Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
magnetism, the end of the needle which points to the south as having a charge of negative
magnetism .... It must be distinctly understood that this method of regarding the magnets
and the magnetic field is only introduced as affording a convenient method of describing
briefly the phenomena in that field and not as having any significance with respect to the
constitution of magnets or the mechanism by which the forces are produced."
~J. J. Thomson,
Elements of the Mathematical Theory of Electricity and Magnetism, fifth edition,
Cambridge University Press(1921)
Chapter 9
Chapter Overview
Section 9.1 provides a brief introduction to the magnetism of magnets. Section 9.2
summarizes the analogy between magnetic poles and electric charge, and considers
the interaction of two identical magnets and the magnetic properties of magnetic
dipoles. Section 9.3 studies the relationship between magnetic dipole moment ~ and
magnetization M, and considers the practical problems of finding the force required
to pull a magnet off a refrigerator door and the disturbance of a compass reading
due to a distant magnet. Section 9.4 discusses the two types of magnetic sources and
shows how to obtain the magnetic field within a magnet. Section 9.5 distinguishes the
types of magnetic materials, according to their differing responses in an external field.
Section 9.6 discusses ferromagnets, in particular, and the magnetization process, as
described by hysteresis loops. Section 9.7 considers the demagnetization field, which
is of practical importance for ferromagnets. Section 9.8 applies the results for the
demagnetization field to analyze particle-deflection experiments. These show that
magnets behave as if they contained microscopic current sources~as if the electrons
themselves contain tiny electric currents~rather than magnetic poles. Section 9.9 dis-
cusses magnetic oscillations, both for large magnets (e.g., compass needles) and small
magnets (e.g., nuclei); the latter applies to nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR), the ba-
sis of the powerful diagnostic called magnetic resonance imaging (MRI). Section 9.10
considers why only some materials are magnets, why some magnets are "hard" and
some are "soft," and how the world's best hard magnets are designed, i
9.1 Introduction
Consider a magnet that attaches a note to a refrigerator door. The magnet, be-
cause it retains its magnetic properties both in isolation and in the presence of
other magnets, is known as permanent, or hard. The refrigerator door, because
it responds strongly to the magnetism of the bar magnet, but does not retain its
magnetic properties in isolation, is known as a soft magnet. Ordinary iron nails
and paper clips are other examples of soft magnets.
384
9.1 Introduction 385
Greenwich Polaraxis
meridian Longitude Declinationangle
Vertical
itude
ComWPaSS
~~N ~ Dipangle
. I
Horiz tal
ass
Equator S
(a) (b) (c)
Figure 9.1 The earth's magnetic field. (a) Angles defining longitude and latitude.
(b) Declination angle in local plane of the earth. (c) Dip angle relative to the
local vertical.
Lodestone (the mineral magnetite, Fe3 04) was the first material found to dis-
play what we would call magnetic properties. Taking advantage of its permanent
magnetism, it was used in China over 2000 years ago as a navigational aid. It has
been used for over 1000 years in the form of compass needles that orient along
the earth's magnetic field.
A characteristic value for the magnitude of the earth's magnetic field (which
includes both the horizontal and vertical components) is 0.5 x 10 -4 tesla (T).
The SI unit for the magnetic field, the tesla = T = N/A-m, is named after Nikola
Tesla, who during the 1880s developed the first ac (alternating current) motor.
In cgs-emu units, the unit of magnetic field is the gauss (G), where 1 G - 10 -4 T.
within a large vat of water. He also gave a rule for the interaction of the poles
of two different magnets: opposite poles attract. Surprising to moderns, there was
no corresponding statement that like poles repel: rather, according to Peregrinus
they only seem to repel:
... the Northern part in a stone attracts the Southern part in another stone,
and the Southern the Northern. But if you do the opposite, namely, bring the
Northern part toward the Northern, the stone which you are carrying in your
hand will seem to repel the floating stone, and if you apply the Southern part
to the Southern, the same will happen. The reason is that the Northern part
feels the Southern, which makes it seem to repel the Northern; of this there
is a token in the fact that the Northern part will in the end join itself to the
Southern.
Although true magnetic poles have not been observed in any laboratory, they are pre-
sented for two reasons. First, the formalism of the magnetism of magnetic poles, which
is a reprise of the electricity of electric charge, is much simpler than the formalism of
the magnetism of electric currents. (For that reason, in practice the magnetic pole for-
malism is employed to design both large magnets used in magnetic resonance imaging
and in particle accelerators, and the microscopic magnetic particles used in magnetic
recording tape and in computer hard drives.) Second, the next two chapters, which
obtain all the laws of the magnetism of electric currents, begin with the magnetic pole
formalism and the equivalence between a magnet and a current loop (when both are
viewed from a distance).
can close on themselves. Figure 5.18 illustrates an electric field and a circuit for
which there is a net electric circulation.
Only by performing experiments that actually probe the interior of a magnet
can we distinguish between the two types of source; the experiments favor the
electric current viewpoint. Nevertheless, as long as we are outside a magnet, we
cannot tell whether it is a flux source with zero net magnetic charge or a current
source. Therefore it is legitimate to treat the exterior of the magnet using the
formalism of magnetic poles, which has a similar structure to the already studied
formalism of electric charges.
The present chapter considers the magnetism of magnets as if it is due to
magnetic poles, with an inverse square law like that of electricity. Chapters 10
and 11 discuss the magnetism of magnets as if it is due to electric currents, which
requires a more complex formalism.
space. With this set of units, Table 9.1 summarizes the basic correspondences
between electric and magnetic poles.
