Sei sulla pagina 1di 26

TOTAL 26 PAGES

Seismic Calculation Report (Including Cover)

Purpose

● PROJECT NAME : : PUERTO BRAVO POWER PLANT PROJECT


 For Review
● DOCUMENT No. : 0-WD490-VE460-00002
 For Approval

● TITLE : Seismic Calculation Report  For Construction

 For Information
● OWNER: SAMAY I S.A..
 For ( )

F 30/04/2016 Doummar Rodrigues Fernandez As Built


G. D. A

Doummar Rodrigues Fernandez


0 19/01/2015
G. D. A

Doummar Rodrigues Fernandez Seismic Calculation


A 10/30/2014
G. D. A Report

PREP REVIEW APPR REVIEW REVIEW APPR


Rev.
DATE DESCRIPTION
No.
Alstom Grid SAS POSCO E&C
Owner

SAMAY I S.A..

Contractor: Subcontractor: Alstom Grid SAS


GRID
Products
FKGA2, tenue sismique CEI 0.5G
Villeurbanne France
FKGA2, seismic withstand IEC 0.5G NOTE TECHNIQUE / TECHNICAL NOTE

273
Page 1 / 25

Goal:
Prove the seismic withstand of the FKGA2 EA1500 to earthquakes according to IEC standard

Summary:
A seismic study is performed with Ansys software. This study is done by the means of a
spectral analysis which imposes at worst a maximal acceleration of 0,5g for the horizontal
direction and 50% of 0,5g for the vertical direction.
According to IEC standard, load combinations are made by summing horizontal forces and
vertical forces with SRSS.
The model is composed of shell, beam and mass elements. It takes into account the
supporting frame lying on feet, the circuit breaker poles and disconnectors, the drive
mechanisms, the capacitors with their supports and others internal parts.
The analysis of results is made by doing the comparison between the stress observed and the
allowable stress of each part.
The displacements of the structure are also analyzed for the different load cases.

Conclusion:
The seismic study of the FKGA2 circuit breaker, based on a spectral analysis, prove its seismic
withstand to 0.5g earthquakes according to IEC standards. (The minimum safety factor
observed is 1.94 on the frame for the load case 5).

© ALSTOM 2010. Alle rechte vorbehalten. All rights reserved. Tous droits réservés. Tutti i diritti riservati. Reservados todos los derechos. Todos os direitos reservados.
Ce document et toutes les informations et données qu'il contient sont confidentiels et sont la propriété légale de l'auteur. Ils ne doivent pas être diffusés, copiés ou utilisés à quelques fins que ce soit sans accord écrit préalable.
This document and any information or descriptive matter set out in it are confidential and copyright property and must not be disclosed, loaned copied or used for any purpose whatsoever without prior written permission

Emission / First Issue Indice actuel / Actual Index Index


Date d’émission / Issue date Etabli par / Compiled by Date de modification / Revision Date Etabli par / Compiled by Approuvé par / Released by

2014-10-30 G. DOUMMAR D. RODRIGUES


02
GRID
Products
FKGA2, tenue sismique CEI 0.5G
Villeurbanne France
NOTE TECHNIQUE / TECHNICAL NOTE
FKGA2, seismic withstand IEC 0.5G
273
Page 2 / 25

Table of contents
Goal: ..................................................................................................................................................................... 1
Summary: .............................................................................................................................................................. 1
Conclusion: ............................................................................................................................................................ 1
1. Introduction ........................................................................................................................................................ 3
1.1. FKGA2 equipment overview ......................................................................................................................... 3
1.2. Components of FKGA2 by material .............................................................................................................. 3
1.3. Presentation of ANSYS Software ................................................................................................................... 4
2. Modelisation ...................................................................................................................................................... 5
2. 1. Conventions ............................................................................................................................................... 5
2.1.1. Units ..................................................................................................................................................... 5
2.1.2. Coordinate system ................................................................................................................................ 5
2.2. Models ........................................................................................................................................................ 5
2.2.1. Elements ............................................................................................................................................... 5
2.2.2. Inertial, geometric characteristics ........................................................................................................... 5
2.2.3. Geometrical model ............................................................................................................................... 6
2.3. Material characteristics................................................................................................................................. 6
2.4. Boundary Conditions ................................................................................................................................... 7
3. Loads ................................................................................................................................................................. 8
3.1. Dead weight ................................................................................................................................................ 8
3.2. Wind ........................................................................................................................................................... 8
3.3. Seismic force ............................................................................................................................................... 8
3.3.1. Presentation of a spectral analysis ......................................................................................................... 8
3.3.2. IEC Standard......................................................................................................................................... 9
3.4. Load combinations ................................................................................................................................. 10
4. Results.............................................................................................................................................................. 10
4.1. Modal Analysis .......................................................................................................................................... 10
4.2. Displacments ............................................................................................................................................. 15
4.3. Stress......................................................................................................................................................... 15
4.3.1 Stresses on frame ................................................................................................................................. 15
4.3.2 Stresses on enclosure support and drive mechanism support ................................................................. 16
4.3.3 Stresses on enclosures .......................................................................................................................... 17
4.3.4 Stresses on enclosure bottom and current transformers ......................................................................... 17
4.3.5 Stresses on pole bottom housing........................................................................................................... 18
4.3.6 Stresses on drive mechanisms (MPa) ..................................................................................................... 19
4.3.7 Stresses on bushing .............................................................................................................................. 20
4.3.8 Bending moments on CB insulators ...................................................................................................... 20
4.4 Bolts ........................................................................................................................................................... 22
4.4.1 Floor reaction....................................................................................................................................... 22
4.4.2 Fixing of main drive.............................................................................................................................. 22
4.4.2 Fixing of enclosure bottom to its support ............................................................................................... 22
5. Conclusion ....................................................................................................................................................... 22
6. Annexes ........................................................................................................................................................... 23
6.1. Real for frame ........................................................................................................................................... 23
6.2. Real for drive mechanism cubicles & part of frame and support .................................................................. 23
6.3. Real for enclosure ...................................................................................................................................... 24
6.4. IEC Spectrum ............................................................................................................................................. 25

© ALSTOM 2010. Alle rechte vorbehalten. All rights reserved. Tous droits réservés. Tutti i diritti riservati. Reservados todos los derechos. Todos os direitos reservados.
Ce document et toutes les informations et données qu'il contient sont confidentiels et sont la propriété légale de l'auteur. Ils ne doivent pas être diffusés, copiés ou utilisés à quelques fins que ce soit sans accord écrit préalable.
This document and any information or descriptive matter set out in it are confidential and copyright property and must not be disclosed, loaned copied or used for any purpose whatsoever without prior written permission

Emission / First Issue Indice actuel / Actual Index Index


Date d’émission / Issue date Etabli par / Compiled by Date de modification / Revision Date Etabli par / Compiled by Approuvé par / Released by

2014-10-30 G. DOUMMAR D. RODRIGUES


02
GRID
Products
FKGA2, tenue sismique CEI 0.5G
Villeurbanne France
FKGA2, seismic withstand IEC 0.5G NOTE TECHNIQUE / TECHNICAL NOTE

273
Page 3 / 25
1. Introduction

1.1. FKGA2 equipment overview


The equipment under study is a FKGA2 circuit breaker mainly composed of:
-1 supporting frame constituted of 3 sheath supports lying on 6 feet.
-3 poles in the enclosures.
-1 main drive mechanism for circuit breaker, placed at the end of the supporting frame.
-4 drive mechanisms cubicles for disconnector, earth switch, IKG
-Internal parts. Main dimensions (mm) of FKGA2 circuit breaker :
2220
5372

2403

1.2. Components of FKGA2 by material


Material 1: Frame (blue) Material 3: Enclosure (red)
Material 7: Main drive (brown) Material 6: Drive mechanisms (green)
Material 8: bushings (pink) covered by surface effect elements for directional ‘pressure’ wind

Geometric model is s0015093330.asm on Pro Engineer Database.

