Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
Abstract
Supercritical CO2 extraction of essential oils is one of the most widely discussed applications in the supercritical
fluid literature. Nevertheless, a comprehensive overview of the‘analytical, processing and modeling aspects has never
been attempted. This is partly due to the difficulties involved in isolating essential oils from the other products which
supercritical COZ can dissolve. Moreover, only a limited number of studies provide quantitative data on the parameters
governing this process.
In this review, solubility data on pure compounds belonging to essential oils are’analyzed. Processes proposed to
isolate and fractionate essential oils by supercritical CO1 and the corresponding modelling aspects are discussed
critically. 0 1997 Elsevier Science B.V.
An ‘absolute’ is a liquid product obtained by post- some cases, like the post-processing of citrus essen-
processing a concrete with ethanol and subse- tial oils, liquid feeds are used. The treatment of
quently removing the solvent. A ‘volatile oil’ is a liquid feeds requires different experimental systems
liquid product obtained by post-processing a con- as compared to solid feeds. Another classification
crete by steam distillation. An ‘essential oil’ can of SFE systems with respect to their use is the
be defined as the volatile material present in plants batch, semi-continuous or continuous processing
[l]. As a rule, it consists of a complex mixture of of the raw material.
terpenes, oxygenated terpenes, sesquiterpenes and
oxygenated sesquiterpenes. Essential oils can also 2.1. Processing of solid matrices
contain diterpenes and some specific compounds
which cannot be classified as belonging to any of In batch processing, the solid is placed in the
the above-mentioned compound families. Other extraction vessel and then the supercritical solvent
compounds which can be extracted from vegetable is fed in until the target extraction conditions are
matter and can be found in concretes, absolutes reached. Contact between the solvent and the
and oleoresins are fatty acids and fatty acid methyl matrix is maintained for a considerable time (up
esters (FAMES), coloring matters (p-carotene),
to several hours), since this kind of operation is
coumarins, psoralens, sterols and flavones.
aimed at reaching the equilibrium composition.
CO, is the supercritical solvent of choice in the
Care should be taken to avoid pressure and tem-
extraction of fragrance compounds, since it is non-
perature variations during the contacting time, and
toxic and allows supercritical operation at rela-
tively low pressures and near room temperature. also the precipitation of the solute phase outside
Generally speaking, supercritical CO2 behaves like the sampling device.
a lipophilic solvent but, compared to liquid This approach is similar to that used for solubil-
solvents, it has the advantage that its selectivity or ity measurements (analytical method), but it is of
solvent power is adjustable and can be set to values limited value if the extractable material shows an
ranging from gas-like to liquid-like. affinity with the insoluble matrix. The driving force
SFE of flavors and fragrances has been reviewed for the process will be the equilibrium concen-
previously by Stahl et al. [2], by Moyler [ 31, and tration of solutes between the solid and the fluid
by Kerrola [4]. These authors provide overviews phases rather than the solubility of the pure com-
with the emphasis only on the analytical aspects pounds in the fluid phase. Moreover, many solutes
of the problem. A comprehensive study of the are extracted simultaneously, and one has to
influence of the process parameters and the mathe- hypothesize that they do not influence each other.
matical models proposed in SFE of fragrance Lastly, since not all the solute can be extracted,
compounds is lacking. sampling from the fluid phase does not provide a
This review is aimed at providing a critical measure of the true composition of the soluble
analysis of the works published recently on SFE matter contained in the matrix.
of essential oils and other related products. It is In semi-batch processing, which is widely
organized as follows: Section 2 deals with experi- employed, raw materials are charged into the
mental methods, while Section 3 deals with equilib- extraction vessel to obtain a fixed bed of particles.
rium data in supercritical CO,. Solid feed The supercritical solvent is fed continuously by a
processing and mathematical modeling are dealt high-pressure pump at a fixed flow rate. One or
with in Section 4, while Section 5 looks at liquid more separation stages are used to precipitate the
feed processing. Conclusions and perspevtives are solute from the supercritical solution. These sys-
presented in Section 6. tems typically use extractors from 0.1 to 2 dm3 on
the laboratory scale and from 2 to 50 dm3 on the
2. Experimental methods pilot scale. In larger systems the solvent is recycled,
as in the pilot plant shown schematically in Fig. 1.
The vegetable material used for the extraction In this case, the last separation stage has to be
of volatile compounds is normally solid, but in maintained at suitable pressure and temperature
E. Reverchon /Journal of Supercritical Fluids 10 (1997) I-37 3
Fig. 1. Schematic representation of a pilot plant (extractor 20 dm’) used for SFE plus fractional separation of essential oils. 1, high-
pressure pump; 2, heater; 3, extractor; 4. heater; 5. separator; 6, cyclonic separators; 7, cooler; 8. CO* condenser; 9, CO, make-up.
conditions to condense the solvent to the liquid plant, four separation stages are used in series.
state to facilitate subsequent recompression. The last three separators are patented cyclonic
Different process implementations have been separation vessels [ 61.
attempted starting from the case of single-stage Micro SFE devices, which are commercially
extraction and separation. Multi-stage extraction available, are also used. These are primarily
can be carried out by operating at increasing designed for analytical purposes and are fre-
solvent densities. Moreover, it is possible to precip- quently connected to analytical devices like gas
itate part of the solute by varying the temperature chromatographs (GC), gas chromatograph-mass
instead of using a decompression stage [ 2,5]. Fig. 2 spectrometers (GC-MS), or supercritical fluid
shows some of the process schemes which can be chromatographs (SFC). These instruments use
applied during separation. However, only a few extraction vessels which can range from 0.1 cm3
authors have provided some insight into the to several hundred cm3. As a rule, they can operate
problems associated with the separation stages in in both batch and semi-batch modes, and are
supercritical fluid processing [6,7] ,&even though equipped with one separation/decompression
the arrangement of the separation stages can be stage. Very small quantities of raw material can
the key step towards successful SFE process be used, but this can be both and advantage and
implementation. a disadvantage. Indeed, small quantities of the
Fractional separation’ capabilities are particu- starting material ‘imply low operation costs, but
larly useful in laboratory systems where maximum also very small quantities of extract. For example,
processing flexibility is required. Nevertheless, a 100 mg sample containing only 1% of essential
industrial plants can also benefit from multi-stage oils by weight yields a maximum extract of only
operation. Fig. 3 shows a photograph of a 1 mg. Therefore, particular caution is required in
4 x 300 dm3 industrial plant used to isolate essen- avoiding product losses, and care is required in
tial oils by SFE and the fractional separation of choosing the extraction time and the organic
the extracts (Essences, Salerno, Italy). In this solvents for product collection,
E. Reverchon / Journal ofSupercritica1 Fluids IO (1997) 1-37
a b
E E
c I d jr--F=&
E
D
Ad E
I
G
0 ls’-
I
Se
32-J
Fig. 2. Different separation processes which can be implemented after the extraction stage. (a) Decompression, (b) temperature
variation, (c) adsorption, (d) antisolvent addition.
Fig. 3. Industrial plant for the SFE of essential oils by extraction and fractional separation. The plant consists of 4 x 300 dm3
extractors and several separation stages in series (Essences, Salerno, Italy).
E. Reverchon /Journal of Supercritical Fluids 10 (1997) l-37 5
available. Solubility data are obtained by adopting the methyl and ethyl esters of fatty acids
different experimental methods. The most widely [24,39,40], and of tryglycerides [22,23,35,36,41].
used methods are the so-called static-analytic, Other compounds of interest, such as long-chain
static-synthetic and dynamic methods. In the static alcohols, were studied by Yau and Tsai [20]; the
methods, the compounds are placed within a closed solubilities of a-tocopherol, p-carotene and capsa-
volume, and equilibrium conditions are obtained icin were studied by Ohgaki et al. [35], Sakaki
by waiting for a suitable time. In the dynamic [25] and Knez and Steiner [42], respectively. The
method, the supercritical solvent flows through the solubility of water in supercritical CO, was studied
solute and very long contacting times are estab- by Chrastil [23].
lished in the system, so that near-equilibrium con- Solubility data of some compounds have been
ditions can be obtained. The difference between reported by more than one author. For example,
the analytic method and the synthetic method is limonene solubilities have been reported by four
that in the former, at equilibrium, a small sample different groups [2,17-191, but the results are not
of the two phases is drawn and then the condensed always consistent. Particularly interesting is the
part is determined by weighing the sample flasks. representation given by Matos et al. [ 191 reported
When using the synthetic method, no samples are in Fig. 5, where the phase equilibria of binary
removed and the detection of a phase transition is systems consisting of supercritical CO, and limo-
obtained by observing the inner part of the equilib- nene and supercritical CO2 and l-8 cineole are
rium cell. A detailed discussion of these methods, shown. It appears that these terpenes are com-
their merits and their defects has been published pletely miscible in supercritical CO2 at 50°C for
recently [ 91. pressures above 98 bar.
Solubility data are reported in the form of tables Data on other compounds of interest, like some
or diagrams. As a rule, interpolation of this data coumarins and psoralens, are not included in
is performed using cubic equations of state (EOS). Table 1 since only the apparent solubility threshold
The most widely used are the Peng and Robinson in supercritical CO2 is available in the literature
(PR) [lo], Redlich and Kwong (RK) [ll] and [431*
Soave (SRK) [ 121 EOS. More complex non-cubic Some authors studied phase equilibria, extrac-
EOS are also available and are sometimes used tion selectivities and solubilities of citrus essential
(such as those proposed by Bender [13] and oils or of key compound mixtures in supercritical
Carnahan and Starling [ 141). Care should be taken CO,. Robey and Sunder [44] separated a cold-
when extrapolating this data, since extrapolation pressed lemon oil into its terpene and flavor frac-
yields only qualitative results. tions and described the results through a density-
A selection of solubility data on the pure com- dependent local-composition equation of state.
pounds frequently found in essential oils is given Kalra et al. [45] produced phase equilibrium data
in Table 1. The same table also reports the solubili- for the system lemon oil-CO, and a model mixture
ties of some undesired compounds and of particu- (75% limonene and 25% citral)-CO, system in the
lar compounds found in vegetable matter. Table 1 temperature range 49.8-8 1°C and at pressures
does not provide an exhaustive list of all the data ranging between 95 and 106 bar. They used a static
available in the literature. Moreover, since the data method to obtain the data. Coppella and Barton
in the literature cover different pressure and tem- [46] studied the vapor-liquid equilibrium of
perature ranges, direct comparisons are not easy. lemon-peel oil at 30-40°C and 40-90 bar. They
Therefore, to compare the data at pre-set values described the phase equilibria by treating the
of temperature and pressure, it is necessary to system as a CO,-limonene binary mixture and by
carry out graphical interpolations or calculations using the Peng-Robinson equation of state [lo].
by interpolating equations. Temelli et al. [47] extracted hydrocarbon terpenes
Further information is available in the literature by supercritical CO, from cold-pressed orange oil
on the solubilities in supercritical COZ of terpenes using a dynamic flow system. At the experimental
and related compounds [2,17-19,26-291, of par- conditions studied, hydrocarbon terpenes were sol-
affins [21,3&32], of fatty acids [22,23,33-381, of ubilized to a greater extent than oxygenated com-
E. Reverchon /Journal of Supercritical Fluids IO (1997) 1-37
Table 1
Solubility data in supercritical CO2 of some pure compounds contained in essential oils. Solubilities are expressed as mg gg’
decreasing terpene content in the mixture. They Goto et al. [51] in the case of l-menthol as a pure
also evaluated the selectivity of the fractionation compound to be solubilized in supercritical CO1
process between terpenes and oxygenated com- and as one of the compounds extracted from pep-
pounds. Furthermore, selectivity increased when permint leaves by supercritical CO2 at 40, 60 and
the terpene content was lower. 80°C and at pressures between about 80 and
‘Some general considerations can be drawn from 250 bar. Krishna Sastri [ 521 showed that during the
the solubility data of the typical compounds SFE of jasmine flowers, the solubility of the pure
extractable from vegetable matter. At low CO, key compounds was more than one order of magni-
densities (T= 40-50°C p = 80-90 bar), terpenes tude greater than the extract loading of the super-
are one or more orders of magnitude more soluble critical COZ during the processing of the vegetable
than paraffins and fatty acids. The other families matter. This data confirms the existence of a parti-
of compounds show negligible solubilities. At high tion factor between two phases in contact.
