Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
• Mindfulness-based interventions hold promise for improving outcomes for children and adolescents
• The number of mindfulness-based interventions being developed and evaluated is increasing rapidly
• There is a need for greater methodological rigor in studies evaluating mindfulness-based therapies
targeting children and adolescents
• Understanding the mechanisms of change is important in the future development of mindfulness-based
family interventions
• Models of mindful parenting have been proposed to guide both research and the clinical application of
mindfulness-based family interventions
Mindfulness has been described as a process of devel- ful awareness and an accepting attitude toward
oping a nonjudgmental accepting awareness of moment-to-moment experience is taught as a way of
moment-by-moment experience (Bishop et al., 2004; helping people tolerate psychological and physiological
Kabat-Zinn, 2005). This involves intentionally attend- distress. Insofar as mindfulness can also raise an
ing to oneÕs ongoing stream of sensations, thoughts, individualÕs awareness of positive experiences that
and emotions as they arise, without evaluating these otherwise may not be attended to, mindfulness training
phenomena as good or bad, true or false, healthy or sick has been used as a means of enhancing emotional well
(Baer, 2003). The practice of mindfulness is integral to being and life satisfaction (Harnett et al., 2010).
Eastern spiritual, philosophical traditions, most nota- The turn of the century has seen a growing interest in
bly Buddhism from which much of the understanding mindfulness as evidenced by a comprehensive search of
and practice of mindfulness within Western psycho- the research literature with the term ÔmindfulnessÕ. In
therapies has derived (Kang & Whittingham, 2010). 1990, a search of 30 databases across multiple disci-
When integrated into Western psychotherapies, mind- plines resulted in 27 hits, when all publication types
2012 The Authors. Child and Adolescent Mental Health 2012 Association for Child and Adolescent Mental Health.
Published by Blackwell Publishing, 9600 Garsington Road, Oxford OX4 2DQ, UK and 350 Main St, Malden, MA 02148, USA
196 Paul H. Harnett & S. Dawe Child Adolesc Ment Health 2012; 17(4): 195–208
(journal articles, book reviews, and dissertations) were conducted both in educational settings and with clinical
included. For the year 2010 the same search resulted in groups either in the home or in clinical settings. The
1060 hits. Of particular interest for the current article school-based studies tended to have a preventative fo-
was the increase in the number of peer-reviewed arti- cus and were generally delivered by teachers specifically
cles on mindfulness focusing on children, adolescents trained in mindfulness procedures. The interventions
or families. Seven were found in 1990 compared to 55 in evaluated in the school setting included programs for
2009 and 116 hits one year later (see Figure 1). With the children themselves and programs aimed at
this rapid escalation of interest in mindfulness, it is improving child outcomes by teaching mindfulness
timely to consider how the concept of mindfulness can skills to teachers, carers or parents (e.g., Coatsworth,
contribute to efforts to improve child and family func- Duncan, Greenberg, & Nix, 2010; Duncan, Coatsworth,
tioning. & Greenberg, 2009b). Two studies focused on reducing
In this article, we first provide a review of intervention psychological distress of the teachers rather than chil-
studies published since 2009. We then consider whe- dren (Franco, Manas, Cangas, Moreno, & Gallego, 2010;
ther the teaching of mindfulness skills has the potential Gold et al., 2010). A second group of studies used
to contribute to the treatment of child and family mindfulness-based strategies within clinical settings
functioning more broadly than has been attempted to where children and young people were referred with an
date. We do so by considering the potential role of existing psychological disorder or identified as high risk
mindfulness in the light of an integrated theoretical for a stress-related physical disorder. While we have
framework for working therapeutically with families. grouped the review into school-based and clinical set-
tings, many of the techniques used to improve child
Method outcomes were common to both types of studies.
2012 The Authors. Child and Adolescent Mental Health 2012 Association for Child and Adolescent Mental Health.
Table 1. Summary of mindfulness-based intervention studies in educational settings
Metz, 2009 a senior post-test of the Learning to students affect; feeling calm/relaxed/
high BREATHE based on MBSR (n = 17) emotional self-accepting; No change
school class regulation; in emotional regulation,
rumination; rumination or
somatization somatization.
Schonert-Reichl & 246 4th–7th grade 11.4 years Classroom Quasi-experimental 10 · 40–50 min weekly Wait list Self-report: > in self-reported
Lawlor, 2010 students control group pre sessions (7.5 hr) optimism; optimism
test post-test :mindfulness, self- school and and positive affect for all
regulation, goal setting, general students; no change in
learned optimism; self-concept; negative affect; > in
plus 3 · 3 min daily positive self-reported general
mindfulness practice and negative self concept for pre
affect. adolescents only. > in
teacher report: teacher report of
social and attention, emotional
emotional regulation, social and
competence emotional competence; <
in teacher report of
aggression and
oppositional behavior.
Mendelson 97 Fourth and 9–10 years School 2 group RCT pre 12 · 45 min sessions (9 hr) No treatment Self-report: Good retention and
et al., 2010 fifth grade test post-test of mindfulness and yoga involuntary acceptability of program
students responses to students and
to stress; teachers; < in rumination,
depression; intrusive thoughts and
peer and emotional arousal; no
school change in positive or
relationships; negative affect,
2012 The Authors. Child and Adolescent Mental Health 2012 Association for Child and Adolescent Mental Health.
affect depression,
or relationships with
peers and teachers;
trend toward
Mindfulness-based therapies for families
Table 1. Continued
Liehr & Diaz, 2010 18 Minority 9.5 years School 2 group RCT pre 10 · 15 min sessions daily Health Self-report: < in depression in
children test post-test for 2 weeks (2.5 hr) of education depression; intervention
attention to breath, anxiety group only; < in
mindful movement anxiety in
and generosity. both intervention and
Paul H. Harnett & S. Dawe
control group.
Semple et al., 2010 25 Children 9–13 School RCT 12 · 90 min weekly sessions Waitlist Attention; < in attention
struggling (18 hr) MBCT for children anxiety; problems; <
academically behavior in anxiety, but
no group
differences; < in
behavior
problems, but
no group
differences.
