Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
Effects of lavender scent on patients' anxiety and pain levels during gynecological
examination
Nilufer Tugut, RN, PhD, Assistant Professor, Gulbahtiyar Demirel, RN, PhD, Assistant
Professor, Muruvvet Baser, RN, Ph.D, Professor Doctor, Elvan E. Ata, RN, PhD,
Assistant Professor, Savas Karakus, MD, Assistant Professor
PII: S1744-3881(17)30120-2
DOI: 10.1016/j.ctcp.2017.05.006
Reference: CTCP 728
Please cite this article as: Tugut N, Demirel G, Baser M, Ata EE, Karakus S, Effects of lavender scent on
patients' anxiety and pain levels during gynecological examination, Complementary Therapies in Clinical
Practice (2017), doi: 10.1016/j.ctcp.2017.05.006.
This is a PDF file of an unedited manuscript that has been accepted for publication. As a service to
our customers we are providing this early version of the manuscript. The manuscript will undergo
copyediting, typesetting, and review of the resulting proof before it is published in its final form. Please
note that during the production process errors may be discovered which could affect the content, and all
legal disclaimers that apply to the journal pertain.
ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT
Title: Effects of lavender scent on patients’ anxiety and pain levels during
gynecological examination
PT
Nilufer Tugut
RI
Assistant Professor, RN, PhD,
SC
E-mail: nlfrtugut@gmail.com
E mail: gulbahtiyar_doganer@hotmail.com
TE
Muruvvet Baser
E mail: mbaser@erciyes.edu.tr
Kayseri, Turkey.
ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT
Elvan E. Ata
E mail: elvanhenden@gmail.com
PT
RI
Savas Karakus
SC
Assistant Professor, MD
E-mail: karakussavas@yahoo.com.tr
U
Adresses: eDepartment of Obstetrics and Gynecology, Faculty of Medicine, Cumhuriyet
AN
University, 58140 Sivas, Turkey
M
D
TE
C EP
AC
ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT
1. Introduction
Although gynecological examinations take a shorter time than do many other examinations,
they evoke negative feelings in many women. Of all medical interventions, gynecological
examinations are the most common cause of anxiety [1-4]. However, gynecological
examinations have a very important place in the protection of women's health as they ensure
PT
the early diagnosis of sexually transmitted infections, genital cancers and ill-health [5]. A
RI
woman’s negative experiences of gynecological examination discourage her from having
another one. Therefore, the aim of protecting women's health with regular gynecological
SC
controls may not always be realized, which can result in the deterioration of women's health.
Thus, gynecological examinations should be conducted in such a way that they do not cause
U
anxiety and women can treat them as they would any other medical examination. In many
AN
studies it is reported that women suffer physical and emotional discomfort during
M
gynecological examinations and thus they avoid them [1-3,5]. On the other hand, some
studies report that the use of techniques such as relaxation exercises and listening to music
D
before and during examination offers a more positive experience for women [1-6].
TE
results have demonstrated that different aromatic fragrances affect the electrical activity of the
EP
brain differently. It has been reported that essential oils such as lavender can raise the level of
the happiness hormone, endorphin, in the brain eight to ten-fold and provide mental and
C
AC
physical relaxation a few minutes after exposure [7]. Studies have revealed that lavender is
useful and can be applied safely [8-10]. In Turkey, although the use of lavender scent as one
supportive approach has been reported, there is not enough research on its effect in the field of
gynecology. This study aimed at determining the effect of lavender scent on anxiety suffered
2.1. Design
The study was conducted in the gynecology and obstetrics outpatient clinic of a university
PT
hospital.
