Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
Your use of the JSTOR archive indicates your acceptance of the Terms & Conditions of Use, available at .
http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp
.
JSTOR is a not-for-profit service that helps scholars, researchers, and students discover, use, and build upon a wide range of
content in a trusted digital archive. We use information technology and tools to increase productivity and facilitate new forms
of scholarship. For more information about JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org.
Biometrika Trust is collaborating with JSTOR to digitize, preserve and extend access to Biometrika.
http://www.jstor.org
VOLUMEXXIV NOVEMBER, 1932 PARTS III AND IV
BIO METRIKA
y= Yoe a (1 + - ) ...........................
,,, (V)^
{( + .(vii).
a Y =Ma a ) ..........I.......
r(p+1) (ai)
Writez =p (1 + and the momentsabout the startof the curve can be foundat
once. These lead to*
Mean = a (p + l)/p
Standard Deviation= = a P+ p. . (viii),
l=p1, s-3p+1
relation,2,82- 3,81- 6 = 0.
providingthe well-knlown
(3) Now suppose thereare twoindependentvariatesu and v both of whichhave
frequencydistributions
providedby Equation (vii). We assumethetwodistributions
to have the same p, but to have different
standarddeviationsa1 and o2, or,what
amountsto the same thing,different nmodaldistancesa and b. We will measureour
variatesu and v fromthe startof theircurves,whichthen take the form
a bFr2(p+ 1) -a b).
If we take the lower octantXOA, the limits of X are - Y to ao, but as Y is now
negativewe get preciselythe same result,or we say that the wholecurveof distri-
butionof Y is (xi), Y being taken as positive,and from0 to oo, and mirroredin the
V U
axis ofX. This resultalso flowsfromthe factthatthe distributionof v _ u mustbe
ba
a symmetricalcurve,as the frequencycurvesforu/a and v/bare identical.
Now if in (iv) we writex=Y, m-p + , we see that the z of(xi) is given by
z = MT9+j (Y) ....................... (xii),
whichleads to IM forthe area of our halfcurve. In otherwordsour curveforY is
the T2,, curvemirroredon itself The ordinatesof this curve have been computed
by Dr E. M. Elderton*.
B
Y |XX
o Au/
Fig. 1.
(4) Now the odd momentsof the mirroredcurvevanish. Let uisfindthe even
We have from(x)
moment-coefficients.
F2s
1
22p-F2(p + 1)
00 rx
Jce-X Y28 (X2 J
Y2)P d YdX ......... (xiii).
-
1s = 22pk2(p e ? _ x2)pdXdX,
~2 +r (p + feX ~ 28+2p+l J O2s(1
* See Biometrika, Vol. xxi. pp. 194-201, or ITables for Statisticians and Bionietriciins, Part I.
pp. lxxix-lxxxviii and 138-144.
19-2
296 Further Applicationsin Statisticsof Tm(x) Bessel Function
or,ifX2= X,
/22s
(2s-1) (2p + 2.s) -/2s-2
(tt2)s 2p + 2 (p2)S''
2 (s 1)
or, i-2 = (2S-1) I + ..................
2s-4(XVi).
Thus finally
=
(2S)(s -- 3.I I1+ s + I (1 + s 2). .........
(1).xvii).
,2,3-2
........ +
It will be clear that whenp ;o we obtain
82s-2 =(2s -1) (2s - 3) ... ,
the familiar/2,-2 formulaforthe normnal
curve,into whichthe Tp+? functionthen
passes.
Considerthe Type VII curve
1
J
(a= (2 + X2)In
Here we have
32s-2=(2s-1)(2s-3) ... 1(I+2n ?) )I (i++ (2 +n 5
and /t2 = a2/(n- 3).
Now it is clearthat we can make /2 anid P4 agree in the Type VII and the TP+?
cuirves*, but fartherthan thatwe cannotgo,althoughthe ,1's maynotdifferwidely
if n be considerable.The Tp+j curve has the furtheradvantage that no moment-
coefficients whileifn be an oddinteger,thoseforthe TypeVII
tendto becomeinfinite,
curve may becomeso. For values of p not too great the Type VII will fitthe dis-
tributionof Y considerablybetter than the normalcurve. For considerablevalues
ofp, both Type VII and the Tp?i curvespass into the normalcurve.
(5) A fewfurtherpointsmay be noted. If p = - I the TO-curveasyimiptotes to
the verticalat the origin,and this holds as long as p lies between- 1 and 0; if
and z = MTp+k(Y)
r
M P{ (2p + 7)} 1 .... ..(xviii)
V27r(p+1)(p+2) r(p+3) (1 + y( (2p+7)
4(p+l)(p+2)J
coincideforpracticalstatisticalpurposes.The areas ofthislattercurveup to given
values of Y have been tabledt fromp = - i to p = 12, but this hardlycarriesus
beyondthe Tm-tables.The completed(and now at press) Y'ablesof the Incomplete
B-function carryus up to 2p + 7 = 101, orp = 47.
(6) Now let us turnto the means of samplesofsize n drawnfromthe Type III
curve
wherethe originis at the startof the curveand a is the distanceto the mode from
the start. Let us suppose a sample x1,x2, x3... xn drawn and let its mean be
Z'n = (X1+ X2+ ... + xn)/n.Then thechanceP ofa samplelyingbetweenx1and x1+ 8xi,
X2 and X2+ X'2 ... Xn and x, + &x. is given by
We have
np~ / ~X2\p /x2\P /XS... X \
P=const.xex a -dn - dX2dX3 ... dx$.
) -a (tn2
Put X2= 12x2'and integrateout forX2= 0 to 12or 02' Oto 1. Thiswill introduce
a B-functioninto the constant,but leave us with
* Cf. Biometrika,Vol. xxi. pp. 171 and 173 foraccordanceof the curves. Their equations are given
on p. 185, wherewe must writein - l=p + i, or n=2p + 3. The twocurveshave thenthe same firstfour
moment-coefficients. If 7 = Y/{2%/(p+ 1) (p + 2) }, thentheproportional area from = 0 up to anyarbitrary
value of I is given by JI1,(j, p + 1), where I,, (-, p + 1) =B,7 (j, p + 1)/B(j, p + 1), B7, and B being the
incompleteand completeBeta-functions.
t See Biometrika,Vol. xxii. pp. 253-283, or Tables for Statisticiansand Biometricians,Part II,
pp. cxxv-cxlii and pp. 169-177.
298 FurtherApplicationsin Statisticsof Tm(x) BesselFunction
P = const.
xe-a dx, (l-)3 + dx4...dx,,
wherels= nan-4 - X5 Xn
Y=p
(X2
----
Xl\/ \ X2 XI\ = V
+ 1) \(x
(p
=-r? +
1(X2 x'
J
a,a2 /X XI t a-X
_
=a_X say. Again P - 2 - Thus we have
p a o- N/8
=-n - n:('- 2 i) 2n............ ()xxiv).
X -Z -/a1 ?x
We thentakeqn= ,B I! and
~~
2'~ 2n
2 '-
(xxvi),
.......................
-2 M21v2 MdJ
is givenby z = jiIIT4(n-2) (Y) ....................(xxix).
We are thereforein a positionto determinewhetherthe variancesof two samples
each measured in terms of the variance of its parent populationare significantly
different.
If the two parentpopulationsare identical,thenY= - (,42' - U2)/M2 . If, as may
oftenbe the case, the parent populationbe unknown,then the onlyremedyis to
take forAl2the value providedby the two samples pooled. If we knowthe means
Yn and i4' of the two samples to be the samne,
this will be i (,a2' + /12), so that the
frequencyof the (lifference
will be given by
Now this Type VII curve,like that forthe variance,has its p known,= i (v - 3),
which can be foundat once fromv the number of categoriesin the sample.
Further,its a, i.e. its modal distance, = (v - 3), and its standard deviation
12 3+ 8
^(v -1). Again,if required,,81J
=i _1- and 82 = 3 +v-1
What is the exact meaning of the 6,815 and 11,668? Are theysimplysamples of the two classes
Inoculatedand Non-Inoculated,thatthe recordershave taken,orhave theysomerelationto the numbers
in the communitywilling or unwillingto be inoculated? If the former,theyare subjectto the moreor
less arbitrarychoice of the recorders,and if we findx2 we are findingit subjectto the suppositionthat
the recordersrepeatedlymade experimentswiththe same numbers.In this case thereis onlyone degree
of freedomin this table, or K - 1 degrees,when two populationswith K categoriesare compared. It
seems in manyrespectsmoreadvantageousto treatthis problemin the mannerit was firstinvestigated,
namelyas the comparisonof two linear series,when the limitationon the degreesof freedomis seenat
once to arise and arise naturally(Biometrika,Vol. viii. pp. 250-254).
But supposethe numbersof Inoculated and Non-Inoculatedarise fromsome naturaldivision,as in
thecase ofvaccination,and non-vaccinationin tne countryat large,thenour tablerepresentsan arbitrary
sample of the total population,and thereare threedegreesof freedom,and this mustbe borne in mind
in determiningthe probabilityof the observedresult. In such a case we may or may not know the
relativefrequenciesof the inoculatedand non-inoculatedin the population under consideration.If we
do not, the onlything we can do is to use the observedratio, as if it werethe populationratio of the
two classes. In the case of the ratio of inoculatedto non-inioculated followingas a natural order,i.e. a
table obtained by a randomsample out of a generalpopulation,wherewe select an individualwithout
regardto whetherhe has beeninoculatedor attackedand afterwardsinquireintodetails,the X2 iS simply
proportionalto the total numberof individuals selected. Thus the %2 forthe above table is 56-234,but
had we takena sample of half the size it wouldbe (subject to variationof sampling)28-117. In other
wordsthe value of X2and accordinglyof P dependsverylargelyon the size of the sample, and the com-
parisonof X2'sfortwo tables of different totals can be made to give almostany value we please to the
probabilityof the two x2'Sbeingdue to samples of different sizes fromthe same parentpopulation. The
quantitywhichwould remainapproximatelythe same would be the 02, and in comparingtwotableslike
the above of different sizes to test whetherthey come fromthe same population,it is ratherthe com-
parisonof jk2 and 0'2, thanofx2andX'2whichshouldguideus.
If, on the otherhand, the sizes of thetwosamplesof Inoculatedand of Non-Inoculatedin a tablelike
that above have been arbitrarilyselected,the X2 will changewidelywiththose sizes. For example,if we
supposethe table formedby two independentsamplings,one of the Inoculatedand anotherof the Non-
Inoculated, and then recordingwhethertheyhad been attackedor not, the verticalmarginaltables are
at our choice,and forfivearbitrarysizes of the two sampleswe have approximately:
(a) (b) (c)i
56 6,759 6,815 56 6,759 6,815 56
5 6,759 6,815
272 11,396 11,668 159 6,656 6,815 68 2,849 2,917
size of the samples on which x2 and X'2are based, but solely on the numberof
cells used in computingthe X2'sbeing the same.
A point here is, perhaps,worthnotingas we have not seen it recorded. If we
take two sets of N samples each, and my.,ma.' be the means of the means of the
two sets, then my.and mg.' will be distributedaccordingto a Type VII curve,if
the originalparentpopulationis, because in thiscase Zn and $n' are so distributed,
wherev is the numberof cells, then since the Mean of X2=v - 1 and its varianceis 2 (v - 1), we should
expect
Mean =v 1 a2,2 =2 (v-1) ......
Now, if therebe K columnsand X rowsin a contingencytable,v = KX, but the mean value of 02 and the
value of 24,2, even if therebe no association,are not
(KX-1)N and 2(KX-1)/N .(. y )
see ? 17 below of this paper. In the veryspecial case of no association and N large,they onlyapproxi-
mate to
(K-1) (X-1)/N and 2 (K-1) (X-1)/N2,
and even thenonlyagree with the values in (,y),whenK and X are indefinitely large,but of a definitely
lowerorderthan N. A contingencytableis hardlylikelyto be of practicalvalue undersuch conditions.
The fact is that when we are studyingthe 02 of a contingencytable taken as a sample froman in-
definitelylargepopulation,successivesampleswillnothave thesame marginaltotalsand the distribution
of 02 is not that of X2/N. Whenwe take two serieseach of definitesize, and testtheirindependenceby
a (X2,P) test,we are reallydealingwithwhat one of the presentwriterslong ago termed"partial con-
tingency,"but it behovesthe user to state verypreciselywhat is the originof thetotalsof his compared
series, and to rememberthat his P as measuringa degree of independenceonly applies to repeated
comparisonof series both of the same totals as the first,and that he cannotgeneraliseas to the degree
of dependencewhichwould arise had he used otherconstantsizes. For the sake of statisticalstudents
the seniorauthorof thispaper believesit advisableto keep verydistincttheusages of x2 and 02, and not
obscurea difficult topic by assuming02 is merelyX2/N.
304 FurtherApplicationsin Statisticsof Tq,(x) Bessel Futnction
we have forthe distribution
and accordingly mf' -mi., the
of the difference
curve
z = j MT Nnp,, (-aNP
3 (m.. -* . (xxxvi),
z = JMTIN(I1) (-N- 2
.