Gregoski et al., 2011 166 Afro-American 15 years School and 3 group RCT pre 12 · weekly (10 min Heath Physiological: BAM group showed
adolescents home test post-test weekdays, 20 mins education; ambulatory greatest improvement
at risk of weekends; life skills diastolic in systolic blood
cardio-vascular 14 hr total; BAM) training blood pressure; BAM group
disease taken from MBSR pressure; showed greater
overnight reduction in diastolic
sodium blood pressure and
excretion; heart rate compared to
self-report: LST; No change in
perceived perceived stress.
stress
Studies targeting parents, carers or teachers
Singh et al., 2010 3 African American Care-givers Home Multiple-baseline 7 session mindfulness None Number of non- Training carers in
caregivers own across participants training compliant mindfulness in group
children provided to carers responses home setting lead to
aged 9–16 to work made by < in non-compliant
with individuals in children responses in carers
their care own children.
Duncan et al., 5 Families of nine 11.5 years School Uncontrolled pilot 7 · 2-hr sessions None Parent report: Qualitative feedback
2009b children in study (14 hr; MSFP) qualitative showing usefulness
6th grade feedback and acceptability
of MSFP to parents.
2012 The Authors. Child and Adolescent Mental Health 2012 Association for Child and Adolescent Mental Health.
Child Adolesc Ment Health 2012; 17(4): 195–208
Table 1. Continued
report:
discipline
consistency
Gold et al., 2010 11 Qualified 20–50 years School Pre test post-test 8 · 2.5 hr weekly None Psychological < in depression, stress,
teachers sessions distress, but not anixety; > in
teaching (25 hr) of a mindfulness Ôaccept without
assistants mindfulness judgmentÕ
course taught by MBSR scale, but not other
teacher scales of the KIMS.
Franco et al., 68 Secondary school 24–58 years School Pre test post-test 10 · 1.5 hr sessions (15 hr) Listening Psychological < in psychological
2010 teachers of mindfulness program to relaxing distress distress
music
Jennings et al., 31 & 39 Teachers Mean age School Study 1: pre test Two day weekend Study 1: none Teacher Study 1 < in time
2011 - reported working in teachers post-test Study 2; workshop, Study 2: self-report: urgency; >
2 studies a high-poverty was 40 waitlist control phone coaching and waitlist well being; in mindfulness. No
urban setting (study 1); one day workshop - The depression; change
(study 1) and mean Cultivating Awareness time in wellbeing,
student teachers age of and Resilience in urgency; depression,
working in a student Education physical physical symptoms,
semi-rural/ teachers (CARE) professional symptoms; motivation
suburban was 21 development program motivation orientation
college (Study 2) orientation; or teacher efficacy.
town setting teacher Study 2 > in
(study 2) efficacy; motivation
mindfulness. orientation (support
Observations: student autonomy); >
classroom in teacher efficacy. No
climate difference in
2012 The Authors. Child and Adolescent Mental Health 2012 Association for Child and Adolescent Mental Health.
(study 2 only) wellbeing,
depression, physical
symptoms, mindfulness
or classroom climate.
Mindfulness-based therapies for families
MBSR, Mindfulness Based Stress Reduction; MBCT, Mindfulness Based Cognitive Therapy; BAM, Breathing Awareness Meditation; MSFP Mindfulness-Enhanced Strengthening
Families Program; KIMS, Kentucky Inventory of Mindfulness Skills. < indicates decrease in outcome; > indicates increase in outcome.
199
200 Paul H. Harnett & S. Dawe Child Adolesc Ment Health 2012; 17(4): 195–208
independent ratings raises concerns about the reliability tual disabilities. Records were kept of non-compliant
of these findings. Mendelson et al. (2010) employed a responses by the carersÕ own children. Results showed
mindfulness-based intervention to improve self-regula- that the mindfulness training they received in the work
tory capacities in fourth and fifth grade children from context transferred to the home context, demonstrated
disadvantaged backgrounds. The current intervention by a reduction in noncompliant responses by the carers
included yoga-based physical activity, breathing tech- children. A small pilot study involving five families
niques and guided mindfulness practice designed to reported by Duncan et al. (2009b) described a modifi-
help children manage arousal and stress levels. Ran- cation of the Strengthening Families Program (SFP), an
domization occurred at the school level with two schools evidence-based, universal, family focused intervention
receiving the intervention four days per week for designed to reduce risk factors and enhance protective
12 weeks while the other two schools served as wait list factors as a means of preventing adolescent substance
controls. The treatment was acceptable to both students use and problem behaviors. The modifications included
and teachers and some significant reductions were teaching the principles of mindfulness and specific
found in the subscales and total score on a measure of mindfulness practices such as mindful breathing.
involuntary response to stress. No effects were found on Results were limited to positive qualitative feedback.
negative or positive affect, depression or peer relation- However, in a larger scale study, Coatsworth et al.
ships, although a trend was noted for greater trust in (2010) found the addition of the mindfulness compo-
friends. nent in MSFP resulted in improvements on a newly
There has been one small randomized trial in which a developed measure of mindful parenting, while the
mindfulness-based intervention was compared to an youths reported their parents to be more consistent in
active intervention focusing on improving depression their use of discipline. Two studies targeting teachers
and anxiety (Liehr & Diaz, 2010). In this study involving found that a course in mindfulness lead to reduced
18 children, minority and disadvantaged children re- psychological distress for those who participated
cruited from a summer camp were randomly assigned (Franco et al., 2010; Gold et al., 2010). Jennings et al.
to either a mindfulness-based intervention or to heath (2011) found mixed support for the Cultivating Aware-
education. Children attended ten 15 min classes of ness and Resilience in Education (CARE) professional
mindful breathing and mindful movement over two development program designed to reduce teachersÕ
weeks. There was a significant reduction in depression distress and promote improvements in teachersÕ well
symptoms for those in the mindfulness group and a being, motivational orientation/efficacy, and mindful-
reduction in anxiety for both groups, in the immediate ness. A significant increase in mindfulness was found
post-treatment follow up. Using a waitlist control, in only one of the two studies reported. One study found
Semple et al. (2010) assessed the impact of a 12-week a decrease in teacherÕs sense of time urgency, sug-
group program based on mindfulness-based cognitive gesting that teachers experienced less stress associated
therapy in children who were struggling academically. with time demands after participating in the program.
