Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
techniques contribute to the effectiveness of a horror film. Many horror films of the past have
used excessive violence to produce their scares, but this can be damaging to the film’s
effectiveness, and in the eyes of some, morally wrong. The information from the collected
sources was combined with original observations from a number of horror films to form a
Table of Contents
Introduction………………………………………………………………………….…Pages 2-3
Data/Analysis..………………………………………………………………………….Pages 9-21
Conclusion…………………………………………………………………………......Pages 21-23
Introduction
Movies have been a popular form of entertainment for audiences since their creation,
dating back to even before the 1900’s. They allow audiences to experience a wide range of
emotions from the safety of their seats. These experiences are provided by various types of
movies, but perhaps one of the most popular genres of film is the horror film. Even within this
genre, there are many of subgenres that create their thrills in many different ways. Some revert
to psychological tricks, disturbing imagery, or violence, as well as many other scare tactics. But
as the genre has grown, so has its content. What was considered inappropriate in a horror movie
from the 60’s is considered tame today. Horror movies continually use the same techniques to
Hong 3
evoke fear in their audience, desensitizing them to the violence and gore, prompting filmmakers
to try and top a previous film’s bloodshed. This is a dangerous, possibly unhealthy, trend.
Horror movies can provide their thrills without extreme violence, as demonstrated by movies like
The Shining, The Haunting, and The Innocents. Even more recent movies like Insidious or The
Conjuring have been successful without excessive violence. Whatever violence that is present in
these films is either offscreen, limited, or brief. If such critically-acclaimed horror films can be
so successful without using the same cheap tactics, what are they doing right? The effectiveness
of a strong horror movie can be attributed to editing that favors long sequences of suspense,
appeals to the fear of the unknown, and is based on the grounds of an atmospheric story,
Literature Review
The Unknown
To support this thesis, a list of sources was collected and analyzed to find common traits
of good horror films. The sources were written by people with experience in filmmaking, or by
people who have been studying film and media for a long time. One important element of horror
films is the element of the unknown. Though visuals can evoke fear to an extent, leaving things
in mystery forces the audience to imagine their own, deepest, personal fears in place of what is
not shown. Since every person is afraid of different things, utilizing mystery helps to truly
frighten the audience without knowing what they are afraid of (Miyamoto).
Hong 4
Outcomes
Horror movies also make great use of getting the audience to question the likelihood of
different outcomes (Frome), and leaving things unknown forces the audience to wait in suspense,
generating fear because they do not know what will result from different discoveries (“How to
Make Your Horror Screenplay More Effective”). But of course, the likelihood of different
outcomes is more directed by the plot of the movie than any other factor. When a story has
different possible outcomes, there has to be both desirable and undesirable outcomes. But the
undesirable outcomes have to be higher in possibility and higher in number to increase the stakes
of the film (Frome). Stephen King, the famous horror writer, hints towards these possible
outcomes early on in his stories, calling back to them later to remind the audience of the potential
danger that a triggering plot point might possess. For example, in The Shining, Dick Hallorann
warns young Danny to stay away from 217, and when Danny later passes room 217, the audience
remembers Hallorann’s warning and fears for Danny’s safety (Freese). Some horror stories also
use isolation in the set-up of their stories. If the characters are isolated, then they will have no
Emotional Connection
Isolated characters are not enough to evoke fear. The characters must be sympathetic and
likable. The audience must connect with the characters, and if they care about them, there is a
greater level of suspense because the viewers are unable to help endangered “friends” on-screen
(Frome; Wixson). The characters are who the audience experience the movie through, they are
vessels for the viewers to feel the same emotions as the characters do without actually having to
be put in danger. But without a sense of connection, these emotions are cut off, and the audience
Hong 5
will be heavily uninterested in the movie (Miyamoto). Of course, the characters are the
audience’s way to experience the story, but without a story there is nothing to experience. James
