Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
Presenters:
Ehsan Mirnateghi
Mansoor Almazrooei
Ali Mobarak
Advisor:
Dr. Elias Saqan
ECVL 499
September 4, 2009
ECVL499 Final Design Project Report: EMA Hospital By Group 2
TABLE OF CONTENTS
LIST OF TABLES ...........................................................................................................................VII
I. INTRODUCTION ................................................................................................................. 1
A. PURPOSE 1
B. BACKGROUND 1
C. SCOPE 3
D. PARKING 11
E. PAVEMENT DESIGN 15
F. SUMMARY 17
D. STRUCTURAL ELEMENTS 29
E. DESIGN 32
G. LIMITATIONS 38
H. SUMMARY 38
A. INTRODUCTION: 39
B. SCOPE: 39
C. SUBSURFACE CONDITIONS: 39
Page ii
ECVL499 Final Design Project Report: EMA Hospital By Group 2
D. DEWATERING: 41
F. SUMMARY: 45
B. SCOPE: 46
F. SCHEDULING: 50
G. CONSTRUCTION SAFETY: 52
H. SUMMARY: 53
CONCLUSION ............................................................................................................................ 54
A. SUMMARY 54
B. CONTACT 55
APPENDIX A .............................................................................................................................. 57
APPENDIX B............................................................................................................................... 61
APPENDIX C .............................................................................................................................. 70
APPENDIX D .............................................................................................................................. 83
Page iii
ECVL499 Final Design Project Report: EMA Hospital By Group 2
List of Figures
Figure 3: Accessibility Plan View (Source: Road and Transportation Authorities) ................ 5
Figure 18: Four modes cases of Wind Load according to (ASCE 7-05 Fig 6.9) ................... 22
Figure 21: Assign each floor as rigid diaghrams, Source ETABS. ....................................... 24
Page iv
ECVL499 Final Design Project Report: EMA Hospital By Group 2
Figure 25: Beams Property (Unit is based on kilo Newton and meter) ................................. 28
Figure 26: Column Property Data (Unit is based on kilo Newton and meter) ...................... 28
Figure 29: TEKLA Model view of Elevation of Floor showing rectangular columns. ......... 31
Figure 30: Assign ETABS to Desgin Concrete Frame using ACI 318-05 ............................ 32
Figure 32: Moment Diagrams for beams in Fourth Floor, Source: ETABS .......................... 34
Figure 46: Final Analytical Model used for Analysis, Source: ETABS ................................ 69
Page v
ECVL499 Final Design Project Report: EMA Hospital By Group 2
Page vi
ECVL499 Final Design Project Report: EMA Hospital By Group 2
LIST OF TABLES
Table 12: Wall pressure coefficients, Cp. (ASCE fig 6.8) .................................................... 23
Table 13: ACI code 10.11.1 Reduction factors of moment of Inertia due to Cracks ............ 31
Table 15 shallow foundation sizes and factor of safety for bearing capacity ....................... 42
Page vii
ECVL499 Final Design Project Report: EMA Hospital By Group 2
Page viii
ECVL499 Final Design Project Report: EMA Hospital By Group 2
I. INTRODUCTION
A. Purpose
This report includes the design of the five story hospital building in accordance to the following
Construction Management.
B. Background
On 1st of September 2008 the construction of a five story hospital is assigned to a team of
senior civil engineering students as part of ECVL499 Civil Engineering Design Project. The hospital
is proposed to be built in area located in between Dubai and Jebel Ali as shown in Figure 1.
Page 1
ECVL499 Final Design Project Report: EMA Hospital By Group 2
The allocated area is to be in less than quarter of the land designated by the owner. The area of the
land allowed for the Hospital is 287,000 m2, which is one-fourth of the colored area as shown in
following Figure 2.
2
Figure 2: Project Area (Approximately 1 km )
The basic architectural plans of this hospital are provided and they include: Basement, Ground
Floor, and Four stories. The architectural drawings for this hospital are attached in Appendix A. In
order to make efficient use of the limited time, the project is broken down into four fields,
management. Each team member is responsible for the design of one of the four main fields. The
team coordinated the designs during regular meetings and all aspects of analysis, design
modifications, and construction details are discussed by all members to compile a final solid general
Page 2
ECVL499 Final Design Project Report: EMA Hospital By Group 2
C. Scope
The following fields of the design of the hospital are:
- Transportation Engineering Roads and Parking facilities required for the hospital
For the transportation engineering the purpose is to design accessible roads entering and leaving
the hospital, and also to provide and design the parking lots for the EMA hospital which is found in
chapter ΙΙ.
For structural engineering, the scope of this purpose is to designs the structural required for the
For geotechnical design criteria regarding foundations for the structure on this report includes the
following:
The scope did not include the design of the retaining walls. Furthermore, the foundations of
Cost charts
Gantt charts
Page 3
ECVL499 Final Design Project Report: EMA Hospital By Group 2
The scope of the transportation section of this report includes the following:
In choosing the hospital location many factors should be considered, the first one of these factors
is accessibility of the hospital and the accessibility is discussed in the next section. The second
consideration is to have a good use of the land and do not misuse the land. The last consideration
is connecting the hospital to a local road instead of an arterial in which there is more safety and
comfort to access the hospital.
roads. As mentioned in the Background, section I.B, there are four roads surrounding the plot of our
project. These roads could be used for entrance and exit to and from Hospital.