COZ densities (T=40-50°C p = 100-200 bar), ter- Solubility information is useful to establish
penes and oxygenated terpenes are completely whether or not a compound can be solubilized by
miscible in supercritical COZ, and the solubilities supercritical CO2 at a given condition. Indeed, the
of many other compound families pass from appre- larger the compound solubility at a given extrac-
ciable to very high. Water deserves a particular tion condition, the more favorable the correspond-
mention. It is always present when natural matter ing desorption isotherm or phase equilibrium curve
is processed (even when previously dried). will be.
Therefore its solubility in supercritical CO, is In conclusion, the analysis of solubility data
particularly important in determining the possi- indicates that low CO, densities should be a good
bility of water cosolvent effects during SFE. All in choice to extract volatile compounds selectively as
all, the solubility data suggest that selective SFE compared to higher molecular-weight compounds.
processing of essential oils has to be performed at However, knowledge of the relative solubilities of
40-50°C and at pressures below 100 bar. Indeed, all extractable compounds does not provide all the
the selectivity of the process should be very high information necessary to perform the SFE process.
only in this range of operating conditions. Mass transfer mechanisms and their possible
Solubility data can be used directly to evaluate different effects on various compound families also
the possibility of extracting compounds only in have to be taken into account if the process is
the case in which the solutes to be extracted have governed by internal mass transfer resistance.
no affinity with the insoluble matrix. If the com- Therefore, the selection of process conditions is
pounds to be extracted are adsorbed on the solid more complex than the mere*determination of the
matrix or contained inside a complex solid struc- solubility data.
ture, different equilibrium relationships have to be
applied. In the case of desorption from a solid
matrix, desorption isotherms are required to evalu- 4. Solid-feed processing and mathematical
ate the relative concentration in the solid and fluid modelling
phases. When solutes are located inside a complex
vegetable structure, phase equilibrium can be The study of the SFE of flavors and fragrances
established between the two phases. At the solid- can be broadly divided into three steps, i.e. : (1)
fluid interface, the solid phase and the fluid phase chemical and organoleptic characterization of the
solute concentrations are related through an equi- extracts, (2) evaluation of the influence of process
librium isotherm. Some information is available in parameters, and (3) mathematical modelling.
the literature for the extraction of [6]-ginger01 An accurate chemical characterization is
from ginger rhizomes from Spiro and Kandiah [50], required, since essential oils are as a rule made up
which produced the partition factor for this system of tens or hundreds of compounds. Their analysis
in supercritical COZ. An example of the difference cannot be reduced to the identification of some
between the solubility data of the pure compound key compounds since the presence and the concen-
and extraction from a natural structure is given by tration of several specific compounds can signifi-
E. Reverchorz 1 Journal ofSupercritica1 Fluids 10 (1997) I-37 9
cal CO2 have been published. Particularly useful 19 to 24% by weight. In a later work, the same
are the reviews by Stahl et al. [2] and Moyler [3]. author optimized the SFE of black pepper oleoresin
They provide comprehensive lists of the vegetable [67]. The best composition was obtained at 280 bar
matter treated by SFE. Table 2 can be regarded as and 55°C with a piperine content of over 50%. In
an updated list covering the literature up to the that case, essential oil was coextracted together with
beginning of 1995. piperine and fixed oil. Thus, Sankar concluded that
Nykanen et al. [ 541 performed a detailed analysis the best selectivity (i.e. the selective extraction of
of angelica root compounds extracted by supercrit- essential oil versus undesired compounds) was
ical CO*. They analyzed the extracts obtained at obtained when supercritical COZ was used at condi-
40°C and under increasing pressure. A summary tions near the critical point.
of their results is given in Table 3, where the Verschuere et al. [ 691 fractionated supercritical
percentages of the various compound families are CO, extracts obtained from hops by performing
reported. Terpenes and sesquiterpenes constituted successive extractions at increasing CO2 densities.
the major constituents of angelica root oil. Some They started at 0.2 g cmp3 and performed several
coumarins and psoralens were also found. The extraction tests on the same sample up to
miscellaneous compounds in Table 3 were mainly 0.9 g cme3. In this manner, they were able to
paraffins. From this data it is evident that the separate the essential oil from the bitter principals
content of non-volatile compounds in supercritical of hops (e.g. humulones and lupulones).
CO2 extracts of angelica root increases significantly Another (albeit qualitative) indication that the
with extraction pressure. Particularly, coumarins composition of supercritical CO2 extracts changes
and psoralens contents are 7% at 80 bar and 50% with extraction pressure was given by Guinamant
at 200 bar. At this latter pressure, the overall [911,who extracted essential oil from Tsuga
content of undesired compounds is 66%. Canadiensis leaves. He analyzed materials
Moreover, it is very interesting to note the compar- extracted at CO, densities of 0.25, 0.40, 0.60 and
ison made by these authors with the product 0.80 g cmm3, and noted the progressive appearance
obtained by steam distillation of angelica root. of high molecular-weight compounds (mainly dit-
The percentage of the various compound families erpenes) in the extract at increasing COZ density.
in the steam-distilled product was similar to the Gopalakrishnan and Narayanan 1571 tested the
extracts obtained by SFE at 80 and 90 bar. extraction of cardamom-seed essential oil in the
The problem of essential oil contamination by temperature range 40-60°C and at pressures rang-
undesired high molecular-weight compounds was ing from 100 to 600 bar. They found an increase
also noted by Sankar [93] during the SFE of black in non-volatile compounds with pressure, from a
pepper. He tested various extraction pressures (from minimum of 4.5% at 100 bar to a maximum of
80 to 100 bar) and temperatures (from 40 to 6O”C), 9.5% at 500 bar. Their conclusion was that the
and found that at 100 bar and 60°C the pungent best operating conditions were at the lowest pres-
principal (piperine) was not recovered. Operating sure (i.e. 100 bar).
at 100 bar and 40°C the oil also contained some Reverchon et al. [83] conducted a comparison
monoglycerides. Evaporation residues ranged from of the SFE of peppermint leaves at two different
Table 3
Composition of angelica root extracts obtained by SFE at 40°C and at various pressure conditions and by steam distillation (SD)
(adapted from Ref. [54])
SFE SD
extraction conditions: 90 bar and 50°C and Similar structures can also be proposed for other
120 bar and 40°C. On increasing the CO2 density, vegetable matters. Therefore, allowances should
oxygenated monoterpenes in the extracts decreased also be made for the different mass transfer mecha-
from 84.4% to 72.7%, whereas sesquiterpenes nisms which operate during wax and essential oil
increased from 4.6% to 13.2%. Moreover, the extraction. Waxes have no affinity with the other
coextraction of waxes increased from about 10% parts of the leaf surface, and thus they are extracted
to 30% by weight compared to the yield of pepper- with very limited mass transfer resistances in the
mint essential oil. solid phase. Therefore, if the residence time of the
The coextraction of undesired compounds supercritical solvent is sufficiently long, their con-
during SFE of essential oil was also noted by centration in the supercritical solution at the exit
Kerrola and Kallio [63] during supercritical and of the extractor could be near the thermodynamic
liquid COZ extraction of coriander fruit. In the value. Therefore, even when higher molecular-
products extracted at 90 bar and 40°C these weight compounds are not coextracted, SFE pro-
authors identified some fatty acids, FAMES and ducts are more similar to a concrete than to an
high molecular-weight hydrocarbons. Oszagyan essential oil. In contrast, essential oil compounds
et al. [77] also observed the presence of waxes and show very large solubilities or complete miscibility
resins in SFE of various herbs. in supercritical COZ, but larger mass transfer resist-
Globally, experimental results show that at ances in the solid phase characterize their extrac-
extraction temperatures between 40 and 50°C and tion process. As a result, essential oil extraction
at extraction pressures lower than 100 bar, higher can be controlled by mass transfer mechanisms.
molecular-weight compounds are not coextracted The problem of the coextraction of waxes can
with essential oil. Indeed, at these operating condi- be solved by introducing fractional separation of
tions their solubilities are negligible, as shown the extracts. This technique consists of a separation
in Table 1. of the compounds contained in the supercritical
Paraffinic compounds were found in the extracts solution by operating two or more separators in
at all process conditions, even when the pure series. The separators are set at different pressure
compound solubility data indicated that their solu- and temperature conditions to precipitate the
bilities in supercritical CO2 were very low. This extracted compounds selectively. Indeed, when
result can be explained by observing the schematic both the essential oil and the waxes are in the
representation of the leaf structure shown in Fig. 6 supercritical solution, no mass transfer resistance
[ 791. Waxes are located on the leaf’s surface, where is present and only solubility conditions apply.
they exert a controlling role on its perspiration. Therefore, it is possible to use the solubility data
Essential oil compounds are preferably located to choose the appropriate separation conditions.
inside the cellular structure in vacuoles [94]. This process arrangement was first proposed by
Stahl and co-workers [2,95] for various vegetable
waxes matters. It takes advantage of the different solubili-
ties exhibited by paraffins and terpenes at temper-
atures of around 0°C in liquid COZ. At these
cuol es
- conditions, the solubility of paraffins is near to
zero. In contrast, terpenes are completely miscible
at these conditions. Therefore, paraffins larger
than CZs, solubilized during supercritical extrac-
tion, can be precipitated in the first separator set
at about 0°C whereas essential oil compounds will
be collected in the second separator, where a large
Fig. 6. A schematic representation of the leaf structure. The
pressure reduction induces the passage of CO, to
locations of cuticular waxes and vacuoles are shown (adapted the gaseous state.
from Ref. [79]). The efficiency of the fractional separation
12 E. Reverchon 1 Journal of Supercritical Fluids 10 (1997) 1-37
process was demonstrated by Reverchon and tions in the last stage were modified to allow for
Senatore [86] when they isolated rosemary essen- COz recirculation. Based on the laboratory and
tial oil. They operated SFE at 100 bar and 40°C pilot-plant studies, an industrial-scale plant with
and used a single-stage and a two-stage separation 4 x 300 dm3 extractors has been built, and has been
procedure. Tests performed using single-stage sepa- in operation since the beginning of 1996. It was
ration produced a concrete-like extract (see Fig. 7 constructed by Fedegari (Pavia, Italy) and is being
for the GC trace of this extract). Fractionation used by Essences (Salerno, Italy). Fig. 3 is a photo-
was performed by setting the first separator at graph of this industrial system.
80 bar and 10°C and the second separator at 25 bar A fractional separation technique was also used
and 0°C. The separation procedure allowed the by Yonei et al. [96] to divide supercritical fluid
isolation of the pure rosemary oil, while in the extracts of ginger into pungent principles (mainly
first separator a nearly odorless white mass con- represented by [6]-gingerol) and essential oil. They
sisting of waxes was collected. Another example operated extraction at 246 bar and 40°C. The first
of fractional separation is shown in Fig. 8, where separation stage was tested at various pressures
GC traces of basil essential oil and waxes are ranging from 79 to 109 bar, and at 60°C. The
reported [ 561. The same procedure was used suc- second separation stage was kept constant at
cessfully in SFE of marjoram leaves [79]. In this 45 bar and 30°C. According to these authors, the
case, the efficiency of the fractionation at various quantity of pungent principles recovered in the
operating conditions was also reported. The range first separator increased with pressure, whereas
of separation conditions explored was from 80 to the separation selectivity decreased.
