Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
Dr T G Ng
Golder Associates (Singapore) Pte Ltd
GEOTECHNICAL SOCIETY
GeoSS OF SINGAPORE (GeoSS)
SCOPE OF PRESENTATION
1. Introduction
4. Conclusion
INTRODUCTION
Introduction: Distinction between
Principles and Application Rules
• C1.4(1) Distinction is made between Principles and
Application Rules, depending on the character of
the individual clauses
• C1.4(2) The Principles comprises:
– General statements and definitions for which there is
no alternative
– Requirements and analytical models for which no
alternative is permitted unless specifically stated
• C1.4(3) The Principles are preceded by the Letter P
Introduction: Distinction between
Principles and Application Rules
• C1.4(4) The Application Rules are examples of
generally recognised rules, which follow the
Principles and satisfy their requirements.
• C1.4(5) It is permissible to use alternatives to the
Application Rules given in this standard, provided
it is shown that the alternative rules accord with
relevant Principles and are at least equivalent
with regard to the structural safety, serviceability
and durability, which would be expected when
using the Eurocodes.
Distinction between Principles and
Application Rules (SS EN 1997-1: 2010)
Eurocode 7 : Geotechnical design
• Designers are responsible to ensure structural safety,
serviceability and durability of the designs.
• Designers are responsible for the planning of the
geotechnical investigation
• Designers are accountable for their decisions, i.e.
specification of field and laboratory tests,
determination geotechnical design parameters and
characteristic values etc.
• 2 briefing/dialogue sessions were held in Nov 2014 to
raise awareness to the designers on key aspects on
geotechnical investigations and recommendations on
how to determinate characteristic values
GeoSS EC7 Work Group
cu=5N
Characteristic
values
Design
values
GEOTECHNICAL PARAMETERS
From ground
SPT N values
investigations
and lab tests
Derived values
cu=5N
Characteristic
How to obtain
values
characteristic
values?
Design
values
CHARACTERISTIC VALUE
• For most limit state cases where the soil volume involved is large,
the characteristic value should be derived such that a cautious
estimate of the mean value is a selection of the mean value of the
limited set of geotechnical parameter values, with a confidence
level of 95% (moderately conservative parameters); where local
failure is concerned, a cautious estimate of the low value is a 5%
fractile (inferior parameters).
• Examples of aplication using statistical methods are available in
Annex E and Annex F of the GeoSS EC7 Guide
Characteristic Values by Statistical Method
Schneider(1999) Method
Xk = mx - 0.5sX
(upper bound equivalent to 95% mean reliable)
Xk = mx – 1.65sX
(lower bound equivalent to low value 5% fractile)
where
Ck = characteristic value
mC = mean value
sX = standard deviation
n = number of samples
CP4 (Current Practice) vs EC7
in Design of Bored Pile
CP4 vs EC7 in Design of Bored Pile
• Site Investigation
• Design
• Structural
• Geotechnical
• Load Test
CP4 vs EC7 in Design of Bored Pile – Site Investigation
CP4 EC7
Allowable concrete SS EN 1992-1:
compressive stress, NRd,p = Acfcd,p > NEd = 1.35Gk + 1.5Qk
sc = 0.25 fcu < 7.5MPa fcd,p = αcc,p fck/ gc,f
acc,p= 0.85 (reinforced); acc,p= 0.60 (un-reinforced)
Pile working load, gc,f = gc x kf = 1.5 x 1.1 = 1.65
Qst = sc . Ac fck = 0.8 fcu
Reinforced
NRd,p = Ac x 0.412 x fcu
Un-Reinforced
NRd,p = Ac x 0.291 x fcu
CP4 EC7
As ≥ 0.5% Ac SS EN 1992-1: 9.8.5(3)
(mm) (m2) (mm) (m2) (mm) rebar (cm2) (%) (%) periphery of pile (mm)
Where,
Qs - Ultimate Total Skin Friction Resistance
Qb - Ultimate End Bearing Capacity
Qa - Allowable geotechnical capacity
WL - Working load
DL - Dead load
LL - Live load
CP4 vs EC7 in Design of Bored Pile – Design (Geotechnical)
Current Practice Qa1 = Qs/2.5 + Qb/2.5
Qa2 = Qs/2 + Qb/3
Qa3 = Qs/1.5
Qa = Min (Qa1, Qa2, Qa3)
Qa > WL = = (DL + LL)
So:
Hence,
Fcd ≥ Rcd
𝛽 (1−𝛽)
𝛾𝑄;𝑑𝑠𝑡 + 𝛾𝐺;𝑑𝑠𝑡 − 𝛾𝑄;𝑑𝑠𝑡 𝑥 𝛼 𝑥 𝐶𝐿 = +𝛾 𝑄𝑡
𝛾𝑠 𝑥 𝑀𝐹 𝑏 𝑥 𝑀𝐹
How ULT & WLT affect the MF & R4 for each design zone?
CP4 vs EC7 in Design of Bored Pile – Load Test
Option 1
CP4 vs EC7 in Design of Bored Pile – Load Test
Option 2
ZONE A ZONE B
NO WLT 1.5xWLT
Less Favourable Resistance More Favourable Resistance
Factors (R4) Factors(R4)
MF = 1.2 MF = 1.2
ULT
1.5xWLT NO WLT
More Favourable Resistance Less Favourable Resistance Factors
Factors(R4) (R4)
MF = 1.2 MF = 1.2
ZONE C (worst profile of same geological formation) ZONE D
CONCLUSION
CONCLUSION
• The 1st Principle - Designers are responsible to ensure
structural safety, serviceability and durability of the designs for
the structures.
• To fulfil the 1st Principle, Designers are responsible for the
planning of the geotechnical investigation which include
Preliminary, Design and Control Investigations
• Guidelines and recommendations in Informative Annexes are
available in EC7-1 and EC7-2 for reference by Designers to
decide on specifications of field and laboratory tests, no of BH,
field and lab tests etc
• Characteristic values shall be determined from derived values
for design purposes.
• Guidelines on GI and Methods to determine Characteristic
values are provided in GeoSS EC7 Guide
CONCLUSION
• Structural Design
o Allowable concrete compressive stress of 7.5MPa and
As>0.5%Ac in CP4 has been removed.
o More comprehensive design considerations in terms of partial
load factors on geometry, material, reinforcement spacing,
permanent casing etc shall be taken.
o Structural capacity varies for reinforced and un-reinforced
concrete section.
• Geotechnical Design
o Alternative method is closer to current design practice
o The geotechnical design is governed by DA1-2
o The quantity and allowable settlement for ULT and WLT remain
the same as current practice
o With comprehensive ULT and WLT, proper GI and determination
of characteristic values, EC7 generally resulting in more
economical design as compared with CP4
REFERENCES
REFERENCES
REFERENCES
http://eurocodes.jrc.ec.europa.eu/
THANK YOU
NG Tiong Guan
Executive Director/Principal
Golder Associates (Singapore) Pte Ltd
18 Ah Hood Road, #10-51,
Hiap Hoe Building @ Zhongshan Park,
Singapore 329983
T: +65 6546 6318 | D: +65 6885 9388 | M: +65 9797 6846 | E:
ngtg@golder.com.sg | www.golder.com