Page 4
ECVL499 Final Design Project Report: EMA Hospital By Group 2
In the drawing it is seen that the road E77 will be converted to a freeway since the Green’s
Community roundabout is being converted to an interchange. Based on this drawing, the EMA road
connects to the E77 road through a signalized interchange under an elevated bridge. So it is not
allowed to connect the hospital to the road E77. Moreover, the hospital should not be connected to the
EMA road which connects to E77 through the signalized interchange based on Road and
Transportation Authorities (RTA) design in that there is a local road that connects to the EMA road.
The letter (H) shows on Figure 6 the location of the hospital. Based on this location, the hospital can
be easily accessed.
Page 5
ECVL499 Final Design Project Report: EMA Hospital By Group 2
Page 6
ECVL499 Final Design Project Report: EMA Hospital By Group 2
The hospital has to be accessed from four directions which are discussed below:
Dubai:
People coming from Dubai can use Interchange 7 to get to road E77, and then turn left using T1
intersection to U-turn at T2 intersection, and finally turns right to reach the hospital.
Abu Dhabi:
People coming from Abu Dhabi can use Interchange 7 to get to road E77, and then turn left using T1
intersection to U-turn at T2 intersection, and finally turns right to reach the hospital.
right and then U-turn at T2 intersection, and finally turn right to reach the hospital.
Leaving
People leaving the hospital can U-turn to get back to EMA road, and then to the T1 intersection. T1
intersection can take to Dubai, Abu Dhabi, and Green Community’s Interchange.
Checking that the local road which is referred to as the service road can take the trips
generated by the hospital, the trip generated is calculated based on Dubai Municipality Studies.
The trips that can be taken by the local road can be easily taken by the EMA Road, so the check
should be done for the local road. The trip generated is calculated based on the number of beds which
However the capacity of one lane is around 1300 pc/lane/hr, the local can carry the trips generated by
the hospital.
Page 7
ECVL499 Final Design Project Report: EMA Hospital By Group 2
In order to have an easier accessibility for the Ambulance a U-turn should be done on the
EMA Road, which is signalized and only used by the Ambulance. The design parameters of the
U-Turn(Ambulance)
Design Speed 60 Km/h
Taper Length 12 m
Deceleration Length 28 m
Queue Length - m
Protected Length 1 m
U-Turn Diameter 14 m
U-Turn Lane Width 4 m
Reduced Median Width 3 m
Chanalizing Nose Width 1 m
based on
Median Width 2 min m RTA
Figure 5: U-turn(Ambulance)
Page 8
ECVL499 Final Design Project Report: EMA Hospital By Group 2
Also people leaving the hospital need a U-turn to get back to the EMA Road. The parameters
Table 4: U-turn(leaving)
U-Turn
Design Speed 60 Km/h
Taper Length 15 m
Deceleration Length 35 m
Queue Length 23.29 m
Protected Length 18.29 m
U-Turn Diameter 14 m
U-Turn Lane Width 4 m
Reduced Median Width 1 m
Chanalizing Nose Width 1 m
based on
Median Width 2 min m RTA
Page 9
ECVL499 Final Design Project Report: EMA Hospital By Group 2
In the future, or by the time the hospital is constructed, Dubai Metro will be ready to take
people from Jebel Ali to Dubai along Sheikh Zayied Road, and the fact that our hospital is nearly
close to Sheikh Zayied Road will also help in the accessibility of the hospital. There will be a lot of
stations along Sheikh Zayied Road, and the closest two stations to the hospital are Dubal, and Jebel
Page 10
ECVL499 Final Design Project Report: EMA Hospital By Group 2
D. Parking
The amount of parking spaces required is determined from the number of beds and the number of
doctors and the staff. The number of beds and the number of doctors are shown in Table 2 which is
based on the Building Regulations & Design Guidelines. It is assumed that the number of staff is 3
The number of parking space required is calculated based on code and result is listed as Table 3.
After number of spaces for the parking have been found, dimensions for the minimum turning
radius, right of way etc, are extracted from RTA standards. The parameters which used are shown in
Table 4.
Page 11
ECVL499 Final Design Project Report: EMA Hospital By Group 2
Once the numbers of the parking spaces are determined, using the design parameters and the
parking stall layout, the plan of parking can be set out. The following options are for the parking stall
layouts which are based on the Dubai Municipality Standard Car Parking Layout dimensions:
1. Two-way Aisle-90º
2. Two-way Aisle-60º
3. One-way Aisle-75º
4. One-way Aisle-60º
5. One-way Aisle-45º
Options 3, 4, and 5 may be omitted in that they restrict the drivers to a very narrow space for
parking and the three of them are one-way and in the one way it is one lane. Since enough space for
parking is available and for more convenient parking design options 3, 4, and 5 are omitted.
