Sei sulla pagina 1di 24

UNIVERSITY OF DHAKA

Course Name: Audit & Assurance 2


Course Code : 3203

A Report on

“Minimum audit fee compliance in


Bangladesh regarding Pharmaceutical
and Chemical Industry ”
Submitted To
Md. Rezaul Karim
Lecturer
Department of Accounting & Information
Systems
University of Dhaka
Submitted By: Meet Creators

Members Name ID
Sheikh Rubel 22-005
Minhazur Rahman 22-014
Sumaiya Sabrina 22-017
Md. Arshad Hossain 22-023
Sadia Akter Asha 22-037
Labonno Akter 22-067
Md Lemon Mia 22-079
Shariful Islam 22-106
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY:

This report provides an analysis and evaluation of the whether companies’ actual
audit fees comply with minimum audit fees , percentage of compliance, whether
CG audit firm and financial statements audit firm similar or not, comparison of
audit fee over the year, audit and non-audit fee comparison, and opinion type
regarding companies. Results of data analyzed show that maximum companies’
audit fees are below MAF(minimum audit fees) that means it is not complying the
criteria, CG audit firm are different in almost all cases, in most cases the audit fees
regarding the company are to some extent increasing, non-audit fees are quite
high. The report finds the overall prospects of these sectors of those companies
are not positive. Though almost all the firms are in unmodified audit opinion
there is a gap of transparency, lack of information, lack of accountability of
management, lack of proper data management. Recommendation for that
industry are improving in information management system, insure transparency
of the organization activities, proper disclosure of information, bringing variation
in appointing audit firm , build a proper system of organizational commitment-
accountibility, and mostly removal of management fraudulence. There is also a
limitation of this report such as lack of proper information, results based on past
performance, personal judgements etc.
Table regarding the minimum audit fee and actual audit
fee compliance
Company name Minimum audit Statutory audit fee Compliance
fee
The Ibn Sina Pharmaceutical Ind. Ltd 560000 199750 No
The Ibn Sina Pharmaceutical Ind. Ltd 595000 297750 No
The Ibn Sina Pharmaceutical Ind. Ltd 665000 150000 No
Imam Button Industries Ltd. 455000 Undefined -
Imam Button Industries Ltd. 455000 Undefined -
Imam Button Industries Ltd. 455000 Undefined -
JMI Syringes & Medical Devices Ltd. 630000 92000 No
JMI Syringes & Medical Devices Ltd. 630000 Undefined -
JMI Syringes & Medical Devices Ltd. 700000 Undefined -

Pharma Aids Ltd 350000 40250 No


Pharma Aids Ltd 350000 40250 No
Pharma Aids Ltd 350000 62500 No
Reckitt Benckiser Ltd 812000 350000 No
Reckitt Benckiser Ltd 868000 543250 No
Reckitt Benckiser Ltd 924000 1299996 Yes
Renata Ltd 3500000 810000 No
Renata Ltd 3500000 575000 No
Renata Ltd 3500000 768750 No

Beacon Pharmaceutical Ltd 109200 220000 No


Beacon Pharmaceutical Ltd 115500 159722 No
Beacon Pharmaceutical Ltd 115500 207000 No
Ambee Pharma Ltd 385000 172500 No
Ambee Pharma Ltd 350000 172500 No
Ambee Pharma Ltd 350000 402500 Yes
AFC Agro Biotech Ltd 420000 186250 No
AFC Agro Biotech Ltd 490000 154375 No
AFC Agro Biotech Ltd 560000 350000 No

ACI Ltd 3500000 600000 No


ACI Ltd 3500000 600000 No
ACI Ltd 3500000 900000 No
Active Fine Chemicals Ltd 980000 126500 No
Active Fine Chemicals Ltd 1092000 63250 No
Active Fine Chemicals Ltd 1155000 350000 No
Kohinur Chemicals Ltd 756000 60000 No
Kohinur Chemicals Ltd 812000 60000 No
Kohinur Chemicals Ltd 868000 220000 No
No
Beximco Pharmaceuticals Ltd 3500000 1500000 No
Beximco Pharmaceuticals Ltd 3500000 2100000 No
Beximco Pharmaceuticals Ltd 3500000 1300000 No
Beximco Synthetics Ltd 868000 450000 No
Beximco Synthetics Ltd 868000 675000 No
Beximco Synthetics Ltd 868000 400000 No
Central Pharmaceuticals Ltd 665000 100000 No
Central Pharmaceuticals Ltd 665000 80000 No

