Sei sulla pagina 1di 7

Journal of

Archaeological
SCIENCE
Journal of Archaeological Science 30 (2003) 1393–1399
http://www.elsevier.com/locate/jas

A practical approach to the identification of low temperature


heated bone using TEM
H.E.C. Koon*, R.A. Nicholson, M.J. Collins
Ancient Biomolecules Group, Drummond Building, University of Newcastle, Newcastle upon Tyne NE1 7RU, UK
Received 29 November 2002; received in revised form 7 February 2003; accepted 13 February 2003

Abstract

Unlike burnt bone, cooked bone leaves no obvious trace. The ability to identify cooked bone has far reaching implications within
the fields of palaeo-anthropology, archaeology and forensic science. There is, however, only limited literature on low temperature
heated bone. This is not due to a lack of significance, but from an absence of any means of identifying such heating at temperatures
insufficient to cause charring. The situation is further complicated by the fact that diagenetic alteration to bone may mimic heat
induced changes.
A previous Transmission Electron Microscopy (TEM) study showed that heat induced morphological changes to the collagen
fibrils occur after low temperature heating of fish bone. This paper investigates whether these findings could be replicated on
mammal bone. A series of experiments were carried out using sheep humeri. These results were compared with cooked and
uncooked bones recovered from experimental burials, representing a variety of different environments (moorland, woodland and
garden soil). Morphological changes to the fibrils were seen following only very mild heating events, such as short-term roasting of
fleshed bone. However, similar changes were observed in unheated bone which had been buried in a low pH (3.5–4.5) soil for 7 years.
Within a given burial cooked and uncooked bone was easily distinguishable. The technique, therefore, has direct application in
forensic studies and may be of value in distinguishing heated from unheated bone within a given archaeological assemblage.
 2003 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.

Keywords: Bone collagen fibrils; IR; Low temperature heating; TEM; Diagenesis; cooked bone

1. Introduction therefore remains undetected. If minimal heating of


bone could be identified perceptions of the past might
The social and practical implications of the tech- change. As an example, establishing cannibalism in the
nological breakthrough heralded by the first use of fire archaeological record is a topic which remains of great
cannot be underestimated [17]. Evidence of heated bone interest and debate especially with regard to sites in the
in later pre-history can be used not only to imply human American Southwest [15,24] and Fiji [4]. Recognising
influence, but also to elucidate dietary habits, cooking cooked human bone could not only help to distinguish
techniques [24] and socio-cultural or funerary practices war related mutilation or secondary burial from canni-
[16]. Unfortunately, it is only possible to identify the balism [7] but the reported incidence of cannibalism
presence of heated bone if charred, from abrasive would arguably increase [6].
features (pot polish) or by inference from the presence The importance of identifying heated bone from
of associated features, such as hearths [8]. This means archaeological sites has led to a number of methods of
that there is a wealth of evidence not being utilised from identification. There are three main stages through
boiled and roasted bone, which though heated, does which a bone passes as it is heated; first water is boiled
not reach a temperature that will induce charring and away, followed by combustion of the organic matter and
finally modification and decomposition of the mineral.
* Corresponding author. Tel.: +44-78137-13205. Methods have identified changes in the appearance of
E-mail address: hannah.koon@ncl.ac.uk (H.E.C. Koon). the bone as well as detecting thermal alteration within
0305-4403/03/$ - see front matter  2003 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
doi:10.1016/S0305-4403(03)00034-7
1394 H.E.C. Koon et al. / Journal of Archaeological Science 30 (2003) 1393–1399