© ALSTOM 2010. Alle rechte vorbehalten. All rights reserved. Tous droits réservés. Tutti i diritti riservati. Reservados todos los derechos. Todos os direitos reservados.
Ce document et toutes les informations et données qu'il contient sont confidentiels et sont la propriété légale de l'auteur. Ils ne doivent pas être diffusés, copiés ou utilisés à quelques fins que ce soit sans accord écrit préalable.
This document and any information or descriptive matter set out in it are confidential and copyright property and must not be disclosed, loaned copied or used for any purpose whatsoever without prior written permission

Emission / First Issue Indice actuel / Actual Index Index


Date d’émission / Issue date Etabli par / Compiled by Date de modification / Revision Date Etabli par / Compiled by Approuvé par / Released by

2014-10-30 G. DOUMMAR D. RODRIGUES


02
GRID
Products
FKGA2, tenue sismique CEI 0.5G
Villeurbanne France
NOTE TECHNIQUE / TECHNICAL NOTE
FKGA2, seismic withstand IEC 0.5G
273
Page 4 / 25
Material 2: Enclosure support and drives support (purple)
Material 4: Enclosure bottom and current transformers Material 5: pole bottom housing

Material 11, 13, 14 and 15: Bolts Material 16: concentrated masses (red)
Material 10: (dark blue) CB pole moving side (left) and fixed side (right)
Material 9 (yellow green) and 12 (blue): Links

1.3. Presentation of ANSYS Software


The analysis is based on the finite element method developed in the ANSYS v13.0 computer
code, property of Ansys Corp. It is used for modelling three dimensional structures with beam,
shell and mass element. This software has been used for static, modal and spectrum analysis.
© ALSTOM 2010. Alle rechte vorbehalten. All rights reserved. Tous droits réservés. Tutti i diritti riservati. Reservados todos los derechos. Todos os direitos reservados.
Ce document et toutes les informations et données qu'il contient sont confidentiels et sont la propriété légale de l'auteur. Ils ne doivent pas être diffusés, copiés ou utilisés à quelques fins que ce soit sans accord écrit préalable.
This document and any information or descriptive matter set out in it are confidential and copyright property and must not be disclosed, loaned copied or used for any purpose whatsoever without prior written permission

Emission / First Issue Indice actuel / Actual Index Index


Date d’émission / Issue date Etabli par / Compiled by Date de modification / Revision Date Etabli par / Compiled by Approuvé par / Released by

2014-10-30 G. DOUMMAR D. RODRIGUES


02
GRID
Products
FKGA2, tenue sismique CEI 0.5G
Villeurbanne France
FKGA2, seismic withstand IEC 0.5G NOTE TECHNIQUE / TECHNICAL NOTE

273
Page 5 / 25
2. Modelisation

2. 1. Conventions

2.1.1. Units
The following units are used in Ansys software:
Mass: tonne Frequency: Hz
Volume mass: t.mm-3 Force: N
Acceleration: mm.s-2 Moment: N.mm or daN.m
Displacement: mm Stress: MPa
Moment of inertia: mm4

2.1.2. Coordinate system


The following axis system has been used through the study:
X axis: transversal axis
Y axis: longitudinal axis
Z axis: vertical axis

2.2. Models

2.2.1. Elements
The model is composed of shell elements, beam elements, mass21 elements and surf
elements:
-SHELL181: Triangular shell element suitable for analyzing thin to moderately-thick
shell structures.
-BEAM44: uniaxial element with tension, compression, torsion, and bending
capabilities.
-MASS21: MASS21 is a point element having up to six degrees of freedom:
translations in the nodal x, y, and z directions and rotations about the nodal x, y, and z
axes. A different mass and rotary inertia may be assigned to each coordinate direction.
-SURF154: 3D element. SURF154 may be used for various load and surface effect
applications. It may be overlaid onto an area face of any 3-D element. The element is
applicable to 3-D structural analyses. Various loads and surface effects may exist
simultaneously.
The number of nodes and degrees of freedom (dof) per element are:
- SHELL181: 4 nodes per element and 6 dof per node.
- BEAM44: 2 nodes per element and 6 dof per node.
- MASS21: 1 node per element and 6 dof per node.
- SURF154: 4 to 8 nodes per elements and 3 dof per node.

2.2.2. Inertial, geometric characteristics


For each element type, the input data (inertial and geometrical characteristics) is different.
These values are stored in the ANSYS preprocessor in “real constants” tables.
-SHELL181: Triangular shell
Input value is the thickness of the shell at each node.
-BEAM44: three dimensional beams
© ALSTOM 2010. Alle rechte vorbehalten. All rights reserved. Tous droits réservés. Tutti i diritti riservati. Reservados todos los derechos. Todos os direitos reservados.
Ce document et toutes les informations et données qu'il contient sont confidentiels et sont la propriété légale de l'auteur. Ils ne doivent pas être diffusés, copiés ou utilisés à quelques fins que ce soit sans accord écrit préalable.
This document and any information or descriptive matter set out in it are confidential and copyright property and must not be disclosed, loaned copied or used for any purpose whatsoever without prior written permission

Emission / First Issue Indice actuel / Actual Index Index


Date d’émission / Issue date Etabli par / Compiled by Date de modification / Revision Date Etabli par / Compiled by Approuvé par / Released by

2014-10-30 G. DOUMMAR D. RODRIGUES


02
GRID
Products
FKGA2, tenue sismique CEI 0.5G
Villeurbanne France
NOTE TECHNIQUE / TECHNICAL NOTE
FKGA2, seismic withstand IEC 0.5G
273
Page 6 / 25
Input data for this type of element are the cross-section area, the two moments of inertia and
the width of the beam at each node.
-MASS21: Point element.
Input values are the masses in each direction and the rotary inertia in each direction.

2.2.3. Geometrical model


The model used for this analysis has 25918 elements and 13550 nodes.
On the model, the location of each beam is given by its neutral axis and the location of each
shell is given by its neutral plane.

