Sei sulla pagina 1di 13

Aesthetes, Ogees and "The Lady":

Queer Complications in The Line of Beauty


Lorena Russell

The Line of Beauty (2004 winner of the Booker


.Prize) follows events in the life of a young gay man in
1980's London. Nick Guest, as his name implies, is a
character who has not quite yet found his place.
When the story begins, he has moved to London to
begin graduate studies in English literature. He is
living in an attic room in the family home of one his
Oxford acquaintances, Toby Fedden. He has an
unrequited crush on Toby, and is serving as unofficial
caretaker of the younger sister, Catherine. Catherine
suffers from what is eventually diagnosed as manic-
Russell 170 Russell 171

depressive disorder. Fragile and self-destructive, she that race, ethnicity, postcolonial nationality criss-cross
is also the one character in the text that retains a with these and other identity-constituting, identity-
critical perspective on her family's dysfunctions. fracturing discourses..." (9). Both of these definitions
Gerald, the father, has just won a seat to Parliament point to the tendency towards queer as a signifier of
on a conservative ticket, and is marked by his excess and elaboration: as a term that strains at the
competitive nature and adoration of "The Lady," boundaries of categories, and functions largely
Prime Minister Margaret Thatcher. It through Nick's through mechanisms of complication.
_ complicated and baffling engagement with the On another level, the aesthetic emphasis within A
Fedden's that Hollinghurst unfolds his story of gay Lineof Beautystrikes me as akin to what Michel
sexuality in 1980's Britain. Foucault describes in his interview "On the
This article focuses on concepts of complication Genealogy of Ethics." In conversation with Paul
and aesthetics within The Line of Beauty to argue for a Rabinow, Foucault struggles to differentiate a strain
particularly queer resonance between these two of ethical thought that avoids the kind of prohibitive
narrative impulses. In part, my use of queer here normalizing one typically associates with ethical
reflects a definition offered by Eve Kosofosky systems. He tentatively differentiates the ethical
Sedgwick in her essay "Queer and Now": lithe open thought of the Stoic philosophers with what emerges
mesh of possibilities, gaps, overlaps, dissonances and in the later empire. Foucault describes how for the
resonances, lapses and excesses of meaning when the Stoics,
constituent elements of anyone's gender, of anyone's this kind of ethic was only a problem of
sexuality aren't made (or can't bemade) to signify personal choice. Second, it was reserved for
monolithically" (Sedgwick 8). One of the major a few people in the population; it was not a
impulses within this notion of queer is its resistance question of giving a pattern of behavior for
to any simple characterization of sexuality. In the everybody. It was a personal choice for a
same essay, Sedgwick goes on to offer considerations small elite. The reason for making this choice
of how the term queer moves beyond exclusive was the will to live a beautiful life, and to
concerns of gender and sexuality to include lithe ways leave to others memories of a beautiful
Russell 172
Russell 173

existence. I don't think we can say that this becomes one of the central signifiers of a queer male
kind of ethic was an attempt to normalize sexuality. If for Foucault, however, the aesthetic
the population. (Foucault and Rabinow 341) marks a space characterized by a lack of social or
For Foucault, this notion of Stoic self-fashioning was juridical scrutiny, for Nick Guest it remains a space
linked to a certain austerity and fatalism, qualities muddled by sexual. insecurities. As an elitist impulse,
that are notably lacking in Nick's character until the as a way for Nick to seek a level of superiority and
novel's conclusion. Still, when Foucault describes
belonging within a limited social group or family, the
"the will to live a beautiful life," he seems to me to be
model of the aesthete seems to promise a level of
moving close to describing the figure of the aesthete social position and belonging he so desperately needs.
that is so well-represented by Nick (and the literary But his performance as an aesthete is compromised
tradition of Wilde, James, Waugh, and Forster that throughout the novel by his apparent lack of Stoic
precedes Hollinghurst's novel). As a guiding resolve, not to mention his failing performance as a
principle of an ethical philosophy, such concept heterosexual man.
seems limited given our contemporary preferences for For Nick, aesthetic class aspirations are closely
Aristotelian and Kantian philosophies. In fact, linked with heterosexual privilege. When Nick feels
Rabinow describes this turn within Foucault as
excluded socially, it gets expressed through
"techniques of the self," a term which seems to imply metaphors that capture his difference in terms of class
its elitist ~d solipsistic tendency (Foucault and and sexuality. At Toby's big twenty-first birthday
Rabinow 341). But by removing the notion of ethics party at Lord Kessler's magnificent estate, for
away from social and political structures and example, Nick circles the various groupings: "He saw
translating it as a kind of self-fashioning, Foucault the great heterosexual express pulling out from the
seeks to carve out a space of self-expression that platform precisely on time, and all his friends were on
would disallow for legislating sexualities. it, in the first-class carriage-in the wagons-lits!" (59).
Whether or not the aesthete offers a solid
This sense of being left in the dust is countered by the
foundation for ethical reasoning, the character of the reassurance he feels when he catches a glimpse of
aesthete persists within the gay literary canon, and himself in a mirror: "As he crossed the drawing room
Russell 174
Russell 175

