Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
Alfred Hitchcock
Film Noir
Noir Fiction
Orson Welles
Stanley Kubrick
Woody Allen
Hong Kong’s Heroic Bloodshed (Editor)
Scorsese 22/6/04 12:26 pm Page 3
Martin Scorsese
Paul Duncan
www.pocketessentials.com
Scorsese 15/7/04 12:36 pm Page 4
A CIP catalogue record for this book is available from the British
Library.
ISBN: 1 903047 66 8
2 4 6 8 10 9 7 5 3 1
Acknowledgements
Contents
1 Novice 27
3 Out On A Limb 85
11
Scorsese 22/6/04 12:26 pm Page 12
PAU L D U N C A N
12
Scorsese 22/6/04 12:26 pm Page 13
M A RT I N S C O R S E S E
13
Scorsese 22/6/04 12:26 pm Page 14
PAU L D U N C A N
14
Scorsese 22/6/04 12:26 pm Page 15
M A RT I N S C O R S E S E
15
Scorsese 22/6/04 12:26 pm Page 16
PAU L D U N C A N
and Mean Streets. One gets the sense that JR and Charlie’s
emotional and ethical conflicts are ones that Scorsese lived
through and worried about. He continued to use violent
New York settings for Taxi Driver, Raging Bull, After Hours
(1985), GoodFellas, Bringing Out The Dead (1999) and Gangs
Of New York (2002), but it can be argued that all the soci-
eties that Scorsese presents in his films, whether it is the
etiquette of The Age Of Innocence, or the pool hall hustling
of The Colour Of Money, or the rituals of Kundun, all have
rules that the characters follow or break at their peril.
The characters must either accept the society they are
trapped in or escape it. There is never any hint that his
characters can change that society – the society is stronger
than any single person.This is most pointedly expressed in
Gangs Of New York where the climatic fight between Bill
the Butcher and Amsterdam Vallon is rendered insignifi-
cant when seen in the context of the Draft Riots that
overtook New York.
16
Scorsese 22/6/04 12:26 pm Page 17
M A RT I N S C O R S E S E
17
Scorsese 22/6/04 12:26 pm Page 18
PAU L D U N C A N
Analysis
‘There are men whom one hates until there comes a day when,
through a chink in their armour, you see something nailed down
and writhing in torment.’
Gerald Kersh
18
Scorsese 22/6/04 12:26 pm Page 19
M A RT I N S C O R S E S E
19
Scorsese 22/6/04 12:26 pm Page 20
PAU L D U N C A N
20
Scorsese 22/6/04 12:26 pm Page 21
M A RT I N S C O R S E S E
21
Scorsese 22/6/04 12:26 pm Page 22
PAU L D U N C A N
22
Scorsese 22/6/04 12:26 pm Page 23
M A RT I N S C O R S E S E
23
Scorsese 22/6/04 12:26 pm Page 24
PAU L D U N C A N
24
Scorsese 22/6/04 12:26 pm Page 25
M A RT I N S C O R S E S E
ects that fail to ignite the box office and Scorsese then
works on superior Hollywood films like The Color Of
Money or Cape Fear to regain his financial standing.
There was a period in the late 1980s and early 1990s
when critics invariably referred to Martin Scorsese as
America’s greatest living director. Since that time directors
as diverse as Michael Mann, David Lynch, Paul Thomas
Anderson, Steven Spielberg and Steven Soderbergh have
built a substantial body of work. It will be interesting to
see if this will still be the case in twenty years’ time.
25
Scorsese 22/6/04 12:26 pm Page 26
Scorsese 22/6/04 12:26 pm Page 27
1 Novice
27
Scorsese 22/6/04 12:26 pm Page 28
PAU L D U N C A N
Voice-Over: Harry.
28
Scorsese 22/6/04 12:26 pm Page 29
M A RT I N S C O R S E S E
29
Scorsese 22/6/04 12:26 pm Page 30
PAU L D U N C A N
Voice-Over: Murray.