Marico Bangladesh Ltd. 1210000 11300000 Yes


Marico Bangladesh Ltd. 1265000 10900000 Yes
Marico Bangladesh Ltd. 1265000 9600000 Yes
Orion Infusion Ltd. 385000 184000 No
Orion Infusion Ltd. 420000 115000 No
Orion Infusion Ltd. 420000 57500 No
Orion Pharma Ltd. 3500000 1150000 No
Orion Pharma Ltd. 3500000 920000 No
Orion Pharma Ltd. 3500000 985000 No

Far Chemical Industries Ltd. 630000 250000 No


Far Chemical Industries Ltd. 700000 250000 No
Far Chemical Industries Ltd. 756000 250000 No
GlaxoSmthKlines(GSK) Bangladesh 121000 18170000 Yes
Ltd.
GlaxoSmthKlines(GSK) Bangladesh 121000 2669000 Yes
Ltd.
GlaxoSmthKlines(GSK) Bangladesh 121000 6199000 yes
Ltd.
Global Heavy Chemicals Ltd. 350000 No
Global Heavy Chemicals Ltd. 1036000 12218880 No
Global Heavy Chemicals Ltd. 1036000 1116820 No

Square Phamraceuticals Ltd. 3500000 287500 No


Square Phamraceuticals Ltd. 3500000 287500 No
Square Phamraceuticals Ltd. 3500000 287500 No
Salvo Pharmaceuticals Ltd. 980000 250000 No
Salvo Pharmaceuticals Ltd. 1036000 345000 No
Salvo Pharmaceuticals Ltd. 1092000 172500 No
Wata Chemicals Ltd. 1148000 280000 No
Wata Chemicals Ltd. 1155000 250000 No
Wata Chemicals Ltd. 1155000 270000 No
Whether there is a similarity between F/Ss audit firm and
CG audit firm:
Company CG Audit firm Statutory audit Same or not
firm
The Ibn Sina Mahd.Ali Al jabadi S.F Ahmed & Co. Not
Pharmaceutical Ind. Ltd
The Ibn Sina Mahd.Ali Al jabadi S.F Ahmed & Co. Not
Pharmaceutical Ind. Ltd
The Ibn Sina Mahd.Ali Al jabadi S.F Ahmed & Co. Not
Pharmaceutical Ind. Ltd

Imam Button Industries Ltd Undefined MS Anisur Rahman & Co. -


Imam Button Industries Ltd Undefined MS Anisur Rahman & Co. -
Imam Button Industries Ltd Undefined MS Anisur Rahman & Co. -

JMI Syringes & Medical Undefined G Kibria & Co. -


Devices
JMI Syringes & Medical Undefined G Kibria & Co. -
Devices
JMI Syringes & Medical Undefined G Kibria & Co. -
Devices

