Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
Savannah Nugent
Professor White
Eng. 1201
24 March 2018
If someone told you that there was clean, efficient, and cost-effective energy available,
you would most likely choose that option. Renewable and non-renewable energy has been a
highly controversial issue throughout the world for decades. Renewable sources are natural
sources that are incessantly regenerative without being depleted which include wind, solar,
geothermal, hydropower, and biomass energy. Non-renewable sources also known as fossil fuels
are substances such as oil, natural gas, and coal. The United States has used fossil fuels since the
beginning of energy consumption. We use them to power our automobiles, factories, homes and
so much more. The problem with fossil fuels is that there is a limited supply and the process
takes thousands of years to complete (R. Energy). That is one thing that both the critics and
supporters of renewable energy can agree on although there is no accurate estimate on when
fossil fuels will diminish. Renewable energy is ecofriendly, helps stimulate the economy, and
decreases America’s dependence on oil from foreign countries. The fact that renewable energy
Fossil fuels are cheaper and a small amount can manufacture a lot of energy. However,
burning fossil fuels such as gas, oil, and coal causes particles in the smoke to rise in the
atmosphere where it remains for either a few years or even a thousand years. Greenhouse gas are
gasses that trap the suns radiation created by the byproducts of fossil fuel combustion thus
Nugent 2
creating temperatures to rise known as global warming. The increased water vapor created from
carbon dioxide boosted the chemical ozone production in urban areas. Global warming impacts
could range anywhere from the loss of coral reefs, fisheries, increased storms and droughts, even
Not only does greenhouse gases effect the ecosystem but mankind as well. The pollution
caused by greenhouse gases kills 3.3 million people per year. Among these deaths 55,000 came
from the United States. Since the industrial revolution these gases have been emitted in the
atmosphere from mankind. The Clean Power Plan terms carbon dioxide as a pollutant under the
Clean Air Act which has an ultimate goal of putting limitations on the amount of carbon
emissions created by electricity-generating power plants, the source of about 37 percent of the
U.S. carbon emissions. Studies show that if we were to implement the Clean Power Plan, it
would reduce untimely deaths in the U.S. by 3,600. While 90,000 children would have fewer
According to a study of global carbon emissions in 2012 the world population pushed an
estimated 35.6 billion tons of carbon into the atmosphere. That averages to an unsettling amount
of 19 tons per person (International Business). The science behind renewable sources can
eliminate a significant amount of carbon from the atmosphere. Some argue that global warming
does not exist. However, studies indicate that temperatures have risen between 0.7 to 1.5 degrees
Fahrenheit during the twentieth century alone (Flynn). The chart below shows that increase and
with the continuous population growth the amount of fossil fuels will only escalate. To ensure
continued economic prosperity we must invest in alternative sources of energy before the
Content Agency Photos, 2017. Opposing Viewpoints in Context, Accessed 24 July 2017.
Natural gas is a fossil fuel that has surged in the past centuries. The method of extracting
that gas involves hydraulic fracturing, in which workers drive millions of gallons of liquid
underground to break open rock formations. This process has caused some negative responses.
The most common complaint is that fracking contaminates drinking water. One example of all
the backlash seen from fracking is the controversial keystone pipeline protest where supporters
from all over the world joined together to oppose such methods. In an article by Lena Groeger
she claims that, “Since 1986 pipeline accidents have killed more than 500 people, injured over
4,000, and cost nearly seven billion dollars in property damages.” (Groeger, Lena). The number
of accidents that have occurred due to fracking raises questions on whether or not the benefits of
fossil fuels are exaggerated and the benefits of renewable energy are downplayed.
Nugent 4
The United States depends on foreign countries that have political instability for fossil
fuels. The current dependency of imports that the U.S. relies on is more than half of its
necessitated consumption of fossil fuels. People usually lean towards the cheapest available
energy source which is fossil fuels subsequently, the cost continues to increase as a direct result
of environmental restrictions. This is mainly due to dangers of transporting the fuels. We have
seen time and time again the damaging effects of oil spills throughout the world. Like the 2010
oil spill in the Gulf of Mexico when 3.19 million barrels of crude oil was leaked into the Gulf.
When the world gets closer to the depletion of fossil fuels the prices will soar as in the
1973 Arab Oil Embargo. During this time the price of oil per barrel first doubled, then
stability of national economies (McGarvey). This in turn made people want to discover
alternatives that would make America independent from the oil in the Middle East. The United
States technology is geared towards the use of fossil fuels so, it is understandable a new
The fact that fossil fuels are a finite source should urge mankind to explore different
options to continue to power the future for generations after generations. Frank Gaffney
president of the Center of Security Policy says the U.S is losing 828,000 jobs every year and
losing $305 billion because of its oil dependency from foreign countries (Security). Investing in
energy sources within our country can keep the money circulating within the local economy
rather than overseas. This would bring a plethora of benefits to the economy and country in
which we live.