Wan, a very popular modern-day horror filmmaker, explains three elements he finds important in
his own films: “the fear of the unknown; that is a very common fear for all of us because we
don't know what happens, therefore we're kind of apprehensive about it. Then, there’s fear for
one's life; human preservation is an idea that a lot of horror movies prey on. All the classic
slasher movies are about someone running for their life or trying to not get killed, right? Then
obviously the third one, which is one that [he plays] a lot in the two Conjuring films, is fear of
losing their loved ones. That is very important” (Wixson). All of these things can be
incorporated into a horror film’s plot, playing off of these primal traits to touch the audience in
Atmosphere
A horror movie needs a story--not necessarily a plot, as proven by the film version of The
Shining, which is a character driven movie--or premise to keep the audience invested. It is the
story that proposes outcomes to fear, it is the story that sets up a location in isolation. It is the
base on which the movie is built, and from there the filmmaker adds scares and suspense. On top
of a strong story, a horror movie needs an effective atmosphere, one of creepy uneasiness
throughout the entire movie. Wan explains that if a horror movie has a chilling atmosphere
throughout the entire run, then the audience will already be unnerved and vulnerable to being
pushed over the edge (“Director James Wan discusses ‘Insidious.’”). A horror story is made
more horrific when it carries a creepy atmosphere, which can be enhanced by a variety of
Alfred Hitchcock, the master of suspense, once said that “there’s no terror in a bang, only
the anticipation of one” (Konow). Hitchcock takes time to carefully structure his sequences of
suspense leading up to a scare, or the revelation of a threat. His suspense is different from a
shock scene, where the shocking occurence ends just as quickly as it started. With suspense,
Hitchcock gives the audience more information than the characters are aware of. He shows the
audience that the characters are in danger and that something bad is going to happen, leaving the
audience in a strong state of tension as they are forced to wait and see when the terrible thing
will happen to those characters (“These 3 HITCHCOCK Techniques”), to whom they have an
emotional attachment. Other directors have used other techniques to build suspense as well.
Fred Walton, director of When A Stranger Calls, spent a good portion of his suspenseful
sequences showing every detail of the scene, allowing the viewer to absorb everything in the
setting and more fully engage in the world of the story (Konow).
different ways. A horror movie can use long, unbroken shots to further intensify the sense of
waiting, building tension up to the scare. Shorter sequences that have quicker cuts can be used to
confuse the viewer and create a sense of chaos. They work best when there is a lot of
information to be given to the audience in a short amount of time, and if there are multiple
perspectives to cover (Gates). Both styles of timing can be used in different scenarios,
depending on the taste and purpose of the filmmaker, but are often used so that shorter sequences
are used to introduce a scare, while the longer type builds off of the set up of that idea. In
Hong 7
addition to timing, framing can also prove to be a powerful technique in the creation of a strong
horror film. Negative space is the space in a frame that is not the subject of the camera’s focus.
Improper balance of positive and negative space looks and feels uncomfortable to the viewer, but
this can be done on purpose in horror films. Also, tight framing restricts what the audience can
see. If there is a close up on a character and the character holds a frightened expression, the
close up prevents the viewer from seeing what is so terrifying for the character (Shelton), which
Lighting
Another important contributor to the fear factor of horror films is lighting. Most people,
religious or even non-religious, associate light from above with heaven and light from below
with hell. Light from below is also generally uncommon in nature, and the way it hits the human
face from a low angle distorts a viewer’s perception of that face. For these reasons, light from
below can create the sense of unease, and can even make the audience feel that something
that scene. Limiting light or filming through objects that block light can also contribute to
feelings of fear. In fact, the absence or limitation of light causes the formation of shadows,
leaving the viewer to fear what may or may not be hiding in that darkness (“8 Spooky Lighting
Techniques”). All of these visual techniques play a major part in the effectiveness of a horror
film, but one factor that should never be neglected is sound design.