Pharma Aids Ltd S.H.Khan&Co. Hussain Khaja & Co. Not


Pharma Aids Ltd S.H Khan & Co. Artisan Not
Pharma Aids Ltd Malek Siddique Wali Artisan Not
Reckitt Benckiser Ltd Ahmed Mashuque & Co. A.Qasem & Co. Not
Reckitt Benckiser Ltd Ahmed Mashuque&Co. A.Quasem&Co. Not
Reckitt Benckiser Ltd Ahmed Mashuque &Co. A Quasem&Co. Not
Renata Ltd K.M. Hasan & Co. Hoda Vasi Chowdhury &Co. Not
Renata Ltd k.M hasan & Co. S.F Ahmed&Co. Not
Renata Ltd K.M Hasan & Co. S.F Ahmed&Co. Not
Beacon Pharmaceutical Ltd Podder & associates Toha Khan Zaman&Co. Not
Beacon Pharmaceutical Ltd Podder & associates Toha Khan Zaman&Co Not
Beacon Pharmaceutical Ltd Podder & associates Toha Khan Zaman&Co Not
Ambee Pharma Ltd Haque Shah Alam Mansur Khan Wahab Shafiq &Co. Not
& Co.
Ambee Pharma Ltd Haque Shah Alam Mansur Khan Wahab Shafiq &Co Not
& Co.
Ambee Pharma Ltd Haque Shah Alam Mansur Khan Wahab Shafiq &Co Not
& Co.
AFC Agro Biotech Ltd Mazumdar Sikder & Safiq Basaq & Co. Not
associates
AFC Agro Biotech Ltd Mazumdar Sikder & Safiq Basaq & Co. Not
associates
AFC Agro Biotech Ltd Mazumdar Sikder & Safiq Basaq & Co. Not
associates

ACI Ltd Al-Muqtadir associates Rahman & Rahman Huq Not


ACI Ltd Al-Muqtadir associates Rahman & Rahman Huq Not
ACI Ltd Al-Muqtadir associates Rahman & Rahman Huq Not
Active Fine Chemicals Ltd Mazumdar Sikder & Shafiq Basak & Co. Not
associates
Active Fine Chemicals Ltd Mazumdar Sikder & Shafiq Basak & Co. Not
associates
Active Fine Chemicals Ltd Mazumdar Sikder & Shafiq Basak & Co. Not
associates
Kohinur Chemicals Ltd Podder & associates Toha Khan Zaman&Co Not
Kohinur Chemicals Ltd Podder & associates Toha Khan Zaman&Co Not
Kohinur Chemicals Ltd Podder & associates Toha Khan Zaman&Co Not

Beximco Pharmaceuticals SA Rashid & associates Mj Abedin & Co. Not


Ltd
Beximco Pharmaceuticals SA Rashid & associates Mj Abedin & Co. Not
Ltd
Beximco Pharmaceuticals SA Rashid & associates Mj Abedin & Co. Not
Ltd
Beximco Synthetics Ltd SA Rashid & associates Mj Abedin & Co. Not

Beximco Synthetics Ltd SA Rashid & associates Mj Abedin & Co. Not

Beximco Synthetics Ltd SA Rashid & associates Mj Abedin & Co. Not

Central Pharmaceuticals Haque Shahalam & Co. Zoha Zaman Kabi Rashid & Not
Ltd Co.
Central Pharmaceuticals Haque Shahalam & Co. Zoha Zaman Kabi Rashid & Not
Ltd Co.

Marico Bangladesh Ltd. Price Water Price Waterhouse Yes


Marico Bangladesh Ltd. MS Nurul Hoda Vasi Co. Not
Marico Bangladesh Ltd. Ms Nurul Ms Qasem Co. Not
Orion Infusion Ltd. MS Rahim Ms khan wahab Co. Not
Orion Infusion Ltd. Ms Rahim Ms khan wahab Co. Not
Orion Infusion Ltd. Ms Rahim Ms khan wahab Co. Not
Orion Pharma Ltd. Artisan Ms Ahmed & Akter Not
Orion Pharma Ltd. Artisan Ms Ahmed & Akter Not
Orion Pharma Ltd. Syful Alam Co. Ms Ahmed & Akter Not

Far Chemical Industries Ltd. Basek&Co. Ahmed & Akter Not


Far Chemical Industries Ltd. Basek&Co. Ahmed & Akter Not
Far Chemical Industries Ltd. Basek&Co. Shiraz Khan Basek & Co. Not
GlaxoSmthKlines(GSK) MABS & J Partners ACNABIN Not
Bangladesh Ltd.
GlaxoSmthKlines(GSK) MABS & J Partners ACNABIN Not
Bangladesh Ltd.
GlaxoSmthKlines(GSK) MABS & J Partners ACNABIN Not
Bangladesh Ltd.
Global Heavy Chemicals - - -
Ltd.
Global Heavy Chemicals - - -
Ltd.
Global Heavy Chemicals - - -
Ltd.

