Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
McVay
SCSCI 4530 – Plant Pathology Plant Disease Investigation
Name of Disease: Apple scab
Hosts: In addition to infecting its namesake domestic apple, flowering crabapple and other
Malus species, apple scab also attacks other closely-related genera within the tribe Maleae,
including hawthorn (Crataegus ssp.), mountain ash (Sorbus ssp.), firethorn (Pyracantha ssp.),
and loquat (Eriobyotrya japonica) (Sutton et al.). Given the hosts are all incident to one tribe
within the Rosaceae, this pathogen has a relatively narrow host range.
Causal Organism: Apple scab is caused by Venturia inaequalis (Cooke) G. Winter (anamorph:
Spilocaea pomi). An ascomycete with septate hyphae and haploid nuclei in the subclass
producing ascocarps (in this case pseudothecia) in a stroma in overwintering leaves or fruit on
the orchard floor (Fig. 10.). Pseudothecia are negatively geotropic, solitary, dark brown to black,
spherical in shape, and approximately 90 to 150 μm in diameter (Fig. 6.). Each pseudothecium
has a distinct ostiole with single-celled apical bristles atop a short beak (Fig. 7.) The centrum is
Asci – of which approximately 50 to 100 are contained per pseudothecium – are six to twelve μm
wide by 55 to 75 μm long, fasciculate, cylindrical, and eight-spored with a short stipe; the ascus
wall is thin and bitunicate (Fig. 8.). Contained within an ascus are eight ascospores, each of
which are yellowish-green to tan and unequally two-celled, meaning the upper cell is shorter and
wider than the lower cell. The unequal size of the two cells in the ascospore is indicative of V.
inaequalis, it being the only member of the genus Venturia with such unique ascospore
morphology, and thence gives the species its binomial name (Fig. 9.) (Gadoury and MacHardy).
1
Dr. Muthu Venkateshwaran, Ph.D. N.R. McVay
SCSCI 4530 – Plant Pathology Plant Disease Investigation
As it relates to asexual reproduction, conidiophores arise from shortened, erect, closely septate
brown mycelia. Likewise, the conidiophores themselves are brown, wavy to nodulose, being
either septate or non-septate. Conidia, each six to nine μm long by twelve to 22 μm wide are
yellowish olive, one- or two-celled, single, terminal, and ovate to lanceolate, with irregular
shapes found on occasion (Fig. 11.). Conidia are produced sequentially, abscising from the
conidiophore and leaving behind abscission ridges indicative of V. inaequalis. Conidia are
produced from lesions on the substrate, typically on the surface of leaves, flowers or fruit (Fig.
12.). However, lesions yielding conidia may also be located on shoots or bud scales (MacHardy).
Diagnosis: Physiological responses on the part of the host to being infected by the pathogen are
succinctly known as symptoms, whereas organismal structures illustrating the presence of the
pathogen on a host are known as signs. Symptoms diagnostic for apple scab occur on the aerial
parts of the host, including leaves, petioles, flowers, sepals, fruit, pedicels, young shoots, and bud
scales (Sutton et al.). Signs indicative for V. inaequalis largely entail the presence of
pseudothecia, mycelia within lesions, and conidia. Microscopy is required to accurately locate
Nonetheless, the symptoms incident to apple scab are generally most noticeable and serious on
leaves and fruit. [Symptoms on blossoms usually occur as small, dark green lesions at the base of
the flower, on the sepals, and on the stem pedicel before and during bloom. When pedicels
become infected the developing fruit may drop, resulting in lower fruit yield (MacHardy).] The
first lesions seen in the spring are usually on the underside of expanding leaves. Once the leaves
open, the upper surfaces also become vulnerable to infection. A lesion first appears as an area
which is a lighter shade of green than the surrounding leaf. The lesion is usually circular and as it
increases in size it becomes olive-colored and velvety due to production of asexual spores known
2
Dr. Muthu Venkateshwaran, Ph.D. N.R. McVay
SCSCI 4530 – Plant Pathology Plant Disease Investigation
as conidia (Fig. 2.) (Sutton et al.). Lesions that form on young leaves may be quite large, some
more than one centimeter in diameter. Lesions that form on expanded leaves are usually smaller
because older leaves are more resistant to infection. Affected tissues eventually may become
distorted and puckered, and the leaf lesions often become cracked and torn. Lesions on the leaves
and fruit are generally blistered and scabby in appearance, with a distinct margin (Fig. 3-4.). The
earliest noticeable symptom on fruit is water-soaked areas which develop into velvety, green to
olive-brown lesions. Infections of young fruit will cause fruit distortion (Fig. 5.) (MacHardy).