A literal analogy between electricity and magnetism would, by analogy to
Chapter 1, consider conservation of magnetic charge and provide examples
where magnetic charge is transferred between two objects but overall is con-
served. However, because each magnet has zero net magnetic charge, there can
be no such transfer of magnetic charge between magnets. The remainder of this
section and the next section applies the analogy between electricity and mag-
netism to magnetic charge, magnetic force, and magnetic field.
388 Chapter 9 ~ The Magnetism of Magnets
Example 9.1 shows that the unit of magnetic pole strength is A-m.
Note: For a magnet, the magnetic poles typically are not concentrated only
at the ends; we can verify this by sprinkling iron filings onto a piece of paper that
covers the magnet. Nevertheless, for simplicity, we will make this idealization.
R 1 = r-r 1
~~ Origin
S= l =N N• l =S
-qm qm qm --qm
an equation for estimating the force between the magnets when they are
collinear, with two like poles so close that they provide the dominant force,
but farther away than d - ~ See Figure 9.3. (b) For l - 20 cm - 0.2 m, and
a square cross-section of side a - ~ 7 ~ _ 0.5 cm - 0.005 m, let IFI - 0.34 x
10 -1 N when r = 0.04 m. Estimate qm.
Solution: (a) If the separation r between the two nearest poles greatly exceeds the
width of the poles, then it is a good approximation to consider only the interaction
between these poles, treated as points. Hence, from (9.1), with qml = qm,
km(qm) 2
IFI ~ r-------T---. (equal strength poles interacting) (9.2)
(b) Solution of (9.2) yields q~ - r(I/~l/km) ]/2 - 23.3 A-m. Including the forces
between the other poles (two attractive interactions at separation r + l ~ l, and
a repulsive interaction at separation r + 2I ~ 2l) would give a more accurate
estimate for qm.
ii iiili!!iiii iiiiiiiiliiiiiiiliiii!iiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiii:!ii!iiii!iiiiiii~iiiliilliiiii!!iiiiiiiiiiliiliiiiiiiiii!iiiiiiiii!!iiiiiiiliilii!iiiii!iiiii!ilii!iiilii!iiliiiiliiiiiliiiiii!iliiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiii!iiiii!iiiiiiiiiiii!ii!iiii!i!i!iiiliiiii!!!ii!ii!iiiiiiiii:2iiiii:ii!i!iiiiiiiii!i!iiiiiiiiiiii
390 Chapter 9 ~ The Magnetism of Magnets
See Figure 9.2. As for the electric field/~, the magnetic field B points away from
positive (north) poles, and toward negative (south) poles. See Figure 9.4.
BEh
2qm qm d
1 ~ I ~ ~,~
Bmag
(a) Co)
Figure 9.5 (a) Compass needle along axis of bar
magnet. (b) Decomposition of total magnetic
field acting on the compass needle into its
components due to the earth and due to the bar
magnet. Effect of a bar magnet on the local
magnetic field. Without the bar magnet, the
needle would point toward the top of the page.
9.2 Magnetic Charge (Poles) 391
3~. Since r - 20.5 cm, (9.5) gives Bmag - 0.541 x 10 -5 T. The needle aligns along
the direction of the net magnetic field (see Figure 9.5b). Hence this field will
cause the needle to rotate from 3~toward ~ by an angle ~) satisfying
tan~) = Bmag. (9.6)
BEh
Taking BEh = 5.0 • 10-5 T, this gives tan~) -0.116, corresponding to an an-
gular deflection of 6.7 ~ In centuries past, no wonder sailors were warned to
keep magnets and iron from the vicinity of the navigator's compass. Today,
global navigation systems employing satellites have made the navigator's com-
pass obsolete; however, magnets don't stop responding if the satellites stop
functioning.
iiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiii!iiiiiiiiiiiiiiii!iiiiiiiiiii!iii!i!!iiiiii!!!!ii!iiiii!i
! i!!ii!iii iiiiii!!iiii!iiiii
!i iiiiii!iiiiiiiiiiiiiiiii
The vector # points from the negative to the positive pole. It has units of A-m 2.
See Figure 9.6(a). Some field lines for it are drawn in Figure 9.6(b).
Consider (9.5) when r >> l, so r/(r 2 - 12/4)2~ r / r 4 = 1/r 3. Then, using
(9.7), Equation (9.5) becomes
2km,
Bmag ~ r3 9 (on axis) (9.8)
The field of a magnetic dipole falls off with distance as r -3, just as for an electric
dipole [compare (3.12)]. Applied to Example 9.3, where q m - 23.3 A-m and
l = 1 cm, (9.7) yields ~ t - 0.233 A-m 2. With r - 20.5 cm, (9.8) then yields
5.41 • 10 -6 T, in three-decimal place agreement with the exact calculation of
Example 9.3.
dipole moment per unit volume is called the magnetization 2(/1, where
...........................................................................................................................................................................................................................
~ ..............~...............................................................i........................................................................................................................
ii i iii!iii i!i!iiiili i!i iii i i iiili!!iiiiiiiiiiiiii!!iiiiiii!iiiiiiiiiiiiii!ili
iiiiiiiiiiiii!i!iiiiii!!
2V/has units of magnetic pole strength per unit area, or N/(T-m 2) - A/m. Because
M is independent of the volume of the system, for many purposes it is a more
fundamental quantity than ~.