2.3. Material characteristics


Materials are described by the following properties:
Elastic modulus (Young’s modulus) EX
Poisson’s ratio NUXY
Mass density DENS
Damping ratio DAMP
Component young mass density poisson’ reference
modulus E (tonn/mm3) s ratio number (per
(N/mm²) material)
Frame 206000 7.85e-9 0.32 1
Enclosure support + drive 210000 7.85e-9 0.3 2
mechanism support
Enclosure sheet metal 69000 2.7e-9 0.33 3
Current transformer and 71000 2.66e-9 0.33 4
enclosure bottom
Pole bottom housing 69000 2.65e-9 0.28 5
Drive mechanisms 70000 2.67e-9 0.35 6
Main drive mechanism 190000 10.1314e-9 0.3 7
Bushings 73084 2.7936e-9 0.33 8
Links between components 2100000 3e-12 0.3 9
CB pole 70000 1e-9 0.3 10
Bolts 206000 7.85e-9 0.3 11-13-14
Links of bushings 210000 7.8e-12 0.3 12
Spacer fixing main drive 69500 2.71e-9 0.33 15
For all parts, a damping ratio of 2% is used.

The following table gives the material and the allowable stress of each component of the
FKGA2:
component material Re (Mpa) yield
stress
Frame NT1104 235
Enclosure support S355MC 355
Enclosure sheet metal NT1460 – H12 65
Enclosure bottom NT1381– H111 115
Current transformer NT1381 – H111 115

© ALSTOM 2010. Alle rechte vorbehalten. All rights reserved. Tous droits réservés. Tutti i diritti riservati. Reservados todos los derechos. Todos os direitos reservados.
Ce document et toutes les informations et données qu'il contient sont confidentiels et sont la propriété légale de l'auteur. Ils ne doivent pas être diffusés, copiés ou utilisés à quelques fins que ce soit sans accord écrit préalable.
This document and any information or descriptive matter set out in it are confidential and copyright property and must not be disclosed, loaned copied or used for any purpose whatsoever without prior written permission

Emission / First Issue Indice actuel / Actual Index Index


Date d’émission / Issue date Etabli par / Compiled by Date de modification / Revision Date Etabli par / Compiled by Approuvé par / Released by

2014-10-30 G. DOUMMAR D. RODRIGUES


02
GRID
Products
FKGA2, tenue sismique CEI 0.5G
Villeurbanne France
FKGA2, seismic withstand IEC 0.5G NOTE TECHNIQUE / TECHNICAL NOTE

273
Page 7 / 25
Pole bottom housing 190 NT1084-0.3ST6
Drive mechanism 80 NT1383 – H111
Main drive mechanism 80 NT1383 – H111
Bushings 85 NT1460
component bending daNm material
moment limit
=1.5xMML
CB insulators Composite 2700
For metallic component, allowable limit is 100% of elastic limit (safety factor of 1)
For example for S355 MC, allowable limit is 355 MPa
Form non ductile component (composite insulators), a safety factor of 1 has to be achieved.

The following table gives the mass of each component modelled with ANSYS:
component mass/unit number mass
(kg/unit) (kg)
Frame - 1 529.1
Drive mechanism support + enclosure - 1 487.2
support
Enclosure sheet metal 162.6 3 487.8
Current transformer and enclosure bottom 281.34 3 844.
Pole bottom housing 21.35 3 64.
Drive mechanisms 23.9 4 95.6
Main drive mechanism 1 377.7
Bushings 46.23 3 138.7
Links between components 0.6
CB pole 383.44 3 1150.3
Bolts 133 3.1
capacitors, IKG, voltage transformers, 36 963
surge arresters
total mass (kg) 5141.1

2.4. Boundary Conditions


FKGA2 is composed of 1 supporting frame (3 enclosure supports + 2 longitudinal beam)
lying on feet. Each foot is individually fixed on the floor by two fixation screws.

The boundary conditions applied to each fixing nodes corresponding to these anchorage
do not allow displacement: Ux=Uy=Uz=0.
The boundary conditions applied to each fixing nodes corresponding to these anchorage
allow every rotations: Rx ≠ 0, Ry ≠ 0 and Rz ≠ 0.
These conditions are applied on the following nodes:
1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,9,10,11,12
A supplementary boundary condition is added on the extremity of the 3 hollow fixed
cylinders (bushing) which lose their 3 translations.
These conditions are applied on the following nodes: 15,16,17

© ALSTOM 2010. Alle rechte vorbehalten. All rights reserved. Tous droits réservés. Tutti i diritti riservati. Reservados todos los derechos. Todos os direitos reservados.
Ce document et toutes les informations et données qu'il contient sont confidentiels et sont la propriété légale de l'auteur. Ils ne doivent pas être diffusés, copiés ou utilisés à quelques fins que ce soit sans accord écrit préalable.
This document and any information or descriptive matter set out in it are confidential and copyright property and must not be disclosed, loaned copied or used for any purpose whatsoever without prior written permission

Emission / First Issue Indice actuel / Actual Index Index


Date d’émission / Issue date Etabli par / Compiled by Date de modification / Revision Date Etabli par / Compiled by Approuvé par / Released by

2014-10-30 G. DOUMMAR D. RODRIGUES


02
GRID
Products
FKGA2, tenue sismique CEI 0.5G
Villeurbanne France
NOTE TECHNIQUE / TECHNICAL NOTE
FKGA2, seismic withstand IEC 0.5G
273
Page 8 / 25

3. Loads
Two types of analysis have been performed on FKGA2: static analysis and spectral analysis.
Static analysis has been performed to simulate the weight of the structure and pressure of wind.
Modal analysis has been made
Static analysis has been done in order to include non participative mass in the spectral analysis.
Spectral analysis has been performed to calculate stresses on the circuit breaker caused by
seism on each direction.

3.1. Dead weight


Dead weight is calculated by a static analysis with a 9810 mm/s² acceleration in the -Z
direction.

3.2. Wind
Wind velocity considered is 200km/h, v = 200/3.6 m/s (ou 200/3.6*1e-3mm/s)
Air density, ρ = 1.23 kg/m3=1.23e-12 tonne/mm3
According to IEC standard 10% of wind pressure is to be considered with seismic case
Pressure pr=1/10*1.23/2*v²=189.8 N/m²or Pa = 0.1898e-3N/mm² or MPa
Multiplied by Cx=1.5 for flat surfaces and cx=0.9 on cylinders (bushing, element type700)
This pressure is applied in 4 load cases: minus X, minus Y, plus X, plus Y

3.3. Seismic force

3.3.1. Presentation of a spectral analysis


A spectral analysis is a technique which permits to compute a structure’s response to transient
excitations that contain many frequencies.
A spectrum is a representation of a load’s time history in the frequency domain.

© ALSTOM 2010. Alle rechte vorbehalten. All rights reserved. Tous droits réservés. Tutti i diritti riservati. Reservados todos los derechos. Todos os direitos reservados.
Ce document et toutes les informations et données qu'il contient sont confidentiels et sont la propriété légale de l'auteur. Ils ne doivent pas être diffusés, copiés ou utilisés à quelques fins que ce soit sans accord écrit préalable.
This document and any information or descriptive matter set out in it are confidential and copyright property and must not be disclosed, loaned copied or used for any purpose whatsoever without prior written permission

Emission / First Issue Indice actuel / Actual Index Index


Date d’émission / Issue date Etabli par / Compiled by Date de modification / Revision Date Etabli par / Compiled by Approuvé par / Released by

2014-10-30 G. DOUMMAR D. RODRIGUES


02
GRID
Products
FKGA2, tenue sismique CEI 0.5G
Villeurbanne France
FKGA2, seismic withstand IEC 0.5G NOTE TECHNIQUE / TECHNICAL NOTE

273
Page 9 / 25
By launching a spectral analysis, it computes the maximum response of the structure to a given
spectrum at each natural frequency. This maximum response is computed as scale factor *
mode shape. These maximum responses are then combined to give a total response of the
structure.
Spectrum analysis follows a modal analysis in which natural frequencies and mode shapes
have been computed. It needs the sum of effective masses obtained at each mode to
determinate the acceleration to apply to the structure on each direction.
For each mode of the structure, a participation factor (function of the mode shape and the
direction excitation) is calculated in the excitation direction. This is a measure of how much a
mode will contribute to the deflections (and hence stresses) in the direction of excitation.

