Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
Frederico Bastos Schuab, Petrobras, Alessandra Winter and Osvair Vidal Trevisan, State University of
Campinas, Leonardo André Fraga Bonzanini,
Copyright 2015, held jointly by the Society of Petrophysicists and Well Log a high viscosity oil (110 cp at 90°C) whose transverse
Analysts (SPWLA) and the submitting authors.
This paper was prepared for presentation at the SPWLA 56th Annual Logging relaxation time (T2) was lower than the two distinct
Symposium held in Long Beach, California, USA, July 18-22, 2015. micro and macropores modes. Results revealed that
with aging macropores and part of the micropores were
ABSTRACT sequentially filled by oil.
This paper presents a case study of core-to-log data This large amount of microporosity filled by oil affects
integration of a well drilled in a carbonate formation the T2 distribution and therefore the determination of
bearing bimodal pore system. Based on the evidences, a cutoffs (T2cutoff), since these micropores, related to Bulk
new approach is proposed for the interpretation of Volume of Irreducible Water (BVI), may contain oil
Nuclear Magnetic Resonance (NMR) logging data. The but do not have significant contribution to permeability.
main tasks involved in the data integration process
were: 1) interpretation of available basic and special This study shows that, depending on the formation
core analysis data (porosity/permeability of 163 plugs, wettability and porosity distribution, the use of a second
Mercury Injection Capillary Pressure (MICP) data of 43 cutoff in the NMR interpretation solves the
samples and wettability tests), 2) NMR measurements incompatibility problem between permeability and
in 9 plugs at different saturations (100% brine and Swi) porosity of the wells obtained by NMR logs.
for three different wettability conditions (plugs were
aged in oil for 18, 33 and 42 days) and, 3) integration of INTRODUCTION
the lab results with NMR well logging data. The main
objective of the study was to understand fluid One of the main products used in NMR log
distribution in the bimodal pore system, in order to interpretation is the transverse relaxation time (T2). As
reduce the uncertainties associated with water shown in the equation below, the relative importance of
saturation and permeability determinations from the the three relaxation mechanisms depends on the type of
NMR log interpretations. fluid in the pores, the sizes of the pores, the strength of
the surface relaxation, and the wettability of the rock
The first NMR log interpretations of the well using surface (Coates et al., 1999).
conventional cutoff (~ 100 ms) resulted in high water
saturations. Such saturations were incompatible with
the laboratory results. Core analysis from the key cored
interval have shown the rocks to be of grainstone
texture and composed of rounded grains with high T2bulk: fluid transverse relaxation time;
porosities and permeabilities. The analyses also point to : suface relaxativity
a high volume of micropores which were confirmed by S/V: surface to volume ratio
the MICP analysis and by the transverse relaxation time T2D: diffusion transverse relaxation time;
distribution (T2) in the 100% brine saturated plugs. The
macro and microporosity proportions determined by Neglecting shale effects, the entire T2 distribution area
both methods (NMR and MICP) confirmed each other, must match the sample effective porosity. For
indicating proportionality between the amount of pores permeability and saturation estimations, it is necessary
and throats. In addition, macroporosity revealed a good to apply to T2 distributions (T2cutoff) a time cutoff which
correlation with absolute permeability, allowing to aims to separate the spectrum areas called in the
conclude that macroporosity is the dominant parameter literature (Coates et al., 1999) by BVI (Bound Volume
controlling fluid flow. For the analysis of T2 Irreducible of Water) and FFI (Free Fluid Index),
distribution at irreducible water saturation (Swi) and located at left and right of the T2cutoff, respectively.
different aging times, rock samples were displaced with
1
SPWLA 56th Annual Logging Symposium, July 18-22, 2016
Permeability can be calculated by the Timur-Coates A well data package covering approximately 45 meters
equation, one of the most used with NMR logs (Romero of a carbonate reservoir was analyzed in the study.
and Gomez, 2004).
The data package covered basic and special
petrophysical data from plugs totalling 163 porosity and
absolute permeability values, 8 irreducible water
saturation (Swi) results, 43 pore throat radius (ptr)
distributions and 8 wettability index values.