# - M V - MAI. (9.10)
# MV
= MA. (9.11)
qm-T- l
Hence the charge densities on the surfaces are -]-(7 m - +qm/A~ Use of (9.11) then
yields
iS;iJiiJjiY;ii!2iJiiJ;iili;iii!ii!ii!~i;!~iii~i!i~ii
i!ii!;i ~iiii;!iiii!ii;i@i~ !l!~!~i~iiiiiii~i!~i~iil iiiiiii!i!iiill !iiii ~i ~lli
iiii!ii!!iiii':iiiiiiiiiiiiiil
iiiiii!iii!iiiiiii!iiiiiiiii!iiiiiiiiiiiii!iiiiiii@i!iiiiiiiiiiii!iiiiii!i!iiiiiiii!iiiiiiiii!iiii!iiiii!iii
iiiiii!ii!iiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiii
This result can be stated more generally: at a surface with outward normal fi,
the magnetic surface charge density Crmis related to the magnetization 2~/at that
surface by
om -- M . ft. (9.12')
For a bar magnet, 2V/usually is along its axis. Since the normal t~ to a side of a
magnet is perpendicular to the axis, there usually is no magnetic charge along
the sides of a bar magnet.
~ From m a g n e t imoment
c to magnetization
Consider the bar magnets of Example 9.1 (qm = 23.3 A-m, A 0.25 x =
I B I - 2~rkmM. (9.14)
is more than 10,000 times the earth's magnetic field. Note that, by (9.4), the
magnetic field of the distant pole of this bar magnet is kmqm/r 2 - k m ~ m A / l 2 =
2.49 • 10 -4 T, which adds a contribution much smaller than that due to the near
pole, but about five times that of the earth.
an attraction between the permanent magnet and the refrigerator. (The dominant
effect arises from the near end of the magnet and its image.) However, if you look
inside the refrigerator there will be, perhaps, a tuna sandwich, but certainly no
image magnet. This attraction is similar to what happens with the amber effect,
discussed in Section 1.2; a more precise analogy is to a small electric charge that
is brought up to a large sheet of electrical conductor.
Let the magnet have its N pole, a flat surface of area A, against the refrigerator.
Then there is an image magnet (S pole) just against the magnet; for Figure 9.8,
consider that the gap between the actual N pole and the image S pole is very
small. This geometry is just like that for two nearby capacitor plates. (Magnetic
poles can't move, so contact can't cause discharge.) Neglecting edge effects, the
magnetic field acting on the image pole, due to the actual magnet, is given by
(9.14). Use of (9.3), (9.12), and (9.14) yields
- s , ~ t 0 - 4 z r k m - 4 Z r x 10 - 7 A2.
N (free space) (9.16)
For B, the rulesgiven in Table 9.1 hold only outside a magnet. However, on
replacing B by/~0H, these rules hold for #0H both inside and outside a magnet.
As we will see shortly, B and/7/, within a magnet, have a more complex rela-
tionship than (9.16).
When physicists say "magnetic field," they usually mean B, which technically
is called the magnetic induction. To avoid this possible ambiguity, we sometimes
employ the usage magnetic B field or simply B field, and magnetic/7/field or
simply H field.
By analogy to Gauss's law relating the flux of/~ through a closed surface to
the electric charge enclosed by that surface, or
9 ~ - f E. ~ d A - 42rkQ~, (9.17)
f _,
#oH. ~ d A - 4rrkmQm,enc, or ~n -- f f-t. ~dA-Qm,enc. (9.18)
With Bearth ,~ 0.5 x 10-4 T, by (9.16), we have Heart h ~ 39.8 A/m. Sometimes the unit
for H is given as A-turns/m. The dimensionless unit "turns" is appended to distinguish
the SI unit for the magnetic H field from that of the SI unit for the magnetization, which
is A/m. "Turns" arises because, as shown in Chapter 11, current-carrying coils wound
with many turns of wire also can produce a magnetic H field (and a magnetic/~ field).
9.4 Inside a Magnet There Really Are No Poles 397
For electrostatics and for permanent magnets, there is zero circulation in the
sense that, on integrating around a closed path with path element dg = ~ds,
Thus E due to static charges, and/7/for permanent magnets, have flux sources
but no circulation sources. Chapter 11 shows that electric currents serve as circu-
lation sources for B and/7/. Chapter 12 shows that time-varying B-fields serve
as circulation sources for E.
-.+
Since there are no isolated magnetic poles,/3 cannot have flux as its source, so
~B - 0 for all closed surfaces. Thus, whatever flux enters one part of a closed
surface, the same amount must leave another part of it. Consider a pancake-
shaped Gaussian surface (a "pillbox") enclosing a magnet face, as in Figure 9.10,
with outward normal ft. By this argument, the normal component of B, o r Bn -
-+
B. fi, must be continuous across the face. We now use this continuity of Bu to
determine B within the magnet.
Consider a bar magnet so long that near one end we can obtain the field/7/
by considering only the magnetic charge at that end. From (9.13) and (9.16),
/ , o H - 2srk~crm just outside this "sheet" of magnetic charge, with the direction
of/7/changing as we go from inside to outside the magnet. See Figure 9.11 (a).
Thus, at its poles there is a discontinuity in #0/q. fi (from 2rckmamto -2Jrkmcrm).