90 bar and from 0 to - 30°C. Fractional separation
was also adopted for the isolation of essential oils 4.1.2. Comparison between liquid and supercritical
from SFE products for peppermint [83], chamo- CO2 extracts
mile [58] and lavender [76]. An example of the Taking as a starting point the discussion on the
detailed identification of waxes is given in Table 4 fractional separation of the supercritical extract,
for chamomile. In this case, paraffins and small one can deduce that if extraction is performed by
quantities of olefins were found. More generally, liquid COz, the problem of the coextraction of
the waxes coextracted consist of odd carbon-atom waxes will be alleviated or resolved. It is true that
paraffins ranging between Czs and &. SFE plus liquid CO2 extracts very low quantities of paraffins,
fractional separation was replicated in a pilot-scale particularly when the extraction temperature is
apparatus designed on the basis of the laboratory near 0°C. This temperature coincides with that
results. It was operated at the same extraction suggested for fractional separation. However, the
conditions as in the laboratory unit, and could use density of liquid CO, ranges between 0.8 and
up to three separation stages. Separation condi- 1.1 g cm-3 under commonly used extraction condi-
tions, and it exhibits a very high solvent power
towards all lipophilic compounds contained in
vegetable matter. Its selectivity is low. Indeed,
liquid CO2 coextracts large percentages of high
I
molecular weight compounds, as shown by the
experimental data. For example, Bestmann et al.
[97] used liquid CO, in a Soxhlet-like apparatus
to extract essential oil from thyme leaves. The
authors carried out a detailed analysis of the
extracts, which contained about 28% paraffins and
l- fatty acids. Chen and Ho [98], during liquid CO,
Fig. 7. GC trace of rosemary concrete-like extract obtained by
extraction of ginger, found up to 67% of non-
SFE at 100 bar and 40°C. No fractional separation was per- volatile matter constituted by pungent principles
formed (adapted from Ref. [SS]). and unidentified components. Kallio and Kerrola
E. Reverchon /Journal of Supercritical Fluids 10 f 1997) 1-37
_ A
1. I
*
4800 6fiKI 8&3
33:2El 66:4@ 1ee:ea 133:20
B
TOT-
1.
Fig. 8. GC traces of basil essential oil (A) and basil waxes (B) obtained by SFE at 100 bar and 40°C plus fractional separation of
the extracts. I, linalool; 2, estragol; 3, methyl eugenol; 4, nonacosane; 5, entriacontane; 6, tritriacontane (adapted from Ref. [56]).
[62] used liquid CO, to extract volatile oil from hydrocarbon content (13.5%) than in steam-dis-
coriander fruits. They operated at 47 and 54 bar tilled oil (20%). FAMES and fatty acids were 1.1%
and at 25°C and at 69 bar and 45°C in a Soxhlet- in steam-distilled oil, and ranged from 5.4 to 17.5%
like apparatus, and found a lower monoterpene at the different liquid CO2 conditions used. These
14 E. Reverchon /Journal of Supercritical Fluids 10 (1997) 1-37
3
TO'
Fig. 9. Comparison of GC traces of lavender essential oil obtained by SFE at 90 bar and 50°C with fractional separation (A) and
steam distillation (B). 1, 1-8 cineole; 2, linalool; 3, linalyl acetate (adapted from Ref. [76]).
ble matter with supercritical CO2 at densities absolute, respectively. Obviously, these techniques
greater than 0.6 g cmW3 if only a single separation induce thermal degradation and solvent contami-
stage is used to recover the extracted fractions. A naton of the products. Therefore, some authors
concrete contains fragrance-related compounds, attempted the fractionation of concretes by liquid
but also undesired compounds like fatty acids or supercritical CO2 extraction.
and their methyl esters, diterpenes and other Gopalakrishnan and Narayanan [ 571 proposed
high molecular-weight lipophilic compounds. post-processing of jasmine concrete by liquid
Moreover, high quantities of paraffins (50-70% COZ. They mixed clean white sand with jasmine
by weight) are present in the concretes. A concrete concrete at 55-60°C and treated this mixture at
can be post-processed by steam distillation or ethyl 100 bar and 20°C with 30 min of contacting time
alcohol solubilization to obtain a volatile oil or an before releasing the supercritical solution into a
E. Reverchon /Journal of Supercritical Fluids 10 (1997) 1-37 11
single-stage separator. The product was highly tage 2.7%). No other high molecular-weight com-
viscous due to the coextraction of volatile com- pounds were extracted. No paraffins polluted the
pounds and high quantities of waxes. The wax volatile oil because they were completely precipi-
content in the extract increased with the number tated in the first separator. The oil yield relative
of extractions performed on the same charge of to this step of the process was 17.3% by weight of
concrete. Moreover, their extracts contained from the charge. Organoleptic analysis classified the
about 13 to 20% of FAMES. product as top-notes jasmine. The second extrac-
Sankar [67] attempted jasmine concrete frac- tion step, performed at 85 bar, produced a liquid
tionation using supercritical CO, at 100 bar and extract with a high content of benzyl benzoate
50°C. He did not report the percentage of waxes (28.3%) and phytol (28.6%). Large quantities of
and FAMES in the extracts, but the lower density various FAMES were also extracted (38.0% over-
adopted in the SFE process, if compared to the all). The yield of this part of the process was
liquid CO2 process used by Gopalakrishnan and 13.1% by weight, and sensory analysis classified
Narayanan [57], should assure lower paraffin and this product as middle- and bottom-notes jasmine.
FAME contents. The yield of jasmine absolute The last extraction step at 200 bar produced an
was also reported as a function of the mass of odorless liquid fraction; a very small percentage
CO2 used (see Fig. 10). of fragrance compounds were found, whereas
Reverchon et al. [74] developed a concrete frac- FAMES were at 83.1%. The yield of this step was
tionation process in which SFE was coupled with 18% by weight. The authors concluded that mixing
fractional separation of the extracts. They pro- the fractions obtained during the first two steps of
cessed a jasmine concrete mixed with 2 mm glass the process showed the best overall reproduction
beads in three successive steps at 40°C and at of the jasmine fragrance. Thus, the yield of jasmine
pressures of 80,85 and 200 bar. The two separation fragrance was 30.3% globally. Throughout the
stages were set at 80 bar and 0°C and 25 bar and extraction process, the waxes collected in the first
- lO”C, respectively. The extraction step per- separator were 14% by weight of the jasmine
formed at 80 bar produced a volatile fraction concrete.
mainly formed by benzyl acetate (62.4%), benzyl Recently, Reverchon and Della Porta [ 1011
benzoate (12.6%) and linalool(l2.3%). Only small adopted a different approach during rose concrete
amounts of FAMES were detected (overall percen- fractionation. In this case, they first ascertained by
GC-MS analysis that rose concrete did not contain
FAMES. Then, they used a one-step SFE process
(80 bar and 40°C) while maintaining the fractional
40-
ol
separation of the products. Separation in this case
ai was the most difficult step of the process owing to
2 30- the presence of low molecular-weight paraffins and
long-chain paraffinic alcohols (steroptens). These
3
2
compounds worsen the quality of rose volatile oil
.c 20 and are very difficult to precipitate in the first
3
._ :il.: separator. Very low temperatures were required in
6 the first separator to obtain their supersaturation
xl 10
3 and precipitation. Indeed, temperatures down to
>
ii
- 16°C were used to precipitate paraffins and
steroptens selectively. The rose oil yield was 49%
by weight of the charged material. A comparison
Carbon dioxide, kg of the SFE volatile oil of rose and the products
Fig. 10. Yield of jasmine absolute obtained by supercritical
obtained by steam distillation and by solubilization
extraction as a function of the total amount of CO, used of the rose concrete in ethyl alcohol was performed
(adapted from Ref. [67]). [ 841. The major differences appeared in the phenyl
18 E. Reverchon /Journal of Supercritical Fluids 10 (1997) 1-37
ethyl alcohol (PEA) content and in the percentages position were also found for extraction times
of paraffins and steroptens. PEA is a characteristic greater than 240 min due to the progressive exhaus-
compound of the rose fragrance; it was present at tion of the lighter compounds and to the conse-
50.0% in the SFE volatile oil, at 10.4% in the quent progressive enrichment of the heavier
steam-distilled oil, and at 28.3% in the alcoholic compounds in SFE extracts. Some tests were per-
solution. Most of the PEA was lost during steam formed on a semi-industral scale using a 20 dm3
distillation since this product is water-soluble. A internal volume extractor. It was charged with
qualitative comparison is also possible from about 2 kg of rose concrete, and produced about
Fig. 11, which reports the GC traces of SFE and 1 kg of rose volatile oil.
steam-distilled rose oil obtained from concrete. An extension of the fractionation processes can
The steam-distilled and solvent-extracted products be proposed for other intermediate products to
also contained 22.7 and 46.4% of paraffins, respec- take advantage of the selectivity of the process
tively, whereas the SFE oil contained only 15.1% and its operation on smaller extraction volumes.
of the lighter paraffins. Steroptens were present at
3.7% in steam-distilled oil, at 3.5% in solvent- 4.1.6. Further comments
extracted oil, and at 2.8% in SFE oil. The extraction of essential oils by supercritical
Large modifications of the rose volatile oil com- CO2 is sometimes carried out under drastic condi-
F
t
Fig. 11. Comparison of GC traces of rose oils obtained from concrete by SFE at 80 bar and 40°C with fractional separation (A)
and by steam distillation (B). 1, phenyl ethyl alcohol; 2, citronellol; 3, phenyl ethyl acetate (from Ref. [84]).
E. Reverchon 1 Journal of Supercritical Flui& 10 (1997) l-37 19
mint leaves, Ozer et al. [ 1031 found that monoter- compounds inside the vegetable matter. According
penes were preferably extracted at the beginning to these results, the monitoring of a single key
of the process, whereas higher molecular-weight compound concentration in the extracts cannot be
compounds were preferably extracted later. representative of the behavior of all the compounds
Kerrola et al. [ 1041 performed supercritical CO2 extracted.
extraction of angelica root at 120 bar and 50°C. Yield curves for the same vegetable matter,
They considered three extract fractions (Fl, F2 although obtained at different extraction pressures
and F3) collected at increasing extraction times. and temperatures, have also been proposed by
Monoterpene hydrocarbons were present at 83% some authors. For example, Sankar and Manohar
and 55% in fractions Fl and F2, respectively, and [ 1051 and Sankar [93] extracted pepper oleoresin
at about only 14% in the F3 fraction. Oxygenated at 80 bar and 40 and 60°C and at 100 bar and 40
monoterpenes and sesquiterpenes were mainly col- and 60°C. This kind of yield curve is of very
lected in the F2 fraction. The highest molecular- limited significance. Indeed, the volatile oil content
weight compounds dominated the third fraction, in a given batch of vegetable matter is fixed. Thus,
which contained about 34% coumarins and pso- if all volatile material is accessible, different extrac-
ralens and 43% fatty acids and other less volatile tion conditions can only yield different extraction
compounds. In this case, many undesired com- rates. The different yields obtained by varying the
pounds were coextracted. Their presence in the extraction conditions therefore depend on the rela-
extracts can be explained by the authors’ choice tive quantities of the undesired compounds which
of too severe extraction conditions. In the SFE of are coextracted.
essential oil from sage leaves, Reverchon et al. [88] If the internal mass transfer mechanisms consti-
monitored the composition of sage essential oil tute the controlling step of the extraction process,
extracted by supercritical CO2 at 90 bar and 50°C the particle size of the vegetable matter and its
against the extraction time. Their results are shown distribution can significantly influence the extrac-
in Fig. 13, in which a large variation of composi- tion time required to obtain a given yield of
tion with extraction time is noted among the essential oil. In this case, extraction at different
different families of componds which constitute particle sizes will largely depend on the length of
sage oil. This behavior can be explained by the the diffusion path. For example, Reverchon and
different diffusion times of the different families of Sesti Osseo [ 1061 reported the influence of particle
size in the case of SFE of basil essential oil.
