Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
growth of international trade and globalization, service. It can be a name, mark, slogan,
marketing strategies of many companies have mascot, symbol, or trademark that
expanded from a national focus to an communicates an identity-image and linkage to
international perspective using either a global the consumer.
approach or a multinational approach. A global
strategy permits a business to produce the same A globalization strategy assumes the brand
product across different countries and different identity-image linkage doesn’t change from
cultures using the same production function. country to country, which means the four Ps-
This global strategy permits firms to have a product, promotion, price, and place-do not
unified competitive advantage based on vary significantly from country to country and
efficiencies in new product development, from culture to culture. For example, the
research and development, economies of scale, benefits of well known drugs easily cross
work force flexibility, and skill transfer countries and cultures without any marketing
(Barron and Hollingshead 2004). To maintain mix barriers, but many products and services
this global competitive advantage the marketing require a multi-national strategy or a local
mix across borders needs to change to adapt to segmented strategy, which means the values,
the different customs, different buying habits, customs, traditions, rules, regulations and the
and different demographic segments within a buying habits across and within countries can
country vary. These variations are not unusual because
there are no universal values, and guidelines
Whether a company adopts a global strategy or that differ from country to country or from
multinational strategy depends on developing a culture to culture despite the many
successful marketing mix that aligns with the communication avenues provided by modern
country’s culture. Brand identification and technology.
image becomes important. Branding is an
intangible asset that can increase a firm’s value CULTURAL DIMENSIONS
baby label, as meaning that the jar contained countries. For example, India’s culture is
babies. extremely strong and provides significant
barriers to marketing in that country. Recently,
Branding and establishing a marketing image Wal-Mart has attempted to enter the market in
requires cultural knowledge. For example, in India on a partnership basis with Bharti, an
Turkey the Turkcell mobile phone Company Indian retailer. This partnership allows Wal-
uses a cartoon animal as a logo and emblem. It Mart to gain access to the market in India.
is called a snabbit. It is a cross between a snail Without the partnership India’s restrictive
and a rabbit with an antenna (Greenfield 2006). governmental policies prevent Wal-Mart from
It represents a unique brand identification and doing business in India. Not only does the
cultural linkage that represents energy, partnership allow entry, but also the many of
dynamism and uniqueness in the the invisible cultural barriers that Wal-Mart
communication industry. Because the cell would have trouble identifying, can be avoided.
phone market includes families, the company By partnering with Bhartia, both partners can
expanded the one character to a family of avoid failure, promote efficiencies and at the
characters. Each family member has a name same time develop a proper brand identification
with different personality characteristics. Cello- and image to insure their product lines and
O represents the father, who is pictured as a service are culturally relevant to the Indian
technophile, joker, and visionary whereas his consumer.
wife Celly is cautious, economical, and an
excellent mother. The daughter, Cellita, A successful example of a global brand
exhibits a concern for the environment. She is identification and image is Singapore Airlines.
fashion conscious and needs freedom. The son, The airline took their country’s friendliness and
Cell Jr., is an internet addict, and soccer made friendliness a successful company brand
enthusiast. The grandfather, Celldede, value on their flights.