...............m (xxxvii).
be useful.
occasionally
Results(xxxvi)and (xxxvii)mnay
(10) Lastlysupposewe have a contingency table,the numberof cellsbeing
K x X,and a sampleofsize N. be takenfromit,thenwe shallfindthatthemean
squarecontingency,#2, ofsucha sample, undercertainconditions, obeysthelaw of
distribution
y= YO' (1 #12)P1 e-i'2,
but thate is notequal to N1 norpi to j (v- 3), wherev-cX = the numberofcells.
If twosamnpleshavingmeansquarecontingencies o and #12withthesamenumber
ofcellsK X and of thesamesize N be drawnunderthe above-mentioned condi-
tion,thenthefrequency oftheirdifference willbe givenby
y= i MTP+{ie (2
02)E
_
, .................
)(xxxviii).
The conditions referred to willbe discussedin a specialsectionlater.
But in manycasese willnotequal E',and it is perhapsin practice a moreusual
problem to determine whether #12maybe reasonably supposedtobe a samplefrom
thesamepopulation as #2, thanto dealwithX'2and X2. The lattercontainthetotal
sizesofthetwosamples,but the p2and#'2 denoting meansquarecontingency lead
us at onceto the problemof whether thecoefficients of meansquarecontingency
<4121(1 + cf/2)and V02/(1 + 02) and so thedegrees ofassociation in thetwosamples
maybe considered as reasonably accordanton thehypothesis of thesamplesbeing
selectedfromthe samepopulation.
Thedistribution of#12_ 02 willbe considered later.It willbe foundthat,under
certainconditions, it obeysthe same law of frequency of the
as the distribution
firstproductmoment coefficientpi,.
(11) Thereis anothermethod ofapproaching theseproblems,and onlyillustra-
tionsfromknown can tellus whichmethodis generally
curvesor surfaces themore
or
effective more suitablein a type
particular of cases. The wholeof our results
dependupon quantitiesY, 71';/2,/U2'; X2,X'2; #2, #P2, whichsatisfya surfacewhich
can be throwninto the form
w = woe-V+u)(VU)P [dVdU].
KARL PEARSON, S. A. STOUFFER AND F. N. DAVID 305
W= -Oe
=wo e~ 2p+l Zp
+ Z)2p+2
dd]
[dtdz]
t2P+l(1
B 1 (p+l,p+l)
ZWOO
V Z-zo
Z,oo ZZ0,
0 1jZO~~~~~~~~~~
Fig. 2.
1
the probabilitythat V/U<
therefore - or U/V< zo is given by
7 ZO ,,
= Pz0,
as it should,forwe have cut offequal areas.
Accordinglythe total chance that V/U should exceed zo and U/V exceed zo is
Qz=2 (p+l,p +i1.............(xli),
as a measuire
whichmay be takenPt/z [((P l+?y- (1-') of the ratios V/U and U/V
of the improbability
y
occurring.
The Tables of theInzcomplete B-f-unctionprovideQz,0up to p = 50, and a small
portionof them are reproducedhereforcomparison.Clearlywe need the argument
onlyup to 0-5. (See Table II.)
(i) Two means I, and x-<,of two samples of size n fr-oma Type VII parent
population.
Qai y +(p= 1
h(pe+. + 1), (xlii).
KARL PEARSON,S. A. STOUFFERANDF. N. DAVID 307
A table of Sm(x) has been computedby Miss David (see below). The tabled
value beingSm(x), it followsthati (1 +a) the usual probabilityintegral= 5 + S (x),
and i (1- a) = *5 - Sm (x). Hence the probabilitythatan observationwill lie outside
the limits + x is given by 1 - 2Sm(x). Consideringthe case of X'2and X2, the
differenceX'2_ X2 and the ratio X'2/X2 tests will give equial probabilitywhenwe
have
1- 2Si (V 2) (X-X2 _ JX2) =2 1 {j.(v-1), i(v-1)} ...(xlvii),
1+ X'21/X2
wherev is the nutmiberof cells under consideration.If we now give v values from
2 upward,and to X'2/X2 = X values from1 to 100,we are able by meaIlsof Table II
to findthe right-handside of the equatiorn.Hence by Table I to determine
and thus %2 and X'2 XX2. The curvesthus obtained are plottedin Fig. 3. Both
-
20 -10 20 30 40
SCALE OF X2
0 5 10 20 30 40
Fig. 3.
by whichwe enterthis diagram are not X'2and X2, we mustreplace
When the statisticalcoefficients
themby the followingas coordinates:
In case of:
Variancesfroma normalcurveAt2 and /A2t
n,92'/22,wheren is the commonsize of the two samples, and 22 the variance of the parent
72/12122,
populationor its substitute.
Meansfroma TypeIII curvein and Y.':
4n~Z, v , wheren is the common size of the two samples; Z the standarddeviationand ,3
Replace 'j2 and r,)2 by R2 and R'2 forthe above two cases.
KARL PEARSON, S. A. STOUFFER AND F. N. DAVID 309
,
while TM (X) ,-( x)
= ...........j. (xlix).
coefficient
an equationprovidingthe differential of T,,,(xc).
* This followsat once fromthe equations in Biometrika,Vol. xxi. pp. 181 (footnote)and 184.
BiometrikaXXIV 20
310 Futrther in Statisticsof T.m
Appltications (x) Bessel Function
Integratingfromx = 0 to x, we find
f
infinitewhen x = 0, and no quadrature formulais applicable. It was therefore
resolvedthat S, (x) = T, (x) dx should firstbe foundby quadrature,and then
So (x) = Si (x) + xTO(x)
be foundfromthe result,sinceL,0o {$xT(o)} =0, whichsurmountsthe difficulty, and
thus So (x) was determined.The values of S1 (x) obtained by quadraturesfrom
[I'i (x) were computedbyMr E. C. Fieller,and appear in the columnunderm= 10
ofTable I. The ordinatesweretakenat intervalsof002 fromx=O to O'6,01 ofx from
x = 0(6 to 4 0 and afterx = 4 0 up to x = 18&5by intervalsof 0 5. The workwas
laborious,the ordinatesbeing calculated to eight figureaccuracy,but the areas,
given to eight figures,were scarcelyto be trustedto the last digit,where there
mightbe an errorof 1 to 2. Thus the seventhdecimal mightsometinmes, but rarely,
be in errorin a unit. For this reasonMiss David's Table computedto eightfigures
was cut downto six forpublication.Althoughthe values of Sm(x) forintegervalues
+ 0 5 ofm could be obtainedwithany desireddegree of accuracy,those forinteger
values onlydepended on a quadrature,which it was difficultto make reliable to
eight decimal places. As a matterof factMiss David's eight figuretable was used
forall the illustrationswhichfollow,but as linear interpolationwas employed*as
adequate forthe purposewe had in view,we should have got ilearlythe same final
resultsfromthe six figuretable now published.
Those who have occasion to use the table must be carefulto note that from
x = 0 to 4 0, the table advances by 01, but fromx = 4 0 to x 18 0 by 0 5, and this
change miiust be borne in mindwhen interpolatinginto the table.
* In a fewcases wherethe value of x led us to thetop of thetablehigherdifferences
wereintroduced.
KARL PEARSON, S. A. STOUFFER AND F. N. DAVID 311
of Table II.
(14) Construction
The probabilityof a ratio, e.g. X12/X2 = X, iS given by Equation (xlvii), and
demands a table of I 1 4 (v - 1), j (v - 1)}, where I,, (p, q) is the incomplete
1+X
B-functionratio,or
xP-1(I - 0)-1
= dx
Ix(p,q) ..................... Of....
i).
xP-
(I.-l(x)q?-
dx
ratiosmaybe notedhere,
An importantrelationbetweentwokindsof B-function
In the actual table* we shouldnot findI$ (j, p) but only e,,(p, O). The relation
betweenthemis
I$, (11 P)=lI (p, -);
(15) Illustrationsof the Methodof using Tables I and II, and of thevalue of
Fig. 3.
Illustration(i). The followingtables are taken froma paper by K. Pearson: A
Studyof TrypanosomeStrains*.
_
Goat as
_
Host _
112 and 13
~~~~~~under _
14
_
|1 _
16
_
17 and
over Totals
_
Lengthof Trypanosomes
in Microns.
1Biometrika,
Vol. x. 1914-1915, pp. 117-118.
KARL PEARSON,S. A. STOUFFERANDF. N. DAVID 313
in these two
What do our two testsgive us forthe probabilityof compatability
x2)'s? We have for the differencetest
Pi X2 _ = 2 {5 - S2 (6&2355)}= 2 tf5- 493,187}
= 0136, fromTable I,
QX12/x2= (25, 2 5) = 2 x *0918,7173
2I.2161
= 1.837,fromTable II.
Fig. 3, p. 308, indicatesat once thatwithX'2 = 17 216 and x2= 4 745,our point
is veryconsiderablyinside the curveforv = 6, orwithoutworkingout the numerical
resultswe knowthat that difference testwill be morestringentthan the ratio test.
Clearlythe ratio test gives us a moderateprobabilityof either(a) or (b) being the
fact,but the difference test suggeststhat neitherhypothesisis correct,or that goat
and dog reacton the trypanosome manlners.This is in accordance
strainsin different
withtheP' andP foundin thefirstplace forthetwotables,but theratiotestbeingless
stringent obscuresthefirstinmpressions drawnfromP' and P. This particularillustra-
tionwas takelnwithoutany knowledgeof what the tests wouldlead to. A similar
example,with the XI2 smaller,might have made it less easy to draw any definite
fromP' and P, whilePi
conclusions - and Q mightoneor bothgiverise
to conclusiveresults.
Illustration (ii). To illustratethe last remarkwe will take two furthertables
fromPearson'sMemoiron Trypanosomes.They are as follows:
TABLE ii (a).
in Microns.
Lengthof Trypanosomres
TABLE ii (b).
in Microns.
Lengthof Trypanosomes
Wild G. mnorsitans
Strain 3 14 34 41 40 28 160
Mvera Cattle Strain ... 3 11 27 30 21 8 100
Illustration (iii). Table iii (a) below was obtained from the schedules of
Pearson'sinquiryinto the conditionof the Polish and Russian Jewimmigrants into
the East End of London. Table iii (b) was adapted fromTable VII, p. 255, of
Franz Boas's workDescendantsofInntigrants,New York,ColumibiaUniversityPress,
1912. The problemto be answeredis this: The distributions of Cephalic Indices of
the Jewishchildrenbornin their adopted countryand those bornin theirland of
origin are significantlydifferent.Can this differencebe attributedto the same
causes in England and in America?
The tables are as follows:
Male Jewish Boys Under 77 5 78.5 79|5 8 X 8 X 855 86 | 875| 88 and Totals
aged 6 to 15 years 77 over Ttl
Born in America 66 48 121 155 248 263 305 289 244 192 140 69 119 2259
Born in Eastern
Europe ... 8 6 10 23 40 47 87 92 93 105 84 82 116 793
The x2of Table iii (a) is 27 907 corresponding to a P of 0057, and the X12 of
Table iii (b) is 257-399corresponding to a P' < 000,0001. Thus the chance of the
distributionof the Cephalic Index of Jewishboysbornin England being the same
as that of Jewish boys born in Eastern Europe is small; the chance that Jewish
boysbornin Americahave the same distribution of CephalicIndex as thatofJewish
boysbornin Americais vanishingly small. Boas attributesthedifference forAmerica
to the influenceof the Arrmerican environmentcausing the head shape of Jewish
childrenbornin America* to approachthe Gentilevalue. Pearsonsupposesit mnay
be due in the correspondingEnglish case to some admnixture of Gentile blood.
Whatever the originsof the differenceof X21s'we may ask how far is there any
likelihoodof the differencesbeing due to a commoncause. In other words,if we
tooksamplesof the childrenof immigrantJews beforeand afterimmigration, what
is the chance that two samples will have a differencein theirX2's equalling or
exceedingthat observed?The numberof cells is 13, and a recourseto Fig. 3 shows
us thatthe point(X'22 '2) lies well withinand awayfromthe v=13 curve;the
difference methodwill therefore be farmorestringentthan the ratiomethod.
We have-1%2 _ 1%2= 114-746 and
{ 5-55.5(114 746)1.
PjX12 - j2 =2
But Table I showsus that S5.5 (18) = *499,989and S5.s (114'746) must be much
nearer'5 than this,or
- IX2 < 000,022.
tx2
PjX12
and
Again,X'2IX2-9=2234,
= 2Io0-2M(6, 6) =
Qx'21X2 2IO67 (6, 6)
= '000,534.
Both testsindicatethatit is veryimprobablethatthe cephalicindexdivergences
have the sanmecause in America and England, but the differencetest is far more
stringent.
Thus farwe have merelyappliedthe (X2.X'2) test and drawnan apparent
conclusionfromit, but in doingso we have reallyoverlookedthe warninggiven in
in Illustrations(i)
the longfootnoteto p. 302. Whilein the case ofthe trypanosomes
and (ii). we have been dealingwithtotalfrequenciesof muchthesame orderin both
* It is importantto note that themereresidencein Americais notsupposedto modifythehead shape
of childrencomingto America. It is the factof birthin Americawhichis creditedwiththe change.
316 FurtherApplications
in Statistics
of Tmn
(x) Bessel Functiona
the two sets of tables,so that N' and N of X'2 and X2will hardlyaffectthe result;
in thepresentillustrationBoas's totalnumberofindividualsis nine timesPearson's.