Therefore, options 1 and 2 are used in the design of EMA hospital parking area. The layouts of
Page 12
ECVL499 Final Design Project Report: EMA Hospital By Group 2
Considering emergencies scenarios common in hospitals angled parking facilitates the car
parking for the drivers. Furthermore, in this design spaces is not an issue. Therefore Option 2 is
One of the problems faced in design parking is the basement parking that is provided by the
Looking at the architect layout, some columns are blocking the car parking. However,
changing the places of any column should not change the architecture layout. In this option the
basement parking will have 16 parking spaces only as shown in the Figure 7. This parking layout will
restrict us to a bigger span of 9.2m. Since, the flooring system used is a one-way ribbed slab; this
span becomes a critical span. Moreover, a 20m ramp should be designed, considering that the height
of the ramp is 2m from the basement level to the ground level. That is because the maximum slope
Page 13
ECVL499 Final Design Project Report: EMA Hospital By Group 2
Another option is to remove the garage and use the space left for store rooms. So the substitute
parking lots of the garage will be provided outside the building. The parking layout of the hospital
Page 14
ECVL499 Final Design Project Report: EMA Hospital By Group 2
E. Pavement Design
In designing the pavement we have two options for the type of the pavement:
- Rigid Pavement
- Flexible Pavement
Since the rigid is mainly used for ramps and high traffic lanes due to its cost, its better to use the
flexible pavement since its typical uses are parking lots and auxiliary lanes and its cheaper than rigid.
The type of the flexible pavement that is used for the design is the full depth asphalt pavement
which consists of a 4 in of HMA for the asphalt pavement and 10 in of the base of the pavement as
Page 15
ECVL499 Final Design Project Report: EMA Hospital By Group 2
The parameters used for the design of the thicknesses of the pavement are shown in the Figure 21.
The Design structural number is 2.86 based on the parameters entered. Then the thickness of the
pavement is determined using the structural number and the material properties as shown in Figure 22.
Page 16
ECVL499 Final Design Project Report: EMA Hospital By Group 2
F. Summary
After obtaining the architectural, and the RTA drawings concerning the project, the parking
lots, the garage, and the entrance and exit roads of the hospital are designed. A two way 60 degrees
aisle is chosen for the parking lots, since the area provided is quite big. It is recommended that the
garage in the basement floor should be substituted with store rooms, since there are many flaws in the
original architectural design of the garage in the basement floor. And instead the parking spaces could
be provided outside the building. The main reason behind that is because; the width of the road does
not match with the RTA standards. For accessibility reasons, the entrance and exits roads of the
hospital are branched from the EMA road. Finally, the parking lots are designed according to the
RTA geometrical manual. And the number of parking lots provided is equal to 201.
Page 17
ECVL499 Final Design Project Report: EMA Hospital By Group 2
structure followed by TEKLA for modeling the building and later for extracting the Bill of Quantities
(BOQ) and other constructional drawings and reports. To ensure their validity, the results are verified
The following flowchart (Figure 14) details the process of structural design in this project.
Page 18
ECVL499 Final Design Project Report: EMA Hospital By Group 2
building entrances, hall ways and operation rooms and offices. The distribution of columns proposed
by the architect is more than what are required for the structure. Furthermore, to facilitate the required
parking spaces in basement parking it is required to remove some of the middle columns. The result
of removing unnecessary columns, the number of columns decreased from 135 columns to 76
columns, which also improved the efficiency and utilization of the building (Figure 15).
Page 19
ECVL499 Final Design Project Report: EMA Hospital By Group 2
which is environmentally suitable, high quality materials is available, the construction methods are
commonly used and as result it is cost effective system for Dubai. On other hand, very few steel
structure for multi-story buildings are constructed in UAE, due to the high cost of the steel and
fabrication in this region and high maintenance cost due to humidity. UAE companies fabricate high
quality concrete and there exist experienced subcontractors to build quality formworks and perform
In our conceptual design the flooring system is one way ribbed slab, supported by girders to
transfer the gravitation load and lateral loads to the vertical square shaped reinforced columns and
shear walls which were located at suitable architectural locations. (Figure 17)
Page 20
ECVL499 Final Design Project Report: EMA Hospital By Group 2
The loads that are considered in the design of this hospital are categorized into Dead, Live and Wind
loads. According to the American Society of Civil Engineers (ASCE) Manual 7-05 the following
Page 21
ECVL499 Final Design Project Report: EMA Hospital By Group 2
Wind loads with the following properties are assumed to be applied to the building:
a) Wind Coefficients:
This coefficient specifies the strength of wind loads that are being applied to the building. The
These parameters depend on the direction of the wind load being applied to the building. These
modes are defined in ASCE code in four cases shown in Figure 18.