The authors proposed that anxiety influences attention, The increase in mindfulness was found when CARE was
which in turn impacts academic performance. Signifi- offered to a group of experienced teachers working in an
cant improvements were found on measures of atten- urban district with high levels of poverty, a high pro-
tion compared to the wait list. There were reductions in portion of at-risk students and a context of limited
anxiety and behavior problems, although no group dif- institutional support. CARE was designed for teachers
ferences at posttest or follow-up. While the authorÕs working in the context of high emotional stress that can
suggestion that mindfulness served to enhance self- lead to emotional reactivity in the classroom. The pro-
management of attention and emotion regulation was gram did not appear to be relevant to a group of student
supported, whether this, in turn, influenced academic teachers and mentors working in a less stressful semi-
performance was not tested. One randomized study rural setting with few at risk students and effective
investigated the impact of mindful breathing meditation institutional support.
on 166 Afro-American adolescents at risk of cardio- On balance there is reasonable cause for optimism
vascular disease (Gregoski, Barnes, Tingen, Harshfield, when considering whether to include mindfulness-
& Treiber, 2011). Three-month interventions were of- based approaches within an existing school curriculum
fered in two high schools during regular health educa- and targeting both students and teachers. Positive
tion classes. The interventions were delivered by mood does appear to be increased while more tradi-
teachers who were each randomly assigned to deliver tional measures of mood symptoms in particular
one of the interventions. The teachers were provided depression, show reductions. What is clearly needed,
with training in an intervention and treatment fidelity however, is a clearer understanding of what treatment
measures assessed adherence to treatment. Breathing should consist of and the dose of treatment that is
awareness meditation produced greater reductions in necessary to effect change given the considerable vari-
systolic blood pressure compared to Life Skills Training ability noted across the studies reviewed above. Vari-
(LST) or the usual Health Education program. Partici- ability in outcome measures and methodological
pants taught breathing meditation also showed greater limitations of studies, which are discussed in more
reductions for 24 hr diastolic blood pressure and heart detail below, limit conclusions that can be drawn.
rate compared to LST.
Six studies reported interventions that targeted the Mindfulness-based interventions delivered in
parents, carers or teachers of children. Singh et al. clinical settings
(2010) investigated the transfer of mindfulness skills Single case studies have been conducted by Singh and
following mindfulness training of carers in a group colleagues using meditation-based strategies to reduce
home for individuals with severe physical and intellec- aggressive behavior in young people with autism or
2012 The Authors. Child and Adolescent Mental Health 2012 Association for Child and Adolescent Mental Health.
doi:10.1111/j.1475-3588.2011.00643.x Mindfulness-based therapies for families 201
Asperger syndrome (Singh, Lancioni, Manikam, et al. and torture. Treatment was delivered by local therapists
2011; Singh, Lancioni, Singh, et al. 2011). In these trained in the two models. Treatment duration was of
studies mothers, after being trained in a meditative equal length (six 60–90 min sessions over two weeks).
procedure, taught their children to redirect attention Follow up occurred 4–5 weeks and again 6 months later
from an aggression-triggering event to a neutral body by interviewers blind to the treatment condition. While
part – the soles of their feet. In both studies parents and there were no differences between the two treatments,
siblings reported a decrease in the frequency of the reductions in post-traumatic symptoms were
aggressive incidents suggesting that the adolescents striking, with recovery rates of 81% for the narrative
with developmental disorders can learn, and effectively exposure group and 71% for the meditation relaxation
use, a mindfulness-based procedure to self-manage group post-treatment. The improvements were main-
their physical aggression. tained at 6 months. Oord, Bögels, and Peijnenburg
Several studies reported on the effectiveness of (2011) reported on a randomized controlled trial with a
mindfulness-based treatments incorporated into either short (8 weeks) follow-up period. The study evaluated
an existing treatment process or delivered as a stand- an 8-week mindfulness course for children displaying
alone treatment in clinical populations. Britton et al. symptoms of ADHD that included a parallel course for
(2010) conducted a prospective uncontrolled clinical parents. Statistically significant changes between pre-
trial of 55 adolescents who had been recent inpatients and post-intervention included a decrease in both child
receiving substance abuse treatment. Six 90 min group and parent ADHD symptoms and an increase in
sessions based on MBSR aimed to improve sleep with parental mindfulness as measured by the Mindfulness
the rationale that poor sleep contributes to mood Attention and Awareness Scale. No changes were
problems, which in turn may increase the risk of observed in parenting stress or parenting style. At fol-
relapse to substance use. Outcomes were emotional low-up, the reduced levels of ADHD symptoms
distress, relapse and substance use measured across remained for both children and parents. A reduction
60 weeks. Completion (defined as attendance at 4 of 6 was found in over-reactive parenting and parental
sessions) was poor (42%) and substance use increased stress between the pre-intervention and follow-up
across the group. There were, however, significant assessment. However, mindfulness scores did not vary
improvements on measures of emotional distress with a between pre-intervention and follow-up.
trend favoring those who were classified as completers Our own work in this area has involved the evalua-
and a reduction in daytime sleepiness for those who tion of an intensive home visiting program focusing on
completed the program. A study of youth who were multiproblem families characterized by emotional dys-
either HIV infected or Ôat riskÕ who were attending a regulation, maternal psychopathology, and substance
pediatric primary care clinic investigated the impact of abuse. The program, Parents Under Pressure (PuP), is
an MBSR program on health-related quality of life and based on the premise that sensitive and responsive
psychological distress. Youth self-reports found a sta- parenting requires emotional regulation skills that are
tistically significant decrease in hostility and general generally dysfunctional in parents with a history of
and emotional discomfort. However, significant trauma or psychopathology, including substance mis-
improvement was found on only three of 18-subscales. use and mood disorders. Thus the program draws from
A small-scale uncontrolled trail of a mindfulness-based the recent literature on emotional regulation with an
program for adolescents diagnosed with ADHD found explicit adaption of mindfulness strategies integrated
little change on a variety of measures (van de Weijer- with parenting skills. The PuP program has been eval-
Bergsma, Formsma, Bruin, & Bögels, 2011). While uated in three separate case studys (Dawe, Harnett,
there was some improvement in the adolescentsÕ Rendalls, & Staiger, 2003; Frye & Dawe, 2008; Harnett
behavior and attention, and some reduction of parent- & Dawe, 2008) and one randomized controlled trial
ing stress in fathers and overreactivity in mothers, (Dawe & Harnett, 2007). These studies found a reduc-
these changes were not reported by all informants and tion in child abuse potential as well as reductions in
were generally not sustained at follow-up. However, the maternal mood difficulties and parenting stress. Nota-
study was very small, with data from only eight partic- bly, the studies did not directly measure mindful par-
ipants available for analysis. Thus, the statistical power enting or parental emotional regulation capacity. As in
to detect change was very low. other studies, measures of mood were used as proxy
Two randomized controlled trials compared mind- measures of this.
