Written Equipment Design Report Rubric

Outcome Professional Quality Adequate Needs Improvement Inadequate Score

(4 points) (3 points) (2 points) (1 point)
Write a technical report English writing and report English writing and report English writing and report English writing and
format is professional format is very good format is satisfactory report format is poor
Completeness & All the required parts of a Some parts of a written report Many parts of a written Major parts of a written
organization of the written report are included are lacking and organization report are missing; poor report are missing; looks
technical report and logically organized. and some sense of logical organization. like a mixup of topics
organization
Draw block / process flow Block / Process flow diagrams Block/ Process flow diagrams Block/ Process flow Block/ Process flow
diagrams and label are drawn extensively and are adequately drawn and diagrams drawing and diagrams are missing
equipment and stream labeled ver0y accurately labeled labeling is not clear or
information missing major information
Determine / collect All required fluid properties Fluid properties are adequately Some fluid properties are Fluid properties are
physical, chemical and are determined / collected determined / collected and missing or source may be missing or unrealistic
transport properties of very accurately and source or some source or correlation is missing
process fluids correlation are all indicated indicated
Apply chemical Material/Energy balance Material/Energy balance Material/Energy balance Material/Energy balance
engineering process calculations are used calculations are used calculations are not clearly calculations are missing
calculations such as mass intensively and very adequately and accurately indicated and/or wrongly applied
and energy balances accurately
Demonstrate design of Equipment design is clearly Equipment design is Equipment design is Minimal evidence of
chemical engineering and very accurately adequately demonstrated with partially demonstrated theoretical calculations
equipment (such as demonstrated with mostly theoretical calculations and with some theoretical of equipment design and
columns, heat exchanges, theoretical calculations and few use of heuristics and valid calculations and many mostly based on not
pressure vessels, reactor minimal use of heuristics and assumptions unrealistic assumptions valid assumptions
... etc.) very valid assumptions and use of heuristics
Include an Innovation to Innovation is truly novel, Innovation is novel and Innovation is not so new No Innovation included
the Equipment that is creative and valid creative with slight validity with poor validity in the design
novel, creative and valid
as supported by evidences
used in the design
calculations
Tabulate the design Specification Sheet is 100% Specification Sheet is 80-90% Specification Sheet is 60- Specification Sheet is
parameters in a complete complete 80% complete less than 60 complete
Specification Sheet
Draw a Prototype Model Prototype is graphically
of the designed excellent using design based
equipment parameter calculations and
includes all auxiliaries
Submit Report on Time Submitted the report earlier
with few modifications or on the deadline with no
after deadline further modifications
Prototype design is graphically
good and included some
arbitrary design parameters
included
Submitted the report within 2
hours after deadline with very
few further modifications
Design is graphically Prototype is unrealistic
difficult to picture out
with few design
parameters applied
Submitted the report 24 Submitted the report
hours after deadline with more than 2 days after
some modifications