he acknowledged himself with a flattered smile in a twenty-first would be followed soon enough by a
mirror. He was wearing a wing collar, and something wedding" only makes him feel even more an outsider
dandyish in him, some memory of the license and to Toby and the Feddens (62)~He clings to every
discipline of being in a play, lifted his 'mood" (54-55). crumb of gay sentiment, but then deconstructs its
As readers, we may doubt how dashing Nick really underlying straight assumptions. When Toby says
looks in his great-uncle's dinner jacket, but Nick "God, darling, you smell like a tart's parlour" Nick
himself seems satisfied with the illusion.
dissects it: "He was holding in the unprecedented
This ironic space that opens in the reader's ,darling' and it was making him as warm and giddy
perspective of Nick's failed illusion finds a comedic as the pot. Then he let out the smoke and saw the
parallel in Nick's self-assured performance as an baldly hetero claims of the rest of the remark" (77). It
aesthete and his clumsy attempt "to be a part of this is this tension between his desire for inclusion in the
hetero mob" (72). Here Nick's desire to pass as class-bound Tory crowd and the relentless
heterosexual is compounded by the fact that the heterosexism that is endemic within the group that
figure of the dandy that Nick so energetically keeps Nick in a kind of limbo, attached to a family
embraces serves as an obvious signal of gay male where he clearly does not belong.
identity. It's hard to stay safely in the closet when Nick is drawn into the family grouping on
one is always dashing out garbed in wing collars, several levels. There is of course his crush on Toby,
commenting endlessly on antiques and gushing and his longing to find a sense of a place as a "lost
shamelessly over Henry James! Still he persists in his middle child" in the Fedden's constellation.
attempts inhabit the Fedden's world, wondering all Primarily, though, he is also attracted to the glamour
the while if Lord Kessler, his guests and his wait staff of their upper-class lives. While Nick recognizes the
are seeing through Nick's heterosexual guise. superficialities of the Feddens' "looking glass world,"
We view this rarified world through Nick's gay he nevertheless can't resist the seduction of their
sensibility. The whole occasion of the birthday seems privilege and its trappings (55). An antique dealers'
to be wrapped up with heterosexual expectations; the son by birth and an aesthete by nature, he moves
fact that "the huge heterosexual probability that a through life by following the pull of his finely-honed
Russell 176 Russell 177

