Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
discussions, stats, and author profiles for this publication at: https://www.researchgate.net/publication/304009145
CITATIONS READS
0 10
2 authors, including:
Xinqian Zheng
Tsinghua University
107 PUBLICATIONS 287 CITATIONS
SEE PROFILE
Some of the authors of this publication are also working on these related projects:
All in-text references underlined in blue are linked to publications on ResearchGate, Available from: Xinqian Zheng
letting you access and read them immediately. Retrieved on: 03 October 2016
Research Article
Abstract
Axial-centrifugal combined compressors are commonly used, and the stresses of their impeller are important and influ-
enced by temperature and pressure. The effects of temperature and pressure on the stresses of the impeller with differ-
ent inlet conditions are investigated. Conjugate heat transfer analysis and three-dimensional structural finite element
analysis are used to get the stresses of the impeller. The effects of temperature and pressure are obtained by comparing
the equivalent (Von-Mises) stresses between cases taking and not taking them into account. From the result, the tem-
perature effect is surprisingly large for low inlet temperature, reaching 57% of the total equivalent stress, and should be
carefully considered. The effect strongly relates with the inlet conditions and the disk thermal boundary conditions.
Thus, the later can’t be treated as adiabatic as usual. For certain inlet conditions, the stress of the impeller can be
improved by adjusting the disk thermal boundary conditions. In addition, the temperature mainly affects the stress on
the disk and the root of the blade. The pressure effect is small for low inlet temperature and can be sufficiently large for
high inlet temperature. Furthermore, the pressure mainly influences the stress on the blade part and can reduce the
stresses at the inducer of a negative-lean impeller.
Keywords
Axial-centrifugal combined compressor, impeller, temperature, pressure, stress
Creative Commons CC-BY: This article is distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution 3.0 License
(http://www.creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/) which permits any use, reproduction and distribution of the work without
further permission provided the original work is attributed as specified on the SAGE and Open Access pages (https://us.sagepub.com/en-us/nam/
open-access-at-sage).
Downloaded from ade.sagepub.com at Tsinghua University on September 7, 2016
2 Advances in Mechanical Engineering
T l C a r E
K W m21 K21 J kg21 K21 1026 K21 kg m23 GPa
1 288.15 101,325
3 413.15 303,975
5 486.06 506,625
7 540.24 709,275
9 584.25 911,925
blades are easy to break up because of fatigue. For the disk, thus making the maximum equivalent stress of the
reason, the stresses at five featured points are moni- impeller the smallest for the thermal condition of the
tored for further analysis. They are the maximum stress impeller.
point at the root of the main blade (M_Root), the max-
imum stress point at the root of the splitter (S_Root),
the maximum stress point on the surface of the main Effect of temperature on impeller stress
blade (M_Surface), the maximum stress point on the To figure out the effects of the temperature on the
surface of the splitter (S_Surface), and the maximum impeller stress, the thermal stress is defined to be the
stress point at the center of the disk (D_Center), as difference of the total equivalent stresses (Von Mises)
shown by dots in Figure 6. of the impeller with real body temperature and that
The total equivalent stresses of the monitored points with a uniform temperature (22°C). According to the
in Figure 6 are shown in Figure 7, varying with the inlet definition, a positive thermal stress means that the ther-
temperatures of the impeller for different cases. It can mal load increases the total equivalent stress of the
be seen that for low inlet temperature, the total equiva- impeller while a negative one means the thermal load
lent stress at the root of the blades is the largest, while decreases the total equivalent stress.
for high inlet temperature the total equivalent stress at The ratios of the thermal stresses to the total stresses
the center of the disk becomes the largest of the impel- at the monitored points for different inlet conditions
ler. At certain temperature range, as the increase in the are presented in Figure 8. As it shows, the thermal
inlet temperature, the total equivalent stress at the stress can be 57% of the total equivalent stress when
blade root blades decreases, especially for the main the inlet temperature is 288.15 K, which means that the
blade, while the equivalent stress at the center of the temperature has to be considered when analyzing the
disk increases. As a result, there are inlet conditions stress of the impeller. It is also obvious that for low inlet
which make the equivalent stress at the root of the temperature, the thermal stresses are large and positive
blades equal to the equivalent stress at the center of the for points at the root of the blades (M&S_Root) but
negative for points at the center of the disk (D_Center). equal at the junction. Thus, the high temperature area
With the increase in the inlet temperature, the thermal will be compressed to make its expansion smaller
stresses at both places decrease. The thermal stresses on while the low temperature area will be tensed to make
surface of the blades are relatively small. its expansion larger. As a result, tensile stress in the
For explanation, two annulus rings with non- circumferential direction is generated at low tempera-
uniform temperature distribution in the radical and ture area while compression stress generated at high
axial direction are separately illustrated in Figure 9 to temperature area.