3.3.2. IEC Standard

Spectrum used to perform the spectral analysis is imposed by the IEC standards TR 62271-
300 First edition 2006-11.

IEC spectrum reaches 14000 mm/s² (1.4 g) for a 2% damping material and 8700 mm/s² (0.87
g) for a 5% damping material in the x and y direction.
For the z direction, the acceleration imposed is 50% of X and Y values

For the dynamic calculations, a first calculation has been performed with the dead weight and
static forces applied for the seismic requirements.
Then, a modal analysis of the model is done. It determines the modes and participating mass
of the structure for seismic calculation.
For each direction, a combination of all the modes with the SRSS method is made.
These calculations are done with a spectrum method to take into account the spectrum for
each damping factor.

We combined these results with the results of the first calculations to obtain all the load cases.
Curves which present acceleration versus frequencies are detailed at the annex 6.

© ALSTOM 2010. Alle rechte vorbehalten. All rights reserved. Tous droits réservés. Tutti i diritti riservati. Reservados todos los derechos. Todos os direitos reservados.
Ce document et toutes les informations et données qu'il contient sont confidentiels et sont la propriété légale de l'auteur. Ils ne doivent pas être diffusés, copiés ou utilisés à quelques fins que ce soit sans accord écrit préalable.
This document and any information or descriptive matter set out in it are confidential and copyright property and must not be disclosed, loaned copied or used for any purpose whatsoever without prior written permission

Emission / First Issue Indice actuel / Actual Index Index


Date d’émission / Issue date Etabli par / Compiled by Date de modification / Revision Date Etabli par / Compiled by Approuvé par / Released by

2014-10-30 G. DOUMMAR D. RODRIGUES


02
GRID
Products
FKGA2, tenue sismique CEI 0.5G
Villeurbanne France
NOTE TECHNIQUE / TECHNICAL NOTE
FKGA2, seismic withstand IEC 0.5G
273
Page 10 / 25

3.4. Load combinations


Load combinations are done according to IEC specifications.
Since FKGA2 is not symmetrical, eight load cases are specified.
P is 100% gravity load
Wmx is 10% wind minus X direction
Wpx is 10% wind plus X direction
Wmy is 10% wind minus Y direction
Wpy is 10% wind plus Y direction
SX is 100% seismic load in X direction
SY is 100% seismic load in Y direction
SZ is 100% seismic load in Z direction
Load Combination name Loads applied
LC1 P+wmx-Sx-Sz
LC2 P+wmx-Sx+Sz
LC3 P+wpx+Sx-Sz
LC4 P+wpx+Sx+Sz
LC5 P+wmy-Sy-Sz
LC6 P+wmy-Sy+Sz
LC7 P+wpy+Sy-Sz
LC8 P+wpy+Sy+Sz

4. Results

4.1. Modal Analysis


Modes value Participating mass (kg)
Number (Hz) X Y Z
1 10,753 32 2464 0
2 11,892 3 223 41
3 12,947 2 4 1
4 14,26 1412 129 31
5 16,182 13 532 539
6 16,768 190 10 12
7 16,946 1 49 9
8 17,025 22 38 10
9 18,336 11 874 46
10 21,388 101 4 33
11 21,86 1568 0 41
12 22,497 108 49 40
13 24,583 338 1 16
14 24,877 44 7 88
15 25,242 1 4 1
16 25,773 370 2 3
17 26,004 139 2 3
18 26,463 0 5 1
19 26,834 132 0 5
20 27,003 31 3 501
© ALSTOM 2010. Alle rechte vorbehalten. All rights reserved. Tous droits réservés. Tutti i diritti riservati. Reservados todos los derechos. Todos os direitos reservados.
Ce document et toutes les informations et données qu'il contient sont confidentiels et sont la propriété légale de l'auteur. Ils ne doivent pas être diffusés, copiés ou utilisés à quelques fins que ce soit sans accord écrit préalable.
This document and any information or descriptive matter set out in it are confidential and copyright property and must not be disclosed, loaned copied or used for any purpose whatsoever without prior written permission

Emission / First Issue Indice actuel / Actual Index Index


Date d’émission / Issue date Etabli par / Compiled by Date de modification / Revision Date Etabli par / Compiled by Approuvé par / Released by

2014-10-30 G. DOUMMAR D. RODRIGUES


02
GRID
Products
FKGA2, tenue sismique CEI 0.5G
Villeurbanne France
FKGA2, seismic withstand IEC 0.5G NOTE TECHNIQUE / TECHNICAL NOTE

273
Page 11 / 25
21 27,483 0 47 1
22 27,846 0 3 25
23 28,202 26 10 8
24 28,506 1 0 47
25 28,645 6 6 2
26 29,025 52 27 15
27 29,249 1 1 6
28 29,448 2 14 9
29 29,567 0 5 9
30 30,441 0 0 0
31 31,237 54 11 368
32 31,534 4 1 86
33 31,975 1 5 2
34 34,473 5 13 11
35 34,724 1 43 199
36 35,801 32 4 312
37 36,166 6 2 14
38 37,143 0 10 2
39 37,443 0 301 33
40 38,363 8 1 58
41 38,43 12 1 44
42 38,752 1 5 22
43 39,801 23 0 587
44 40,346 1 0 1
45 40,349 0 0 0
46 40,367 1 0 8
47 41,995 2 0 118
48 43,227 8 1 221
49 44,428 6 0 5
50 44,837 51 0 45
51 46,339 1 4 1
52 46,518 3 1 9
53 47,187 0 0 0
54 47,214 3 0 25
55 47,61 0 0 1
56 48,055 0 0 27
57 48,148 0 1 3
58 48,732 0 7 14
59 48,939 0 0 23
60 49,694 2 7 1
61 50,367 1 0 8
62 50,777 5 0 120
63 51,987 9 6 15
64 52,349 9 3 2
65 54,697 1 2 92
66 55,486 2 5 225
67 56,073 3 3 9
68 56,961 0 0 4
69 57,269 0 0 20
© ALSTOM 2010. Alle rechte vorbehalten. All rights reserved. Tous droits réservés. Tutti i diritti riservati. Reservados todos los derechos. Todos os direitos reservados.
Ce document et toutes les informations et données qu'il contient sont confidentiels et sont la propriété légale de l'auteur. Ils ne doivent pas être diffusés, copiés ou utilisés à quelques fins que ce soit sans accord écrit préalable.
This document and any information or descriptive matter set out in it are confidential and copyright property and must not be disclosed, loaned copied or used for any purpose whatsoever without prior written permission

Emission / First Issue Indice actuel / Actual Index Index


Date d’émission / Issue date Etabli par / Compiled by Date de modification / Revision Date Etabli par / Compiled by Approuvé par / Released by