fulness-based treatment with an active alternative Overall, the studies carried out in clinical settings,
treatment. In a small study of depressed adolescents, like those in educational settings, justify optimism for
Hayes, Boyd, and Sewell (2011) found that an adapta- the potential of mindfulness based therapies to improve
tion of Acceptance and Commitment Therapy for ado- child, adolescent and family functioning. In addition to
lescents produced greater decreases in a measure of the efficacy of programs that deliver interventions
depression compared to treatment as usual (cognitive directly to children and adolescents, programs that
behavioral therapy). There were also decreases in target parents and carers appear to be effective in
behavior problems, although this difference was not improving parental functioning, and in turn, promote
significantly greater for the ACT condition. Finally, positive child outcomes.
Catani and colleagues investigated the effectiveness of
meditation-relaxation compared to narrative exposure Methodological limitations
therapy in traumatized children living in refugee camps While the majority of the studies reviewed were pilot
in Sri Lanka (Catani et al., 2009). The latter treatment studies that had a range of methodological problems, a
protocol was designed specifically for people who have small number of studies have been randomized control
been exposed to enduring trauma associated with war trials. Thus, some caution needs to be exercised when
2012 The Authors. Child and Adolescent Mental Health 2012 Association for Child and Adolescent Mental Health.
202
Table 2. Summary of mindfulness-based intervention studies in clinical settings
Singh, Lancioni, 3 Adolescents 13–18 Home Multiple-baseline 17–24 weeks of None Number of aggressive < in aggressive incidents
Singh et al., with across ÔMeditation on incidents maintained over 4 years.
2011a Asperger participants the Soles of the FeetÕ
Syndrome
Lancioni, 3 Adolescents 14–17 Home Multiple-baseline 5 days of training in None Number of aggressive < in aggressive incidents
Manikam, with Autism across Meditation on incidents maintained over 3 years.
Singh et al., participants the Soles of the Feet
2011a
Paul H. Harnett & S. Dawe
Britton et al., 55 Adolescents 16.4 Outpatient Pre-post 6 · 90 min weekly None Self-report: emotional > in substance use; < in
2010 with sleep (SD = 1.2) group sessions (9 hr) distress; relapse emotional distress;< in
problems modified (MBSR) resistance; substance use daytime sleepiness for
following and CBT completers only.
substance
abuse
treatment
Sibinga et al., 33 HIV-infected 13–21 Pediatric Pre-post 8 · ? weekly sessions None Self-report: health related < in one of nine domains
2011 and at-risk primary based on MBRS. quality of life; of psychological distress
youth care hospital psychological distress (hostility); > in two of
clinic nine domains of quality
of life (general and
emotional discomfort).
van de Weijer- 10 Adolescents 11–15 Academic Pre-post with 8 · 90 min weekly group None Adolescent report: behavior; < in externalizing
Bergsma et al., with ADHD treatment 8 week mindfulness sessions for executive functioning; behavior problems
2011 center followup adolescents. Eight mindfulness; fatigue; reported by fathers
parallel sessions with happiness; attention. only; < in executive
parents. Mother and father report: functioning problems
behavior; mindfulness; reported by fathers
parenting style; parenting only; > in some
Stress. Teacher report: behavior aspects of attention,
but overall no change;
no change in
adolescent internalizing,
attention problems.
fatigue or happiness;
no change in
adolescent or parent
mindfulness; < in
parenting stress for
fathers but not
mothers at post but
nor follow-up; < in
mothers overreactivity
at post but not follow-up
2012 The Authors. Child and Adolescent Mental Health 2012 Association for Child and Adolescent Mental Health.
Child Adolesc Ment Health 2012; 17(4): 195–208
Table 2. Continued
Hayes et al., 38 Adolescents 12–18 Outpatient RCT ACT -individual sessions TAU-manualized Depression, Emotional and < in depression greater
2011 experiencing psychiatric using published CBT provided by behavioral functioning for ACT than TAU;
moderate clinic treatment manuals the psychiatric greater proportion of
to severe service ACT condition showed
depressive clinically significant
symptoms change in depression;
no change in behavioral
problems.
Catani et al., 31 Children 8–14 Community - RCT 6 sessions Meditation- 6 sessions PTSD symptoms < PTSD symptoms at
doi:10.1111/j.1475-3588.2011.00643.x
2012 The Authors. Child and Adolescent Mental Health 2012 Association for Child and Adolescent Mental Health.
Dawe, 2008 referred by pre post- sessions 11.5 mood, child abuse potential, followed up. Significant
child protection measures (range 9–13) child behavior problems, social < on all measures
services support pre-post, 2 of 10 families
showed no change on
Mindfulness-based therapies for families
any domain.