Hence, if his proportions remainingthe same were reduced to Pearson's total, his
x'2 would be 28-600 and i (X2 _ X2)= 03465, giving S5.5(03465) instead of
S.r (114-746). We should thus reach
PJX'2 - X2 9149,
or witha high degree ofprobabilityconcludethat the difference betweenPearson's
and Boas's Jews and Gentilescould be attributedto a commonsource.
We do not say that the process here adopted is whollylegitimate,but it does
indicate the need for caution in applyingthe (X '2, e2) test in either form
*, and
suggeststhat a (0I2, 02) test may be betterapplicablewhenthe marginaltotalsare
so different
and so arbitraryt.
Illustrationt(iv). The matterof the precedingillustrationmay be pursuedin
a somewhat differentdirection. The cephalic indices of Jew and Gentile are
markedlydivergent. If we take as our Gentiles two such closely allied races as
English and Swedish, with an almost identical mean index, will either of our
testssufficeto indicatea markeddifference betweenthe x2's forthe two series?
Two such seriesare shownin Tables iv (a) and (b). Table iv (a) is taken froma
paper by Nathaniel 0. M. Hirsch, entitled: "Cephalic Index of American born
Childrenof threeForeign Groups$."
Table iv (b) is based on Pearson'sdata forthe JewishChildrenof East London,
and on his data forEnglish School Children.
Russian Jews 5 2 4 11 21 34 46 65
Swedes ... 17 19 17 19 18 22 12 18
Malesborn Under
in England 73-95 |7445 75-45 76-45 77-45 78 45 79 45 80 45
Eastern Jews - 5 7 10 13 20 28
English ... 146 86 167 226 272 342 266 230
Male
Males bOrn { 81 45 | 82 46 I L 1 S |86'95 |
bongln 81-45 82-45 83-45 84-45 85-45 86-45 and Totals
+
in England
~~~~~~~~~~over
Here X'2= 234-6659forthe 15 cells,and again P' is < 000,0005. Thus both series
of data are in accordin indicatingthat the Jewishmale child differsessentiallyin
head shape fromeither of these series of Gentile male children. But a new
problemarises: Is it indifferent whetherthe Gentiles consideredare English or
Swedish, what is the probabilitythat X'2 and X2 could result fromtwo samples
drawnfromthe same Jew-Gentilepopulation?
= 1 748,954,and we have,since
We will apply firstthe ratio test. Here X'2/X2
v=15, and i(v-1)=7,
Qx 2/X2=2I. (7, 7) = 3077.
Thus on the basis ofthe ratio test,it is notat all improbablethatX'2 and x2 could
have arisen fromthe same population,i.e. it is indifferent whetherSwedish or
English boysbe comparedwith the Jews.
Now let us consider the differencetest. We have iX'2 - 2 = 502451, and
i(v-2)= 6-5. Hence
Pi X12 X2 = 2 [5 -S6.5 (50 2451)}.
Now 502451 is outside the limits of our Table I and S6.5(18) = -499,97663,so
S6.5(50'2451) has a greatervalue than this,and we can onlysay that
X (fs f s)2
(N+ N')2 f+f I
N +N'
Here the part withincurled bracketsconsistsonly of proportionalfrequencyand,
neglectinginfluenceof randomsampling,would remain unchangedif N and N'
if we multiplyeach X2by
were modified. Accordingly,
(N + N')2 MM'
NN' X(M+M,)21
we shall reduce it to what would arise if we had the series M and M' instead of
1Vand N'. As thereis no reason whateverwhywe should not take as manyJews
as Gentiles,we mayput M = M', or the multiplieris (NV+ N')2/4NN'. For Hirsch's
data the multiplieris 1-16424,and forPearson's3 01753. Thus we have
M2 = 156 2127, MX% =708-1139,
TABLE v (b).
Crimesagainst PropertywithViolence.
Superficiallyit would appear that Crimes against the Person have decreased at
each age, and Crimesagainst PropertywithViolencehave increasedat each age*.
The x2 forTable v (a) = 2-0207indicatinga value of P forsix cells of *8460; the
samples forthe two yearsmightaccordinglyhave arisenfromthe same population,
or we cannot by this test assert a fall in the five years of Crimes against the
Person.
Turning to Table v (b) we have X'2= 10-5304 with P' = 0626; this is not
absolutelyagainst the 1925 and 1930 resultsbeing samples of the same popula-
tion-if they were, one sample in about 17 would give a greater discrepancy
betweenthe two yearsthan the presentone-but it does not like the P of the x2
of thefirsttable suggestno change in the intensityof crimeforthe twoyears.
We may now turn.to the usual secondaryproblem: Is it likely that such
changesas are exhibitedin the two tables are compatiblewitha commonorigin?
We ask iftheX'2andx2 couldarisefromsamplingfroma common source.We do
not definethis commonsource; it maybe that both crimesagainst the personand
against propertywith violenceat each age are decreasingor are stationaryor are
*
It is to be notedthat the data pay no attentioni
to changesin the populationof each age group in
the fiveyears.
Applicationsin Statistics
320 FFurther of Tm(x) BesselFunction
increasing.None of these possibilitiesis definitelyruled out by an overwhelming
but some of themare not veryprobablein eitherone or othercase.
improbability,
We have to considerwhetherX'2and x2 are improbableas a resultof samplingfrom
a commonpopulation.
test will be the morestringent,but
Our Fig. 3 again showsthat the difference
we are not so farfromthe v = 6 curveas to believe the two tests will differmuch
in any inferenceto be drawnfromthem. We have at once,
TABLE vi (b).
Females.
The main featureof the two tables is the decreasein juvenile and the increasein
adult thieving. Is the sourceof this the same forthe two series*?
The X'2for Table vi (a) is 272 6336, which forv = 7 connotesa probability
P' < 000,0001 forthe two yearsbeing samples ofthe same population. The x2 for
Table vi (b) is 42'7161, connotinga probabilityP < 000,0005 for the two years
being samples of the same population. Thus in the case of bothmalesand fenmales
therehas been a most significantchange in the age distributions.We then turn
to the problemof whetherthis change can be attributedto the same sourcein the
two sexes. We have
12/X2= 6 3825 and _
JX'2 Jx2= 114 95875.
Turiningto the ratio test first,
Qx/2/x2= 2I.i (3, 3)
= 0403.
On the ratio test accordinglythe odds are about 24 to 1 against twvosuch values,
x'2and x2,occurring, iftherewerea common source.We shouldsaythereforethat
it was unlikely,but not excessivelyimprobablethat the age changes in larceny
were the same forthe two sexes.
We next take the difference
test,
'2-i2=2 { ,5-S2. (114 95875)}.
The value of this S2.5 functionlies outside our table, but we can say it is con-
siderablygreaterthan 2.5(18) = -499,9996,or we have
TABLE vii.
Schoolboys.
CentralHeightsin Inchesof 12 yearsold Worcestershire
Group 48 49 50 51 52 53 55 56 57 58 59 60 61 62 63 64 Totals
Mean Variance 3
* "A StatisticalStudyof Oral Temperatures,"by M. H. Williams, M.B., Julia Bell, M.A. and Karl
Pearson. Studies in National Deterioration,Drapers' CompanyResearchMemoirs,No. IX, Table LXII,
p. 109, CambridgeUniversityPress.
KARL PEARSON,S. A. STOUFFERANDF. N. DAVID 323
we can test forits probabilityby the integralof the normal curve. When we do
not knowthe parent population,the best value to give to Z appears to be that of
the combinedsamples. But here a question arises: Should 2 be taken equal to
2 (i2' + 42), whichit would be if actuially$2= $1-our hypothesis-or to
i (2' + /12) + 4 (-$2
whichis the observedvalue? We inclineto the latteralternative. Accordingly
(-72)-Vn1)
'%)n -6875 x4 8097
v/I2 + /2 + i ($2- l2 411v534,5O5
in our presentcase.
The probabilityof a ratio as large as or larger than this is *20906,and taking
the possibilityof either sign for x2- x, we have *4181 for the chance of a
deviationof this size. The test thereforeindicates that it wouldbe legitimateto
considerthe difference between Z2 and xl as due to randomsampling.
If we take for 12 the value 6-539,012of the aggregate, whichwould render
our theorymore accurate*, we find the probability= 4470, and although this
to some extentfrom4181, it leads to preciselythe same conclusion.
differs
(b) XYe may adopt "Student's z test." Here the same assumption of
normalityforthe parentpopulationis made,but we divide X2 - $1 by the observed
= V/(/I2
standarddeviationof the difference + p1) Thus in our case
*=6875 *20454,
V11298,177
fromwhichwe obtain the chance of the mean difference of the samples lyingout-
side + 6875 to be *4406,a value lying between the two values deduced from
method(a), and thus confirmingthe resultthat the schoolsveryprobablyhave-the
same mean statureforboys of 12.
But to assume thismakesno sensibledifference alreadydrawn
in the concluisions
with regardto the variancesof the two samples.
TABLE viii.
in Children.
Pulse Rate and BodyTemperature
Pulse Rate
Body 48 50 52 54 56 58 60 62 64 66 68 70 72 74 76
Temperature 49 51 53 55 57 59 61 63 65 67971 73 75 7TOta1
A. 98A4... ... 3 7 6 5 1 - -- .
_ 22
B. 994 ... ... - 2 2 8 5 3- 2 - 22
A and B.. ... _. 3 7 8 7 9 5 3 - 2 - 44
All Temperatures 3 33 91 189 272 134 88 34 12 7 2 2 - 1 1 869
Now Y= (- +P -f X)
and forour particularcase
Y= 87'003,946.
Again,the curve being given by
Z = JNTn (p + l) -i (Y)
4( (p + 1) {ft(p + 1) + 1)
* T is measuredfromstartof the pulse ratecurve,whereasT.' and x,, are absolutevalues of the means.
KARL PEARSON, S. A. STOUFFER AND F. N. DAVID 327
but the latterfactorin the exponentis unityto the same degree of accuracyas we
have used in passing fromthe Type VII to the normalcurve.
Thus our Bessel functionTm(Y) curvehas reducedto the normalcurve
2Zn ' - x.)
222
z =Ze (1vi),
=zoe-* .......................
preciselythe curvefromwhichwe obtainedourfirstresultthatthe twomeanswere
not compatiblewithbeing randomsamples fromthe pulse rate population.
It may seem a misfortunethat the example chosen does not fall within the
range of Table I.- We will accordinglytry if we have any better luck with the
ratio method. This is providedby Equation (xlii). But about this equation an im-
portantpoint must be borne in -mind,$n' and $n are not the absolute means,but
thosemeans measuredfromthe startofthe curve. We musttherefore subtracta or
5 962,908fromZ the modalvalue or 55-418,303,to get the startof the curvewhich
is accordinglyat 49-455,398pulse rate*. Thus we have
=n -60O181,818 - 49 455,398= 10O726,420
and Xi = 54 454,546 - 49455,398 = 4-999,148,
givingthe ratio$'/$ = 2-145,650,or
QE,/=2I.j79o(112-583,526, 112-583,526).
-
( _,'2)mdx'
test foreesus
* It mustbe remarkedthat in this case as in othersthe ratio as well as the difference
to make appeal by way of knowledgeor of hypothesisto the real or supposed parent population. See
furtheron this point p. 328, ftn.
21-2
328 FurtherApplicationsin Statisticsof Tm(x) Bessel Function
But m is so large thatwe can safelyreplaceourcurveby the normalcurve,and thus
Jr5 e_4mw'2 dx'
Q$n'ln=2+.5
=2 1821 d'
e-4MX/2 dxt
Write 4mx'2= - 42, and we have
Q7 nIlx-=21;_ 7ree d.
\8rnx1821
thus -2f - .2
QF
or,using the probabilityintegraltable of the normalcurve, -000,000,05. Thus we
see that on the ratio hypothesisthe randornnessof the two samnples
is onlyslightly
less improbablethan on the difference test. Both involvea knowledgeof thepulse
ratedistribution.It nmay be asked,what can we learnwithoutthisknowledge?The
replymustbe that we can onlyworkwith the combinedA and B as representing
to some extent*(!) the generalpulse rate distribution.This gives
/31= 237,7557, o:= 3 863,8146, p + 1 = 16 823,9941
= n (p + 1)-
in1 = 365 627,8?71,
or z = INT35.627,8n (1337 57,708),
a value still fartherremovedthan beforefromthe range of m and Y in the Tmand
Sm tables, and still more appropriateto the application of a normal curve. The
* In manycases probablywe could appeal to experienceas to what sortof value is likelyto take;
/l
we knowits value formanytypesof variate,weight,pulse rate,barometerheights,etc. If we do not have
any suggestionfromexperience,the onlyvalue we can take is thatobtainedfromthecombinedsamples,
even if it appears ludicrousto find81 on fortycases. But is it afterall verymuch more absurd than
findinga varianceon twentycases,whichtheproblemalso requires?Again,itmaybe said thatthedifference
testmakes moreappeal to or hypothesesabout the supposed or knownparentpopulationthan the ratio
testdoes. But the reader mustnot forgetthat the whole theoryof x'2in relationto x2 is based on the
assumptionthat the relative frequenciesof the parent population may be replaced by the relative
frequenciesof the combinedsamples. This is clear enoughif we approach x2 as Pearson has done in
Bionietrika,Vol. viii. p. 252.
