Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
Background and Purpose Population-based studies are cru- stantial proportion of nonfatal strokes managed solely outside
Downloaded from http://stroke.ahajournals.org/ by guest on December 24, 2017
cial for identifying explanations for the decline in mortality the hospital system: 28% in Auckland and 22% in Perth of all
from stroke and for generating strategies for public health patients registered. The age-standardized annual incidence of
policy. However, they present particular methodological diffi- stroke (all events) was 27% higher among men in Perth
culties, and comparability between them is generally poor. In compared with Auckland (odds ratio, 1.27; P=.O16); women
this article we compare the incidence and case fatality of tended to have higher rates in Auckland, although these
stroke as assessed by two independent well-designed incidence differences were not statistically significant. In both centers
studies. approximately a quarter of all patients died within the first
Methods Two registers of acute cerebrovascular events month after a stroke. There were significant differences in the
were compiled in the geographically defined metropolitan prevalence of hypertension among first-ever strokes.
areas of Auckland, New Zealand (population 945 369), during
1991-1992 for 12 months and Perth, Australia (population Conclusions These two studies emphasize the importance
138 708), during 1989-1990 for 18 months. The protocols for of identifying all patients with stroke, both hospitalized and
each register included prospective ascertainment of cases nonhospitalized, in order to measure the incidence of stroke
using multiple overlapping sources and the application of accurately. The incidence and case fatality of stroke were
standardized definitions and criteria for stroke and case remarkably similar in Auckland and Perth in the early 1990s.
fatality. However, there are differences in the sex-specific rates that
Results In Auckland, 1803 events occurred in 1761 resi- correspond to differences in the pattern of risk factors. (Stroke.
dents, 73% of which were first-ever strokes. The corresponding 1994^5^52-557.)
figures for Perth were 536 events in 492 residents, 69% of Key Words • Australia • cerebrovascular disorders •
which were first-ever strokes. Both studies identified a sub- epidemiology • incidence • New Zealand
A fter a long period of neglect, there is now fresh clear whether there has been a change in the incidence
/ \ interest in the epidemiology of stroke. In part of stroke or a change in natural history, with the average
J. V . this reflects a desire to explain the sustained stroke becoming less severe.3 However, in the absence
decrease in mortality from stroke seen in many devel- of definitive breakthroughs in the treatment of acute
oped countries over recent decades as well as the stroke, it seems likely that much of the fall in mortality
increases in several Eastern European countries.1 It also from stroke can be attributed to changes in risk factors
reflects concern that rapid increases in both relative and rather than to improvements in the medical manage-
absolute numbers of the elderly will overwhelm eco- ment of stroke.
nomic, medical, and social resources providing care for Largely because of methodological difficulties in mea-
the disabled aged, many of whom have experienced a suring the incidence of stroke, there is a scarcity of
stroke.2 Despite advances in noninvasive neuroimaging well-designed epidemiologic studies of its trends and
techniques, the recognition of various risk factors for determinants.4 Although hospital-based studies are a
stroke, and improved epidemiologic methods, it is un- popular source of data on stroke, they are complicated
by selection bias and therefore are of limited use either
for monitoring the effects of primary prevention or for
Received September 30, 1993; final revision received November planning of health services. Population-based studies,
29, 1993; accepted November 29, 1993.