describe the mechanism of how the temperature distri- The disk of the impeller can be considered as a spe-
bution influences the stress of the impeller. cial annular ring with non-uniform temperature distri-
With non-uniform temperature distribution in the bution in the radical and axial directions. Thus, tensile
radial or axial direction, the thermal expansion in the stress in the circumferential direction is generated at
circumferential direction will be different for areas in low temperature areas while compression stress at high
the meridian plane. For the high temperature area, temperature areas in the meridian plane. For stress
the expansion will be larger, while for the low tem- caused by the centrifugal load tends to be tensile, the
perature area, smaller. However, as the areas are con- tensile stress generated by non-uniform temperature
nected with each other, the deformation must be will enlarge the total stress and cause a positive thermal
Figure 9. Annulus rings with non-uniform radical and axial temperature distribution.
stress while the compression one will reduce it and temperatures set at the inner disk, which is constant
causes a negative thermal stress. and the temperature of the fluid, which is decided by
Figure 10 shows the calculated temperature distribu- the inlet condition of the impeller for a constant work-
tion of the impeller. The calculated temperature distri- ing state. For low inlet temperature, the surface tem-
bution of the impeller is decided by the surface peratures at the inner disk are much higher than the
fluid, which leads to the temperature at the outer disk has much to do with the temperature of the disk, it also
is much lower than that at the inner disk. As a result, reminds that the cooling and the inlet condition of the
the stress at the outer disk, where the M&S_Root impeller should coordinate with each other to get the
points located, is enlarged and the thermal stress is pos- lowest stress of the impeller.
itive while the stress at the inner disk, where the
D_Center points located, get reduced and the thermal
stress becomes negative. Effect of pressure on impeller stress
With the increase of the inlet temperature, the tem- As with the thermal stress, to figure out the effect of
perature of the fluid increases, which makes the tem- the pressure on the stress of the impeller, the aerody-
perature at the outer disk higher. While the surface namic stress is defined as the difference of the equiva-
temperatures at the inner disk are constant, the tem- lent stress (Von Mises) with the aerodynamic load to
perature distribution of the impeller becomes more uni- that conducted in the vacuum. Similarly, a positive
form. Thus, the thermal stress decreases as shown in aerodynamic stress increases the total equivalent stress
Figure 11. of the impeller while a negative one decreases the total
As the thermal stress of the impeller relates with its equivalent stress.
temperature distribution which is decided by the fluid Figure 12 shows the ratios of the aerodynamic stres-
temperature and the thermal boundary conditions of ses to the total stress for monitored points at Figure 6
the impeller, the thermal boundary conditions of the for different inlet conditions. It can be seen that the
disk are very important and cannot be treated as adia- aerodynamic stress at the center of the disk is nearly
batic. For its influence on the stress of the impeller, the zero for all the inlet conditions. For low inlet tempera-
thermal boundary condition of the disk can be used to ture, the aerodynamic stresses are small. However, the
improve the stress of the impeller by controlling the aerodynamic stresses increase almost linearly with the
temperature distribution of the impeller. In addition, inlet temperature for points except that at the center of
the temperature mainly affects the stress on the disk the disk and can reach 18% of the total equivalent
and the root of the blade. As the stress of the impeller stress, thus cannot be ignored in the stress analysis of
the impeller. The aerodynamic stress is positive at the backward, a tensile stress will be generated at the front
root of the blades (M&S_root) and negative on the sur- side of the impeller and a compression stress at the
face of the blades (M&S_Surface), which means the back side of the impeller. As there is a predominant
pressure enlarges the stress at the root of the blade tensile stress caused by the centrifugal load, the stress
while reduces it on the surface. at the front side is enlarged while the stress at the back
To better understand the effect of the pressure, side is reduced.
