Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
in foals
Netherlands.
Summary
clarithromycin (CLA), often combined with rifampicin (RIF), are commonly used to treat
Rhodococcus equi infections, but effects on sweating have not been investigated.
Objective: To determine the effects of AZI, CLA and RIF on sweat responses in normal foals.
Study design: Each experiment was a blinded, duplicated, 6-foal × 3-period counterbalanced
This article has been accepted for publication and undergone full peer review but has not
been through the copyediting, typesetting, pagination and proofreading process, which may
lead to differences between this version and the Version of Record. Please cite this article as
doi: 10.1111/evj.12677
This article is protected by copyright. All rights reserved.
Methods: Antimicrobials were given orally for 5 days. In experiment 1, ERY (25 mg/kg, three
Accepted Article times daily), AZI (10 mg/kg, once daily), and CLA (7.5 mg/kg, twice daily) were given. In
experiment 2, ERY, RIF (10 mg/kg, twice daily), and ERY/RIF combination were used.
Quantitative intradermal terbutaline sweat tests were performed daily for 3 days before and 1, 2,
5, 9, 24, and 39 days after treatment. Data were analysed by repeated-measures analysis of
Results: In experiment 1, all macrolides suppressed sweating although CLA and AZI were less
potent than ERY. In experiment 2, significant sweat suppression occurred in foals given ERY
with or without RIF but there was no effect of RIF alone. Rifampicin reduced sweat suppression
Main limitations: Because ERY blood concentrations were not measured, effects of RIF on
Conclusions: All macrolides commonly used to treat R. equi pneumonia, i.e. ERY, AZI, and
CLA, induce anhidrosis in foals. The potent anti-sudorific effect of ERY is delayed but not
Introduction
Pneumonia caused by Rhodococcus equi remains an important cause of morbidity and mortality in
foals one to six months of age [1]. The treatment of choice for over 30 years has been the
combination of a macrolide antibiotic such as erythromycin (ERY) with rifampicin (RIF) [2].
Relatively higher bioavailability and superior tissue and cell penetration have made the newer
macrolides, clarithromycin (CLA) and azithromycin (AZI), preferred over ERY [3].
Adverse effects of ERY have been reported to occur within the first five days of treatment and
include mild diarrhoea, hyperthermia and respiratory distress [4; 5]. The authors previously
reported the use of a quantitative intradermal terbutaline sweat test (QITST) to demonstrate
that acts by inhibiting bacterial DNA-dependent RNA polymerase and is effective against
intracellular organisms including R. equi [7; 8]. Administration of RIF with CLA resulted in
plasma and tissue concentrations of CLA less than 10% of those found when the drug was given
alone [9]. The effect of RIF co-administration on sweat responses in foals given macrolides has
The main objectives of this study were first, to look for a class-wide anti-sudorific action
of macrolides in foals by examining the effects on sweating of CLA and AZI, and second, to
determine whether the reported marked reduction in bioavailability of CLA by RIF predicts a
similar effect on the ability of ERY to induce anhidrosis. We hypothesised that all macrolides
administered would cause anhidrosis and that co-administration of RIF would improve the sweat
Twelve pony and pony-cross foals aged one month at enrolment were used for each experiment.