Sound
Many have looked at how sounds affect the brain, and came to the conclusion that
nonlinear sounds of high pitches and frequencies make humans feel uncomfortable, partially
Hong 8
because they resemble the screams of the young (Stoller-Conrad; Shelton). But high sounds are
not the only useful noises in horror films. Infrasounds are sounds that are so low that they
cannot be heard, only felt by the human body. This disorients the mind, and has even caused
dizziness in some people who have been subjected to infrasounds (Shelton). Lots of sound
effects can clearly indicate to the audience that something or someone is on the way, which
works with Alfred Hitchcock’s theory of suspense. However, unfamiliar noises have their place,
too. Noises that do not sound like they come from the world as people know it can cause fear
because people do not understand them, or how they happened (Lopez), which fits with the fear
of the unknown.
Loud, sudden noises have also found their way into most horror movies, surprising the
audience when they least suspect it. The basic idea of a jump scare is a sudden burst of sound
accompanied by an unsettling image. They can follow a slow build of suspense or come out of
nowhere. There are also “faux jumpscares,” which are normal jump scares, only instead of
unsettling imagery, whatever is accompanying the loud noise turns out to be nothing worthy of
fear, like a cat or a friend of the protagonist (Calvo). James Wan’s films include lots of jump
scares, but both his work and his word in given interviews make it clear that he dislikes the fake
jumpscare. He believes that they would startle just to startle and do not leave a frightening
impression as a normal jump scare might, draining the tension and killing the potential of
genuine jump scares (“Director James Wan discusses ‘Insidious.’”). Although jump scares are
common, they are not required. Many horror films (like The Shining) instead use a lack of
sound, leading the audience to worry that things are unusually quiet. Showing a threat without a
loud sound is a more subtle approach that can be quite unsettling in a clean, simple way (Calvo).
Hong 9
Data
ineffective)
that space.
Showing the
was ineffective
(1961), dir. Jack atmosphere all was accidentally amazing with its
Hong 10
observed Feb 10 ghosts only seen and moved hints, and most
have expected an
Hong 11
accompanied
noise
essence that
inhuman
movie Behind”)
(2017), dir. Gabe cheesy gore and on the short’s showed how
them
whatsoever.
gloomy
ambience and
depressing
silence
slow build up of
tension that
made the
audience expect
a jump scare,
happen
leading up to contributed to an
characters
(1980), dir. Peter the ghost going effects to make powerful sound
ghost’s tragic
backstory,
touching a soft
spot in the
audience. Kept
the ghosts
offscreen (fear
of unknown),
were distorted
through barriers,
the bottom of a
Hong 17
bathtub flowing
with water
Analysis
This data collection is a descriptive study, because it seeks to describe what factors of
a movie and its editing evoke reactions of fear from horror movie audiences. To collect the
data, the observational method was used because the research is a creative endeavor that
requires the researcher to observe and analyze movies. The tool used in this observational
process was a double entry notebook, where the notebook was divided into observations and
personal interpretations. The observations were strictly what was seen or heard on-screen,
while the personal interpretation column allowed the researcher to explain what it was about
the observation was relevant to the research question. Observations were usually recorded to
highlight common traits amongst all nine films, or things that stuck out and were worth
mentioning. Notes also recorded things that did not evoke fear from the researchers. The
observed movies were The Innocents (1961), The Conjuring (2013), When A Stranger Calls
(1979), Insidious (2010), Insidious 2 (2013), The Changeling (1980), The Ring (2002), Lights
Out (2016), and Elf on the Shelf, a 2017 short uploaded to YouTube by CryptTV.
It is very important for filmmakers to play off of the audience’s expectations, tricking
them into believing that a certain event will happen, and as tension builds up to that event,
something else occurs, surprising the audience. Most, but not all of the horror movies that
were observed also contained supernatural antagonists. Horror movies can have effective
human antagonists, but based on the observations, it is ineffective to cross over elements.
