Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
ACCOUNTING
AT&T
Vs.
Verizon
Case
LORENZO
ROSSI
1224242
1)
It
is
absolutely
reasonable
to
compare
two
corporations
like
AT&T
and
Verizon,
since
these
two
are
very
similar
in
characteristics
and
in
the
services
they
offer.
Both
companies
are
communications
network
providers
and
both
provide
to
general
customers
and
companies
different
services
like
wireless,
wireline,
broadband
data,
and
video
services
along
with
managed
m
networking
and
wholesale
services.
More
over,
these
two
telecommunication
giants
are
er as
co
structured
in
a
really
close
manner;
they
are
indeed
set
up
on
two
main
operating
branches,
eH w
which
are
wireless
and
wireline.
o.
rs e
A
comparison
between
the
two
may
be
made
for
several
different
reasons;
it
could
be
done
a
ou urc
research
to
better
understand
the
industry,
or
to
analyze
and
compare
the
financial
position
of
each
of
the
companies,
or
even
to
understand
market
strategies
or
to
assess
the
weight
of
a
o
single
company
in
the
entire
industry
and
the
market
share
that
it
possesses.
As
a
financial
aC s
vi y re
analyst,
in
my
case,
I
would
definitely
go
and
analyze
the
financial
structure,
position
and
strategy
of
AT&T
and
Verizon.
From
such
a
research
I
could
gain
important
information
on
who
might
be
a
future
market
leader,
or
whom
revenues
will
tend
to
increase
over
time,
or
which
of
the
two
ed d
ar stu
corporations
may
represent
a
better
investment
for
me
or
for
some
of
my
hypothetical
clients
willing
to
invest
in
the
telecommunication
industry.
Benefits
from
running
such
a
comparison
are
sh is
several
and
these
up
mentioned
are
just
a
few,
since
from
the
financial
point
of
view,
these
two
giant
companies
have
long
stories
to
tell
and
big
questionings
to
be
discovered.
Th
2)
Overall,
people
nowadays
tend
to
have
a
higher
need
of
communication
means
than
it
used
to
be
in
past
times.
And
this
tendency
is
visible
even
from
year
to
year,
especially
on
the
Wireless
side
where
every
year
there
is
a
noticeable
and
impressive
surge
in
subscriptions
and
so
in
revenues
for
these
two
companies.
While
the
wireless
side
is
going
really
strongly
and
really
fast,
https://www.coursehero.com/file/13702395/Accounting-ATT-V-Verizon-Case/
1
the
wireline
is
struggling
and
it
may
be
possible
to
see
it
disappear
in
some
near
future.
The
future
is
of
course
in
the
wireless
side
of
communications
and
many
people
have
already
abandoned
the
wireline
towards
wireless.
Overall
though,
the
trend
is
that
of
an
industry
in
constant
and
rapid
growth,
given
also
by
the
fast
pace
of
technology,
which
goes
hand
by
hand
with
the
wireless
and
the
communication
industry
as
a
whole.
3)
Operating Results ($ Millions): 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014
Total Operating Revenue 124,280 126,723 127,434 128,752 132,447
Less: Cost of Services (Excluding
Depreciation) 52,379 57,374 55,228 51,464 60,611
m
Less: Selling General & Administrative 32,864 38,844 41,066 28,414 39,697
er as
Less: Impairment & Other Charges 85 2,910 0 0 2,120
EBITDA 38,952 27,595 31,140 48,874 30,019
co
31% 22% 24% 38% 23% 28%
eH w
Less: Depreciation & Amortization 19,379 18,377 18,143 18,395 18,273
EBIT 19,573 9,218 12,997 30,479 11,746
o.
16% 7% 10% 24% 9% 13%
Less: Interest Expense
rs e
Plus: Equity in Net Income of Affiliates
2,994
762
3,535
784
3,444
752
3,940
642
3,613
175
ou urc
Plus: Other Income (1) 1,676 249 134 596 1,652
EBT 19,017 6,716 10,439 27,777 9,960
15% 5% 8% 22% 8% 12%
Less: Taxes -1,162 2,532 2,900 9,224 3,442
o
Less: Income Attributable to Minority Interest 315 240 275 304 294
vi y re
https://www.coursehero.com/file/13702395/Accounting-ATT-V-Verizon-Case/
2
The
first
table
is
relative
to
Verizon
while
the
second
regards
AT&T.
From
the
margin
analysis
I
did,
we
may
see
a
common
trend
for
EBIT,
EBT
and
Net
Income
margins,
with
a
little
difference
that
Verizon
is
more
efficient
since
its
margins
are
on
average
higher
than
AT&T
ones.
There
is
one
exception
though,
we
may
see
that
Income
attributable
to
minority
interest
(which
may
represent
preferred
stock
holders)
is
much
higher
for
Verizon,
so
that
the
actual
Net
income
attributable
to
shareholders’
margin
is
higher
for
AT&T
with
respect
to
Verizon.