the organic and mineral phases. At a macroscopic level, attached between the meat and the bone. After heating
studies have focused on the observation of thermally all of the samples were left to cool for 15 min before
induced colour changes and patterns of warping and being reweighed and then defleshed using a scalpel.
cracking on the bone surface [11,20]. Within the bone Six samples were also taken from sheep metapodials
microstructure, the chemical modification and loss to which had been previously buried. The samples utilised
the organic fraction of bone has been investi- for this study came from three different post deposition
gated through analytical techniques monitoring carbon, environments; A1 and A2 were buried in a garden soil, a
hydrogen, and nitrogen (CHN) concentrations [13,22], worked clay loam which had been previously limed to
as well as glycine/glutamic acid (gly/glu) ratios and raise the pH to neutral; B1 and B2 were buried in a
ammonia (NH3) levels [23]. Changes to the mineral have deciduous woodland, in a moderately drained stagno-
also been identified using x-ray diffraction [20] and gleic brown earth soil, with pH 3.5–4.5; C1 and C2 were
infrared spectroscopy [22]. buried in the Yorkshire Moors into a humus iron-pan
The situation however is complicated by the fact that stagnopodzol with pH 3.5–4.5. Three of these samples
weathering processes cause similar alteration to bone, (A2, B2 and C2) had been subjected to the same heating
such as cracking, cortical exfoliation and colour change regime: they were all boiled for one hour (including
to the bone surface [1], an increase in crystal size and 20 min for water to boil), prior to burial for 7 years. The
organisation within the bone mineral [22,25], a loss of three remaining samples were not heated, but had also
collagen and modification to the remaining amino acid been buried for the same 7-year period [12].
composition [9,26]. Indeed a recent study failed to Approximately 5 mm3 sections were removed using a
discriminate between boiled and buried bone [19]. hacksaw, from both the experimentally heated and
Furthermore, attempting to detect evidence of cook- previously buried specimens. Finally, the samples were
ing provides an additional problem in that when heating placed in a solution of 0.5 M HCl and stirred con-
food the objective is to retain the moisture. This being tinuously on a Spiro-mixer at 4 (C. This low tempera-
the case it is unlikely that the bone would reach even the ture was employed to minimise destruction of the
initial stage of thermal alteration where water is boiled collagen during demineralisation, caused by hydrolysis
out of the bone especially if the surrounding flesh acts as from the low pH of the acid [2]. To control for deminer-
an insulator from the external temperature. Conse- alisation comparative preparations were also conducted
quently, the aforementioned changes used to identify using 0.1 M EDTA with the pH adjusted to neutral
heated bone will only occur at temperatures greatly (pH 7) using 0.5 M NaOH.
beyond those achieved during domestic roasting or Once demineralised the insoluble ‘collagen’ residue
boiling. was washed thoroughly with distilled water, to remove
In this study we explore an alternative approach, salt and soluble gelatine before being cut into 2 mm3
namely monitoring heat-induced changes to the packing cubes with a scalpel. TEM preparation was adapted
of the collagen fibril. Evidence from previous studies of from Richter [18]. Samples were placed in a boiling tube
mineralised sheep tendon [21] and fish bone [18] suggest with approximately 3 ml phosphowolframacid, which
that mild heating leads to disorganisation of mineralised had been adjusted to pH 7 with 0.5 M NaOH. In order
collagen fibrils, observable using TEM. It was unclear if to liberate the collagen fibrils the boiling tube was placed
mammal bone collagen would react in a similar way, nor in a beaker of ice and the solution macerated (Ultra-
if the alterations could be unequivocally attributed to Turrax) for 3 min. In order to maintain a low tempera-
heating, or could also be caused by diagenesis (cf. [19]). ture maceration was conducted in 30 s bursts with 30 s
This paper comprises an investigation to monitor intervals between. The head of the macerator and the
changes to collagen fibrils in sheep bones subjected to forceps used to transport the samples were washed
low temperature heating, burial for 7 years, or both. thoroughly with distilled water before processing each
Primarily TEM analysis was used to identify alterations new sample, to minimise cross contamination.
to the collagen component, supplemented with infrared The resulting solutions were transferred to Falcon
investigation to monitor any corresponding changes to tubes and centrifuged on a Minstral 3000 centrifuge at
the mineral component. 3000 g and 4 (C for 15 min. Afterwards the super-
natants were discarded and the remaining pellets were
2. Materials and methods re-suspended in 1 ml of phosphowolframacid and mixed
using an Autovortex mixer. A 0.5 ml drop from each of
To obtain fresh heated bone samples the humeri of the solutions was pipetted on to three formwar grids and
fleshed sheep forelimbs of approximately equal size were allowed to air dry for 5 min, after which time the excess
used. The specimens (1–8) were placed on a preheated liquid was removed and the grids dried with filter paper.
domestic oven and exposed to temperatures of 180 (C A piece of filter paper was placed on to a petri dish
and 220 (C, over different time durations. The bone and dampened with a 50:50 solution of an ethanol/water
temperatures were measured using a thermocouple mix. A portion of dental wax was placed on the filter
H.E.C. Koon et al. / Journal of Archaeological Science 30 (2003) 1393–1399 1395