203
204 Paul H. Harnett & S. Dawe Child Adolesc Ment Health 2012; 17(4): 195–208
8 remained in treatment,
considering the balance of evidence for including
mindfulness into interventions for children and fami-
measures at 3 month
intervention, > on
potential for brief
Significant < on all
measures for PuP
studies have been conducted makes it difficult to build
Results
on child abuse
in TAU group
a consistent picture of efficacy, although arguably does
follow up speak to the issue of generalizability. Related to
the issue of diversity in populations studies is the
range of outcome measures adopted, again leading to
little consistency to allow for a more measured apprai-
sal of the benefits of mindfulness. The dimensions
Parent report: parenting stress,
information
clinic based
Mean number of
Randomized
design
follow up
measures
methadone
12 Women offenders 5.6 years In home or
parents
prison
clinic
maintenance
methadone
security or
Type
64 Families on
2012 The Authors. Child and Adolescent Mental Health 2012 Association for Child and Adolescent Mental Health.
doi:10.1111/j.1475-3588.2011.00643.x Mindfulness-based therapies for families 205
active ingredients of programs if any are to be optimally authors speculated that other variables not measured
effective (Kazdin, 2007; Kazdin & Nock, 2003). While in their study, possibly parental emotion regulation or
ÔmindfulnessÕ as a psychological construct is assumed adaptive coping skills, might be candidates to explain
to be responsible for improved outcomes, this was not the relationship. This conclusion is consistent with the
systematically investigated in any of the studies above. model of mindful parenting put forward by Duncan
One obstacle for research on mechanisms of change is et al.Õs (2009a) and the mechanisms proposed by Bö-
the lack of psychometrically sound measures of the gels et al. (2010); specifically that heightened parental
construct of ÔmindfulnessÕ as it relates to parents and awareness of their own and their childÕs emotional
children. We note that two measures are in develop- states and enhanced parental emotional regulation
ment that will help to facilitate such research in the skills allow the parent to respond more flexibly to the
future (Coatsworth, Duncan, Greenberg, & Nix, 2009; child, as opposed to responding with a ÔmindlessÕ
Greco et al., 2011). However, another obstacle has been automated negative reactivity.
the lack of an agreed model of mindful parenting to
guide research on mechanisms of change. An important Placing mindfulness within a broader context
development, then, are recent attempts to identify the
mechanisms that change as a consequence of improved While the ÔmindfulnessÕ of children and parents is a
parental mindfulness. Duncan, Coatsworth, and variable that may prove to be a key factor in adaptive
Greenberg (2009a) describe a model of mindful functioning, there is a danger that a focus on mindful-
parenting that focuses on the benefits of mindfulness- ness in isolation from other variables influencing the
based interventions to enhance the parent-child rela- development of children and functioning of families
tionship. Specifically, the authors suggest that parents could limit consideration of the full range of variables
who acquire mindfulness skills will have an enhanced that potentially mediate outcomes in treatment. We
capacity to listen with full attention (increased sensi- suggest the benefits of mindfulness-based interventions
tivity to the childÕs cues); will adopt a more nonjudg- targeting families would be better considered within the
mental acceptance of self and child (a balance between context of an integrated framework of family function-
parent-orientated, child-orientated, and relationship ing, one that is itself informed by existing models of
orientating goals); have greater emotional awareness of child development and family functioning (Cicchetti &
self and child (acknowledgment of the childÕs emotional Cohen, 2006; Sameroff, 2010). That is, we suggest that
state and responding to the childÕs needs with less mindfulness-based interventions may be better con-
negative emotions); be better able to self-regulate in the sidered as one strategy for obtaining positive outcomes
parenting relationship (maintaining a focus on long when working with children and their families rather
term parental goals and values and avoidance of short- than an endeavor in its own right. We present here an
term automated reactive responses); and display more integrated framework (Figure 2) for working with fami-
compassion for self and child (the expression of more lies and consider below how mindfulness-based inter-
positive affect toward the child and avoidance of ventions can sit within and complement other
self-blame in the parenting role). More recently Bögels, intervention strategies. Indeed an important implica-
Lehtonen, and Restifo (2010) have argued that mind- tion of the integrated framework is that changes in
fulness-based interventions improve aspects of atten- mindfulness can be tested as mediators and modera-
tion, in particular the ability to disengage from tors of change across multiple domains of functioning.
unexpected and emotionally charged stimuli. Integrat- The integrated framework we propose takes, as its
ing findings from the experimental literature on mind- starting point, the aim of promoting positive child
fulness, the authors suggest mindfulness-based developmental outcomes across multiple domains of a
parenting interventions may exert their effects by: (a) childÕs functioning and across time. This is achieved by
reducing parental stress; (b) reducing parental preoc- targeting both proximal and more distal domains of
cupation resulting from parental and/or child psycho- family functioning. Those influences most proximal to
pathology; (c) improving parental executive functioning a child are (a) the quality of the parent child relation-
(in particular reduced impulsivity); (d) reducing the ship and (b) how the parent behaves in their parenting
impact of dysfunctional upbringing schemas and hab- role. In regards to the quality of the parent child rela-
its; (e) increasing self-nourishing attention; and (f) tionship, the framework draws on BiringenÕs work on
improving marital functioning and co-parenting. In a emotional availability (Biringen, 2000, 2004). This
recent cross-sectional study of Duncan et al.Õs (2009a) model delineates the dimensions of the parent-child
model, Parent et al. (2011) investigated the relationship relationship that predict the quality of parent-child
between parental mindfulness, parental depression, attachment and other child developmental outcomes.
positive and negative parenting practices (based on Four dimensions describe the behavior of the parents –
observations of parent-child interactions) and child the ability to respond sensitively to the child (sensi-
outcomes (internalizing and externalizing problems). tivity), provide structure to help the child manage their
Correlational analyses carried out on the results of 180 emotions and behaviors (structuring), promote auton-
families involving 242 children aged 9–15 showed that omy (non-intrusiveness); and minimize angry and
parental mindfulness was associated with both inter- hostile interactions (non-hostility). In addition to being
nalizing and externalizing problems of the children. emotionally available, the integrated framework high-
Regression analyses failed to find that parental lights the importance of parental values and expecta-
depressive symptoms or positive or negative parenting tions of the child as major influences on the choices a
behaviors acted as intervening variables to explain parent make about issues such as their style of disci-
the significant association. While this might suggest pline, level of child monitoring and importance of
mindfulness has a direct effect on child outcomes, the family routines.
