Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
net/publication/263615706
CITATIONS READS
3 585
2 authors:
Some of the authors of this publication are also working on these related projects:
All content following this page was uploaded by Eduardo Mojica-Nava on 03 July 2014.
Abstract—A direct current distribution microgrid represents a evolving electrical grid. The main focus is on control strategies
practical solution to efficiency problems of existing AC electrical of the DC bus voltage and power management. The remainder
grid. It can integrate more effectively different forms of renewable of the paper is organized as follows: An analysis result on
energy sources such as photovoltaic cells, wind generators and efficiency of DC distribution system compared with current
fuel cells. This scheme has specific issues given its DC nature AC system is provided in Section 2. Section 3 makes a review
in regards to efficient operation and protection systems. Addi-
tionally, control methods commonly used to integrate distributed
about concepts, topologies, control and protection aspects of
generation and loads into a microgrid with energy storage ele- DC microgrids. In Section 4 further analysis of the control
ments must be adapted accordingly to the DC own requirements. methods developed for DC MG is performed. Finally, Section
Main topics of this scheme are currently being developed and 5 draws a conclusion and point out research opportunities and
researched, whereby a survey on the principal research projects future trends.
and prospective on DC distribution microgrids is presented.
II. M OTIVATION
I. I NTRODUCTION A. AC system versus DC system
The integration of renewable energy to the modern electri- Edison and Westinghouse struggle defined the predominant
cal system as a sustainable way to supply the energy demand technology for use electric energy [3]. AC became the standard
has many issues to solve. The main problem is to convert the because it has several advantages over DC at generation,
existing infrastructure to a smart grid which improves the use transmission and distribution level [4]:
of non-dispatchable sources such as photovoltaic energy (PV),
wind generation (WG), and fuel cells (FC) [1]. The electrical • Voltage transformation: easier to elevate and lower the
grid is a system of generation, transmission and distribution of AC voltage even near to the load
energy in form of alternating current (AC) [2]. The reason of
• Circuit breaker protection: periodic zero voltage cross-
such system is the ease of voltage level transformation and the
ings facilitate the extinction of fault currents.
inherent AC nature of the rotating machine driven by fossil or
hydro energy, thus it is not conceived for the renewable energy • Voltage stability: AC voltage decoupled from active
sources (RES). power allows controlling it by means of reactive
power.
RES have characteristics that make them more difficult to
use: PV highly depends on atmospheric conditions to produce • Bulk generation characteristics: the alternating inher-
useful energy and even with ideal conditions this energy needs ent rotating machine driven by fossil energy.
to be stored. It is an inherent direct current (DC) source
of energy due to its DC response and the common use of However, at present some of the DC advantages over
batteries. Wind power generators have an alternating response AC become more relevant, specially at the distribution and
but it is inconstant depending on the wind speed which is consumption level [4], such as:
an uncontrollable and unpredictable variable, then the more
• Incorporation of renewable energy resources and en-
practical form of using its energy is converting the AC into
ergy storage: such as PV, FC, batteries provides na-
DC power. Other RES such as FC has similar characteristics.
tively DC power, which means avoiding one conver-
They are naturally DC forms of producing energy. In addition,
sion step to AC on each device.
there is a limitation on the concentration of renewable energy,
given that those resources are distributed in wide areas, then • Modern lighting and electronics: eliminating rectifier
the energy production must also be in distributed manner. step to provide power to devices which use DC.
This paper shows the main advances and projects on DC • Power quality: the reduction of power electronic con-
microgrids as a key technology for practical integration of verters decreases the distortion caused to the voltage
distributed and renewable energy sources into the present signal in the point of common coupling (PCC).
by Osaka University, as well as output power from PV and
different capacities and efficiencies for PV converter, grid
converter and load converters. The total energy consumption
is 84.4 MWh per year, and a PV generation of 27.6 MWh
per year, the simulation shows that the overall power losses
in the DC microgrid are about 7.1% lower than in the AC
microgrid. The sensitivity analysis indicates that the effect of
efficiency of load converters has a large effect on total losses
(1% less efficiency causes more than 10% more losses). The
grid converter has also an important effect on losses, with a
slope of about 9%. The most interesting result is regarding the
capacity of the PV system, the authors define a lower limit to
improve the efficiency of the distribution system at about 11
kW. More DG contributing power over this limit is expected
to improve the results on efficiency.
