Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
Abstract
Education reform policies, NCLB and ESSA, have at their hearts student achievement
and teacher performance, however, each policy has overlooked or disregarded a fundamental
challenge that a large fraction of students face before any learning can occur and that is poverty.
Poverty has a devastating effect on large student populations both urban and rural, and the
education reform policies that are being supported on the National level, and pushed down to the
State, and local levels do very little to address this issue. This paper will examine three policies
designed to alleviate the problems of poverty and the effects poverty has on student learning and
achievement. Understanding how poverty affects student’s ability to learn, where they learn and
the conditions under which they learn, I will choose one of the three solutions I believe will have
When the Every Student Succeeds Act (ESSA) became law last December, the education
community breathed a collective sigh of relief. The bill was nearly a decade overdue after
widespread dissatisfaction with its predecessor, No Child Left Behind (NCLB). The
conventional wisdom among ESSA's advocates was that the new law would refocus
attention on the country's most vulnerable students. However, a focus on the elimination
of poverty as a barrier to education for a large majority of urban and rural students did not
exist in any of the aforementioned policies, although poverty has been recognized as a
In 2017 the state of Michigan had seventy three-percent (73%) or 1,118, 605 school age
children eligible for free and reduced lunch, a standard predictor of poverty. These numbers
indicate that even the more affluent districts are serving students who are suffering from food
and housing insecurity. School Nutrition Programs like Free and Reduced lunch is one of the
largest federally funded poverty elimination programs aimed directly at eliminating poverty as a
barrier for school-age children. Students in these programs receive a healthy well-balanced meal
for part of the day, yet they face the stress of food insecurity when they arrive home.
Students in districts with high poverty are also beneficiaries of targeted funding programs
like Title I, a program designed to provide targeted services to schools and school districts with
large percentages of students in poverty. This program is designed to support and supplement
the school food service programs by providing healthy breakfasts and afterschool snacks, while
Poverty elimination programs alone are not enough. There has been a recent push to fund
teachers to help understand the effects poverty has on academic preparedness and students ability
to learn, and to bring into focus that poverty is a crisis that needs to be managed to ensure student
No longer can we consider the problems and needs of low-income students simply a
matter of fairness…Their success or failure in the public schools will determine the entire
body of human capital and educational potential that the nation will possess in the future.
Without improving the educational support that the nation provides its low-income
students – students with the largest needs and usually with the least support -- the trends
of the last decade will be prologue for a nation not at risk, but a nation in decline…. (Huff
Post, 2018)
Education
2: the field of study that deals mainly with methods and problems of teaching.”
(www.wordcentral.com, 2018)
Most people view education as the great equalizer, meaning every person has the ability
to raise their station in life through education. Politically, the American dream is synonymous
with education and training, building a set of skills that will allow you to command a salary
Poverty
Poverty is hunger. Poverty is lack of shelter. Poverty is being sick and not being
able to see a doctor. Poverty is not having access to school and not knowing how
to read. Poverty is not having a job, is fear for the future, living one day at a time.
Poverty has many faces, changing from place to place and across time, and has
been described in many ways. Most often, poverty is a situation people want to
escape. So poverty is a call to action -- for the poor and the wealthy alike -- a call
to change the world so that many more may have enough to eat, adequate shelter,
access to education and health, protection from violence, and a voice in what
Poverty then can be described as the reason those living in it struggle to become
educated. The absence of resources to provide the basic needs of many school-age children, their
families, and their communities is the central driver behind the achievement gap between poor
children and wealthy children. Knowing that this inequity exists has been the driving force
behind the development of numerous policies that focus on eradicating poverty as a barrier to
education. However, the most recent educational policies focus on teacher quality and test
scores which effectively removes poverty as the central barrier to a good quality education.
Test scores, then, are poor evidence for teacher quality because those scores mask what
impact teacher quality does have on the lives and learning of children. But this remains
ignored by many political leaders, education reformers, and the general public, leading to
three very common retorts to any recognition that poverty overwhelms the impact of
schools and teachers: (1) Poverty should not be used as an excuse. (2) If some
exceptional schools (often charters) can produce high test scores, then why can't they all?
