Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
MAY 2014
DISCLAIMER
The persons named as the authors of this report hereby certify that: (i) all
of the views expressed in the research report accurately reflect the
personal views of the authors on the subjects; and (ii) no part of their
compensation was, is, or will be, directly or indirectly, related to the
specific recommendations or views expressed in the research report. This
report has been prepared by Danish Ship Finance A/S (Danmarks
Skibskredit A/S) (“DSF”).
This report is provided to you for information purposes only. Whilst every
effort has been taken to make the information contained herein as reliable
as possible, DSF does not represent the information as accurate or
complete, and it should not be relied upon as such. Any opinions
expressed reflect DSF’s judgment at the time this report was prepared
and are subject to change without notice. DSF will not be responsible for
the consequences of reliance upon any opinion or statement contained in
this report. This report is based on information obtained from sources
which DSF believes to be reliable, but DSF does not represent or warrant
its accuracy. The information in this report is not intended to predict actual
results, and actual results may differ substantially from forecasts and
estimates provided in this report. This report may not be reproduced, in
whole or in part, without the prior written permission of DSF. To Non-
Danish residents: The contents hereof are intended for the use of non-
private customers and may not be issued or passed on to any person
and/or institution without the prior written consent of DSF. Additional
information regarding this publication will be furnished upon request.
HEAD OF RESEARCH
Christopher Rex, rex@shipfinance.dk
ANALYTICAL TEAM
Mette Andersen, mba@shipfinance.dk
Ninna Kristensen, nmk@shipfinance.dk
Sabine Janus, saj@shipfinance.dk
TABLE OF CONTENTS
SHIPPING MARKET REVIEW – MAY 2014
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY, 1
SHIPBUILDING, 13
CONTAINER, 19
CRUDE TANKER, 26
PRODUCT TANKER, 34
LPG TANKER, 43
DRY BULK, 50
GLOSSARY, 58
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
SHIPPING MARKET REVIEW – MAY 2014
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
Please read the disclaimer at the beginning of this report care- shipping markets and strong contracting activity, risk seems to
fully. The report reviews key developments in shipping markets be building up.
and the main shipping segments during the period January 2013
Buying low and selling high has always been the recipe for good
to April 2014 and indicates possible future market directions.
investments. In today’s shipping markets, investors and tradi-
THE SHIPPING INDUSTRY IS UNDERGOING A PROCESS OF tional shipowners are taking advantage of historically low prices
TRANSITION DRIVEN BY A COMBINATION OF TECHNOLOGICAL to purchase both new ships and secondhand vessels.
ADVANCES RELATED TO FUEL EFFICIENCY AND ENVIRONMEN-
Their investment strategy varies but, as we know, many roads
TAL REQUIREMENTS. WE EXPECT SEVERAL SHIPPING SEG-
lead to Rome. Some are investing in fuel-efficient newbuildings,
MENTS TO FACE SIGNIFICANT HEADWINDS FROM FUTURE
compliant with tomorrow’s standards today, while others are
SUPPLY UNTIL A NEW BALANCE BETWEEN SUPPLY AND DE-
choosing to buy and maybe retrofit older vessels. Owners with a
MAND HAS BEEN ESTABLISHED. FREIGHT RATE VOLATILITY
portfolio of expensive and highly leveraged vessels are strug-
MAY INTENSIFY IN THIS PERIOD AND OLDER VESSELS ARE EX-
gling to find opportunities. Shipping is not a team sport and
PECTED TO BE SCRAPPED PREMATURELY IN SEVERAL SEG-
never will be, but everyone is vulnerable to unexpected value
MENTS. SECONDHAND VALUES ARE EXPECTED TO MIRROR THE
depreciations.
MARKET FRAGMENTATION BETWEEN FUEL EFFICIENT VESSELS
AND OLDER VESSELS, AND OLDER VESSELS MAY FACE UNUSU- We expect premature scrapping to be the new norm until a new
ALLY HIGH VALUE DEPRECIATIONS. THESE EXTRAORDINARY balance between supply and demand has been re-established.
CHANGES REPRESENT NOT ONLY A THREAT BUT ALSO AN OP- The value implication of premature scrapping could easily turn
PORTUNITY FOR THE SHIPPING INDUSTRY. out to be a shorter cash-flow period. If this filters through to the
valuation of the vessels, secondhand prices for older and ineffi-
GENERAL REVIEW AND OUTLOOK
cient vessels could be subject to unexpected depreciations.
The landscape of the global economy has been in transition in
recent decades. The growing global economic dependence on Up to now, it has primarily been the tanker segments that have
the Chinese economy is the most obvious, but not the only, ma- attracted new investors’ attention. But the Post-Panamax con-
jor transformation during the last ten to 15 years. The globalisa- tainer segment and some of the offshore supply segments seem
tion in general and the insatiable demand for energy and raw equally exposed to future oversupply issues. The dry bulk mar-
materials, in particular, have effectively reshaped international ket’s belief in future Chinese commodity demand is a story of its
trade flows during the last decade. Most shipping segments own. We share this optimism from a short to medium-term per-
have benefited substantially, as we all know. But in the after- spective, but we remain sceptical about the long-term pro-
math of the global financial crisis, global trade volume growth spects. We argue that China is on the brink of a transition to a
has slowed substantially, mirroring the stronger than expected service-based economy. The rebalancing exercise is about
decline in economic growth across the globe. This deceleration switching China’s growth model away from investment and more
has fuelled questions about whether international trade will re- towards private consumption. Lower investments may eventual-
main an engine of global growth. We truly believe so, but the ly reduce Chinese commodity consumption, and hence reduce
short to medium-term outlook for the global economy suggests the growth in China’s dry bulk demand. In our view, this process
that world trade volumes will grow on a par with world GDP ra- will happen before the vast majority of the Capesize fleet be-
ther than by a multiple, as in the past. This is not cause for come obvious candidates for scrapping.
alarm in itself, but in combination with several oversupplied
Million dwt
Million dwt
fleet increased by 44% between 2008 and 2013 (fig. 3), while 50 50
seaborne trade volumes only increased by 18%. These figures
indicate a nominal gap between supply and demand above 25 0 0
percentage points, while we estimate the current effective out-
put gap to be closer to 17%. Nevertheless, it is important to -50 -50
remember that some segments maintain a reasonably good bal-
ance between supply and demand. These segments are in par- -100 -100
2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016
ticular gas carriers, offshore supply vessels and some of the
smaller niche markets (e.g. car carriers).