2012 The Authors. Child and Adolescent Mental Health 2012 Association for Child and Adolescent Mental Health.
206 Paul H. Harnett & S. Dawe Child Adolesc Ment Health 2012; 17(4): 195–208
Critically, however, and an area that typically nonjudgmental acceptance of problem behavior that is
receives less focus in many traditional family focused responded to more favorably by the children in their
interventions, the integrated framework suggests that care, improving the quality of the carer–child interac-
the extent to which the parentsÕ capacity to be emo- tions. This was echoed by Coatsworth et al. (2010) who
tionally available and ability to consistently implement found changes in parental discipline and monitoring by
parenting practices based on fair and reasonable values mothers in the standard Strengthening Families Pro-
and expectations is directly influenced by the parentÕs gram was not received well by the youth in their study.
emotion regulatory capacities. Parents create a social Children whose mothers received mindfulness training
and emotional climate to which children must learn to in addition to SFP reported their mothers to be more
self-regulate, as well as provide the safety net when self- consistent in their use of discipline and more likely to
regulation fails (Sameroff, 2010). High levels of parental monitor where they were and who they were with.
emotional dysregulation results in a high stress envi- Children from the SFP group reported slight increases
ronment and impairs the parentÕs capacity to be emo- in motherÕs negative affect directed toward them, while
tionally available. Thus a significant contribution that MSFP children reported a decrease in negative affect
mindfulness can make is to provide a therapeutic (despite positive affect remaining high throughout).
approach that may directly enhance this self-regulatory Mothers in the MSFP condition perceived their children
capacity. However, the integrated framework acknowl- to display more positive and less negative affect,
edges parental functioning and a childÕs development whereas mothers in the SFP condition perceived less
are affected by multiple influences, including the positive affect and more negative affect from their chil-
resources (or lack of) available to the family, schools, dren. The authors suggested that when disciplinary
neighborhoods, culture and economic and political strategies are taught in conjunction with mindful par-
climate (e.g., Bronfenbrenner, 1986; Sameroff, 2010). enting, parents are able to modulate their emotional
Thus, the ecological context in which the family is reactivity to their childrenÕs behavior and this may have
embedded is an important target for therapy – by contributed to building a closer and more loving rela-
helping parents manage those aspects of the social tionship between parent and children (Coatsworth
ecology that are amenable to change, such as managing et al., 2010). Within the school environment Gold et al.
life stressors and engaging support. (2010) noted that teachers described the intervention to
be helpful in controlling their stress because they
became more accepting and nonjudging. The authors
Mindfulness and the integrated framework
report that ÔResponding, not reacting, teaches us to take
A common theme of the articles reviewed was that controlÕ (p. 188). There is some empirical support for
mindfulness leads to greater acceptance of problem this suggestion. Two studies by Bluth and Wahler
child behavior by parents, carers and teachers that (2011a,b) tested the hypotheses that mothersÕ everyday
leads to an increase in the quality of the relationship mindfulness would covary inversely with the effort they
with the children in their care. For example, Singh et al. put into parenting, that mothersÕ mindfulness will co-
(2010) speculated that mindfulness training might vary inversely with their reports of their childrenÕs
produce a transformational change in carers that does problem behavior, and that mindfulness would mediate
not occur following training in contingency manage- or moderate the correlation between their effort and
ment and specific methods of behavior management. their reports of their childrenÕs problem behavior. Par-
On the contrary, mindfulness training leads to enting effort was described as emotionally taxing
2012 The Authors. Child and Adolescent Mental Health 2012 Association for Child and Adolescent Mental Health.
doi:10.1111/j.1475-3588.2011.00643.x Mindfulness-based therapies for families 207
struggles parents have when trying to handle chal- ingredient of interventions, but is unlikely to be the sole
lenging situations with their children, such as reacting variable responsible for the changes in outcome.
emotionally in the moment rather than disciplining in a
manner more in line with their values. Bluth and
Wahler found that mothers reporting high mindfulness Acknowledgement
were less intrusive and more able to avoid the escala- This review article was commissioned by the Editors of the
tion of conflicts with their adolescents (Bluth & Wahler, journal, for which the first author received a small honor-
2011a) and pre-schoolers (Bluth & Wahler, 2011b) arium towards expenses. The authors have both declared
compared to mothers who were classified as low mind- that they have no competing or potential conflicts of in-
fulness. The authors argued that parental mindfulness terest arising from the publication of this article.
has the potential to interrupt or de-escalate a chaotic or
emotionally charged situation. Mindful parents can be
more aware of their habitual patterns of parent-child References
interaction, leading to a less reactive and more nuanced Baer, R.A. (2003). Mindfulness training as a clinical interven-
responses, that requires less effort. tion: A conceptual and empirical review. Clinical Psychology:
Our integrated framework acknowledges the impor- Science & Practice, 10, 125–143.
tant influence of the social ecology within which the Biringen, Z. (2000). Emotional availability: Conceptualization
family is embedded. At this level mindfulness-based and research findings. American Journal of Orthopsychiatry,
therapeutic techniques have a potentially important 70, 104–114.
Biringen, Z. (2004). Raising a secure child: Creating emotional
role to play. Duncan and Bardacke (2010) in a study of
availability between parents and your children. New York:
pregnant women reported that mindfulness training The Berkley Publishing Group.
helped the women cope with stressful aspects of preg- Bishop, S.R., Lau, M., Shapiro, S., Carlson, L., Anderson, N.D.,
nancy and family life post-intervention, expanding their Carmody, J., et al. (2004). Mindfulness: A proposed opera-
repertoire of skills to cope with contextual demands tional definition. Clinical Psychology: Science Practice, 11,
such as poverty, major life events, work related stress 230–241.
Bluth, K., & Wahler, R.G. (2011a). Does effort matter in
and interpersonal tensions (Duncan & Bardacke,
mindful parenting? Mindfulness, 2, 175–178.