If FR/Jllbe the relationfrequencyof the sth categoryof the parentpopulationM, thenthe truex2 iS
givenby
'
SsS'NN N';/
f8I\2 /E,
(N +N') /MN
F8
and it is not till we put A ,fX,i.e. the relativefrequencyof the combinedsamples, thatwe obtain
JIl N?+N'')
the value given by various writersforX2.In otherwords,the verybasis of the x2 methodis an appeal
to the combinedsample relativefrequenciesas a representationof an infiniteparentpopulation. The
weakniessof this whenthe samples may consistof 10 to 20 individualsis onlytoo obvious.
KARL PEARSON, S. A. STOUFFER AND F. N. DAVID 329
forX12:?U2 andforX2: /2
~M2M2
where M2S=i (p2' +.tj) + j ("- )2 = 14-929,063,or 6 6293 and 3-2862 are the
required values. The diagram indicates that this point is well outside the curve
v = 22, and thus the ratio will give the morestringenttest.
We have forthe purposeof illustrationused throughoutboth tests,but Fig. 3,
p. 308, willalwaysenable the investigatorto choosea priori the testwhichprovides
the lesserprobability.
(16) We next turn to the importantproblemof determiningfromthe mean
square contingencieswhethertheymay be consideredas samples froma common
parentpopulation.Now if we have a x x X contingencytable,whereK 3 X,the mean
square contingency )12 must lie between 0 and X -1.
Thus as faras a Pearson curve may be consideredapplicable-this is our first
condition-it must theoreticallybe of the limitedrange typeor ofform
y = yo [d/12].....................
( i2Y'I (p - 0112p2 (lvii),
wherep= X-1. In the case of such a curveof knownrange the values of pl and
P2 can be determinedin termsof the mean 012 and of the variance. Let these be
412
and a then we have
1) (
pi +1 = +1)2 (4 (P- *.) (
lviii).
P2+1 =(-0) ( _1)-1
Now when the size of the sample is fairlylarge,the varianceof 012 will be a small
quantitycomparedwiththe productof the two segmentsof the range as divided
by the mean S612,i.e. 4.12 (p - 012).
The mostunfavourablecase forthe largenessof eitherpi or p2 occurswhenthey
are nearlyequal and N the size of the sampleis small. For example,if 4i2= *5and
a'2,L2 is of the order*01and Kc= X = 2, thenpl = P2 = 11 . (lvii) becomes in this case
a Type II curve and the distributionof means of samples fromsuch a curvehas
not yet been solved in any practicallyuseful manner. But the /82 forthis case is
about 2-8 and we should not errgreatlyby treatingthe distributionas practically
normal*, and then the distributionof the means of 2 wouldalso be normal.
ProfessorKondo has made a second experimentfora 3 x 3 table withN= 250
(loc. cit.in footnotebelow, pp. 441, 419-420). The numberof cells is here again
* ProfessorKondo (Biometrika,Vol. xxi. pp. 416-418) has dealt with a case of this kind. He has
dealt with the observedmean and variance of 012 in 804 samples of 100, froma parentpopulationof
0i2= 5; here the observedvalue of 12=499,8005 renderedthe curveslightlyskew.
KARL PEARSON, S. A. STOUFFER AND F. N. DAVID 331
p12/,12
= 1-2S 1+1ije (01t2 -12)1 . (xi).
plj+ l= xF=i(K-1)(X-1) (1 + ){ (- (v +
p N2~N N
1+ v+ ( 1 ( 1)(v +
+) + V ...(lxvi).
so that we cannotpass to the 012 test by writingmerelyv = KX. This would only
be true if Kcand X were verylarge indeed,whichwould be veryrare in practical
work. For the like reasonpi + i can onlybe taken as i (v - 2), wherev = KcX,when
notonlyN is verylarge but (c + X - 2)/(KX)is a verysmall fraction.For example,if
K = X= 10, or a contingencytable of 100 cells,whichis veryunusual,we can hardly
assertthat 18/100is a verysmall fraction.
Next turningto p2 we have
P2 + 1 = I N X- 1) {1-K N (1 + )(1+ + (1 X1
- - 2) (v +
=IN(x 1) (1+ v (c- 1)+ ( l 1)
{(X -}) . ..(xvii).
1 +- = .989,975,
p
leading by (lviii) to
pi= 7-2815 and p2 =816-7803.
Workingwith(lxii) we have at once
V= 16-3- =12-5,
whence F= 800 (1 + *03125+ *0013)= 826-0400.
Thus p,= 7-2811 and P2 = 816'7589.
We see thereforethat the two methodsaccordwell,and furtherthatP2 is so
where se = 204,1897.
large that (lix bis) will adequatelyexpressthe distribution,
Finally,by (lxi), the probabilityof the occurrenceof the difference
01 -2_ 12 = .05
is given by P12_2= 1- 287.7815(10 2095).
And again = 21222,2n2
Q0l8/IL2 (832815,8 2815).
Both involve a twofoldinterpolationwith regardfirstto the arguments,and
secondlyto the ordersof the functions.For the purpose of appreciatingthe pro-
babilitiesthe hyperbolicformula* will suffice.From Table I we find
(102095) = *4920,0818
S7-7815
and thus POL,2_0L2= -01598.
Again fromTable II we have
1.222,222(8-2815, 8'2815) = *008,324,230,
and accordingly Qo1t2/12 = *01665.
Such values would onlylead us to say that it is notveryprobablethat 01'2 and
were samples froma population having zero contingency.Here, as so often,
the difference test is, if onlyslightly,still morestringentthan the ratio test.
In orderto determinethis'a priorifromourdiagram,Fig. 3, p. 308, we mustfirst
findv fromthe relationi (v - 2) = 7-7815, or v = 17-563. The curvecorresponding
to this is nearly mid-waybetweenthe curvesforv = 17 and 18. Corresponding to
x2 and RX2we have Eq12 and e-112, or 8+1676and 28-5866. This point is just inside
the v = 18 curveand so clearlywithinthe v = 17-563curve; thusthe difference test
is the morestringent.
(18) The previoussection indicates that the solution of the problemof two
mean square contingenciesarisingas samplesfromthe same populationis relatively
easy,if that populationhas zero contingency.This followsfrointhe factthat the
approximateexpressionsfor 12 and a0,i2 are knownand relativelysimnple.In the
case where the contingencyis not zero the problenm is muchharder,as although
approximateexpressionsare knownfor012 and cr2al2they are laborious to determine
in particularcases.
* Tablesfor Statisticiansand Biometricians,Part II. Formula (a), p. xviii,i.e.
= + oXzol+ 0&Zio+ Xz1'-.................................... (lxviii).
tzx 00oo
334 FurtherApplicationsin Statisticsof Tm(x) Bessel Function
Illustration(x). We will firstillustrate the method in a particularexample
providedby Kondo and then considerwhat is needed in order that the values of
is and a2,a2 mightbe obtainedmorereadily.
Kondo took 250 samplesof size 200 froman infinitepopulationofa 3 x 3 table
withthe followingproportionalfrequencies*:
Now Kondo has given the 250 values of 412 whichhe obtainedforhis samples;
the largestof these is '370,502 and the least '054,2014. Let us inquirewhatis the
chanceof such a difference occurringin samplesof 200 takenfromthe table above.
The difference
01'2 '316,301 and the ratio 1't2/012= 6'835,704; hence we
-_ =
require
S8.21,064(11'808,316),
and (8'712,064,8'712,064).
IL27,6n
Using the hyperbolicinterpolationformula(lxviii), we find
S8=212,00'(11808,316)=496,3113,
and .127,621(8'712,064, 8'712,064) = 000,111,08.
Accordingly p,L,2_,2= '007,3774 and QOL,/,OL2= '000,222,16.
' Biometrika, Vol. xxi. p. 411.
t Biometrika, Vol. xxi. p. 419. 1 Ibid. p. 412.
KARL PEARSON,S. A. STOUFFERANDF. N. DAVID 335
S612 C+ -N IV2 1
_
+ 2)2t*@--@6@?6s6**li
............(lxix),
=f, *2
(2+1 +
.
-
............(lxx).
N4)i2(P )i2)2}
P2 = f
* Biometrika,Vol. xxi. p. 413.
t They are in factthe chances thatan individualwill be drawnfromeach particularcell.
T 012 is of course the mean of the mean squared contingency of samples and only approaches$,2
as N is increased.
in Statisticsof Tl,,(x) BesselFunction
336 FurtherApplications
These expressionsdo not contain #l, #2 orf2, whichwould not thereforerequire
calculation. How farcan (lxx) be used instead of (lviii) and the fullerbut still
incompleteresults(lxix)? This cannot be determinedtill far more experimental
workhas been undertakenon the twosetsofapproximations.We mayplace herethe
formulaefromwhichOi2 and fi are to be determined.Let Cpq be the chance that an
individualwill be drawn fromthe pth rowqth column,Cp. the chance that it may
be drawnfromanywherein the pth rowand C.q fromanywherein the qth column.
q=x
C.q)and Cp. = S
Let Cpq = Cpq/(cp. Cpq, i.e.thesumoftheCpq forthepth row; in the
q=1
same mannerlet C., S Cpq or be the sum of C., forthe qth column. Then
p=1
=12 (Cpq) - 1 ....... "I (lxxi),
whereX denotesa summationforthe wholetables,and
f4= (42pq\ -( q (C 2q +
21 . *..(lxxii).
p..
Cpq p= ' Cp. q=1 C.q /Cpq
*
Kondogivesfi = 801,842,butwe have failedto finda slip in our arithmetic.This leads to p=7 7059,
p.2= 76-271 and PIP1 ~=J 00490.
KARL PEARSON, S. A. STOUFFER AND F. N. DAVID 337
=
C.q | 283,5513 512,9879 -392,3533 | Cptht1?188,8925
Ithuis~2= 188,8925
Sv C2p) 1-426,6992
c2.q -0804,0134 -2631,5659 -1539,4111 CP
(Sq = 1-432,2344
qCL
Cq~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~.
-365,7932 -538,7034 -527,7378 2 (CC-PY=I+S2. +S3.
= 1-636,6847
p=3(-('0 1) S p (P2
(0=3
c ) | S C ) | pyCp. C")
p=1 Cpq pJ1 p=1 (ilCPI
Cpl CP2 p=1 Cp (,p
= 1-1930,5669 =1 1636,4101 =1-2280,4222 9 1-4170530
Sarmex C.q *33812928 -596,9338 -481,8264
Finally,by (lxxii),
=4 x 1-636,6847- 3 x 1-426,6992- 3 x 1-432,2344+ 2 x 1-417,0530
= -804,0440.
Applicationsin Statisticsof Tm(x) Bessel Function
338 Fuqrther
Curves of this formare knownto be accuratewhenwe are samplingfroma popula-
tion,whereinthereis no correlationofcharacterand thedistributionis ofnormaltype.
Equations (lviii) to findpi and p2 will then apply and we may writethem
2
pl + l s(f 2,9 ), p2+1=(-s) df-)
The values ofp, and p2 can be determinedif the mean and varianceof '2 or R2 be
known.
If eitherp, or p be large,say p2, we are thrownback on the Type III curve
y= Yo' (J2P2 92)P,e-42P2 ,2 l (lxv)
or y= yo'(J2p2 R2)Pi e Jxv),
R2.l
and accordinglythe distributionof the differenceof the ,2 of two samples,or the
R2, will be given by
y _MT= 11 I.2(n12 _ n2)} .
i (lxxvi),
or y= iMITp,T+1
{pp(R2 _ R2)}
and Table I can be applied, or
(fl'2 _ .
PI, _2 = 1-2Spl+j {P2 2) . (lxxvii).
and PR,2 _ R2 = 1 - 2Spl+j{p2(R2 _ R2)} .......
It is needlessto add that the ratio test can be also used in such cases, or
Q,,21/,,=2I __ (pl+l,pl+1)
and QR2/R
= 1
2I 1 (p + 1 + 1. (lxxviii).
1+ R12/R2
IV= MY" x YV M7( r+l)r(2 + l) e-Yju+y,v) Ur, VrT [du dv] . . .(lxxxi).
Let us firstapproachthisfromthe standpointof the ratioofv to u, and writez = v/u.
Then (lxxxi) becomes
1 (T1 + 1) 1 (ra + 1)
Write = (ryl + rY2Z) u and we have
W M1r+1 '(
F(fM(Tj 2+
*
1)e e-t~rTT+r2+1 [d4dz].
t+ir(2 (71T+ + ry2Z)rl+r2+2
z7)T+2+
Jo
1+ !.0 _Ya
w1
whereI is the functiontabled in the IncompleteB-functionTable now at press.
(x) Bessel Function
Applicationsin Statisticsof Tmn
340 Futrther
Just as earlier (see p. 306) we should add to this the other equal wedge for
1
U/V > zo, or z taking values from0 to -. Calling this P"z, we have, from
(lxxxiii),
1
t2 dz
z
p =B yrT+1 7Y22+? z
B (ri + 1, T2 + 1 )J (71+ Y2Z)Tl+T2+2
+.X071
Y2
+ Lo.2 1 + X--Y
Yi 72
a resultinvolvinga double entryinto the B-functionTable.