Sources: Clarksons, Danish Ship Finance Delivery Scrapping
45 MILLION DWT SCRAPPED DURING 2013
The combination of low freight rates and high scrapping prices
continues to support a high level of demolition activity. 45 mil- Figure GRO.4
lion dwt was scrapped during 2013. After five years of high
demolition activity, many of the obvious candidates have al-
The world fleet is becoming increasingly young
ready been scrapped. Today, less than 5% of the world fleet is Only 9% of the world fleet is older than 20 years
older than 25 years (fig. 4). Accordingly, the average demolition 800 40%
age continues to decline. So far in 2014, the average scrapping 36%
age has dropped to 27 (fig. 5). % of world fleet >>
600 30%
THE COST OF OVER-ORDERING COULD BE A SHORT OPERATING LIFE
% of world fleet
The average scrapping age becomes an issue if vessels are
Million dwt
scrapped before they reach the age of their expected technical
400 20%
operating life. Standard vessels are expected to operate until 19%
18%
the age of 25 years, while specialised vessels are expected to
trade until the age of 30 years. If a vessel is scrapped prema- 12%
200 10%
turely, it simply has fewer years to generate the expected in- 8%
come. Consequently, in segments where few old vessels remain, 4%
5%
the cost of over-ordering could be a significant reduction in the
0 0%
remaining operating life of older vessels. 0-5 5-10 10-15 15-20 20-25 25+ Orderbook
Sources: Clarksons, Danish Ship Finance Dry Bulk Tanker Container Other % of fleet
Million dwt
profile to absorb the orderbook by means of regular fleet re- 30 20
placement (i.e. scrapping) and annual demand growth. The cur-
rent orderbook-to-fleet ratio stands at 18%, while less than
10% of the world fleet is 20 years or older. It therefore seems 15 10
Fleet renewal
the next few years. LPG
2
Chemical Tanker
Product Tanker
0
Ro-Ro Offshore
Other
-2
0% 5% 10% 15% 20% 25% 30% 35% 40%
Orderbook / fleet
Million dwt
Million dwt
43
GAME COULD BE TRAPPED BY THE REDUCED OPERATING LIFE, 40
33
40
Scrapping age
Scrapping age
And more vessels are yet to enter the market. With less than
10% of the fleet older than 20 years and an orderbook-to-fleet 25 25
24
ratio of 18%, the world fleet is poorly positioned to absorb the 23
could be subject to unexpected depreciations. Sources: Clarksons, Danish Ship Finance Average age of vessel scrapped, Panamax (Dry Bulk)
NEWBUILDING PRICES
ened. Since late 2008 the combination of excessive global yard Sources: Clarksons, Danish Ship Finance * Global order cover = Orderbook / yard capacity
Million cgt
(i.e. the revised MARPOL annex VI) and the low but rising new-
building price has presumably been behind investors’ sudden
appetite for new vessels. 40 2
2014. The combined capacity of the latter constitutes 84% of South Korea China Japan Europe Rest of the world
Sources: Clarksons, Danish Ship Finance
the estimated 2013 global yard capacity. This means that 16% * Global order cover = orderbook / yard capacity
lion cgt in 2013, which was in line with the estimated 2013 yard
capacity. But less than half of the 200 yards building new ves-
sels in 2013 received new orders during the 15-month period. 18
More than half of the orders were dry bulk orders (fig. 4). Fu-
Million cgt
ture capacity reductions or a climb up the complexity ladder
seem to be a prerequisite for the future success of China’s ship- 12
building industry.
SOUTH KOREA RECEIVED ORDERS OF 17 MILLION CGT 6
South Korea remains the most sophisticated builder region in
Asia. In 2013, South Korean yards received new orders of 17
million cgt, widely diversified among the more high-spec seg- 0
ments (fig. 4). South Korean yards built primarily for non- China South Korea Japan
Dry Bulk Tanker Gas Container Offshore Other
domestic owners.
Sources: Clarksons, Danish Ship Finance
Million cgt
13 3
million cgt was actually delivered during the year (fig. 5). Of the 13
73%
outstanding 18 million cgt, we estimate that 15 million cgt was 10
1
postponed to 2014 or later (fig. 6). The remaining 3 million cgt 17
7 50%
(i.e. 5%) initially on order for delivery in 2013 is thought to 5
12
2
have been cancelled outright. This basically means that every 74% 8
1 3
2
fourth vessel scheduled for delivery in 2013 was postponed. 2
4
-
CHINA DELIVERED ONLY 58% OF SCHEDULED DELIVERIES IN 2013 China South Korea Europe Japan Rest of the
world
Last year was a bloody one for the Chinese shipbuilding indus-
try. Considerable restructuring activity and tightened credit lines Sources: Clarksons, Danish Ship Finance Firm orders Purchase options Actual deliveries
Deliveries
Million cgt
much as 81% of all orders scheduled for delivery in 2013 were 25
actually delivered. While 15 million cgt was scheduled, 12.5 mil- 10 20%
lion cgt was actually delivered. The remaining orders were post- 16
poned to a later delivery date. No orders appear to have been
5 10 10 10%
cancelled in 2013. 7
6
2 2
0 0%
Tanker Bulk Container Gas
BY 11% AND HENCE CONSTITUTED 42% OF THE GLOBAL RE- 86% 86%
82%
DUCTION IN CAPACITY. 77%
75 75%
2013
Million cgt
during 2013. We estimate that global yard capacity was reduced 55 53
50 50%
from 64 million cgt in 2012 to 57 million cgt in 2013 (fig. 7). 46
48 49
Million cgt
LARGE YARDS PULL THE LOAD IN SOUTH KOREA -11%
-1.50 -15%
South Korean yards have maintained fairly stable capacity and -14%
operate at a utilisation rate around 80%. Only 3% (600,000 cgt) -17% -17%
of South Korea’s yard capacity turned idle during 2013 (fig. 8.), -2.25 -23%
and the region now has aggregate yard capacity of 16.7 million
cgt. The industry is becoming increasingly consolidated. Eight
large yards currently constitute 92% of total South Korean yard -3.00 -30%
capacity. China South Korea Japan Europe Rest of the
world
Million cgt
Million cgt
0 0
to lower future demand. By 2016, we expect global yard capaci-
ty to have returned to the 2008 levels. But Chinese and South
Korean yards are expected to account for 73% of global yard
-5 -5
capacity, in contrast to 54% in 2008.