RI
2.3. Population and sample
Women who were admitted to the gynecology and obstetrics outpatient clinic of a training
SC
and research hospital and who met the inclusion criteria listed below comprised the
- being non-pregnant
- not having any chronic health problems including asthma / allergic asthma, chronic
D
lung disease
TE
- not having any mental health problems such as anxiety, depression, panic attacks,
EP
The sample size of the study was based on Braden and colleagues’ study [11], using the
NCSS-PASS 2008 (Statistics, Graphics, Power Analysis & Sample Size Program) program
(Type I error of 0.05 and Type II error of 0.20 were assumed). After this calculation, the
The study sample consisted of 156 women who met the inclusion criteria and voluntarily
gave their informed consent to participate in the study. The participants who met the inclusion
ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT
criteria were randomly assigned into two groups with an equal chance by means of the
random sampling method. After the women were given numbers, they were selected from the
random number table, and then 78 women assigned to the intervention group and 78 to the
control group. The first person was assigned to the intervention and the second person to the
PT
2.4. Data collection
RI
In this present study, three forms were used to collect the data.
SC
literature and aimed to determine sociodemographic characteristics, obstetric history and the
U
examination. The questionnaire consisted of 10 closed-end and open-end questions.
AN
State Anxiety Inventory (STAI): in order to determine the participating women's anxiety levels
M
during gynecological examination, the State Anxiety Inventory developed by Spielberger [12]
and translated into Turkish by Oner and Le Compte [13] was used. The cronbach alpha value
D
of State Anxiety Inventory ranged between 0.94 and 0.96, In the present study, Cronbach's
TE
alpha value was 0.91 for the State Anxiety Inventory. The scale has reverse-scored and direct-
scored items. The total scores of reverse-scored and direct-scored items are separately
EP
calculated. The total score obtained from the reversed items is subtracted from that of the non-
reversed items. A predetermined constant value is added to this value. This predetermined
C
AC
constant value is 50 for the State Anxiety Inventory. The final value obtained is the
individual's anxiety score. Total score obtained from the scale vary between 20 and 80.
Higher scores indicate higher anxiety levels, while lower scores indicate low levels of anxiety.
The mean scores determined during implementations varied between 36 and 41. Spielberger
reported that scores between zero and 19 obtained from the scale indicate that the person has
"no anxiety," between 20 and 39 indicates that the person’s anxiety level is “mild,” between
ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT
40 and 59 indicates that the person’s anxiety level is "moderate," and between 60 and 79
indicates that the person’s anxiety level is "severe," and that those whose score is 60 or higher
Visual Analog Scale (VAS): in order to determine the severity of pain and emotional distress
suffered by women in the intervention and the control groups during gynecological
PT
examination, the VAS was used [14]. The VAS is used to convert values which cannot be
RI
measured numerically into numerical values. The scale is widely used for pain assessment. In
the VAS assessment, zero refers to no pain, 1-4=mild pain, 5-6=moderate pain and 7-10=
SC
severe pain.
U
To perform the study, written approvals were obtained from Erciyes University Clinical
AN
Research Ethics Board (dated and numbered 2014/568) and the hospital where the study was
M
conducted. Before the women who presented for gynecological examination were enrolled in
the study, it was determined whether they met the inclusion criteria or not. Those who did
D
meet the inclusion criteria were informed of the purpose and content of the study and then
TE
their written informed consent was obtained. The women were divided into two groups by the
random sampling method. In order to obtain accurate data, the participating women were told
EP
not to write any personally identifiable information but to use a pseudonym on all documents
other than the consent form. They were also told that all the data obtained would remain
C
AC
room were determined with the relevant questionnaire, their anxiety levels during
gynecological examination were determined with the State Anxiety Scale. The participants
were given an average of 10 to 15 minutes to fill in the questionnaires. Then the lavender
scent prepared by the researchers was put into the examination room. As suggested in other
studies, 10% lavender oil was prepared and put into a lamp [3,4]. Lavender oil has been
ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT
reported to be effective in reducing anxiety 3 to 15 minutes after it is inhaled [1-5].
Considering the time determined in the aforementioned studies and the time needed for the
inhale the lavender scent. The concentrated lavender oil was placed at a distance of 15 cm
from the gynecological examination table and the room temperature was set at between 21
PT
and 24 C°. Gynecological examination of the participants in the intervention group was
RI
performed by the same physician.