Thus, if we use the ratio test, (lxxxvi) shows that the determinationof Qzo
involvesverylittle moretroublethan in the cases we have alreadydealt withwhen
71= 72 and r1= T2
Accordingly
1 { (n1- 1), (n2- 1)1+I{I(n21 - 1),.E(n, - 1) ... (lxxxvii).
Q2/=12=I
QO'2'2 2tF
1 2-b
+-- I'2 21
~~~~~~1+ -2
A question may arise as to whetherthe sum of the two I-functionsmay not be
greaterthan unityand so Q022/,12> 1 and impossible. Clearly the denominatorsof
ratiosare equal, since
both B-fuinction
B {1 (ni-1), E (n2-1)1 =B {(1(n2-1) i (nl-1)}.
We can thereforewrite QI22/,12 in the form
2/0,12B
QO'2 1(v-3), -3)}
-21(n2
KARL PEARSON, S. A. STOUFFER AND F. N. DAVID 341
where 1
1 ~~~~~1
and '=
1+ a2 n2 + O2-n
0.22 aj8 n2
Writex = 1- x' in the secondintegral,and we have
Q A(n-3)
(1n-lX)i(N2-8) dx+ f a' j(n1-3) (1 - x')i("r-3)dx'
122 n2a212
~~~2
2n
+-72- 1 +-.2 n-
0.1
22
or that 1< 2
a'l
This curve is allied to the Tm(x) Bessel Function curve and passes into it when
= T2= r, but as faras we are aware has not yet been studied. Its consideration
is leftforanotheroccasion. If T1 = r2=r and we write
Y= (1 + 72) Y, p = 72 'Yl
" and rn= +j,
72+7Y1
we have, by the properchoice ofwo01,
(1 _ p2)m+i e -Py T2,( Y') [dY'] ...... (lxxxviiibis),
z=M
Tm(Y') not changingsign with Y', and whenwe put Y' negativewe get the other
sectionof thearea we need to integrateto get rid ofX as in ? (3), p. 295. This cuirve
has been fullydiscussed in Biomerika, Vol. xxi. pp. 168-187. Its area when
integratedforY' between- oc and + so equals M, and we have its ordinatestabled*.
* See Biornetrika, Vol. xxi. pp. 195-201, or Tables for Statisticiansand Biometricians,Part II,
pp. lxxix-lxxxviii and pp. 138-144.
BiometrikaXXIV 22
342 FurtherApplications in Statisticsof Tmn
(x) Bessel Function
In termsofthedifference
Y,
Z= =M (71
(4y17
+ y)r?1
e2)2.t?
-
e+2VaV Yr+
T+ {i (Y1 + 7Y2) Y} [dY] . . .(lxxxix).
Thiscurveforpracticalpurposesmaybe replacedbya Pearsoncurveof thesame
firstfourmoments afterT= 11*.
Illustration.It maybe asked forwhattypeof variateswouldit be adequate
to have , = r2? We replyat once for92 and R2, when the sizes of the samplesare
considerableas conmpared withthe numberofarraysin 1?2 or the numberof variates
involvedin R2. This is the case wherewe are jfistifiedin usingrEquations (lxxv),
and consequently(lxxxix). If n be the numberof arraysor the total numberof
v.ariates,and N, IV' be the sizes of the samples,then we have
Tj= T2 = T= i ( - 3),
while y1j=j(i-n-2), 'Y2=i(N'-n-2),
and the curveof distribuition of;say,t'2 - q2 will be given by
= M {(N -n
2) (N' -2)}Fl
-2) -n N'-N YT
Z =_z2MAl e-I N'-2 t4) Y} [dY],
j (N N) - ni- 2}n-2 4n-2) {i(Nl+
where y}=,72
-2 .................................... (xc),
aiid we assume the parentpopulationto be withoutassociationin its characters.
There is small difficulty in plotting this curve fromDr Elderton'sTable of
ordinates,and at presentthe plainimeter or a quadrature formulamust be applied
to determiine the requisiteareas beyond the values + (q'2 _ q2) observed. An im-
portantpoint arises froinboth the Equations (lxxxviii) and (lxxxix),namelythat
whenthe sizes of the samples are unequal, then the differenceof two statistical
measuresdoes not give a symmetricalcurve,but one whichlike that of the distri-
bution of the firstprodtuct-momyrent coefficientmay be notablyskew. The fuller
discussionof these curves must,however,be left to a furtherpaper. It may be
asked: Why,if the ratio-testgives an adequatelysinlple expressionforthe proba-
bility, should we deal furtherwith the more complicated expressionsfor the
probabilityof the difference?The answer,we think,is that the resultsof the two
testsare oftennot so closelyin accordthat we can be confidentone may not fora
particularcase be morecorrectthan the other. The probabilitydeduced leads at
once to a frequency, and the touchstoneof the more correcttest is that it should
give this frequencythe moreexactlyand moreoften.The onlyway of determiining
this is the experimentalone. This would not be hard in the case of the range of
x2'sbased on pairs ofsamplestaken froma uni-variatepopulation. It would,how-
ever,be farnmore laboriousin the case of samiplecontingencytables taken froma
bi-variatetable. Still it is to be hopedthatsuch workwill eventuallybe undertaken.
(22) General Conclusions.
The main purposeof the presentpaper has been to discussan alternativeto the
ratio methodin dealing witha numberof statisticalcoefficients,such as X2,O2,)2,
2, R2, (2, whichon certainhypothesesas to the parentpopulationobey accurately
* loc. cit. p. 181.
KARL PEARSON, S. A. STOUFFER AND F. N. DAVID 343
y
=
yol (V
_X%2)& ~
N)(1- +N *( N'
whichtakes the formof (e.,)if N + N' be verylarge. The Type III curveis therefore no moreexact in
the case of x2than it is in the case of 2 or R2, it dependsupon the largesize of N+N'. This pointis
frequently overlooked,but it is actuallyinvolvedwhen we replacethe binomialdistributionsby normal
curvesin our deductionof (e2).
22-2
344 FurtherApplicationsin Statisticsof T,,,(x) Bessel Function
m r-.4 cq M ',t XO W 1- GO = C
m -'t e: Co r- OD m 0 M xo 00 0
61 .l & 'N 6q 6q t
.el
PI-,)
.114 in. km m aq 11114 00 LO N 0
m xo 1- -t 't xo 00 0 m m N Co m N. M Lm t- m 0 0 00 00 m t- m to
- M r-4 N 01 o W 0 Ql GI r-4 t- 0 N "--4 00 M W =
M XO 00 0 Gq M M Gq 00 00
In w 'It C)
+
O Gq
m
=
1-
"14
QC
r--4 w
m
t-
=
xo
00
m
M
R
o
00
C.N
Co
00
r-4
"-4
Xn Co
00 r--4
,14 t-
r-
=
1-
OC) r-
r--4 CD
L-
aq
M
,,14 C)
M
(=)
14
Gq
k-,M
10 xo
C) r--j
t-
aq
Xn
00
t-
r-
Co
(::>
C)
r--4 r--4 00
I
cq
=
t-
10
00
CD
Co
ql
Gq
m
Xo
CeD
00
XM
00
M
t 1- 00 = 0 C) 0 m 00 I- Co "t N. C)
M t- 0 ,14 r- -4 -,t t- 0 M Co 00 0 aq Co 0
14 aq M XCD W 1- 00 oo m 0 '--4 GI ?.YZ
r-4 Gq ,!t kf W oo M 0 GI M 10 t- QC
0 0 0 0..... 0 Gq C. m
..... M. m
......C) 0 ..... ..... .....
+ m = t- r--4 00 w
+to Co m w 1- 00
0 xn oc t- P-4 xn V' r--4 M. t- 00 0 aq
r--4 00 r--4 Gq m 0 Co O N C-q X0 "-4
't M 00'0 " 0 W Xo Co C.' ^."
M " N 00 0 = L t- 'Tt
.14 M r-4 W 00 M W 00 = t- N.
--4 r-4 N. C V. M M N. N, 0 m t- xn m
--,14 00 -t r-
N Gq C't to
. . . . m.
xo t- 00 C C)
. . .
C1.1 't CO
. 'NM
4'- 00 m 0
. Gq
ko t- oc N Itt
. . . . .
0
C>
. . . . . .
80-000,C) 0
. . . . .
- r-4 --4 r-4 r--4 r--4 P--4 r--4 N. m m ^m
t- I- 00 00 k- W XO 'I GI O t-
O in. r- W cq V- Gq I- N. CO '--q XO Gq xo 00 o M 't CO
C"Z -t C f- M C) M Co 1- C' M " I 4 XO
f.,l (=) -j M tJ4 xo Co t- 00 aq Co Co
+Ll + M
+
N. Co 14 r--4 N, 10 ill 00 p- Xn Cq = m m 00 O t-
C)
m r-4 Co Gq C.14 m M r--4 CO CC (m 00 oo 00 (M 'Itt
O C) C.0 m -t xn r--4 L- (M -t C) -It m C)
0 M C) 00 t- Di GI m m Gq P--4 CD t- "t I- Co cq
oo = 00 t- t 0 14 ^.' M r-.4 km t- Itt
+ +
+
0 r--4 I- M 11,14 00 ^M aq -t 1.14 xo cq m *1 w
I- V- ,!14 r-4 0 Xn In C 00 N 00 ko
t- r--A = = r-4 xo 0 Co It Co m t- 00 0 Gq
t 14 00 7 1- M 00 (=> Zo ,Z11 M C) Co (=)
"-4 Xn 14
1- m GI CO 'tt oo = 00 = (m Co = to (M r- 0
t- "'t = M "'14 Vz 00 0
OC 1- XL-D 1- '114 -4,14 C O
U-
. ._4 -,14 00 Gq U., 00 C) M -,14 -. N. '-4 Cj Co CY.
cl' in. t- C= P--4 N. "t Co t- C., C) N. vz xo CO L- = "-4 N. OZ "t LO CO t- V- 00 m 0
-- r-4 N, N GI Cv".' Cy., m VI., M VD m m m M m Nt
r- P--4 --4 -4 N. N, G9 N. . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
14) +jf +
Gq _111 (Z> Co r- M C) ,tJ4 X , r, 00 M t- 00 1- 00 OC>
m
t CC 14 (M N.
Co
xo
1-
(0
Gq
00
m Co
O vt "It m O IN (::> V'., C) o xn w m N14 40
4.Q
W Gq p-4 -,t r--4 Cq Co Xo (M 1- C) 00 Gq XO tO
cq M -.4 CC 0 00 r--4 00 xCD 00 14 M. Co
CO Gq 00
r -- 4 -. I M.. Co -4 Xo (M N It
r-4 C.'l ,14 xo W L- 00 <7. C) - r-4
g! N. -t CZ OC N -It tO 00 (M r--4 t- OC) 0 M
. 'i . . . .tJ4
. M,, 14
. n. M. M. CV.
M M
. . . . M.
"-4 _4 m-4 Cy'. 14
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
"-4 14 14 14 M Cq 0 p-
C) Cvn. -t Xo Cq M L" 00 N
t Co t- 0 r-4 M LO CO L- 00 C) 0 r-I N
G4 00 C) oq -V xn
. . .d4 .t vt.
t
r . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .,YD
. m
. v. . . . t
-1Z +
t I +
P-Z 'iC O OC)
kr
'IN
L-
aq
oc
OC)
OC
O
00 o
1- W 00 r- W X000 (M X0 MWOO
1.10 .-4
;4 'n '.q W
'4'tXr '.t
X
m 00
C) t- QC 0 0
(M
Gq
xo
Q
CD
XM
t-
N
cq
CO
r--4
0 00 M-
Gq
O
t-
O
ac xo Vl N M xm '- O N m 0 t- 00 W 0 C)
C 10 C". or, C w I- Itt w '.t 1-11 N GI =
4.Q
cq 00 r--4 to Gq aq 00 r-4 00 m t- xo 00 C
(Z Lll r--4 O xo xr.) C) 't M .!t N lt'
t xo w m m 00 0
OC CID C -il r.,^. m 0 '.-vt .- W w C> m 0 M. 10 xo m
N m I.- Lo ao w M 00 m xr It
0 C.,:) xn. 00 I - xn L- evz l- C) Co m
t- 0 (:7, -t X ,!14 -,14 OC) C.,j W = rq xCl
W 00 00 1- Xn N (:r
km "t Co I- oo Gq -t XCD 10 C-0 W Co I- t-
;t :n "It 'T VI"
N. N. r.,I M CeD M ^. '.N M M m -t4 't 'It -t -V -t -t -t - -t -t
C. O . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . .
+ +
-4 Co M m -t P-4 C) U- C 00 m xr.) 0 I- QC C"l C-1400 r--4
-t M r-li tc .O C) OC) w OC) 0
r--l 1-0 t M N. OC 00 C) M W -tl -t O (n '_4 Co N. oo m '- m L- [- "'t '--4 M 0 00
C)
M V., CO M N m 00 GI O "It xcz r--4 xn. Co xo N. Co 0
C) n r--4 -t 1- C^. 0 Lll M 00
ac -t m aq eD t- OC) oc Co C) C C) X m Gq to 00 0 r. O r- m
C) el) Gq "liq
JL- r-q M rq -V CO oc) M O r-4 (1-4 em - I- I- 00 00 00 0c) OC) 00 M
o q
. . . . . . . . . . .