Figure 18: Four modes cases of Wind Load according to (ASCE 7-05 Fig 6.9)
Page 22
ECVL499 Final Design Project Report: EMA Hospital By Group 2
Another exposure factor required by ASCE for wind load calculation is the Wall pressure
coefficient Cp. This factor depends on the direction of wind with respect to the building. In the
Table 12 “L” is the length of building in the direction of wind and B is the side of building which
All the data gathered from Dubai Municipality and ASCE code are stipulated in ETABS as
shown in Figure 20. With these data as required by ASCE code, ETABS considers all 12 different
Page 23
ECVL499 Final Design Project Report: EMA Hospital By Group 2
Next to transfer lateral load from the wind load to the vertical supports, each floor is assigned as
rigid diaphragm shown in Figure 21. As a result the distributed lateral load on side of building is
translated into one concentrated load in each floor applied near the center of floor located by
diaphragm. This load is then transfers to vertical supports. The distribution of this lateral load is
Page 24
ECVL499 Final Design Project Report: EMA Hospital By Group 2
Interpreting case 1 as sample on lateral wind load helps to check reliability of the ETABS
model. In this case it can be seen in story respond output from ETABS (Figure 22), the lateral load in
the higher elevation is stronger. But on the roof floor this load decreases in almost half (170kN to
90kN). This is due to the distribution of tributary area for rigid diaphragm, that for each floor is half
from the floor bellow and half from the floor above, but for the tributary are for roof is only the half
from floor below thus the force applied is almost a bit more than half of the load compare to the force
Page 25
ECVL499 Final Design Project Report: EMA Hospital By Group 2
For defining the seismic load to the structure, three main factors were considered shown in
Figure 23.
Geotechnical Parameter: Based on type of the soil available at the site, which is sand, UBC
(Uniform Building Codes) 1997, assigns the type of soil profile as “SD”.
Regional Parameter: Based on Dubai Municipality regulation for this region this building
earthquake, UBC 1997 code assign the importance factor I = 1.5 for hospital.
Page 26
ECVL499 Final Design Project Report: EMA Hospital By Group 2
After defining all the required information for hospital all the inputs stipulated in the ETABS
Similar to the wind load, earthquake load is also translated into concentrated load to each floor.
The ETABS output for these loads are shown in Figure 24.
For validating this result shear base ratio is calculated. In this structure shear base ratio is 0.12
(Appendix B) This ratio is in the range of 0.10 to 0.15 which validates the result of seismic load
Page 27
ECVL499 Final Design Project Report: EMA Hospital By Group 2
Studying in the available materials and construction methods suitable commonly used materials are
selected for use in construction. For slabs, ribs, column and beams the 30MPa concrete, one of most
commonly used types of concrete, is selected. This concrete provides enough strength which results in
appropriate section sizes, both architecturally and economically. Properties of this concrete and steel
Figure 25: Beams Property (Unit is based on kilo Newton and meter)
The higher strength concrete (f’c = 50Mpa) is used to reduce the sections size of the shear walls.
The concrete properties for shear walls and its reinforcements are stated in Figure 26.
Figure 26: Column Property Data (Unit is based on kilo Newton and meter)
Page 28
ECVL499 Final Design Project Report: EMA Hospital By Group 2
D. Structural Elements
There are several options for selecting the floor slab systems. One-way solid slab, ribbed one-way
slab, two way solid slab, waffle slab, flat slab etc. In this building, one-way ribbed slab is selected for
its versatility, lightweight and as it is commonly used in UAE and therefore subcontractors are
familiar with this system. The cross section of this flooring system after going through analysis and
Page 29
ECVL499 Final Design Project Report: EMA Hospital By Group 2
(ii) Beams
The one-way ribbed slab flooring system is confined with beams in perpendicular to ribs and
also on exterior of building to support the flooring system. The plan views of allocation of these
beams are shown in Figure 28. Wide rectangular (350mm deep by 600mm wide) beams are used
instead of deep beams to reduce the floor system total thickness and make efficient use of space
between the floors. The designs of these sections are detailed in Design section.
(iii) Columns
Rectangular columns are used so they can fit into the partition inside the building.
The dimension of rectangular columns varies according to the location in the floor plan and elevation.
The sizes are from 250x300 mm on sides and 300x400mm in middle of structure.
Page 30
ECVL499 Final Design Project Report: EMA Hospital By Group 2
Figure 29: TEKLA Model view of Elevation of Floor showing rectangular columns.
Shear walls are used around the staircases and elevators, to resist the lateral loadings on the building.
The plan view of the building showing the geometry and location of the initial location of designated
shear walls are shown Figure 28. But these designated location of shear walls are not continued for
final design, look for more details in section E. Design part (iv) Shear walls.
All reinforced concrete sections such as beams, columns and walls due to the applied load are
susceptible to probable tension cracks. This will reduce the gross area of the concrete members and
thus reduce the effective moments of inertia. In order to consider the influence of these tension cracks
in members, the ACI code 10.11.1 permits to use the factors in Table 13. Therefore, the effective
moments of inertia are used in the ETABS for the analysis of the structure.
Table 12: ACI code 10.11.1 Reduction factors of moment of Inertia due to Cracks
Page 31
ECVL499 Final Design Project Report: EMA Hospital By Group 2
E. Design
After reviewing the architectural drawing and defining the loads, material and elements used in the
building, the initial data are stipulated into ETABS structural model. After several runs and
interpolation, the dimensions are modified to obtain the optimum design. The design parameters such
as structural strength, allowable stress, strain, bending moments shear forces and deflections are
Figure 30: Assign ETABS to Desgin Concrete Frame using ACI 318-05
Page 32
ECVL499 Final Design Project Report: EMA Hospital By Group 2
As mentioned earlier the flooring system is designed to be one-way ribbed slab. As it shown in
Figure 27, this system is combination of equal spaced Ribs 150x300mm at 50cm spacing and covered
by 7cm thick concrete. The ETABS output and detail cross checking of final values are reported in
the Appendix B. The steel reinforcement of concrete cover is shown in Table 14.