After the examination, each woman in the intervention group was taken to the waiting room
SC
and administered the State Anxiety Inventory to determine the level of anxiety experienced
during the gynecological examination and the VAS to determine the severity of pain and
examination room where there was no lavender scent, and their gynecological examination
was performed by the same physician. After the examination, each woman in the control
D
group was taken to the waiting room and administered the State Anxiety Inventory to
TE
determine the level of anxiety experienced during gynecological examination and the VAS to
determine the severity of pain and emotional discomfort after the examination.
EP
The study data were analyzed with the SPSS 16 software package. The sociodemographic
C
AC
characteristics of the participants were given as numbers, mean values and standard deviation
in the tables, and the groups were compared using the Chi-square test and Fisher's exact test.
While the scores obtained from the scales at the pre-test and post-test were compared with the
independent sample t-test, the mean scores of participants in the intervention and control
groups at pre-test and post-test were compared using the paired t test. For the significance
3. Results
intervention and control groups. Some 48.7% in the intervention group and 57.7% in the
PT
control group were under 35 years of age. The participants in both groups had similar
characteristics in terms of their mean age, marital status, educational status, place of residence
RI
and employment status (p>0.05). Forty-one percent in the intervention group and 25.6% in the
control group had a good level of income. The difference between the two groups was
SC
statistically significant (p<0.05). Thirty-four percent in the intervention group, and 33.3% in
U
the control group were admitted to the hospital complaining of bleeding. The reasons why
AN
participants in both groups presented to the hospital were similar (p>0.05).
M
D
TE
C EP
AC
ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT
Table 1
n(%) n (%) p
PT
Age
<35 years 38(48.7) 45(57.7) 0.336
RI
≥35 years 40(51.3) 33(42.3)
SC
Marital status
Married 74(94.9) 74(94.9) 1.000
U
Unmarried 4(5.1) 4(5.1)
AN
Education
Primary school 30(38.6) 21(26.9) 0.148
M
Place of residence
Province 49(62.8) 54(69.2) 0.179
District 14(17.9) 17(21.8)
EP
Employment status
C
Table 2 shows that the mean scores the participants in the intervention and control groups
obtained from the State Anxiety Scale before the application were 39.8±5.4 and 38.1±6.0
respectively. The pre-application mean scores the participants in the intervention and control
groups obtained from the state anxiety scale was similar (p>0.05). The post-application mean
PT
scores of the participants in the intervention and control groups obtained from the State
RI
Anxiety Scale were 37.0±5.2 and 46.8±3.2 respectively. The difference between the mean
SC
Table 2 indicates that the mean pre- and post-application state anxiety scores of the
participants in the intervention group were 39.8±5.4 and 37.0±5.2 respectively, and the
U
difference between the mean scores was statistically significant (p<0.05). The mean pre- and
AN
post-application state anxiety scores of the participants in the control group were 38.1±6.0 and
M
46.8±3.2 respectively, and the difference between the mean scores was statistically significant
(p<0.05).
D
Table 2
TE
Distribution of the mean scores the participants in the intervention and control groups
EP
obtained from the State Anxiety Scale before and after the application.
Mean Scores of Scale Intervention Group (n= 78) Control Group (n= 78)
C
X±SD X±SD t/ p
AC
participating women. While the mean VAS score of the intervention group who stated that
they suffered pain during the gynecological examination was 1.5±0.9, it was 5.6±1.8 for their
counterparts in the control group. The difference between the VAS scores was statistically
significant (p<0.05).
PT
Table 3
RI
Distribution of the gynecological examination-related mean VAS scores of the participants in
SC
VAS Scores Intervention Group (n= 35) Control Group (n= 51)
U
X±SD X±SD t/ p
1.5±0.9 5.6±1.8 11.805/0.000
AN
M
The correlation between the mean scores obtained by the women participating in the study
from the VAS and the State Anxiety Scale after the gynecological examination is given in
D
Table 4. The correlation between the mean scores obtained by the participants in the
TE
Table 4
EP
Correlation between the mean scores obtained by the women participating in the study from
C
the VAS and the State Anxiety Scale after gynecological examination.
