Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
I c I
KONRAD BASLER
BRUNO THURLIMANN
, .. • • 4" ~
by
n
Konrad Basler and Bruno Thurlimann
Lehigh University
Fri t,zEngineering L·aboratory
Report 'No. 251-19
November 1960
Page
FOREWORD i
SYNOPSIS iii
INTRODUCTION 1
I WEB BUCKLING 3
101 The Phenomenon of Web Buckling 3
102 Web Participation under Bending 6
II THE ULTIMATE B"ENDING MOMENT 8
201 Vertical Buckling or the Flange 9
202 Lateral Buckling 12
2 3
0 Torsional Buckling of the Flange Plate 2.1
REFERENCES
251.19 - i -
IOREWoRD _
SYNOPSIS
INTRODUCTION
This has -been pointed out ever since buckling values were
computed, and as a consequence a somewhat smaller factor of
safety was applied to web buckling than against primary column
251019 -2
the material, the r.esu~t of the linea~ buck;ling. theory ~h~t :La
.cPDlPlonly used can thuf;' be illustrated as in Figo'. lb. TtLe, pl.~te
remains ,plane for all 'posi tive values of the applied st~aln_ ~'a
(1)
comp~ess1on
(4)
with the resultant later,l forces Ta and Tb. These two re-
actions are
(5a)
(5b)
-17
Ocr (w)
_ nfE
- 2
If
t Af+.1 Aw
6
or °cr(W) "'E2
=(1) (6)
r
it should be expecte.d that· here O"cr (w) would apply. That this
is the ca.se is shoWn in S,ec. 4- 2, where the respective diagrams
derived by Clark apd Hill are reproduced as Fig. 13.
O'er
-= 0< A <{2 (7a)
(7b)
with
c) "The Preservation
,1 ' j , • i
or Shape
shape has but little effect upon ~he resulting buckling, stress
and an analysis on the basis of ocr (w)alone is a conservat,1,ve
one in all cases.
(8e.)
(8b)
with
stresses are less than one half of the yield stress thus it, is
of little interest in ~he design of plate girders. Therefor~L~
(0.053 ~ - 0045)0.68
o
inelastic range, - < 26 (9b)
d
This correlation between old and ejc 1s plotted in Fig. 10.
As indicated, the condition
¥ ~ 12 + .Jc (90)
(loe. a flange width to thickness ratio not exceeding 12 ,plUS
251.19 -24
the result, namely ~/r, c/d, Aw/Af, and bit. Whereas the
f~rst two essentially control lateral and torsional buckl~ng
be suggested.
(10)
(llb)
Assurrling thq.t the stress corr;1)utat1on woul~ be done with
(12b)
251.19 .
similar to tnat for t~e plastic moment will not ta.ke pJ.ace.
In order to keep the conoept si~ple it is proposed to use
exp~ess1on 12b only for the range of web slenderness rat1qs
where ~ > ~o, namely in the post-buckling range where a
Nav~e~-Bernoulli linear stress dist~lbution would be an un-
conservative assumption. In the range of ~ <:; t3 o ' au = cry
l~lill be us~d.
~ = 6.0 ~!
Conforming to the existing U. S. specifications an 1nter-
mediate v~l~e ~s suggested,
(30 =
I
-{rE'
5• 7 --a (13)
which gives 130 = 170 when 0 = 0y = 3? ksi, Fig. 12, and 140
for a yield stress eq"lrlal to 50' ksi.
ance with Eq. 14a since this expression applies only to web
slenderness ratios M = bit in e~ce:;lsf t30 ::: 5. 7 ~ B/a i = 5. 7 X
1300 00/19.8' ::: 222. Hence au = acr and Mu = auI/e a = 19.8 x
14,380/25.9 :;: 11,000 k;-in. For a moment arm of 150", Pu th :::
Mu /150" =.73 k. u
As shown in Table 1, P ex :;:: 81 k giving a
ratio of e~per1mental to ultimate load of 1.11.
251.19 -31
in ocr ::;;: 0.79 0 y ::;;: 0.79 x 8.6 ::;;: 37 5 kai. With ~o= 5.7~E/d
Girder G5:
t
Computation sim11a~ to that f'or girder G3 g1'ves:
IV APPENDIX
t
(16)
With:
I y ~ Girder's moment of inertia abt. weak axis ~ ~ Af c
2
. A'
K: ::; Torsiona, 1, oonstant = -31 (2cd.3 +bt.3 +~Cd.3) ~ 1. · A f (2d~,--!!t2)
3 Ar '
, 2: 2
r :: Warping, constant =1 I b
2
~ 1 "A:rb c"
4 y 6
G ~ S~ea~ Modulu~ = E
2-(1+v)
1 Aw
S = Section Modulus :::: bAf(l~ 'If )
rr Ea t2
2 Aw
_ Mer +8 (l+v) l~'li
,~ T -- +
.0C1' 't 2~:i! 1 Aw 2
d 2 (20)'2
(1+ 6 ".A.fJ
''--v--'' ~
C D
251.19 -35
1.2 t1m~s ~h~ web th~cknes8 t, and in all the cases where the
wa~ area 1s negl~g1ble compa~ed with the flange are~~AwlA~-O.