NEWBUILDING PRICES ON A STRUCTURAL DECLINE
Newbuilding prices have been on a structural decline during the -10 -10
2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016
last five years and are expected to remain low until the consoli-
China South Korea Japan Europe Rest of the world
dation process has come to an end. Still, the surprisingly high
Sources: Clarksons, Danish Ship Finance
contracting activity during 2013 has enabled newbuilding prices
to be increased at yards that have attracted new orders. Note
Figure SB.10
that only yards receiving new orders are part of the process of
Global yard utilisation expected to increase to 77%
determining prices. Accordingly, the increase in newbuilding Based on a 5 million cgt reduction in 2014 capacity
prices should not be interpreted as evidence of a market in bal- 100 100%
92%
ance. It simply reflects the ongoing selection process whereby 86% 86%
82%
inefficient yards go out of business and sustainable yards attract 77% 77% 78%
80 80%
new orders.
Million cgt
More than 550 yards built the capacity delivered during 2013,
50%
but fewer than 250 received new orders during 2013 and the
first quarter of 2014. The latter represented 84% of the global 40
38
40 38 40%
Million cgt
2015 CAPACITY DOWN BY 6% TO 49 MILLION CGT
The outlook for 2015 remains subject to future contracting ac- 40 2 40%
tivity. It should, however, be clear that the window of oppor- 17
55 53
tunity for placing orders with expected delivery in 2015 is com- 46 48 49
20 38 40 38 20%
ing to an end. Assuming that it takes 18 months to build a ves-
23
sel, the window will close in two months. Nevertheless, some
yards, particularly in China, do offer significantly shorter deliv- 0 0%
2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016
ery times. In 2013 and 2014, some vessels were contracted
with a delivery time of only eight to ten months. For such short Capacity Delivery Spare capacity (70% utilisation) Utilisation
delivery time to make sense, it is plausible that yards had start- Sources: Clarksons, Danish Ship Finance
Index
Index
EXPECT TO SEE VALUE DEPRECIATIONS FOR OLDER, INEFFI-
1,100 1,100
CIENT POST-PANAMAX VESSELS IN THE YEARS TO COME.
FREIGHT RATES
index. The index kept relatively stable with an average index Sources: Clarksons, Danish Ship Finance
Dliveries
vessels continue to slow steam. It seems that the industry is 8% 10%
6%
being shaped by a saving strategy that minimises the marginal 6% 6%
Teu (,000)
costs per moved teu through huge investments in large cost- 1,000 5%
efficient vessels. This strategy seems currently to be adding ca-
pacity to an already oversupplied market. Liners are cascading 0%
Scrapping
of their fleet. Besides, we are seeing a tendency towards opera- -5%
Teu (,000)
Teu (,000)
SCRAPPING REACHED ALL-TIME HIGH 250 250
The poor market conditions triggered record-high scrapping ac-
tivity within the Panamax transitable segments. A total of 0 0
440,000 teu was scrapped during 2013. The high demolition
activity combined with a modest inflow of new vessels within -250 -250
these segments resulted in a slightly improved market outlook,
and several of the smaller segments witnessed negative fleet -500 -500
growth during the year (fig. 5). During the first four months of 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014
Year-on-year growth
Year-on-year growth
CONTAINER DEMAND UP BY 2% IN 2013
Seaborne container import volumes increased by 2% in 2013. 10%
15%
10%
Year-on-year growth
er, this share has declined from a level of 92% over the last ten 5%
Million teu
25 3% 4%
EUROPE BACK ON TRACK WITH POSITIVE IMPORT GROWTH
3%
Containerised imports into Europe increased by 1% after a
2%
tough 2012 with negative growth, indicating that the region is 13 2%
1%
slowly fighting its way out of the slump. The main contributors 1% 1%
route from Asia and Europe also increased by 1%. Sources: IHS Global Insight, Danish Ship Finance Import volumes, 2013
TEU (,000)
regain confidence over the course of 2013, contracting 1.9 mil-
1,600 2
lion TEU (242 vessels) with an average size of 8,200 TEU. This
was the largest contracting volume since the boom in 2007.
With 88% of all contracts for vessels of 8,000 teu or more, the 800 1
industry seems to be gearing up for the anticipated 2016 open-
ing of the enlarged Panama Canal. The expansion of the Canal
has left the current Panamax segment severely threatened and 0 0
2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014
no contracts were made in this segment in the entire year. The
delivery time was on average 26 months, but it proved to be Post-Panamax 3,000-7,999 Post-Panamax 8,000-11,999 Post-Panamax 12,000+
very volatile and some of the big Post-Panamaxes are scheduled Sources: Clarksons, Danish Ship Finance
to be delivered in a little over 14 months (fig. 7).