Hong 18
The spirits in Insidious and The Changeling would communicate to the characters, only they
did so through other human characters, usually psychics. This kept the ghosts in mystery, and
the lack of direct communication allowed the audience to individually imagine how such a
horrible thing might sound. Diana, the ghost in Lights Out, spoke English and could be seen
up close, slamming doors and rocking on the floor. This was not as scary, because her
movements looked too normal, and it did not feel like a supernatural being was present, it
While the filming process is what gives the villain movement, the editing can also
determine how the movements will look in the final film, and the issue could have been
resolved That is not to say that supernatural villains cannot have human traits (or vice versa),
but it is just beneficial to keep these traits to a subtle limit. If there are human antagonists,
then the movie can use that to its advantage. What makes movies like Black Christmas,
When A Stranger Calls, and Halloween scary is that the killer is just a normal person.
Movies like these warn the audience that the “normal” person right next to them could be
dangerous. But mixing elements from either type of villain, if not properly handled, can
possibly result in an ineffective villain. In addition to the portrayal of the villain, James Wan
(director of Insidious) explained in an interview that it is crucial for horror movies to have a
consistent undertone of dread and unease, so that audiences are already at the edge of their
seats when the frights occur to push them over the edge. The observed movies achieved this
feeling, often having characters framed in a way so that a dark background loomed behind
them, or by using shots where the characters could be seen standing alone in wide, open
spaces. These images indicate that anything at any time could come out from that supposedly
Hong 19
empty space to harm the character, even in scenes that seem safe. This sense of false security
keeps every scene uneasy, whether or not a threat is actually present. In When A Stranger
Calls, the character Jil is on the phone when it suddenly cuts to a subtle movement in another
room, then cutting back to Jil on the couch. Jil believes she is safe, but the audience is now
aware that she is not as safe as she thinks. This builds suspense through dramatic irony, a
technique that Alfred Hitchcock was very fond of. When A Stranger Calls and Halloween
both used a similar technique: in both movies, a character is made aware that something evil
is in the house, only she does not know where. The editor then briefly cuts to various rooms
in the house, each shrouded in darkness, to visually inform the audience that the character
could be in any location. Halloween further enhances this effect by editing in the sound of
Michael Myer’s (the film’s antagonist) breathing over this sequence of cuts. Lastly, a very
common technique that is used in multiple films was used for scenes when a character sees
something horrifying. The editor lingers on the character’s reaction for a moment before
revealing what they are actually seeing, or sometimes they do not reveal that horror at all.
Lingering before revealing forces the audience to wait, and there is suspense before the shock
that will release the unbearable tension. Lingering on the character’s reaction and then not
showing what they are seeing can also be effective, because it builds the suspense and does
not release it, carrying over the tension to the following scenes while also making the
audience feel that the subject of the character’s view was too scary to be shown, which
These were just some of the things that were taken away from the observation process.
While not every finding was exactly surprising, it definitely brought more attention to
Hong 20
techniques that might have been neglected if not given careful attention. These results
demonstrate some of the editing techniques that filmmakers of good horror films have used to
communicate messages to the audience in a way that frightens them. However, the method
used to collect this information was limited, because artistic topics like filmmaking are
subject to opinion. There was not a concrete way to determine the exact reason a scene was
effective, because the editing alone did not make the movie impactful; the story, the
soundtrack, the performances, and the writing are just as important. Editing is crucial and
brings these elements together, determining the direction of the film, but it is very difficult for
editing to support a weak story with unconvincing performances and terrible writing. If this
research were to be repeated, the observations would be more specific to more carefully
separate elements of editing from other filmmaking factors. For example, future research
could look at scenes building suspense and measure the time between cuts until the final
release of tension.