Then the remainger A in the £irst term is the square of Ocr (v)
(F,ig. 5), becaus~ the numerator equa.ls (0.65 'E) 2 using Poisson's
:t'atl0 \I = Q.3.
The ~a4ius of gyration r of the equ1~alent column Qo~posed
Ratio MulMy
i ! 1
llb
:;::
1~ + 7
3P
+L
p2 -
(1-+ 2 )
.12 P
251.19 -36
_~2 1 3 2 .b 21· - 2
Mom. of Inertia I = AfYb + 3 Yb t + Af (b-Yb) + 12 t (24b- Yb)
Section Modulus Sa + L = Afb [T)~ + pT)3 + (1-T)b)2 +
Ya I-~b 3 b
Ultimate Moment M
U
= (J
YSa
hence
(19)
bit = 53
1 + P
6
Resulting in
for r3 = 360 f3= 53
11b Mu/My Mut'My
p = 0 0.500 1.00 1.00
= 1/2 0.481 0.94 1004
=1 0.466 0.89 1007
=2 0.444 0082 1.12
=3 0·430 0077 1017
=4 0.417 0.74 1.20
=5 0.413 0.70 1.23
251.19 -37
= 2..086 x 30090
300 x 300
== == =::=====-====:=·c=~== ..
~
Case c = 10", d =.-- [in],
I-dt _ _ a. .... - - __ -
--.,.-------- -
251.19 -38
in Fig. 13.
251.19 . -39
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
b: Depth of girden
c: Half of flange width
d: Thiokness of flange
e: Distance from NA to e4:trelne fibe:r
r: Radius of gy~a~lon
t: Thickness o~ web
l~: Deflecti9n p~~pepd1c~lar to the plane Of the web
A: Area
E: Modulus 'of E~astic1ty (30,000 ksi)
M: Bending moment
I: Moment of Inert1~
Subscripts: ~ - a1:>ove
b - below
01'1 -'" ori tj_cal
ex - expex'ilnental
f - compl'6ss1011 f'lange
i -- initia.l
!' = res i<lllG'l
th """. tJ1Go:~etical
5. Winter, G.
PO·ST-B,UCKLING STREl\fGTH OF PLATES IN STEE14 DESIGN
I.A.B.S.E., F. Rep., p. 268, 1952
6. Taylor, J. C., Vasishth, N. C., Yuan, C. Y., and
Vasarhelyi, D. D.
AN EXPERI~ENTAL INV'ESTIGATION OF THE B'EHAVIOR OF A
RIVETED PLATE GIRDER W'rTH A. THIN WEB
University o~ Washington~ Report, August 1959
7. Moore, R. L.
OBSERVATIONS ON TIlE BERAVIOa OF ALUMINUM ALLOY ,TEST
GIRDERS .-
A.S.C.E., Trans., Vol. 112, ppo 901-920, 1947
8. stussi, F., KQl1bruuner."C. F., und Walt, M.
VERS UCHSBERI CHT UBER DAS AUSBEULEND.ER AOF EIN ~
SEITIGEN, GLEIC~SSIG UND UNGLElcHMASSIG VERTEILTEN
DRUCK BEANSPRUCHTEN PLATTEN
Inst. f. Bauat. a.d. E.T.H., Mitt. Nr. 25, Verlag
Leemann, Zurich, 1951
9. von Karman, Th.
ENCYKLOPADIE DEB. MATHEMATISGHEN WISSENSCHAFT~
Vol. IV, p. 349, 1910
10. Hu,P. C., LtUldquist, E. E., and Batdor.f, ,S. B.
EFFECP OF SMALL D~IATIONS FROM FLATNESS ON TijE
~ECTlvE WIDTH AND BUCKLING OF PLATES IN COM-
PR-ESSION
N'A:C.A., T.N. 1124, 1946
251.19
..
. .
Table 1 Summary of Bending Tests on vlelde'd Plate Girders
£ea
GIRD--ER
2c =
d =
20. 56
0.427
1\OY=35.4 12. 19
0.769
1\0;=38.6 108.62
0.328
1'
0;=35.5
.12."16
0.774
1\0;=37.6
H8.62
0.22810;=-35.5
TEST TI TI T2 TI T2 TI T2 TI T2
2k = 100- 100 50 100 -50 100 50 r 100 50
ftr = 19 32 16 39 19 30
I·
15 36 18
Parameters 2 c/d = 48" 16- 16'
b/t- = 185 185: 185 ~ 388
Aw-/Af :: I. 5 1-.4 1.6 0.7 0.8
- th 106 109 ~
73 141 145' 126 130 118 1.21
Ult. Loads .Pu =
{ P ex :: 81 135· 144 130 136 118 125 1'1 0 124
u
Pu eX /D
r
th "-- I .1 I 0.96 Q99 1.03- 1.05 1.00 1.03 1.04 1.-14
u
t
-( o +1 x:~
IEed
Fig.lb
Fig.lo
y
1.0=Yi
, ~-. .- -- .