In the example of Figure 1, the T2 distribution is
influenced only by surface relaxation effects because In addition, 9 plugs were taken for NMR analyzes
the rock is completely saturated with brine. Besides, it under varying saturation conditions, according to the
is a sample with an homogeneous pore distribution sequence:
(unimodal).
Cleaning ; drying and full brine- saturation
According to May and Kantzas (2002), it is usually
assumed that the fluid in the small pores will not be NMR (T2) measurements;
produced and that the fluid in the large pores are prone
to flow. Therefore, the T2cutoff separates capillary fluid Irreducible water saturation by centrifuge (Air-
from free fluid, while separating large pores from small Water);
pores.
NMR (T2) measurements;
In a study of petrophysycal NMR characterization with
100% (brine) saturated plugs, Lonnes et al. (2003)
Cleaning, drying and full brine-saturation;
suggested that the interpretation of T2 as porosity
distribution could lead to errors, and therefore, the
Irreducible water saturation by centrifuge (Oil-
NMR data should be calibrated to laboratory results Water);
other than NMR measurements on plugs.
NMR (T2) measurements;
2
SPWLA 56th Annual Logging Symposium, July 18-22, 2015
RCAL
3
SPWLA 56th Annual Logging Symposium, July 18-22, 2015
MICP AND NMR (SW100% BRINE) in Figure 5. As in the ptr distribution, samples #176 and
#325 showed unimodal T2 distribution, which are
MICP analysis investigates the injection pressure associated with zones #2 and #4.
variation that is inversely proportional to the pore throat
size. The smaller the pore throat, the higher the pressure
required to overrun it and fill out the subsequent pore
space.
Microporosity Macroporosity
MICP NMR MICP NMR
AVG 52.26% 51.49% 39.86% 48.51%
Figure 4: Pore throat radius distribution of 43 samples.
Mínimum 33.93% 38.19% 16.94% 30.55%
Máximum 74.56% 69.45% 58.94% 61.81%
For the bimodal grainstones (zone # 3), the plot shows
Samples 38 7 38 7
that the rock is composed mainly of pores connected by
Reference rgp<0.5 T2<200-250 ms rgp>5 T2>200-250 ms
throat radii smaller than 0.5 micrometers and larger
than 5 micrometers. These limits are the same as those
used by Allen et al (2001) studying similar carbonate As suggested by Clerke (2007), permeability is
rocks from the Middle East. The volumes detected governed by the larger pores of these bimodal rocks.
above 5 microns radii represent the macropores and are Large pores are expected to be connected by large
associated with interparticle porosity. As there is no throats, appearing above 5 micrometers in the MICP
matrix present in the zone, the volumes found below the analyzes. Likewise it is expected that the longer times,
0.5 microns throat radii are associated with the grain, above 200-250 ms at T2 plots, are related to larger
i.e., with intraparticle porosity (microporous grain). pores.
Zones #2 and #4 carry only micropores associated with
the grain and the fine matrix. Cantrell and Hagerty Despite the fact that MICP and NMR analyzes are
(1999) found the occurrence of such microporosity in based on different principles, the equivalence between
similar carbonate rocks in the Arab-D formation. the micro and macroporous fractions of the two
methods suggests that there are no significant effects of
In the NMR analysis with fully saturated brine samples diffusive coupling between these pore classes, as noted
(100% brine), relaxation surface effects predominates by Allen et al. (2001). Furthermore, it shows that pore
(Coates et al., 1999) and T2 distribution reflects the and throat sizes are proportional (small pores are
porosity distribution. connected by small throats and big pores are connected
by big throats) in these bimodal carbonates.
Out of the 9 samples used in the NMR analysis, 7
samples showed a bimodal T2 distribution, resembling
the ptr distribution obtained via MICP, as demonstrate
4
SPWLA 56th Annual Logging Symposium, July 18-22, 2015
Another important point suggested by the similarity of inferior perm-porosity qualities. The obtained
the curves is that the low mesoporosity volumes, seen cutoff and irreducible water saturation values are
in MICP, probably presents relaxation times within the shown in Table 2. As this cutoff separates the
macroporous portion of NMR. In other words, the irreducible water from the moving fluids will be
NMR macroporous fraction accounts for sum of the adopted the term T2Swi to name it.
meso and macroporosity contributions in MICP.