Hence #o(Hout - Hin) has magnitude 4zrkm~m - 4~rk~M - #0M. Since we want
.-+ _+ -~
B i n - Bout at the interfaces, this suggests the following definition for B. With
.-+
H obtained, both inside and outside the magnet, by the rules of Table 9.1 in
Section 9.3 (with/3 -+ #0f/), and with 2(4 known, we set
In free space, where 2(4-6, (9.20) reduces to (9.16). In general, (9.20) also
B are depicted.
398 Chapter 9 ~ The Magnetism of Magnets
M - x H. (9.22)
Here X ("chi") is called the magnetic susceptibility. Since 2(4 and/7/have the
same units, x is a dimensionless quantity. It is material dependent and temper-
ature dependent. For paramagnets X > 0, and for diamagnets x < 0. In small
fields, (9.22) also holds for soft ferromagnets (x > 0) and for perfect diamagnets
(x = -1), provided that account is taken of the demagnetization field produced
by the material itself, as discussed in Section 9.7.
When (9.22) holds, Equation (9.20) can be rewritten as
-+ ..+ -+ .-+ --~ -+
for the permeability l* and the relative permeability #r. Permeability has the same
symbol as the magnetic moment, so beware of the possibilities of notational
confusion.
For low to moderate fields, (9.22) also holds for soft ferromagnets (such as
used in transformers). However, hard ferromagnets, and soft ferromagnets in
large fields, are not described by (9.22).
Ferromagnetic Materials
As already indicated, there are two classes of ferromagnetic materials.
after the electric current is turned off, but they are not very good permanent
magnets. The names soft and hard arose because it is easier to magnetize iron
(which is relatively malleable, or soft) than the less malleable, or hard, iron alloys.
tl
M t t
M M
$
Mri 'iMs
H--~
r
Figure 9.15 Hysteresis loops for various types of magnetic materials. (a) A magnet
that can be easily magnetized and tends to retain its magnetism, but not perfectly.
(b) A hard magnet, which retains its magnetism until the demagnetization field is
reached. (c) A soft magnet, which magnetizes and demagnetizes easily. (Even the last
kind of magnet can show a certain amount of hysteresis, wherein the magnetization is
not a single-valued function of the applied field. However, there is no hysteresis on
the scale of this figure.)
402 Chapter 9 [] The Magnetism of Magnets
Wilhelm Weber, in the mid-19th century, considered that the fundamental unit of mag-
netism is something like an indivisible atomic magnet; normally, the positive pole of one
atomic magnet cancels the negative pole of an adjacent magnet, leaving only poles at
the ends of the magnet. A significant advantage of this picture is that it explains why
the magnetization of magnets saturates. The magnetic poles on a magnet can appear
to redistribute when subjected to external magnetic fields (or when heated nonuni-
formly). We interpret this in terms of a rearrangement of the atomic magnets rather
than a motion of true magnetic poles within the magnet. The characteristic magnetic
moment of an atomic magnet is the Bohr rnagneton #B = eh/4rrrne = 9.27 x 1 0 .24
A - m 2. Here h = 6.63 x 1 0 -34 J-s is Planck's constant, and m e - 9.11 x 1 0 -31 kg is
the electron mass. One /~B per cube 2 x 10 -1~ m on a side gives a magnetization
M = 9.27 x 1 0 -24 A-m2/8 x 1 0 .30 m 3 - - 1.16 x 1 0 6 A/m, which is very close to the
saturation magnetization of common magnets.
i i i ~i ~i ~
i~
i~
i i~i!~il!~i~i?i~i i!i!ii i~ili iil ii~i~i!~ii~~i~i~ii~!~i?i!i!iiii~i!~i~i!i~!i!i~i~i~i~ii~ii~i!i!~!i~i~i
Anisotropic barium ferrite 37.0 x 105 20.0 x 105
NEO (Nd2Fe14B) 10.3 x 105 16.0 x 105
Alnico V 9.95 x 10s 4.4 x 10 4
Carbon steel 8.0 x 10s 4.0 x 103
y-Fe203 3.7 x 105 2.4 x 104
The demagnetization field is important only for materials exhibiting strong mag-
netic properties, because it is proportional to the magnetization. It is negligible
for paramagnets and diamagnets.
For a magnet with remanence, F-td~magacts even without an externally applied
magnetic field. One reason magnets tend to lose their magnetization with time
is this demagnetization field. To avoid such demagnetization fields, and thus
to retain (i.e., "keep") the magnetization, keeper magnets are employed, as in
Figure 9.14.
For uniformly magnetized, ellipsoidally shaped magnets, which include
spheres, pancakelike objects, and cigar-shaped objects, Hdemagis uniform within
the magnet. For other shapes, /2/dem~gis nonuniform.
T--~
404 Chapter 9 s The Magnetism of Magnets
For a needle-shaped magnet magnetized along its axis, the magnetization at the
surface is nearly perpendicular to the surface normal (except perhaps in the
tiny region at the end of the needle), so (7 m - - M . / ~ ~-~ O. See Figure 9.17 (a). For
a toroidal magnet magnetized tangentially, (7 m - - 2~// 9 / ~ - - ~ 0 exactly. See Figure
9.17(b). Since ~m -- O,there is no flux source for/2/,_ so H - O, both inside and
outside. Since B - #0H outside the magnet,/~ - H - 13outside. Clearly,
in this case. However, inside the magnet B -/~02~ # 6. Although the normal
component of B is continuous (= 0), its tangential component is not continuous,
on crossing from the interior (where B = # 0 ~ to the exterior (where/~ = ()).