After analysis and design with appropriate reinforcements the maximum deflection due to
Page 33
ECVL499 Final Design Project Report: EMA Hospital By Group 2
(ii) Beams
To initiate the basic structural design, the moment diagrams of the beams after initial loading are
reviewed; and the most critical beams with maximum bending moment selected to be designed
(Figure 23).
Figure 32: Moment Diagrams for beams in Fourth Floor, Source: ETABS
Due to constructability the dimensions of this beam is selected as the governing dimensions of most
of the floor beams. Dimensional parameters are stated in ACI code Table 9.5(a)—“minimum
thickness of non prestressed beams or one-way slabs unless deflections are calculated”. Therefore,
for a beam with 6.8m span, the thickness should not be less than 320mm unless the deflection is
calculated (Calculation 1). In our case to the depth of floor is designed to be to 350mm therefore no
Page 34
ECVL499 Final Design Project Report: EMA Hospital By Group 2
(iii) Columns
As mentioned earlier in D. Structural Elements section (iii)”Columns” rectangular columns are used
in this structure in order to efficient use of space inside hospital. Moreover, these columns are
reinforced with approximately 4% to 5% of steel which saves the amount of concrete used. It is
permitted by ACI code 10.9.1 to use up to 8% of steel reinforcement but this will increase the chance
of having honeycomb which substantially decreases the load caring capacity the column.
(McCormac)
As a result the columns section sizes are distributed in three categories depending on their
location so the load applied on them. 1 After designing column by ETABS, three types of columns
selected to be cross checked. Details of corresponding analysis and design calculation can be found in
Appendix B.
1
All the sections are analyzed and design based on ACI 318-05 code
Page 35
ECVL499 Final Design Project Report: EMA Hospital By Group 2
As mentioned earlier in section D. Structural Elements (iv) “Shear Walls”, In initial design of this
structure, 4 shear walls allocated around the staircases and elevators. After analysis of building with
these distributions of shear walls, the wall at the grid 2 and 3, overstressed with required
reinforcement ratio more than 2% which is not permitted by the code. ACI Chapter 14. Moreover the
initial distribution of shear walls Figure 17. Therefore an additional shear wall is allocated on the
other side of the hospital to distribute the symmetrical stiffness for the structure and solve the
Page 36
ECVL499 Final Design Project Report: EMA Hospital By Group 2
Finally the lateral deflection is also controlled based on the ACSE code Table 12-12-1 for
hospital permits 0.7% deflection relative to story height bellow for hospital which goes under
occupancy category IV (ASCE Table 1-1). Therefore this code permits for this structure
28mm Inter-story drift for each floor (height = 4m) and global drift of 168mm for total height of
structure (hTotoal = 24m). In this design of this structure due to the relativity wide area with respect to
Page 37
ECVL499 Final Design Project Report: EMA Hospital By Group 2
drawing model. The TEKLA model used to extract the Bill of Quantities (BOQ) of material and
G. Limitations
In order to complete required structural design of this project. There are two more tasks remaining;
First task is to find the effect of earthquake loads which are lateral loads applied to the building. The
next task is to use the final results from ETABS to modify the TEKLA model. Absolute Bill of
Quantities (BOQ) extracted for construction estimation and drawings may then be produced.
H. Summary
After revising the architectural drawing, different types of loading that affected the structures are
studied. According to the service loads and the spans of columns, the one-way ribbed slab flooring
system is selected. This flooring system is supported by interior beams as shown in Figure 28. Two
types of columns are also selected due reduction in axial loads in upper floors. After that all defined
loads, material and elements used in the building, and the initial data are fixed into ETABS structural
model. After several runs and interpolation, the dimensions are modified to obtain the optimum
design according to ACI 318-05. The axial service loads and moments from the columns on the
footing are analyzed and provided for the design of foundation. The final sections sizes are also used
to model the structures on TEKLA where Bill of Quantity (BOQ) is extracted and provided for
constructional estimation.
Page 38
ECVL499 Final Design Project Report: EMA Hospital By Group 2
A. Introduction:
Three borings were performed within the area of the hospital and are included in the Appendix
B. The geotechnical recommendations presented in this report are based on the available project
information, building location, Service Loads acting on Columns, and the site investigation report
given by AL Mawazeen Laboratories. The purpose of this report was to develop geotechnical design
B. Scope:
Review of subsurface conditions
C. Subsurface Conditions:
The subsurface conditions were explored with three soil test borings. Each of the borings was
completed to depth of 20 m below current ground surface. The attached boring plan shows the
location of borings (figure15: in the Appendix B). A standard penetration test was done on each
boring and the samples were taken to AL Mawazeen laboratories. The results of laboratory tests were
used in identifying and describing the physical characteristics of the soils and to aid in defining the
soil strata description (table 14). Based on the standard penetration test, the N values obtained from
each borehole are shown in table 8 (Appendix B). The ground water Level was observed at the depth
of 4.5 meters. After studying the soil strata description and the boreholes information, the fence
Page 39
ECVL499 Final Design Project Report: EMA Hospital By Group 2
fines.