Table 1
A summary table representing the number of fibrils counted and classified (excluding any ambiguous fibrils) once the samples had been
demineralised. It also shows the results of the infrared analyses and a brief description of the conditions that each sample was subjected to prior
to analyses

Sample Brief description Unaltered fibrils Altered fibrils SF C/P


Beaded Dumbbell
1 Unheated fresh control 85 2 0 2.72 0.38
2 Unheated fresh control 73 2 0 – –
3 Heated at 220 (C to 60 (C over 6 min 79 6 0 – –
4 Heated at 180 (C to 60 (C over 14 min 43 26 1 – –
5 Heated at 220 (C to 80 (C over 16 min 28 10 0 – –
6 Heated at 180 (C to 80 (C over 18 min 13 13 1 2.68 0.45
7 Heated at 180 (C to 96 (C over 60 min 26 72 2 2.64 0.51
8 Heated at 220 (C to 100 (C over 30 min 12 67 4 2.59 0.63
A1 Unheated and buried in garden soil pH 7 87 0 0 – –
A2 Heated and buried in garden soil pH 7 50 28 7 – –
B1 Unheated and buried in woodland soil pH 3.5–4.5 83 17 0 – –
B2 Heated and buried in woodland soil pH 3.5–4.5 7 4 2 – –
C1 Unheated and buried in moors pH 3.5–4.5 42 26 2 – –
C2 Heated and buried in moors pH 3.5–4.5 1 38 8 – –

paper and a 0.5 ml drop of uranyl acetate (2% solution heating. Extensive heating leads to an increase in SF and
in 50:50 ethanol/water mix) was suspended on top. The a decrease in the carbonate/phosphate peak ratio
formwar grids were then floated on this solution, speci- (C/P) [19].
men side down, for 30 min, during which time the
system was covered to protect it from light. Each set of 3.2. Observed changes to the collagen fibril
three grids (per sample) were finally analysed under a
JEOL 1200EX transmission electron microscope. TEM analyses of the heated fresh bone samples
Infrared analysis was also carried out on four samples identified unaltered collagen fibrils, together with fibrils
from the heating experiments. These were chosen as they exhibiting localised areas of swelling both along the
displayed the most alteration to the collagen fibrils fibrils and at the ends. These are the areas described by
under TEM. An unheated control sample was also Richter [18] as ‘melted’ and represent regions where
analysed. localised unpacking of the fibril has occurred. Fibrils
Bone samples were crushed into powder using a pestle were identified as collagen from their distinct staining
and mortar, before being mixed with potassium bromide pattern with a characteristic periodicity, and fibril
and pressed into discs [5]. Analysis was carried out using diameters of between 55–65 nm. Statistical comparison
Fourier Transform Infrared Spectroscopy. The infrared was performed on the most intact and cleanest of each of
‘splitting factor’ (SF), a measure of apatite crystallinity, the three prepared grids. Fibrils were classed using the
was calculated using the splitting ratio of the Phosphate following criteria, adapted from observations made by
4 doublet at 567 cm1 and 605 cm1 after Weiner and Richter [18].
Bar-Yosef [26]. The Carbonate/Phosphate Ratio (C/P)
was also calculated from the infrared spectrum using the 3.2.1. Unaltered
peaks at 1415 cm1 (CO23) and 1035 cm1 (PO34) A collagen fibril with no evidence of ‘melting’. The
[27]. fibrils should have an equal diameter throughout
(Fig. 1A).
3. Results and discussion
3.2.2. Altered, beaded or dumbbell
3.1. Infrared analyses There are two categories of alteration utilised in
this study to describe a modified fibril. Both have
Infrared analyses were unable to discriminate amorphous areas connected by strands that retain a
between the samples, as none had crystallinity (SF) normal collagen-banding pattern. A beaded fibril
values higher than 2.8 (Table 1), the value associated (Fig. 1B) has one or more localised areas of melting both
with fresh modern bone [26]. This suggests that no along the fibril and at the end. A dumbbell (Fig. 1C)
alteration had occurred to the mineral component of describes a short (typically <3 µm) collagen fibril that
these bone samples as a result of low temperature has bulbous areas of melting at both ends. This probably
1396 H.E.C. Koon et al. / Journal of Archaeological Science 30 (2003) 1393–1399