From the hysteresis loop for a toroidal magnet, where Hd~ag = 0, we can
deduce the hysteresis loop for magnets of other shapes by including the appro-
priate demagnetization field. Keeper magnets of soft iron, as in Figure 9.14, are
often placed across the poles of horseshoe magnets to direct the magnetic flux
of one pole directly to the other, thus making the combination behave like a
toroidal magnet, with small demagnetization field.
For shapes other than those discussed, the demagnetization field is nonzero.
We now c o n s i d e r f]demagfor the shape that gives the largest demagnetization
field.
By (9.12'), for a slab magnetized uniformly along its normal, the surface charge
densities are Crm - - +M. See Figure 9.18. Now recall that, when edge effects are
neglected, the electric field E within a capacitor of charge density -t-~ on its
plates has magnitude 47rk~. Likewise,/x0H within a magnetic slab has magni-
tude 4Jrkmcr m - 4zrkmM-/x0M. This gives I/:/I - IMI. Since H points from the
positive to the negative side--that is, opposite to M--here we h a v e / 2 / _ -2(//.
9.7 Demagnetization Field Ftdem~g 405
D e m a g and
n eslabs--in
t i z aantapplied
i o nforfieldsoft magnets--needles
fields
Consider the soft magnetic material known as mu metal, which is used for
magnetic shielding. Determine the effect of the demagnetization field on
the magnetization of a mu metal in the earth's magnetic field Bearth ~ 0.5 •
10 -4 T. Consider both the thin needle and the thin slab geometries.
Solution: We use material constants from Table 9.2. With the field and mag-
netization along the axis of a needle-shaped sample, for which Hdemag ~ O, we
have H = Next - He~th = 39.8 A/m. Hence, if (9.22) holds, the magnetization
406 Chapter 9 u The Magnetism of Magnets
How We K n o w B Is Truly F u n d a m e n t a l
In the next chapter, we will learn that the force/~ on a panicle of charge q as it
moves with velocity ~ through a region of magnetic field B is
F - qfi x B. (9.28)
It is not clear t h a t / ~ , rather than #0/~, should be used in this equation~ The
toroid and slab geometries suggest two ways to distinguish between how B and
H cause the deflection of charged particles"
Chapter 12 will show that/3 (and hence, not/2/) also determines the elec-
tromotive force associated with Faraday's law. The magnetic induction/~ is the
quantity of true fundamental significance.
To have clean particle tracks in the deflection experiments described earlier, the electri-
cally charged muons (particles similar to electrons, but about 200 times more massive)
are used. This is because their strongest interactions with other particles occur via elec-
tromagnetism, and because when they do interact, the momentum transfer is small
since they are mass-mismatched with both the much lighter electrons and the much
heavier nuclei.
Magnetic Oscillations
Just as the torque on an electric dipole moment } in an electric field E is given
by ~ - } x bT, so the torque on a magnetic dipole moment fi in a magnetic field
B is given by
i~i{~i~:~i~ii~iSi:~~i:~i:~i:i~iiiiiii2ii:i:~i:i:iiil
:!i~i:i:ii:ii:iii:ii::ii:i~i:iii:ii:iii~ii:i:~i~ii:i~i:i~ii:i:ii:ii:ii~:ai:i~:i:i:i:i:ii:ii:i:i:i~{i
~i{:i:ii:i:ii:i:ii:i:!i:~i:il:!i:~i:i:i!::Ii;:!i:i:i:i:{:i!:i~:!ii:ii{:~i~i:{i:ii~:i:i{:i:i:i~!i~i:i:~:!i:ii:@
Ji!i!:i:i{i:~i:~i:i!i~:i~ii:~i~i~i:i{:~i~:!i:i{i{i~ii!i@
i!:i:i:~i:i{i:i:i:i:ii:i:~ii~!:~{~i:i~!i{i:{i:!i:~i{:i!i:i!:i!~i:i~i!i:~ii:i:~i!{~i~i!i~i~i:i:i!~ii{i:i!:i~i:
Thus
momentum L"
dL
= g. (9.31)
dt
Equations (9.29) and (9.31) can be used to explain the operation of acompass
needle, leading to a torque that drives the magnet to orient/~ along B, and to
have oscillations about that equilibrium. They also can be used to explain the
oscillations around equilibrium of tiny electronic and nuclear magnets; these can
be observed using the techniques of electron spin resonance (ESR) and nuclear
408 Chapter 9 ~ The Magnetism of Magnets
magnetic resonance (NMR). The word spin refers to angular momentum that
appears to be intrinsic to the object. It is to be distinguished from any orbital
angular motion that arises because the object is in an orbital (either an electron
about the atom or a nucleon about the nucleus). Associated with spin (a vector) is
a magnetic moment (also a vector). For simplicity, we will use L for all these
types of angular momentum.
r -- -#B6~. (9.32)
For a macroscopic object of moment of inertia I about its z-axis, the angular
momentum component L~ is given by
d~
Lz- Ioo~- I dt" (macroscopic object) (9.33)
dLz d28
dt = I ~ - ~. (9.34)
d20
I dt--~ = -#BO. (macroscopic magnet) (9.35)
This is just like the harmonic oscillator equation, with (x, K, m) ~ (0, ~B, I).