Ponies used for Experiment 1 (4 females and 8 males) weighed 19 to 63 kg and those used for
Experiment 2 (9 females and 3 males) weighed 43.5 to 100 kg. Experiments were performed
from April to November of a single year. Foals were considered healthy on the basis of normal
results of physical examinations and complete blood counts performed 2 weeks before
washout interval of at least 34 days to allow sufficient time for full return to free sweating [4]. At
the completion of experiments, foals and their dams were returned to research herds. For
Experiment 1, foals were given ERY, CLA, or AZI at each period. To achieve a completely
where A, B, C are the 3 treatments ERY, CLA, AZI). For Experiment 2, foals were given ERY,
RIF, or the combination of ERY and RIF at each period, with the treatment order fully balanced
among foals as for Experiment 1. Each period was 42 days. A summary of the design of
experimental periods is provided in Figure 1. For two days before until 10 days after treatment
began, foals were housed together if weaned, or with their dams, in covered stalls that were
shielded from direct sunlight and provided with wall fans. Foals were treated by mouth for 5
successive days. All study personnel involved in drug administration and data collection were
blinded to treatment. For Experiment 1, treatments were ERY basea (25 mg/kg bwt 3 times
daily), CLAb (7.5 mg/kg bwt twice daily) or AZIc (10 mg/kg bwt once daily). A lactose-based
powder was compounded to be visually indistinguishable from the macrolide preparations. This
placebo was given at times when antibiotics were not scheduled. For Experiment 2, treatments
were ERY, RIF (10 mg/kg twice daily) or ERY/RIF combination. Following completion of
treatment, from days 5 to 10, foals remained in covered stalls during the period of maximal
hyperthermia risk and monitored. On Day 10, foals and dams were moved into pasture
enclosures containing shade structures and kept there until the end of the experimental period
(Day 39). Feed and hay were provided both in shaded and open areas; water was only available in
open areas. Investigators were masked as to treatment assignments. Rectal temperatures were
recorded 3 times daily while foals were stalled (at approximately 0600, 1300, and 2000 h) and
twice daily (0600 and 1700 h) after they were turned out. Respiratory rate, heart rate and faecal
consistency were recorded once daily at 0600 h throughout experiments. In addition to the
scheduled temperature checks, foals kept outside were observed regularly (approximately every 2
h on the hottest days, less frequently on cooler days) during daylight hours for tachypnoea or
other signs of heat stress. When a foal was suspected of heat stress, its rectal temperature was
immediately checked. If the rectal temperature was 39.4°C or above, the foal was brought with
with cold water until the rectal temperature was below 38.9°C.
Sweat tests
Quantitative intradermal terbutaline sweat tests (QITST) were performed as previously described
[10] daily on Days -2, -1, and 0 to establish baseline sweating responses for each foal and on
Days 1, 2, 5, 9, 24, and 39 after treatment began. In brief, each foal was restrained without the
use of sedatives and a 5 × 30 cm strip of hair was clipped from one side of the neck parallel to
and 2.5 cm below the dorsal margin of the neck. Starting at the cranial aspect of this strip, 6
intradermal injections of 0.1 mL of serial 10-fold dilutions of the β-adrenergic agent terbutaline
sulphate in 0.9% saline were made through a 25-gauge needle at approximately 2.5 cm intervals
as follows: 0 (control), 0.1, 1, 10, 100 and 1000 mg/L. Preweighed 3 × 6 cm strips of absorbent
padd were taped over each injection site. Thirty minutes later, pads were removed and absorbed
sweat quantified as weight change. Opposite sides of the neck were used alternately for
successive tests.
Data Analysis
All statistical calculations were performed using a commercial software packagee. In order to
meet test assumptions of normal distribution and equal variance, sweat weights were log10-
transformed for analysis. Sweat weights were analysed in two different ways. First, effects of
treatment, terbutaline concentration, and day on sweat weight were explored by 3-factor and 2-
procedures as previously described [6]. Second, plots of log10 sweat weight vs. log10 terbutaline
concentration for each treatment-day combination were modelled by simple linear regression
and the slopes of the fitted lines were obtained. Effects of treatment and day on terbutaline
slopes were examined by repeated-measures analysis of covariance with treatment and day as
parallel. Rectal temperature, heart rate, and respiratory rate data were subjected to 2-factor
were found by any of these analyses, effects were further tested at each level of each factor and,