Figure 13 gives the distribution of the aerodynamic
stress with different inlet conditions. It is noted that the
distributions of the aerodynamic stress are similar and
Conclusion and remarks
the aerodynamic stresses are positive at the rearward of In this article, the effects of temperature and pressure
the blades and negative at the front part of the blades on the stress of the impeller working at the same state
and at the back of the disk. That means the pressure in different inlet conditions of temperature and pressure
reduces the stress at the front part of the blades and at were studied. Conjugate heat transfer analysis was used
the back of the disk while enlarges it at the rearward of to obtain the temperature and pressure of the impeller
the blades. and the fluid which were then applied as boundary con-
That is because the turning of the fluid in different ditions in the three-dimensional structural FEA to
streamsurfaces causes different counterforce to the obtain the stress of the impeller. Finally, the effects of
impeller according to the conversation of the momen- temperature and pressure on the stress of the impeller
tum. In blade-to-blade streamsurface, as the fluid turns were obtained by comparing the equivalent (Von-
along the blade, the counterforce tends to push the Mises) stress between considering and not considering
blade from the pressure side to the suction side. In mer- the thermal load or the aerodynamic load. Two main
idional steamsurface, as the fluid turns upward at the conclusions are as follows:
rearward of the passage, the counterforce of the fluid
tends to push the outer part of the impeller backward. 1. The temperature effect can reach 57% of the
As the front part of the researched impeller blades total equivalent stress when inlet temperature is
lean to the suction side, the centrifugal force tends to 288.15 K, which suggests that the temperature
pull the blades from the suction side to the pressure effect should be carefully considered in the stress
side. The centrifugal force effect is opposite with that analysis of the impeller. The effect of the tem-
of the counterforce in blade-to-blade streamsurface. perature strongly relates with the inlet condi-
Thus the stress is reduced. However, if the blades do tions of the impeller and the thermal boundary
not lean to the suctions side enough, the effect of the conditions of the disk, which cannot be treated
pressure will be different. as adiabatic. The stress of the impeller can be
In the cases for the rearward of the blades and the improved by controlling the thermal boundary
back of the disk, the counterforce in meridional stream- conditions of the disk. In addition, the tempera-
surface plays an important role. As shown in Figure ture mainly affects the stress on the disk and the
14, as the outer part of the impeller is pushed root of the blade.
Funding
The author(s) disclosed receipt of the following financial sup-
port for the research, authorship, and/or publication of this
Figure 14. Radical normal stress of the impeller under only article: This research was supported by the National Natural
aerodynamic load. Science Foundation of China (Grant No. 51176087).
4. Witek L. Experimental crack propagation and failure design. In: ASME turbo expo 2004: power for land, sea,
analysis of the first stage compressor blade subjected to and air, Vienna, Austria, 14–17 June 2004, pp.1513–1519.
vibration. Eng Fail Anal 2009; 16(7): 2163–2170. New York: ASME.
5. Witek L. Crack propagation analysis of mechanically
damaged compressor blades subjected to high cycle fati-
gue. Eng Fail Anal 2011; 18: 1223–1232. Appendix 1
6. Schilhansl MJ. Stress analysis of a radial-flow rotor. J
Eng Gas Turb Power 1962; 84: 124–130. Notation
7. Immaneni D and Rencis JJ. Coupled axisymmetric and C specific heat capacity of the solid
plane stress finite element model for the stress analysis of D elastic stiffness matrix of the solid
an aircraft engine compressor. In: ASME 2007 interna-
E elasticity modulus
tional mechanical engineering congress and exposition,
Seattle, WA, 11–15 November 2007, pp.637–645. New
f body force vector of the fluid
York: ASME. h volumetric enthalpy
8. Sayer RJ. Finite element analysis—a numerical tool for n rotating speed when the inlet total
machinery vibration analysis. Sound Vib 2004; 38: 18–21. temperature is T0
9. Mukherjee S and Baker D. Thermal design of high pres- nc rotating speed when the inlet total
sure ratio turbocharger compressor wheels. SAE techni- temperature is Tt
cal paper 2002-01-0162, 2002. p pressure
10. Zheng XQ, Jin L, Du T, et al. Effect of temperature on pt inlet total pressure of impeller
the strength of a centrifugal compressor impeller for a p0 101,325 kPa
turbocharger. Proc IMechE, Part C: J Mechanical Engi- q heat flux vector of the fluid
neering Science. Epub ahead of print 3 August 2012.
T viscous stress tensor of the fluid
DOI: 10.1177/0954406212454966.
11. Bohn D, Heuer T and Kusterer K. Conjugate flow and
T temperature
heat transfer investigation of a turbo charger. J Eng Gas Tt inlet total temperature of the impeller
Turb Power 2005; 127: 663–669. T0 288.15 K
12. Zheng XQ and Lan CJ. Improvement in the performance V velocity vector of the fluid
of a high-pressure-ratio turbocharger centrifugal com-
pressor by blade bowing and self-recirculation casing a thermal expansion coefficient of the solid
treatment. Proc IMechE, Part D: J Automobile Engineer- a thermal expansion coefficient matrix
ing 2014; 228: 73–84. e total strain vector
13. Sirakov B and Casey M. Evaluation of heat transfer h efficiency of the assumed axial compressor
effects on turbocharger performance. J Turbomach 2013; ahead
135: 021011.
l thermal conductivity of the solid
14. Verstraete T, Alsalihi Z and Van den Braembussche RA.
Multidisciplinary optimization of a radial compressor for
r density of the solid
microgas turbine applications. J Turbomach 2010; 132: p pressure ratio of the assumed axial
031004. compressor ahead
15. Ashihara K, Goto A, Guo S, et al. Optimization of s stress vector
microturbine aerodynamics using CFD, inverse design
and FEM structural analysis: 1st report—compressor