Nugent 5
The critics of renewable energy claim that renewable energy cannot harness enough
power to support the necessitated amount of energy needed. Fossil fuel energy is currently
supplying 87% of the worlds energy (R. Energy). There is enough wind and solar energy alone to
power the world however, there are issues with harnessing and storing power when wind and sun
are not available. Further science is needed to exploit those issues. There are both positive and
negative side effects that come from the use of renewable and non-renewable energy. Weighing
out the pros and cons of each source can lead us in right direction when choosing what’s best for
us globally.
Wind turbines are another source of renewable energy, wind energy is generated by the
fan turbines that spin from the force of the wind and then turns a generator, causing the
production of electricity. As with any source of energy there are pros and cons, or side effects of
the technology involved in manufacturing or distributing such forms of energy. This form of
energy is ever changing with new developments every day. The national wind technology center
stated that by the year 2030 the united states could see a 50 percent reduction in the cost of wind
energy, and a drastic rise in the percentage of the U.S. being supplied by wind energy. Wind
energy has the potential to produce more jobs in America and is expected to increase every year
Wind energy requires large amounts of land to operate and could cause a disruption in
migration patterns. Not to mention the hundreds of thousands of birds that are killed from
collisions with the wind turbines in the united states every year. Fossil fuels also greatly affect
our environment and its inhabitants as well as causing extinction level events with certain species
of animals, with more than 200 species being extinct since 1970 (Clemmitt, Marcia). The initial
cost is relatively high however, it improves air quality and can sustain the demands of energy.
Nugent 6
Stanford researchers projected global wind energy potential at 72,000 GW(gigawatt). Which
means that, wind can supply ten times the amount of energy the entire world would need
(Flavin). As of 2016 only 5 percent of the United States energy was produced from wind
turbines, as opposed to 37 percent being from fossil fuels (National Wind Technology Center).
Solar energy comes from the suns radiation and is converted to energy through the use of
solar panels. These panels are what deliver the electricity to heat and power homes and
businesses worldwide. Solar energy is very abundant and produces no pollution or carbon
dioxide. Critics argue that solar energy is unpredictable because sun is not always available and
only so much of the energy from the sun can be converted into solar photovoltaic cells. The
supporters of solar energy do not deny that there are some issues that need to be worked out
before energy from the sun can fuel the world (R. Energy).
Scientist believe that there are enough brilliant minds out there to tackle those issues.
There have been significant innovations in recent years when it comes to solar energy. One of
the most important advances came from Scientist Daniel Nocera and Matthew Kanan at MIT
(Massachusetts Institute of Technology). This development is the process where storing the
energy created by the sun can be stored for later use. The key factor that makes this process
possible is Nocera and Kanan’s formulation of a catalyst, which makes the process of storing
energy attainable. The process described by Nocera is, “… the energy to split water
into hydrogen and oxygen for storage. At night, the stored hydrogen and oxygen could be
recombined using a fuel cell to generate power while the solar panels are inactive." (Higgins,
James M).
Geothermal energy is a renewable resource that is produced from the heat deep under the
surface of the earth. Geothermal energy has the potential to provide energy at a low cost while
Nugent 7
having a minimal impact on the environment, and provide practical applicational uses as a heat
source. With newer drilling and extracting techniques being constantly improved geothermal
energy could be a viable source of energy. Also has the potential to stimulate economic growth,
especially the rural areas. Compared to the production of fossil fuels, geothermal energy power
plants produce very little amounts of air emissions (National Geothermal Collaborative). With
proper maintenance a geothermal power plant can produce energy for a long while.
This is a diagram of a geothermal power plant producing energy and heat to be provided
for use. First the water is heated and goes to the heat exchanger, which is then ready to be used.
Nugent 8
Then the once heated water returns to the ground cooled and ready to begin the process once
again.
Hydropower energy is produced from water being ran through a generator allowing it to
produce electricity, only having to damn up a river to produce power. This form of energy has a
great protentional for economic growth with the positions in the power plants to keep them
but, causes no pollution and can even facilitate in the management of fresh water (R. Energy).
The advantages of renewable energy outweigh the risk, with further research they could become
more advanced in providing clean efficient and environmentally and ecofriendly energy.