when significant, post hoc multiple pairwise comparisons were obtained with Bonferroni
heteroscedasticity of data were evaluated by the Shapiro-Wilk tests and Mauchly’s tests of
sphericity, respectively. Greenhouse-Geisser corrections were applied to data that violated the
sphericity assumption. Influence of experimental order (period) on sweat weights were evaluated
as effect of replicate on day × terbutaline interactions in 3-factor mixed ANOVAs with one
between-subjects factor (period) and two within-subjects factors (day and terbutaline
Results
One foal given four doses of ERY developed severe diarrhoea and was euthanised on day 2 of
treatment after failing to respond to fluid resuscitation and supportive care. Gross necropsy
revealed moderate diffuse acute to subacute colitis with oedema of the colonic wall and tan
discoloration of the colonic mucosa. There was no evidence of R. equi infection. This foal was
replaced in the study. Four other foals developed mild self-limiting diarrhoea (one each in the
ERY and CLA groups and two in the AZI group). On 10 occasions in three foals (seven times in
a single foal), rectal temperatures >39.4°C were recorded while foals were in stalls (two during
the baseline period, seven in the CLA group and one in the ERY group); three of these were
>40°C. During the first 3 days in paddocks, there was a single instance of temperature >39.4°C
Because sweat responses conducted during the baseline period did not differ (P>0.05 for
each antibiotic), data for the three pretreatment tests (days -2, -1, and 0) were combined and
used for further analyses. Significant 3-factor treatment × day × terbutaline interaction for
terbutaline-induced sweat responses was not found (P = 0.2), indicating that ERY, CLA, and
AZI did not differ in their effects on sweat responses expressed as day × terbutaline interactions
(Fig 2). There were significant effects of day (P<0.0005) for all three antibiotics; the effects of
day were significant (P<0.05) for all terbutaline concentrations above 0.1 mg/L (Fig 2).
Compared to baseline (pretreatment) values, sweat weights were significantly lower over at least
four terbutaline concentrations on post-treatment days 1 to 9 (Fig 2) for ERY and days 2 and 5
for CLA and AZI. There were significant effects of treatment (P<0.05) at all days after baseline
and effects of treatment were significant (P<0.05) for 15 out of 30 post-baseline terbutaline
concentrations. Compared with ERY sweat responses at each of these 15 significant points, 8
and 14 of these were greater in the CLA and AZI groups respectively and 4 were greater in AZI-
than in CLA-treated foals (Fig 2). When slopes of terbutaline plots were analysed (Table 1), there
was a significant treatment × day interaction (P = 0.02). Effects of day were significant for each
antibiotic, extending from day 1 to days 9, 2, and 5 for ERY, CLA, and AZI, respectively.
Effects of treatment were significant on days 1 and 5; CLA and AZI groups were significantly
Experimental period did not influence sweat responses for any treatment (P>0.05 for all
Oral treatments were generally well tolerated by subject foals. Nine foals developed mild self-
limiting diarrhoea over the course of treatment (four in ERY, two in RIF, three in ERY/RIF
assessed by day × terbutaline interactions. There were significant effects of day (P<0.0005) on
terbutaline sweat responses for ERY and ERY/RIF treatments, but not for RIF (P = 0.8). The
effects of day were significant (P<0.05) for all concentrations of terbutaline in foals given either
ERY or the ERY/RIF combination. Compared to baseline (pretreatment) values, sweat weights
were significantly lower for at least 2 terbutaline concentrations on each post-treatment day (Fig
3) for ERY and ERY/RIF. There were highly significant effects of treatment (P<0.0005) at all
days after baseline and effects of treatment were significant (P<0.05) for 21 out of 30 post-
baseline terbutaline concentrations. For most (12/21) of these significant treatment effects, both
ERY groups differed significantly from RIF but not from each other. On day 1, however, sweat
amounts were higher at all terbutaline concentrations for ERY/RIF than they were for ERY
alone (Fig 3). When slopes of terbutaline plots were analysed (Table 2), there was a highly
significant treatment × day interaction (P<0.0005). There were significant effects of day for ERY
and ERY/RIF but not for RIF (P = 0.07). Effects of treatment were significant on days 1
through 24. All pairwise comparisons among treatments were significantly different on day 1
whereas sweat responses on days 2 and 5 were greater for RIF than for the two ERY groups.
Consistent with results found for sweat weights (above), RIF significantly reduced the effect of
ERY on day 1.