30
Scorsese 22/6/04 12:26 pm Page 31
M A RT I N S C O R S E S E
31
Scorsese 22/6/04 12:26 pm Page 32
PAU L D U N C A N
32
Scorsese 22/6/04 12:26 pm Page 33
M A RT I N S C O R S E S E
33
Scorsese 22/6/04 12:26 pm Page 34
PAU L D U N C A N
34
Scorsese 22/6/04 12:26 pm Page 35
M A RT I N S C O R S E S E
Voice-Over: JR.
Moral: “It was great at the top but boy getting to the top
is murder.”
35
Scorsese 22/6/04 12:26 pm Page 36
PAU L D U N C A N
36
Scorsese 22/6/04 12:26 pm Page 37
M A RT I N S C O R S E S E
37
Scorsese 22/6/04 12:26 pm Page 38
PAU L D U N C A N
38
Scorsese 22/6/04 12:26 pm Page 39
M A RT I N S C O R S E S E
cast and crew worked during the week to earn money for
rent and food and then filmed over the weekends.The first
version ran 58 minutes and didn’t work because it didn’t
have a story, although all the material about the boys
hanging out together was natural. Haig Manoogian put
money towards a second version that was filmed three
years later. Harvey Keitel was the only actor to return from
the first version and he was joined by Zina Bethune as The
Girl, Mike Wadleigh as cameraman and Thelma
Schoonmaker as editor. This version won Best Student
Film at the Chicago Film Festival but couldn’t get a distri-
bution deal. Eventually, a distributor said he’d take it if
they added a nude scene. Keitel flew over to Amsterdam
whilst Scorsese was in Europe and they filmed the very
effective dream sequence.The film got distribution.
39
Scorsese 22/6/04 12:26 pm Page 40
PAU L D U N C A N
40
Scorsese 22/6/04 12:26 pm Page 41
M A RT I N S C O R S E S E
41
Scorsese 22/6/04 12:26 pm Page 42
PAU L D U N C A N
42
Scorsese 22/6/04 12:26 pm Page 43
M A RT I N S C O R S E S E
43
Scorsese 22/6/04 12:26 pm Page 44
PAU L D U N C A N
44
Scorsese 22/6/04 12:26 pm Page 45
M A RT I N S C O R S E S E
45
Scorsese 22/6/04 12:26 pm Page 46
PAU L D U N C A N
46
Scorsese 22/6/04 12:26 pm Page 47
M A RT I N S C O R S E S E
47
Scorsese 22/6/04 12:26 pm Page 48
Scorsese 22/6/04 12:26 pm Page 49
49
Scorsese 22/6/04 12:26 pm Page 50
PAU L D U N C A N
50
Scorsese 22/6/04 12:26 pm Page 51
M A RT I N S C O R S E S E
51
Scorsese 22/6/04 12:26 pm Page 52
PAU L D U N C A N
52
Scorsese 22/6/04 12:26 pm Page 53
M A RT I N S C O R S E S E
53
Scorsese 22/6/04 12:26 pm Page 54
PAU L D U N C A N
54
Scorsese 22/6/04 12:26 pm Page 55
M A RT I N S C O R S E S E
Italianamerican (1974)
Cast: Catherine Scorsese, Charles Scorsese, Martin
Scorsese
55
Scorsese 22/6/04 12:26 pm Page 56
PAU L D U N C A N
56
Scorsese 22/6/04 12:26 pm Page 57
M A RT I N S C O R S E S E
57
Scorsese 22/6/04 12:26 pm Page 58
PAU L D U N C A N
58
Scorsese 22/6/04 12:26 pm Page 59
M A RT I N S C O R S E S E
leads her out of the dining room, through the kitchen, into
the back and then into the ladies’ toilets. The simplicity
and directness of all these shots make them almost invis-
ible and not at all showy. Scorsese likes to do inserts of
hand gestures. We have inserts of Alice’s friends’ hands
clasping hers in condolence, and of Alice doing a ‘chop-
chop’ gesture to tell Tommy to scram. Ben points his hand
at Alice like a gun, which is a prelude of the violence to
come (his job is to pack powder into bullets). There are
similar shots in Mean Streets (Giovanni) and Taxi Driver
(the salesman swiping his hand over the guns). There are
many mirror scenes, partly to overcome the logistical
problem of filming in small motels. Perhaps the shot of
Alice shaving her legs is a homage to The Big Shave? Or
perhaps not.