Moreover, different PSDs produced different
shapes of the yield curve at lower extraction times
and during the approach to the asymptotic yield.
If external mass transfer or equilibrium are the
controlling steps of the process, the particle size
cannot affect the extraction rate by very much.
The solvent flow rate can control extraction if
equilibrium conditions apply or if the external
mass transfer mechanism is the prevailing resis-
tance factor during the extraction process. In con-
trast, if the internal mass transfer resistance
controls the process, there will be a negligible
influence of the solvent flow rate on the kinetics
-0 - 100 200 300 400
of the extraction process (i.e. different CO, flow
t, min rates do not modify the extraction rate; see, for
Fig. 13. Variation of sage oil composition with extraction time.
example, Fig. 14, where two different COZ flow
0, Terpenes; v, oxygenated terpenes; 0, sesquiterpenes; rates produce practically the same extraction rate
W, oxygenated sesquiterpenes (adapted from Ref. [SS]). of sage essential oil [ 1071).
E. Reverchon / Journal of Supercritical Fluids 10 (1997) 1-37 21
0 (4)
0 50 100 150
t, min
where II is an integer, r is the radius of the sphere
Fig. 15. Empirical modelling of the extraction rate by liquid (m), D is the diffusion coefficient of the solute in
CO2 for various vegetable matters. 0, clove; A, cardamom;
the sphere (m2 s-i), t is the extraction time (s), q
V, sandalwood: ? ? , ginger; W, vetiver. The curves are from the
model of Eq. (1) (adapted from Ref. [ 1081). is the concentration of the solute remaining in the
sphere (kg m3), and q. is the initial concentration
of the extractable material. The extension of the
(qrs), and proposed the following differential equa-
results to the whole bed of particles is immediate,
tion: since all the particles are assumed to be at the
same extraction conditions.
Bartle et al. [ 1111 applied this model to the SFE
of various physical systems. For example, they
where k is the kinetic constant. This equation can monitored the SFE of rosemary leaves by analyz-
be readily integrated with the initial condition that ing the content of l-8 cineole in the extracts. They
at t = 0, qrs = qrs,,, obtaining: concentrated their attention on the asymptotic
trend of the yield curves to obtain an extrapolation
qr8= qrsOexp (- kt) (3) method to evaluate the extraction time necessary
According to these authors, if internal diffusion is for matrix exhaustion.
the controlling step, it is possible to set k = DA/Vz, Reverchon et al. [ 1121 applied this model to
where A/V is the particle surface-to-volume ratio describe the yield curves of essential oils isolated
and z is the diffusion distance. They found a by SFE plus fractional separation of various vege-
best-fit value of the internal diffisivity D of table matrices (basil, rosemary and marjoram).
3 x lo-l3 m2 s-l by applying this model to experi- Experimental results were described fairly well by
mental data on vanilla oleoresin. this model, as shown in Fig. 16 for rosemary
Kandiah and Spiro [ 1091 used a similar essential oil. Three different particle sizes in the
approach in the representation of ginger SFE. SFE of the basil essential oil were also tested [ 561.
They also found a strong dependence of the extrac- Once again, a fairly good agreement between the
tion rate on the ginger particle size, which con- model and the yield data was obtained. The par-
firmed the controlling role exerted by internal ticle size distribution of the various basil charges
diffusion. was also considered. With the addition of this
The empirical approach can be useful when information, the model tended to overestimate the
information on the mass transfer mechanisms and extraction yield. This behavior was somewhat
on the equilibrium relationships is missing; how- expected, since this model considers the ideal
ever, these models are little more than an interpola- extraction behavior for each single particle,
tion of the experimental results. neglecting their interactions.
E. Reverchon /Journal of Supercritical Fluids 10 (1997) I-37 23
1
The solid phase balance can also be proposed
on a single spherical particle. In this case, the mass
balance will be:
(7)
200
t, min
where r (m) is the particle fractional radius, and
Fig. 16. Heat transfer analogy in modelling the SFE and frac- D, (m” s- ‘) is the effective intraparticle diffusion
tional separation of rosemary essential oil and waxes at 100 bar
coefficient. In this case it will be possible to model
and 40°C. A, Essential oil; A, waxes. The curves represent the
model of Eq. (4) (adapted from Ref. [ 1121). the concentration profiles along the particle.
If we choose to represent the SFE process by
the differential mass balances given by Eqs. (5)
4.3.3. Models based on differential mass balance
and (6), they can be solved with the appropriate
Material balances along a section of the extrac-
initial and boundary conditions provided that the
tor have been widely used to describe the behavior
solid versus fluid phase equilibrium relationship
of fixed beds during solid-liquid operations like
q*(c) is known. A linear relationship is usually
adsorption/desorption, chemical reaction and
used in the modelling of SFE processes due to the
extraction. Material balances also constitute a
lack of experimental data on the phase equilibrium:
flexible mathematical tool.
All the mass balance models proposed up to c=k,q* (8)
now have been developed with the assumption of
negigible axial dispersion, constant solvent density where k, is the volumetric partition coefficient of
and flow rate along the bed, and that the essential the extract between the solid phase and the fluid
oil can be modelled as a single compound. On the phase at equilibrium.
basis of these hypotheses, two independent mass The system of partial differential equations
balances can be written over an element of the (Eqs. (5) and (6)) with the equilibrium relationship
extractor of a height dh. For example, the mass ( Eq. (8)) and the initial condition at t =O, c= 0
balances can be written as: and q =qO and the boundary condition at h = 0,
c(O,t) = 0 can be solved numerically applying, for
(5) example, the method of characteristics.
In Eq. (6), the group A$/( 1 -E) V depends on
the geometry of the particles through A,$. This
(1 -,,VZ = -A,K(q-g*) (6) group is dimensionally equal to l/s. Therefore, it
is possible to define the internal diffusion time as
where E is the bed porosity, V is the extractor ti = ( 1 -E) V/,4$, where ti is a characteristic time
volume (m3), c is the extract concentration in the of the extraction process. Thus, Eq. (6) can be
fluid phase (kg mm3), q is the extract concentration rewritten as:
in the solid phase (kgmm3), u is the superficial
a4
solvent velocity (m s-l), A, is the total surface of
particles (m’), q* is the concentration at the solid- zt=-ti
L(q-q*) (9)
24 E. Reverchon / Journal of Supercritical Fluids 10 (1997) 1-37
Moreover, if the extraction is assumed to be uni- calculation by assuming the mean thickness of
form along the bed (i.e. &/ah = constant), Eqs. (5) sage leaves (0.29 mm) as the height of the slab
and (9) can be rewritten as a system of ordinary particles. The other two dimensions of the slab
differential equations: were determined from the mean particle size of the
charge as measured by sieving. A fairly good fit
(5 )c+N$
P
+(l -.,v$ =o (10) was obtained for the whole range of particle sizes
studied. The best fit among the yield curves and
the experimental data was obtained for
dq
dt=-tii c4-4*1 (11) Di=6.OX 10-‘3m2s-1 (see Fig. 17). The fit was
particularly good, even when considering the
largest sage particles (3.1 mm). The hypothesis
where W is the solvent mass flow rate (kg s-l)
that internal diffusion is the limiting stage of the
and p is the solvent density (kg mm3). In this case,
mass transfer mechanism was verified by perform-
a solution can be obtained numerically using the
ing SFE of sage oil at different CO2 flow rates:
fourth order Runge-Kutta method. Starting with
yield curves substantially overlapped when
Eqs. (10) and (1 l), if the accumulation of the
expressed against the extraction time (see Fig. 14).
extract in the fluid phase can be neglected (&/at =
To obtain a simpler representation of the SFE
0), a simple analytical solution can be obtained.
of essential oils, simplified models were also tested.
Reverchon [ 1071 proposed the extraction of sage
Reverchon and Sesti OS&O [I061 in the SFE of
oil as a model case for SFE from leaves. SFE was
basil oil neglected the accumulation of solute in
performed at 90 bar and 50°C and fractional
the fluid phase and assumed that extraction was
separation was performed to isolate a sage essential
uniform along the extraction bed. With these
oil that did not contain coextracts [SS].
assumptions, an analytical solution was obtained
Experiments were repeated at four different par-
from which Di could be determined from a fit of
ticle sizes and at two different CO2 flow rates. The
the experimental data. The limits of the applicabil-
SFE rate largely depended on the particle size;
ity of the simplified mass balances when applied
therefore, according to the schematic representa-
to SFE of leaves can be explained by comparing
tion of the leaf structure proposed in Fig. 6, a
two characteristic process times, namely the
model with a controlling internal mass transfer
resistance was adopted. The mathematical model
was based on Eqs. (5) and (9) with the equilibrium loo-
relationship as given in Eq. (8). The Villermaux
[ 1131 relation was used to introduce the internal
80 -
diffusivity Di:
I2
ti=P O_ (12)
I
internal diffusion time and the residence time. the fluid phase (&/at = 0), and presents an analyti-
During the SFE of basil essential oil [56] and of cal solution. Experiments were performed at two
sage essential oil [88], the internal diffusion times different process conditions (69.8 bar and 29°C
were generally very large as compared to the and 79.8 bar and 32°C). However, the low content
residence time, especially when particles larger of essential oil in basil leaves (around 1% as a
than 0.3 mm were considered. Fluid phase concen- rule) and the different structure of leaves as com-
tration profiles were smooth, partly justifying the pared to seeds should give very small or zero
assumptions made in developing the simplified fractions of readily extractable material. The lim-
models. ited number of experiments presented by the
Sovova et al. [ 1141 proposed a more articulated authors can also be explained using a model con-
approach when modelling the SFE of essential oil taining only the internal diffusion resistance. Mira
from caraway seed, further developing a model et al. [ 1181 proposed the use of this same model
previously presented by the same research group in studying SFE of dried orange peel at 150 bar
for the SFE of seed oils [115,116]. These authors and 50°C. They studied the influence of particle
proposed a physical representation of the seed size and COZ flow rate on the extraction rate.
particles as being composed of cells broken up Observations similar to those put forward in the
during grinding and of cells which are still intact. work of Coelho et al. [ 1171 could be made for the
They hypothesized the existence of two mass application of this model to orange-peel oil extrac-
transfer resistances during SFE. The first is located tion. A model with internal diffusion as the limiting
in the supercritical mixture and controls the extrac- stage seems applicable in this case for all particle
tion process until all the essential oil in the broken sizes explored except for the experiments per-
cells is exhausted. The second is in the walls of the formed at the smallest particle size.
undestroyed cells and controls the remaining part Goto et al. [51] performed SFE of peppermint
of the process. These hypotheses were transferred oil from leaf pieces of about 3 mm in size. They
to the mathematical model by introducing two performed SFE at 88 bar and 60°C and measured
mass balances for the solid phase (similar to those the extraction yield by monitoring the concen-
in Eq. (6)). One was written for the easily accessi- tration of the extracts in l-menthol. Experiments
ble essential oil, and the other was written for the at three different CO2 flow rates were performed.