NEWBUILDING PRICES INCREASED BY 15% Figure CS.9
Newbuilding prices increased across the board as demand for Newbuilding price up 15% from January 2013 to April
new vessels intensified once again. The price of an 8,500 teu 2014
Post-Panamax vessel increased by 15% between January 2013 140 140
Million USD
Million USD
vessels, especially for the larger vessels. Even though the mas- 70 70
sive ordering in combination with the already oversupplied mar-
ket should be expected to lower secondhand values, at least for
less fuel efficient vessels, we find little evidence of this. In fact, 35 35
the value of a five-year old 8,500 teu vessel seemed to increase
by 8% from January 2013 to April 2014. High expectations for
future earnings are built into these values. Let us hope that 0 0
these vessels will be trading long enough to benefit from a fu- 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015
ture recovery (fig. 8). 8,500-9,100 TEU Newbuilding 8,500-9,100 TEU 5YR
Million teu
31%
The fleet is young, the orderbook stands at 36% of the fleet and 2.50 30%
the demand outlook is characterised by lower future growth po-
tential in many – both emerging and advanced – economies.
15%
Structural issues related to high unemployment, low investment, 1.25 15%
persistent output gaps, tight credits and large levels of debt 5%
constrain the future growth outlook for container demand. 0% 0%
Moreover, unlike other ship segments, we see little possibilities 0.0 0%
for new major trade lanes to emerge because the incremental 0-5 5-10 10-15 15-20 20-25 25+
growth of container trade is so meticulously linked to global GDP 3-7,999+ teu 8-11,999+ teu 12,000+ teu % of fleet
in general and national GDP in particular. Please read the Gen- Sources: Clarksons, Danish Ship Finance
eral Review and Outlook for a comprehensive discussion.
Figure CS.11
ASIA REMAINS THE HEART OF GLOBAL CONTAINER TRAFFIC
Container import volumes are on average expected to
Asia remains the heart of global container traffic. In 2013, Asian increase 5% annually
container exports accounted for more than 50% of total export 180 180
volumes and contributed two-thirds of the growth in export vol- Annual growth
umes. Asian container imports accounted for almost 40% of + 5.1
total import volumes and contributed 42% to the growth in vol- 135
Annual growth
135
+ 3.0 40
umes.
Annual growth
Million teu
Million teu
+ 8.8 33
CHINESE GROWTH DRIVES MUCH OF ASIAN CONTAINER DEMAND
26
27
There is a close correlation between the outlook for Asian con- 90 90
22
tainer demand and the Chinese economy. The rise of China as a 20 24
leading exporter has been closely linked to the rapid growth of 14
20
supply-chain networks in Asia (i.e. those that are centred in 45 16 20 45
China). According to the IMF, China accounted for about 50% of 12 60
48
all intra-Asian trade flows of imported inputs in 2013. For many 27
39
of its Asian trading partners, China has become the single most 0 0
important destination for intermediate goods, since supply- 2003 2008 2013 2017
chains have more frequently been routed through China for the Sources: IHS Global Insight, Danish Ship Finance Asia Europe North America Other
final stage of assembly. But Chinese imports from its Asian trad-
Deliveries
American demand is, on average, expected to increase by 5%
(,000) teu
-0.2
annually up to 2017. Global seaborne trade volumes are also 750
expected to increase by 5% annually on average up to 2017 -0.4
(fig. 10).
-0.6
THE POST-PANAMAX FLEET SET TO INCREASE BY 15% IN 2014 0
Scrapping
The Post-Panamax fleet is expected to increase by 15% in 2014. -0.8
Index
Index
SEEMED TO BE OUT OF REACH, RATES SOARED AND THE BAL-
TIC DIRTY TANKER INDEX SURGED ABOVE INDEX 1,000. 1,000 1,000
ter rates increased, first in the VLCC segment and then in the VLCC Suezmax Aframax
Suezmax and Aframax segments. VLCCs experienced the sharp- Sources: Clarksons, Danish Ship Finance
Other
16%
Deliveries
EXCEEDED DISTANCE-ADJUSTED DEMAND GROWTH AND THE
20 0.0%
OVERSUPPLY CONTINUES TO BE A MAJOR ISSUE.
Million dwt
CRUDE TANKER FLEET GREW BY 2% IN 2013 10 -5.0%
After years of being relatively high, fleet growth came down to
just below 2% in 2013 – the lowest growth rate since 2002 (fig. 0 -10.0%
4). Growth was concentrated in the first six months, where after
Scrapping
fleet growth turned negative. -10 -15.0%
Percentage
Million dwt
15 45%
Annual growth
Annual growth
has grown rapidly in the US, and domestic crude oil production 10% 10%
is now at its highest annual average since 1989. This has re- 8% 10%
duced the amount of light/sweet crude oil imports needed by US 0%
3%
0%
refineries, primarily at the expense of medium-haul West African -2% -3% -2%
-8% -7%
-1%
Annual growth
Million tonnes
600 5% 6%
INCREASE IN LONG-HAUL WEST AFRICAN TRADE
The decrease in US and European crude oil imports from West
400 2% 3%
Africa has made the crude oil available to the Asian market in-
1%
stead. Asia is a keen recipient of West African crude oil as it can 0%
be mixed into its normal crude slate. The inclusion of a 200 0%
Annual growth
Annual growth
10% 10%
tance-adjusted demand remained on a par with 2012 due to
11%
more long-haul imports from both China and the US (fig. 8). 6% 7% 7%
This was on the back of 2% fleet growth, which was skewed 0%
0%
0%
-4%
towards the beginning of the year. Consequently, market fun- -7%
-10% -9%
damentals improved during the second half of 2013 and resulted
-10% -10%
in a temporary spike in spot rates. However, the crude tanker
market remains oversupplied.