These results can further help researchers look at how movies affect audiences,
especially as Internet streaming and the increase in personal technology bring media to people
of all kinds and ages. Finding a way to create horror without conforming to the usual jumps
and violence can provide the thrills that people seek without subjecting them to offensive
material. The hope for this research is to encourage creativity, as well as developing the
strong story and characters that many movies tend to lack. Much was taken away from these
findings, such as how subtle hints in editing can have a major effect on the audience. The
research also stressed the importance of mystery and leaving things to the imagination to
Hong 21
conjure up personal fears, rather than directly giving the audience something that may or may
The effectiveness of a strong horror movie can be attributed to editing that favors long
sequences of suspense, appeals to the fear of the unknown, and is based on the grounds of an
Conclusions
Based on the information gathered from the literature review and the data collection,
the many elements of a strong horror film can be compiled into a new formula for an effective
horror movie. James Wan explained that horror movies should have a consistent undertone of
dread. In the data collection, the most successful horror movies possessed a strange quality
that made the audience feel as though they were constantly being watched. These two
elements can be combined, so that the underlying tone throughout the horror movie is the
feeling that the audience is never truly safe and away from prying eyes. To achieve this, the
lighting can hit faces from below. Scenes of dialogue will be shot over characters’ shoulders,
or from a distance. Seeing the characters from a distance will also be applied when the
characters are alone, imitating the point of view of a villain. The camera will peer at them
through barriers, like windows or bars. This style of filming will only be broken when
characters discover something. In those cases, the camera will draw closer to the character’s
face, utilizing the fear of the unknown because the audience can not see the horror that they
do. Additionally, eerie sounds (as described in the literature review) will be present in scenes
Hong 22
where the true presence of a threat is unknown, so that the audience can feel uneasy even if
In conclusion, horror movies are each unique in their own way. Even copycat films
and shot-for-shot remakes are in some way different from the movies that inspired their
creation. Because they are each unique, it can be hard to decipher how each tiny element
affected the movie as a whole. But it is possible to look at what the best horror movies have
different horror films. The observed movies showed that an effective horror film needs an
engaging story or premise with sympathetic characters that carries a chilling atmosphere
(which can be achieved through editing, lighting, sound, etc.) throughout, with long
sequences of suspense building up to genuine scares, either to introduce a scare or to build off
of the introduction of a threat from earlier in the film. These visuals are to be supported by a
soundtrack, with nonlinear noises and infrasounds that surprise and unnerve audiences. In
addition, the editing of sound into the movie should not neglect a lack of sound, which is
effective in its own way. The sounds can indicate a threat that is not explicitly shown on
screen, forcing the viewers to personally imagine the worst thing that their minds can conjure
up. The events of the movie (as experienced by the audience through sympathetic characters)
are the meat of its effectiveness, supported by atmosphere, sound, and timing, which are
glued together by the mentioned editing techniques. Of course, even this balance of elements
can differ between films depending on the people who make them. Some might include some
things, while leaving out others. But an absolute necessity for an effective horror film is
imagination and creativity from both the filmmakers and the audience. With this in mind,
Hong 23
horror films can be made to provide the desired thrills without having to resort to tiring tactics
of offensive nature.
Hong 24
Works Cited
“Behind the Scenes of The Conjuring.” YouTube, uploaded by Horror Movies Official, 30 Nov.
2014, www.youtube.com/watch?v=4SiV-6znBbg. Accessed 1 Apr. 2018.
Calvo, A.D. “So You Want to Make a Horror Film? On Jump Scares and Other Basics of
Fright.” Filmmaker Magazine, 28 Oct. 2013,
filmmakermagazine.com/76622-so-you-want-to-make-a-horror-film-on-jump-scares-and-
other-basics-of-fright/#.WqKNlVMwi-p. Accessed 9 Mar. 2018.
Freese, Cris. “How to Write Suspense like Stephen King.” Writer’s Digest,
www.writersdigest.com/editor-blogs/there-are-no-rules/write-suspense-stephen-king.
Accessed 15 Mar. 2018.