-t 't '-!t -'t -t 'I
. . . . .
-,V -It -t --It
. . . .
-It -' Nt "t It -t It
km w r- oo m C) N. M "'t 10 W t-- 00 (m 0
D aq m It x:: C-0 t- OC)
KARL PEARSON, S. A. STOUFFER ANDF. N. DAvrD 3 4a'
+ + I I
t- 00 Lo N. r--l ka 00 VD as Vj It 11 M 00 M w M VD ko M CM 0 CO aq r--l 00 W -.q"L- C; w t- ":t M
m t- 00 t- 11 m Gq CYD m m GN xo m xo m ^M Gq 11-t C11404 11 m m 11 00 t- IRt l-Rlt00 t- "IZP m GN to m t- co 00
o m 't m 0 11 t- L- 10 r-4 --4 10 m 0 N GN m m -It 0 m m m r--4 w 0 m lzll m t- 00 00 m (71.1C., mzm
10 Gq m m m m xo P-4 r- m oo co Nt 00 00 c Gq CD 0 vt 'Tt m t- co 00 m m m m m m m m m m mm=
Gq TIZ n I" 10 km m r- r- 00 o Gq Nt km CD t- 00 00 m m 01. m m m m mmmmm m m m m m m m m
m m m m VD VD M VD VD m -V It 11 " 1.14 1-t "iq I" Nt ":t " I" It 1114Nt Itt -P "It 11 11 11 Ikt "liq 't Nt
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
(o co t- m w 00 zo io 1- to CD It c Gq t- t- t- 10 m Nt m r- w 10 0 m
m 00 r--l m 1.11 t- Gq km 1- 1.11 00 m km m 00 vl moo m
wt-0000mmmm mm=
8 100 mkm r--4 r--l r- L- Nt m Gq to w L- 00 m m
10VD
0 r-VDo co
01 Gq r-4 w O r-4 M CD O r-, 't t- t- M 0 M ^M aq 114 0 r-4
r-4 t- m t- m r-4 m Gq C) 10 m N 1t m t- 00 00 m m m m m m m m m m m mm=
VD lw 10 to m k- r- 00 00 m r--l m km m r- oo 00 00 m m m m m m m m m m m m mmmmm =mm
m VD VD m VD VD VD m I.YD m "iq "iq "iq Nt Itt IRt ll!t " Nt 1"4 11 11 11 11141114 Nt 11 11 't I" "liq IRt IRt v IT14 I" IRt "liq
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
I I + + +
00 10 ":t r--l M 10 Gq 00 00 t- CO rM M w N Lo .1 00 lomo N= 0 "14 0 t "t 00 - 1- 00 ko 0 M w
r--l m 00 1- m t- 0 00 m to r-4 t- GM 0 00 0 "It 0 r- r- N t- 00 r- CD t- 't m cq xo CD t- 00 m (M m
oo C) m w 0 aq Gq 00 m to Nt Nt to m 'Itt CO r" to M r- M 00 km M 04 L" CO t- 00 00 M M M M M MM=
r- ko r--l 00 to r-4 t- Gq 00 PM w IRt 00 m t- M 00 r--l ^M xo w t- 00 00 M M M M M M M M M M M MM=
Nt km m m t- oo 00 m m 0 Gq Nt ko CD 1- 00 00 m m m CZ m m C.N m m m m m m C) m m m m m 1-11 m
m m m VD I.YD M m ?.YD "M "It "It -1 Nt " It " I" -t -1-14It .1 11 11 't Nt N14 11 " Itt It 'Itt " 1-14111141.14 " "liq 1-d4
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 0 . . . . . . . . . .
+ I
w Ilt:vm 00 00 m 0 m Gq r--4 m C) I'll m CD r--l km al 'o t- t- M M "'14 M N CO m 0 ^M a,., n zo r--l t-
t- "liq CM Mi oo t- r--l m Itt io 1-4 km to r--l r--l 0 erz m 00 co 10 M t- 0 CO t- ":t M M ll') C t- 00 M m M 7.%
t- 00 m m GN m 't to to m km r--l m r- m 1-1 m r- t- '.14 M Gq io w L- 00 00 M M C." M M m M M m
I- I t- M 00 "14 M -tI4 ko Gq 10 '.14 r--f to 0 VD km w r- oo 00 M m m M M m M M '- M M m M (m M
w r- 00 00 m m 0 0 m km it- 00 co m m m m m m M m m m m m m m m m m m m m
VD CM. CY.%m VD VD VD 11 ltr " "It N14 It "'t "t "14 " '.14 Tp .1 'I 't "14 "d4 --t -,II '-t -" '" " -:r --t
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ". . . ". . . . . . . . . . .
+ I + + I
xo L- L- Nt t- L- Gq r--4 Nt t- xo 00 km m VD C) 00 11 aq CD m C) t- m r-4 -P I -
00 C-111 r-4 P..4 00 Cq In c 00 m
M in. t- C) " r-4 Gq t- t- N 00 km C) M C) Lo C> N. OD r.-I N. I- 0 = t- lf' C) -M a0 t- 00 00 M m M=M
m t- Gq 1t 't C) "iq lll Mj m w 11 ko t- w M =,--4 m o ":t (m GII Lo c 1- 00 M M ld- = = --- M M M M M
1114P-4 00 't C) co P-4 o r--4 to In 0 M-4 m In m ol xo w t- 00 00 M M (m M M I-M M (m m m m m m = m
r- 00 00 M 0 C) r-4 Gq N t- 1- 00 00 m m Cs m mm= cnm m m m m m M M M M m M M
Nt 11 114 v "It -t -t I-P 1-il It 11114 I" 'Itt Nt ":t
VD m
. .
VD VD "
. . .
1-t
. .
"
.
1114Nt
. . . .
Nt "
. .
"It
.
1:14 11
. . "
.
"iq -:14
. .
Nt
. . . . . . . . . . . . -t. . .
-t
. . .
I I I
m Gq C^. r- 00 0 I- Gq Nt xo CD CD m N m CD 00 N CD 00 elll (M I- c 00 CD '-.4 'Rt w 00 00 CC'd
r--l -II to = m = CD M. = r- C) M N oo 10 ry., o r--4 xo C) 0 r- r--' ":t w 1- 00 m m m m m m m
t- Nt t- t- "iq 00 C) m CD t- km Gq to aq 1- 'I m "14 m VD to 1- 00 00 m m m m m m m m m m C., C)
N 00 m 00 m t- cq km m 't 10 ^M x qq "t CD L- oo OD MMMMM M C') m M mmmmm m m
o r--lr-4 N
1114'14 '14 11
. . . .
N
1.14
.
VD
114
.
m
11
.
"'t
'14
.
":t 'tt
11114
. 1114
.
0 t- 00 00 M
. 0 . . .
lld4
N14 "liq 1111411114
m M
IR14 "iq
. .
M M C.,
11-14-14 ":t
. . .
MMM
. . 11
11 "
. . Nt
m
. 4 mmmmm
. -t
10 11 't .
. . . Itt
m m m m CT.,
.!:v '". 't. 't. 't.
m
.:t . .
+ I +
w 00 co m co m m 00 co m t- N m r--4xo Lo r- 00 r-4 00 t- C) V N r-4 00
o 00 r--40 Co 10 r--4XO N C40 W 11 N 'Itt t- V.%C.NM 10 t- 00 00 M M n m m m m
1-140 m m t- m r-4 r--lt- U-3 t- ko C) m 1.0 1- 00 00 m m m m m m m 0. m m m (01
m m m r- r-4 10 00 r-4 O'D Gq 00 cq 'Itt w 1- 00 m m m m m m m m m m m m m m <M C= C)
aq Gq m m 1.14 Nt in to to w t- 00 00 m m (m m m m m m m m m C., m m m C., m mm m =M m C)
o It "
. 1414
. .14 ". .V
1414
. . 1t
1414,14 . 1t
. .t . .di .14 .14
. 'Tp
10 . It. .,14 .14 .o 1414 . I't
. 1,14
. 1414 . 1414
. . .o . V
1414 . -,
. -P
. . -t
vV . -14
. . . in.
.
t- 00 M t- Cq LO QC W r--4W -4 10 "fd'-t W = 00 W N LO 1- 00 %d
Co Co -II Gq ,14 C) M tt 0 1t OC) W = Co 00 Co --4 -" CO 1- 00 M M M M M M C 0
?--410 M Gq M C) 00 M CO,-4 11 = t- 00 C.'M M M M M M M C-, M (7-1a,-,)
N. 1- r-4 11 00 r-4 11 t- C) Gq r--400 GN In W t- 00 M M M M M M M M M
,,14 o 41' to to o W CD t- t- 00 00 m m m m m m m m mmmmm m m m m n m m m m
14
-,14
. -,14 . --!Iq
. .d4 . -,t
. .,14-,t . .14 1,14
. ,t .
" Nt
. . 'Itt
. ll!V
NZ" .
" 11 11 11 114
. . . . . . It. '". ltj4
. 't.
". -'t
. -t. -tt
. 't. . "v
-14 . "'t
. ". . . Im
. k"
.
+
00 Ilt:VC.NC.4 M ":t r--4M r-4 C) OT w C) M 0 m 00 Gq W I:' '-4 " t- oc C.N O' 'M
oo "!:r VIDCD km Gq m 00 m CD CD 't N km 00 N m 00 "It m 8 m co t- 00 m m m m m
C) '4 M km M 0 0 00 to M C) CO Gq aq m m xo t- oo m m m = m C., M M M m ? ? ?
.1141- al. CM -t t- cl C) Gq 00 ^M LO t- 00 00 m m m m m m m m m m m m m m m m
co w co w t- t- t- t- 00 00 oo m (M (M m m m m m m m m m m m m m m m C.- m
1114"It -tl,,,t 14 -,t -,t -V t -,V " -,Zp-t " - :r '-14It ti
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . .
M m m
t-
r- m r-4 cez I
t-000000 oc
w
000000m (M t- 00 M
M,mm m
14 11,14rr 14 4 "
0
m "t W t-
O'., (m M M M
mmm M M M (M M
m mm01.(M =(====S
00 M
to
888800
ixl" kf' in 10
SkO 00 8
10 LO
t14 qt 14,,14 14 ,14 Z14 14 14 ,14 -tJ4 ,t t 14 -V t -ti -*4 " -tJ4-,t --14 llt . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
+
in CD Co = t- r- ^M ":t N to t- V. + V- 00 m
Gq xo 00 G9 00 t- C) 1- m co m 00 t- Gq In t- 00 C., m m m 1-1r. m
Gq r--4M t- VD M r--4 W L- 00 M M C; M M M M M M
0,
r-4 aq Gq Mj 'Itt -i4 LO I-mw w
M.m m m m MMMM4
oo 00 m m m
MM(M=4 mm===
-Rt 14 -!14,-14
MMMM(M mC)
I t-., LI in km km km ul ir.) In kr U'D
-.14 --p -,II -,II 't -It -111 -111 -t . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
lp 10cq 00 m
-4
w"-4 0 0
"-f "-f
0 m cq ko Nt "-f Gq r- m N m N r- co 10 LO m aq m C.9 m w 10 Nt Nt
r-4 co M aq 8 m m m 0 r- 00 00 m 0 P-4 m m 7-4 m N m I- Nt Gq Nt co "-4 co I-
m Nt m m Nt N to "-f m 0 Gq Gq "-f Gq 10 M Co N Co cl 7-4 t M 00 co aq co m Gq 't 10 co
M M 10 co 00 co m m 0 10 00 m 00 co Gq 00 Gq W M 7-4 M t co Co r- 00 00 00 M M M M
co aq co 8 n w m ci 10 r- m r- Gq m xo co r- r- co co 00 m mmmmm m m m C., m mm
0. '-f '-f Gq Gq N ai m M.5 m m 4 t " 44 -,t -,t -t -,t t -,t 't --t t 't 't 't 't 't -t 't 't " -I'
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
ip M C-N r-i o CO W,t m M r-4 r-4 't r-4 W 00 co t- DI W t- W "t r-4 r-4 co -t xo W -4 w 0 W 7-4 7-4 w M
10 M Gq o I- t- Gq t " r- co M U t- 00 0 Co in t- M W r- 10 I- I- CM co 0 m I- co 0 0 co
M VD in. aq oo C., -t r-4 00 Co 10 t- M Co 1- M lf' 10 V.N o co Cr., 1- cq. r- 0 Gq I" w 1- r-
m 0 ao," XI M Co r-4 M N m M in iz", 1- Gq 10 00 M ,t w L- 1-- 00 OOMMM N. M M
10 00 Gq t- o I" t- 0 m w 00 0 - m 1-t to W t- t- 00 00 00 M C. M M C-N M M M C.' C.' M M C-N M
o 0. 7-4 7-4 N. N cq M M M M t "14 t '" t t t t zt t I t -t -V "t -t -,,V t t ,!t t 't "'t t
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
...