-20% -20%
2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013
Million dwt
Million dwt
38 38
Million USD
Million USD
120 120
SECONDHAND PRICES DROPPED 10% IN 2013
Secondhand prices followed a similar trend but faced a steeper
descent during the first part of 2013, with prices on average 80 80
0 0
2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014
VLCC - Newbuilding price
VLCC - Secondhand price
Sources: Clarksons, Danish Ship Finance
Percentage of fleet
MASSIVE RISE IN CONTRACTING IS OF INCREASING CONCERN
At the beginning of 2013, the orderbook seemed manageable
Million dwt
90 30%
26%
25%
and fleet growth was expected to fall in the coming years. How-
ever, the unexpected boom in contracting at the end of 2013 60 20%
naturally caused the orderbook to increase, currently constitut-
12%
ing 12% of the fleet (fig. 11). With the current market suffering 8%
30 10%
from the massive oversupply, an orderbook/fleet ratio of 12%
raises doubts about a recovery in the near future. Moreover, 2%
0%
slow steaming has been used extensively to minimize overca- 0 0%
pacity, but additional speed reductions seem unlikely at this 0-5 5-10 10-15 15-20 20-25 25+ Orderbook
Deliveries
sels contracted prior to 2010 are either postponed or cancelled, 5% 5%
20 5%
Million dwt
this would bring fleet growth down to a level just above 2% in
2014. 3%
10 2% 2% 3%
GROWTH IN SEABORNE OIL TRADE EXPECTED AROUND 2-3%
To counterbalance fleet growth and remove some of the current
0%
oversupply in the crude tanker segment, demand has to grow 0 0%
Scrapping
significantly. Under the current circumstances, seaborne crude
oil trade is expected to increase by about 2-3% over the coming
-10 -3%
years, up from -1% in 2013 (fig. 13). This development is ex- 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016
pected to be driven primarily by Asia, China in particular, as it is
expanding its refinery capacity and its strategic petroleum re-
Sources: Clarksons, Danish Ship Finance VLCC Suezmax Aframax
Annual growth
Annual growth
patterns. At present, the Middle East acts as a major export hub 10% 10%
for crude oil. However, over the coming years, its refinery ca- 10% 3%
pacity will expand by 2.5 million barrels per day and its crude oil 0%
2% 3% 2%
0%
exports will decline as a result. Part of this will have to be re- -7%
-1%
TALS. HOWEVER, MASSIVE ORDERING ACTIVITY AND POTEN- MR spot rate, annual average
TIALLY SHORTER DISTANCES REDUCE THE CHANCES OF A
MARKET RECOVERY. 22,500 22,500
FREIGHT RATES
demand for heating oil. During the last few months of the year,
above USD 15,000 per day (fig. 2). LR2 rates, however, experi- MR LR1
enced a slight decline. Sources: Clarksons, Danish Ship Finance
North America →
Europe → Africa
Europe
3%
4%
North America →
South America → Asia Pacific
Asia Pacific 3%
4% North America →
South America
Middle East → 3%
Asia Pacific
Asia Pacific →
7%
Europe
Europe → North 3%
America
9%
Europe → Asia
Other
Pacific
43%
10%
Asia Pacific →
Asia Pacific
11%
11%
Deliveries
There continues to be an oversupply of tonnage in the product 9% 10%
11%
Million dwt
10 10.0%
Scrapping
last time may occur as a consequence of the development of
more export hubs, since only vessels in ballast arrive at these -5 -5.0%
terminals. Hence, this could reduce the implications of oversup- 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013
Percentage
Million dwt
3 60%
47%
ies, it also had a large number of non-deliveries. In total, only Actual deliveries >>
Scheduled deliveries
47% of all MR orders scheduled for 2013 were actually deliv- 2 40%
ered, while 25% were postponed for later delivery and another
28% were cancelled (fig. 5). It appears that a number of orders
1 20%
contracted before 2009 continue to be deferred to a later point
in time.
0 0%
SCRAPPING INCENTIVE WAS LOW IN 2013 MR LR1 LR2
The improved spot market during the first part of 2013 reduced Scheduled deliveries Delivered
owners’ incentive to scrap. In 2013, a little more than 2.1 mil- Postponed orders Cancelled orders
Sources: Clarksons, Danish Ship Finance
Annual growth
Annual growth
Measured in volumes, the total trade increased by approximate- 25% 25%
portant for the MRs, as parcel size, port size and distances 4 32%
match the characteristics of this trade. 27%
Annual growth
US EXPORTS OF PETROLEUM PRODUCTS HIT ANOTHER RECORD HIGH 3 24%
US exports reached new heights in 2013 after continuous
growth throughout the year. That resulted in annual growth of 17%
Annual growth
Million tonnes
11%
America only represents 5% of African imports, it is the fastest-
growing African trade (fig. 8). It can be argued that the geopo- 20
8%
10%
litical situation in Africa hampered import growth, as the growth 7%
rate in 2013 was only half that of 2012. Thus, there is potential 6%
4%
for further growth in the coming years. 10 4% 5%
Asia Pacific, led by North American naphtha exports. Besides Sources: IHS Global Insight, Danish Ship Finance
Annual growth
Annual growth
fineries are configured to produce a high quantity of gasoline.
20% 20%
Should Indonesia import the surplus from Europe, it would in-
crease distances and thereby support distance-adjusted demand
13%
growth. 11% 11%
2% 5% 1% 1% 1%
0% 0%
THE PRODUCT TANKER MARKET IS GETTING CLOSER TO A BALANCE -12%
Overall, fleet growth slightly exceeded distance-adjusted de-
mand growth in 2013. However, as tonnage demand was sup- -20% -20%
ported by changes in underlying factors, the cargo-carrying ca- 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013
pacity diminished, resulting in an overall market improvement. World Africa Asia Pacific South America
Sources: IHS Global Insight, Danish Ship Finance
Million dwt
Million dwt
15 15
almost evenly split between MRs and LR2s, while no LR1s were
ordered. However, in 2014 owners have turned towards LR1s Sources: Clarksons, Danish Ship Finance LR2 LR1 MR
and more than 1 million dwt has already been contracted, while
contracting in the MR and LR2 segments has been minimal. Figure P.11
NEWBUILDING PRICES INCREASED SLIGHTLY IN 2013 Newbuilding prices rose slightly in 2013
Asset prices increased as a consequence of the contracting Secondhand prices went up by more than 15% in 2013
most product tanker segments (fig. 11). The increase was most-
ly reflected in MRs. While an increase in asset prices often puts 60 60
a lid on buying activity, it can also have the opposite effect as
ship owners begin to fear missing out on the trough.