2014-10-30 G. DOUMMAR D. RODRIGUES


02
GRID
Products
FKGA2, tenue sismique CEI 0.5G
Villeurbanne France
NOTE TECHNIQUE / TECHNICAL NOTE
FKGA2, seismic withstand IEC 0.5G
273
Page 12 / 25
70 58,14 0 9 5
71 59,763 0 0 0
72 59,926 0 0 1
73 60,224 1 4 13
74 61,827 0 0 0
75 65,029 0 0 4
76 65,606 1 0 2
77 65,672 0 0 1
78 66,114 2 0 9
79 67,371 0 2 44
80 68,728 0 0 39
81 72,135 0 0 2
82 72,829 0 0 1
83 73,236 0 1 2
84 76,276 0 0 46
85 77,097 0 1 2
86 77,89 0 0 1
87 78,18 0 0 37
88 79,497 0 0 5
89 80,076 0 0 0
90 80,668 0 0 2
91 80,995 0 1 1
92 81,717 0 0 0
93 82,484 0 0 2
94 82,925 0 0 0
95 83,379 0 0 30
96 86,415 0 0 2
97 87,724 0 0 7
98 88,532 0 0 9
99 88,914 0 0 0
100 89,186 0 1 7
101 89,99 0 0 62
102 90,56 0 0 7
103 91,184 0 0 3
104 92,064 0 0 0
105 94,333 0 0 1
106 96,162 0 0 0
107 97,05 0 0 0
108 98,442 0 0 1
109 98,921 0 0 0
110 99,219 0 0 0
111 100,216 0 0 2
112 100,728 1 0 0
113 100,938 2 0 6
114 101,174 1 0 0
115 102,167 0 0 66
116 102,537 1 0 16
117 103,858 1 0 6
118 105,765 0 0 10
© ALSTOM 2010. Alle rechte vorbehalten. All rights reserved. Tous droits réservés. Tutti i diritti riservati. Reservados todos los derechos. Todos os direitos reservados.
Ce document et toutes les informations et données qu'il contient sont confidentiels et sont la propriété légale de l'auteur. Ils ne doivent pas être diffusés, copiés ou utilisés à quelques fins que ce soit sans accord écrit préalable.
This document and any information or descriptive matter set out in it are confidential and copyright property and must not be disclosed, loaned copied or used for any purpose whatsoever without prior written permission

Emission / First Issue Indice actuel / Actual Index Index


Date d’émission / Issue date Etabli par / Compiled by Date de modification / Revision Date Etabli par / Compiled by Approuvé par / Released by

2014-10-30 G. DOUMMAR D. RODRIGUES


02
GRID
Products
FKGA2, tenue sismique CEI 0.5G
Villeurbanne France
FKGA2, seismic withstand IEC 0.5G NOTE TECHNIQUE / TECHNICAL NOTE

273
Page 13 / 25
119 106,918 0 0 16
120 107,909 1 0 17
121 109,207 0 0 0
122 111,058 0 0 0
123 111,306 0 0 1
124 112,168 0 0 10
125 113,08 0 0 0
126 113,828 0 0 6
127 114,547 0 0 31
128 115,444 0 0 0
129 115,663 0 0 35
130 117,3 0 0 9
131 118,886 0 0 1
132 119,356 3 0 0
133 119,471 0 0 0
134 119,756 0 0 0
135 120,065 0 0 1
136 123,149 0 0 0
137 124,086 0 0 1
138 129,575 0 0 0
139 130,631 0 0 3
140 132,683 0 0 1
141 132,801 1 0 1
142 133,852 0 1 5
143 135,312 0 0 1
144 135,756 0 0 0
145 136,777 0 0 0
146 137,957 0 0 0
147 139,53 0 0 0
148 140,656 0 0 0
149 140,917 0 0 0
150 140,946 0 0 1
151 141,054 0 0 2
152 141,917 0 0 0
153 143,247 1 0 0
154 146,189 0 0 0
155 147,526 0 0 0
156 148,55 0 0 1
157 148,598 0 0 1
158 148,749 0 0 0
159 150,537 1 0 0
160 154,352 0 0 0
161 157,582 0 0 0
162 160,417 0 0 0
163 163,247 0 0 0
164 164,142 0 0 2
165 165,594 0 0 0
166 165,942 0 0 0
167 167,249 0 0 0
© ALSTOM 2010. Alle rechte vorbehalten. All rights reserved. Tous droits réservés. Tutti i diritti riservati. Reservados todos los derechos. Todos os direitos reservados.
Ce document et toutes les informations et données qu'il contient sont confidentiels et sont la propriété légale de l'auteur. Ils ne doivent pas être diffusés, copiés ou utilisés à quelques fins que ce soit sans accord écrit préalable.
This document and any information or descriptive matter set out in it are confidential and copyright property and must not be disclosed, loaned copied or used for any purpose whatsoever without prior written permission

Emission / First Issue Indice actuel / Actual Index Index


Date d’émission / Issue date Etabli par / Compiled by Date de modification / Revision Date Etabli par / Compiled by Approuvé par / Released by

2014-10-30 G. DOUMMAR D. RODRIGUES


02
GRID
Products
FKGA2, tenue sismique CEI 0.5G
Villeurbanne France
NOTE TECHNIQUE / TECHNICAL NOTE
FKGA2, seismic withstand IEC 0.5G
273
Page 14 / 25
168 172,866 1 0 2
169 173,926 0 0 0
170 173,983 0 0 0
171 174,982 0 0 0
172 175,02 0 0 0
173 175,792 0 0 1
174 176,382 1 0 4
175 177,612 1 0 4
176 178,735 3 0 2
177 180,089 0 0 0
178 180,631 0 0 0
179 181,049 0 0 0
180 182,727 0 0 0
181 182,948 0 0 1
182 183,105 0 0 0
183 186,296 0 0 0
184 189,397 0 1 0
185 189,847 0 0 0
186 191,577 0 1 2
187 192,194 0 1 1
188 192,904 0 0 0
189 193,302 1 0 1
190 193,418 0 0 1
191 194,842 0 0 0
192 195,069 0 0 0
193 195,896 0 0 0
194 198,036 0 0 0
195 200,073 0 0 0
196 201,37 0 0 0
197 205,238 0 0 0
198 206,374 0 0 0
199 208,341 0 0 1
200 209,287 1 0 6
total mass participation 4888 (X) 4976 (Y) 4911 (Z)
total mass 5141 5141 5141
participation % 95.07 % 96.79 % 95.51%

The table presented above gives the mass participation per each mode and the total mass
participation in each direction.
The values printed in bolt are the natural frequencies for which there is a maximal mass
participation in each direction. They represent the frequencies for which the structure will be
requested at it maximum.