2010). The ability to employ mindfulness skills to pro- Bluth, K., & Wahler, R.G. (2011b). Parenting preschoolers: Can
tect against such adversity is worthy of increased mindfulness help? Mindfulness, 2, 282–285.
attention given the negative impact of stressors asso- Bögels, S.M., Lehtonen, A., & Restifo, K. (2010). Mindful
ciated with low SES on individual and family func- parenting in mental health care. Mindfulness, 1, 107–120.
tioning (McEwen & Gianaros, 2010). In a recent study Britton, W.B., Bootzin, R.R., Cousins, J.C., Hasler, B.P., Peck,
Sturge-Apple, Skibo, Rogosch, Ignjatovic, and Heinzel- T., & Shapiro, S.L. (2010). The contribution of mindfulness
practice to a multicomponent behavioral sleep intervention
man (2011) found that mothers facing the stress of following substance abuse treatment in adolescents: A
extremely low social economic status displayed abnor- treatment-development study. Substance Abuse, 31, 86–97.
mal sympathovagal activity (hyporarousal). This phys- Broderick, P.C., & Metz, S. (2009). Learning to breathe: A pilot
iological reaction, the result of the need to adjust to trial of a mindfulness curriculum for adolescents. Advances
chronic stress, was associated with disengaged and in School Mental Health Promotion, 2, 35–46.
insensitive interactions with their children during Bronfenbrenner, U. (1986). Ecology of the family as a context
for human development: Research perspectives. Develop-
observations of free play. Importantly, Ganzel, Morris,
mental Psychology, 22, 723–742.
and Wethington (2010) have presented evidence point- Burke, C.A. (2009). Mindfulness-based approaches with chil-
ing to the potential of mindfulness-based therapies to dren and adolescents: A preliminary review of current
significantly influence the physiological processes research in an emergent field. Journal of Child and Family
associated with individuals physiological adjustment to Studies, 19, 133–144.
ongoing stress – raising the hope that mindfulness- Catani, C., Kohiladevy, M., Ruf, M., Schauer, E., Elbert, T., &
Neuner, F. (2009). Treating children traumatized by war and
based therapies can potentially promote improved
tsunami: A comparison between exposure therapy and
family functioning and child outcomes in socially and meditation-relaxation in North-East Sri Lanka. BMC Psychi-
economically disadvantaged families (see Repetti, atry, 9, 22.
Robles, & Reynolds, 2011). Cicchetti, D., & Cohen, D.J. (2006). Developmental psychopa-
thology: Theory and method (2nd edn). New York: John Wiley
and Sons.
Conclusion Coatsworth, J.D., Duncan, L.G., Greenberg, M.T., & Nix, R.L.
(2009). changing parentÕs mindfulness, child management
The results of the research conducted thus far suggest skills and relationship quality with their youth: results from
that mindfulness-based techniques have the potential a randomized pilot intervention trial. Journal of Child and
to improve aspects of individual and family functioning Family Studies, 19, 203–217.
Coatsworth, J.D., Duncan, L., Greenberg, M., & Nix, R. (2010).
that are associated with better developmental outcomes
Changing parentÕs mindfulness, child management skills
for children and families. However, we argue that the and relationship quality with their youth: Results from a
outcomes of interventions targeting children, adoles- randomized pilot intervention trial. Journal of Child and
cents, and families will be most informative if the Family Studies, 19, 203–217.
mindfulness-based therapeutic techniques are inte- Dawe, S., & Harnett, P.H. (2007). Reducing potential for child
grated into existing programs that address multiple abuse among methadone-maintained parents: Results from
domains of family functioning rather than pursued as a randomized controlled trial. Journal of Substance Abuse
Treatment, 32, 381–390.
an independent endeavor. It is important that the field Dawe, S., Harnett, P.H., Rendalls, V., & Staiger, P. (2003).
avoids continued proliferation of programs and focuses Improving family functioning and child outcome in metha-
more on understanding the mechanisms responsible done maintained families: The parents under pressure
for change. ÔMindfulnessÕ is emerging as an active program. Drug and Alcohol Review, 22, 299–307.
2012 The Authors. Child and Adolescent Mental Health 2012 Association for Child and Adolescent Mental Health.
208 Paul H. Harnett & S. Dawe Child Adolesc Ment Health 2012; 17(4): 195–208
Duncan, L.G., & Bardacke, N. (2010). Mindfulness-based Liehr, P., & Diaz, N. (2010). A pilot study examining the effect
childbirth and parenting education: promoting family mind- of mindfulness on depression and anxiety for minority
fulness during the perinatal period. Journal of Child and children. Archives of Psychiatric Nursing, 24, 69–71.
Family Studies, 19, 190–202. McEwen, B.S., & Gianaros, P.J. (2010). Central role of the
Duncan, L.G., Coatsworth, J.D., & Greenberg, M.T. (2009a). A brain in stress and adaptation: Links to socioeconomic
model of mindful parenting: Implications for parent-child status, health, and disease. Annals of the New York Acad-
relationships and prevention research. Clinical Child and emy of Sciences, 1186, 190–222.
Family Psychology Review, 12, 255–270. Mendelson, T., Greenberg, M.T., Dariotis, J.K., Gould, L.F.,
Duncan, L.G., Coatsworth, J.D., & Greenberg, M.T. (2009b). Rhoades, B.L., & Leaf, P.J. (2010). Feasibility and prelimin-
Pilot study to gauge acceptability of a mindfulness-based, ary outcomes of a school-based mindfulness intervention for
family-focused preventive intervention. Journal of Primary urban youth. Journal of Abnormal Child Psychology: An
Prevention, 30, 605–618. official publication of the International Society for Research in
Franco, C., Manas, I., Cangas, A.J., Moreno, E., & Gallego, J. Child and Adolescent Psychopathology, 38, 985–994.
(2010). Reducing teachersÕ psychological distress through a Mercer, J., & Pignotti, M. (2007). Shortcuts cause errors in
mindfulness training program. Spanish Journal of Psychol- systematic research syntheses: Rethinking evaluation of
ogy, 13, 655–666. mental health interventions. The Scientific Review Of Mental
Frye, S., & Dawe, S. (2008). Interventions for women prisoners Health Practice, 5, 59–77.
and their children in the post-release period. Clinical Oord, S., Bögels, S.M., & Peijnenburg, D. (2011). The effec-
Psychologist, 12, 99–108. tiveness of mindfulness training for children with ADHD and
Ganzel, B.L., Morris, P.A., & Wethington, E. (2010). Allostasis mindful parenting for their parents. Journal of Child and
and the human brain: Integrating models of stress from the Family Studies, doi:10.1007/s10826-011-9457-0
social and life sciences. [Research Support, N.I.H., Extra- Parent, J., Garai, E., Forehand, R., Roland, E., Potts, J.,
mural Review]. Psychological Review, 117, 134–174. Haker, K., et al. (2011). Parent mindfulness and child
Gold, E., Smith, A., Hopper, I., Herne, D., Tansey, G., & outcome: The roles of parent depressive symptoms and
Hulland, C. (2010). Mindfulness-based stress reduction parenting. Mindfulness, 1, 254–264.