G. MARTIN EDL 775 POLICY RESEARCH AND POLITICS 6
And (3) Just test students at the beginning and end of each year to factor out the home
Policy
There are several policies and programs designed to alleviate poverty as a barrier to
education. Three of those policies I will address in this paper. The first policy being Title I
funding which is a national program that receives its funding from the Federal Government,
whose primary role is helping schools provide services to poor students in an effort to minimize
the effects of their socio-economic status as it relates to educational attainment. There are
several types of services that are provided under Title I funding, for this paper, I will focus on the
As a policy Title I one is designed to take federal funding and distribute it to school
Title I, Part A (Title I) of the Elementary and Secondary Education Act, as amended
(ESEA) provides financial assistance to local educational agencies (LEAs) and schools
with high numbers or high percentages of children from low-income families to help
ensure that all children meet challenging state academic standards. Federal funds are
currently allocated through four statutory formulas that are based primarily on census
poverty estimates and the cost of education in each state. (Michigan Department of
Education)
There are four Title I grants providing direct assistance to students in high poverty school
districts, basic, concentration, targeted and Education Finance Incentive Grant (EFIG) that Local
G. MARTIN EDL 775 POLICY RESEARCH AND POLITICS 7
Educational Agencies (LEA’s) can apply for with each having their own formulation for
eligibility.
The basic grant provides funding to LEA’s that have a low number of students in poverty.
In order to be eligible for this grant, LEA’s must count at least 10 students or greater than two-
percent (2%) of the school-age population who meet the established poverty guidelines.
Concentration Grants use the same requirements for eligibility as the basic grant,
however, the funds go to LEA’s with more than 6,500 or fifteen-percent (15%) of the school-age
Targeted Grants use the same data as the basic and concentrated grants to determine
eligibility but allow for LEA’s with higher numbers or percentages of children in poverty to
Finally, the Education Finance Incentive Grant (EFIG), which base the distribution of
• a state's effort to provide financial support for education compared to its relative
• the degree to which education expenditures among LEAs within the state are
Once the allocation is made LEA’s receiving this funding should target this funding to
schools serving the highest population of poor students, with the option of a school-wide
program serving all students, or target services directly to students who fit the poverty criteria,
and who may be at risk for failing to meet the states academic standards.
I would argue, politically these programs look good and on some levels have achieved
some of the outcomes for which the programs were designed. However, these programs have
G. MARTIN EDL 775 POLICY RESEARCH AND POLITICS 8
had limited effect on school-age children and their families as a policy that truly challenges
poverty and creates equity. Students who are receiving educational services provided by Title I
and or take part in the school nutrition programs are only able to receive the services once they
reach the school building. Limiting the effectiveness of the services provided to students by Title
I to school operating hours. Noting, these programs may also become obsolete under ESSA, due
to the ambiguity in the law about how states comply with supplement and not supplant
Currently, schools receiving Title I funds educate more than two-thirds of our low-
income children and children of color, and yet approximately 5,750 Title I schools
nationwide received substantially less state and local funding than their non-Title I peers
within the same district. on average, these Title I schools are shortchanged by about
$440,000 per year, and the federal funds spent in these schools are often, in effect, being
used to make up some or all of that shortfall, instead of providing the additional resources
The Second policy to be discussed is the preparation of teachers who teach or will be
teaching in high poverty school districts. Let’s start with the misconception most people,
politicians and even some educators have about poverty. Poverty is not just an urban problem.
Urban areas and depressed rural areas are not the only places with high rates of students living in
poverty, when in reality poor children are present in all school districts. “Millions of school-age
students in America live in poverty. You don’t have to teach in a blighted urban area or a
depressed rural region to teach students who are from a poor family.” (Teaching, 2018)
G. MARTIN EDL 775 POLICY RESEARCH AND POLITICS 9
Earlier I provided the definition of poverty, from the World Bank. In that definition, there
were several factors that contribute to poverty and each of those factors individually or
collectively may be present and create a barrier for any of the students in a school district.
Recognizing that these barriers are present and how to properly deal with them as educators, for
the students could mean the difference between success and failure.
Attempts to close the achievement gap for low-income students have often met with
limited success. Maybe that's because such efforts have ignored another kind of gap—the
gap between the skills that teachers [and, district-level administrators] must have to
provide high-quality instruction for disadvantaged students and the preparation that
teachers [and, district-level administrators] actually receive before they enter the
During my interview with an urban school district superintendent, he stated: “he has
purchased books and have held several professional development days designed to help his staff
(all school district staff), understand poverty as a barrier, helping his teaching staff understand
how to teach with poverty in mind.” (Toal, P) This not only helps the students, but it helps the
staff understand the student's situation, better understand the community and families, which in
turn helps relieve their stress and anxiety about doing their jobs, which keeps staff in place and
High-poverty schools have high staff mobility and high student mobility. One of the
In this case, the instability and insecurity occur both at home and at school. To combat
high staff mobility, some school districts are offering a 5% additional pay differential to
keep staff stable. To combat high student mobility, it is imperative that schools use a
G. MARTIN EDL 775 POLICY RESEARCH AND POLITICS 10
formative assessment for students and immediately provide the interventions and safety
Student and staff mobility can be minimized with proper teacher training, and
high poverty school districts, and providing inducements like pay incentives may bring
Also, consider that teachers in high poverty schools may work harder than
counterparts at schools outside of high poverty areas, because of the gap in achievement
these teachers are required to spend more time fixing student issues than actually
teaching.