Following the calculation of corrected SPT blow counts and friction angle of the soil, the
graphs of corrected SPT blow counts, and friction angle versus depth were obtained as shown in
figures 20, and 36. From these graphs, it is seen that the soil becomes very dense and acts as a bed
rock starting from 12m depth. Therefore, the parameters used for the design of EMA hospital
concerning The corrected SPT blow counts and friction angle of the soil are 10 and 30 degrees.
5
Depth (m)
10 B.H.1
B.H.2
15 B.H.3
20
25
5
Depth (m)
10 B.H.1
B.H.2
15 B.H.3
20
25
D. Dewatering:
Since it is expected that most of the excavation will be above the ground water table, de-
watering will not be required during excavation and construction of the foundations.
foundation. Due to the presence of basement, the foundation elevation is considered at the depth of
4m below the ground surface and all of the above soil will be excavated. After obtaining the axial
service loads acting on each column from the structural report, these values were used in bearing
capacity calculations (table 18 in the Appendix B). The axial loads had a wide range starting from
200 KN to 2400 KN. Two single and two combined footing were designed with factors of safety
Page 41
ECVL499 Final Design Project Report: EMA Hospital By Group 2
Table 14 shallow foundation sizes and factor of safety for bearing capacity
Type of B L( Area( Qcol(max) qu(soil F
5 5 .7
5 5 .7
5 .7
Combined 800 3
2 3 6 1100 .8
After calculating the immediate settlement of the soil using the Shmertmann’s method for sand,
the maximum settlement occurred for the combined footing (3m x 5.5m). The value of this settlement
is equal to 20 mm which is less than the maximum tolerable settlement which is 25mm (see Appendix
B table 25). Hence, since both of the settlement and factor of safety of the shallow foundation for
bearing capacity were acceptable, the sizes of the foundations were finalized. The layout of the
After finding the sizes of the shallow foundations, the foundation was modelled on ETABS and
exported to SAFE later on. Subsequently, the foundation’s thickness and reinforcement were
designed on SAFE. The values of the punching shear were checked and were acceptable for thickness
of 1m for combined and single footings. This thickness was considered for the design of the shallow
foundation of the EMA hospital. Later on the design conducted by SAFE was revised by hand
calculation as shown in the Appendix B. And a section of a single footing showing the reinforcement
Page 42
ECVL499 Final Design Project Report: EMA Hospital By Group 2
For the design of the retaining walls, tie back anchor sheet piles were considered. Since the soil
will be excavated till depth of 4m, lateral earth pressures of the soil at rest till this depth were found
as shown in the figure 27:. It is seen that at depth of 4m value of the lateral earth pressure at rest is
equal to 30 KPA. And the graph is almost linear. Therefore the maximum horizontal force acting on
the sheet pile would be 60 KN. A section of the tie back anchor is shown in the figure 28. The tie
backs have the typical angle of 15 degrees with respect to the horizontal axis. The depth of the tie
backs is at 2m below the current ground level. The calculation parameters of the tie back anchor are
Page 43
ECVL499 Final Design Project Report: EMA Hospital By Group 2
0.5
1.5
Depth (m)
2 B.H.1
B.H.2
2.5 B.H.3
3.5
4.5
Page 44
ECVL499 Final Design Project Report: EMA Hospital By Group 2
F. Summary:
The subsurface conditions of EMA Hospital were explored by three borings. After applying
SPT test on each boring, the samples were sent to Al-Mawazeen laboratory. By using the lab results,
the corrected SPT blow counts and Friction angle of the soil was calculated. The strata description of
the soil shows that the soil is mainly loose to medium dense sand. From the data obtained, the bearing
capacity, sizes, thickness, and the reinforcements of the footings were calculated. The result was a
combination of combined footings and single footings with 1m thickness. Tie back anchor sheet piles
were recommended to be used for facilitating the excavation process and to act as retaining structures.
The recommendation submitted are based on the available subsurface information, the axial service
loads provided by the structural engineer, and design details provided by the architect.
Page 45
ECVL499 Final Design Project Report: EMA Hospital By Group 2
V. CONSTRUCTION ENGINEERING
from this software, the quantity take off process became relatively easy. Software that was used in
estimating process is the RSMEANS software which is provided on the web. This software estimates
the cost of the building in U.S. pricing. However, the prices of labor were adjusted to match Dubai’s
pricing. Afterwards, the project was scheduled and network diagrams and Gantt’s charts were
produced.
B. Scope:
The scope includes the following:
Quantity takeoff
Scheduling
Safety regulation
Page 46
ECVL499 Final Design Project Report: EMA Hospital By Group 2
constructed was calculated as shown in the Appendix D. However, the volume of concrete for slabs,
beams, shear walls, and columns were taken from the modeled structure on TEKLA. The summarized
Page 47
ECVL499 Final Design Project Report: EMA Hospital By Group 2
estimated. These items were picked and the quantities were entered in the software. After the unit cost
estimate was complete, the results were exported to EXCEL. Subsequently, the pricing of labor were
adjusted to match the Dubai pricing by considering an amount of 3$ per hour for each laborer. The
unit cost estimate of the EMA hospital is shown in table 14. The total cost of the project was
estimated to be 4.7 million dollars which is equivalent to 470 dollars per square meters since the total
area of the land is 10000 m2. For further inquiry on the excel sheet produced see table 15 in the
Appendix D.