AC
r p
Intervention Group (n=35) VAS 0.464 0.005
Gynecological examination is a process causing anxiety for women [2,3]. In this present
study, the state anxiety levels of the women in the intervention and control groups before the
gynecological examination were similar and mild (p<0.05). In studies conducted by Demiray
and colleagues [15], Kocabas and Khorshid [6] and Erbil and colleagues [16], women’s
PT
anxiety levels before gynecological examinations were moderate. The results of the studies
RI
indicate that although the gynecological examination takes a short time, it leads to negative
feelings at different levels in many women. A woman’s negative experience might prevent
SC
her from having a further examination. In order to protect women’s health, it is essential to
perform gynecological examinations without causing discomfort and to ensure that women
U
treat gynecological examinations like any other examinations. Therefore, to reduce the
AN
participants’ anxiety, different methods such as playing music, special clothing, relaxation
M
techniques have been implemented and these methods have been determined to reduce
In the present study, the lavender scent used during gynecological examination reduced
TE
anxiety.
The use of lavender scent during a gynecological examination helps women undergo a
EP
more positive examination process. On the other hand, the state anxiety level of the
participants in the control group was mild before the examination but increased to moderate
C
AC
after the examination. In many studies, women reported moderate levels of anxiety owed to
[2,3,16,21,22]. The results of those studies are consistent with those of the present study.
In different studies, lavender scent has been found to have positive effects on anxiety, pain
and depression levels [7,11,23-37]. Lavender scent and/or oil was used by Itai and colleagues
[27] for anxiety disorders, by Graham and colleagues [34] before radiotherapy, by Louis and
ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT
Kowalski [33] for pain, anxiety and depression in hospitalized patients, by Buckle [23] and
Braden and colleagues [11] prior to surgery, by Hoya and colleagues [28] prior to gastroscopy
and by Lehrner and colleagues [35] in a dental clinic, and they all reported that it reduced
anxiety levels.
In the present study, it was found that the pain suffered by the participants in the control
PT
group during examination (5.5±1.8) was about three times greater than that suffered by the
RI
participants in the intervention group (1.5±0.9), and that lavender scent was effective on pain.
In the intervention group, as the state anxiety score decreased so did the VAS score. State
SC
anxiety is a temporary emotional state characterized by subjective tension, feelings of anxiety
U
intervention which takes place at a particular time, during which different feelings are
AN
experienced, the result of the present study supports this theoretical knowledge.
M
5. Conclusion
D
Given the result of this study that lavender scent reduced anxiety and pain suffered during
TE
Authors' contribution
C
Nilufer Tugut: Study design, data analysis, data interpretation and drafting of the manuscript.
AC
Gulbahtiyar Demirel: Study design, data collection, data interpretation, critical revision of the
References
PT
the gynaecologic examination: Factors associated with discomfort, A.O.G.S. 82(11)
RI
(2003) 1030−1036.
[2] J.D. Huber, C.F. Pukall, S.C. Boyer, E.D. Reissing, S.M. Chamberlain, Physicians
SC
experiences with women who are difficult or impossible to examine gynaecologically, J.
U
[3] H. Grundström, K. Wallin, C. Berterö, You expose yourself in so many ways: Young
AN
women's experiences of pelvic examination, J.P.O.G. 32(2) (2011) 59−64.
M
[5] C.K. Bates, N. Carroll, J. Potter, The challenging pelvic examination, J. Gen. Intern Med.
TE
and music in reducing the anxiety related to gynaecological examination, J.C.N. 21(5-6)
(2012) 791−799.