Square Phamraceuticals Chowdhury Bhattacharjee Das Chowdhury Datta & Co. Not
Ltd. & Co.
Square Phamraceuticals Chowdhury Bhattacharjee Das Chowdhury Datta & Co. Not
Ltd. & Co.
Square Phamraceuticals Chowdhury Bhattacharjee Das Chowdhury Datta & Co. Not
Ltd. & Co.
Salvo Pharmaceuticals Ltd. Rashid & associates M/s Masih Muhuith &Co. Not
Salvo Pharmaceuticals Ltd. Rashid & associates M/s Masih Muhuith &Co. Not
Salvo Pharmaceuticals Ltd. Rashid & associates M/s Masih Muhuith &Co. Not
Wata Chemicals Ltd. A Wahab & Co. Haque Shah Alam Mansur Not
& Co.
Wata Chemicals Ltd. Artisan Haque Shah Alam Mansur Not
& Co.
Wata Chemicals Ltd. Artisan Fames & R Not
Percentage of audit fee increasing/decreasing every year:
YEAR COMPANY AUDIT FEE INCREASING PERCENTAGE
OR NOT OF CHANGE
2015 ACI LTD 600000 0
2016 ACI LTD 600000 0 0
2017 ACI LTD 900000 300000 33.33%
2015 Pharma Aids ltd 40250 0 0
2016 Pharma Aids ltd 40250 0 0
2017 Pharma Aids ltd 62500 22250 55.27%
2015 Reckitt Benckiserer 350000 0 0
Ltd
2016 Reckitt Benckiserer 543250 193250 55.21%
Ltd
2017 Reckitt Benckiserer 1299996 756746 139%
Ltd
2015 RENATA Ltd 810000 0 0
2016 RENATA Ltd 575000 -235000 -29%
2017 RENATA Ltd 768650 193650 33.68%
2015 BEACON PHARMA 220000 0 0
LTD
2016 BEACON PHARMA 159722 -60278 -27.40%
LTD
2017 BEACON PHARMA 207000 47278 29.60%
LTD
2015 AMBEE PHARMA LTD 172500 0 0
2016 AMBEE PHARMA LTD 172500 0 0
2017 AMBEE PHARMA LTD 402500 230000 133%
2015 AFC AGRO BIOTECH 186250 0 0
LTD
2016 AFC AGRO BIOTECH 154375 -31875 -17.11%
LTD
2017 AFC AGRO BIOTECH 350000 195625 126.72%
LTD
2015 IBN SINA PHARMA 199750 0 0
LTD
2016 IBN SINA PHARMA 297750 98000 49%
LTD
2017 IBN SINA PHARMA 150000 -147750 -49%
LTD
2015 IMAM BUTTON NOT FOUND
INDUSTRIES LTD
2016 IMAM BUTTON NOT FOUND
INDUSTRIES LTD
2017 IMAM BUTTON NOT FOUND
INDUSTRIES LTD
2015 JMI SYRINGES & 92000 O 0
MEDICAL DEVICES
LTD
2016 JMI SYRINGES & NOT FOUND
MEDICAL DEVICES
LTD
2017 JMI SYRINGES & NOT FOUND
MEDICAL DEVICES
LTD
2015 ACTIVE FINE 126500 0 0
CHEMICALS LTD
2016 ACTIVE FINE 63250 -63250 -50%
CHEMICAL LTD
2017 ACTIVE FINE 350000 286750 453%
CHEMICAL LTD
2015 KHOHINUR 60000 0 0
CHENICALS LTD
2016 KOHINUR CHEMICALS 60000 0 0
LTD
2017 KOHINUR CHEMICALS 220000 160000 266.66%
LTD
2015 BAXIMCO PHARMA 1500000 0 0
LTD
2016 BAXIMCO PHARMA 2100000 600000 28.57%
LTD
2017 BAXIMCO PHARMA 1300000 -800000 38.O9%
LTD
2015 BAXIMCO 450000 0 0
SYNTHETICS LTD
2016 BAXIMCO 675000 225000 50%
SYNTHETICS LTD
2017 BAXIMCO 400000 -275000 -40.74%
SYNTHETICS LTD
2015 CENTRAL PHARMA NOT FOUND
LTD
2016 CENTRAL PHARMA 80000 0 0
LTD
2017 CENTRAL PHARMA 100000 20000 25%
LTD
2105 MARICO 11300000 0 0
BANGLADESH LTD
2016 MARICO 10900000 -400000 -3.54%
BANGLADESH LTD
2017 MARICO 9600000 -1300000 -11.93%
BANGLADESH LTD
2015 ORION INFUSION LD 184000 0 0
2016 ORION INFUSION LD 115000 -69000 -37.50%
2017 ORION INFUSION LD 57500 -57500 -50%
2015 ORION PHARMA LTD 1150000 0 0
2016 ORION PHARMA LTD 920000 -230000 -20%
2017 ORION PHARMA LTD 985000 65000 7.06
2015 FAR CHEMICAL 250000 0 0
INDUSTRIES LTD
2016 FAR CHEMICAL 250000 0 0
INDUSTRIES LTD
2017 FAR CHEMICAL 250000 0 0
INDUSTRIES LTD
2015 GSK BD LTD NOT FOUND
2016 GSK BD LTD NOT FOUND
2017 GSK BD LTD NOT FOUND
2015 GLOBAL HEAVY NOT FOUND
CHEMICAL LTD
2016 GLOBAL HEAVY 258750 0 0
CHEMICAL LTD
2017 GLOBAL HEAVY 172500 -86250 -33.33%
CHEMICAL LTD
2015 SQUARE PHARMA 287000 0 0
LTD
2016 SQUARE PHARMA 287500 500 .17%
LTD
2017 SQUARE PHARMA 287500 0 0
LTD
2015 SAVLO PHARMA LTD 250000 0 0
2016 SAVLO PHARMA LTD 345000 95000 38%
2017 SAVLO PHARMA LTD 172500 -172500 -50%
2015 WATA CHEMICALS 280000 0 0
LTD
2016 WATA CHEMICALS 250000 -30000 -10.71%
LTD
2017 WATA CHEMICALS 270000 20000 8%
LTD
AUDIT OPINION TYPE :