Page 48
ECVL499 Final Design Project Report: EMA Hospital By Group 2
following:
1. General requirements:
A. Storage Box
B. Offices
C. Scaffolding
2. Earth work:
A. Sheet piling
B. Excavation
C. Backfill
3. Concrete work:
A. Footings
F. Ramp
4. Walls:
partiotion-3, partition-4
A. Doors
B. Windows
Page 49
ECVL499 Final Design Project Report: EMA Hospital By Group 2
7. Finishes:
A. Wall’s painting
B. Ceiling’s painting
B. Asphalt paving
F. Scheduling:
As soon as the W.B.S. of the EMA hospital was complete, the number of days for each
activity was calculated by dividing the quantity of each activity over the daily output as shown in
table 8. Later on Gantt charts and network diagrams were obtained by the use of the MS project
software by plugging the number of days for each activity and relating the activities (see the
Appendix D for the Gantt charts and network diagrams). A time lag of 3 days was considered after
each concrete work activity was done, so that the concrete cures. Afterwards, the cost per hour of
each activity including the profit was added to the resources. From the resource’s cash flow reports,
the cost of the EMA hospital per each week throughout the total time of the project was calculated.
Cost curve showing the expenditure of resources over the life of the project is shown in figure 9. The
project start date is January 1, 2009, and the project end date is December 5, 2009. Major holidays in
UAE and Fridays were considered nonworking days for this project. A construction site layout plan is
Page 50
ECVL499 Final Design Project Report: EMA Hospital By Group 2
Cost curve
5000000
4500000
4000000
Cumulative cost($)
3500000
3000000
2500000
2000000
1500000
1000000
500000
0
10/29/200 12/18/200 2/6/2009 3/28/2009 5/17/2009 7/6/2009 8/25/2009 10/14/200 12/3/2009 1/22/2010
8 8 9
Date (weeks)
G.Construction Safety:
First aid:
1. First aid provisions and medical care supplies should be available for the employers
2. Provisions should be made prior to the start of the project for quick medical attention
Fire protection:
1. Fire protection devices and effective fire protection and prevention programs should
Employer’s safety:
Page 52
ECVL499 Final Design Project Report: EMA Hospital By Group 2
2. The employers are required to wear appropriate personal protective equipment in all
operations where there is the danger of getting exposed to hazardous conditions such
H.Summary:
After obtaining the quantities for each item regarding the EMA hospital by the aid of TEKLA
and hand calculations, these values were used for unit cost estimation. Later on the quantities
obtained were exported to an excel sheet and the unit cost estimate was performed. The total cost of
the project is 4.7 million dollars. Afterwards, the work break down structure was planned and used to
obtain Gantt charts and network diagrams by the usage of MS project. The total duration of the
Page 53
ECVL499 Final Design Project Report: EMA Hospital By Group 2
Conclusion
A. Summary
After obtaining the architectural, and the RTA drawings concerning the project, the parking
lots, the garage, and the entrance and exit roads of the hospital are designed. A two way 60 degrees
aisle is chosen for the parking lots, since the area provided is quite big. It is recommended that the
garage in the basement floor should be substituted with store rooms, since there are many flaws in the
original architectural design of the garage in the basement floor. And instead the parking spaces could
be provided outside the building. The main reason behind that is because, the width of the road does
not imply with the RTA standards. For accessibility reasons, the entrance and exits roads of the
hospital are branched from the EMA road. Finally, the parking lots are designed according to the
RTA geometrical manual. And the number of parking lots provided is equal to 201.
In this project, two engineering softwares are used. ETABS is used to analyze the structure
followed by TEKLA for modeling the building and later for extracting the Bill of Quantities (BOQ)
and other constructional drawings and reports. At the same time for ensuring the validity of the
results, they are verified, and validated by hand calculation on sample elements of the structure.
The subsurface conditions of EMA Hospital are explored by three borings. After applying SPT
test on each boring, the samples are sent to Al MAWAZEEN laboratory. By using the lab results, the
corrected SPT blow counts and Friction angle of the soil is calculated. The strata description of the
soil shows that the soil is mainly loose to medium dense sand. From the data obtained, the bearing
capacity and sizes of the footings are calculating for different foundation’s options. One option
considered for the EMA Hospital is the combination of combined footings and spread footings. The
second option is raft foundation. Later on, the immediate settlements of spread footings and raft
foundations are calculated. Sheet piles are recommended to be used for facilitating the excavation
Page 54
ECVL499 Final Design Project Report: EMA Hospital By Group 2
The recommendation submitted are based on the available subsurface information, the axial
service loads provided by the structural engineer, and design details provided by the architect. It
should be noted that the structural design is not yet complete. So in case of any change in the axial
After obtaining the quantities for each item modeled in the Hospital’s structure by the usage of
TEKLA, these values are used for unit cost estimation. The total Volume of Concrete estimated at
this stage is approximately 1150 cubic meters. Based on the quantities obtained are used in software
called RS.MEANS for the unit cost estimation. The total cost of the structure at this stage is
3,350,000 $.