essential oil protected by the walls of the closed They hypothesized that the peppermint essential
cells. The relative proportions of these contribu- oil was adsorbed in waxes located on the leaf
tions were determined by the grinding efficiency. surface, i.e. they considered only the fraction of
A third diffreential mass balance was proposed for essential oil originally located in the epidermal
the fluid phase. The system of three PDEs consti- hairs. These authors modeled peppermint particles
tuted by the mass balance equations was solved as slabs of infinite length and considered as a
by numerical integration. Five adjustable parame- uniform extraction in the fluid-phase mass balance
ters were determined using the least-squares (&/d/r = constant). The solid-phase mass balance
method. Experimental results were proposed at for a single slab-like porous particle was written
different extraction conditions, and experiments as:
were performed in upflow and downflow condi-
tions. The effect of channelling was observed in
the upflow operation. However, to validate models (13)
with a large number of adjustable parameters, an
adequate number of experimental data sets has to where fl is the porosity of the leaf, qi is the
be used. concentration of solute in leaf pores, and y is the
Coelho et al. [ 1171 adopted the model proposed leaf coordinate. They also assumed that the com-
by Sovova [ 1151 for seed oils to model the liquid bined external and internal mass transfer processes
COZ extraction of basil essential oil. This model can be described by the linear driving-force
neglects the term related to solute accumulation in approximation [ 1191. Moreover, it was supposed
26 E. Reverchon /Journal of Supercritical Fluids 10 (1997) 1-37
that equilibrium in the pores was established proposed. An analytical solution was obtained
instantaneously. An analytical solution was thus assuming a parabolic concentration profile inside
obtained. The only parameter in the model was the particles. Then, Catchpole et al. [ 1021 used this
the adsorption equilibrium constant, which was model to fit the experimental data for the simulta-
best fitted to the experimental results. The experi- neous SFE of vegetable oil, essential oil and water
mental data and the model curves are reported in from coriander seeds at 200 bar and 40°C (see
Fig. 18. They concluded that mass transfer in both Fig. 12 for a graphical representation of the data).
the particle and the external film was so fast that Goto et al. [121] and Roy et al. [122] used the
adsorption equilibrium alone controlled the overall shrinking-core model to fit the experimental data
extraction rate. on the SFE of ginger rhizomes performed at three
When porous, spherical particles are considered, different COZ flow rates. Two adjustable parame-
in which the solute exists in pores as a trapped ters were used in the model: solubility and effective
liquid and the solid has no affinity for the liquid, intraparticle diffusivity. Yield curves plotted
the driving force for the extraction process is against the extraction time were coincident, indi-
represented by the solubility of the solute in the cating that the extraction process was controlled
fluid phase. Such a situation can be described by by the mass transfer mechanism. However, only
the shrinking-core model. As solute is extracted, one of the yield curves produced at different par-
the front between the solute and the solvent ticle sizes was fitted by the model.
phase recedes towards the centre of the particle. The shrinking-core model seems more applicable
Therefore, the solute contained within the par- to the seed structure than to other vegetable
ticle is concentrated in a core of diminishing radius. matter. Seed structure can be described by porous
In this case, the solid-phase mass balance, written particles, and the content of vegetable oil is very
for a single spherical particle, can be represented high (frequently over 50% by weight). It is far less
by Eq. (7). This model was first proposed by King justifiable to use the shrinking core model to
and Catchpole [ 1201 to describe the SFE of vegeta- describe, for example, the structure of ginger rhi-
ble oil from seeds (peanuts). The hypothesis of a zomes. Indeed, the maximum ginger oil yield, as
linear equilibrium condition at the particle surface measured by Roy et al. [ 1221, is lower than 4% by
and the linear driving force approximation were weight. Moreover, Spiro and Kandiah [ 501 demon-
strated for SFE of ginger rhizomes that a partition
factor applies between the solid and fluid phase
solute concentration, i.e. the driving force for the
process is not the solubility in supercritical COZ,
since the solute is not freely available in the
solid phase.
Hortacsu et al. [ 1231proposed two mathematical
models representing the plant matter as arrays of
cellular, permeable tubes or as serially intercon-
nected, perfectly mixed tanks. These representa-
tions were suggested by an analysis of the physical
structure of the vegetable matrix. However, these
models were not tested on experimental data.
0 Reverchon and Poletto [ 1241 recently proposed
0 10 20 30 40 50 60 the modeling of rose and tuberose concrete extrac-
t, min tion. They observed by optical microscopy that
concretes consist of an oily phase mainly formed
Fig. 18. Modelling of the SFE of peppermint oil as a desorption
process. Effect of CO2 flow rate on the extraction of
by compounds which are easily soluble in super-
l-menthol. 0, 3.3 x lo-’ kg s-‘; 0, 6.5 x 10m5kg s-l; A, critical CO2 and a waxy phase where insoluble
13 x 10m5kg s-l (adapted from Ref. [51]). waxes are predominant, and in which small quanti-
E. Reverchon / Journal ofSupercritica1 Fluids 10 (1997) I-37 21
ties of liquids are trapped. On the basis of the exposed to sunshine [53]. Oxygenated compounds
experimental results obtained at different CO2 flow are highly odoriferous and are the principal odor
rates, they formulated a model in which extraction carriers, although hydrocarbon terpenes and ses-
from the oily phase was controlled by equilibrium, quiterpenes can also contribute to their flavor
and a variable mass transfer resistance controlled [ 1271.
the extraction of solute from the waxy phase. The There is considerable interest in developing tech-
mathematical representation by differential mass niques which can produce concentrated peel oils
balances produced a fairly good fit of the experi- with a low hydrocarbon content. At present, the
mental data. most commonly used procedures to concentrate
peel oils are vacuum distillation, extraction with
4.3.4. Further comments alcohol, partition between two solvents with
Different models have been proposed to describe different polarities, and preparative adsorption
the major features of the SFE of essential oils. chromatography. These processes suffer some dis-
However, their general validity is not the same. advantages: specifically, organic solvents have to
Since the composition of the SFE extracts varies be removed, and distillation may induce thermal
with the extraction pressure and temperature, a degradation of the product. No specific procedures
preliminary optimization of the extraction condi- have yet been proposed to eliminate allergenic
tions is required. Moreover, accurate experimental compounds.
data on the essential oil yield cannot be obtained Supercritical CO2 may be used as a very selective
without the adoption of the fractional separation solvent, and does not produce thermal degradation
technique. More information is still required on or solvent contamination of products. Therefore,
the influence of the various process parameters it should be possible to set up new processes to
like the extraction time, particle size, etc. The deterpenate essential oils and to eliminate
extraction mechanisms postulated in the models allergenic compounds. To date, two different
must correspond to the real structure of the vegeta- approaches have been proposed in the supercritical
ble matter. fractionaton of essential oils. These are (1) super-
critical desorption and (2) continuous counter-
current tower processing.
5. Liquid feed processing
5.1. Supercritical desorption
Citrus-peel oils and many other essential oils
consist of large quantities of hydrocarbon terpenes Yamauchi and Saito [ 1281 used a semi-prepara-
and sesquiterpenes, and of small percentages of tive supercritical chromatographic system to frac-
oxygenated terpenes. Terpenes are unsaturated tionate a cold-pressed lemon-peel oil. It was
compounds which can undergo structural injected directly into a 50 mm x 7.3 mm ID column
rearrangements and hydration reactions; they are packed with silica gel. The column temperature
also oxidized rapidly by air. As a rule, citrus-peel was held constant at 40°C while the outlet pressure
oils are produced by cold pressing. This process was increased from 100 to 200 bar. Ethanol was
also releases non-negligible quantities of non-vola- also added in the last part of the experiments.
tile compounds like coumarins and psoralens into Four fractions were obtained, and were mainly
the oil. Some of them, like bergapten, have a well- composed of terpenes, oxygenated terpenes,
ascertained phototoxic activity [ 125,126]. For this oxygenated terpenes removed by ethanol addition,
reason, strong limitations have been imposed on and high molecular-weight compounds,
the use of citrus-peel oils. IFRA (the International Cully et al. [ 1291proposed citrus-peel oil desorp-
Fragrance Association) recommended a maximum tion from several adsorbents (silica gel, aluminium
content of 0.4% of cold-pressed bergamot oil and oxide, Kieselgur, cellulose, bentonite and magne-
a maximum content of 2% of the other citrus-peel sium silicate) using supercritical CO,. They used
oils in products which are applied to skin areas temperatures ranging from 50 to 70°C and
28 E. Reverchon /Journal of Supercritical Fluids 10 (1997) 1-37
Table 6
Bigarade peel oil fractionation by supercritical CO, desorption. (Terpenic fraction desorbed at 77 bar and 40°C. Deterpenated fraction
desorbed at pressures up to 120 bar. Residue collected from the desorption column by washing with warm ethanol. Adapted from
Ref. [133].)
Compound family Crude oil (%) Terpenic fraction (%) Deterpenated fraction (%) Residue (%)
Table I
Bergamot peel oil fractionation by supercritical CO2 desorption (Terpenic fraction desorbed at 75 bar and 40°C. Deterpenated fraction
desorbed at pressures up to 100 bar. Residue collected from the desorption column by washing with warm ethanol. Adapted from
Ref. [131].)
strongly on the water content of the adsorbent, densities of 0.50 and 0.75 g cme3 (corresponding
thus showing a low reproducibility of desorption. to temperatures of between 37 and 57°C and
Silica gel was confirmed as the best adsorbent for pressures from 109 to 170 bar), obtaining break-
this task. The work was carried out in two steps: through curves for each compound of the mixture.
122 bar and 40°C for 20 min and 405 bar and 60°C At the highest CO, density studied, practically no
for 100 min, and a micro SFE apparatus was used. selectivity was observed (i.e. all the breakthrough
Most hydrocarbons were desorbed during the first curves almost overlapped). At 0.5Og cm-3, two
step. The fraction desorbed at higher COz density distinct families of breakthrough curves were
still contained 20-30% of hydrocarbon terpenes. found, one for the hydrocarbon terpenes and one
The product obtained by supercritical desorption for the oxygenated terpenes. At the same COz
was compared to the deterpenated oils produced density, selectivity decreased slightly with increas-
by vacuum distillation. The traditional deterpena- ing temperature. It is reasonable to suppose that
tion technique produced a loss of the more volatile if lower CO, densities are employed (for example,
aliphatic aldehydes. 0.25 g cmP3, as used by Barth et al. [ 1301) an even
Vega-Bancel and Subra [ 1351 conducted super- better separation can be obtained.
critical desorption experiments on a model mixture Chouchi et al. [ 1311 also reported a first attempt
of citrus-peel oils consisting of six hydrocarbon to model the supercritical desorption of bergamot
terpenes and six oxygenated terpenes. They first oil. They considered the oil as consisting of two
adsorbed and then desorbed this mixture at CO, key compound families, and measured the yield
30 E. Reverchon /Journal of Supercritical Fluids 10 (1997) 1-37
according to this subdivision against the desorp- the oxygenated terpenes, respectively, at the begin-
tion time. The yield curves for desorption were ning of the desorpton process.
obtained (see Fig. 20). The data was fitted by Eqs. (5) and (14) were solved analytically,
developing a simplified model of the process. The giving:
overall mass balance on the desorption bed was
written as in Eq. (5). To define the mass balance C OX=Fqo {exp[-k(t--:)I-exp(-kr)}
in the solid medium (silica gel), information about
the mass transfer coefficient is needed. Moreover,
(15)
an equilibrium relationship is required to connect
the oil concentration between the fluid phase and where ceXis the concentration in the fluid phase at
the solid phase. For a complex system such the exit of the desorber, and H is the bed height
as bergamot oil, this information is missing. (cm).