COMPANY AUDIT OPINION


ACI LTD UNMODIFIED
ACI LTD UNMODIFIED
ACI LTD UNMODIFIED
Active fine chemicals ltd UNMODIFIED
Active fine chemicals ltd UNMODIFIED
Active fine chemicals ltd UNMODIFIED
Pharma Aids ltd UNMODIFIED
Pharma Aids ltd UNMODIFIED
Pharma Aids ltd UNMODIFIED
Reckitt Benckiser Ltd UNMODIFIED
Reckitt Benckiser Ltd UNMODIFIED
Reckitt Benckiser Ltd UNMODIFIED
RENATA Ltd UNMODIFIED
RENATA Ltd UNMODIFIED
RENATA Ltd UNMODIFIED
BEACON Pharmaceutical Ltd UNMODIFIED
BEACON Pharmaceutical Ltd UNMODIFIED
BEACON Pharmaceutical Ltd UNMODIFIED
AMBEE Pharmaceutical Ltd UNMODIFIED
AMBEE Pharmaceutical Ltd UNMODIFIED
AMBEE Pharmaceutical Ltd UNMODIFIED
AFC AGRO BIOTECH LTD UNMODIFIED
AFC AGRO BIOTECH LTD UNMODIFIED
AFC AGRO BIOTECH LTD UNMODIFIED
Khinur Chemicals Ltd UNMODIFIED
Khinur Chemicals Ltd UNMODIFIED
Khinur Chemicals Ltd UNMODIFIED
The Ibn Sina Pharmaceutical Ind. Ltd. UNMODIFIED
The Ibn Sina Pharmaceutical Ind. Ltd. UNMODIFIED
The Ibn Sina Pharmaceutical Ind. Ltd. UNMODIFIED
Imam Button Industries Ltd. UNMODIFIED
Imam Button Industries Ltd. UNMODIFIED
Imam Button Industries Ltd. UNMODIFIED
JMI Syringes & Medical Devices Ltd. UNMODIFIED
JMI Syringes & Medical Devices Ltd. UNMODIFIED
JMI Syringes & Medical Devices Ltd. UNMODIFIED
Beximco Synthetics Ltd UNMODIFIED
Beximco Synthetics Ltd UNMODIFIED
Beximco Synthetics Ltd UNMODIFIED
Beximco Pharmaceuticals Ltd UNMODIFIED
Beximco Pharmaceuticals Ltd UNMODIFIED
Beximco Pharmaceuticals Ltd UNMODIFIED
Central Pharmaceuticals Ltd UNMODIFIED
Central Pharmaceuticals Ltd UNMODIFIED
Central Pharmaceuticals Ltd UNMODIFIED
Marico Bangladesh Ltd UNMODIFIED
Marico Bangladesh Ltd UNMODIFIED
Marico Bangladesh Ltd UNMODIFIED
Orion Pharma Ltd UNMODIFIED
Orion Pharma Ltd UNMODIFIED
Orion Pharma Ltd UNMODIFIED
Orion Infusion Ltd UNMODIFIED
Orion Infusion Ltd UNMODIFIED
Orion Infusion Ltd UNMODIFIED
Far Chemical Industries Ltd UNMODIFIED
Far Chemical Industries Ltd UNMODIFIED
Far Chemical Industries Ltd UNMODIFIED