From the Section of Geriatric Medicine, University of Auckland
on the other hand, can provide the necessary data, but
(New Zealand) (R.B., J.B.B.); the Department of Medicine (Neu- only if they adhere to several "ideal" criteria for defi-
rology), Flinders Medical Centre, South Australia (C.S.A.); the nitions, design, and presentation of data.4 However,
Department of Public Health, University of Western Australia, these studies are costly and demanding, particularly in
Nedlands (K.DJ.); the Department of Neurology, Royal Perth regard to identifying nonfatal events managed entirely
(Australia) Hospital (E.G.S.-W.); and the Department of Neurol- in the community. Clearly, incomplete case-finding
ogy, Auckland (New Zealand) Hospital (N.E.A.). would lead to an underestimation of the true incidence
Correspondence to Ruth Bonita, MPH PhD, Section of Geriat-
ric Medicine, University of Auckland, Private Bag 93-503, Auck- of stroke. In this article we present data from two stroke
land 9, New Zealand. registers that met all the criteria for well-designed
Bonita et al Stroke in Australasia 553
incidence studies, with the important objective of com- TABLE 1. Comparison of Selected Baseline Variables
paring the incidence and case fatality of stroke between Among Stroke Events Registered In the Auckland
two defined Australasian populations. (1991) and Perth (1989-1990) Stroke Studies*
Auckland Perth
Subjects and Methods (N=18O3) (N=536)
Study Populations
The study populations were all residents of Auckland, New Variable n % n %
Zealand, and of a geographically defined segment of metro- Age, y
politan Perth, Western Australia. The population of Auckland
15-64 433 24.0 107 20.0
was 945 369 according to the 1991 Census. The study popula-
tion in Perth was estimated at 138 708 (at June 30, 1989) by 65-74 512 28.4 144 26.9
linear extrapolation of the relative change in the population of 75-84 611 33.9 203 37.8
the study area for the intercensal period 1981 through 1986.
The proportion of people 65 years and older was greater in 85 + 247 13.7 82 15.3
Perth (12.3%) than Auckland (9.4%), but the structure and Mean age, y
availability of hospital and other health services for stroke
share certain similarities. Both cities have experienced consid- Men 68 71
erable postwar immigration flows and now have distinctive Women 74 75
multicultural populations.
Total 72 73
Ascertainment of Stroke Events
Downloaded from http://stroke.ahajournals.org/ by guest on December 24, 2017
Country of birth
The Auckland register operated for 12 months from March Australia/New Zealand 1239 68.7 286 53.4
1, 1991; the study period for the Perth register was 18 months
beginning February 20, 1989. Details of the case-finding United Kingdom 299 16.6 99 18.5
procedures adopted by each stroke register are described Pacific Islands 125 6.9 0 0.0
elsewhere.5-6 In brief, each study included a wide range of
overlapping sources, including daily checks of attendances at Europe 34 1.9 103 19.2
and admissions to all acute hospitals, routine searches for Other 106 5.8 48 9.0
in-hospital events, radiology requests for axial computed to-
mographic (CT) scans, perusal of death certificates and au- Married 875 48.5 260 48.5
topsy reports, and in the Perth study radiology requests for Residence
carotid duplex ultrasound. Hospital morbidity data were also
scrutinized for any mention of cerebrovascular disease (the Home 1512 83.9 435 81.2
International Classification of Diseases [9th revision, ICD-9] Hostel/lodge 103 5.7 44 8.2
codes 430-438) as an additional check for completeness of
ascertainment.7 Institution 188 10.4 57 10.6
Both studies paid particular attention to identifying nonfatal History of stroke 498 27.6 166 31.0
events occurring outside the hospital setting. To enlist the Management in hospital 1305 72.4 418 78.0
active support of the two communities, considerable emphasis
was given to widespread publicity. Before the Perth study *Missing and unknown values are not Included.
began, all medical practitioners serving the study population
were telephoned and sent a letter. The objectives of these
contacts were to clarify the aims of the study and invite each recurrent event during the study period was considered to have
doctor to refer all cases of suspected stroke or transient occurred if more than 28 days had elapsed from the initial
ischemic attack, irrespective of medical condition, to a central episode that brought the patient into the study. Total stroke
office. Access to this office was facilitated by the use of a events therefore refer to all events, rather than patients, and
24-hour answering machine. Regular follow-up by telephone include patients both with and without a history of stroke. A
and progress reports ensured continuing cooperation from case "managed in hospital" is one in which admission occurred
medical practitioners. Similarly, the Auckland study included within 28 days of stroke onset. Twenty-eight-day case fatality
regular phone calls to 170 general practitioners who repre- is defined as the proportion of all events that resulted in death
sented a 25% random sample of all primary care physicians in within 28 days of onset.