© ALSTOM 2010. Alle rechte vorbehalten. All rights reserved. Tous droits réservés. Tutti i diritti riservati. Reservados todos los derechos. Todos os direitos reservados.
Ce document et toutes les informations et données qu'il contient sont confidentiels et sont la propriété légale de l'auteur. Ils ne doivent pas être diffusés, copiés ou utilisés à quelques fins que ce soit sans accord écrit préalable.
This document and any information or descriptive matter set out in it are confidential and copyright property and must not be disclosed, loaned copied or used for any purpose whatsoever without prior written permission

Emission / First Issue Indice actuel / Actual Index Index


Date d’émission / Issue date Etabli par / Compiled by Date de modification / Revision Date Etabli par / Compiled by Approuvé par / Released by

2014-10-30 G. DOUMMAR D. RODRIGUES


02
GRID
Products
FKGA2, tenue sismique CEI 0.5G
Villeurbanne France
FKGA2, seismic withstand IEC 0.5G NOTE TECHNIQUE / TECHNICAL NOTE

273
Page 15 / 25
4.2. Displacments
Load Combination’s Loads applied Max Displacement (mm)
LC1 P+wmx-Sx-Sz 3,63
LC2 P+wmx-Sx+Sz 2,07
LC3 P+wpx+Sx-Sz 2,52
LC4 P+wpx+Sx+Sz 3,19
LC5 P+wmy-Sy-Sz 6,75
LC6 P+wmy-Sy+Sz 6,08
LC7 P+wpy+Sy-Sz 6,27
LC8 P+wpy+Sy+Sz 7,22

Load case 8: Highest displacements

4.3. Stress

4.3.1 Stresses on frame


Load Combination’s Loads applied Max Stress (MPa)
LC1 P+wmx-Sx-Sz 49,4
LC2 P+wmx-Sx+Sz 36,7
LC3 P+wpx+Sx-Sz 41,7
LC4 P+wpx+Sx+Sz 64,6
LC5 P+wmy-Sy-Sz 121,3
LC6 P+wmy-Sy+Sz 110,5
LC7 P+wpy+Sy-Sz 88,7
LC8 P+wpy+Sy+Sz 99,4
Allowable Limit 235
Safety factor 1.94
© ALSTOM 2010. Alle rechte vorbehalten. All rights reserved. Tous droits réservés. Tutti i diritti riservati. Reservados todos los derechos. Todos os direitos reservados.
Ce document et toutes les informations et données qu'il contient sont confidentiels et sont la propriété légale de l'auteur. Ils ne doivent pas être diffusés, copiés ou utilisés à quelques fins que ce soit sans accord écrit préalable.
This document and any information or descriptive matter set out in it are confidential and copyright property and must not be disclosed, loaned copied or used for any purpose whatsoever without prior written permission

Emission / First Issue Indice actuel / Actual Index Index


Date d’émission / Issue date Etabli par / Compiled by Date de modification / Revision Date Etabli par / Compiled by Approuvé par / Released by

2014-10-30 G. DOUMMAR D. RODRIGUES


02
GRID
Products
FKGA2, tenue sismique CEI 0.5G
Villeurbanne France
NOTE TECHNIQUE / TECHNICAL NOTE
FKGA2, seismic withstand IEC 0.5G
273
Page 16 / 25

Load case 5: Highest Stresses level

4.3.2 Stresses on enclosure support and drive mechanism support


Load Combination’s Loads applied Max Stress (MPa)
LC1 P+wmx-Sx-Sz 29,5
LC2 P+wmx-Sx+Sz 18,1
LC3 P+wpx+Sx-Sz 20,1
LC4 P+wpx+Sx+Sz 30,2
LC5 P+wmy-Sy-Sz 43,1
LC6 P+wmy-Sy+Sz 30,6
LC7 P+wpy+Sy-Sz 35,3
LC8 P+wpy+Sy+Sz 43,3
Allowable Limit 355
Safety factor 8.2

Load case 8: Highest Stresses level

© ALSTOM 2010. Alle rechte vorbehalten. All rights reserved. Tous droits réservés. Tutti i diritti riservati. Reservados todos los derechos. Todos os direitos reservados.
Ce document et toutes les informations et données qu'il contient sont confidentiels et sont la propriété légale de l'auteur. Ils ne doivent pas être diffusés, copiés ou utilisés à quelques fins que ce soit sans accord écrit préalable.
This document and any information or descriptive matter set out in it are confidential and copyright property and must not be disclosed, loaned copied or used for any purpose whatsoever without prior written permission

Emission / First Issue Indice actuel / Actual Index Index


Date d’émission / Issue date Etabli par / Compiled by Date de modification / Revision Date Etabli par / Compiled by Approuvé par / Released by

2014-10-30 G. DOUMMAR D. RODRIGUES


02
GRID
Products
FKGA2, tenue sismique CEI 0.5G
Villeurbanne France
FKGA2, seismic withstand IEC 0.5G NOTE TECHNIQUE / TECHNICAL NOTE

273
Page 17 / 25

4.3.3 Stresses on enclosures


Load Combination’s Loads applied Max Stress (MPa)
LC1 P+wmx-Sx-Sz 11,4
LC2 P+wmx-Sx+Sz 9,3
LC3 P+wpx+Sx-Sz 9
LC4 P+wpx+Sx+Sz 10,8
LC5 P+wmy-Sy-Sz 18
LC6 P+wmy-Sy+Sz 16
LC7 P+wpy+Sy-Sz 16,9
LC8 P+wpy+Sy+Sz 18,6
Allowable Limit 65
Safety factor 3.49

Load case 8: Highest Stresses level


4.3.4 Stresses on enclosure bottom and current transformers
Load Combination’s Loads applied Max Stress (MPa)
LC1 P+wmx-Sx-Sz 12,5
LC2 P+wmx-Sx+Sz 10,7
LC3 P+wpx+Sx-Sz 9,5
LC4 P+wpx+Sx+Sz 14,4
LC5 P+wmy-Sy-Sz 41,3
LC6 P+wmy-Sy+Sz 36,3
LC7 P+wpy+Sy-Sz 37,6
LC8 P+wpy+Sy+Sz 42,6
Allowable Limit 115
Safety factor 2.7

© ALSTOM 2010. Alle rechte vorbehalten. All rights reserved. Tous droits réservés. Tutti i diritti riservati. Reservados todos los derechos. Todos os direitos reservados.
Ce document et toutes les informations et données qu'il contient sont confidentiels et sont la propriété légale de l'auteur. Ils ne doivent pas être diffusés, copiés ou utilisés à quelques fins que ce soit sans accord écrit préalable.
This document and any information or descriptive matter set out in it are confidential and copyright property and must not be disclosed, loaned copied or used for any purpose whatsoever without prior written permission

Emission / First Issue Indice actuel / Actual Index Index


Date d’émission / Issue date Etabli par / Compiled by Date de modification / Revision Date Etabli par / Compiled by Approuvé par / Released by

2014-10-30 G. DOUMMAR D. RODRIGUES


02
GRID
Products
FKGA2, tenue sismique CEI 0.5G
Villeurbanne France
NOTE TECHNIQUE / TECHNICAL NOTE
FKGA2, seismic withstand IEC 0.5G
273
Page 18 / 25

Load case 8: Highest Stresses level


4.3.5 Stresses on pole bottom housing
Load Combination’s Loads applied Max Stress (MPa)
LC1 P+wmx-Sx-Sz 8
LC2 P+wmx-Sx+Sz 4,5
LC3 P+wpx+Sx-Sz 5,9
LC4 P+wpx+Sx+Sz 10,3
LC5 P+wmy-Sy-Sz 31,7
LC6 P+wmy-Sy+Sz 27,9
LC7 P+wpy+Sy-Sz 27,8
LC8 P+wpy+Sy+Sz 31,6
Allowable Limit 190
Safety factor 6.0