"·--r~~·-=*1~·Zr-=...,
=--=--=--=---:....-----_---....:..--0.05....-1 . 0 - +1 +2 _._ _.-
X_Eo·
---. --
Ii t.
- --- 0 ? "
-----.~v=.lO------·-O.5--...
-- -..... "
Y"
.h,-.,.,r-.,
'\
t-
---
jEcrl
,,'
. . . . . ---,-" I
~ /
-I !_y2+y~+~:: X+! I
Fi9~ic
..
\ -.- M
AE~My
... - O~34 .'
l..
1=0.129+' .&=
... ·11
b~50'
1: I-
/.
099 0.68 0.34 -0 M/My My =f5700k-in
f)
G5- TI t X= -18
1'225- 0.767
d·,
+-2cii ---t -J.-
J -
I .J ~g:l ;;.
,
~ ·Ya
I
b- ( b)
N.A.--
I ·- N.A.
Vb.
t
A
f'\.
(o)
-r-.d . (c)
Fig. 3 (a) NotatioTI p (b) Buckling Modes of' the Compression Flange
and (0) Effective Girder Cross Section
1
1
1
1
1
1
I
I
I
I
1
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
v: Sf Vena ntis Torsi'on w : Warping Torsion
O.65E"' _ . ".2 E
OCr(v)= lb/2ed . q;r-(w)::------..-
I. 2c .1 r-----··-- ~
M.' _ ~ lJ.Tr EIYG K
2 4
7T E;yr-. ()
Id cr l' 12: + 14 " . a
- 2 2~- 2
O.65E_) W-,-.E).
~r(v,w) =11 ( tb/2ed'"
t (
,5/6 ,:
~
r-~
- CTcrCw) 't,.{v,w)
~r{W)
o lO
d
o
I
I
~
I
I
f. ------~·~I It-i
o
«
Z
·CTcr'o;
1.0 -r-
I +- r~ t
Mcr(!
.
;= -f-f'
!) t,2c
Mer
L
1 ~
. X2
~=t-4 I Aw
t
I
I .--..
I;
~,D.5 -------------------~----_ ...... ----_.,- -----_. --- _.~---....,..,,-----" t
I
.. _-_._.---- .-
j-
-I OCr I
i
I
I fry = )!
1
I,
I'
t
I
I
!
o
O. 0.5 1.0 2.0 A
£ = 0.0011:
y I I I I II • I I I I I t I I I f I f I :sa
o 50 100 15) itr =1TA/i~y
A 0 10 20 30 40 50 J./2c
,;2: O.---....--...--~......--......-~-.-.---.--..~-t--..-.-..po---..p--.....---ra~----r--....-----.~~"'i!--.....--....--~.......--+----~~~
~OS TA
1.0
1.5
~Ey(12+2A~
A,}
Fl[~ r Lpte~al
....... .L -
n'U,-:.~~ll·TlP
... "--'-.---- --c;.. Cll'r\le
-.-.. , ~
Vcr .
(-;';j\
OCr/a;
luO ---\
d; :
(h
1-0.53(A-O.45)1.36
. 0.5 + I
1 - 0
OCr I
o-y :: )!
+
tJ
o
o 0.5 1.0 J2 2.0 A
:'y = p.OO,":! I I I I I I I I I , I I I I I I E$= C! d
o 10 20 30
30
~
2c =12+ 2c
d
20
10 ~~
o
o 50
I l I
I" $ 1 30t
I '
Mu~ e- ~
I
~
A
~ S ~
.~
y [~
d ~
\1 8 ""
~
~ .,., ~:! I
~ """~" "'"",,~
"'~l"§-"~",.
I
.- ii % 1· i
1 - i
1 ; I
0- - - ............. '.. ..,. T \ 1
T II ""
u -", --. __ ." Ii I
II ?
,~ =~
I I "
I I '0
I
I
j _==_,
o
it
1 -~
L___ _
f3~!f
~~
bQ 360 tl
!,
-~-""":"I:~ .......-...
..... ~~~:~~
~~- ...
o ~tl(P\
100 i2:~_",~vJ
..
a.-
o
tn
o
. -
U-
o
U LaJ
b
.. . I 20 :1 -U-~P 1-20'
CD
¢' q,S
II
-I
LLI
IaJ
Iii 100 100
a: =r-I--I CJ)=T~20- ~
~ - VARIES
011 TO 20II
~
a: I-
~=
0 _ ~-,
. ' /, /~~"_,_,
4: - --........ ..
•
..:.~_----.,--....,-----.~ ~,
>0 - ~_
80 '
/-
/ CTcr (w ) ---++--
/
1/:
,I j// I L=300 "
60
·L= 300· / /;,/;
'1/ 1"b::
- 16
~. . ! -
t
40 33 KSI -
33 KSI
I - - - - ----4----- - - - - -
cr(v) t I OCr(v)
. . .---......"'.""'' _-.... - -! . ,,"" ~
14
20· VI -, ~,'
~~~~ I
---- ------ 2_
14