sensibilities and desires. Ultimately, though, Nick's Hogarth, as he updates their critiques to explore the
aesthetic disposition will prove an inadequate guide: political and ethical bankruptcy of 1980's England
this "line of beauty" puts him on a superficial course through a queer lens.
of fleeting pleasures, allowing little space for As this trio of literary predecessors implies (and
confronting the meanness and ugliness that lie just here one could certainly add Oscar Wilde to the mix),l
under the surface of the comfortable Tory lifestyle. Hollinghurst is also writing within a tradition of gay
The end of the novel finds him alone, outed, brutally fiction. But while James, Wilde, Waugh and Forster
excluded from the Feddens, and facing a likely future for the most part tended to treat homosexuality in
of AIDS/HIV. oblique, traditionally coded ways, Hollinghurst
When described in this way, the story sounds updates his treatment of the figure of the gay aesthete
like a traditional morality tale: a warning against the by considering his explicit relationship to broader
excesses and superficialities of the ruling class and political issues in the Thatcher era. Ultimately, The
decadent lifestyles of the 1980's. And in part, this is LineofBeauty'sengagement with sexuality
certainly what the novel is about. In his review, critic complicates whatever moralizing the story invites.
Andrew Holleran writes "TheLineof Beautymay As Holleran points out, the conclusion of the story,
suddenly seem, despite its contemporary setting, as specifically its treatment of AIDS, is largely what
old-fashioned as Richardson's Pamela--orHogarth's helps the book to succeed. Even beyond that, though,
The Rake's Progress."Still, Holleran allows, and I the novel's queering complicates what could be
agree, that Hollinghurst's fiction, while critiquing the simplistic. Such complication is, in fact, one of the
superficialities of an aesthete's life, manages to hallmarks of what one could term a "queer poetic," a
convey a broader view than the moralizing one finds literary or theoretical approach that seeks to broaden
in Richardson or Hogarth. Although the novel clearly readers' understandings of sexuality beyond that of
critiques the superficiality of the ruling classes, the commonly received or imagined. In this
Hollingsworth's approach to these social questions complication Hollinghurst's novel mirrors the title's
follows more in the path of Henry James, Evelyn allusion to the architectural term "ogee," the so-called
Waugh and E.M. Forster than that of Richardson or "line of beauty" that achieves its aesthetic effects
Russell 178 Russell 179

through a balanced complication. The two lines of The novel thus carefully maps the sometimes
complication I want to concentrate on in this essay, intricate interdependence of status and secrecy. As
Nick's negotiations of the seductions of a gay life Eve Kosofsky Sedgwick argues in Epistemologyof the
against the privileges of Tory lifestyles, point to ways Closet,the closet in queer lives represents that
in which the queering of novel itself thematically and oppositional space of secrecy through which gay
structurally mimics the complicated yet pleasing identities gets crafted. The Line of Beauty tracks these
effects of the ogee. complications of the closet: those unpredictable yet
The complexities of the closet complicate Nick's potent effects that the ongoing plays between secrecy
life on multiple levels. He is drawn to the Feddens in and knowledge yield.2 Throughout the text, Nick
part due to his unrequited crush on the Fedden's son. must negotiate the imperatives of the closet against
While his affections offer one motivation for him to his desire for social acceptance.
install himself in the Fedden's family constellation, From the beginning, Nick Guest's private sex life
this connection remains unknown to all but Nick. is at odds with his life with the Feddens. At the
From the Fedden's perspective, his role in the family opening of the novel, a naIve and inexperienced Nick
is as watchdog over the unstable sister Catherine, Guest surreptitiously seeks gay companionship
who is also privy to his early forays into the world of through the want ads. His efforts payoff when he
the want ads. The two conspire like children when the meets Leo, a sexy, working-class black bicyclist. At
adults are vacationing in France. When the novel once, his desires put him at odds with his class
begins, Nick's gay identification comes out of these ambitions as represented by the Feddens: "Gerald
unrequited desires: he has had no gay lovers and has [Fedden] could say, 'I want to be Home Secretary,'
never really been challenged to live as gay. Through and have people smiling but conceding the
the course of the story, he moves from an eroticaIly- possibility. But Nick's ambition was to be loved by a
charged affair with a working class man he meets handsome black man in his late twenties with a racing
through the want ads to an equally surreptitious bike and a job .inlocal government" (25). This erotic
affair with a wealthy, but closeted friend of the ambition, with its embrace of class, race and gender
Feddens. difference, is not going to win Nick Guest social
Russell 180 Russell 181