Hence the angle 0 oscillates. Instead of the harmonic oscillator frequency ~0 =
~/K/m, here we have
~ n
c o - ~/#-Y. (9.36)
With both NMR and ESR, the intensity of the absorption of electromagnetic energy at
the resonance frequency is proportional to the number of absorbing nuclei. Moreover,
the frequency of absorption can depend on magnetic fields produced by the local
environment. Thus, these methods may be used as diagnostics for the presence of, and
the study of the local environments of, various atoms, ions, and nuclei. NMR is the
basis for the powerful medical diagnostic technique of magnetic resonance imaging
(MRI). The intensity of absorption in a known magnetic field gradient provides a local
measure of the density of different types of nuclei. Modern computers (and, in particular,
powerful desktop workstations and personal computers) make it possible to analyze a
wealth of data taken in many orientations, and then to deduce the position in the body
where the energy was absorbed.
410 Chapter 9 m The Magnetism of Magnets
where F, the gyromagnetic ratio, depends upon the atom or nucleus. Specif-
ically, Yelectron--1.759 • 1011 s-iT -1 and ~proton- 2.675 x 108 s-iT -1. As a
consequence of their lower ly t, protons oscillate (resonate) at much lower fre-
quencies than do electrons.
We will solve (9.29) and (9.31) to obtain the resonance frequency of a given
magnetic moment. Unlike the case for the compass needle, for an atom or nucleus
the angular momentum f, has a fixed magnitude. Combining (9.31), (9.29), and
(9.3 7) gives
d~
d t = y L x B. (microscopic magnet) (9.38)
This is very different from (9.35), and it has a very different solution. To be
specific, let B point along ~. Then, rather than an oscillation (in which only Lx
might participate), there is a precession (in which Lx and Ly participate equally).
See Figure 9.20(b).
Since the vector cross-product is perpendicular to both vectors, the right-
hand side of (9.38) is perpendicular to both B and L, so
- dL - dL
L . dt = O, B " -d-~ - O. (9.39)
dill 2 d(L. L) ds
dt = dt = 2L.-d-/- = 0 (9.40)
has fixed magnitude If,• - v/Lx2 + L 2. Thus, as stated previously, we may write
dLx
= y(LyBz- LzBy) = y L y B . (9.44)
dt
9.9 Magnetic Oscillations 411
d4)
---L• sin 0 = (Y B)L• sin O- (9.45)
dt
Thus
dO
dt= -yB, (9.46)
which can also be obtained from the y-component of (9.38). The solution of
(9.46) is
where
o) = y B (9.48)
o) yB
f- 2zr = 2Jr" (9.49)
~ NMRforMRI
Consider hydrogen in water. Find the NMR resonance frequency for B = 1 T.
Solution: By (9.48), the protons absorb energy at the frequency f = y B/27c =
(2.675 • 108)(1)/2zr = 42.6 MHz. This is somewhat below the FM band, which
begins around 88 MHz.
Here are some technical aspects of NMR and ESR. For NMR: (1) it is easy
to build tunable measuring devices in this frequency range; (2) there are many
types of nuclei with distinct magnetic moments; and (3) the resonances are
very sharply defined in frequency. On the other hand, for ESR: (1) the resonant
frequencies can be inconveniently high for measurement devices; (2) there is
only one type of electron and not many radically different environments for it;
and (3) different ESR resonances are not as sharply defined in frequency. All
these factors lead to the choice of NMR over ESR for use in MRI.
Magnetic resonance experiments on electron and nuclear spins within mate-
rials provide evidence that, in the torque law of (9.29), it is B - #o(/7/+ 2~,
rather than the/,o/2/due to magnetic poles, that applies.
412 Chapter 9 a The Magnetism of Magnets
wall
The answer is that the electrostatic energy of electron orbitals can sometimes
be lowered if the electron magnetic moments develop a preferential ordering
relative to one another. This is associated with the fact that, by what is called the
Pauli principle, no two electrons can occupy the same orbital, unless they have
opposite intrinsic~or spin--angular momentum. In some cases, there is a pref-
erence for the electron magnetic moments to counteralign, leading to what are
called antiferromagnets. Antiferromagnets are poor magnets, but they are inter-
esting just the same, with their own magnetic resonances. The tendency of many
materials to develop magnetic order is so weak that it is easily overwhelmed by
thermal agitation of the atomic magnets; magnetic order occurs only at low tem-
peratures. Many complex types of magnetic order exist, one of which is glasslike:
so-called spin-glasses, with local magnetic order that is random to the eye.
9.10 Permanent Magnets 413
In technical terms, the orientation of the orbitals relative to the crystal is attributed to
the crystal field energy; the orientation of the magnetic moments relative to the orbitals
is attributed to the spin-orbit energy, and the overall orientation of the magnetization
relative to the crystal is attributed to the magnetic anisotropy energy.