Frome, Jonathan, and Aaron Smuts. “Helpless Spectators: Generating Suspense in Videogames
and Film.” TEXT Technology, 1 Nov. 2004.
Gates, Chris. “When Editing a Horror Movie or Thriller, Timing Is Key.” Videomaker, 4 Aug.
2014. Videomaker.com,
www.videomaker.com/article/c3/17056-when-editing-a-horror-movie-or-thriller-timing-i
s-key. Accessed 8 Feb. 2018.
Heimdahl, Lisolette, et al. “Effects for Timing of Revealing Threats in Contents.” Japan Society
for Graphic Science, 2017,
www.projektowaniegier.us.edu.pl/wp-content/uploads/2017/09/Effects-for-timing-of-rev
ealing-threats-in-horror-contents.pdf. Accessed 21 Feb. 2018.
“Insidious Chapter 2 Extended Behind the Scenes Featurette.” Youtube, 4 Sept. 2013,
www.youtube.com/watch?v=flJdcNkYm4E. Accessed 1 Apr. 2018.
Konow, David. “The Rules of Terror in Horror Movies.” Tested.com, 1 May 2013,
www.tested.com/art/movies/455206-rules-terror-horror-movies/. Accessed 13 Mar. 2018.
Lehne, Moritz, and Stefan Koelsch. “Toward a General Psychological Model of Tension and
Suspense.” Frontiersin.org, 11 Feb. 2015,
www.frontiersin.org/articles/10.3389/fpsyg.2015.00079/full. Accessed 14 Mar. 2018.
Miyamoto, Ken. “9 Simple Lessons for Writing Effective Horror Screenplays.” Screencraft.org,
4 May 2016,
screencraft.org/2016/05/04/9-simple-lessons-for-writing-effective-horror-screenplays/.
Accessed 15 Mar. 2018.
Renée, V. “8 Spooky Lighting Techniques You Can Use in Your Horror Film.”
Nofilmschool.com, 2018,
nofilmschool.com/2016/10/8-spooky-lighting-techniques-you-can-use-your-horror-film.
Accessed 14 Mar. 2018.
Renée, V. “How to Make Your Horror Screenplay More Effective.” Nofilmschool.com, 1 Oct.
2013,
nofilmschool.com/2013/10/how-to-make-your-horror-film-screenplay-more-effective.
Accessed 15 Mar. 2018.
Rhode, Jason. “Seeking Out The Changeling 35 Years Later.” CrypticRock.com, 18 Sept. 2015,
crypticrock.com/seeking-out-the-changeling-35-years-later/. Accessed 1 Apr. 2018.
Shelton, Jacob. “15 Ways You Didn’t Even Realize Horror Movies Are Manipulating You into
Fear.” Ranker.com,
www.ranker.com/list/horror-movie-tricks-for-scaring-the-audience/jacob-shelton?utm_ex
pid=16418821-388.pwrOe5-lSJetLqzNW0S00A.0&utm_referrer=https%3A%2F%2Fww
w.google.com%2F. Accessed 13 Mar. 2018.
Stoller-Conrad, Jessica. “Putting Fear in Your Ears: What Makes Music Sound Scary.” National
Public Radio, 12 June 2012,
www.npr.org/sections/health-shots/2012/06/12/154853739/putting-fear-in-your-ears-wha
t-makes-music-sound-scary. Accessed 15 Mar. 2018.
“These 3 HITCHCOCK Techniques Are Not Copied Enough.” YouTube, uploaded by Sven
Pape, 1 July 2017, www.youtube.com/watch?v=E1LzhiCcOY0. Accessed 17 Mar. 2018.
Wixson, Heather. “Interview: James Wan on His Creative Process, Returning to Horror with The
Conjuring 2 and His Approach to Aquaman.” Dailydead.com, 9 June 2016,
dailydead.com/interview-james-wan-creative-process-returning-horror-conjuring-2-appro
ach-aquaman/. Accessed 13 Mar. 2018.