Sei sulla pagina 1di 4

COMPARISON - PERKINS ADVANTAGES OVER CUMMINS - 1010 KVA.

FEATURES CUMMINS CATERPILLER MISTUBISHI MTU

GENERAL/PERFORMANCE

MODEL KTA 38 G5 3508B MGS1000B mtu 16v 2000


V8 V 12 16v
No. OF CYL./DISPLACEMENT VEE 12 CYLINDERS
14:01 16:01
COMPRESSION RATIO 13.9:1 14
1010 1010 1010
KVA 1010
8000 8300 7500
WET WT. (ENG + RAD) 6000 KG

BLOCK LOAD ACCEPTANCE 40% 60% 50% 40%

SERVICE PERIOD 250 HOURS ONLY 300 250 250


12 TIMES OIL AND FILTER
NO OF CHANGES IN 3000 HOURS CHANGE 12 12 12

FUEL SYSTEM

FUEL CONSUMPTION

AT 100 % LOAD 204 LIT/HR 202.12 216 204.91

AT 75 % LOAD 153.5 153.34 164 153

GOVERNOR ELECTRONIC with PT pump Caterpillar ADEM II ELECTRONIC TYPE ELECTRONIC TYPE

INJECTION PUMP TYPE PT (Common rail)

LUBRICATION SYSTEM

L.O. SYSTEM CAPACITY 145 LIT 227 200 160

COOLING SYSTEM

COOLANT CAPACITY 260 LIT 278 100 200

INTAKE & EXHAUST SYSTEM

COMBUSTION AIR INTAKE 66.9 M3/MIN 65.8 65.8 M3/MIN 66.7

EXHAUST TEMP. 500 deg.C 428.7 515 530

ENGINE PROTECTION
LOW L.O.PRESSURE LOW L.O.PRESSURE LOW L.O.PRESSURE LOW L.O.PRESSURE
HIGH COOLANT TEMP. HIGH COOLANT TEMP. HIGH COOLANT TEMP. HIGH COOLANT TEMP.
LOW COOLANT LEVEL LOW COOLANT LEVEL LOW COOLANT LEVEL LOW COOLANT LEVEL
OVERSPEED OVERSPEED OVERSPEED OVERSPEED
PERKINS

4008 TAG 2A

8 CYLINDER COMPACT

13.6 :1

1010

4400 KG

65%

500 HOURS

6 TIMES OIL AND FILTER CHANGE

198 LPH

148.7

ELECTRONIC - with unit injection

Unit injection

153 LIT-MAX 127LIT MIN

150 LIT

75M3/MIN

438 deg.C

LOW L.O.PRESSURE
LOW OIL
HIGH COOLANT TEMP.
LOW COOLANT LEVEL
OVERSPEED
FILTER CHOKE