59
Scorsese 22/6/04 12:26 pm Page 60
PAU L D U N C A N
60
Scorsese 22/6/04 12:26 pm Page 61
M A RT I N S C O R S E S E
when she was there.The film ends with Alice and Tommy
preparing to make a life with David in Tucson, the sign for
the Monterey Dining Room ahead of them in the
distance implying the happy future they had been seeking.
61
Scorsese 22/6/04 12:26 pm Page 62
PAU L D U N C A N
62
Scorsese 22/6/04 12:26 pm Page 63
M A RT I N S C O R S E S E
63
Scorsese 22/6/04 12:26 pm Page 64
PAU L D U N C A N
64
Scorsese 22/6/04 12:26 pm Page 65
M A RT I N S C O R S E S E
65
Scorsese 22/6/04 12:26 pm Page 66
PAU L D U N C A N
(1941) and became best known for his scores for Alfred
Hitchcock films like Psycho (1960), North By Northwest
(1959) and especially Vertigo (1958). Vertigo, a film about
obsession and madness, most closely resembles Taxi Driver,
which was Herrmann’s last film. The horrible thoughts
and actions of James Stewart in Vertigo are made acceptable
because of the romantic/foreboding score. Similarly,
Herrmann evokes the romantic/foreboding side of Travis
Bickle. He thinks he is a knight in shining armour, but he
is instead being devoured by the demons within.
66
Scorsese 22/6/04 12:26 pm Page 67
M A RT I N S C O R S E S E
67
Scorsese 22/6/04 12:26 pm Page 68
PAU L D U N C A N
68
Scorsese 22/6/04 12:26 pm Page 69
M A RT I N S C O R S E S E
69
Scorsese 22/6/04 12:26 pm Page 70
PAU L D U N C A N
70
Scorsese 22/6/04 12:26 pm Page 71
M A RT I N S C O R S E S E
71
Scorsese 22/6/04 12:26 pm Page 72
PAU L D U N C A N
72
Scorsese 22/6/04 12:26 pm Page 73
M A RT I N S C O R S E S E
73
Scorsese 22/6/04 12:26 pm Page 74
PAU L D U N C A N
74
Scorsese 22/6/04 12:26 pm Page 75
M A RT I N S C O R S E S E
PAU L D U N C A N
76
Scorsese 22/6/04 12:26 pm Page 77
M A RT I N S C O R S E S E
77
Scorsese 22/6/04 12:26 pm Page 78
PAU L D U N C A N
78
Scorsese 22/6/04 12:26 pm Page 79
M A RT I N S C O R S E S E
79
Scorsese 22/6/04 12:26 pm Page 80
PAU L D U N C A N
80
Scorsese 22/6/04 12:26 pm Page 81
M A RT I N S C O R S E S E
81
Scorsese 22/6/04 12:26 pm Page 82
PAU L D U N C A N
82
Scorsese 22/6/04 12:26 pm Page 83
M A RT I N S C O R S E S E
Verdict: 5/5
83
Scorsese 22/6/04 12:26 pm Page 84
Scorsese 22/6/04 12:26 pm Page 85
3 Out On A Limb
PAU L D U N C A N
86
Scorsese 22/6/04 12:26 pm Page 87
M A RT I N S C O R S E S E
87
Scorsese 22/6/04 12:26 pm Page 88
PAU L D U N C A N