+ +
t- 00 - W w 0 ,* cq xo 0 r-4 r" r- r-4 "14 cq I- W C-N W W C "!t t M lf "t M W (N CD
w ol 0 1- 1- r-,t M to W M 00 Gq 0 to w m r--l M M, lez 0 Co Gq ,t t- 10 r-4 M 0 10 1- Co Gq
0 1t r- N 1t 0 00 41.% Gq m co 0 M Co M 't km M "t Gq 't N 10 CC t 0 10 M r-4 t ifl CD 1- 00
C) 10 m N I" VD "t Gq I- 00 I- I" I- m m t- It m VD t- 0 N I" 10 co t- 00 00 00 m m C., m m m
r- " in r-4 aq M M M M C.,
IV, "t t "t 14"t 'I, '14'I. .,h't '14'd,'14 't -t t 't -,tt -,t
o tt 00 m CC Rt CD 00 0 cv'.N '" 10 CO I- L- 00 00 M M M M M cn M M M M
I? 9 71 SI V V In In M.M.1.1t11.11
,-4
L" C-q 00
P.". 0 1-
Gq 00 r-4 I"
aq M
L- m
IRt co
10
00
co
C., 00
w m
00 in
ol
r-4
W
m
r-4 10 0
r-4 00
10 Gq
00 Gq
ol
m
1t
00
Gq t-
t- m
r-4 M
0 O.".
co co
M
L-
co
W M CO
m ^M m
ao," 't
clt
m
m
F5 -4 Cy'. Co
O.". I-zt 00
Gq r-4 co m
co
m
t-
00 r-4 in "14 0
0 It r-4 1t It
r--4 m ko co t-
01 IM
r-4 w
00 00
Zo r--4 to 00 oo in M 0 00 M 't M 00 Gq M CM 0 Co r--4 10 00 - M 't QD I- r- 00 00 MMMMM M M
I" ^M I- r-4 10 00 al 11-11 t- m r--4 N 1-t in co t- t- 00 00 00 C-N M m mmmmm m m m C,, m m m
C,, 0 0 r-4 r-4 rq t.4 N VZ ".D VD M t -,t .14 -" -" t " qM t -.14 t 14 t " ,14 11,14 14 tt -jl -t t" ,14 -,t
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
1-41 +
I'd
CN. ^M CD --tt xo 10 0 m Gq t w 00 L- " 0 CD cq 00 L- m 0 t- - Nt m n t- to N ^M
1t CO I" r- Gq m r-4 r-4 m r- w 9 co km 10 N cq I- co co w IRt Gq 00 or, 0 CD r-4 L- W r-4 r--l M to M
10M t- C) 00 U --f Gq 00 r-4 C.9 M Co 10 NONOW m Gq 4) M 1- L- 10 Gq Co 0 Gq '444 co 1, 1- 00 00
1- " m o-. -.. -4 zo t- --t m C> 00 m co I- co m m VD I- 0 rn -" 10 co I- 00 00 m mmmmm m m
Gq co m N 10 t- in Ca L- r- 00 4 m
C
. oI" m
.
0 m 00.
r-4 -4
. .
aq
.
cq
.
Gq ^M M
. . .
M
. .
r--4-l-ZIt
t
.
'"
.
t
.
-"
.
t
.
.14 I
. .
-14
.
00 m m m m
Itt
.
.14 I
. .
11
.
.14
.
mmmmm
"
.
.14 ".
.
"
.
.14
.
mmmmm
t
.
-14 R* t
. . .
,14
. .
.14
.
+ +
ci r- m w Gq m m G9 m co r--f m M ut co t- to km 00 r- m 't I- m m 8 co to Gq 00 0 co 00
em r--4 M M oo 0 rll N. 00 r--4 0 0 0 N W M P" CD r--4 CD 00 r- 00 00 0 M " 0 r--4 1- O.N t- IIZP 00 -
o m 4 co C) LO m 1- m " LO Gq 00 w m 0 m 0 m CD m 10 co r--l CVI.) m m LO m Gq 111410 co r- 00 a0 M
4 X 1- m 00
n -t 00
m
(N
1- CM V.1i r--4
co 0 m co
10
00
& ^.0 00
ci m
0
ic
r- M
co co
Co r-4 10
r- 00 00
00 r--l Cv' 10 Co
xmmmm
1-
m
1-
m
QC 00 M
m 01.1 m
MMMMM
m m m m m
M
m
M
m
_-) r--4 r--4 N. r.1I m M M llt It I" 1t - It It -V It "It -t " -t -, "t -t -tq -t " --t -Rt "It --t It I"
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
+ +
r--4 00 t- Gq Gq L- t- 10 L- m kfl --t r-11 00 t- r--l Gq Co 00 Gq t- C) M 00 0 10 M r- M L- C) 00 km 't
C) -4 0 00 r--4 O".) 00 M M M I- C xO r--f t t- 04 CD --( t- - I- M 00 I- -V O (M ,t ,t r-4 L- 0 VD kO
1- ("q ko m cq It CD OC) 10 m ko w LO w M k- N oo n t 10 r--l co 0 m llt w 1- 00 00 m m m
N. m Gq r--l 1- 00 10 00 00 -t 00 M 00 10 r- 10 M "-4 M in Co t- 00 co M M M MMMMM M M
10 0 eo m -V 00 r-4 " 1- m r--l m -t Lp co 1- 00 00 oc qz m m q D m m m a., -n.m m m C--m m m m
CD 0 -4 -q "-4 N. N. m VD M M " t -t --t " " -: -t -,v -iq -iq ,II -iq - 't 't 't 't -t "" ,zt "t '1114 ,t "'t
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
+ +
C) m c C xn C) "-4 C) t- N M tc r--4 ,di OD -t W m t- -4 V." Co km Gq M., t- C) Itil co w m ^M rIq m L-
0 OC Ll C'. 0 G9 I- Gq (N Cq CD M Gq C 0 I- 0 "-4 00,14 J.- ,It I- W in. a"., " w -4 CM C) w C) m 10 c
0 0 00 t- 00 1- ^M "zt N. M M 1- IrD = r--4 L- 00 1- 00 "-4 m Gq Gq s 10 n Gq 't w I- co oc m m m m
-t L- t- 10 M C.,10 Co M ll" "t 0 ^MM (,.-IOCM L- C) C".'t Cor- 00 00 00 cn M M cn cn cn M M M M
C) in. 0 -V 00 CM lfll 00 o Gq -Tt 10 w L- t- ac 00 m mmmmm mmmmm mmmmm m m
r--4 r--4 (,11 N N.MMM '4di -t -P
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
+
N, 00 1- - r--4 O llf - It N rq C., LO CO M 0 r- CO
0 00 ^M Co C'. 10 N Gq Co 1- Co M ^-Z MM C) 0 1- 00 't Ll W 00 r- W 00 CM 00 0 M to M M to W
-4 w L- I- Gq M 00 r--4 cq xo 14 10 r--4 I- w r--4 W #.,^. M 00 M 00 't 00 r--4 ,t ll-D L- 1- O-C 00 M M cn
r--4 ^M Gq 1- 00 VD 't "-4 M r--l CD 00 00 xn. r--4 CD M Gq -t el CO P- 00 OD ON. M M M MMMMM M M
Ll r--4 W "-4 LO M M w M "-4 M "t 10 I- 00 00 00 M cn M M M M MMMMM MMMMM (7-1 M
C) -- - N. I-N N. M M VD -t -t -t 't -V --v -P -,t -,-P ,zt -t -t -t -,t -,t -,t 't -V - -M -, -V -t4 -V "t Itt
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
+
I r.11 jfl C) OC 00 (7.1-,f r--j Cvl.) _t -tq t _ N. 1_ C) C) CD G,,j M.Z f- N tJ4 -iq = r- W 00 O Co Co -t
'-7 C) -t M 00 't ll, Itt N. CD C) M 00 Co in
- tI rl I
M W or, M r--4 IN 00 0 00 L- rN OC W M OC I(,. cn ---l 10 w I- 00
i' 1-0 ifZ -t - L- O '-q N 0 M Cl"Z " t- ,t tZ CO N. I- - M in. C I- OC 00 M M M (M M
-4
CY.1 1., .% C) OC r"l Cv' (,,,I M -t x ^M 10 W L- 00 30 M M C., M M M M (M M (M M M
I - -M W 0 --V t- M V ^M 10 w 1-- 1- cc) 00 M M M M C= M M M M =.', cn M M (7-% M M M M
"- 4 N. N. M v 1. M ^M "tt 't -t -,t -t -V -t -,:r -tq -t di -V -t -t -P -M -" --V -1, " - '14 I" '". ,t "di "
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
TABLE II. Values of I, 41(v - 1), I (v -I )},v = 2 to 25 and x = '01 to '50,for determining
theProbability ofRatios,e.g-.x%1x2.
x- 01-*50 v=2--7
v=2 3 4 5 6 7
X
(V-
l)=03 1 1l5 2 25 3
'01 '063 768 56 '010 000 00 '001 692 55+ '000 298 00 *000053 74 '000 009 85+ '01
'02 '090 334 47 '020 000 00 '004 772 77 '001 184 00 '000 300 75- '000 077 62 02
'03 '110 824 69 '030 000 00 '008 741 44 '002 646 00 *00( 819 78 '000 258 00 '03
'04 *128188 43 '040 00000 '013 417 07 '004 67200 '001 664 48 '000 602 21 '04
'05 '143 566 29 '050 000 00 '018 693 04 '007 250 00 '002 875 76 '001 158 12 '05
'06 157 542 43 060 000 00 '024 496 26 010368 00 '004 486 12 '001 970 27 '06
'07 '170 463 43 '070 000 00 '030 772 22 '014 014 00 '006 521 83 *003079 93 '07
'08 '182 554 89 '080 000 00 '037 477 97 018 17600 1009004 21 004 525 26 08
'09 '193 973 37 '090 000 00 '044 578 42 '022 842 00 '011 950 56 '006 341 28 '09
'10 '204 832 76 '100 000 00 '052 044 02 '028 000 00 015 374 72 '008 560 00 '10
*11 '215 219 03 '110 000 00 '059 849 42 '033 638 00 '019 287 59 '011 210 48 '11
'12 '225 198 90 '120 000 00 '067 972 43 '039 744 00 '023 697 45+ '014 318 90 '12
'13 '234 825 47 '130 000 00 '076 393 38 '046 306 00 '028 610 26 '017 908 63 '13
'14 '244 141 78 '140 000 00 '085 094 64 053 312 00 '034 029 90 '022 000 29 14
'15 '253 183 31 '150 000 00 '094 060 20 '060 750 00 '039 958 35- '026 611 88 '15
'16 '261 979 76 '160 000 00 '103 275 47 '068 608 00 '046 395 85+ '031 758 75- 16
'17 '270 556 26 '170 00000 '112 726 99 '076 87400 '053 34109 '037 453 76 '17
'18 '278 934 34 '180 000 00 '122 402 29 085 536 00 '060 791 27 '043 707 34 '18
'19 '287 132 59 '190 000 00 '132 289 75- 094 582 00 '068 742 25- '050 527 51 '19
'20 '295 167 24 '200 000 00 '142 378 49 '104 000 00 '077 188 63 '057 920 00 '20
'21 '303 052 54 '210 000 00 '152 658 26 '113 778 00 '086 123 84 '065 888 31 '21
'22 '310 801 12 '220 000 00 '163 119 39 '123 904 00 '095 540 22 074 433 78 '2'2
'23 '318424 23 '230 000 00 '173 752 67 '134 366 00 105429 11 '083 555 66 *23
'24 '325 931 94 '240 00000 184549 36 '145 15200 '115 780 88 '093 251 17 '24
'25 *33333333 250 00000 '195 501 11 '156 25000
o 12658500- 103515 62 25
'26 '340 636 66 '260 000 00 '206 599 90 '167 648 00 137830 12 '114 342 43 '26
'27 '347 849 40 '270 00000 '217 838 05+ '179 33400 o 149 50409 '125 723 19 '27
'28 '354 978 44 '280 00000 '229 208 15- I '191 29600 '161 59404 '137 647 82 '28
'29 '362 03007 '290 00000 '240 703 03 '203 52200 '174 08640 '150 104 54 '29
'30 '369 010 12 '300 00000 '252 31579 '2)1600000
o 18696696 '163 08000 30
'31 375923 99 '310 00000 '264 039 69 '228 71800 '200 220 90 '176 559 34 '31
'32 '382 776 69 '320 00000 '275 868 23 '241 66400 '21.3832 81 '190 526 26 '32
'33 '389 572 92 '330 000 00 '287 795 04 '254 826 00 '227 786 80 204 963 09 '33
'34 '396 317 08 '340 000 00 '299 813 93 '268 19200 '242 066 44 '219 850 85+ '34
'35 '403 013 32 '350 00000 '311 918 83 '281 75000 '256 654 85- 235169 38 '35
.'36 '409 665 53 '360 00000 324103 8:3 '295 48800 l 271 534 73 '250 897 31 '36
.37 '416 277 43 '37000000 '336 363 11 1 '309 39400 '286 688 37 267012 22 '37
'38 '422 852 55+ '380 000 00 '348 690 97 '323 456 00 '302 097 72 283490 70 '38
'39 '429 394 26 '390 00000 '361 081 79 '337 66200 I:317 744 35+ 300308 37 '39
'40 '435 905 78 '400 000 00 373530 04 '.352000 00 '333 60956 31744000 '40
'41 '442 390 22 '410 000 00 '386 030 28 '366 45800 '349 674 '6 334 859 57 '41
'42 ! '448 850 58 '420 000 00 '398 577 12 '381 024 00 ':365 919 48 '352 540 34 '42
'43 | 455 289 74 '430 000 00 '411 165 24 '395 686 00 ':382 325 47 370 454 92 '43
'4-1 '461 710 54 '440 (000 00 '423 789 37 '410 432 00 '398 872 64 '388 575 33 '44
'45 '468 115 72 '450 000 00 '436 444 29 '425 250 00 '415 541 14 406 873 12 '45
'46 '474 507 97 '460 000 00 '449 124 80 '440 128 00 '432 310 98 425 319 39 '46
'47 '480 889 93 '470 000 00 '461 825 74 '455 054 00 '449 162 04 '443 884 85+ '47
'48 '487 264 21 '480 000 00 '474 542 00 '470 016 00 '466 074 10 '462 539 98 '48
'49 '493 633 ;38 '490 000 00 '487 268 45+ '485s002 00 '483 026 87 '481 255 00 49
'50 ' 500 000 00 '500 000 00 '500 000 00 '500 000 00 '500 00000 ' 50 000 00 '50
348 FurtherApplicationsin Statisticsof Tm(x) Bessel Function
TABLE II (continued).