Problems
9 - 2 . 1 Two 5 cm long, 2-mm-by-2-mm magnets the inverse cube of the distance. Show how such an
are uniformly magnetized. One will lift twice as inverse cube law might be obtained by measuring
much iron as the other. When placed on the same the force on the pole of one long magnet due to
axis at 3 cm nearest distance, as in Figure 9.3, another short magnet.
their force of attraction is 0.04 N. Estimate their
pole strengths. Note: As shown in Example 9.6, the 9 - 2 . 8 In the astatic balance, two thin magnetic
amount of iron a magnet can lift is proportional to needles of equal moment are mounted on a fiber
the square of its pole strength. with their moments normal to the fiber axis. See
Figure 9.23. The upper needle (in the z = a plane)
9 - 2 . 2 For 1/31 = 0.5 T in a region of space, the has its magnetic moment along 5, and the lower
force is 0.75 N on a single pole qm of a long magnet needle (in the z = 0 plane) has its magnetic moment
(l = 10 cm). (a) Find qm. (b) Find the field due to along -)~. (a) Will there be a net torque in a uniform
the magnet 5 cm along its perpendicular bisector. field (such as that of the earth)? (b) Let a nonuni-
form field B be applied along the y-direction, with
9-2.3 A small magnet, collinear with the orienta- the applied field larger for the needle in the z - a
tion of a compass needle, is moved toward the com- plane. How will the astatic balance twist?
pass needle. At 20 cm, the compass needle switches
direction. If the horizontal component of the earth's
field is 0.41 G, find the moment of the magnet. /Rotation axis
9-2.11 The magnetic line poles )~ and - - ~ ' m 9-4.2 Consider a nonuniformly heated bar mag-
are parallel to z, intersecting the z = 0 plane at net of length l and cross-sectional area A, magne-
()co, 0) and ()co, 1), respectively. Thus the mag- tized along its axis, with M = M1 at its north pole,
netic dipole moment is parallel to the y-axis. With and M = M2 < M1 at its south pole. Since the mag-
finite dipole moment per unit length ~ (where netic charges on the ends do not sum to zero, there
I~1 = Xml), but l -+ 0, show that IB = 2km[-~ + must be some bulk magnetic charge. (a) Assuming
2(~. ~)t~]/r 2, where r is the nearest distance to the that the magnetic charge density is uniform, find
dipole lines. its magnitude. (b) Find the field along the axis at a
distance 4l from its north pole, under the assump-
....%.
.. ~........ 9 - 2 . 1 2 Consider a dipole sheet, with dipole tion that the magnet is very narrow, so that the bulk
......iii!ii!ii!i~:
..............moment
.. per unit area d # / d A = M/0. To ob- magnetic charge can be thought of as a line charge.
tain such a sheet, in the previous problem let (c) Compare that field with the field at the same
-+ d ~ - (d#/dA)~dx, and integrate on x from position if the magnet had a uniform magnetiza-
- ~ to 0. For an observer at ()co, yo), show that tion M~.
B = -[2k~Mlo/ro](~ x t~0), where r 0 = (%2 + y2)
and t~0 = ~sin~)0 + )~cos~)0 points fro
of the dipole sheet to the observer.
mJ the edge
9-5.1 How would you use a soft magnet to focus
the magnetic field of a permanent magnet?
9 - 5 . 2 How would you use a soft magnet to create
9 - 3 . 1 Consider a uniformly magnetized magnet a region of weakened magnetic field?
with M = 3.2 x 105 A/m, l = 5 cm, and A =
16 mm 2. It is magnetized along its axis. (a) Find 9 - 5 . 3 Relate field expulsion and magnetic repul-
qm, ~m, and #. (b) Estimate the field on the axis at sion; field concentration and magnetic attraction.
0.1 cm, 2 cm, and 10 cm from the north pole. (See Figures 9.12 and 9.13.)
9 - 3 . 2 Two identical magnets of length l, cross- 9 - 5 . 4 In scalar form, for SI units we have B =
section A (where ~ ( ( l ) , magnetization M, and # 0 ( H + M), whereas for cgs-emu units we have
mass m are placed in a tube, one above the other, B = H + 4 z ~ M . The SI units are tesla (T) for
with like poles near each other. (a) If the magnets B, ampere-turn/meter (A-turn/m) for H, and
are very strong, find the value of the separation s ampere/m (A/m) for M. The cgs-emu units are
to suspend the upper one against gravity. (b) If the gauss (G) for B, where 1 T = 1 0 4 G , oersted
magnets are weak, estimate the minimum magne- (Oe) for H, and "magnetic moment unit"/cm 3, or
tization needed to suspend the upper one against mmu/cm 3 for M. (a) By taking M = 0, show that
gravity. 1 A-turn/m = 4z~ x 10 - 3 0 e . (b) By taking H = 0,
show that 1 A/m = 10 -3 mmu/cm 3. (c) Show
9 - 3 . 3 The lifting strength of a long magnet with that Xemu- M / H gives values 1/4Jr as large as in
3 cm 2 cross-section is 30 N. Find its magnetization. SI units.
9 - 3 . 4 The magnetization of a long magnet with 9 - 5 . 5 A soft magnetic material has M =
8.4 cm 2 cross-section is M = 2.2 x 10 s A/re. Find 2500 A/m in a field B - 0.005 T. (a) Find the
its lifting strength. SI values for H and x. (b) Find the cgs-emu values
for M, B, H, and X. Hint: See Problem 9-5.4.
9 - 3 . 5 Consider a long bar magnet of magnetiza-
tion M, length l, and square cross-section (with side 9 - 5 . 6 For a small applied magnetic field, sketch
a (< t). It is oriented normal to a large sheet of soft M versus H for a paramagnet, a diamagnet, a soft
magnetic material (e.g., a refrigerator), with its near ferromagnet, and a perfect diamagnet.
pole a distance r from the sheet. Find the lead-
ing dependence on r of the force of attraction for
9-6.1 A magnet has Ms = 0.84 x 106 A/m and
(a) r (( a, (b) a << r << l, (c) l (< r. Mr - 0.53 x 103 A/m. Would this make a good per-
manent magnet? Discuss.