Fig. 1. Four TEM images highlighting the different forms of alteration observed in collagen fibrils after a heating event. A, an unheated collagen
fibril. B, a beaded shaped heated collagen fibril. C, a dumbbell shaped heated collagen fibril. D, amorphous material likely to be denatured collagen.

arises from a parting of the fibril at the beaded region


and thus is a more advanced state of degradation.
Amorphous material was also observed in samples
from the heating experiments (Fig. 1D). Although there
was no clear evidence of banding indicative of native
collagen similar material was identified by Richter [18]
as fully denatured collagen.
The pattern of deterioration observed in these exper-
iments confirms the earlier findings by Richter [18], with
an apparent progression from beaded fibrils to dumb-
bells and amorphous collagen with greater exposure to
heat (Figs. 2 and 3).

3.3. Fresh heated bone

In all cases the fleshed bone reached a substantially


Fig. 2. A. Temperature profiles recorded from roasted bone, the
lower temperature than that achieved by the oven itself numbers 3–8 refer to the fresh heated bone samples, for further details
(Fig. 2a). Also on visual inspection no signs of thermal see Table 1. B. Changing proportion of altered collagen fibrils plotted
alteration (warping, cracking or colour change) were against integrated heating time (assuming an activation energy of
173 kJ mol1). Again the numbers 3–8 refer to the fresh heated bone
apparent on the bone surface. Nevertheless a clear samples and 2 refers to an unheated fresh control, for further details
relationship is observed between the heating profile and see Table 1.
H.E.C. Koon et al. / Journal of Archaeological Science 30 (2003) 1393–1399 1397

Fig. 3. A stacked bar chart showing the relationship between increased temperature and the percentage of altered bone collagen fibrils, using TEM
analyses of samples heated until the bone temperature reached 60 (C (3–4), 80 (C (5–6), 96 (C (7) and 100 (C (8). Two unheated fresh samples (1–2)
are also included as controls.

the rise in the number of damaged fibrils. This is 3.4. Buried bone
demonstrated in Fig. 3 where samples have been
arranged in ascending order on the basis of the maxi- Fig. 4 shows the results of the TEM analyses from six
mum bone temperature that each attained. To confirm weathered bone samples. Significantly, two of the un-
this the total amount of thermal damage (estimated by heated weathered samples (B1 and C1, both from acid
integrating the heating curve and assuming an activation soil) displayed the same types of alteration to their
energy of 173 kJ mol1; Collins unpublished data) was collagen fibrils as that seen in the fresh heated samples.
calculated for each experiment (Fig. 2b). These values This is perhaps not surprising; we estimate that burial
were then normalised to a constant 100 (C and reported for 7 years at 10 (C is thermally equivalent to short
as times@100 (C. This relationship indicates that the boiling (w15s@100 (C). However, the unheated sample
observed alteration of fibrils is not an artefact of sample buried in a neutral pH soil for the same 7-year period
preparation and confirms that the deterioration of col- displayed no detectable alteration. The combined data
lagen is highly temperature dependent (e.g. [3,10,14]). from these three experiments indicated that collagen
The rapidity of thermal alteration detectable by TEM is fibril deterioration is not solely controlled by time/
remarkable, given that Roberts et al. [19] conclude temperature but is also influenced by the burial environ-
that in order to fashion measurable change in cooked ment. Indeed it is striking that the relative degree of
bone (such as change in mineralogy, loss of collagen) collagen fibril deterioration mirrors the observed surface
prolonged (>9 h) boiling would be required. degradation of the buried bone itself. Bone buried in
Despite the many similarities in the morphological neutral clay loam soil lacked surface alteration, whilst
changes observed by this study and that of Richter [18], considerable cortical exfoliation and fungal damage was
the rates of change in experimentally heated sheep bone evident in bones buried in both the brown earth (pH
are somewhat slower than those of fish (Pleuronectes 3.5–4.5) and the humus iron-pan stagnopodzol soil (pH
platessa). In our study several unaltered fibrils were 3.5–4.5) [12].
identified after roasting for 60 min during which time Roberts et al. (2002) [19] state that more than nine
the bone temperature reached in excess of 95 (C hours of boiling would be needed to show physical or
(w323s@100 (C). However, Richter found that at 60 (C chemical alteration in bone. In our burial experiments
after 30 min (w2s@100 (C) most of the fibrils exhibited however, bones were only boiled for one hour. Our
alteration and at 100 (C after the same duration all the method reveals significant degradation of the fibrils in
collagen had ‘melted’ [18]. This is anticipated due to the all of the boiled samples. This finding is anticipated by
lower thermal stability of fish bone collagen [28]. the results from our roasting experiments, the most
1398 H.E.C. Koon et al. / Journal of Archaeological Science 30 (2003) 1393–1399