C
AC
[7] N. Motomura, A. Sakurai, Y. Yotsuya, Reduction of mental stress with lavender odorant,
lavender essential oil, C.R. Seances Soc. Biol. Ses Fil. 183 (1989) 342−348.
[11] R. Braden, S. Reichow, M. Halm, The use of the essential oil lavandin to reduce
(2009) 348−355.
PT
[12] C. Spielberger, Theory and Research in Anxiety, In C.D. Spielberger (Ed.), Anxiety and
RI
Behavior Academic Press, New York, 1966.
SC
Publications, Istanbul, 1998.
[14] M.E. Wewers, N.K. Lowe, A critical review of visual analogue scales in the measurement
U
of clinical phenomena, Research in Nursing & Health. 13 (1990) 227−236.
AN
[15] A. Demiray, K.E. Akin, K. Çevik, L. Khorshid, M.S. Yücebilgin, A comparison of the
M
[16] N. Erbil, A. Sengul, N. Ergul, Determining the attitudes and anxiety levels of Turkish
TE
women before gynecological examination, Journal of Human Sciences. 5(1) (2008) 1−13.
[17] D. Sarpkaya, G. Vural, Use of the gynecological examination of the four ways of
EP
[18] K. Sand-Jecklin, Patient anxiety levels related to gynecologic examinations: Use of the
240−242.
[21] B. Altay, B. Kefeli, Some factors affecting the anxiety level of women coming for
PT
University. 5(4) (2012) 134−141.
RI
[22] N. Tugut, Z. Golbasi, Aspects of emotional and physical discomfort in gynecologic
SC
Research. 40(6) (2014) 1777−1784.
U
[24] L.W. Chien, S.L. Cheng, C.F. Liu, The effect of lavender aromatherapy on autonomic
AN
nervous system in midlife women with insomnia, Evidence-Based Complementary and
M
[25] P. Conrad, C. Adams, The effects of clinical aromatherapy for anxiety and depression in
D
the high risk postpartum woman - A pilot study, Complementary Therapies in Clinical
TE
217−224.
[29] J.T. Kim, C.J. Ren, G.A. Fielding, A. Pitti, T. Kasumi, M. Wajda, A. Lebovits, A.
Bekker, Treatment with lavender aromatherapy in the post-anesthesia care unit reduces
PT
opioid requirements of morbidly obese patients undergoing laparoscopic adjustable
RI
gastric banding, Obesity Surgery. 17(7) (2007) 920−925.
[30] P.H. Koulivand, M.K. Ghadiri, A. Gorji, Lavender and the nervous system, Evidence-
SC
based Complementary and Alternative Medicine. (2013) 1−10.
U
aromatherapy on the quality of sleep in ischemic heart disease patients hospitalized in
AN
intensive care units of heart hospitals of the Isfahan University of Medical Sciences,
M
[32] W.S. MPham, W. Siripornpanich, The effects of lavender oil inhalation on emotional
D
states, autonomic nervous system, and brain electrical activity, J. Med. Assoc. Thai. 95(4)
TE
(2012) 1−10.
[33] M. Louis, S. Kowalski, Use of aromatherapy with hospice patients to decrease pain,
EP
anxiety, and depression and to promote an increased sense of well-being, Am. J. Hosp.
[35] J. Lehrner, L. Marwinski, L. Johren, L. Deecke, Ambient odors of orange and lavender
reduce anxiety and improve mood in a dental Office, Physiology & Behavior. 86 (2005)
92−95.
ACCEPTED MANUSCRIPT
[36] P. Sasannejad, M. Saeedi, A. Shoeibi, A. Gorji, M. Abbasi, M. Foroughipour, Lavender
PT
autonomic nervous system, and brain electrical activity, Journal of the Medical
RI
Association of Thailand. 95 (2012) 598−606.
[38] O.R. Kutanis, T. Tunc, The relationship between state and trait with self-esteem in
SC
nurses: a university hospital case, Industrial Relations and Human Resources Journal.
U
AN
M
D
TE
C EP
AC