Verdict: 5/5
88
Scorsese 22/6/04 12:26 pm Page 89
M A RT I N S C O R S E S E
89
Scorsese 22/6/04 12:26 pm Page 90
PAU L D U N C A N
90
Scorsese 22/6/04 12:26 pm Page 91
M A RT I N S C O R S E S E
91
Scorsese 22/6/04 12:26 pm Page 92
PAU L D U N C A N
92
Scorsese 22/6/04 12:26 pm Page 93
M A RT I N S C O R S E S E
93
Scorsese 22/6/04 12:26 pm Page 94
PAU L D U N C A N
94
Scorsese 22/6/04 12:26 pm Page 95
M A RT I N S C O R S E S E
95
Scorsese 22/6/04 12:26 pm Page 96
PAU L D U N C A N
96
Scorsese 22/6/04 12:26 pm Page 97
M A RT I N S C O R S E S E
97
Scorsese 22/6/04 12:26 pm Page 98
PAU L D U N C A N
98
Scorsese 22/6/04 12:26 pm Page 99
M A RT I N S C O R S E S E
Bad (1987)
Cast: Michael Jackson (Darryl), Alberto Alejandrino
(Hispanic Man), Paul Calderon (Dealer), Horace Daily
(Street Bum), Roberta Flack (Darryl’s Mother), Marvin
Foster (Crack Customer), Greg Holtz Jr. (Cowboy),Adam
Nathan (Tip), Jaime Perry (Ski), Pedro Sanchez (Nelson),
Wesley Snipes (Mini Max)
99
Scorsese 22/6/04 12:26 pm Page 100
PAU L D U N C A N
100
Scorsese 22/6/04 12:26 pm Page 101
M A RT I N S C O R S E S E
101
Scorsese 22/6/04 12:26 pm Page 102
PAU L D U N C A N
102
Scorsese 22/6/04 12:26 pm Page 103
M A RT I N S C O R S E S E
103
Scorsese 22/6/04 12:26 pm Page 104
PAU L D U N C A N
104
Scorsese 22/6/04 12:26 pm Page 105
M A RT I N S C O R S E S E
105
Scorsese 22/6/04 12:26 pm Page 106
PAU L D U N C A N
106
Scorsese 22/6/04 12:26 pm Page 107
M A RT I N S C O R S E S E
107
Scorsese 22/6/04 12:26 pm Page 108
PAU L D U N C A N
108
Scorsese 22/6/04 12:26 pm Page 109
M A RT I N S C O R S E S E
Moral: Lionel Dobie: “It’s art. You give it up, you were
never an artist in the first place.You make art because you
have to.”
Seeing: In his SoHo loft, Lionel is alive and does all his
thinking.Whilst in there, the world is full of music (Procul
Harlem, The Rolling Stones, Bob Dylan) and what he
sees/feels. These are represented with quick cutting and
multiple points of view.We are looking at him create, and
he is looking at what he is creating.We don’t really see the
painting until his big show.
Outside the loft, the world is quite normal and sedate,
with Scorsese using relatively normal shooting and editing
techniques. By making this contrast in his filming style, the
loft becomes a magic place that we do not want to leave,
echoing Lionel’s obsession with and addiction to painting.