the city. In Auckland, domiciliary visits by physiotherapists
and speech therapists and by stroke field officers to stroke Study Variables
patients being cared for in the community were reviewed on a Once it was established that the patient met the clinical
monthly basis as an additional check to the referrals by the criteria for inclusion, a semistructured personal interview
participating doctors. covering the onset of the stroke and other medical and social
factors was completed as soon as possible after the event. In
Study Definitions the Perth study, a neurology registrar (C.S.A.) interviewed all
Stroke was defined according to the World Health Organi- patients, whereas in Auckland, trained nurses in liaison with a
zation definition as "rapidly developing signs of focal (or neurologist (N.E.A.) interviewed the patients. If the patient
global) disturbance of cerebral function lasting 24 hours or was dead or unable to communicate, an appointment was
longer, or leading to death, with no apparent cause other than made with a close relative or friend to whom the same
vascular."8 This definition includes spontaneous subarachnoid questions were directed. Both studies were also characterized
hemorrhage but excludes subdural and extradural hematomas by follow-up interviews at selected intervals in the year after
and transient ischemic attacks. First-ever strokes refer to the index event: 1, 6, and 12 months in the Auckland study and
patients who had no previous history of stroke; that is, they 4 and 12 months in the Perth study.
suffered their "first-ever-in-a-lifetime" stroke during the study With regard to risk factors, diabetes mellitus was accepted
period. Patients who gave a history of stroke before the study on the basis of either a history of that condition or when a
period were classified as having suffered a recurrent event only random blood glucose level was found to exceed 11.1 mmol/L
after careful review of all the available medical information. A poststroke. Smoking status was classified as "current smoker"
554 Stroke Vol 25, No 3 March 1994
Men Women
rate per 100 000, log scale rate per 100 000, log scale
10000q 10000q
1000 = 1000
100: 100:
10:
Downloaded from http://stroke.ahajournals.org/ by guest on December 24, 2017
10:
15-24 25-34 35-44 45-54 55-64 65-74 75-84 85* 15-24 25-34 35-44 45-54 55-64 65-74 75-84 85*
Age group Age group
Line graphs show age-specific annual stroke incidence (first-ever) rates (per 100 000 population) for men and women in Auckland
(1991) and Perth (1989-1990).
TABLE 3. Comparison of 28-Day Case Fatality of Stroke by Age, Sex, Management, and Sequence In
Auckland (1991) and Perth (1989-1990), All Events
fifths of all patients registered in both studies were Table 3 shows there was no significant difference
living in a private residence, the remainder being in between the two populations in the 28-day case fatality
institutional care; the proportions of patients married, for stroke. In both studies, the overall case fatality was
living alone, and managed in hospital were similar. 24% and was higher in women and in older people (75
The age- and sex-specific annual incidence (first-ever) years and older).
rates for the two populations are presented in the Table 4 compares selected characteristics of first-ever
Figure. These increase rapidly with age and are consis- strokes for patients from the two populations. Among
tently and significantly higher in men than women in the men who suffered a stroke, the proportion with
both studies. Although not shown in the Figure, in each either a history of hypertension (P=.O14) or on antihy-
age group the 95% Cl values overlap around the rates pertensive treatment (P=.O07) was significantly higher
(shown elsewhere56), suggesting no statistically signifi- in Perth. For women who suffered a stroke, a similar
cant difference in age-specific rates between the two difference was found in the proportion with a history of
populations. There was no significant difference be- hypertension (P<.0001) or on antihypertensive drugs
tween Auckland and Perth in overall annual age-stan- (i'=.011). Slight differences in data collection methods
dardized incidence rates (141.5 and 145.6 per 100 000, used in the two studies are thought unlikely to account
respectively) (Table 2). However, age-standardized for this difference.
rates in men in Perth were higher (191.5 per 100 000)
than in men in Auckland (153.3 per 100 000); this The women in the Auckland study were more likely to
difference was statistically significant (odds ratio, 1.27; have smoked, whereas men in Auckland were more
95% Cl, 1.05-1.53; P= .016). The age-standardized rates likely to have a history of diabetes mellitus, although
in women were similar (128.6 and 108.3 per 100 000 in these differences did not reach conventional levels of
Auckland and Perth, respectively). significance.