Million USD
Million USD
45 45
SECONDHAND PRICES ROSE MORE THAN 15% IN 2013
Secondhand prices also rose in 2013, by more than 15% (fig.
30 30
11). However, this was from a very low level after unexpectedly
dropping by 20% in 2012. Subsequently, ship owners saw an
investment opportunity for secondhand vessels, which resulted 15 15
Percentage of fleet
THE
During 2013, spot rates were high compared with previous 30 27%
Million dwt
years, which led to a massive ordering spree of close to 14 mil-
lion dwt. At the beginning of 2014, the entire orderbook con- 20
17%
18%
tained around 19 million dwt or 17% of the fleet (fig. 12). A lit- 14%
Deliveries
ly 1 million dwt of the orderbook was contracted prior to 2010 2%
2% 3.0%
Million dwt
4 2%
0
DISTANCE-ADJUSTED DEMAND EXPECTED TO BE AROUND 2-3%
0.0%
Over the next couple of years, distance-adjusted demand is ex-
Scrapping
pected to grow roughly 2.5%, compared with 1% over the past -4
-1.5%
three years (fig. 14). As in previous years, the main driver is Net fleet growth, year-on-year
LR2 LR1 MR
Sources: Clarksons, Danish Ship Finance
Annual growth
Annual growth
15% 13% 15%
ucts, Australia and Japan are facing a rising deficit, as they are
shutting down refineries due to unprofitable production. Conse-
quently, they have to increase imports of petroleum products in 8% 8%
0% 0%
MIDDLE EAST A NEW EXPORT HUB
Demand for petroleum products in Asia Pacific will also be sup-
ported by Middle Eastern exports, especially as the region’s new -8% -8%
refinery capacity becomes fully operational over the coming pe- 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016
riod from 2014 to 2017 (fig. 15). This will provide an extra 2.5 World Africa Asia Pacific Europe
million barrels per day of refinery capacity to the world market. Sources: IHS Global Insight, Danish Ship Finance
Annual growth
Million tonnes
high-quality petroleum products. The Middle East itself has few 45 3.5%
quality requirements for domestically consumed petroleum
products, and while Saudi Arabia accepts a diesel with a maxi- 30 2.0%
mum sulphur content of 2,000 parts per million (ppm), Europe
only accepts a maximum of 10 ppm. Subsequently, the Middle
15 0% 0.5%
East could increase profits by exporting the bulk of its high- 0%
product tanker demand could increase as a consequence of ris- America and America America
the
ing Middle Eastern exports and imports. The result would be a Caribbean
higher level of seaborne trade than is currently expected. More- Sources: IHS Global Insight, Danish Ship Finance
Other
17%
Deliveries
REMARKABLE RISE IN DELIVERIES COMPARED WITH 2012 8%
Million Cu.M.
Compared with 2012, when the number of new vessels entering 2
Scrapping
ments, less than 0.2 million Cu.M. was delivered. However,
measured by the number of vessels, only six MGCs were deliv- -1 -4%
ered, compared with 22 SGCs. The LGC segment has not had 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013
split between MGCs and SGCs – although the ratio was 1:3 Percentage of fleet >>
30%
measured by the number of vessels. The scrapping age re- 6 30%
27%
mained fairly high at 28-30 years, in line with previous years.
percentage of fleet
SECOND-HIGHEST LEVEL OF FLEET GROWTH IN RECENT YEARS
Million Cu.M.
5 23%
The large number of deliveries in combination with the very low
degree of scrapping resulted in the second-highest level of fleet 16%
15%
growth seen in recent years. The LPG fleet grew by 8% in 2013, 3 15%
world’s total seaborne LPG trade. Asia Pacific was also the main
contributor to the annual increase in seaborne LPG trade, as 60% 60%
roughly 2 million tonnes, out of a total increase of 3 million
tonnes, was imported by the region. Close to 90% of Asia’s LPG
Annual growth
Annual growth
imports are supplied by the Middle East. 30% 24% 30%
10%
6% 7% 6%
THE MIDDLE EAST CONTINUES TO BE THE BIGGEST EXPORTER
0% 0%
Middle Eastern LPG exports have experienced an annual average -3%
-4%
growth rate of around 6% since 2005. Currently, the Middle East -12%
supplies 38 million tonnes of LPG to the market, 66% of the to- -30% -30%
tal seaborne LPG trade. Consequently, the LPG market is highly
sensitive to changes in Middle Eastern production.
-60% -60%
2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013
US EXPORT ON THE RISE
North American LPG exports, driven by the US, increased by an World Asia Pacific South America Europe
average of 25% per annum from 2005 to 2013. For the past two Sources: IHS Global Insight, Danish Ship Finance
years, the region has been the third-largest LPG exporter in the
world, only exceeded by the Middle East and Africa. North Amer-
ican LPG production has risen in tandem with the strong growth Figure LPG.7
in production of shale oil and shale gas as well as increasing re-
US LPG exports soared by 69% in 2013
finery utilisation. However, currently US LPG exports are hin- 375 75%
69%
dered by infrastructural constraints, and thus more export facili-
Annual growth in US LPG exports >>
ties are needed in order for exports to increase significantly.
This situation was marginally improved in 2013, as a new LPG 300 60%
export facility helped increase exports (fig. 7).
Annual growth
225 45%
Unlike most of the shipping markets, the LPG market is not suf-
fering from oversupply. The market was therefore able to ab- 32% 32%
sorb the high fleet growth of 2013 even though it exceeded dis- 150 30%
23%
tance-adjusted demand.