exemplifies the adventurer and philanderer, but
he acts as a teenager does. These logos The first global study that identifies and
represent the Turkish extended family and are differentiates cultural dimensions was
symbols consistent with the Hofstede’s cultural Hofstede’s work of almost thirty years ago
collectivism (Hofstede 1983). Because these (Hofstede 1983). These five dimensional
cartoon characters provide a brand approaches embrace individualism versus
identification and linkage with the Turkish collectivism, power distance, uncertainty
collectivistic culture, Turkcell’s market share is avoidance, feminine versus masculine and long
sixty percent in Turkey. term versus short term. The second study
began in 1993 using data from 18,000 middle
To design a successful branding identity and managers in 62 countries and provides nine
image linkage for each national or specific dimensions on which a national culture can be
culture requires companies not to anticipate the evaluated and understood (Javidan and House
values and attitudes shared by individuals and 2001). These more recent nine cultural
groups within specific countries (Nandan dimensions include Hofstede’s five dimensions
2005). These shared attitudes and behaviors and add four more dimensions: assertiveness,
shape each country’s behavior and beliefs about in-group collectivism, performance orientation
what is important (Hofstede 1983). To market a and human orientation. The research of Javidan
product within these various cultures requires and House provides a basis for a cultural
understanding of how to involve the customer conceptual framework to analyze and
(Engeseth 2006), but each country’s culture understand the impact of various external
norms, language, and symbols provide a cultural ramifications associated with a firm’s
different cultural framework on how to predict attempt to develop a successful brand across
customer behavior within and between and within cultures. Table I provides a cultural
TABLE I
Cultural Dimensions
generous approach toward society as a whole, cookies were introduced in Hong Kong,
but this socialistic ideology focuses on society employees offered morsels for tasting purposes
equality to promote fairness and generosity. to prospective customers. Customers declined
Within the Chinese and Indian cultural systems the offer. The custom in China, Korea, Taiwan,
specific individual or specific group rewards and Hong Kong did not permit individuals to
are not well developed or prevalent (Dessler pick up food that was not wrapped. Also, when
2007). Since China and India appear to be doing business with customers who were not
rapidly moving toward a semi-capitalistic friends, the custom was to place the money
approach to their economies, a more humanistic exchanged on the counter as opposed to
orientation might be developing within each handing the change back to the customer on a
country that is more in line with the more hand-to-hand basis. As a result of these
individualistic human resource approach customs Kentucky Fried Chicken’s finger
present in western countries. licking good branding advertisement did not
succeed in China.
Similar to the human orientation dimension the
performance-oriented dimension in China and Currently, Chinese youngsters flock to the
India, where a society rewards individuals and homegrown versions of MySpace and YouTube
group members for improvement, remains (Einhorn 2007). For advertisers identifying the
questionable. However, Hong Kong ranks high acceptable social standards and boundaries
on the performance-orientation dimension, becomes risky and presents a business dilemma
according to Javidan and House, because of the based on the social mores and values present in
western influence from British rule. To enable the Chinese culture and from the political rules
the Indian and the Mainland Chinese to develop and regulations that spring from these mores.
a more complete performance oriented system As an example Yoqu, the Chinese MySpace or
requires each country to move toward a free YouTube, appeals to the younger Chinese
market economy. Since the Indian Government generation. However, government censorship
and the Chinese Government encourage their becomes a significant hurdle. Yoqu translates
companies to compete on the world market, a as “good” and “cool”. This linguistic branding
more performance-oriented culture should is acceptable, but the Chinese Net Cops did not
develop and adapt to the international approve of the racy videos on the Yoqu Web. In
globalization trends in both countries. But the other countries a naughty video might anger
weak performance orientation present within parents and certain types of groups, but in
China and India cultures has not permitted China the government censors requested the
businesses within each country to more fully videos be immediately removed from the Web.
develop their human resource functions and This censorship means all content has to be
marketing strategies (Dessler 2007). This lack reviewed before uploading to the Web site,
of cultural assertiveness hinders Indian and which increases the cost and the risk of doing
Chinese companies, and their ability to develop business. For example, 2007 was the year of the
a global aggressiveness strategy particularly in pig, and Nestle planned a TV ad depicting a
the marketing area, where building brand smiling cartoon pig (Fairclough and Fowler
identification and image linkage can determine 2007), but the Chinese state-run TV network
the success or failure of a product or service. banned the pig commercial. China’s political
agenda did not want to convey a brand image
BRAND INTERACTION
that violates Muslim religious principles.
AND THE CHINESE CULTURE
According to Muslim beliefs, the pig represents
a lack of cleanliness.
To further explain the importance of the
cultural impact on brand identification and the
image linkage there are a number of examples
that illustrates the linkage. When Mrs. Fields
Marketing Management Journal, Spring 2008 34
Branding in the Global Arena: The Role of Culture Krueger and Nandan
Rahul Dravid and Sachin Tendulkar, are being begin to dissolve, which leads to an extremely
used as brand ambassadors for national and complex diverse global environment, and
international campaigns. According to Saha provides businesses with the need and the
and Sinha (2006), some examples of this opportunity to read, identify, and develop new
phenomenon include Japanese watchmaker cultural competence. To help companies
Citizen, which has signed the current captain of identify these cultural patterns, segments and
the Indian cricket team, Rahul Dravid as its variances a number of concepts and questions
brand ambassador in India as well as in the are listed in Table II. These encourage
USA. Also, Indian movie stars Abishek businesses to build on the present cultural
Bachan, Shah Rukh Khan and Aishwarya Rai capital within countries to create new
are brand ambassadors for global companies successful marketing techniques, and at the
Omega, Tag Heur and Longines respectively. same time to prevent unsuccessful product
development, promotions, pricing and
To adapt to cultural eating habits of the Indian distribution.