Severely infected leaves or fruit will often drop from the tree. Infection which causes significant
defoliation for two or three years in a row can result in weakened trees that are more susceptible
primary inoculum. In most years and locations, the first ascospores are mature and
capable of causing infection at about the time of bud break. Ascospores continue to
mature and are discharged over a period of five to nine weeks (Stensvand et al.). The
peak period of ascospore discharge is usually between the pink and full-bloom stages of
blossom development. However, if rain starts during the night and continues throughout
the following morning, few ascospores are released until after sunrise. In the same breath,
low temperatures (i.e., less than ten degrees Celsius) slows the pace – or may even inhibit
otherwise splashed onto uninfected leaves, flowers, fruit, etcetera, throughout the summer
(Keitt and Jones). All forms of inocula are partial to infection courts – or, sites on a host
3
Dr. Muthu Venkateshwaran, Ph.D. N.R. McVay
SCSCI 4530 – Plant Pathology Plant Disease Investigation
where infection can occur – coinciding with younger leaves, flower buds, developing
long as the relative humidity is or exceeds 95%. The timetable necessary for infection to
occur is proportional to the number of hours of wetness and ambient temperature. The
duration of the wet period required for infection increases with the maturity of the fruit
hyphae directly penetrate the surface of the substrate, becoming established between the
epidermis and the cuticle. Infection may occur in a variety of temperature extremes, from
as little as one degree Celsius to as many as 26°C. The duration of the wetting period for
successful ascospore infection varies with ambient temperature, ranging from as much as
(Brook). Infection rarely occurs under conditions where air temperature exceeds 26°C
(Keitt and Jones). The physiological phenomenon contributing to this metabolism is not
Infection: After penetrating the cuticle, the infecting mycelium forms a subcuticular
stroma. Said stroma produces conidiophores and conidia in a localized, visible lesion on
primarily leaves and fruit, but also produced on flower pedicels, twigs, and bud scales
(MacHardy). Lesions with conidia at the center are visible nine to seventeen days
temperature and relative humidity. Nonetheless, the minimum relative humidity required
4
Dr. Muthu Venkateshwaran, Ph.D. N.R. McVay
SCSCI 4530 – Plant Pathology Plant Disease Investigation
for sporulation is between 60 and 70%, and periods of subminimal humidity do not
pseudothecia on the leaf tissue. Most pseudothecia form within four weeks of leaf drop,
the ascogonium developing until the lumen in the pseudothecium is filled with
pseudothecium proceeds with development, maturing in late winter or early spring and
culminating in the synthesis of asci and ascospores. Moisture is necessary for the
maturation (Brook).
twelve degrees Celsius, whereas the optimal temperature range for ascospore maturation
is between sixteen and eighteen degrees Celsius (Stensvand et al.). Factors such as type
of cultivar or the date of leaf fall have no known effect on the date of ascospore
maturation. Nevertheless, mature asci expand through the ostiole and forcibly discharge
ascospores throughout the subsequent spring and early summer. These asci, stimulated to
sporulate from frequent wetting wrought by rain or heavy dew, may be found on
overwintered leaves strewn about the orchard floor (Brook). Upon discharge, the
and fruit on the orchard floor. The fungus can also overwinter as mycelium in twig
lesions and bud scales, but only in cool maritime climates such as Northern Europe.