18%
75 12% 15%
6%
2%
0 0%
2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013
Million Cu.M.
Million Cu.M.
RECORD-HIGH CONTRACTING IN 2013 3 3
LPG exports to Asia. The high level of ordering activity has con- VLGC LGC MGC SGC
tinued into 2014, with roughly 2.5 million Cu.M. contracted in Sources: Clarksons, Danish Ship Finance
Million USD
Million USD
2013 (fig. 9). Secondhand prices for VLGCs rose by as much as 60 60
17% from the low in the first quarter to year-end, driven by
owners’ appetite for vessels. The LGC and MGC segments stayed
more stable with an increase of only 2%. 30 30
0 0
2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013
Percentage of fleet
30%
Million Cu.M.
6 27% 30%
HUGE JUMP IN THE ORDERBOOK/FLEET RATIO
The LPG market is currently not suffering from oversupply, but
the market remains severely affected by seasonality and addi- 4
16%
20%
15%
tional risk is building up. In 2013, record-high freight rates led
to a massive inflow of new orders, which had a clear impact on
2 7% 10%
the orderbook, now constituting 38% of the total fleet (fig. 10). 5%
The majority is scheduled to be delivered in the coming three
years with 1.5 million Cu.M. in 2014, a massive 3 million Cu.M. 0 0%
in 2015 and so far another 1 million Cu.M. in 2016. 0-5 5-10 10-15 15-20 20-25 25+ Orderbook
HIGH FLEET GROWTH POSES A THREAT TO MARKET BALANCE VLGC LGC MGC SGC
Sources: Clarksons, Danish Ship Finance
If the orderbook is delivered according to schedule, gross fleet
growth will exceed 7% in 2014 and 15% in 2015, thus challeng-
ing the current market balance. To offset the potential negative
effects of the massive inflow of vessels in the coming years,
Figure LPG.11
scrapping has to increase. The technical operating life of LPG
Gross fleet growth expected at 7% in 2014
vessels is 30 years. However, in a scenario where vessels are Scrapping could bring fleet growth down to 3%
considered scrapping candidates the moment they are due for 6.0 16%
their fifth special survey or higher, net fleet growth could de- Net fleet growth, year-on-year
crease to 3% in 2014, while still being double-digit in 2015 (fig. 11%
4.5 12%
11).
Deliveries
GROWTH IN DISTANCE-ADJUSTED DEMAND TO SLOWLY DECLINE 8%
Million Cu.M.
3.0 8%
Growth in distance-adjusted demand for seaborne LPG trade is
expected to slowly decline to 4% in 2016. Without significant
3%
scrapping activity, demand will not be sufficient to employ the 1.5 3% 4%
2%
inflow of vessels, and with expected double-digit fleet growth in 1%
2015, the market outlook is fragile. However, 2014 may offer 0.0 0%
Scrapping
further freight rate improvements. -1%
Annual growth
Annual growth
vide China with a competitive advantage, as propane prices are
30% 30%
expected to remain much lower than propylene prices. In addi-
tion, China is expanding its refinery capacity and thereby in- 7%
6% 6% 6% 5% 4%
creasing its need for feedstock. Usually, refineries prefer using
0% 0%
naphtha; however, LPG can be used as a substitute. Conse-
quently, demand may depend on the price spread between LPG -12%
and naphtha.
-30% -30%
2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016
US LPG EXPORTS ARE ON THE RISE
An increasing share of Asian imports is expected to be sourced World Asia Pacific South America Europe
from the US, where the growth in production of shale oil and Sources: IHS Global Insight, Danish Ship Finance
Index
Index
6,000 6,000
WAY THROUGH THE YEAR, MARKET SENTIMENT IMPROVED,
SUPPORTING FREIGHT RATES. HOWEVER, BY APRIL THIS YEAR
RATES HAD COME DOWN TO INDEX 1,484. 3,000 3,000
BALTIC DRY INDEX UP BY 31% ON AVERAGE
Dry bulk freight rates had one of their worst ever years in 2012
and halfway through last year, it looked as though 2013 was 0 0
going to be even worse. However, in June freight rates began to 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015
After four consecutive years with double-digit fleet growth, the 80 10% 11%
fleet expanded by 6% in 2013 (fig. 4). This was primarily led by
Deliveries
10%
7% 7% 7% 7%
the Panamax fleet, which grew 9%, whereas the Handysize 24
Million dwt
30 6%
15
segment contracted by 0.5%. As of April 2014, the fleet consists 40 5%
23
of 721 million dwt, of which Capesize constitutes 41% in dwt. 7 46
39 42
7 9 7 0%
DELIVERIES DECLINED 11 11
6 21 22
9 9
0
Deliveries amounted to 62 million dwt, 38% lower than in the
Scrapping
previous two years, when close to 100 million dwt was deliv-
-5%
ered. At the beginning of the year, 100 million dwt was sched-
-40
uled to enter the fleet. However, during the year 28% was post-
-10%
2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014
poned and another 10% was cancelled. This meant that only
62% of vessels scheduled to be delivered found their way to the Sources: Clarksons, Danish Ship Finance Capesize Panamax Handymax Handysize
sea (fig. 5). More than two-thirds of deliveries were postponed
or cancelled in the second half of the year. Figure DB.5
23 MILLION DWT SCRAPPED IN 2013 62% of scheduled orders were delivered in 2013
Postponements were highest in the second half of the year
Scrapping activity declined in 2013, to 23 million dwt. The aver-
24 80%
age scrapping age was 28 years; hence, the dry bulk segment
Delivery ratio >>
still retains a relatively high scrapping age. However, when look-
ing at the scrapping age per segment, the average scrapping 64% 63%
65%
% of scheduled deliveries
18 60%
age of a Capesize vessel declined to 23 years, as the large in- 56%
flow of Capesize vessels resulted in a long period of low rates.