Therefore, the simplified approach suggested by The desorbed amount (Y) was then calculated
Tan and Liou [ 136,137] was followed. These by integrating c,, over time, i.e.:
authors described the desorption of ethyl acetate
Y=J c,,Q dt (16)
(EA) from activated carbon by means of supercrit-
ical CO,, obtaining a fairly good fit between where Q is the volumetric flow rate (cm3 min- ‘)
supercritical desorption data and the model. Tan of COz. Two different values of k are obtained
and Liou [ 136,137] suggested a mass balance in from the model (one for each key compound) by
the solid phase written in terms of a linear desorp- fitting Eq. (16) to the experimental data. A fairly
tion kinetics model: good agreement between the model curves and the
experimental results was obtained, as shown in
a4
-=-kq Fig. 20.
(14)
at
with the initial condition at t =O, q= qO, where k 5.2. Fractionation in a continuous counter-current
is the desorption constant (l/m). Chouchi et al. tower
[ 1311 chose qO=ql +q2, where q1 and q2 are the
concentrations of the hydrocarbon terpenes and Several investigators attempted the deterpenation
of citrus-peel oils using a continuous method. Stahl
et al. [2] proposed the supercritical fractionation of
peel oils using a continuous, counter-current, high-
pressure column. They treated bitter and sweet
orange-peel oil at a pressure of 80 bar. The axial
temperature profile aong the column displayed the
highest temperature in the middle of the column
(SSOC), whereas the temperature at the head of the
column was fixed at 75”C, and at the bottom at
60°C. The starting composition of the orange-peel
oil was 90% hydrocarbon terpenes. They obtained
less than 1% oxygen-containing compounds at the
top of the column and a hydrocarbon content of
42% at the bottom. According to these authors, for
given conditions of temperature and pressure, the
40 60 80 100 120 140 160 degree of enrichment can be regulated via the
time, min relative solvent throughput.
Fig. 20. Desorption of bergamot peel oil. The curves are Perre et al. [ 1381 described a pilot-scale appara-
according to the model of Eq. (16). 0, hydrocarbon terpenes; tus for continuous counter-current operation
0, oxygenated terpenes (adapted from Ref. [ 1311). capable of treating 250 dm3 of citrus-peel oil per
E. Reverchon /Journal ofSupercritica1 Fluids 10 (1997) 1-37 31
_A
TO1
TO1
2
/
L
L
- sfbe 8000
33 :20 66 :40 188 :ea 133 :20
Fig. 22. GC traces of bergamot oil continuous fractionation. (A) Top fraction, (B) bottom fraction. 1, limonene; 2, linalool; 3, linalyl
acetate (from Ref. [ 1421).
the column are reported. Small percentages of (0.25-0.30 g cme3) should be preferred to elimi-
linalool and linalyl acetate are still present in the nate the hydrocarbon terpene fraction, since the
top fraction. selectivity of the process decreases at higher
densities.
5.3. Further comments Some further considerations are possible when
comparing supercritical desorption to the
Silica1 gel proved to be the best adsorbent for continuous counter-current tower process.
the supercritical desorption of citrus-peel oils. Supercritical deterpenation allows hydrocarbon
Process conditions at very low CO2 densities terpene reduction as well as the elimination of
E. Reverchon /Journal of Supercritical Fluids 10 (1997) I-37 33
coumarins and psoralens, but large plant volumes ment in essential oils achieved by eliminating ter-
will be required for industrial-scale operation. For penes and other undesired compounds is highly
example, a 200 dm3 volume for a charge of 20 kg attractive, since fractionated essential oils can have
of crude essential oil can be required. The con- a longer shelf life and a very high added value.
tinuous counter-current tower allows hydrocarbon
terpene elimination but oxygenated compounds
and non-volatile compounds will be collected
together at the bottom of the column. This process References
allows the treatment of high volumes of crude
[l] Encyclopaedia of Food Science and Technology, Wiley,
essential oils in the continuous mode. Therefore,
New York, 1992.
the best process arrangement appears to be a [2] E. Stahl, K.W. Quirin, D. Gerard, Verdichtete Gase zur
continuous counter-current tower and a supercriti- Extraction und Raffination, Springer, Berlin, 1987.
cal deterpenation column operated in series. In [3] D.A. Moyler, in: M.B. King, T.R. Bott (Eds.) Extraction
this manner, the advantages of both techniques of flavours and fragrances with compressed CO,,
Extraction of Natural Products Using Near-Critical
can be exploited. The continuous counter-current
Solvents, Blackie, Glasgow, 1993.
tower should be used for the deterpenation of high [4] K. Kerrola, Literature review: isolation of essential oils
quantities of crude essential oil, whereas supercriti- and flavor compounds by dense carbon dioxide, Food
cal desorption should be used for coumarin and Rev. Int. 11 (1995) 547.
psoralen elimination from the concentrated pro- [5] E. Reverchon, L. Sesti Osseo, Comparison of processes
for supercritical CO, extraction of oil from soybean seeds,
ducts obtained in the previous stage of the process.
J. Am. Oil Chem. Sot. 71 (1994) 1007.
[6] M. Perrut, High performance extract-solvent separators,
in: M. Perrut (Ed.), Proceedings of the First International
6. Conclusions and perspectives Symposium on Supercritical Fluids, 1988, p. 627.
[7] A. Birtigh, G. Brunner, Regeneration of loaded supercriti-
cal fluids, in: I. Kikic, P. Alessi (Eds.), Proceedings of the
It has been demonstrated that SFE can produce
Third Congress0 Italian0 sui Fluidi Supercritici e loro
superior quality products characterized by the Applicazioni, 1995, p. 67.
absence of artefacts and by a better reproduction [8] IFT (Int. Food Technol.) Sensory evaluation guide for
of the original flavour or fragrance. The suggested testing food and beverage products, Food Technol. 35
recipe to extract essential oils by SFE is to operate (1981) 50.
[9] G. Brunner, Gas Extraction, Springer, Berlin, 1994.
at low CO, densities (0.25-0.50 g cm-3) and to
[lo] D.-Y. Peng, D.B. Robinson, A new two-constants equa-
add fractional separation of the extracts. Higher tion of state, Ind. Eng. Chem. Fundam. 15 (1976) 59.
COZ densities can be useful only if non-essential 111 0. Redlick, J.N.S. Kwong, On the thermodynamics of
oil compounds are required in the extract. solutions. V. An equation of state: fugacities of gaseous
From an industrial point of view, SFE oleoresins solutions, Chem. Rev. 44 (1949) 233.
121 G. Soave, Equilibrium constants from a modified
are commercially available and essential oils pro-
Redlich-Kwong equation of state, Chem. Eng. Sci. 27
duced by SFE are now being put on the market. (1972) 1197.
However, much research is still needed in all 131 E. Bender, Habilitationsschrift. Ruhr-Universitat,
aspects related to the supercritical fluid extraction Bochum, 197 1.
of essential oils. More extended and reliable soluti- 141 N.F. Carnahan, K.E. Starling, Equation of state for non
attracting rigid spheres, J. Chem. Phys. 51 (1969) 635.
lity data is required for essential oil components.
151 E. Gomez de Azavedo, E. Matos, M. Nunes da Ponte,
Data on the partition factor between the fluid P.C. Simoes, Phase equilibria of systems containing limo-
phase and the solid phase is very much needed. nene, cineole and supercritical carbon dioxide, in: M.
Information on the process parameters which Perrut (Ed.), Proceedings of the First International
affect the SFE process is still scattered, and mathe- Symposium on Supercritical Fluids, 1988, p. 135.
[ 161 M. Richter, H. Sovova, J. Kucera, Solubility of monoter-
matical modelling of the major features of the
penes in supercritical carbon dioxide, in: Proceedings of
process is still in its initial stages. the Second International Symposium on High Pressure
To date, post-fractionation of essential oils is by Engineering, 1990, p. 306.
far the least studied aspect. However, the improve- [ 171 Ph. Marteau, J. Obriot, R. Tufeu, Experimental determi-
34 E. Reverchon /Journal of Supercritical Fluids 10 (1997) l-37
nation of vapor-liquid equilibria of CO2 + limonene and [35] K. Ohgaki, I. Tsukahara, K. Semba, T. Katayama, A
CO,+citral mixtures, J. Supercrit. Fluids 8 (1995) 20. fundamental study of extraction with superciritical fluid.
[ 181 G. Di Giacomo, V. Brandani, G. Del Re, V. Mu&ante, Solubilities of a-tocopherol, pahnitic acid, and tripahnitin
Solubility of essential oil components in compressed in compressed carbon dioxide at 25°C and 4o”C, Int.
supercritical carbon dioxide, Fluid Phase Equilib. 52 Chem. Eng. 29 (1989) 302.
(1989) 405. [36] K.D. Bartle, A.A. Clifford, S.A. Jafar, G.F. Shilstone,
[ 191 H.A. Matos, E. Gomes de Azavedo, M. Nunes da Ponte, Solubilities of solids and liquids of low volatility in super-
P.C. Simoes, M.T. Carrondo, Phase equilibria of natural critical carbon dioxide, J. Phys. Chem. Ref. Data 20
flavours and supercritical solvents. Fluid Phase Equilib. (1991) 713.
52 (1989) 357. [37] Y. Iwai, T. Fukuda, Y. Koga, Y. Arai, Solubilities of
[20] J.-S. Yau, F.-N. Tsai, Solubilities of 1-hexadecanol and myristic acid, palmitic acid, and cetyl alcohol in supercriti-
1-octadecanol in subcritical and supercritical carbon diox- cal carbon dioxide at 35°C J. Chem. Eng. Data 36
ide, J. Chem. Eng. Data 37 (1992) 285. (1991) 430.
[21] E. Reverchon, P. Russo, A. Stassi, Solubilities of solid [38] N.R. Foster, S.L.J. Yun, S.S.T. Ting, Solubility of oleic
octacosane and triacontane in supercritical carbon diox- acid in supercritical carbon dioxide, J. Supercrit. Fluids
ide, J. Chem. Eng. Data 38 (1993) 458. 4 (1991) 127.
[22] T. Bamberger, J.C. Erickson, C.L. Cooney, SK. Kumar, [39] W.B. Nilsson, E.J. Gauglitz, J.K. Hudson, Solubilities of
Measurement and model prediction of solubilities of pure methyl oleate, oleic acid. oleyl glycerols, and oleyl glycerol
fatty acids, pure triglycerides, and mixtures of triglycer- mixtures in supercritical carbon dioxide, J. Am. Oil Chem.
ides in supercritical carbon dioxide, J. Chem. Eng. Data Sot. 68 (1991) 87.
33 (1988) 327. [40] K.K. Liong, R.N. Foster, SST. Ting, Solubility of fatty
[23] J. Chrastil, Solubility of solids and liquids in supercritical acid esters in supercritical carbon dioxide, Ind. Eng.
gases, J. Phys. Chem. 86 (1982) 3016. Chem. Res. 31 (1992) 400.
[24] J.H. Liang, A.-I. Yeh, Process conditions for separating [41] H. Hammam, Solubilities of pure lipids in supercritical
fatty acid esters by supercritical CO,, J. Am. Oil Chem. carbon dioxide, J. Supercrit. Fluids 5 (1992) 101.