5
Dr. Muthu Venkateshwaran, Ph.D. N.R. McVay
SCSCI 4530 – Plant Pathology Plant Disease Investigation
Survival of overwintering mycelia is otherwise uncommon outside of said regions due to
remain viable in the absence of a living host as a saprophyte on dead host tissues – such
as leaf and fruit lesions – for the next growing season, in which said pathogen initiates
primary inoculum in the form of ascospores (Keitt and Jones). Furthermore, since V.
tissue killed directly by the pathogen via mycotoxins, it may continue to produce
secondary inoculum (i.e., conidia) through the course of the current growing season
Management: Apple scab is effectively managed with multisite protectant fungicides, such as
quinone outside inhibitors (QoIs); or, single-site curative and protectant fungicides, such as
Fungicides with curative properties are primarily used in postinfection applications, whereas
protectants are applied prior to infection as preventatives. Single-site protectants are susceptible
to becoming useless when repetitively used to manage apple scab epidemics, as V. inaequalis is
that inhibit or promote a single gene or group of genes within the fungal metabolism.
Nevertheless, chemically-organic fungicide applications are the norm for any integrative pest
Traditionally, scab sprays have been applied in accordance with key host phenological stages. A
typical spraying regime would have the first application at or immediately after bud break, with
subsequent applications at 1-cm green, tight cluster, full pink, bloom, and petal fall stages
6
Dr. Muthu Venkateshwaran, Ph.D. N.R. McVay
SCSCI 4530 – Plant Pathology Plant Disease Investigation
(MacHardy). Such control programs require absolute precision, reflecting the potential risk of
infection posed to the fruit crop. The scope of these computerized predictions typically includes
infection periods, models for ascospore maturation, tree phenology, cultivar susceptibility, and
In organic apple production, variations on copper, sulfur, and lime sulfur are the most widely
employed inorganic fungicides to control apple scab. These compounds are all multisite
protectants, being very effective in killing any spores (including those of beneficial epiphytes) on
leaf surfaces, although lime sulfur appears to have some curative activity. However, the efficacy
of said protectants is subject to the weathering effects of rain. Likewise, rapid expansion of the
tree canopy at springtime (i.e., between the mouse ear and tight cluster stages) increases the risk
by which infection occurs on unprotected host tissue. As a result, repeat applications may be
necessary to control apple scab inocula, especially when rainy conditions persist over a multiday
period (Mills). In spite of the industry’s reliance upon organic and inorganic fungicides, there
have been several attempts at the development of biocontrol measures to combat the pathogen.
Unfortunately, none of said measures have been widely adopted into commercial agricultural
In terms of other control and preventative measures, orchard sanitation practices in the autumn
can significantly reduce the number of ascospores (i.e., primary inoculum) the following spring,
thereby augmenting the efficacy by which fungicide applications control the fungus (Keitt and
Jones). For example, applications of urea prior to leaf fall mitigates the formation of
pseudothecia, increases the breakdown of leaf litter, and may potentially decrease the amount of
ascosporic inoculum by an order of 50% to 90%. Urea may also be directly applied to the leaf
litter in either late autumn, early spring prior to bud break, or both. These urea treatments can be
7
Dr. Muthu Venkateshwaran, Ph.D. N.R. McVay
SCSCI 4530 – Plant Pathology Plant Disease Investigation
combined with the shredding of leaves with a flair mower to promote leaf decomposition and
interspecific competition betwixt V. inaequalis and soil inhabitants on leaf residues (Mill). Or, as
a substitute for urea, commercial powdered mixes containing various epiphytic microorganisms
may be applied to shredded leaf residue for a similar effect (MacHardy). However, even a 90%
reduction in pseudothecia and ascospores as a source of primary inoculum does not sufficiently
reduce scab infection under favorable conditions without a diverse mix of other control measures
(Mills).
Chemical practices are not the only means by which to prevent or control apple scab epidemics.