Million dwt
On the other hand, the average scrapping age of a Handysize
vessel remained high at 30 years, as many of the vessels were 12 40%
with dry bulk demand. Sources: Clarksons, Danish Ship Finance Actual deliveries Postponements Cancellations
Annual growth
Million tonnes
region, importing 103 million tonnes per year, increased de-
2,250 10%
mand by 3% after negative growth in 2011-12. However, dis- 8% 8%
tance-adjusted demand to the region declined by 6%, as long- 6% 6%
haul imports from India, Brazil and Venezuela were replaced by 4% 4%
4%
more short-haul Canadian iron ore. 1,125 5%
iron ore, but since 2009 it has reduced exports by 85% and now 0 0%
2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013
exports 18 million tonnes per year, making it the seventh-
Iron ore Coal Grain Other
largest exporter. The reason for this massive decrease was a Sources: IHS Global Insight, Danish Ship Finance
Million dwt
activity once again peaked in 2013 and new orders of 90 million
(years)
80 26 2
dwt were added to the orderbook (fig. 7). 40% of the contracts 21 3
USD million
USD million
more than 29% in most segments during 2013, returning to the
2010 levels. In particular, the sharp rate increases in the 80 40
Million dwt
Million dwt
book (fig. 9). In the next four years, 158 million dwt is sched-
100
99
uled to enter the fleet, 80% of this in the Capesize and Panamax 40 40
81
39
63
segments. In the first quarter of 2014, 15 million dwt was deliv-
56
44
44
ered. Of this, 12% was originally scheduled for delivery in the
25
15
4
fourth quarter of 2013. 0 0
-23
-23
-6
-27
-7
-30
-31
-34
EXPECTED SCRAPPING OF 14 MILLION DWT
-31
-11
The current overcapacity is pushing the average vessel life
-40 -40
downwards, as the number of obvious scrapping candidates is 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017
diminishing (fig. 10). Today, vessels as young as 15 years are
Sources: Clarksons, Danish Ship Finance Demolition Deliveries
being scrapped. In our fleet projections, we apply a scrapping
scenario where vessels become scrapping candidates immedi-
ately before they are due for a special survey (beginning from Figure DB.10
the fourth special survey). In this scenario, more than 34 million 54% of the dry bulk fleet is 0-5 years old
The orderbook constitutes 21% of the fleet
dwt will become scrapping candidates in 2014 (fig.9). In the
500 60%
event that these vessels are scrapped and the entire orderbook 54% % of dry bulk fleet >>
scheduled for 2014 is delivered, the fleet would grow by 5%.
However, if the significant postponement activity of 2013 is re-
375 45%
peated in 2014, the fleet growth could be a lot smaller. In a
scenario where only 60% of scheduled orders are delivered and
Million dwt
% of fleet
all vessels qualifying for scrapping are demolished, fleet growth
250 30%
could drop to 1% in 2014.
21%
SEABORNE DEMAND TO GROW BY 4% IN 2014 16%
Seaborne dry bulk trade is forecast to grow by 4% in 2014. This 125 10% 11% 15%
growth will primarily be spurred by Asian demand. In the com- 5% 4%
ing years, Africa is expected to have the biggest growth poten-
tial in percentage terms, increasing its demand for seaborne dry 0 0%
bulk trade by 19% between now and 2017. Overall demand is 0-5 5-10 10-15 15-20 20-25 25+ Orderbook
Million tonnes
Million tonnes
Annual growth
es with the goal of spurring heavy investments in expanding the + 6.9 404
railways in the western part of the country. This may have a 2,500 1,060 353 2,500
positive effect on dry bulk demand. Despite the lower steel out- 1,277
1,111
put in China, it is still expected to increase iron ore imports in 807 290
as it is one of the only profitable industries in the country not Sources: IHS Global Insight, Danish Ship Finance Iron ore Coal Grain Other
yet sanctioned. The question remains whether the iron ore sec-
tor will become subject to international sanctions; however, at as it is the biggest exporter of low-quality coal into China. On
the moment there is nothing to indicate this. Some of the exist- the positive side, if the Indonesian coal is substituted by Aus-
ing sanctions on Iranian exports were eased at the beginning of tralian coal, distances would increase and thus also distance-
2014. However, India’s Supreme Court has lifted the ban in Goa adjusted demand.
and other mining areas, thus it might not be long before India COKING COAL DEPENDENT ON CHINESE DEMAND
regains its position as one of the main exporters of iron ore.
Coking coal (i.e. coal used in steel production) is also dealing
AFRICA EXPECTED TO INCREASE IRON ORE OUTPUT with falling prices as a consequence of an oversupply in the
Africa is expected to scale up its exports of raw materials to market, as well as in the steel market. China is the biggest im-
China, in particular iron ore. Sierra Leone, Mozambique, Liberia porter of coking coal and its imports are estimated to grow by
and Guinea are projected to expand production of iron ore, coal 12%, although this is dependent on the price spread between
and bauxite. domestic and foreign coking coal.
COAL TRADE UP BY 4% IN 2014 CRIMEA CRISIS COULD LEAD TO ADDED COAL IMPORTS INTO EUROPE
Despite a general oversupply of coal and declining prices, the The recent geopolitical turmoil in the Crimea could potentially
trade is expected to experience firm growth of 4% in 2014. Coal result in added imports of thermal coal into Europe. Europe is
prices are expected to decrease slightly in 2014. This is a result currently building up huge inventory levels of natural gas, in
of producers expanding capacity, especially in Australia, South preparation for a potential escalation of the situation. However,
Africa and Colombia, while emerging markets are showing from a longer-term perspective, Europe may begin to consider
weaker demand. On top of this, the fact that China is focusing reducing its energy dependence on Russian gas. In such a sce-
more on clean energy further clouds the outlook. For instance, nario, the consequences could be a potential rise in European
the Chinese government has announced a 3% tax on imports of coal imports and/or an increasing share of gas from the US. The
thermal coal with a low calorific value. This could hit Indonesia, latter could however be a costly solution.