approval with the Feddens. It does however, prove and shrubbery behind the high Victorian railings....
gratifying for Nick, at least in the short run. There were hidden places, even on the inside, the
Hollinghurst offers us insight into Nick's closeted path that curled, as if to a discreet convenience, to the
negotiations, as he carefully avoids a gay bar for his gardener's hut behind a larch-lap fence..." (13). This
first meeting with Leo and instead choosing a solidly secret yet elitist setting proves the perfect stage for
middle-class area whose affectations immediately put Nick's sexual experience:
the working-class Leo on edge. But Leo's initial just before he came he had a brief vision of
reticence in the pub gives way to passion in the elite himself, as if the trees and bushes had rolled
spaces of the Notting Hill gardens. The garden space away and all the lights of London shone in
that sets the scene for Nick's first gay sex signals the on him: little Nick Guest from Barwick, Don
complications of the closet. As was true with and Dot Guest's boy, fucking a stranger in a
Hollinghurst's earlier novel, TheSwimmingPool Notting Hill garden at night. Leo was right,
Library, spaces seem to resonate with queer desire or it was so bad, and it was so much the best
its repudiation, its possibility for expression or for thing he'd ever done (36).
repression. Thus the setting and the sex combine to provide Nick
The ambivalent play between public and private with a sense of himself doubly situated: at once "bad"
finds expression through the garden setting. The and" good," at once open and hidden, both inside
communal gardens behind the Fedden's spacious and outside the dominant culture.
home are actually far from public, rather they exist as This doubleness is also something Nick lives out
a shared but locked space in an elitist part of town. through his ambivalence about his own sexual
For Nick, they hold strong appeal, in part because of identity, and his inability to fit into gay culture: "As
the way their double nature combines class and so often he felt he had the wrong kind of irony, the
secrecy: "The communal gardens were as much a part wrong knowledge, for gay life. He was still faintly
of Nick's romance of London as the house itself: big shocked, among other emotions of interest and
as the central park of some old European city, but excitement, at the idea of a male couple" (94). Still, as
private, and densely hedged on three sides with holly his character develops, he becomes more comfortable
Russell 182
Russell 183

with this identity, merging his acute sense of style Leo, but remains quiet about Wani, who fiercely
with what one might call "gay sensibility": "He felt cloaks his identity behind a very public marriage
deliciously brainwashed by sex, when he closed his engagement.
eyes phallus chased phallus like a wallpaper pattern The relationship between Nick and the Feddens
across the dark, and at any moment the imagery of is one of many secrets. There is Nick's secret crush on
anal intercourse, his new triumph and skill, could Toby that begins the whole infatuation. Their
gallop in surreal montage across the street or relationship becomes one that evolves out of secrets.
classroom or dining table" (136). Early in the story, Nick makes the decision to not tell
The double existence that Nick will lead
the vacationing Fedden family that Catherine had
throughout the novel becomes exacerbated when he come close to a suicidal episode with a set of carving
leaves Leo behind, and in 1986, pairs with a rich but knives. While Nick is not secretive about his
deeply closeted Lebanese man, Wani. It seems that sexuality-they know from the beginning that he is
Nick has found his perfect mate, one who combines gay - he does make a point of keeping his
the elegance of wealth and its trappings with gayness relationship with Wani quiet, and it is the power of
and racial difference. They embark on a business this secret that sets the stage for an eruption of
venture, starting a new stylish magazine titled scandal at the end. Finally, though, the complications
"Ogee." Together he and Wani move through the of the closet come to involve Gerald Fedden when
mid-eighties, and the metaphorical meanings of the Nicks discovers his secret affair with his secretary,
"line of beauty" come to encompass cocaine. Nick Penny. The scandal that ruins Gerald's career ends
continues to balance his queer identity in the up having as much to do with this elicit affair as with
conservative family as an open secret: something that Nick's sexuality. Thus the meanings of the closet
is assumed to be shared knowledge, but something come to extend well beyond sexual orientation per se,
which remains unspoken and hidden. Toby knows of and the novel becomes an examination of broader
his sexuality from his college days, but remains workings of power, knowledge and ignorance.
oblivious to Nick's attraction towards him. Nick
This alignment of Gerald Fedden's sexual
openly confides in Catherine about his affair with vulnerability alongside Nick's sexual vulnerability
Russell 184
Russell 185