On the contrary, cultural practices can go a long way towards keeping disease abated. In general,
trees should be pruned regularly so that their canopies are relatively open. This management
technique promotes circulation around and through the canopy, thereby facilitating the drying of
environmental conditions ideal for apple scab infection. In addition, this pruning regime
Another means of preventing apple scab – without needing to rely on chemical inputs – is the
selection of genetically superior plant material for the home and commercial orchard. Even
amongst the commercially-available apple cultivars, the most frequented host of apple scab,
and ‘Cox’s Orange Pippin’ are by far the most susceptible cultivars to V. inaequalis, whereas
‘Discovery,’ ‘Elstar,’ ‘Honeycrisp,’ and ‘Ingrid Marie’ are all examples of cultivars with
well as home orchards, choosing apple cultivars with low susceptibility to scab is essential.
Altogether, more than 60 cultivars have been released worldwide in the last thirty years with
8
Dr. Muthu Venkateshwaran, Ph.D. N.R. McVay
SCSCI 4530 – Plant Pathology Plant Disease Investigation
resistance to races of apple scab. The gene most commonly conferring resistance in these
resistant cultivars is known as the Vf gene complex (Sutton et al.). The resistance conferred by
this gene complex, originating from Malus floribunda ‘Siebold’ x ‘Van Houtte,’ has
failure of cultivars with specific resistance, apple breeding programs worldwide are now
addressing apple scab with cultivars exhibiting broad resistance to the pathogen, with some
success (MacHardy). ‘Liberty,’ and ‘Florina’ and ‘GoldRush’ in particular, have been hits with
the apple growing industry; ‘Florina’ is now the second most widely grown cultivar in France
after ‘Golden Delicious,’ meanwhile ‘GoldRush’ has quickly become the sixth most widely
grown cultivar in North America, as of 2006, with a large following amongst consumers in New
York and New England (MacHardy). These three cultivars are a testament to the ongoing – and
likely never ending – work of developing apple germplasm capable of tolerating or resisting
Importance of Disease: Apple is one of the most important fruit crops grown and sold both
domestically and abroad, wine grape being first. Apple scab is the most economically important
disease of apples worldwide (Sutton et al.). The disease, first described in Sweden by E.M. Fries
in 1819 but known from paintings dating back to the fifteenth and sixteenth centuries, is present
wherever apples and other host plants are cultivated (Keitt and Jones). However, severity is
reduced, or the pathogen is altogether rare in semiarid regions of production, such as western
North America and western Australia (James and Sutton). Crop losses can be pronounced in
regions dominated by humid, cool weather conditions, as is the case across Northern Europe, the
northeastern United States, and Canada. Economic loss from apple scab is directly attributable to
fruit or pedicel infections (reducing shelf appeal to the consumer at market alongside poor
9
Dr. Muthu Venkateshwaran, Ph.D. N.R. McVay
SCSCI 4530 – Plant Pathology Plant Disease Investigation
postharvest viability) and indirectly due to repeated premature defoliation, which reduces host
growth and yields for several years (MacHardy). Likewise, repeated defoliation places
physiological stress on the host, thereby increasing susceptibility to winter injury or long-term
References:
Blaise, P.H. et al. 1987. Apple Scab: A teaching aid on microcomputers. Plant Disease 71 (7):
574-578.
Venturia inaequalis (Cke.) Wint. New Zealand Journal of Agricultural Research 12:214-
227.
Gadoury, D.M., and W.E. MacHardy. 1982. A model to estimate the maturity of ascospores of
James, J.R., and T.B. Sutton. 1982. Environmental factors influencing pseudothecial
1080.
Keitt, G.W., and L.K. Jones. 1926. Studies of the epidemiology and control of apple scab.
Merwin, I.A., et al. 1994. Scab-resistant apples for the Northeastern United States: New
MacHardy, W.E. 1996. Apple Scab: Biology, Epidemiology, and Management. APS Press: St.
Paul, Minnesota.