109
Scorsese 22/6/04 12:26 pm Page 110
PAU L D U N C A N
110
Scorsese 22/6/04 12:26 pm Page 111
M A RT I N S C O R S E S E
New York, New York the artists are unequal in celebrity and
development, which leads to friction and conflict. 3/5
GoodFellas (1990)
Cast: Robert De Niro (James “Jimmy” Conway), Ray
Liotta (Henry Hill), Joe Pesci (Tommy DeVito), Lorraine
Bracco (Karen Hill), Paul Sorvino (Paul “Paulie” Cicero),
Frank Sivero (Frankie Carbone), Tony Darrow (Sonny
Bunz), Mike Starr (Frenchy), Frank Vincent (Billy Batts),
Henny Youngman (Himself), Margo Winkler (Belle
Kessler), Jerry Vale (Himself), Christopher Serrone (Young
Henry Hill), Robbie Vinton (Bobby Vinton), Illeana
Douglas (Rosie), Samuel L Jackson (Stacks Edwards),
Edward McDonald (Himself)
PAU L D U N C A N
112
Scorsese 22/6/04 12:26 pm Page 113
M A RT I N S C O R S E S E
113
Scorsese 22/6/04 12:26 pm Page 114
PAU L D U N C A N
114
Scorsese 22/6/04 12:26 pm Page 115
M A RT I N S C O R S E S E
115
Scorsese 22/6/04 12:26 pm Page 116
PAU L D U N C A N
116
Scorsese 22/6/04 12:26 pm Page 117
117
Scorsese 22/6/04 12:26 pm Page 118
PAU L D U N C A N
118
Scorsese 22/6/04 12:26 pm Page 119
M A RT I N S C O R S E S E
119
Scorsese 22/6/04 12:26 pm Page 120
PAU L D U N C A N
120
Scorsese 22/6/04 12:26 pm Page 121
M A RT I N S C O R S E S E
121
Scorsese 22/6/04 12:26 pm Page 122
PAU L D U N C A N
122
Scorsese 22/6/04 12:26 pm Page 123
M A RT I N S C O R S E S E
123
Scorsese 22/6/04 12:26 pm Page 124
PAU L D U N C A N
124
Scorsese 22/6/04 12:26 pm Page 125
M A RT I N S C O R S E S E
125
Scorsese 22/6/04 12:26 pm Page 126
PAU L D U N C A N
126
Scorsese 22/6/04 12:26 pm Page 127
M A RT I N S C O R S E S E
127
Scorsese 22/6/04 12:26 pm Page 128
PAU L D U N C A N
128
Scorsese 22/6/04 12:26 pm Page 129
M A RT I N S C O R S E S E
Casino (1995)
Cast: Robert De Niro (Sam “Ace” Rothstein), Sharon
Stone (Ginger McKenna-Rothstein), Joe Pesci (Nicholas
“Nicky” Santoro Sr.), James Woods (Lester Diamond), Don
Rickles (Billy Sherbert), Alan King (Andy Stone), Kevin
Pollak (Phillip Green), L Q Jones (Commissioner Pat
Webb), Dick Smothers (Senator), Frank Vincent (Frank
Marino), John Bloom (Don Ward), Pasquale Cajano (Boss
Remo Gaggi), Melissa Prophet (Jennifer Santoro), Bill
Allison (John Nance), Vinny Vella (Artie Piscano), Oscar
Goodman (Himself), Frankie Avalon (Himself), Steve Allen
(Himself), Jayne Meadows (Herself), Jerry Vale (Himself)
129
Scorsese 22/6/04 12:26 pm Page 130
PAU L D U N C A N
130
Scorsese 22/6/04 12:26 pm Page 131
M A RT I N S C O R S E S E
131
Scorsese 22/6/04 12:26 pm Page 132
PAU L D U N C A N
132
Scorsese 22/6/04 12:26 pm Page 133
M A RT I N S C O R S E S E
133
Scorsese 22/6/04 12:26 pm Page 134
PAU L D U N C A N
Verdict: Scorsese has never been shy about his film influ-
ences, but this is interesting because by not including the
Powell & Pressburger films, or the Italian neorealists, I
suddenly realised that Scorsese is living a sort of schizo-
phrenic existence as a film-maker. Is he making his films
134
Scorsese 22/6/04 12:26 pm Page 135
M A RT I N S C O R S E S E
Kundun (1997)
Cast: Tenzin Thuthob Tsarong (Dalai Lama (Adult)),
Gyurme Tethong (Dalai Lama (Aged 10)),Tulku Jamyang