x= 01---50 v= 8-13
v7=8
(v-1) =35
9
4
10
45
11
5 1 12
515
13
6
TABLE II (continued).
a= '01-*50 v= 14-19
v=14 15 16 17 18 19
x (v-1)=6'5 7 7-5 8 8'5 9
*0l *01
*02 *000ooo 01 *02
*03 'oo 000 10 *000 000 03 *000 000 01 *03
*04 *000 000 60 *oo0 000 23 *000 000 09 *o30000 03 *000 000 0] *04
a05 000 002 44 *000 001 03 '000 000 43 *000 000 18 '000 000 08 *000000 03 '05
'06 000 007 58 *000003 48 *o00 001 60 *ooo o00 74 *000000 34 *000 000 16 '06
'07 '000 019 64 *000009 68 *000004 79 *000 002 37 o(0o ool 18 *000 000 58 07
'08 000 044 46 *ooo 023 32 '000 012 25+ *ooo 006 45+ *000 003 40 '000 001 80 *08
*09 000 090 84 *ooo 050 26 '000 027 87 *000 015 48 '000 008 62 '000 004 80 '09
'10 000 171 14 '000 099 29 i000 057 73 '000 033 63 '000 019 62 '000 Oll 47 '10
'11 '000 301 88 '000 182 71 '000 110 82 *oo 067 34 '000 040 98 I'000 024 98
'12
'12 000 504 31 '000 317 09 '000 199 79 *o 126 12 '000 079 74 00() 050 49 '12
'13 '000 804 83 '000 523 85+ 000 341 67 '000 223 26 *00 146 11 '000 095 76 1 '13
'14 '001 235 25+ '000 829 80 '000 558 56 '000 376 66 '000 254 40 '000 172 06 i '14
'15 '001 833 03 '001 267 55- 1 000 878 26 '000 609 61 '000 423 79 '000
2o95 03 '15
'16 '002 641 24 '001 875 80 '001 334 80 '000 951 48 '000 679 29 '000 485 63 '16
'17 '003 708 45+ '002 699 49 '001 968 83 '001 438 39 '001 052 45- 1000 771 11 '17
'18 '005 088 43 '003 789 71 '002 827 82 '002 113 61 '001 582 13 '001 185 88 '18
'19 '006 839 73 '005 203 53 '003 966 12 '003 027 93 '002 315 06 '001 772 34 '19
'20 '009 025 04 '007 003 56 '005 444 77 '004 239 75- 003 306 16 '002 581 46 '20
'21 '011 710 56 '009 257 38 007 331 16 '005 814 91 '004 618 74 '903 673 27 '21
'22 '014 965 07 '012 036 80 '009 698 41 '007 826 37 006 324 38 '005 116 96 '22
'23 018 859 04 015 416 95- '012 624 57 '010 353 56 '008 502 51 006 990 84 '23
'24 '023 463 59 '019 475 23 '016 191 67 '013 481 54 '011 239 78 ',009 381 85+ '24
'25 '028 849 42 '024 290 14 '020 484 48 017 299 84 '014 629 02 '012 384 78 '25
'26 '035 085 64 '029 940 04 '025 589 25- '021 901 19 '018 768 05- '016 101 16 '26
'27 '042 238 66 '036 501 79 '031 592 19 '027 379 97 '023 758 09 1020 637 80 '27
'28 '050 370 99 '044 049 36 '038 577 95+ '033 830 47 '029 702 04 '026 104 99 '28
'29 059 540 16 '052 652 47 '046 627 96 '041 345 12 '036 702 44 '032 614 43 '29
'30 '069 797 56 '062 375 21 '055 818 76 '050 012 54 '044 859 37 '040 276 94 '30
'31 '081 187 50+ '073 274 66 *066 220 38 '059 915 58 '054 268 23 '049 199 94 '31
'32 '093 746 17 '085 399 64 '077 894 69 '071 129 37 '065 Ol 36 '059 484 84 '32
'33 '107 500 85+ '098 789 54 '090 893 88 '083 719 39 '077 185 82 '071 224 36 '33
'34 '122 469 15+ '113 473 24 '105 259 06 '097 739 68 '090 841 13 '084 499 88 '34
'35 '138 658 39 '129 468 23 '121 018 94 '113 231 13 '106 037 17 '099 378 86 '35
'36 '156 065 13 '146 779 78 '138 188 78 '130 220 07 '122 812 26 '11i5 912 48 '36
'37 '174 674 82 '165 400 43 '156 769 47 '148 716 95+ '141 187 52 '134 133 51 '37
'38 '194 461 65- '185 309 55+ '176 746 88 '168 715 38 '161 165 45+ '154 054 43 '38
'39 '215 388 47 '206 473 17 '198 091 45+ '190 191 42 '182 728 93 '175 666 06 '39
'40 "237 406 98 '228 843 95+ '220 758 00 '213 103 18 '205 840 51 '198 936 49 '40
'41 '260 457 95+ '252 361 44 '244 685 83 '237 390 78 '230 442 12 '223 810 52 '41
'42 '284 471 69 '276 952 44 '269 799 10 '262 976 59 '256 455 25- 250 209 65+ '42
'43 '309 368 62 '302 531 68 '296 007 46 '289 765 87 '283 781 46 '278 032 49 '43
'44 '335 059 97 '329 002 56 '323 206 91 '317 647 66 '312 30:336 *307 155 7:3 '44
'45 '361 448 66 '356 258 18 '351 280 94 '346 496 07 '341 885 97 '337 435 62 '45
'46 '388 430 23 '384 182 49 '380 101 86 '376 171 82 *'372378 46 '368 709 89 '46
'47 '415 893 90 '412 651 52 '409 532 32 '406 524 00 '403 616 22 '400 800 13 '47
'48 '443 723 76 '441 534 89 '439 427 07 '437 392 14 '435 423 24 '433 514 52 '48
'49 '471 799 96 '470 697 27 -'469 634 78 '468 608 41 '467 614 74 '466 650 88 '49
'50 '500 00000 '5(0 000 00 .500 000 00 '500 000 00 '50() 000 00 '|500 000 00 '50
_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ ~ _ _ _---I__ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _J__ _ _I__ __
(x) Bessel Function
350 FurtherApplicationsin Statisticsof T?fl
TABLE II (continued).
x= '01-'50 v= 20-25
v=20 21 22 23 24 25
X 11 X
i(v - 1) =95 10 10.5 11.5 12
*01 '01
-02 '02
-03 -03
-04 '04
'05 '000 000 01 '000 000 01 -05
*06 '000 000 07 '000 000 03 '000 00001 '000 000 01 .06
0 000 000 29 '000 000 14 '000 000 07 '000 000 04 '000 000 02 000 000 01 '07
.08 '000 000 95+ '000 000 50+ *)00 000 27 *o)00000 14 '000 000 07 '000 000 04 '08
o09 )00 002 68 '000 001 50- )00 000 84 '000 000 47 '000 000 26 '000 000 15- *09
'10 '000 006 71 '000 003 93 '000 00'2 30 '000 001 35+ 0oooooo 80 '000 000 47 '10
'11 '000 015 25- '000 009 32 000 005 70 '000 003 49 '000 002 14 -000 001 31 '11
'12 '000 03201 '000 020 32 000 012 91 000 008 21 000005 23 000 003 33 '12
'13 '000 062 85- o000041 29 '000 027 16 '000 017 88 '000 Oll 78 '000 007 77 '13
14 '000 116 53 '000 079 01 '000 053 62 '000 036 43 '000 024 7 o000016 86 '14
'15 '000 205 65- '000 143 51 '000 100 25- '000 070 09 '000 049 05+ '000 034 36 '15
*16 '000 347 61 '000 249 10 '000 178 69 '000 128 30 '000 092 20 '000 066 31 '16
'17 '000 565 66 '000 415 42 '000 305 38 '000 224 70 '000 165 47 '000 121 96 '17
'18 '000 889 94 '000 668 58 '000 502 78 '000 378 44 '000 285 08 '000 214 92 '18
'19 '001 358 45+ '001 042 34 '000 800 56 '000 615 42 '000 473 48 '000 364 55+ '19
'20 '002 017 96 '001 579 12 '001 236 90 '000 969 70 '000 760 83 '000 597 39 '20
'21 '002 924 66 '002 331 03 '001 859 63 '001 484 85- '001 186 54 '000 948 85+ '21
'22 '004 144 68 '003 360 54 '002 727 27 '002 215 21 '001 800 70 '001 464 80 '22
'23 '005 754 21 '004 741 03 '003 909 79 '003 226 96 '002 665 41 '002 203 14 '23
'24 '007 839 40 '006 556 89 '005 489 06 '004 598 86 '003 855 91 '003 235 21 '24
'25 '010 495 75+ '008 903 28 '007 558 96 '006 422 71 '005 461 25- '004 646 85- '25
'26 '013 827 25+ '011 885 44 '010 224 94 '008 803 24 '007 584 63 '006 539 01 '26
'27 '017 945 01 '015 617 59 013 603 19 '011 857 54 '010 343 10 ' 009 027 87 '27
'28 '022 965 53 '020 221 26 '017 819 13 '015 713 86 '013 866 69 1 *()2 244 30 '28
'29 '0'29 008 64 '025 823 31 '023 005 53 '020 509 80 '018 296 81 I '016 332 51 '29
'30 '036 195 01 '032 553 36 '029 300 01 '026 389 94 '023 784 0() 021 448 00 '30
*31 044 643 52 '040 540 98 '036 842 03 '033 502 81 '030 484 93 '0227754 67 ':31
'32 '054 468 26 '049 912 51 '045 769 58 '041 997 35- '038 558 78 |035) 421 14 '32
'33 '065 77-556 '060 787 68 '056 215 44 '052 018 98 '048 163 08 '044 616 45+ '33 I
-34 '078 660 87 '073 276 06 '068 303 28 '063 705 29 '059 449 03 '055 505 05- '*34
'35 '093 205 72. '087 473 60 '082 143 66 '077 181 50+ '07*2 5c56 54 '068 241 42 '35
'36 '109 474 85- '103 459 16 '097 830 02 '092 556 03 '087,609 19 i '082 964 44 I '36
'37 '127 513 53 '121 291 33 '115 434 93 '109 915 98 '104 709 14 '090 791 71 '37
'38 '147 345 27 '141 005 53 '135 006 62 '129 323 12 '123 932 38 '118 814 04 i '38
'39 '168 969 90 1]62611 64 '156 565 91 '150 810 19 '145 324 36 '140 090 39 '39
'40 *192 362 12 '186 092 02 '180 103 87 j '174 377 87 '168 896 34 I 't63 643 44 '40
'41 '217 470 63 -211400 28 '205 580 00 '199 992 54 1 '194 622 51 '189 4.56 14 1 '41
'42 244 217 84 '238 460 66 '232 921 30 '227 584 86 '2'22 438 11 '217 469 18 1'42
'43 "272 500 17 '267 168 16 '262 022 11 '257 049 ,35- '252 238 59 '247 579 79 '43
i44 *302 188 97 '297 389 37 '292 744 90 '288 244 94 '283 880 06 '279 641 85+ '44
*45 |333 132 07 '328 964 09 '324 921 83 '320 996 61 '317 180 7,5- '313 467 35+ '45
'46 '365 155 90 :361 707 62 '358 357 27 "35-,098 03 I *351 923 82 ! '348 829 25+ '46
'47 '398 068 17 *395 413 72 '392 831 04 I '390 31505- '387 861 26 '385 465 66 '4
'48 '431 660 95+ '429 858 18 '428 102 39) '426 390 22 '424 718 70 '423 085 19 1 '48
'49 '465 714 30 '464 802 84 '463 914 59 '463 047 90 *462
' 201 28 '461 373 41 '49
'50 '500 000 00 -500000 00 '(500 000 () | 500 000 00 '500 000) 00 '500 000 00 '50