Mills, W.D. 1944. Efficient use of sulfur dusts and sprays during rain to control apple scab. New
10
Dr. Muthu Venkateshwaran, Ph.D. N.R. McVay
SCSCI 4530 – Plant Pathology Plant Disease Investigation
Stensvand, A., D.M. Gadoury, T. Amundsen, and R.C. Seem. 1997. Ascospore release and
Sutton, T.B., H.S. Aldwinckle, A.M. Agnello, and J.F. Walgenbach, eds. 2014. Compendium of
Apple and Pear Diseases and Pests, Second Edition. APS Press: St. Paul, Minnesota. 8-
11.
Vaillancourt, L.J. and J.R. Hartman. 2000. Apple scab. The Plant Health Instructor. DOI:
Definitions:
1. Ascocarp, or ascoma (pl. ascomata): The fruiting body of a fungus in the phylum
Ascomycota, consisting of very tightly interwoven hyphae and may contain millions of
2. Ascus (pl. asci): A sac, typically cylindrical in shape, in which the spores of ascomycete
fungi develop.
conjugation of mycelia from two different mating types in order to sexually reproduce,
4. Centrum (pl. centra): Collectively, all the structures enclosed within the ascocarp of a
fungus.
5. Fasciculate: Formed of, or growing in, bundles or clusters akin to fasces, a weapon used
6. Negatively geotropic (from negative geotropism): The act of growing against gravity.
11
Dr. Muthu Venkateshwaran, Ph.D. N.R. McVay
SCSCI 4530 – Plant Pathology Plant Disease Investigation
8. Pseudoparaphysis (pl. pseudoparaphyses): A hypha growing betwixt asci derived from
within the pseudothecium, but originating from above (i.e., the tectum, the structure that
covers the ostiole while the pseudothecia develops), and not from the base of the
ascocarp.
10. Pseudothecium (pl. pseudothecia): An ascocarp resembling a perithecium, but whose asci
are not regularly organized into a hymenium and are instead bitunicate, having a double
wall which expands when it takes up water and shoots the enclosed spores out suddenly
to disperse them.
11. Stroma: A cushion-like mass of fungal tissue, having spore-bearing structures either
Register of Figures:
Fig. 1. ‘Jonathan’ fruit with apple scab lesions. (Courtesy J. Hartman and The American
Phytopathological Society, Vaillancourt, L.J. and J.R. Hartman. 2000. Apple scab. The Plant
Health Instructor. DOI: 10.1094/PHI-I-2000-1005-01. Updated 2005.)
12
Dr. Muthu Venkateshwaran, Ph.D. N.R. McVay
SCSCI 4530 – Plant Pathology Plant Disease Investigation
Fig. 2. Apple scab lesions on young ‘Golden Delicious’ leaves. (Courtesy W.E. MacHardy and
The American Phytopathological Society, Vaillancourt, L.J. and J.R. Hartman. 2000. Apple scab.
The Plant Health Instructor. DOI: 10.1094/PHI-I-2000-1005-01. Updated 2005.)
Fig. 3. Scab lesions coalescing into blisters at the cuticle-epidermal interface of the leaf.
(Courtesy W.E. MacHardy and The American Phytopathological Society, Vaillancourt, L.J. and
J.R. Hartman. 2000. Apple scab. The Plant Health Instructor. DOI: 10.1094/PHI-I-2000-1005-
01. Updated 2005.)
13
Dr. Muthu Venkateshwaran, Ph.D. N.R. McVay
SCSCI 4530 – Plant Pathology Plant Disease Investigation
Fig. 4. Blistered scab lesion on fruit. (Courtesy W.E. MacHardy and The American
Phytopathological Society, Vaillancourt, L.J. and J.R. Hartman. 2000. Apple scab. The Plant
Health Instructor. DOI: 10.1094/PHI-I-2000-1005-01. Updated 2005.)