Sot. 68 (1991) 687. [42] 2. Knez, R. Steiner, Solubility of capsaicin in dense
[25] K. Sakaki, Solubility of S-carotene in dense carbon diox- CO,, J. Supercrit. Fluids 5 (1992) 251.
ide and nitrous oxide from 308 to 323 K and from 9.6 to [43] E.M. Calvey, S.W. Page, L.T. Taylor, Apparent solubility
30 MPa, J. Chem. Eng. Data 37 (1992) 249. threshold densities of substituted coumarins, J. Supercrit.
[26] E. Stahl, D. Gerard, Solubility behaviour and fraction- Fluids 3 (1990) 115.
ation of essential oils in dense carbon dioxide, Perfumer [44] R.J. Robey, S. Sunder, Application of supercritical pro-
Flavorist 10 (1985) 29. cessing to the concentration of citrus oil fractions, paper
[27] M. Richter, H. Sovova, The solubility of two monoter- presented at the AIChE National Meeting, San Francisco,
penes in supercritical carbon dioxide, Fluid Phase Equilib. CA, 1984.
85 (1993) 285. [45] H. Kalra, S.Y.-K. Chung, C. Chen, Phase equilibrium
[28] R. Tufeu, P. Subra, C. Plateaux, Contribution to the data for supercritical extraction of lemon flavors and palm
experimental determination of the phase diagrams of oils with carbon dioxide, Fluid Phase Equilib. 36 (1987)
some (carbon dioxide + terpene) mixtures, J. Chem. 263.
Thermodynam. 25 (1993) 1219. [46] S.J. Coppella, P. Barton, Supercritical carbon dioxide
[29] M. Maier, K. Stephan, Chem. Ing. Technol. 56 (1984) extraction of lemon oil, in: T.G. Squires, M.E. Paulaitis
222. (Eds.), Supercritical Fluids: Chemical Engineering
[30] M.A. McHugh, A.J. Seckner, T.J. Yogan, High pressure Principles and Applications, American Chemical Society
phase behavior of binary mixtures of octacosane and Symposium Series, no. 329, American Chemical Society,
carbon dioxide, Ind. Eng. Chem. Fundam. 23 (1984) 493. Washington, DC, 1987, p. 202.
[31] I. Swaid, D. Nickel, G.M. Schneider, NIR-spectroscopic [47] F. Temelli, J.P. O’Connell, C.S. Chen, R.J. Braddock,
investigations on phase behaviour of low-volatile organic Thermodynamic analysis of supercritical carbon dioxide
substances in supercritical carbon dioxide, Fluid Phase extraction of terpenes from cold pressed orange oil, Ind.
Equilib. 21 (1985) 95. Eng. Chem. Res. 29 (1990) 618.
[32] W.J. Schmitt, R.C. Reid, The solubility of paraffinic [48] S. Platin, E.O. Ozer, U. Akman, 0. Hortacsu,
hydrocarbons and their derivatives in supercritical carbon Equilibrium distributions of key components of spear-
dioxide, Chem. Eng. Commun. 64 (1988) 155. mint oil in sub/supercritical carbon dioxide, J. Am. Oil
[33 ] A. Kramer, G. Thodos, Solubility of I-hexadecanol and Chem. Sot. 71 (1994) 833.
pahnitic acid in supercritical carbon dioxide, J. Chem. [49] M. Btidich, G. Brunner, S. Hoffmann, S. Jung, Donnes
Eng. Data 33 (1988) 230. d’equilibre du systeme essence de peau d’orange/CO,
134 ] A. Kramer, G. Thodos, Solubility of 1-octadecanol and supercritique, in: P. Pellerin, M. Perrut (Eds.), 3tme
stearic acid in supercritical carbon dioxide, J. Chem. Eng. Colloque sur les Fluides Supercritiques: Applications aux
Data 34 (1989) 184. Produits Naturels, 1996, p. 197.
E. Reverchon 1 Journal of Supercritical Fluids 10 (1997) 1-37 35
[50] M. Spiro, M. Kandiah, Extraction of ginger rhizome: par- extraction from geranium plants, J. Essential Oil Res. 5
tition constants and other equilibrium properties in (1993) 185.
organic solvents and in supercritical carbon dioxide, Int. [67] K.U. Sankar, in: S.S.H. Rizvi (Ed.) Supercritical fluid
J. Food Sci. Technol. 25 (1990) 566. carbon dioxide technology for extraction of spices and
[51] M. Goto, M. Sato, T. Hirose, Extraction of peppermint other high value bio-active compounds. Supercritical
oil by supercritical carbon dioxide, Jpn. J. Chem. Eng. 26 Fluid Processing of Food and Biomaterials, Chapman
(1993) 401. and Hall. London, 1994, p. 155.
[52] S.V.G. Krishna Sastri, Supercritical fluid extraction of [68] J.P. Bartley, P. Foley, Supercritical fluid extraction of
fragrances from jasmine flowers, PhD thesis, Indian Australian-grown ginger, J. Sci. Food Agric. 66 (1994)
Institute of Technology, 1994. 365.
[53] International Fragrance Association (IFRA), Code of [69] M. Verschuere, P. Sandra. F. David, Fractionation by
Practice, Geneva, Switzerland, 1992. SFE and microcolumn analysis of the essential oil and
[54] I. Nykanen, L. Nykanen, M. Alkio, Composition of the bitter principles of hops, J. Chromatogr. Sci. 30
angelica root oils obtained by supercritical CO, extraction (1992) 388.
and steam distillation, J. Essential Oil Res. 3 (1991) 229. [70] C.R. Langenzaal, A. Chandra, S.T. Katsiotis, J.J.C.
[ 551 M. Ondarza, A. Sanchez, Steam distillation and super- Scheffer, A.B. De Haan, Analysis of supercritical carbon
critical fluid extraction of some Mexican spices, dioxide extracts from cones and leaves of Hum&s lupulus
Chromatographia 30 (1990) 16. L. cultivar, J. Sci. Food Agric. 53 (1990) 455.
[56] E. Reverchon. L. Sesti OS&O, D. Gorgoglione, 711 C. Bicchi, P. Rubiolo, C. Rovida, Analysis of constituents
Supercritical CO, extraction of basil oil: characterization of Iris rhizomes: simultaneous SFE of irones and iridals
of products and process modeling, J. Supercrit. Fluids 7 from Iris pallida L., J. Flavour Fragr. 8 (1993) 261.
(1994) 185. 721 N. Gopalakrishnan, C.S. Narayanan, Supercritical
[57] N. Gopalakrishnan, C.S. Narayanan, Carbon dioxide carbon dioxide extraction of cardamom, J. Agric. Food
extraction of Indian jasmine concrete, J. Flavour Fragr. Chem. 39 (1991) 1976.
6 (1991) 135. [73] G.V.R. Rao, P. Srinivas, S.V.G.K. Sastry. M.
[58] E. Reverchon. F. Senatore, Supercritical carbon dioxide Mukhopadyay, Modeling solute-cosolvent interactions
extraction of chamomile essential oil and its analysis by for supercritical fluid extraction of fragrances,
gas chromatography-mass spectrometry, J. Agric. Food J. Supercrit. Fluids 5 (1992) 19.
Chem. 42 (1994) 154. [74] E. Reverchon, G. Della Porta, D. Gorgoglione,
[59] N. Sanders, in: M.B. King, T.R. Bott (Eds.), Extraction Supercritical CO2 fractionation of jasmine concrete,
of Natural Products Using Near-Critical Solvent, Blackie, J. Supercrit. Fluids 8 (1995) 60.
Glasgow, 1993, p. 43. [75] N. Adasoglu, S. Dincer, E. Bolat, Supercritical fluid
[60] M. Poiana, V. Sicari, A. Neri, B. Mincione, Extracion extraction of essential oil from Turkish lavender flowers,
par CO, supercritique de certaines essences d’agrumes, J. Supercrit. Fluids 7 (1994) 93.
in: P. Pellerin, M. Perrut (Eds.), 3tme Colloque sur les [76] E. Reverchon. G. Della Porta, F. Senatore, Supercritical
Fluides Supercritiques: Applications aux Produits CO, extraction and fractionation of lavender essential oil
Naturels, 1996, p. 173. and waxes, J. Agric. Food Chem. 43 (1995) 1654.
[61] B.G. Cieslinski. G.T. Wilkinson, R. Kluba, S. Hornby, [77] M. Oszagyan, B. Simandi, J. Sawinsky, K. Horvath, A.
Optimal conditions for the separation of essential oil from Kery, E. Lamberkovics, Supercritical fluid extraction of
liquid carbon dioxide extracts of coriander seeds, in: M. essential oils from mixtures of medicinal plants, in: M.
Perrut, G. Brunner (Eds.), Proceedings of the Third Perrut, G. Brunner (Eds.), Proceedings of the Third
International Symposium on Supercritical Fluids. vol. 2, Symposium on Supercritical Fluids, vol. 2, 1994, p. 453
1994, p. 323 [78] E. Reverchon, G. Donsi, F. Pota, Extraction of essential
[62] H. Kallio, K. Kerrola, Application of liquid carbon oils using supercritical CO,: effect of some process and
dioxide to the extraction of essential oil of coriander, pre-process parameters. Int. J. Food Sci. 3 (1992) 187.
Lebensm. Unters. Forsch. 195 (1992) 545. [79] E. Reverchon, Fractional separation of SCF extracts from
[63] K. Kerrola, H. Kallio, Volatile compounds and odor marjoram leaves: mass transfer and optimization,
characteristics of carbon dioxide extracts of coriander J. Supercrit. Fluids 5 (1992) 256.
fruits, J. Agric. Food Chem. 41 (1993) 785. [80] R. Dick, K.W. Quirin, P. Cresp, Massoia lactone, extrac-
[64] S.B. Hawthorne, M.L. Riekkola, K. Serenius, Y. Holm, tion et concentration par le CO, supercritique, Parfums,
R. Hiltunen, K. Hartonen, J. Chromatogr. 634 (1993) Cosmetiques, Aromes 103 (1992) 91.
297. [Sl] N.K. Sinha, D.E. Guyer, D.A. Gage, CT. Lira,
[65] X. Ma, X. Yu, Z. Zheng, J. Mao, Analytical supercritical Supercritical carbon dioxide extraction of onion flavors
fluid extraction of Chinese herbal medicines, and their analysis by gas chromatography-mass
Chromatographia 32 (1991) 40. spectrometry, J. Agric. Food Chem. 40 (1992) 842.
[66] A.S.R. Machado. E. Gomes de Azavedo, R.M.A. [82] Z. Knez, F. Posel, J. Golob, Extraction of plant materials
Sardinha, M. Nunes da Ponte, High pressure CO2 with supercritical CO,, in: M.A. McHugh (Ed.),
36 E. Reverchon / Journal of Supercritical Fluids 10 (1997) 1-37
Proceedings of the Second International Symposium on dense ou un melange de dioxyde de carbone et d’ethanol,
Supercritical Fluids, 1991, p. 101. Sci. Aliments 7 (1987) 481.
[83] E. Reverchon, A. Ambruosi, F. Senatore, Isolation of [loll E. Reverchon, G. Della Porta, Rose concrete fraction-
peppermint oil using supercritical CO2 extraction, ation by supercritical CO,, J. Supercrit. Fluids 9 (1996)
J. Flavour Fragr. 9 (1994) 19. 199.
[84] E. Reverchon, G. Della Porta, D. Gorgoglione, [ 1021 O.J. Catchpole, E.W. Andrews, G.N. Toikka, G.T.
Supercritical CO2 extraction of volatile oil from rose con- Wilkinson, Mathematical models for the extraction of oils
crete, J. Flavour Fragr., 12 (1997) 37. from plant matrices using near critical solvent, in: M.