Glaxo Smth Kline(GSK) Bandesglah Ltd UNMODIFIED
Glaxo Smth Kline(GSK) Bandesglah Ltd UNMODIFIED
Glaxo Smth Kline(GSK) Bandesglah Ltd UNMODIFIED
Global Heavy Chemicals Ltd UNMODIFIED
Global Heavy Chemicals Ltd UNMODIFIED
Global Heavy Chemicals Ltd UNMODIFIED
Square Pharmaceuticals Ltd UNMODIFIED
Square Pharmaceuticals Ltd UNMODIFIED
Square Pharmaceuticals Ltd UNMODIFIED
Salvo Pharmaceuticals Ltd UNMODIFIED
Salvo Pharmaceuticals Ltd UNMODIFIED
Salvo Pharmaceuticals Ltd UNMODIFIED
Wata chemicals Ltd UNMODIFIED
Wata chemicals Ltd UNMODIFIED
Wata chemicals Ltd UNMODIFIED
COMPARISON BETWEEN AUDIT FEE AND OTHER FEE:

YEAR COMPANY AUDIT FEE OTHER FEE HIGHER ONE


2015 ACI LTD 6000000.00 11442536.00 Other fee
2016 ACI LTD 6000000.00 4392346.00 Audit fee
2017 ACI LTD 9000000.00 12640494.00 Other fee
2015 Active fine chemicals ltd 126500.00
2016 Active fine chemicals ltd 63250.00 19000.00 Audit fee
2017 Active fine chemicals ltd 350000.00
2015 Pharma Aids ltd 40250.00
2016 Pharma Aids ltd 40250.00
2017 Pharma Aids ltd 62500.00
2015 Reckitt Benckiser Ltd 350000.00 542900.00 Other fee
2016 Reckitt Benckiser Ltd 543250.00 1177438.00 Other fee
2017 Reckitt Benckiser Ltd 1299996.00 988827.00 Audit fee
2015 RENATA Ltd 810000.00 7543876.00 Other fee
2016 RENATA Ltd 575000.00 3707200.00 Other fee
2017 RENATA Ltd 768750.00 1530678.00 Other fee
2015 BEACON 220000.00 2464268.00 Other fee
Pharmaceutical Ltd
2016 BEACON 159722.00 1928051.00 Other fee
Pharmaceutical Ltd
2017 BEACON 207000.00 1651812.00 Other fee
Pharmaceutical Ltd
2015 AMBEE 172500.00 205475.00 Other fee
Pharmaceutical Ltd
2016 AMBEE 172500.00 169452.00 Audit fee
Pharmaceutical Ltd
2017 AMBEE 402500.00 381075.00 Audit fee
Pharmaceutical Ltd
2015 AFC AGRO BIOTECH 186250.00 1444630.00 Other fee
LTD
2016 AFC AGRO BIOTECH 154375.00 2205162.00 Other fee
LTD
2017 AFC AGRO BIOTECH 350000.00 1722478.00 Other fee
LTD
2015 The Ibn Sina Pharmaceutical Audit fee
Ind. Ltd. 199,750.00