Experimental period did not influence sweat responses for any treatment.
and after treatment. Erythromycin-induced anhidrosis is the likely explanation for reports of
hyperthermia in foals treated for R. equi pneumonia with this antibiotic [4]. Because foals in the
current study were protected from direct sunlight for 5 days after treatment regimens were
completed, signs of heat stress attributable to treatment were not seen. In the previous study, six
of ten foals that were given ERY then immediately moved outside developed signs of heat stress
within 3 days whereas only one of 24 ERY-treated foals in the current experiment became
Standard treatment doses of the macrolide antibiotics CLA and AZI also inhibited sweating
albeit with lower potency than did ERY. There is a single previous report of AZI-associated fatal
hyperthermia [11] and the authors are aware of multiple foals that developed signs of heat stress,
fatal in some cases, during treatment with CLA. On the basis of the findings in this and our
previous study, all macrolide antibiotics commonly used for treatment of R. equi pneumonia
suppress sweating. These antibiotics may all pose commensurate risk of hyperthermia when
prokinetic, and immune-modulating effects [12]. Macrolides with 14- or 15-member lactone
secretagogues [12-15]. These actions likely explain the salutary effect of ERY and AZI in
humans with panbronchiolitis, cystic fibrosis, and other chronic respiratory diseases typified by
mucus hypersecretion [12]. The mechanisms by which secretion is suppressed are not fully
defined but it is likely that macrolides act to limit secretagogue-induced calcium entry into cells
thereby preventing ion flow through calcium-dependent chloride and potassium channels. It is
not known whether or not inhibition of calcium entry and ion channel function is involved in
macrolide-induced anhidrosis of foals but it is worth noting that the necessary cellular machinery
analysed in two different ways, i.e. both as absolute sweat weights and as slopes of sweat weight vs.
terbutaline plots. Both of these analyses when applied to sweat responses on day 1 showed that
combination of ERY with RIF was less suppressive than ERY alone. Notwithstanding this early
post-treatment difference, it is clear from Figure 3 that the addition of RIF had only a minor
overall effect on ERY-induced anhidrosis. This was somewhat surprising in light of reports that
RIF administration reduced the bioavailability of CLA in foals at least 8-fold [9; 20] via induction
of the intestinal efflux transporter P-glycoprotein [20]. Because absorption by foals of the
macrolide tulathromycin was likewise reduced [21], it is reasonable to assume that ERY
absorption is lower when given with RIF. Unfortunately, serum ERY concentrations were not
measured as part of this study. One possible explanation for our findings is that ERY-induced
anhidrosis occurs at doses much lower than those used to treat pneumonia. Efficacy of low-dose
treatment has been demonstrated previously for the immunomodulatory effects of macrolides in
In summary, we have shown that ERY, CLA and AZI used at standard antimicrobial
doses in foals induce sweating dysfunction. Additionally, co-administration of ERY with RIF
also suppressed normal sweat responses whereas RIF alone had no effect. Effects of RIF on
CLA- and AZI-induced anhidrosis were not examined in this study. Foals treated with any of
these antibiotics should be considered at risk for hyperthermia both during treatment and in the
immediate post-treatment period. Future work should be aimed at determining the mechanism
of macrolide-induced anhidrosis.
All procedures were approved by the University of Florida’s Institutional Animal Care and Use
Committee.
Sources of funding
This study was supported by funds from the Grayson-Jockey Club Research Foundation and the
Authorship
Study design was by A.L. Stieler Stewart and R.J. MacKay. Data analysis was performed by R.J.
MacKay. All authors contributed to data collection, study execution, and manuscript preparation.
Figure Legends
Fig 1: Summary of experimental design. QITST = quantitative intradermal terbutaline sweat test.
Fig 2: Weights (mean ± s.d.) of sweat collected into absorbent pads over intradermal saline or
For each terbutaline concentration within a treatment group, days with significantly different
sweat weights are marked with an asterisk; time- and concentration-matched values across the
three treatments that are significantly different do not share a letter. Terbutaline concentrations
Fig 3: Weights (mean ± s.d.) of sweat collected into absorbent pads over intradermal saline or
terbutaline injections in foals treated with either erythromycin, rifampicin, or the combination of
erythromycin and rifampicin. Within each treatment points differing significantly from baseline
Manufacturers’ addresses
a
Erythromycin USP; Westlab Pharmaceuticals, Westlab Pharmacy, Gainesville, Florida, USA.
b
Biaxin®; AbbVie Inc., North Chicago, Illinois, USA.
c
Zithromax®, Pfizer Inc., New York, New York, USA.
d
StayFree Ultrathin Maxi Pads, Energizer Holdings, Inc., St. Louis, Missouri, USA.
e
IBM® SPSS® Statistics 21; IBM North America, New York, New York, USA.