population and avoid cultural violations of the
Indian religious principles, fast food brands To answer some of these questions there are
such a Pizza Hut and McDonald’s have adapted numerous examples that exemplify the risk and
their offerings in India according to Bhan and dilemmas associated with branding and
Nemer (2006). McDonald’s has not offered its different cultural implications. For example,
main staple of beef-based products in India for different cultures develop less visible formal
fear of offending segments of the population and informal rituals. In Japan formal gift giving
who may regard the cow as being sacred. The is a widely accepted ritualistic standard of
“Big Curry Mac” and “McAloo Tikki” burgers courtesy. In the United States gift giving is
do not use beef and are very successful in India. perceived as a bribe in business. The Japanese
Similarly Pizza Hut has launched “Tandoori have a low tolerance for ambiguity and are very
Pizza,” which has a flavor that is more formal, indirect and patient in their business
attractive to the Indian palate than American dealings. In contrast, the United States culture
pizza. has a high tolerance for ambiguity and is
informal, direct, punctual, and time oriented.
CULTURAL AND BRANDING: KEY These cultural differences appear superficial,
ISSUES FOR GLOBAL COMPANIES but can spell the difference between successful
business practices and unsuccessful business
As economic and political integration transpires endeavors. For example, the Japanese and
through globalization, local and national Korean companies have stressed the importance
customs, traditions, standards, and boundaries of branding, and as a result the Chinese
TABLE II
Are there local and national attitudes that affect the branding of a product or service?
perceive Japanese and Korean products as multi-national strategy should research each
superior in quality (Ahlstrom, Nair, Young and country’s cultural dimensions, local patterns,
Wang 2006). and segments for the purpose of aligning the
firm brand and image with that country’s
To create a brand strategy for a single global or culture. This brand-image alignment enables a
multi-national brand given the diversity of firm to quickly and successfully build brand
world cultures presents a challenge for equity in the global-local market place. Brand
international firms. Obtaining information equity leads to profitability and provides a
about the laws and tax policies about a country bankable asset. For example, recently Sears
doesn’t require too much research. However, issued bonds solely based on the Kenmore,
brand identification and image linkage becomes Craftsman and Diehard brands (Berner 2007).
quite complex because most cultural patterns
and cultural segments are invisible to the REFERENCES
outsider. Over the centuries the social,
religious, psychological and political values Ahlstrom, David, Anil Nair, Michael Young
have evolved to produce different local and and Linda Wang. (2006), “China:
national values, customs, and traditions. These CompetitiveMyths and Realities,” Advanced
patterns are not easy to decode, not only for Management Journal, Vol. 71, pp. 4-10.
individuals within the culture, but even more so Barron, Jennifer and Jim Hollingshead, (2004),
for those individuals not raised within the “Brand Globally, Market Locally,” Journal of
culture. These cultural variances on one hand Business Strategy, Vol. 23 No. 1, pp. 9-14.
provide cultural barriers for businesses and on Berner, Robert (April 16, 2007), “The New
the other hand provide a whole new set of Alchemy at Sears,” Business Week, April 16,
marketing segments and opportunities for pp. 58-60.
businesses to identify. However, these new Bhan, Niti (2006), “Brand Magic in India,”
marketing opportunities come with a new set of May, Business Week online, http:www.
risks. Each local and national cultural segment businessweek.com/innovate/conten/may2006/
has different values. This variation in values id200600.
produces a variation in cultural capital with Dessler, Gary (2007), “Expanding into China?
different customs, standards, boundaries, and What Foreign Employers Should Know
symbols between and within countries. For About Human Resource Management in
example, low context cultures such as the China Today,” Advanced Management
United States focus on direct written Journal, Vol. 71, 4, pp. 11-23.
agreements whereas high context cultures such Deagon, Brian (2002), “Brand-building Means
as the Asian cultures focus on what is unwritten More Than Just Advertising a Product,”
and indirectly implied (Hall 1976). Investor’s Business Daily, April 5, A3.