points to the ways the social intolerance can work left here with an explicit link between "queer" and
. against both straight and queer. But it also invites "beauty," two terms that come together over the
consideration of Fedden's secret affair with Penny as notion of the "unusual." For the Feddens and their
a kind of sex which, while not gay, puts him on equal homophobic friends, Nick's attachment is "the sort of
ground with Nick. However, it is Nick who will bear thing you read about, it's an old homo trick. You can't
the brunt of Fedden's rage, as they perversely blame have a real family so you attach yourself to someone
him for Gerald's political downfall. These characters else's" (420). While the phrase" an old homo trick"
are as much positioned by power as by desire, and reveals the narrow homophobia that informs the
queerness is clearly as inflicted by class as by Fedden's circle of friends, the notion of "queer" as
sexuality. While the first party leaves Nick feeling signifying an alternative family signals one of the
alienated from the "hetero mob," the latter affair with ways that the novel shifts identity from the rather .
Margaret Thatcher leaves him aware of the "The essentialist notion of desire to a broader notion of
fantastic queenery of the men. The heterosexual affiliation.
queenery" (333). This complication of identity-the notion that
The outsider position that Nick Guest inhabits is queering might extend beyond the somewhat narrow
in one sense indicative of his queerness, but his definition of "gender of object choice" - is achieved in
queern~ss is again something that extends quite part through the text's treatment of the closet and its
beyond his sexual predilections. Nick also is queer on potential variations. On another level, though, The
account of his oblique and tenuous position within LineofBeautycomes to engage the various
the Fedden family, and his tentative relationship is a implications of nationality. Hollinghurst refuses to
matter of class and politics, as well as blood. When look at sexual identity in isolation from issues of race,
things explode at the end of the novel, one of the country and class, and in that sense, his work pursues
Fedden's friends confronts him: "I mean, didn't it another characteristic of queering. As Cathy J. Cohen
strike you as rather odd, a bit queer, attaching explains in her article "Punks, Bulldaggers and
yourself to a family like this?" "Nick thought it was Welfare Queens," to be truly transformative, queering
unusual- that was the beauty of it..." (420). We are must be "located in its ability to create a space in
Russell 186 Russell 187

opposition to dominant norms" rather than simply which country she was now in. "She showed
being liJ.1kedto a potentially homogenizing sexual them in the Falklands, didn't she?" (278)
identity (Cohen 438). While The Line of Beauty This line typifies the level of political conservatism
manages to communicate a traditional, some might that dominates in the Fedden household. While
even say homogenous, gay identity, it complicates Hollinghurst notably puts such political sentiments
this presentation of identity through its engagement into context, it is hard not to cringe along with
with a range of issues around British nationality, Catherine at the level of jingoism expressed here.
power, class and empire. Gerald's mother betrays her attitude with her
For one thing, one never quite forgets one is dismissal of one guest who "talked a lot of rot at
reading an English novel. Hollinghurst's characters dinner on...the coloured question. I wasn't next to
inhabit a range of familiarly English spaces: the him, but I kept hearing it. Racism, you know" (71).
comer pub, the city garden, the manor house. One By the end the Fedden's class morality ends up
hilarious scene takes place at a local fair where Gerald including a rather damning brew of infidelities and
is campaigning in what is described as "A perfect secrets, of and homophobia and racism.
English day." In a gesture of perverse The Feddens and their circle of friends are
competitiveness, Gerald gets taken up with the sport suitably entranced by Margaret Thatcher, whom they
of "welly-wanging" or tossing Wellingtons (236). reverently address as "The Lady." The novel invites
Even when they are in France they insulate readers to consider the superficiality of Gerald
themselves to the point where they forget they are not Fedden's seduction of Thatcher against Nick's
in England: seductions of his lovers. In an early scene, Gerald.
The talk came round, as it often did with the refinishes his door in blue when he hears that "The
Feddens, to the Prime Minister. Nick saw Lady" disapproves of green. It is notable in text so
Catherine clench in annoyance when her conscious of aesthetics that one would bastardize
grandmother said, "She's put this country on oneself in this way: renouncing a favored color on the
its feet!" -clearly forgetting, in her fervour, basis of political aspirations. When Thatcher finally
comes around to their home, Nick engages in the
Russell 188
Russell 189