Fig. 4. A stacked bar chart comparing the effect of burial and of heating and burial, on the percentage of alteration to bone collagen fibrils. This
is achieved using TEM analyses of sets of heated weathered (A2, B2 and C2) and unheated weathered (A1, B1 and C1) bone samples, from three
different deposition environments, for further sample details see Materials and methods.

intense of which was only equivalent to boiling for however, heated bone could be identified without the
10 min. It is not clear why the collagen fibrils for the need for comparative material.
bones which had been boiled prior to burial were not
significantly more damaged than those from the heated
fresh bones, considering they were exposed to 100 (C Acknowledgements
for significantly longer. This needs further investigation
This paper results from work carried out for an MSc
and may reflect different effects induced by boiling and
dissertation at the University of Bradford. We wish to
roasting, or preferential loss of the damaged fibrils
acknowledge the help and support of all those involved
over the period of 7 years in the burial environment.
in this project. In particular, we wish to thank J.
Comparison of the paired boiled and unheated buried
Fearnley of the Department of Biomedical Sciences,
samples (Fig. 4) showed that in all cases TEM analysis
University of Bradford, for his time and assistance in
could discriminate the heated bones.
using the TEM; C. Smith and S. Roberts of the Ancient
Biomolecules Research Group and the Chemical
4. Conclusion Analytical Services Unit, University of Newcastle upon
Tyne, for preparing and running SF and C/P analyses.
This study provides an intriguing insight into the
initial deterioration of a collagen fibril. Changes are
detected by TEM as unpacking and fragmentation of the References
collagen fibril, but as yet it is not known what under- [1] A.K. Behrensmeyer, Taphonomic and ecologic information from
lying process drives this change. The alterations occur bone weathering, Paleobiology 4 (1978) 150–162.
during the mild heating which accompanies cooking and [2] M.J. Collins, P. Galley, Towards an optimal method of archaeo-
well before any gross collagen loss or change in mineral logical collagen extraction: the influence of pH and grinding,
Ancient Biomolecules 2 (1998) 209–222.
crystallinity are apparent. The study has also highlighted
[3] M.J. Collins, M.S. Riley, A.M. Child, G. Turner-Walker, A basic
the problem of identifying bone that has been heated mathematical simulation of the chemical degradation of ancient
prior to burial. The reason for this is that similar collagen, Journal of Archaeological Science 22 (1995) 175–183.
alteration occurs to bone as a consequence of both [4] D. Degusta, Fijian cannibalism and mortuary ritual: bioarchaeo-
prolonged or extreme subsurface diagenesis and heating logical evidence from Vunda, International Journal of
Osteoarchaeology 10 (2000) 76–92.
processes. As a result, TEM analyses of collagen fibrils
[5] M.J. DeNiro, S. Weiner, Chemical, enzymatic and spectroscopic
would be of value in discriminating between heated characterisation of ‘collagen’ and other organic fractions from
and unheated bone from a single (well-preserved) prehistoric bones, Geochimica et Cosmochimica Acta 52 (1988)
archaeological assemblage. Within a forensic timescale, 2197–2206.
H.E.C. Koon et al. / Journal of Archaeological Science 30 (2003) 1393–1399 1399