Overall,
trends
are
pretty
much
similar
for
both
companies,
but
we
can
also
notice
how
both
companies
over
time
tent
to
be
less
and
less
efficient
since
expenses
are
rising
at
a
faster
pace
with
respect
to
revenues.
m
er as
co
4)
eH w
This
is
the
data
relative
to
Verizon
(reorganized
BS,
showing
NOA,
then
tables
for
NOWC
and
o.
ratios).
rs e
ou urc
Assets ($ Millions): 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014
Accounts Receivable 12,573 11,781 11,776 12,576 12,439 13,993
Inventory 1,426 1,131 940 1,075 1,020 1,153
o
Prepaid Expenses & Other Current Assets 5,247 2,223 4,269 4,021 3,406 3,324
Property, Plant & Equipment 91,985 87,711 88,434 88,642 88,956 89,947
aC s
Goodwill & Other Intangibles 29,236 27,818 29,235 30,072 30,434 30,367
Other Assets 8,756 5,635 5,155 4,128 4,535 6,628
Investments in Unconsolidated Businesses 3,118 3,497 3,448 3,401 3,432 802
Total Operating Assets 224,408 212,792 216,507 221,659 219,969 221,555
ed d
Cash & Cash Equivalents 2,009 6,668 13,362 3,093 53,528 10,598
ar stu
Liabilities & Owners' Equity ($ Millions): 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014
sh is
Accounts Payable & Accrued Liabilities 15,223 15,702 14,689 16,182 16,453 16,680
Other Current Liabilities 6,708 7,353 11,223 6,405 6,664 8,649
Th
Current Portion of Long-Term Debt 7,205 7,542 4,849 4,369 3,933 2,735
Long-Term Debt 55,051 45,252 50,303 47,618 89,658 110,536
https://www.coursehero.com/file/13702395/Accounting-ATT-V-Verizon-Case/
3
Working Capital Ratios 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014
Daily Sales 292 304 317 330 348
Daily Expenses 207 223 236 197 249
DSO 40 39 40 38 40
Days Inventory 9 7 8 8 8
Days Prepaid Expenses 11 19 17 17 13
Days Payable 76 66 68 83 67
Days Other Current Liabilities 36 50 27 34 35
Cash-to-cash Cycle -51 -51 -30 -54 -40
Net Working Capital 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014
Accounts Receivable 12,573 11,781 11,776 12,576 12,439 13,993
m
Plus: Inventory 1,426 1,131 940 1,075 1,020 1,153
er as
Plus: Prepaid Expenses & Other Current Assets 5,247 2,223 4,269 4,021 3,406 3,324
co
Less: Accounts Payable & Accrued Liabilities 15,223 15,702 14,689 16,182 16,453 16,680
eH w
Less: Other Current Liabilities 6,708 7,353 11,223 6,405 6,664 8,649
Net Working Capital -2,685 -7,920 -8,927 -4,915 -6,252 -6,859
o.
rs e
Following
is
the
data
relative
to
AT&T
instead.
ou urc
Assets ($ Millions): 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014
Accounts Receivable 14,845 13,610 13,231 12,657 12,918 14,527
Prepaid Expenses 1,562 1,458 1,102 1,035 960 831
o
Cash & Cash Equivalents 3,741 1,437 3,045 4,868 3,339 8,603
Total Assets 268,312 268,488 270,442 272,315 277,787 292,829
Liabilities & Owners' Equity ($ Millions): 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014
sh is
Accounts Payable & Accrued Liabilities 21,260 20,055 19,956 20,911 21,107 23,592
Prepaid Revenue & Customer Deposits 4,170 4,086 3,872 3,808 4,212 4,105
Th
https://www.coursehero.com/file/13702395/Accounting-ATT-V-Verizon-Case/
4
Working Capital Ratios 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014
Daily Sales 340 347 349 353 363
Daily Expenses 234 272 264 219 281
m
er as
Less: Prepaid Revenue & Customer Deposits 4,170 4,086 3,872 3,808 4,212 4,105
Net Working Capital -5,231 -6,797 -5,358 -7,917 -6,661 -5,414
co
eH w
o.
5)
rs e
ou urc
Here
we
see
net
operating
assets
and
the
amount
of
reinvestment
in
the
business
through
long-‐
term
assets
from
2009
to
2014
for
AT&T,
from
here
we
may
see
if
the
company
has
been
o
reinvesting
in
the
business
or
not
by
looking
at
the
change
over
the
years.
Overall,
in
these
6
aC s
vi y re
Total Ending Balance in Long Term Assets 164,981 167,685 170,223 175,679 184,720
https://www.coursehero.com/file/13702395/Accounting-ATT-V-Verizon-Case/
5
For
Verizon
instead,
we
may
see
underneath,
that
from
2009
to
2014
there
have
been
many
variations
but
overall
the
company
has
not
much
reinvested
into
the
business
since
over
these
6
years
NOA
have
actually
decreased
and
long
term
assets
haven’t
changed
much.
m
er as
Other Assets 5,635 5,155 4,128 4,535 6,628
Total Ending Balance in Long Term Assets 169,839 170,287 173,915 172,670 172,718
co
eH w
Beginning Balance in Long-term Assets
o.
