Parameters TransBio-Filter MBBR MBR

Capacity 50 KLD 50 KLD 50 KLD

Structure Civil Civil Packaged
Area Required 59 m2 40 m2 50 m2
Electromechanical Cost 1150000 1050000 1900000
Rs.(all inclusive)
Civil Cost Rs.(all Inclusive) 500000 650000 850000
Total Cost Rs. 1650000 1700000 2750000
Sludge Generation No Yes Yes
Treated Water Reuse Gardening Gardening Gardening
odour odorless Objectionable odorless
Technology Patent Filed Open Open
Environment Friendly Attached Growth Very Low
Green Technology. Process, compact Plant Environmental
Lowest Operational with resistance to shock Footprint. Low Space
Cost. Very low power load, Easy for Required.
consumption. Automatic Installation with
Operations. Resistant to Biodigested Sludge.
Shock Load. Converts
Waste into useful Bio-
nutritional products.

Advantages
Annual Makeup of Maintenance of Air grid Very High Installation
Media & transzyme is in MBBR Tank is & Operation Cost.
required. critical, possibility of Very High Power
loss/Carry over of Consumption.
Media. Annual Makeup Membrane is delicate
of Media is required. and costly. Required
Skilled Labour to
Operate the plant.

Disadvantages
Technical Comparison

Bar Screens Volume 1 m3 1 m3 1.5 m3

Oil & Grease Trap 1 m3 1 m3 2.25 m3
Equalization/Inlet Tank 15 m3 15 m3 40 m3
Volume
Equalized water Transfer 1 HP 1 HP 1.5 HP
Pump
Pump Electricity 0.75 KW 0.75 KW 1.1 KW
Consumption
Tube Settler Not Required Not Required
Tube Deck Media Not Required Not Required
Aeration Tank(MBR/MBBR Not Required 12.5 m3 24 m3
Reactor) Volume

No. of Membranes Not Required Not Required 15

FAB/MBBR Media Not Required 1 Lot Not Required
Air Blower Not Required 3 HP 10 HP
Power Consumption of Air Not Required 2.25 KW 7.5 KW
Blower

Diffusers Not Required 1 Lot 1 Lot

Suction Pump Not Required Not Required 1 HP
Suction Pump Power Not Required Not Required 0.75 KW
Consumption
Secondary Tube Settler Not Required 5 m3 Not Required
Tube Deck Media Not Required 1 Lot Not Required
Chemical Cleaning Tank Not Required Not Required 2 m3
Chemical Cleaning Pump Not Required Not Required 1 HP

Chemical Cleaning Pump Not Required Not Required 0.75 KW

Power Consumption

Sludge Transfer Pump Not Required 1 HP 1 HP

Power Consumption of Not Required 0.75 KW 0.75 KW
Sludge
Pump
Sludge Dewatering System Not Required Sludge Drying Bed Filter Press
Filter Feed Tank Not Required 5 m3 Not Required
Filter Feed Pump Not Required 1 HP Not Required
Filter Feed Pump Power Not Required 0.75 KW Not Required
Consumption
Chlorine Dosing Pump Power 0.25 KW 0.25 KW 0.25 KW
Consumption
Multigrade Filter Not Required 2 m3/Hr Not Required
Activated Carbon Filter Not Required 2 m3/Hr Not Required
Transfer Pump 0.5 HP Not Required Not Required
Trandfer Pump Power 0.37 KW Not Required Not Required
Slow Sand Bed Filter(only Required Not Required Not Required
Grit
& Gravels, no fine & Course
Sand)
Treated Water/Outlet Tank 15 m3 15 m3 15 m3
Power Consumption per Hour 1.3 KWH 4.75 KWH 11.2 KWH
Daily Electricity 8 Hrs 20 Hrs 20 Hrs
Consumption
Daily Power Consumption 10.4 Units/Day 95 Units/Day 224 Units/Day
Annual Power Consumption 3640 Units/Annum 33250 Units/Annum 78400 Units/Annum
Annual Power Cost @ Rs. Rs. 25480/Annum Rs. 232750 / Annum Rs. 548800 / Annum
7/Unit
Annual Repair Cost Not Required Rs. 20000 / Annum Not Required
Annual Chemical Not Required Rs. 2500/Annum Not Required
Cost(Cowdung, Urea, DAP
etc.)
Annual Carbon & Sand Media Not Required Rs. 5000/Annum Not Required
Replacement

Annual Organic Media & Rs. 64520/Annum Not Required Not Required
Transzynme
Topup/Replacement
Manpower Required Unskilled, Part time Skilled, Full Time Skilled, Full Time
Annual Manpower Cost Rs.72000/Annum Rs. 150000/Annum Rs. 150000/Annum
Total Operational Expense Rs. 162000/Annum Rs. 410250/Annum Rs. 698800/Annum
Vermicompost Output 4000 Kg/Annum
Vermicompost Revenue Rs. 40000/Annum
Net Operational Cost Rs. 122000/Annum Rs. 410250/Annum Rs. 698800/Annum
Amount of Wastewater 17500 KL 17500 KL 17500 KL
Treated
Annually
Operational Cost (Rs./KL) 6.971428571 23.442857143 39.93142857