References
1. Giguère, S., Cohen, N.D., Chaffin, M.K., Slovis, N.M., Hondalus, M.K., Hines, S.A. and
Prescott, J.F. (2011) Diagnosis, treatment, control, and prevention of infections caused
4. Stratton-Phelps, M., Wilson, W.D. and Gardner, I.A. (2000) Risk of adverse effects in
pneumonic foals treated with erythromycin versus other antibiotics: 143 cases (1986-
5. Traub-Dargatz, J., Wilson, W.D., Conboy, H.S., Dyars, T.D., Masri, M., Hodgson, D.
combination with rifampicin for respiratory disease during hot environmental conditions.
7. Jacks, S.S., Giguère, S. and Nguyen, A. (2003) In vitro susceptibilities of Rhodococcus equi
Veterinary Medicine, 4th edn., Ed: S. Giguère, J. Prescott, P. Dowling. Blackwell Publishing,
Ames. pp 291-294.
9. Peters, J., Block, W., Oswald, S., Freyer, J., Grube, M., Kroemer, H.K., Lämmer, M.,
is nearly abolished by chronic comedication of rifampicin in foals. Drug Metab. Dispos. 39,
1643-1649.
10. MacKay, R.J. (2008) Quantitative intradermal terbutaline sweat test in horses. Equine Vet.
J. 40, 518-520.
11. Cortez, J., Aguilar, J.J., Lagioia, M., Fernandez, R. and Losinno, L. (2008) Use of
12. Kanoh, S. and Rubin, B.K. (2010) Mechanisms of action and clinical application of
13. Kondo, M., Kanoh, S., Tamaoki, J., Shirakawa, H., Miyazaki, S. and Nagai, A. (1998)
15. Lu, S., Liu, H. and Farley, J.M. (2011) Macrolide antibiotics inhibit mucus secretion and
calcium entry in Swine airway submucosal mucous gland cells. J. Pharmacol. Exp. Ther.
336, 178-187.
16. Bovell, D.L., Riggs, C.M., Sidlow, G., Troester, S., MacLaren, W., Yip, W. and Ko, W.H.
17. Huang, Y., Ko, W.H., Chung, Y.W. and Wong, P.Y.D. (1999) Identification of calcium-
activated potassium channels in cultured equine sweat gland epithelial cells. Exp. Physiol.
84, 881-895.
18. Rakhit, S., Murdoch, R. and Wilson, S.M. (1998) Persistent desensitisation of the beta-2
adrenoceptors expressed by cultured equine sweat gland epithelial cells. J. Exp. Biol. 201,
259-266.
19. Wilson, D.C., Corbett, A.D., Steel, C., Pannirselvam, R. and Bovell, D.L. (2007) A
preliminary study of the short circuit current (Isc) responses of sweat gland cells from
normal and anhidrotic horses to purinergic and adrenergic agonists. Vet. Dermatol. 18,
152-160.
20. Berlin, S., Spieckermann, L., Oswald, S., Keiser, M., Lumpe, S., Ullrich, A., Grube, M.,
21. Venner, M., Peters, J., Hoehensteiger, N., Schock, B., Bornhorst, A., Grube, M., Adam,
U., Scheuch, E., Weitschies, W., Rosskopf, D., Kroemer, H.K. and Siegmund, W. (2010)
terbutaline plots.
†
Slopes (mean ± s.d.) of lines fitted to plots of log10 sweat weight vs. log10 terbutaline
asterisk.
Erythromycin/
†
Slopes (mean ± s.d.) of lines fitted to plots of log10 sweat weight vs. log10 terbutaline
asterisk.