Load case 5: Highest Stresses level

© ALSTOM 2010. Alle rechte vorbehalten. All rights reserved. Tous droits réservés. Tutti i diritti riservati. Reservados todos los derechos. Todos os direitos reservados.
Ce document et toutes les informations et données qu'il contient sont confidentiels et sont la propriété légale de l'auteur. Ils ne doivent pas être diffusés, copiés ou utilisés à quelques fins que ce soit sans accord écrit préalable.
This document and any information or descriptive matter set out in it are confidential and copyright property and must not be disclosed, loaned copied or used for any purpose whatsoever without prior written permission

Emission / First Issue Indice actuel / Actual Index Index


Date d’émission / Issue date Etabli par / Compiled by Date de modification / Revision Date Etabli par / Compiled by Approuvé par / Released by

2014-10-30 G. DOUMMAR D. RODRIGUES


02
GRID
Products
FKGA2, tenue sismique CEI 0.5G
Villeurbanne France
FKGA2, seismic withstand IEC 0.5G NOTE TECHNIQUE / TECHNICAL NOTE

273
Page 19 / 25

4.3.6 Stresses on drive mechanisms (MPa)


Load Combination’s Loads applied CMK Main drive FK
LC1 P+wmx-Sx-Sz 2,3 6
LC2 P+wmx-Sx+Sz 1,2 5
LC3 P+wpx+Sx-Sz 1,3 5,5
LC4 P+wpx+Sx+Sz 2,5 6,6
LC5 P+wmy-Sy-Sz 2,9 3,6
LC6 P+wmy-Sy+Sz 1,7 2,6
LC7 P+wpy+Sy-Sz 1,7 3
LC8 P+wpy+Sy+Sz 3 4
Allowable Limit 80 80

Load case 8: Highest Stresses level

Safety factor 12.1 Load case 4: Highest Stresses level


© ALSTOM 2010. Alle rechte vorbehalten. All rights reserved. Tous droits réservés. Tutti i diritti riservati. Reservados todos los derechos. Todos os direitos reservados.
Ce document et toutes les informations et données qu'il contient sont confidentiels et sont la propriété légale de l'auteur. Ils ne doivent pas être diffusés, copiés ou utilisés à quelques fins que ce soit sans accord écrit préalable.
This document and any information or descriptive matter set out in it are confidential and copyright property and must not be disclosed, loaned copied or used for any purpose whatsoever without prior written permission

Emission / First Issue Indice actuel / Actual Index Index


Date d’émission / Issue date Etabli par / Compiled by Date de modification / Revision Date Etabli par / Compiled by Approuvé par / Released by

2014-10-30 G. DOUMMAR D. RODRIGUES


02
GRID
Products
FKGA2, tenue sismique CEI 0.5G
Villeurbanne France
NOTE TECHNIQUE / TECHNICAL NOTE
FKGA2, seismic withstand IEC 0.5G
273
Page 20 / 25

4.3.7 Stresses on bushing


Load Combination’s Loads applied Max Stress (MPa)
LC1 P+wmx-Sx-Sz 6,8
LC2 P+wmx-Sx+Sz 5,5
LC3 P+wpx+Sx-Sz 5,7
LC4 P+wpx+Sx+Sz 7,1
LC5 P+wmy-Sy-Sz 12,8
LC6 P+wmy-Sy+Sz 11,6
LC7 P+wpy+Sy-Sz 9,9
LC8 P+wpy+Sy+Sz 11
Allowable Limit 85
Safety factor 6.6

Load case 5: Highest Stresses level

4.3.8 Bending moments on CB insulators


All the bending moments are given in daN.m. They’re calculated at the base of insulators only,
where max values are expected.
The six insulators of the circuit breaker poles moving side (left) and fixed side (right) are
referenced in the picture below:

© ALSTOM 2010. Alle rechte vorbehalten. All rights reserved. Tous droits réservés. Tutti i diritti riservati. Reservados todos los derechos. Todos os direitos reservados.
Ce document et toutes les informations et données qu'il contient sont confidentiels et sont la propriété légale de l'auteur. Ils ne doivent pas être diffusés, copiés ou utilisés à quelques fins que ce soit sans accord écrit préalable.
This document and any information or descriptive matter set out in it are confidential and copyright property and must not be disclosed, loaned copied or used for any purpose whatsoever without prior written permission

Emission / First Issue Indice actuel / Actual Index Index


Date d’émission / Issue date Etabli par / Compiled by Date de modification / Revision Date Etabli par / Compiled by Approuvé par / Released by

2014-10-30 G. DOUMMAR D. RODRIGUES


02
GRID
Products
FKGA2, tenue sismique CEI 0.5G
Villeurbanne France
FKGA2, seismic withstand IEC 0.5G NOTE TECHNIQUE / TECHNICAL NOTE

273
Page 21 / 25

Insulator 1 Insulator 2 Insulator 3


Insulator 4 Insulator 5 Insulator 6

In the following table, bending moment in insulators is indicated (daN.m)

Load Loads Max value Max value Max value Max value Max value Max value
Combination applied (insu1) (insu2) (insu3) (insu4) (insu5) (insu6)
LC1 P+wmx-Sx-Sz 156,9 141,2 113,6 55,8 44,2 44,8
LC2 P+wmx-Sx+Sz 102,8 72,7 22,7 30,6 11,1 9,3
LC3 P+wpx+Sx-Sz 101,5 71,4 21,6 40,5 20,9 8,6
LC4 P+wpx+Sx+Sz 155,7 140,1 112,6 64,6 52,6 51,3
LC5 P+wmy-Sy-Sz 156,4 116,5 224,9 72,2 50 99,3
LC6 P+wmy-Sy+Sz 77,3 52 151,5 39,6 25,7 70,9
LC7 P+wpy+Sy-Sz 76,8 52,1 151,6 41,3 23,8 69,4
LC8 P+wpy+Sy+Sz 155,9 116 224,6 75,5 53,8 101,4
Allowable Limit 2700 2700 2700 2700 2700 2700
Safety factor 14.1

© ALSTOM 2010. Alle rechte vorbehalten. All rights reserved. Tous droits réservés. Tutti i diritti riservati. Reservados todos los derechos. Todos os direitos reservados.
Ce document et toutes les informations et données qu'il contient sont confidentiels et sont la propriété légale de l'auteur. Ils ne doivent pas être diffusés, copiés ou utilisés à quelques fins que ce soit sans accord écrit préalable.
This document and any information or descriptive matter set out in it are confidential and copyright property and must not be disclosed, loaned copied or used for any purpose whatsoever without prior written permission

Emission / First Issue Indice actuel / Actual Index Index


Date d’émission / Issue date Etabli par / Compiled by Date de modification / Revision Date Etabli par / Compiled by Approuvé par / Released by

2014-10-30 G. DOUMMAR D. RODRIGUES


02
GRID
Products
FKGA2, tenue sismique CEI 0.5G
Villeurbanne France
NOTE TECHNIQUE / TECHNICAL NOTE
FKGA2, seismic withstand IEC 0.5G
273
Page 22 / 25
4.4 Bolts

4.4.1 Floor reaction


The screw used to link the frame feet to the ground are:
Screw HSL M16, class 8.8, ISO profile.
Equivalent section: 156.6 mm²
Yield stress: σe = 627 MPa Maximum elastic shear stress: Γe = 0.6*σe = 376 MPa
Tightening torque: C = 179 N.m according to Alstom specification. It gives the following tension
strength on the screw according to the N965 standard: Ft0= 61780 N.