courses that provide an overview of poverty and methods of working with this
For example, in New York City public schools, teaching candidates are provided
with;
explores the relationship between socioeconomic factors and learning will better
prepare students for the challenges of public school teaching. (Bing.com, 2018)
G. MARTIN EDL 775 POLICY RESEARCH AND POLITICS 11
Not only do current teachers and future teachers need to be properly trained on how to
properly handle the poverty barrier, but experienced teachers who are highly qualified need to be
consistently show that experienced teachers are more effective than beginners at
discipline, motivating students, and adapting instruction for students with diverse
experience are assigned to high-minority, high poverty school districts. “Seven in four of the five
largest school districts in Maryland, for example, schools with the highest average percentage of
novice teachers (46 percent) were compared to schools with the lowest average percentage of
novice teachers (11 percent). Eight schools with the largest proportions of novice teachers had
more than twice as many minority students, almost three times as many poor students, and less
than half as many students achieving at satisfactory levels on state achievement tests.” (AFT,
2018)
There is evidence that partnerships between schools that serve predominantly low-income
students and teacher preparation programs can have a positive outcome for both schools and
future teachers. Prospective teachers are taught judgment focused teaching which relies on the
teacher’s judgment to adapt the lessons and provide additional supports if a large number of
students do not grasp the concepts being taught, which is in direct conflict with common core
standards that require a teacher to move through the lesson plan at the dictated pace. These
partnerships also emphasized problem driven instruction where students work in collaborative
G. MARTIN EDL 775 POLICY RESEARCH AND POLITICS 12
groups on task that emphasize comprehension and literacy, over worksheets. Practice-based
learning provides benefits for both the prospective teacher and the student, by providing
extensive reading and writing practice and providing the prospective teacher with an additional
1,000 hours of teaching experience. Allowing the prospective teacher the rare opportunity to
practice the lesson taught in their methods class in a live classroom environment, with the added
benefit of more adults in the schools leading to more focused one on one interventions.
The third and final policy analysis focuses on national poverty elimination programs
aimed at relieving the sting of poverty for the families and communities where these poor
students live. To help combat poverty and eliminate poverty as a barrier to education, the state of
Michigan through funding from the federal government provides several different food service
programs for poor children, their families, and their communities. For the purposes of this paper,
I will focus on the programs that are directly related to schools and school-aged children.
Study after study has shown that when students come to school prepared, they have better
outcomes. Preparedness begins with rest and nutrition. Students who eat a healthy well-balanced
meal, behave well, perform better, and have better cognitive development. They actively
participate in the educational experience, and a healthy eating environment teaches them about
The National School Lunch, School Breakfast, and Afterschool Snack Programs were
established to make nutritionally balanced, low-cost meals, snacks, and/or milk available
statewide to children through the completion of high school. These federally funded meal
G. MARTIN EDL 775 POLICY RESEARCH AND POLITICS 13
entitlement programs are available to public and nonprofit private schools, and residential
free or reduced meals through their school districts food service programs. These children come
from families that are between one-hundred thirty percent (130%) to one-hundred fifty percent
(150%) of the federal poverty level, in other words these students are some of the poorest
students in the country, who live in some of the poorest communities and go to school who have
large population of students fitting this criterion. For a majority of these students, school is the
Students who receive free and reduced lunch rely on the schools to be open in order to
receive a good meal. Most schools are not year-round and close several times a year including
several weeks during the summer limiting access for this population of students to good healthy
meals. For these students, the summer food service programs were created to provide additional
The Summer Food Service Program (SFSP) was created to ensure that children in lower-
income areas could continue to receive nutritious meals during long school vacations
when they do not have access to the National School Lunch or School Breakfast
Programs. The SFSP, also known as Meet Up and Eat Up, is operated at the local level by
Education (MDE), Office of Health and Nutrition Services. (MDE Food & Nutrition
Programs)
However, with the neighborhood schools being closed for financial reasons and those that
remain, closed for the summer, students have to be able to get to the site where meals are being
G. MARTIN EDL 775 POLICY RESEARCH AND POLITICS 14
provided in order to utilize this service. (MDE Food & Nutrition Programs) The Director of
MDE Health and Nutrition services, Stated; “Food and housing insecurity is a crisis in our
schools here in Michigan, and there is really no legislative will to talk about the elimination of
poverty on a statewide scale. I believe until we as a country decide to tackle poverty for the
For the poor access to the programs and services that are designed to eliminate barriers
also creates barriers. Community-based food service programs that provide meals to every
“A poverty strategy may be more likely to succeed if it addresses the more specific
problems that are of concern to groups and communities, that policymakers and community
problem solvers can get their heads around, and for which “success” and “failure” can be both
Conclusion
As a nation, we must address poverty, as a crisis and condition that will have detrimental
effects on our future, understanding that poverty is an impediment to any real attempts at
education reform.
