and continuous sup-
ing also o¡ered them the opportunity to
port to both professionals and volunteers,
share examples of their interventions that
who every day came into contact with death,
made them feel proud, as well as examples
people who had risked their lives, or lost their
of how they implemented strategies of self
loved ones on the journey to Greece and
care. All participants asked for follow-ups
safety. For men and women of the Coast
of the training, specifying that these follow-
Guard, this was one of the most basic needs
ups should focus on speci¢c issues. Invari-
they felt; ‘but how do we address this need? We
ably, they all emphasised the need for
can note the gaps and needs for improvement, we
ongoing support for carers.
understand that it is very important to do something
and through the seminar we saw how it can be done,
Putting the training into practice but to whom shall we speak about this?’. I advised
them to follow o⁄cial procedure. I don’t
One day, I was asked to intervene in a situ-
know whether it was because of this advice,
ation that had arisen in one of the refugee
but some days later most of the Greek news
camps. Aid workers had asked, through an
journals reported that the Coast Guard
interpreter, for some support concerning
personnel’s trade union had requested help
two families that had arrived three days ear-
of the relevant Ministry ‘in order to prevent
lier. During the trip, the boat had sunk and
professional burn out and vicarious traumatisation’.
many of those on-board had lost members
of their families, including children, to the The Ministry of the Marine, responsible
for the Coast Guard, replied by organising
sea. The volunteers were most concerned
a team of psychologists to address this issue.
about a grieving man who had lost his wife.
In conclusion, in order for interventions such
He was sitting alone, not eating, not partici-
as the training to be e¡ective, they must be
pating in anything, completely disinterested
followed-up or accompanied by other
in the world around him. They thought they
actions: more personnel, more specialised
would be unable to cope with the situation
sta¡, better coordination and cooperation
and asked me, as a psychologist, to speak to
him. I used the principles of the training to assist those in need ^ and less work for
publicity purposes! Constant support of the
seminar in a direct and applied way. I used
people on the front line and follow-up
the ‘pyramid’ approach (which places PFA
training are essential.
within the framework of overall mental
health and psychosocial response after a cri-
sis event, IASC, 2007) and worked with the References
volunteers to highlight how to become Asylum in Europe [November] (2015), http://
informed before intervening, to engage the www.asylumineurope.org/reports/country/
‘community’ (other refugees in the camp) to greece.

78
Copyright © War Trauma Foundation. Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited.
Gkionakis

Inter-Agency Standing Committee (IASC). chaos-greek-islands-three-tier-refugee-regis-


(2007). IASC Guidelines on Mental Health and tration-system-syria-lesbos?CMP¼fb_gu323/.
Psychosocial Support in Emergency Settings. Geneva:
IASC. UNHCR (2015) [November 29/Greece data
snapshot] http://data.unhcr.org/mediterranean/
Losi, N. (2006). Lives elsewhere. Migration and Psychic country.php?id¼83.
Disease. London: Karnac.

Papadopoulos, R.K. (2002). Refugees, home and Nikolaos Gkionakis, is a psychologist and scien-
trauma. In R. K. Papadopoulos (Ed.) Therapeutic ti¢c director at the Babel Day Centre, in Athens
Care for Refugees. No Place Like Home. London: Kar- Greece. email: babel@syn-eirmos.gr.
nac. Tavistock Clinic Series. This personal re£ection was written with
the aid of Mindy Ran, Production Editor at
The Guardian (21 November 2015). ‘Chaos on Greek Intervention, through a series of email inter-
islands as refugee registration system favours Syrians’ views and conversations throughout December
http://www.theguardian.com/world/2015/nov/21/ 2015. Mr Gkionakis has approved this text.

79
Copyright © War Trauma Foundation. Unauthorized reproduction of this article is prohibited.

Potrebbero piacerti anche