Einhorn, Bruce (2007), “China Falling Hard
Creating well-known brands and successful for Web 2.0,” Business Week, January 15,
marketing techniques consistent with a pp. 66-67.
country’s cultural dimensions represents a Engeseth, Stefan (2006), “Tap into Culture and
challenge for international firms, but is Customers,” Brand Strategy, March,
necessary for success. Branding builds pp. 36-37.
customer awareness, encourages repetitive Engardio, Pete (2006), “Emerging Giants,”
purchases, loyalty, enhances pricing power, Business Week, July 31, pp. 41-49.
facilitates brand extensions, promotes Fairclough, Gordon and Geoffrey Fowler,
distributional efficiency, and provides a (2007), “Pigs Get the Ax in China TV Ads, in
competitive advantage in promotional efforts. Nod to Muslims,” Wall Street Journal,
By analyzing a country’s cultural framework a January 25, Vol. CCXLIX No. 20, D1.
firm can anticipate and avoid cultural pitfalls. A
company that has a globalization strategy or a
37 Marketing Management Journal, Spring 2008
Branding in the Global Arena: The Role of Culture Krueger and Nandan
Formbrun, Charles (1996), Reputation: Saha, Saugat and Vivek, Sinha (2006), “Local
Realizing Value from the Corporate Image, Celebs, Global Connect,” Economic Times,
Harvard Business School Press, Boston, MA. July, p. 29.
Friedman, Thomas L. (2005), The World is Shenkar, Oded and LuoYadong (2003),
Flat: A Brief History of the Twenty-First International Business, John Wiley & Sons,
Century, New York: Farrar, Straus and Inc., Hoboken, NJ.
Giroux. Ronen, Simcha (1986), Comparative and
Greenfield, Sue (2006), “Turkcell: the Only Multinational Management, NY: Wiley.
Turk on Wall Street,” In Thomas Wheelen Roy, Subir (2005), Made in India – A Study of
and David Hunger (10th Ed.) Strategic Emerging Competitiveness, New Delhi:Tata
Management and Business Policy, pp.6-1-6- McGraw-Hill Publishing Company Limited.
13, Pearson Education, Inc., Upper Saddle Sengupta, Jayanta (2006), WrapAround –
River, New Jersey. Delivering a Great Brand Experience, New
Hall, Edward (1976), Beyond Culture, Garden Delhi: Rupa & Company.
City, NY. Anchor Press. Warner, Malcom and Pat Joynt (Ed) (2002)
Hofstede, Gert (1983), “The Cultural Relativity Managing Across Cultures: Issues and
of Organizational Practices and Theories,” Perspective, 2nd Ed, Thomson Learning,
Journal of International Business Studies, London, UK
Fall, pp. 75-89. Whitely, William and George England (1997),
Javidan, Mansour and Robert House (2001), “Managerial Values as a Reflection of
“Cultural Acumen for the Global Manager: Culture and the Process of Industrialization,”
Lesson from Project Global,” Organizational Academy of Management Journal, 20, 3,
Dynamics, (Spring) pp. 289-305. pp. 439-453.
Kiley, David and Deborah Stead (2007), “Ford Zakaria, Fareed (2006), “India Rising,”
Goes Back to the Future,” Business Week, Newsweek, March 6, pp. 34-4.
February 19, p. 11.
Kotler, Philip (1988). Marketing Management:
Analysis, Planning and Control, Englewood
Cliffs, NJ: Prentice-Hall.
Khermouch, Gerry, Stanley Holmes and Moon
Ihlwan (2001), “The Best Global Brands,
BusinessWeek, August 6, pp. 50-57.
Kriplani, Manjit (2006), “Call Center? That’s
So 2004,” Business Week, August 7, p. 40.
Lakshman, Nandini (2006), “Going Mobile in
Rural India,” Business Week on Line,
http:/bizyahoo.com/special/brand/06_article5
.html.
Melewar, T.C., Maureen Meadows, Wenqiang
Zheng and Richard Rickards (2004), “The
Influence of Culture on Brand Building in the
Chinese Market: a Brief Insight,” Brand
Management, July, Vol. 11, No. 6,
pp. 449-471.
Nandan, Shiva (2005), “An Exploration of the
Brand Identity-brand Image Linkage: A
Communications Perspective,” Brand
Management, April, Vol. 12 No. 4.
pp. 264-278.