Kunga Tenzin (Dalai Lama (Aged 5)), Tenzin Yeshi
Paichang (Dalai Lama (Aged 2)), Tencho Gyalpo (Dalai
Lama’s Mother),Tsewang Migyur Khangsar (Dalai Lama’s
Father), Geshi Yeshi Gyatso (Lama of Sera), Sonam
Phuntsok (Reting Rimpoche), Lobsang Samten (Master
of the Kitchen), Gyatso Lukhang (Lord Chamberlain),
Jigme Tsarong (Taktra Rimpoche), Tenzin Trinley (Ling
Rimpoche), Robert Lin (Chairman Mao)
135
Scorsese 22/6/04 12:26 pm Page 136
PAU L D U N C A N
136
Scorsese 22/6/04 12:26 pm Page 137
M A RT I N S C O R S E S E
137
Scorsese 22/6/04 12:26 pm Page 138
PAU L D U N C A N
138
Scorsese 22/6/04 12:26 pm Page 139
M A RT I N S C O R S E S E
139
Scorsese 22/6/04 12:26 pm Page 140
PAU L D U N C A N
140
Scorsese 22/6/04 12:26 pm Page 141
M A RT I N S C O R S E S E
141
Scorsese 22/6/04 12:26 pm Page 142
PAU L D U N C A N
Moral: “You have to keep the body going until the brain
and the heart recover enough to go on their own.”
142
Scorsese 22/6/04 12:26 pm Page 143
M A RT I N S C O R S E S E
143
Scorsese 15/7/04 12:34 pm Page 144
PAU L D U N C A N
behind the film and the techniques used, the film does not
take me out of myself like other Scorsese films.Watching
Taxi Driver, I am in Travis Bickle’s world. Similarly for
Raging Bull and GoodFellas and Casino, I am in a place that
Scorsese makes interesting for me. Bringing Out The Dead
does not feel right.There is something missing. 2/5
144
Scorsese 15/7/04 12:34 pm Page 145
M A RT I N S C O R S E S E
145
Scorsese 22/6/04 12:26 pm Page 146
PAU L D U N C A N
146
Scorsese 22/6/04 12:26 pm Page 147
M A RT I N S C O R S E S E
147
Scorsese 22/6/04 12:26 pm Page 148
PAU L D U N C A N
148
Scorsese 22/6/04 12:26 pm Page 149
M A RT I N S C O R S E S E
149
Scorsese 22/6/04 12:26 pm Page 150
PAU L D U N C A N
150
Scorsese 22/6/04 12:26 pm Page 151
M A RT I N S C O R S E S E
151
Scorsese 22/6/04 12:26 pm Page 152
PAU L D U N C A N
152
Scorsese 22/6/04 12:26 pm Page 153
Reference Materials
Books
I just want to mention that probably the best book on
Scorsese so far, the one that actually shows him at work, is
The Scorsese Picture by David Ehrenstein. It was published
in 1992 by Birch Lane Press in America but is not well
known, so I urge you to go to ebay and bookfinder and
amazon to buy a copy.
153
Scorsese 22/6/04 12:26 pm Page 154
PAU L D U N C A N
154
Scorsese 22/6/04 12:27 pm Page 155
M A RT I N S C O R S E S E
Documentaries
Celebrity Profile: Martin Scorsese (1997) 40 mins – Slick
American docu examining life up to Kundun including
interviews with Scorsese, De Niro, Keitel and many
major collaborators.
Scene By Scene With Martin Scorsese (1998) 50 mins – Mark
Cousins interviews a relaxed Scorsese using clips with a
major section on Kundun.
155
Scorsese 22/6/04 12:27 pm Page 156
PAU L D U N C A N
Websites
Scorsese and his films – http://www.scorsesefilms.com/ –
News and links to articles.
Martin Scorsese Information Page – http://members.cox.
net/scorseseinfo/ – Lots of links to articles and inter-
views.
De Niro Scorsese – http://www.deniroscorsese.com/ –
As the name suggests, a tribute site to both creators,
including lots of photos.
156
Scorsese 22/6/04 12:27 pm Page 157