The achievement gap between children from different income levels exists before
children enter school. Families are children’s most important educators. Our society must
invest in parental education, prenatal care, and preschool. Of course, schools must
improve; everyone should have a stable, experienced staff, adequate resources and a
balanced curriculum including the arts, foreign languages, history, and science. If every
child arrived in school well-nourished, healthy and ready to learn, from a family with a
G. MARTIN EDL 775 POLICY RESEARCH AND POLITICS 15
stable home and a steady income, many of our educational problems would be solved.
There are several nation poverty elimination programs that have been in existence since
1964 when the original war on poverty began 57 years ago. Today there are more than 51% of all
school-age children in the United States living in poverty and attending public schools. “Time is
not change.” (Matthews, D. 2014) If education is really going to be the great equalizer, the goal
of any future school reform policy designed to close the achievement gap in high poverty school
districts, utilizing student and teacher performance, should focus on addressing poverty through
teacher training and professional development. This a very direct way to address the problem at
the classroom level, without creating new and more costly policies and programs.
G. MARTIN EDL 775 POLICY RESEARCH AND POLITICS 16
References
An Assessment of the Effectiveness of Anti-Poverty ... (n.d.). Retrieved April 10, 2018, from
10 Facts About How Poverty Impacts Education. (2017, January 19). Retrieved from
https://www.scilearn.com/blog/ten-facts-about-how-poverty-impacts-education
Attracting Well-Qualified Teachers to Struggling Schools ... (n.d.). Retrieved April 10, 2018,
fromttps://www.bing.com/cr?IG=90FE61AC56FF4C3EAE1C19C184FB703D&CID=33
25DBDA052261A23593D017048D60DE&rd=1&h=KI_pXNwG9rqAnBe5FKp4_0iAXx
e7RQypjI3VuSjg6jE&v=1&r=https://www.aft.org/periodical/american-educator/winter-
2002/attracting-well-qualified-teachers-struggling&p=DevEx,5069.1
At Meeting with Secretary King, Teach Plus Teachers Present Letter Signed by Hundreds of Title
I Educators on Using Title I Funding for Equity. (n.d.). Retrieved April 10, 2018, from
http://teachplus.org/news-events/press-release/meeting-secretary-king-teach-plus-
teachers-present-letter-signed-hundreds
Cain, A. J. (2018, March 01). Four Ways to Protect Vulnerable Students Under ESSA. Retrieved
protect-vulnerable-students-under.html
Columbia Law Review, & Columbia. (2017, November 24). Two Cheers for Evidence: Law,
Research, and Values in Education Policymaking and Beyond. Retrieved April 10, 2018,
from http://columbialawreview.org/content/two-cheers-for-evidence-law-research-and-
values-in-education-policymaking-and-beyond/
https://www.bing.com/cr?IG=27E71AE6571C468D82395C42F8DA965C&CID=0A89C
G. MARTIN EDL 775 POLICY RESEARCH AND POLITICS 17
F788D9663C8298CC4A38C39622F&rd=1&h=fPGPb7UhhzHW-
x9Wb9MVGOr47z7izaSsJsoVbD6Fh_g&v=1&r=https://www.wested.org/online_pubs/tc
of the Every Student Succeeds Act. (2016, August 31). Retrieved from
https://www.ed.gov/news/press-releases/fact-sheet-supplement-not-supplant-under-title-i-
every-student-succeeds-act
http://frac.org/wp-content/uploads/cnnslp.pdf
Matthews, D. (2014, January 08). Everything you need to know about the war on poverty.