9-4.1 For arbitrary ~, determine the discontinuity 9-6.2 (a) O f the materials listed in Tables 9.2
of the normal component of the artificially defined and 9.3, which would make the best hard magnet?
quantity C = #0(H + aM) on crossing the pole of (b) Which would make the best material for mag-
a very long bar magnet. Treat H as being due to netic focusing?
magnetic poles.
416 Chapter 9 ~ The Magnetism of Magnets
9-7.1 (a) For a magnet of length l - 16 cm, cross- 9 - 1 0 . 2 In your own words, explain why the mag-
section 0.25 cm 2, and magnetization M = 7.8 x netization in NEO is oriented relative to the crystal
10 s A/m, estimate H and/3 at the midpoint. (b) axes.
Is ndemag large or small within the volume of a long
magnet? 9-G.1 Devise an experiment to establish that the
9-7.2 Consider a needle-shaped sample of per- interaction between two magnets is not due to elec-
malloy in the earth's magnetic field of 0.5 x 10 - 4 T. trostatic forces.
Find its magnetization. Hint: Is it due to suscepti- 9 - G . 2 Magnetic attraction and the amber effect
bility or to saturation? appear to differ. In the amber effect, the comb has
9-7.3 In Example 9.8, how might a "keeper" mag- a net charge, and attracts small objects. A magnet
net (of what shape?) maintain the magnetization of has no net pole strength, but it attracts soft iron, like
a thin slab of carbon steel along the normal? nails. Show how the effects are similar (a) for the
amber effect, by including the charge left behind
9 - 7 . 4 Determine the magnetization for an iron on your hair after rubbing the comb through it; (b)
needle that is oriented (a) along the earth's mag- for magnets, by neglecting the effect of the distant
netic field, (b) normal to the earth's magnetic field. magnetic pole.
external field.) This method is due to Faraday, who so Bp ,~ ( - p / 2 ) ( d B z / d z ) . (b) With Bz for a dipole,
discovered diamagnetism. The sample, of length l, from (9.8), find Bp near the axis (small p).
is suspended vertically in the midplane y = 0 be-
tween the N and S poles of a source magnet, and
the force on the sample is measured with a bal-
ance. At the sample, the field due to the magnet
is nearly vertical, so M = X H ~ X By(0)/~t0, where
By(0) is shorthand for By(x, 0, z). This induces
charges • - - ~ m A = MA on the top and bottom
of the sample. See Figure 9.24. (a) Is the sample, Figure 9.26 Problem 9-G.8.
depicted in Figure 9.24, paramagnetic or diamag- 9 - G . 9 Hard disks, or hard drives, used for mag-
netic? (b) Explain why there is no net force along netic storage of information in the form of magne-
y. (c) Let B~(+l/2) be shorthand for B~(x, +t/2, z), tized regions, have been made from aluminum plat-
and note that B~(x, 0, z ) = 0 by symmetry. Show ters in the following way. The surface is given a hard
that F~ = qm[Bx(l/2) - Bx(-l/2)] ,~ qml(dBx/dy), coating of nickel-phosphorus, and then is given cir-
using the straight-line approximation for differ- cumferential grooving. A chromium underlayer, a
ences. (d) With qm = M A = x H A ~ x(By/~o)A, cobalt alloy magnetic layer, and a hydrogenated car-
show that F~ = Al(x/#o)By(dB~/dy). (e) Evaluate bon overlayer are then sequentially sputtered on,
F~ for X = 0.8 x 10 -5, V = 3.8 mm 3, By = 0.05 T, and the disk finally is lubricated. In 1996, track
and dBx/dy = 4.2 T/m. widths were of the order of 5 #m, and bit lengths
(the region defining a region of well-defined mag-
netization) were of order 0.2 ~tm. By definition,
8 bits equals 1 byte. Estimate the storage density.
[Answer: Of order 0.08 Gb/in z, where Gb is a
gigabyte.]
magnet, will the vertical equilibrium position of the to a frictionless turntable. One magnet is centered
first magnet be stable? at ( - a , 0, 0) and has its moment pointing along 3?-
The other is centered at (a, 0, 0) and has its mo-
9 - G . 1 3 A small magnet can be levitated below ment pointing along 5. (a) Indicate how each mag-
a large magnet with two pieces of (diamagnetic) net will twist. (b) Using conservation of angular
graphite, one above and one below the smaller momentum, indicate how the turntable will twist.
magnet. (a) Can one permanent magnet below an- (c) Compute the torque on each magnet. (d) With
other permanent magnet be in equilibrium? (b) Can l the moment of inertia of the turntable, compute
one permanent magnet below another permanent its angular acceleration.
magnet be in stable equilibrium? (c) Why doesn't
Earnshaw's theorem apply to diamagnets and para- 9-G.16 Figure 9.27 shows two refrigerator-type
magnets? (d) How can the diamagnets make the permanent magnets placed against a refrigerator
equilibrium stable? ("soft iron"), including the domain structure of the
magnets. Indicate the magnetization (if any) of the
9-G,14 A theorem about storage of information part of the refrigerator near each magnet. Deter-
states, loosely, that the ratio of energy-to-read to mine which of the magnets is held on more strongly.
energy-to-write can be made very small. Discuss
this in the context of reading and writing printed
matter, compact disks, and hard disks.