Table 2: T2cutoff and irreducible water saturation
The plots in Figure 6 show the good correlations values.
between volumes larger than 0.5 micrometers Unimodal Bimodal
(MICP) and greater than 200 ms (NMR) with the T2cutoff (ms) Swi (%) T2cutoff (ms) Swi (%)
permeability of the samples. Such good correlation AVG 69 35,0% 58 27,7%
supports that micropores, although connected, do Mínimum 39 21,2% 35 22,8%
not contribute significantly to permeability. The Máximum 98 48,8% 76 32,1%
straightforward consequence is that permeability Samples 2 7
can be estimated from the macroporosity values
evaluated by both methods.
NMR (SWIOIL-WATER)
CORE-TO-LOG (NMR)
6
SPWLA 56th Annual Logging Symposium, July 18-22, 2015
In Figure 8, LOG-1 and LOG+1 correspond to logs for plugs in fully brine saturated condition (blue).
depth variations of 0,5ft. The dashed lines represent the Furthermore, track 7 plots microporosity (red squares)
fluid bulk relaxation, measured for the brine (in blue) and meso + macroporosity (blue squares) derived from
and estimated for the reservoir oil (black). the MICP interpretation. It is observed that the
irreducible fluid curve (NMRbft) presents values that
For all samples, the T2 log distribution shows 3 distinct are below the MICP microporosity measurements
peaks. Based on the findings of the rock data analyses, (Phi_Micro). After the findings on fluid distribution in
the first peak in short times, generally below 30 ms, is the plugs, that was expected due to the oil remaining
interpreted as due to the capillary water in the smaller inside micropores.
micropores. The peak at intermediate times is related to
the oil, in both micropores and macropores. Some
curves show brief breaks around 100 ms, as in sample
#258, suggesting time separation between the two pore
signals. In the case, probably the longer times are
related to oil filling larger pores. The latest time peaks
appear at up to 2,000 ms and are probably associated
with bulk relaxation of filtrate invasions of the water
based drilling fluid.
X50
7
SPWLA 56th Annual Logging Symposium, July 18-22, 2015
Figure 10 shows the well NMR log interpretation after permeability results. As expected, the best fit of the
using the T2cutoff of 75 ms. In this case, the modelled permeability curve with RCAL permeability
microporosity log curve (NMRbft) shows a good fit data was achieved using the Timur-Coates equation and
with the MICP microporosity results, as shown on track micro and macroporosity obtained by 75 ms T2cutoff
7. As seen in the fully brine-saturated plug analyses, (T2K).
macroporosity is the primary responsible for
permeability. Therefore, permeability was calculated CONCLUSIONS
by the Timur-Coates equation with fixed coefficients (a
= 10, b = 2 and c = 4), and macroporosity (NMRff) and The laboratory results integration from RCAL, MICP
microporosity (NMRbvi) corresponding to FFI and BVI and NMR analysis in fully brine-saturated condition,
respectively. For comparison purposes, two showed that the main reservoir (zone #3) has bimodal
permeability curves were calculated and plotted along: pore throat and pore size distributions with large
one by direct regression with macroporosity and the fractions of micropores (52.26%) and macropores. As
other considering the T2cutoff for Swi purposes. grainstones are free of matrix textures, these volumes
are related to porosity within the grains (intraparticle)
and between the grains (interparticle), respectively.
The last track shows the 3 permeability curves The authors would like to acknowledge Petrobras for
built by the different approaches. The orange providing the well database and for funding the study.
curve with the 25 ms T2cutoff (T2Swi) and the blue
curve with the 75 ms T2cutoff (T2K), both using
Timur-Coates equation. The red curve was based
on a regression between macroporosity and
permeability. The black dots are the RCAL
8
SPWLA 56th Annual Logging Symposium, July 18-22, 2015