Biomass energy is made from plant and plant derived materials, which is the energy
expended from the photosynthesis process. This makes this a completely renewable resource,
also there is a give and take with the greenhouse gases. Which means the amount of carbon
The picture above shows the united states navy going green by using a blend of biofuels
to power a F/A-18 Super Hornet. This being a push to grow the nation’s security department by
running their jets on renewable energy. Biofuels are very important because as of now it is the
only renewable alternative to fossil fuels in our vehicles we use every day. Every gallon of
biofuels used helps reduce the risk of all the harmful and toxic issues with spilled oil tankers and
The critics of renewable energy claim that jobs will disappear if the world was to actively
explore alternative sources of energy. They believe that shutting down the powerplants that are
already in service will put the economy in a recession. They also claim that renewable energy is
not cost competitive and therefore should not be explored as a viable solution to meet energy
demands. For these reasons to hold any merit the critics would have to acknowledge the
The fossil fuel industry employs about 600,000 people in the United States since 2017
Renewable Energy already employs thousands of people, the Environmental Defense Fund
estimated that there were 769,000 jobs in renewable energy with a job creation rate expressively
higher than that of the rest of the economy (R. Energy). Green jobs range from engineers,
accountants, scientist, constructors, operation managers, and so much more. The jobs that stem
from renewable energy can help stimulate the economy and reduce unemployment to 4.4 percent
from the current 5.7 percent (Podesta). The jobs available with renewable energy can cover the
amount of jobs lost with fossil fuels and create even more positions in energy than what’s
currently available.
the world. The bottom line is that renewable sources of energy helps stimulate the economy by
creating jobs and keeping our money local. The U.S would gain independence with reducing our
dependency on foreign countries for oil while the money that is outsourced to other countries for
oil would remain in the United States. The overall well-being of our planet would significantly
improve. Less deaths and fewer illnesses related to the pollution of fossil fuels would occur from
implementing renewable energy. Fossil fuels are a finite source of energy so, it is imperative to
find an alternative source of energy. While renewable energy does have some issues that requires
further research, it will ultimately help our communities prevail. I see renewable energy as the
Works cited
Adams, Jill U. "Air Pollution and Climate Change." CQ Researcher, 13 Nov. 2015, pp. 961-84,
library.cqpress.com/cqresearcher/cqresrre2015111300.
library.cqpress.com/cqresearcher/cqresrre2003012400.
Flavin, Chris, and Janet Sawin. "Renewable Energy Sources Can Meet America's Energy
Demands." Energy Alternatives, edited by David Haugen and Susan Musser, Greenhaven
2017. Originally published as "Renewables: What We Meant to Say," World Watch, vol.
Flynn, Sally Driscoll. "Global Warming: An Overview." Points of View: Global Warming, 31
Context, http://link.galegroup.com/apps/doc/CT3294260092/OVIC?u=dayt30401&xid=4
Groeger, Lena. "Pipelines Explained: How Safe Are America's 2.5 Million Miles of Pipelines?"
http://link.galegroup.com.sinclair.ohionet.org/apps/doc/EJ3010930219/OVIC?u=dayt304
Hance, Jeremy. "America's Dependence on Fossil Fuel Is to Blame for the Oil Spill." BP Oil
Spill, edited by David Haugen, Greenhaven Press, 2012. At Issue. Opposing Viewpoints
in Context,
http://link.galegroup.com.sinclair.ohionet.org/apps/doc/EJ3010761203/OVIC?u=dayt304
Higgins, James M. "The Looming Energy Crisis Creates Opportunities for Solar Power." The
Energy Crisis, edited by Lisa Krueger, Greenhaven Press, 2010. At Issue. Opposing
Viewpoints in Context,
http://link.galegroup.com.sinclair.ohionet.org/apps/doc/EJ3010609207/OVIC?u=dayt304
Powered Future," The Futurist, vol. 43, no. 3, 2009, pp. 25-29.
“Increase in Global Temperatures Shows 2016 Warmest Year on Record.” Tribune Content
Institute for the Analysis of Global Security. "Alternative Energy Sources Are Necessary to
Krupp, Fred. "Greenhouse Gas Emissions Should Be Reduced." Global Warming, edited by
Context, Accessed 20 March 2018. Originally published as "testimony before the U.S.
Lyons, Christina L. "Native American Sovereignty." CQ Researcher, 5 May 2017, pp. 385-408,
library.cqpress.com/cqresearcher/cqresrre2017050500.
McGarvey, Robert. "The United States Can Minimize Its Dependence on Middle East Oil." Oil,
Independence: Salvation or Mirage?" American Legion Magazine, vol. 154, June 2003,
pp. 24-26.
http://link.galegroup.com.sinclair.ohionet.org/apps/doc/EJ3010220255/OVIC?u=dayt304
Context, http://link.galegroup.com/apps/doc/EJ3000103732/OVIC?u=dayt30401&xid=83
“Navy Uses Biofuel Blend. Tribune Content Agency Photos, 2010.” Opposing Viewpoints in
Context, http://link.galegroup.com/apps/doc/CT3294210820/OVIC?u=dayt30401&xid=a
Podesta, John. "A Green Economy Will Produce Many New Green Jobs." The Green Movement,
Recovery: A New Program to Create Good Jobs and Start Building a Low-Carbon
“Renewable Energy.” Opposing Viewpoints Online Collection, Gale, 2017. Opposing Viewpoints
U.S. Department of Energy. "Biomass Is a Proven Renewable Resource with Many Uses."
http://link.galegroup.com.sinclair.ohionet.org/apps/doc/EJ3010220254/OVIC?u=dayt304