2016 The Ibn Sina Pharmaceutical Audit fee


Ind. Ltd. 297,750.00

2017 The Ibn Sina Pharmaceutical Audit fee


Ind. Ltd. 150,000.00

2015 Imam Button Industries Ltd.


Undefined

2016 Imam Button Industries Ltd.


Undefined

2017 Imam Button Industries Ltd.


Undefined

2015 JMI Syringes & Medical Audit fee


Devices Ltd. 92,000.00

2016 JMI Syringes & Medical


Devices Ltd. Undefined

2017 JMI Syringes & Medical


Devices Ltd. Undefined

2015
Kohinur Chemicals Ltd 60,000.00 65,000.00

2016
Kohinur Chemicals Ltd 60,000.00 1,357,650.00

2017
Kohinur Chemicals Ltd 220,000.00 1,514,851.00

2015 Beximco Pharmaceuticals


1,500,000.00 7,499,601.00
limited

2016 Beximco Pharmaceuticals


2,100,000.00 9,730,579.00
limited
2017 Beximco Pharmaceuticals
1,300,000.00 5,181,653.00
limited

2015 Beximco Synthetics


450000 100,000.00
Liimited
2016 Beximco Synthetics
675,000.00 180,000.00
Liimited
2017 Beximco Synthetics
400,000.00 130,000.00
Liimited
2015 Central Pharmaceuticals Audit fee
Limited 100,000.00

2016 Central Pharmaceuticals Audit fee


Limited 80,000.00

2015
11,300,000.00 1,000,000.00
Marico Bangladesh Ltd.
2016
10,900,000.00 1,200,000.00
Marico Bangladesh Ltd.
2017
9,600,000.00 1,200,000.00
Marico Bangladesh Ltd.
2015 Audit fee
184,000.00
Orion Infusion Ltd.
2016 Audit fee
115,000.00
Orion Infusion Ltd.
2017 Audit fee
57,500.00
Orion Infusion Ltd.
2015 Far Chemical Industries Other fee
250,000.00 617,214.00
Ltd.
2016 Far Chemical Industries Audit fee
250,000.00 125,521.00
Ltd
2017 Far Chemical Industries Audit fee
250,000.00 159,691.00
Ltd
2015 GlaxoSmthKline(GSK) Other fee
Not found 18,170,000.00
Bangladesh Ltd.
2016 GlaxoSmthKline(GSK) Other fee
Not found 2,669,000.00
Bangladesh Ltd.
2017 GlaxoSmthKline(GSK) Other fee
Not found 6,199,000.00
Bangladesh Ltd.
2015 Global Heavy Chemcals Other fee
Not found 2,669,000.00
Ltd.
2016 Global Heavy Chemcals Other fee
258,750.00 12,218,880.00
Ltd.
2017 Global Heavy Chemcals Audit fee
172,500.00 1,116,820.00
Ltd.
2015 Square pharmaceuticals Audit fee
287,000.00 1,689,494.00
ltd.
2016 Square pharmaceuticals Audit fee
287,500.00 1,501,437.00
ltd.
2017 Square pharmaceuticals Audit fee
287,500.00 1,501,437.00
ltd.
2015 Salvo Pharmaceuticals Other fee
250000.00 4,226,919.00
Limited
2016 Salvo Pharmaceuticals Other fee
345000.00 6,261,325.00
Limited
2017 Salvo Pharmaceuticals Other fee
172500.00 4,662,028.00
Limited
2015 Other fee
Wata Chemicals Limited 280000.00 1,635,000.00

2016 Other fee


Wata Chemicals Limited 250000.00 1,530,000.00

2017 Other fee


Wata Chemicals Limited 270000.00 1,270,000.00
Graph:Showing whether audit fee is increasing or not?