(MBSR) for primary school teachers. Journal of Child and Repetti, R.L., Robles, T.F., & Reynolds, B. (2011). Allostatic
Family Studies, 19, 184–189. processes in the family. Development and Psychopathology,
Greco, L.A., Baer, R.A., & Smith, G.T. (2011). Assessing 23, 921–938.
mindfulness in children and adolescents: Development and Sameroff, A. (2010). A unified theory of development: A
validation of the child and adolescent mindfulness measure dialectic integration of nature and nurture. Child Develop-
(CAMM). Psychological Assessment, 23, 606–614. ment, 81, 6–22.
Gregoski, M.J., Barnes, V.A., Tingen, M.S., Harshfield, G.A., & Schonert-Reichl, K.A., & Lawlor, M.S. (2010). The effects of a
Treiber, F.A. (2011). Breathing awareness meditation and mindfulness-based education program on pre- and early
LifeSkills Training programs influence upon ambulatory adolescentsÕ well-being and social and emotional compe-
blood pressure and sodium excretion among African Amer- tence. Mindfulness, 1, 137–151.
ican adolescents. Journal of Adolescent Health, 48, 59–59. Semple, R.J., Lee, J., Rosa, D., & Miller, L.F. (2010). A
Harnett, P.H., & Dawe, S. (2008). Reducing Child abuse randomized trial of mindfulness-based cognitive therapy
potential in families identified by social services: Implica- for children: Promoting mindful attention to enhance social-
tions for assessment and treatment. Brief Treatment and emotional resiliency in children. Journal of Child and Family
Crisis Intervention, 8, 226–235. Studies, 19, 218–218.
Harnett, P.H., Whittingham, K., Puhakka, E., Hodges, J., Spry, Sibinga, E.M., Kerrigan, D., Stewart, M., Johnson, K., Magyari,
C., & Dob, R. (2010). The short-term impact of a brief group- T., & Ellen, J.M. (2011). Mindfulness-based stress reduction
based mindfulness therapy program on depression and life for urban youth. Journal of Alternative and Complementary
satisfaction. Mindfulness, 1, 183–188. Medicine, 17, 213–218.
Hayes, L., Boyd, C.P., & Sewell, J. (2011). Acceptance and Singh, N.N., Lancioni, G.E., Manikam, R., Winton, A.S.W.,
commitment therapy for the treatment of adolescent depres- Singh, A.N.A., Singh, J., & Singh, A.D.A. (2011a). A mind-
sion: A pilot study in a psychiatric outpatient setting. fulness-based strategy for self-management of aggressive
Mindfulness, 2, 86–86. behavior in adolescents with autism. Research in Autism
Jennings, P.A., Snowberg, K.E., Coccia, M.A., & Greenberg, Spectrum Disorders, 5, 1153–1158.
M.T. (2011). Improving classroom learning environments by Singh, N.N., Lancioni, G.E., Singh, A.D.A., Winton, A.S.W.,
cultivating awareness and resilience in education (CARE): Singh, A.N.A., & Singh, J. (2011b). Adolescents with Asper-
Results of two pilot studies. Journal of Classroom Interac- ger syndrome can use a mindfulness-based strategy to
tion, 46, 37–48. control their aggressive behavior. Research in Autism Spec-
Joyce, A., Etty-Leal, J., Zazryn, T., Hamilton, A., & Hassed, C. trum Disorders, 5, 1103–1109.
(2010). Exploring a mindfulness meditation program on the Singh, N.N., Lancioni, G.E., Winton, A.S.W., Singh, J., Singh,
mental health of upper primary children: A pilot study. A.N., Adkins, A.D., & Wahler, R.G. (2010). Training in
Advances in School Mental Health Promotion, 3, 17–17. mindful caregiving transfers to parent–child interactions.
Kabat-Zinn, J. (2003). Mindfulness-based stress reduction Journal of Child and Family Studies, 19, 167–174.
(MBSR). Constructivism in the Human Sciences, 8, 73–107. Sturge-Apple, M.L., Skibo, M.A., Rogosch, F.A., Ignjatovic, Z.,
Kabat-Zinn, J. (2005). Full catastrophe living: Using the & Heinzelman, W. (2011). The impact of allostatic load on
wisdom of your body and mind to face stress, pain, and maternal sympathovagal functioning in stressful child con-
illness: Fifteenth anniversary edition. New York: Delta Trade texts: Implications for problematic parenting. Development
Paperback/Bantam Dell. and Psychopathology, 23, 831–844.
Kang, C., & Whittingham, K. (2010). Mindfulness: A dialogue van de Weijer-Bergsma, E., Formsma, A.R., Bruin, E.I., &
between Buddhism and clinical psychology. Mindfulness, 1, Bögels, S.M. (2011). The effectiveness of mindfulness train-
161–173. ing on behavioral problems and attentional functioning in
Kazdin, A.E. (2007). Mediators and mechanisms of change in adolescents with ADHD. Journal of Child and Family Stud-
psychotherapy research. Annual Review of Clinical Psychol- ies, published online 22 September 2011, doi:10.1007/
ogy, 3, 1–27. s10826-011-9531-7
Kazdin, A.E., & Nock, M.K. (2003). Delineating mechanisms of
change in child and adolescent therapy: methodological
issues and research recommendations. Journal of Child Accepted for publication: 9 November 2011
Psychology & Psychiatry & Allied Disciplines, 44, 1116–1129. Published online: 17 January 2012
2012 The Authors. Child and Adolescent Mental Health 2012 Association for Child and Adolescent Mental Health.
Copyright of Child & Adolescent Mental Health is the property of Wiley-Blackwell and its content may not be
copied or emailed to multiple sites or posted to a listserv without the copyright holder's express written
permission. However, users may print, download, or email articles for individual use.