[6] S.A. Hurlbut, The taphonomy of cannibalism: a review of the [18] J. Richter, Experimental study of heat induced morphological
anthropogenic bone modification in the American southwest, changes in fish bone collagen, Journal of Archaeological Science
International Journal of Osteoarchaeology 10 (2000) 4–26. 13 (1986) 477–481.
[7] P.M. Lambert, B.R. Billman, B.L. Leonard, Explaining varia- [19] S.J. Roberts, C.I. Smith, A. Millard, M.J. Collins, The
bility on mutilated human bone assemblages from the taphonomy of cooked bone: characterizing boiling and its
American southwest: a case study from the Southern Piedmont of physico-chemical effects, Archaeometry 44 (2002) 485–494.
Sleeping Ute Mountain, Colorado, International Journal of [20] P. Shipman, G.F. Foster, M. Schoeniger, Burnt bones and teeth:
Osteoarchaeology 10 (2000) 49–64. an experimental study of colour, morphology, crystal structure
[8] J.G. McDonnell, Pyrotechnology, in: D.R. Brothwell, A.M. and shrinkage, Journal of Archaeological Science 11 (1984)
Pollard (Eds.), Handbook of Archaeological Sciences, Wiley and 307–325.
Sons, Chichester, 2001, pp. 493–505. [21] J.M. Snowden, J.F. Weidemann, A morphological and biochemi-
[9] P.M. Masters, Preferential preservation of non-collagenous pro- cal examination of the hydrothermal denaturation of collagen,
teins during bone diagenesis: Implications of chronometric and Meat Science 2 (1976) 1–18.
stable isotopic measurements, Geochimica et Cosmochimica Acta
[22] M.C. Stiner, S.L. Kuhn, S. Weiner, O. Bar-Yosef, Differential
51 (1987) 3209–3214.
burning, recrystallisation, and fragmentation of archaeological
[10] C.A. Miles, A.J. Bailey, Thermally labile domains in the collagen
bone, Journal of Archaeological Science 22 (1995) 223–237.
molecule, Micron 32 (2001) 325–332.
[23] R.E. Taylor, P.E. Hare, T.D. White, Geochemical criteria for
[11] R.A. Nicholson, A morphological investigation of burnt animal
thermal alteration of bone, Journal of Archaeological Science 22
bone and an evaluation of its utility in archaeology, Journal of
(1995) 115–119.
Archaeological Science 20 (1993) 411–428.
[12] R.A. Nicholson, Bone degradation, burial medium and species [24] C.G. Turner, J.A. Turner, Man Corn: Cannibalism and Violence
representation: debunking the myths, and experiment-based in the Prehistoric American Southwest, University of Utah Press,
approach, Journal of Archaeological Science 23 (1996) 513–533. Salt Lake City, 1999, pp. 16–21.
[13] R.A. Nicholson, Bone degradation in a compost heap, Journal of [25] N. Tuross, A.K. Behrensmeyer, E.D. Eanes, L.W. Fisher, P.E.
Archaeological Science 25 (1998) 393–403. Hare, Molecular preservation and crystallographic alterations
[14] C.M. Nielsen-Marsh, R.E.M. Hedges, T. Mann, M.J. Collins, A in a weathering sequence of wildebeest bones, Applied
preliminary investigation of the application of differential Geochemistry 4 (1989) 261–270.
scanning calorimetry to the study of collagen degradation in [26] S. Weiner, O. Bar-Yosef, States of preservation of bones
archaeological bone, Thermochimica Acta 365 (2000) 129–139. from Prehistoric sites in the Near East: a survey, Journal of
[15] S.A. Novak, D.D. Kollmann, Perimortem processing of human Archaeological Science 17 (1990) 187–196.
remains among the Great Basin Fremont, International Journal [27] W.E. Wright, H.P. Schwarcz, Infrared and isotopic evidence for
of Osteoarchaeology 10 (2000) 65–75. diagenesis of bone apatite at Dos Pilas, Guatemala: Palaeodietry
[16] T. Oestigaard, Sacrifices of raw, cooked and burnt humans, implications, Journal of Archaeological Science 23 (1996)
Norwegian Archaeological Review 33 (2000) 41–58. 933–944.
[17] C. Renfrew, P. Bahn, Archaeology: Theories, Methods and [28] J. Woodhead-Galloway, Collagen: the Anatomy of a Protein.
Practice, Thames and Hudson, London, 1996, pp. 240–241. Studies in Biology no. 117. Edward Arnold, London, 1980.

Potrebbero piacerti anche