Wata Chemicals ltd

Salvo Pharmaceuticals ltd

Square Pharmaceuticals ltd

Global Heavy Chemicals ltd

GlaxoSmthKline(GSK) Bd. Ltd

Far Chemical Ind. Ltd

Orion Pharma ltd

Orion Infusion ltd

Marico Bangladesh ltd

Central Pharmaceuticals ltd

Beximco Synthetics ltd

Beximco Pharmaceuticals ltd

Kohinur Chemicals ltd

Active Fine Chemicals ltd

ACI ltd

JMI Syringes & Medical Devices ltd

Imam Button Ind. Ltd

The Ibn Sina Pharmaceutical Ltd

AFC Agro Biotech ltd

Ambee Pharmaceutical ltd

Beacon Pharmaceutical ltd

Renata ltd

Reckitt Benckiser ltd

Pharma Aids Ltd

0 2000000 4000000 6000000 8000000 10000000 12000000

Fee in 2017 Fee in 2016


MAF comparison between 2016 & 2017

Wata Chemicals ltd

Salvo Pharmaceuticals ltd

Square Pharmaceuticals ltd

Global Heavy Chemicals ltd

GlaxoSmthKline(GSK) Bd. Ltd

Far Chemical Ind. Ltd

Orion Pharma ltd

Orion Infusion ltd

Marico Bangladesh ltd

Central Pharmaceuticals ltd

Beximco Synthetics ltd

Beximco Pharmaceuticals ltd

Kohinur Chemicals ltd

Active Fine Chemicals ltd

ACI ltd

JMI Syringes & Medical Devices ltd

Imam Button Ind. Ltd

The Ibn Sina Pharmaceutical Ltd

AFC Agro Biotech ltd

Ambee Pharmaceutical ltd

Beacon Pharmaceutical ltd

Renata ltd

Reckitt Benckiser ltd

Pharma Aids Ltd

0 1000000 2000000 3000000 4000000

2017 2016

We have conducted our study over 24 companies among 27 companies in pharmaceuticals & chemicals
industries, as we do not find annual report of other 2 companies. Among the 24 companies, only 2
companies would comply with the minimum audit fee & another 2 companies would comply with the
minimum audit fee for 1 year & other companies would not comply with the minimum audit fee
.Among the 24 companies , only 8 companies minimum audit fee has been increased in 2017 than
2016,2 companies minimum audit fee has been decreased in 2017 than 2016 and others remain same.

 Minimum audit fee has been increased in {(8/24)*100}=33.3% companies


 Minimum audit fee has been decreased in {(2/24)*100}=8.3% companies
 Minimum audit fee remain same in {(14/24)*100}=58.4% companies

Audit fees and other fees related to Pharmaceuticals industry:

Average others
Year Audit fee Others fee Average audit fee
fee
2015 16,266,750.00 56,558,965.00 813337.5 3770597.667
2016 18,247,347.00 50,373,041.00 912367.35 2963120.059
2017 20,547,246.00 43,938,792.00 978440.2857 2746174.5

Comparision in 2015

Average
Audit Fee
18%

Average
others fee
82%
Comparision in2016

Average
audit fee
24%

Average
others fee
76%

Comparision in 2017

Average
audit fee
26%

Average others
fee
74%

It seems that others fee is much more higher than statutory audit fee over the
years though there is a reduction in the average rate of others fee and increase in
the average statutory audit fee over the years . Actually statutory audit fee is not
comparable to others fee but we have done to show a common difference.
Others fees are higher because they include litigation fee, company secretary fee
etc.
Conclusion:

Finally through the analysis the audit fees and non-audit fees of pharmaceutical
companies’ show that there is incompliance between the statutory audit fees and
minimum audit fees. Almost all of the firms are in unmodified audit opinion there
is a gap of transparency, lack of information, lack of accountability of
management, lack of proper data management. Good corporate governance
guidelines and different steps of government related to auditing may improve the
situation of this sector.

Potrebbero piacerti anche