Fig. 5. Distortion of apple fruits due to apple scab infection. (Courtesy W.E. MacHardy and The
American Phytopathological Society, Vaillancourt, L.J. and J.R. Hartman. 2000. Apple scab. The
Plant Health Instructor. DOI: 10.1094/PHI-I-2000-1005-01. Updated 2005.)
14
Dr. Muthu Venkateshwaran, Ph.D. N.R. McVay
SCSCI 4530 – Plant Pathology Plant Disease Investigation
Fig. 6. Pseudothecium of Venturia inaequalis embedded in leaf tissue. The arrows point to
hyphae which may represent two different mating types. (Courtesy W.E. MacHardy and The
American Phytopathological Society, Vaillancourt, L.J. and J.R. Hartman. 2000. Apple scab. The
Plant Health Instructor. DOI: 10.1094/PHI-I-2000-1005-01. Updated 2005.)
Fig. 7. Cross section of a pseudothecium of Venturia inaequalis. The cross section has been
stained so that the asci and ascospores are pink. (Courtesy W.E. MacHardy and The American
Phytopathological Society, Vaillancourt, L.J. and J.R. Hartman. 2000. Apple scab. The Plant
Health Instructor. DOI: 10.1094/PHI-I-2000-1005-01. Updated 2005.)
15
Dr. Muthu Venkateshwaran, Ph.D. N.R. McVay
SCSCI 4530 – Plant Pathology Plant Disease Investigation
Fig. 8. Asci of Venturia inaequalis, each containing eight, two-celled ascospores. (Courtesy
W.E. MacHardy and The American Phytopathological Society, Vaillancourt, L.J. and J.R.
Hartman. 2000. Apple scab. The Plant Health Instructor. DOI: 10.1094/PHI-I-2000-1005-01.
Updated 2005.)
Fig. 9. Two-celled ascospores of Venturia inaequalis. (Courtesy W.E. MacHardy and The
American Phytopathological Society, Vaillancourt, L.J. and J.R. Hartman. 2000. Apple scab. The
Plant Health Instructor. DOI: 10.1094/PHI-I-2000-1005-01. Updated 2005.)
16
Dr. Muthu Venkateshwaran, Ph.D. N.R. McVay
SCSCI 4530 – Plant Pathology Plant Disease Investigation
Fig. 10. Depiction of a fallen apple leaf, showing the mature pseudothecia of Venturia inaequalis
protruding above the substrate, ready to release ascospores. (Courtesy W.E. MacHardy and The
American Phytopathological Society, Vaillancourt, L.J. and J.R. Hartman. 2000. Apple scab. The
Plant Health Instructor. DOI: 10.1094/PHI-I-2000-1005-01. Updated 2005.)
Fig. 11. Conidia of Spilocaea pomi (teleomorph: Venturia inaequalis). (Courtesy J. Hartman and
The American Phytopathological Society, Vaillancourt, L.J. and J.R. Hartman. 2000. Apple scab.
The Plant Health Instructor. DOI: 10.1094/PHI-I-2000-1005-01. Updated 2005.)
17
Dr. Muthu Venkateshwaran, Ph.D. N.R. McVay
SCSCI 4530 – Plant Pathology Plant Disease Investigation
Fig. 12. Cross section through a leaf infected with apple scab. Arrow indicates the leaf cuticle
which has been ruptured and pushed back by the mass of erupting conidia and conidiophores.
(Courtesy W. E. MacHardy and The American Phytopathological Society, Vaillancourt, L.J. and
J.R. Hartman. 2000. Apple scab. The Plant Health Instructor. DOI: 10.1094/PHI-I-2000-1005-
01. Updated 2005.)
Fig. 13. Illustrated disease cycle of Venturia inaequalis on domestic apple. The disease cycle is
similar for other host plants of the pathogen. (Courtesy of The American Phytopathological
Society, Vaillancourt, L.J. and J.R. Hartman. 2000. Apple scab. The Plant Health Instructor.
DOI: 10.1094/PHI-I-2000-1005-01. Updated 2005.)
18