you-need-to-know-about-the-war-on-poverty/
Programs That Mitigate the Effects of Poverty on Children. (n.d.). Retrieved from
https://www.bing.com/cr?IG=13B5394FD7844B8F95AD4972C06B8F62&CID=38BDB
0E3325466621870BB3933FB673B&rd=1&h=3PJheCY6MRlKB48NQYR90g4hmWaUz
JmJ1XVkThIZ000&v=1&r=https://www.princeton.edu/futureofchildren/publications/doc
s/07_02_05.pdf&p=DevEx.LB.1,5519.1
Poverty and its Impact on Education: Today and Tomorrow. (n.d.). Retrieved April 10, 2018,
fromttp://www.bing.com/cr?IG=E759D0A545514A0E8966C2D267DD75BF&CID=15C
F4EA79EED60E713FE456A9F42618C&rd=1&h=B3hTqrvFIJ0vepxXH-
HDHAxcJid4mPZ_rcmrMXvPa2g&v=1&r=http://www.nea.org/assets/docs/HE/TA09Po
vertyCapra.pdf&p=DevEx,5070.1
Poverty discourses in teacher education: Understanding policies, effects and attitudes. (n.d.).
Poverty and Education: Questions Raised ... - Daily Kos. (n.d.). Retrieved April 10, 2018,
fromttp://www.bing.com/cr?IG=500A9C3C56B944F191E3E154705B37EC&CID=0117
EDFAAB6F6A152AD7E637AA206BB9&rd=1&h=6BS9KVepxhX8cXp6zO63kilwPwyr
jAes9_l7QUhkTTQ&v=1&r=http://www.dailykos.com/story/2011/6/7/982488/-
&p=DevEx,5070.1
Poverty Reduction Strategies for the US. (n.d.). Retrieved April 10, 2018, from
https://www.bing.com/cr?IG=9ED0560BE4AD4968A3FB56929F8A901C&CID=239B4
51A91E16D7A3E174ED7904E6CD2&rd=1&h=IjM80nzQEDoDr5VYDuXUNMg7r-
8SO6d0Vbj9E2Uxm5Y&v=1&r=https://www.brookings.edu/wp-
content/uploads/2012/04/bane_paper.pdf&p=DevEx,5068.1
Preparing Teachers for High-Poverty Schools - Educational ... (n.d.). Retrieved April 10, 2018,
fromttp://www.bing.com/cr?IG=0B1EBDE7799A4A26A0BCE971C7771700&CID=28A
05C6E413C63EA24CB57A3409362B6&rd=1&h=SScE1Nd7JSHxwQZRMGhVfP3bsrg
Pd-
K5WB9rJm0RfCU&v=1&r=http://www.ascd.org/publications/educational_leadership/ma
y05/vol62/num08/Preparing_Teachers_for_High-
Poverty_Schools.aspx&p=DevEx,5046.1
2016/questioning-payne
Slade, S. (2016, July 24). Poverty Affects Education--And Our Systems Perpetuate It. Retrieved
education_b_7861778.html
G. MARTIN EDL 775 POLICY RESEARCH AND POLITICS 19
Socol, A. R., Robinson-Clark, S., Haycock, B., Grayson, N., Trust, E., Jr., J. B., Smith, R. (2017,
September 06). Trends in State ESSA Plans: Defining Away Low Performance for
line/trends-state-essa-plans-defining-away-low-performance-groups-students/
Ten Dynamics of poverty that undermine school success.doc. (n.d.). Retrieved April 10, 2018,
fromttp://www.bing.com/cr?IG=601E690D851B4C638DA5C273DF2CB157&CID=1D2
467230702676B07E16CEE06AD6665&rd=1&h=NIBNyIIMM-
FDjTZa43XHhL2Okm4QPlgM8FO86UDRqgs&v=1&r=http://www.ahaprocess.com/wp-
content/uploads/2013/08/Education-Solutions-10-Dynamics-Poverty-Undermine-School-
Success.pdf&p=DevEx,5069.1
Waiting for a School Miracle. Retrieved April 10, 2018, from New York Times
https://www.nytimes.com/2011/06/01/opinion/01ravitch.html
T., & Lindsay, B. (2011, March 31). Understanding Poverty in the Classroom: Changing
What You Can Do for Students Living in Poverty - Teachingcom. (n.d.). Retrieved April 10,
2018, from
http://www.bing.com/cr?IG=F78E4A56AB1745BC818782DD254EB7E7&CID=2502C8
FDCDB7620F2C49C330CC1863B1&rd=1&h=BxSE6vkR_HBm_kJOO3o3iYc2reE87j
NMDTHtUoKIiLQ&v=1&r=http://teaching.monster.com/benefits/articles/2597-what-
you-can-do-for-students-living-in-poverty&p=DevEx,5072.1
You are here MDE Food & Nutrition Programs School Nutrition Programs. (n.d.). Retrieved from
http://www.michigan.gov/mde/0,4615,7-140-66254_50144---,00.html