Max shear value is 7064 N (load case 8)


Max traction value is 31466 N (load case 5)
Shear stress: 6862/156.6 = 45.1 MPa Safety factor = 376/45.1= 8.34
Tension stress: 31466/156.6 = 200.9 MPa Safety factor = 627/200.9 = 3.12.
Additionally, pretension load for M16 bolt is 61780 N, higher than 31466. No loss of torque.

4.4.2 Fixing of main drive


Screws used are HSL M20, class 8.8, ISO profile. Equivalent section: 244.8 mm²
Tightening torque: C = 348.8 N.m according to Alstom standard N965 which gives a tension
force of 96530 N
Max shear value is 5071 N (load case 4)
Max traction value is 9628 N (load case 4)
Shear stress: 5071/244.8 = 20.7 MPa Safety factor = 376/20.7= 18.2.
Tension stress: 9628/244.8 = 39.3 MPaSafety factor = 627/39.3 = 15.9.
Additionally, pretension load for M20 bolt is 96530 N, higher than 9628. No loss of torque.

4.4.2 Fixing of enclosure bottom to its support


Screws used are HSL M24, class 8.8, ISO profile. Equivalent section: 352.5 mm²
Tightening torque: C = 100 N.m according to instructions which gives tension force 22815 N
Max shear value is 14965 N (load case 8)
Max traction value is 10917 N (load case 5)
Shear stress: 14965/352.5 = 42.5 MPa Safety factor = 376/42.5= 8.8
Tension stress: 10917/352.5 = 31 MPa Safety factor = 627/31 = 20.2.
Additionally, pretension load for M24 bolt is 22815 N, higher than 10917. No loss of torque.

5. Conclusion

A seismic analysis of the FKGA2, based upon a spectral method, was carried out.
Safety factors for max bending values are far higher than 1.
Max stress values for metallic components are lower than elastic limit.
Safety factors for metallic components are higher than 1.
The results give the proof of the seismic withstand of the FKGA2 to earthquakes 0.5g IEC.

© ALSTOM 2010. Alle rechte vorbehalten. All rights reserved. Tous droits réservés. Tutti i diritti riservati. Reservados todos los derechos. Todos os direitos reservados.
Ce document et toutes les informations et données qu'il contient sont confidentiels et sont la propriété légale de l'auteur. Ils ne doivent pas être diffusés, copiés ou utilisés à quelques fins que ce soit sans accord écrit préalable.
This document and any information or descriptive matter set out in it are confidential and copyright property and must not be disclosed, loaned copied or used for any purpose whatsoever without prior written permission

Emission / First Issue Indice actuel / Actual Index Index


Date d’émission / Issue date Etabli par / Compiled by Date de modification / Revision Date Etabli par / Compiled by Approuvé par / Released by

2014-10-30 G. DOUMMAR D. RODRIGUES


02
GRID
Products
FKGA2, tenue sismique CEI 0.5G
Villeurbanne France
FKGA2, seismic withstand IEC 0.5G NOTE TECHNIQUE / TECHNICAL NOTE

273
Page 23 / 25
6. Annexes

6.1. Real for frame

Real 2: thickness 7mm (purple)


Real 3: thickness 16mm (red)
Real 4: thickness 10mm (blue)

6.2. Real for drive mechanism cubicles & part of frame and support
Real 1: thickness 10mm (blue)

© ALSTOM 2010. Alle rechte vorbehalten. All rights reserved. Tous droits réservés. Tutti i diritti riservati. Reservados todos los derechos. Todos os direitos reservados.
Ce document et toutes les informations et données qu'il contient sont confidentiels et sont la propriété légale de l'auteur. Ils ne doivent pas être diffusés, copiés ou utilisés à quelques fins que ce soit sans accord écrit préalable.
This document and any information or descriptive matter set out in it are confidential and copyright property and must not be disclosed, loaned copied or used for any purpose whatsoever without prior written permission

Emission / First Issue Indice actuel / Actual Index Index


Date d’émission / Issue date Etabli par / Compiled by Date de modification / Revision Date Etabli par / Compiled by Approuvé par / Released by

2014-10-30 G. DOUMMAR D. RODRIGUES


02
GRID
Products
FKGA2, tenue sismique CEI 0.5G
Villeurbanne France
NOTE TECHNIQUE / TECHNICAL NOTE
FKGA2, seismic withstand IEC 0.5G
273
Page 24 / 25
6.3. Real for enclosure
Real 5: thickness 6 mm (pink)

Real 6: thickness 12 (green) enclosure bottom

Real 7: thickness 20 mm (brown) inside transformer and pole bottom housing


Real 8: thickness 40 (pink) housing welding
Real 9: thickness 50 (light green) current transformer
Real 10: thickness 15 (dark blue) outside transformer
Real 11: thickness 8 (turquoise) CMK drives support

© ALSTOM 2010. Alle rechte vorbehalten. All rights reserved. Tous droits réservés. Tutti i diritti riservati. Reservados todos los derechos. Todos os direitos reservados.
Ce document et toutes les informations et données qu'il contient sont confidentiels et sont la propriété légale de l'auteur. Ils ne doivent pas être diffusés, copiés ou utilisés à quelques fins que ce soit sans accord écrit préalable.
This document and any information or descriptive matter set out in it are confidential and copyright property and must not be disclosed, loaned copied or used for any purpose whatsoever without prior written permission

Emission / First Issue Indice actuel / Actual Index Index


Date d’émission / Issue date Etabli par / Compiled by Date de modification / Revision Date Etabli par / Compiled by Approuvé par / Released by

2014-10-30 G. DOUMMAR D. RODRIGUES


02
GRID
Products
FKGA2, tenue sismique CEI 0.5G
Villeurbanne France
FKGA2, seismic withstand IEC 0.5G NOTE TECHNIQUE / TECHNICAL NOTE

273
Page 25 / 25
6.4. IEC Spectrum
Spectrum applied in X and Y directions:

Spectrum applied in Z direction:

© ALSTOM 2010. Alle rechte vorbehalten. All rights reserved. Tous droits réservés. Tutti i diritti riservati. Reservados todos los derechos. Todos os direitos reservados.
Ce document et toutes les informations et données qu'il contient sont confidentiels et sont la propriété légale de l'auteur. Ils ne doivent pas être diffusés, copiés ou utilisés à quelques fins que ce soit sans accord écrit préalable.
This document and any information or descriptive matter set out in it are confidential and copyright property and must not be disclosed, loaned copied or used for any purpose whatsoever without prior written permission

Emission / First Issue Indice actuel / Actual Index Index


Date d’émission / Issue date Etabli par / Compiled by Date de modification / Revision Date Etabli par / Compiled by Approuvé par / Released by

2014-10-30 G. DOUMMAR D. RODRIGUES


02

Potrebbero piacerti anche