charade, summoning the nerve to actually ask her to wallpaper or blue front doors-she noticed nothing,
dance:
and yet she remembered everything" (336). As the
It was the simplest thing to do-Nick came party ends, Nick, Wani and a waiter retreat upstairs
forward and sat, half-kneeling, on the sofa's for cocaine and sex, while below, the Mercedes carries
edge, like someone proposing in a play. He the Prime Minister away.
gazed delightedly at the Prime Minister's Beyond Hollinghurst's biting characterizations of
face, at her whole head, beaked and Tory superficiality, the novel finds its political
crowned, which he saw as a fine if sensibility when it finally comes round to facing the
improbable fusion of the Vorticist and the reality of AIDS. The 1980's are the decade when
Baroque. She smiled back with a certain AIDS emerged, and this novel silently tracks the
animal quickness, a bright blue challenge. evolution of this epidemic and its effects on the
(335) characters. The Feddens and their circle are
The dance between Thatcher and Nick dance
predictable homophobic in their responses. When
stands out as one of the most hilarious, and
Nick finally speaks aloud about gay sex and
performative, moments in the text. A jealous Gerald protection, a family friend, after some confusion of
"saw the PM, his idol, who had said before that she oral sex as kissing, responds: "I'm afraid that what
wouldn't dance, but who now, a couple of whiskies you're saying fills me with physical revulsion... They
on, was getting down rather sexily with Nick," and had it coming to them" (296). We not only find Nick's
moves in to interrupt their perceived intimacy (336). circle narrowing as his two lovers succumb to the
For Nick, the dance might represent the apotheosis of disease, but he also faces the prospects of his own
his social climbing and heterosexual performance. mortality, and in doing so evolves beyond the narrow
The superficiality of the whole social group seems to sentiments of his aestheticism.
find new expression in Nick's characterization of As the novel concludes, Nick faces the possibility
Thatcher, who is described as moving "in her own of his own HIV positive status. Although is just on the
accelerated element, her own garlanded perspective, verge of getting the test results, he firmly confronts
she didn't give a damn about squares on the this possibility ["it came over him that the test results
Russell 190 Russell 191

would be positive" (437)], and in doing so, shifts his in stoicism" (473). While the transition implied by the
outlook on the world. Suddenly, his aesthetic removal novel's end is by no means earth-shattering, we are
turns to involvement and a deeper kind of emotional left with hope for a more resolute and self-reliant
engagement with his surroundings: character. For Nick, the need to embrace the attitude
The emotion was startling. It was a sort of of a stoic implies not so much the need to abandon his
terror, made up of emotions from every ethics of the aesthetic, but rather to pursue beauty
stage of his short life, weaning, from a more secure and self-contained, albeit fatalistic
homesickness, envy and self-pity; but he felt position. As he moves out of the Fedden's attic he is
that the self-pity belonged to a larger pity. It able to move into a more comfortable space with his
was a love the world that was shockingly own sexuality, and to refashion himself to live as a
unconditional It wasn't just this street guest no more.
comer but the fact of a street comer at all
that seemed, in the light of the moment, so Notes
beautiful. (438)
, See Nicholson Baker, The Size of Thoughts: Essaysand Other Lumber, 1st ed. (New
These closing lines of the novel gesture to a different York: Random House, 1996). for a comparison of Hollinghurst's The Folding Star
kind of aesthetic involvement, one that links with a and Wilde's Picture of Dorian Gray. Certainly the figure of Wildean aesthete also
echoes strongly within The Line of Beauty.
broad-based sYmpathy or love, quite different that the
level of solipsistic engagement Nick has modeled thus 2 See Eve Kosofsky Sedgwick, Epistemology of the Closet (Berkeley: University of
California Press, 1990). for a discussion of the complications of the closet in late-
far. twentieth century western culture.
This change in sensibility corresponds to Nick's
emergence from the closed and closeted circle of the
Fedden household, but also with his embrace of a Works Oted

new reality, his sensibilities sharpened by the sudden Baker, Nicholson. The Size of Thoughts: Ess<\ys and Other Lumber. 1st ed. New
York: Random House, 1996.
acceptance of his mortality. As he projects himself
Cohen, Cathy J. "Punks, Bulldaggers, and Welfare Queens." ~ 3 (1997): 437-65.
imaginatively into his new future of living with HIV, Foucault, Michel, and Paul Rabinow. "On the Genealogy of Ethics: An Overview
he recognizes "He was young, without much training of Work in Progress." The Fom:ault Reader. Ed. Paul Rabinow. New York:
Pantheon Books, 1984.340-72.
Russell 192

Holleran, Andrew. "The Essentials of Heaven." Gay & Lesbian Review 11.6 .
(2004): 35-6.
Hollinghurst, Alan. The Line of Beauty. New York & London: Bloomsbury, 2004.
_. The Swimming Pool Library. London: Otatto & Windus, 1988.
Sedgwick, Eve Kosofsky. Epistemology of the Ooset. Berkeley: University of
California Press, 1990. .
__. "Queer and Now." Tendencies. Series Q. Durham: Duke UP, 1993.1-19.

Potrebbero piacerti anche