A significant data processing simulation is presented in [9].
The model includes real data of house consumption in the
UK, PV and WG models comprising atmospheric conditions, a
Fig. 1. DC System with PV. Adpated from [8] storage model of lead-acid batteries and a charging/discharging
controller. The main objective is to optimize the percentage of
use of PV and WG to reduce the total energy consumption and
For those reasons, several DC or hybrid AC-DC distribution peak-hour power variation. The result is an optimal microgrid
systems are being proposed, for example as high availability constituted by 12 x 12 houses with one renewable unit per
solutions in data centers [5] [6]. household (83% PV and 17% WG), which reduces power peak
fluctuation in 12% and further 4.6% if include storage batteries.
B. Efficiency in DC System The total energy consumption was reduced by 16%.
Power efficiency in transmission and distribution is defined Those results show clearly the impact on the losses reduc-
as the ratio between total power delivered to the consumers and tion when a DC distribution system is applied, basically due
the total power produced by the generators. This is a measure to the feasibility to integrate RES and ESS in the microgrid.
of losses caused by lines and transformation stages in the grid.
AC system has in addition a few more variables involved in the C. Distributed Generation in Microgrids
total efficiency such as total harmonic distortion (THD) caused
by the characteristics of loads or the effect of inductance of A good strategy to improve energy efficiency is to produce
lines and loads causing reactive power flow [7]. In DC system, it as close as possible to the consumers in a distributed form.
there is only active power, voltage and current involved in This reduces energy losses in transportation and conversion
efficiency. Several case study papers have performed efficiency and is highly compatible with RES, due to the fact that many
analysis regarding to the DC distribution microgrid in a local renewable energies are distributed in wide areas. Commonly
facility [4] [8]. used renewable energy sources (PV and WG) heavily depend
on environmental variables, thus it is practical dispose them in
In [4], the authors compare a distribution system avoiding distributed manner having more stable average conditions and
line impedance effects and modeling the efficiency of conver- pursuing a more effective energy catchment [10].
sion stages in several conditions for residential use of energy
(heating, ventilation, lighting, home electronics, laundry, etc.), The problem in a distributed scheme of generation is
and having the possibility to integrate a distributed generation coordination: every part of the grid should contribute in the
device (such as fuel cell) into the bus bar of a microgrid. They total energy consumption and be managed in order to maintain
consider four different cases: 1- AC distribution without DG; quality in the PCC. As shown in Figure 2, each source of
2- DC distribution without DG; 3- DC distribution with fuel energy is connected to a common point, and their interface is
cell; 4- AC distribution with fuel cell. This study shows that power electronics which adapt the signal produced by the DG
residential DC distribution by itself is disadvantageous due to electrical conditions in the PCC. This is done by managing
to the inefficient bulk rectification at the entrance of the DC active and reactive power, frequency, and voltage to work
bus (first conversion step from utility AC to DC showed in properly in parallel [11].
Figure 1 as grid converter) when only loads are connected to 1) AC Microgrid: The integration of DG into an AC bus
the MG. However, if local DG as a fuel cell is connected to has been widely studied as a microgrid based on parallel
the distribution bus, the efficiency is worst in the AC case due connected inverters (represented by DGs, loads, and ESS in
to the conversion from DC to AC required to connect the fuel Figure 2). Main characteristics of this approach are:
cell to the bus. They conclude that when using DC distribution
the efficiency improves only in case of the presence of a DG • Every DG is connected to the bus via an inverter,
in the Microgrid. synchronized in frequency and phase to maintain the
bus voltage in the PCC.
A simulation for a system with 20 residencies and a 30 kW
PV system is compared with an AC and a DC Mictrogrid in [8]. • Control of active power and reactive power in inverters
The authors consider data for electric consumption measured is managed by power electronics.
Fig. 3. DC Microgrid with DG and ESS
Fig. 2. AC Microgrid with DG and ESS