Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
Procedural Controls
Procedural controls include the field, office, and laboratory procedures that specify how
activities related to data generation should be carried out. Forms of procedural control include
Standard Operating Procedures (SOPs), chain-of-custody (CoC) procedures, survey scripts and
instructions, checklists, calibration procedures, training courses and so on. Procedural controls
are the main way to minimize extraneous variation before it occurs.
Sampling Control
Some types of samples have inherent properties that may introduce extraneous variability into
data being generated. For instance, differences in sex, age, and social class, may introduce
extraneous variability in sociological surveys. Environmentally related examples might include:
soil type, geologic strata, species, location and depth, and season (or other time unit). Applying
sampling controls involves grouping the data by the control factor and calculating statistical
analyses for each homogeneous group. Stratified sampling designs are one form of sampling
control.
Sampling controls can be used to prevent, identify, or correct all kinds of extraneous variation.
As a consequence, they are used to some extent in most statistical studies.
Experimental Control
Statistical studies can be categorized into two types — observational and experimental. In an
observational study, the phenomenon under investigation is a characteristic of the objects being
sampled. The concentrations of arsenic in the soils of a waste management facility would be an
example. Variability and bias in observational studies can be assessed through the use of control
samples. Control samples (like quality samples) are groups of samples that don’t have the
condition being tested but are otherwise identical to the experimental group. Adding an offsite
(or background) area to the study of the waste management facility would be an example of a
control group.
In an experimental study, the phenomenon under investigation is assigned to the objects being
sampled. Testing a pollution cleanup technique on several plots of contaminated soil would be an
example of an experimental study. In such a study, the cleanup techniques would be randomly
assigned to the plots in a manner that would help control some of the variation in the plots.
So, the difference between experimental and observational studies is that in an:
Experimental study, samples are randomly assigned to controlled conditions.
Observational study, samples are randomly selected from preexisting conditions.
Another way to control variability and bias is through the use of placebos. A placebo is usually
thought of as a faux drug because of its association with statistical tests of pharmaceuticals, but it
can be any item or action that gives the appearance of being a valid treatment. For example, give
two patients blue pills, one of which has some active ingredient and the other does not. To test a
new pesticide, spray two agricultural test plots, one of which contains the pesticide and the other
contains just water. The key is that the subject or data generator can’t tell the difference. In
Season 5, episode 14 of the television series House, the nurse can tell which patients are being
given the placebo during Dr. Foreman’s drug trial because the real pharmaceutical has a strong
odor. This would not be a good example of an effective placebo.
Placebos are a type of blinding. In any experiment, there are subjects or samples, experimenters,
data collectors or generators, and data analysts. Sometimes, one individual will fill several roles,
such as the experimenter who designs the experiment
and then generates and analyzes the data. But whenever
there are humans involved, there exists the possibility of
intentional or unintentional bias. Blinding is simply the
act of denying one or more of the study participants
with information that might induce them to behave
differently.
To test the effects of a pharmaceutical, for example, a
single-blind study might involve not telling subjects
I’m not telling who got the whether they are receiving the active drug or a placebo.
placebo. (Cat stays in bag.) A double-blind study might involve not telling either
the subjects or the data generators (the nurses who collect physical measurements on the subjects
or the lab technicians who analyze blood samples) who received the drug and who received the
placebo. A triple-blind study might involve not telling the subjects, the data generators, or the
data analysts who received the drug and who received the placebo. It’s ironic that the less
informed the participants are, the better the statistics. Too bad government doesn’t work that
way.
Statistical Control
Special statistics and statistical procedures can be used to partition variability shared by
measurements so that extraneous variability can be assessed. For example, partial correlations
quantify the relationship between two variables while holding the effects of other variables
constant. A covariate is a continuous variable that is incorporated into an analysis of variance
design to eliminate extraneous variability so that tests of the grouping factors will be more
sensitive. Statistical controls are typically used when variation cannot be controlled adequately
through other means.
Techniques for Controlling Extraneous Variability.
Variance Control Technique
Quality Samples and
Measurements
Experimental
Procedural
Replicates
Statistical
Sampling
Blanks
Tests
Prevent
Use
Identify
Correct
Reference
Variance
Strategy
Control
Replication
Randomization
Sampling
Controlled
Variance
http://statswithcats.wordpress.com/2010/09/19/it%E2%80%99s-all-in-the-technique/