[85] E. Reverchon, M. De Camillis, Produzione di estratti ali- Perrut, G. Brunner (Eds.), Proceedings of the Third
mentari mediante SCFE: l’olio essenziale di rosmarino, International Symposium on Supercritical Fluids, vol. 2,
Ind. Aliment. (1991) 266. 1994, p. 47
[86] E. Reverchon, F. Senatore, Isolation of rosemary oil: [103] E. Ozer, S. Platin, U. Akman, 0. Ortacsu, M. Goto, Doga
comparison between hydrodistillation and supercritical (Turkish J. Chem.) 16 (1992) 273.
COZ extraction, J. Flavour Fragr. 7 (1992) 227. [104] K. Kerrola, B. Galambosi, H. Kallio, Characterization
[87] R.L. Mendes, J.P. Coelho, H.L. Fernandes, I.J. of volatile composition and odor or angelica root extracts,
Marrucho, J.M.S. Cabral, J.M. Novais, A. Palavra, J. Agric. Food Chem. 42 (1994) 1979.
Applications of supercritical CO2 extraction to microal- [105] K.U. Sankar, B. Manohar, Extraction of essential oils
gae and plants, J. Chem. Technol. Biotechnol. 62 using supercritical carbon dioxide, in: M. Perrut (Ed.),
(1995) 53. Proceedings of the First International Symposium on
[88] E. Reverchon, G. Della Porta, R. Taddeo, Extraction of Supercritical Fluids, 1988, p. 807.
sage essential oil by supercritical CO,: influence of some [ 1061 E. Reverchon, L. Sesti Osseo, Modelling the supercritical
process parameters, J. Supercrit. Fluids 8 (1995) 302. extraction of basil oil, in: M.Perrut, G, Brunner (Eds.),
[89] P. Barton, R.E. Hughes, M.M. Hussein, Supercritical Proceedings of the Third Symposium on Supercritical
carbon dioxide extraction of peppermint and spearmint, Fluids, vol. 2, 1994, p. 189.
J. Supercrit. Fluids 5 (1992) 157. [ 1071 E. Reverchon, Mathematical modelling of supercritical
[90] S. Polesello, F. Lovati, A. Rizzolo, C. Rovida, extraction of sage oil, AIChE J. 42 (1996) 1765.
Supercritical fluid extraction as a preparative tool for [108] S.N. Naik, H. Lentz, R.C. Maheshawari, Extraction of
strawberry aroma analysis, J. High Res. Chromatogr. 16 perfumes and flavours from plant materials with liquid
(1993) 555. carbon dioxide under liquid-vapor equilibrium condi-
[91] J. Guinamant, Extraction par fluide supercritique: appli- tions, Fluid Phase Equilib. 49 (1989) 115.
cations aux aromes et aux parfums, Parfums, [109] M. Kandiah, M. Spiro, Extraction of ginger rhizome:
Cosmetiques, Aromes 104 (1929) 81. kinetic studies with supercritical carbon dioxide, Int. J.
[92] K. Nguyen, P. Barton, J.S. Spencer, Supercritical carbon Food Sci. Technol. 25 (1990) 328.
dioxide extraction of vanilla, J. Supercrit. Fluids 4 [l lo] J. Crank, The Mathematics of Diffusion, Clarendon
(1991) 40. Press, Oxford, 1975, p. 85.
[93] K.U. Sankar, Studies on the physicochemical characteris- [ 11l] K.D. Bartle, A.A. Clifford, S.B. Hawthorne, J.J.
tics of volatile oil from pepper extracted by supercritical Langenfeld, D.J. Miller, R.A. Robinson, A model for
carbon dioxide, J. Sci. Food Agric. 48 (1989) 483. dynamic extraction using a supercritical fluid, J. Supercrit.
[94] J.B. Pridham, Terpenoids in Plants, Academic Press, New Fluids 3 (1990) 143.
York, 1967. [112] E. Reverchon, G. Donsi, L. Sesti OS&O, Modeling of
[95] E. Stahl, K.W. Quirin, D. Gerard, Solubilities of soybean supercritical fluid extraction from herbaceous matrices,
oil, jojoba oil and cuticular waxes in dense carbon diox- Ind. Eng. Chem. Res. 32 (1993) 2721.
ide, Fette Seifen Anstrichmittel 12 (1983) 458. [ 1131 J. Villermaux, Chemical engineering approach to dynamic
[96] Y. Yonei, H. Ohinata, R. Yoshida, Y. Shimizn, C. modelling of linear chromatography, J. Chromatogr. 406
Yokoyama, Extraction of ginger flavor with liquid or (1987) 11.
supercritical carbon dioxide, J. Supercrit. Fluids 8 [114] H. Sovova, R. Komers, J. Kucera, J. Jez, Supercritical
(1995) 156. carbon dioxide extraction of caraway essential oil, Chem.
[97] H.J. Bestmann, J. Erler, 0. Vostrowsky, Extraktion von Eng. Sci. 49 (1994) 2499.
thymian mit flussigem CO2 im labormaBestab, Lebensm. [115] H. Sovova, Rate of the vegetable oil extraction with
Unters. Forsch. 180 (1985) 491. supercritical CO2 - modelling of extraction curves,
[98] CC. Chen, C.-T. Ho, Gas chromatographic analysis of Chem. Eng. Sci. 49 (1994) 409.
volatile components of ginger oil extracted with liquid [116] H. Sovova, J. Kucera, J. Jez, Rate of the vegetable oil
carbon dioxide, J. Agric. Food Chem. 36 (1988) 322. extraction with supercritical CO, - extraction of grape
[99] D.A. Moyler, Extraction of essential oils with carbon oil, Chem. Eng. Sci. 49 (1994) 415.
dioxide, J. Flavour Fragr. 8 (1993) 235. [117] L.A.F. Coelho, G.R. Stuart, J.V. de Oliveira, S.G.
[loo] J.P. Vidal, H. Richard, Obtention dune oleoresine de d’Avila, Extraction of Brazilian basil oil using carbon
poivre noir par extraction avec du dioxyde de carbone dioxide at high pressures: experimental data and process
E. Reverchon /Journal of Supercritical Fluids 10 (1997) 1-37 31
modeling, in: I. Kikic, P. Alessi (Eds.), Proceedings of dioxide: deterpenation and psoralens elimination,
the Third Congress0 sui Fluidi Supercritici e loro J. Supercrit. Fluids 7 (1994) 177.
Applicazioni, 1995, p. 115. [131] D. Chouchi, D. Barth, E. Reverchon, G. Della Porta,
[118] B. Mira, M. Blasco, A. Berna, S. Subirats, Supercritical Supercritical CO2 desorption of bergamot oil, Ind. Eng.
CO2 extraction of essential oils from orange peel, in: I. Chem. Res. 34 (1995) 4508.
Kikic, P. Alessi (Eds.), Proceedings of the Third [132] G. Della Porta, E. Reverchon, D. Chouchi, D. Barth,
Congress0 sui Fluidi Supercritici e loro Applicazioni, Citrus peel oils processing by SC-CO, desorption:
1995, p. 157. deterpenation and high molecular weight compounds
[119] M. Goto, J.M. Smith, B.J. McCoy, Parabolic profile elimination, in: I. Kikic, P. Alessi (Eds.), Proceedings
approximation for chemical reactions, Chem. Eng. Sci. of the Third Congress0 sui Fluidi Supercritici e loro
45 (1990) 443. Applicazioni, 1995, p. 139.
[ 1201 M.B. King, O.J. Catchpole, in: M.B. King, T.R. Bott [133] D. Chouchi, D. barth, E. Reverchon. G. Della Porta,
(Eds.) Physicochemical data required for the design of Bigarade peel oil fractionation by supercritical CO*
near-critical fluid extraction process. Extraction of desorption, J. Agric. Food Chem. 44 (1996) 1100.
Natural Products Using Near-Critical Solvents, Blackie, [134] P. Dugo, L. Mondello, K.D. Bartle, A.A. Clifford,
Glasgow, 1993. D.G.P.A. Breen. G. Dugo, Deterpenation of sweet orange
[121] M. Goto, B.C. Roy, Y. Nomura, T. Hirose, Kinetic and lemon essential oils with supercritical carbon dioxide
studies of supercritical fluid extraction from natural solid using silica gel as an adsorbent, J. Flavour Fragr. 10
materials, in: M. Perrut, G. Brunner (Eds.), Proceedings (1995) 51.
3rd Symposium on Supercritical Fluids, vol. 2, 1994, [ 1351 A. Vega-Bancel, P. Subra, Adsorption and desorption of
p. 165. some hydrocarbon and oxygenated terpenes under
[122] B.C. Roy, M. Goto, T. Hirose. Extraction of ginger oil supercritical conditions, in: I. Kikic, P. Alessi (Eds.),
with supercritical carbon dioxide: experiments and model- Proceedings of the Third Symposium Fluidi Supercritici
ing, Ind. Eng. Chem. Res. 35 (1996) 607. e loro Applicazioni, 1995, p. 149.
[123] 0. Hortacsu, 0. Aeskenazi, U. Akman, Release mecha- [ 1361 C.S. Tan, D.C. Liou, Desorption of ethyl acetate from
nisms of extractable compounds from plant matrices activated carbon by supercritical carbon dioxide, Ind.
during supercritical fluid extraction, ACS Symp. Ser. 608 Eng. Chem. Res. 27 (1988) 988.
(1995) 364. [ 1371 C.S. Tan, D.C. Liou, Modeling of desorption at supercrit-
[ 1241 E. Reverchon, M. Poletto, Mathematical modelling ical conditions, AIChE J. 35 (1989) 1029.
supercritical COz fractionation of flower concretes, Chem. [ 1381 C. Perre, G. Delestre, L. Schrive, M. Carles,
Eng. Sci. 51 (1996) 3741. Deterpenation process for citrus oils by supercritical
[125] S.T. Zaynoun, B.E. Johnson, W. Frain-Bell, A study of CO, extraction in a packed column, in: M. Perrut, G.
oil of bergamot and its importance as a phototoxic agent, Brunner (Eds.), Proceedings of the Third International
Contact Dermatitis 3 (1977) 225. Symposium on Supercritical Fluids, vol. 2, 1994, p. 465.
[126] M. Naganuma, S. Hirose, K. Nakayama, K. Katajima, [ 1391 M. Sao, M. Goto, T. Hirose, Fractionation of citrus oil
T.A. Somega, A study of the phototoxicity of lemon oil, by supercritical fluid extraction tower, in: M. Perrut, G.
Arch. Dermatol. Res. 278 (1985) 31. Brnnner (Eds.), Proceedings of the Third International
[127] J. Owusu-Yaw, R.F. Matthews, P.F. West, J. Food Sci. Symposium on Supercritical Fluids, vol. 2, 1994, p. 83.
51 (1986) 1180. [ 1401 M. Sato, M. Goto, T. Hirose, Fractional extraction with
[128] Y. Yamauchi, M. Saito, Fractionation of lemon peel oil supercritical carbon dioxide for the removal of terpenes
by semipreparative supercritical fluid chromatography, from citrus oil, Ind. Eng. Chem. Res. 34 (1995) 3941.
J. Chromatogr. 505 (1990) 237. [ 1411 P.C. Simoes, H.A. Matos, P.J. Carmelo, E. Gomes de
[ 1291 J. Cully, E. Schutz, H.-R. Volbrecht, Verfahren zur entfer- Azavedo, M. Nunes da Ponte, Mass transfer in counter-
nung von terpenen aus etherischen olen, European Patent current packer columns: application to supercritical
no. A 0 363 971, 1990. CO, extraction of terpenes, Ind. Eng. Chem. Res. 34
[ 1301 D. Barth, D. Chouchi, G. Della Porta, E. Reverchon, M. (1995) 613.
Perrut, Desorption of lemon oil by supercritical carbon [ 1421 E. Reverchon, unpublished results.