TABLE 4. Prevalence of Selected Characteristics Between Auckland and Perth, By Sex, Flrst-Ever Events
Men Women
the National Heart Foundation of New Zealand, the Austra- ration (prepared by H Tunstall-Pedoe). J Clin Epidemiol. 1988;41:
lian Brain Foundation, and the Medical Research Foundation 105-114.
of Royal Perth Hospital for financial support. We are indebted 9. Doll R, Muir C, Waterhouse J, eds. Cancer Incidence in Five
Continents. New York, NY: Springer-Verlag; 1970.
to numerous patients, doctors, and hospitals and grateful for 10. Anderson CS, Jamrozik KD, Burvill PW, Chakera TMH, Johnson
cooperation from the Health Department of Western Austra- GA, Stewart-Wynne EG. Determining the incidence of different
lia, the Auckland and Perth Coroners, the Registrars-General sub-types of stroke: results from the Perth Community Stroke
in New Zealand and Western Australia, and the Perth Office Study, 1989-1990. MedJAust. 1993;158:85-89.
of the Australian Bureau of Statistics. Dr Bonita is the 11. Bamford J, Sandercock P, Dennis M, Burn J, Warlow C. Why are
Masonic Senior Research Fellow and Joanna Broad the Ma- patients admitted to hospital? experience of the Oxfordshire Com-
sonic Research Analyst in the Section of Geriatric Medicine, munity Stroke Project. BrMedJ. 1986;292:1369-1372.
12. Hobbs MST, Jamrozik KD, Hockey RL, Alexander H, Beaglehole
School of Medicine, Auckland. R, Dobson AJ, Heller RF, Jackson R, Stewart AW. Mortality from
coronary heart disease and incidence of acute myocardial
References infarction in Auckland, Newcastle and Perth. Med J Aust. 1991;
1. Bonita R, Stewart AW, Beaglehole R. International trends in 155:436-442.
stroke mortality: 1970-1985. Stroke. 1990;21:989-992. 13. Marmot MG, Poulter NR. Primary prevention of stroke. Lancet.
2. Heikkinen E. Health implications of population ageing in Europe. 1992;339:344-347.
World Health Slat Q. 1987;40:22-40. 14. Kuller LH. Incidence rates of stroke in the eighties: the end of the
decline? Stroke. 1989;20:841-843.
3. Scheinberg P. Controversies in the management of cerebrovascular
15. MacMahon S, Peto R, Cutler J, Collins R, Sorlie P, Neaton J,
disease. Neurology. 1988;38:1609-1616.
Abbott R, Godwin J, Dyer A, Stamler J. Blood pressure, stroke
4. Malmgren R, Warlow C, Bamford J, Sandercock P. Geographical and coronary heart disease, Part I: prolonged differences in blood
and secular trends in stroke. Lancet. 1987;2:1196-1199. pressure, prospective observational studies corrected for the
5. Bonita R, Broad JB, Beaglehole R. Changes in stroke incidence regression of dilution bias. Lancet. 1990;335:765-774.
and case-fatality Auckland, New Zealand in 1981-1991. Lancet.
Downloaded from http://stroke.ahajournals.org/ by guest on December 24, 2017
Stroke. 1994;25:552-557
doi: 10.1161/01.STR.25.3.552
Downloaded from http://stroke.ahajournals.org/ by guest on December 24, 2017
Stroke is published by the American Heart Association, 7272 Greenville Avenue, Dallas, TX 75231
Copyright © 1994 American Heart Association, Inc. All rights reserved.
Print ISSN: 0039-2499. Online ISSN: 1524-4628
The online version of this article, along with updated information and services, is located on the
World Wide Web at:
http://stroke.ahajournals.org/content/25/3/552
Permissions: Requests for permissions to reproduce figures, tables, or portions of articles originally published in
Stroke can be obtained via RightsLink, a service of the Copyright Clearance Center, not the Editorial Office.
Once the online version of the published article for which permission is being requested is located, click Request
Permissions in the middle column of the Web page under Services. Further information about this process is
available in the Permissions and Rights Question and Answer document.