PPE 91,985 87,711 88,434 88,642 88,956
Wireless Licenses
rs e 72,067 72,996 73,250 77,744 75,747
ou urc
Investments in Unconsolidated Businesses 3,118 3,497 3,448 3,401 3,432
Other Assets 8,756 5,635 5,155 4,128 4,535
Total Beginning Balance in Long Term Assets 175,926 169,839 170,287 173,915 172,670
o
Depreciation
aC s
6)
ar stu
https://www.coursehero.com/file/13702395/Accounting-ATT-V-Verizon-Case/
6
7)
I
calculate
ROE
as
Total
asset
turnover
times
Profit
margin
times
equity
multiplier.
Instead,
for
RNOA
I
posed
EBIAT
over
NOA,
for
ROOA
I
posed
(EBIAT
+
(Operating
Liabilities*(1-‐Tax
Rate))
all
over
Total
Operating
assets.
I
get
return
from
operating
leverage
as
(op
liab/noa)*(rooa*((0.6)*r))
and
return
from
financial
leverage
as
(net
debt/equity)*(rnoa-‐r(1-‐t)).
This
is
for
AT&T.
2010 2011 2012 2013 2014
m
Total Asset Turnover 46% 47% 47% 46% 45%
er as
Profit Margin 16% 3% 6% 14% 5%
Equity Multiplier 2.4 2.6 2.9 3.0 3.4
co
eH w
ROE 18% 4% 8% 20% 7%
o.
rs e
ou urc
2010 2011 2012 2013 2014
RNOA 6.6% 3.3% 4.9% 11.1% 4.3%
ROOA 4.8% 2.5% 3.4% 7.1% 3.0%
o
https://www.coursehero.com/file/13702395/Accounting-ATT-V-Verizon-Case/
7
8)
By
taking
a
look
at
the
numbers,
postpaid
subscribers
increased
dramatically
in
the
last
5/6
years
for
both
companies,
while
the
number
of
prepaid
subscribers
decreased
in
the
meanwhile.
So
totally
the
number
of
total
subscriptions
increased
massively
over
these
years,
and
this
is
mainly
due
to
postpaid
subscribers;
this
may
be
due
to
improvements
in
technology
over
the
years,
where
paying
with
credit
cards
and
so
with
postpaid
automatic
refill
accounts
may
have
gotten
easier.
ARPU
instead
has
decreased
over
time
and
this
is
mainly
due
by
the
customer
shift
toward
installment
purchases,
and
away
from
extended
service
contracts.
EBIT
and
EBITDA
margins
are
volatile
but
they
mainly
stay
over
an
average
of
28/30%
for
EBITDA
and
13/16%
for
EBIT.
m
er as
co
9)
eH w
Overall,
there
has
been
a
huge
increase
in
the
wireless
industry.
Both
firms
have
experienced
a
o.
rs e
rise
in
revenues
and
customers
in
it.
This
may
be
mainly
driven
by
the
fact
that
mobile
devices
ou urc
have
increased
dramatically
in
the
last
few
years
and
so
consequently
the
use
of
wireless
connection.
More
over,
the
convergence
of
voice,
data
and
video
in
unique
packets
on
wireless
o
10)
In
the
wireline
sector,
mainly
corporations,
and
not
much
individual
customers,
are
still
keeping
ed d
ar stu
up
the
industry.
This
market
has
seen
a
deteriorating
trend
over
the
last
decade
due
primarily
to
the
rise
of
the
wireless
connections.
The
wireline
industry
is
mainly
driven
by
the
fact
that
much
sh is
of
a
packet’s
life
is
wireline
before
becoming
wireless,
so
even
today,
many
people
still
utilize
wireline
connections
and
this
is
the
key
factor
that
still
keeps
up
the
industry.
Th
11)
The
overall
strategy
for
each
firm
obviously
is
to
move
towards
the
wireless
market
since
it
represents
the
market
and
the
industry
of
the
future
as
I
think
that
the
wireline
industry
is
destined
to
die
and
disappear
in
a
near
future.
This
indeed
may
be
seen
from
the
data
given,
as
we
can
see
that
year
by
year
the
market
for
wireline
has
been
going
down.
The
strategy
is,
in
my
https://www.coursehero.com/file/13702395/Accounting-ATT-V-Verizon-Case/
8
opinion,
to
make
as
much
technological
improvements
as
possible
in
the
wireless
industry,
and
to
invest
more
and
more
capital
on
it
in
order
to
facilitate
the
customer
experience.
I
definitely
expect
to
see
the
wireless
market
to
increase
massively
and
the
wireline
to
disappear
completely
over
the
long
run.
m
er as
co
eH w
o.
rs e
ou urc
o
aC s
vi y re
ed d
ar stu
sh is
Th
https://www.coursehero.com/file/13702395/Accounting-ATT-V-Verizon-Case/
9