B. Contact
For more information regarding this design, contact:
Ehsan Mirnateghi Director of EMA construction Group
(Senior Civil Engineer at American University in Dubai)
Email: Ehsan.Mirnateghi@mymail.aud.edu
Mobile: +971 50 6884898
Or
Mansoor Almazrooei
(Senior Civil Engineer at American University in Dubai)
Email: Mansoor.Almazrooei@mymail.aud.edu
Mobile: +971 50 5152588
Or
Ali Mobarak
(Senior Civil Engineer at American University in Dubai)
Page 55
ECVL499 Final Design Project Report: EMA Hospital By Group 2
Mamlouk, Michael S. Materials for Civil and Construction Engineering. Pearson Education,
2006.
Building Code Requirements For Structurak Concrete and CBommentary (ACI 318M-05)
American Society of Civil Engineers, Minimum Design Loads for Buildings and Other
Page 56
ECVL499 Final Design Project Report: EMA Hospital By Group 2
APPENDIX A
Page 57
ECVL499 Final Design Project Report: EMA Hospital By Group 2
Page 58
ECVL499 Final Design Project Report: EMA Hospital By Group 2
Page 59
ECVL499 Final Design Project Report: EMA Hospital By Group 2
Page 60
ECVL499 Final Design Project Report: EMA Hospital By Group 2
APPENDIX B
Calculations 1: Cross checking the Analysis output of ETABS for Design of Ribs
Fourth Floor
Ribs KJ JI GF Units
h 0.35 0.35 0.35 m
bw 0.15 0.15 0.15 m
Ltributary 0.5 0.5 0.5 m
2
wd 3.5 3.5 3.5 kN/m
2
wl 2 2 2 kN/m
Ln 4.4 5.8 5 m
wd+ self Weight 4.9 4.9 3.9 kN/m
wl 2 2 1 kN/m
wu 9.02 9.02 6.22 kN/m
wuLn2 174.63 303.43 155.50 kN.m
V1 19.8 26.2 15.6 kN
V3 103.0 350 103 kN
Coff ETABS Coff ETABS Coff ETABS
M1 - 1/24 -7.3 -33.0 - 1/11 -27.6 -99.0 - 1/10 -15.6 -295.0 kN.m
M2 1/14 12.5 101.0 1/16 19.0 22.0 1/14 11.1 150.0 kN.m
M3 - 1/10 -17.5 -164.0 - 1/11 -27.6 -101.0 - 1/24 -6.5 -286.0 kN.m
Check Static moment Wl^2/8 Envelope ETABS Wl^2/8 Envelope ETABS Wl^2/8 Envelope ETABS
2
Wl /8 22 25 200 38 47 122 19 22 441 kN.m
Page 61
ECVL499 Final Design Project Report: EMA Hospital By Group 2
Calculations 2: Cross checking ETABS Design output for area of reinforcement required for Ribs
Flexural
reinforcement: Top Steel(left)
Negative (M1)
2
Asreq by Hand 65 250 130 mm
2
Asreq by ETABS 89 144 120 mm
2
Asprovided 142 258 142 mm
bars 2 #10 2 #13 2 #10 SI
Bottom Steel
Positive (M2)
2
Asreq by Hand 115 179 102 mm
2
Asreq by ETABS 99 153 136 mm
2
Asprovided 142 258 142 mm
bars 2 #10 2 #13 2 #10 SI
Top Steel(Right)
Negative (M3)
2
Asreq by Hand 145 250 62 mm
2
Asreq by ETABS 92 153 67 mm
2
Asprovided 142 258 142 mm
bars 2 #10 2 #13 2 #10 SI
Shear reinforcement:
Vu ETABS 11 11 12 kN
φVc = 29 29 29 kN
No Stirrups No Stirrups No Stirrups
Stirrups Vu < 1/2 *φVc Vu < 1/2 *φVc Vu < 1/2 *φVc
Page 62
ECVL499 Final Design Project Report: EMA Hospital By Group 2
Calculations 3: Detail Analysis of beams on (Row I) for cross checking outputs from ETABS Analysis.
Fourth
Floor
M1 - 1/24 -81.8 -33.0 - 1/11 -70.8 -99.0 - 1/11 -301.6 -295.0 - 1/10 -130.4 -137.0 - 1/10 -142.5 -137.0 - 1/10 -196.4 -137.0 kN.m
M2 1/14 140.3 101.0 1/16 48.7 22.0 1/16 207.3 150.0 1/14 93.1 112.0 1/14 101.8 112.0 1/14 140.3 112.0 kN.m
M3 - 1/10 -196.4 -164.0 - 1/11 -70.8 -101.0 - 1/11 -301.6 -286.0 - 1/14 -93.1 -40.0 - 1/14 -101.8 -40.0 - 1/14 -140.3 -40.0 kN.m
Wl^2/8 Envelope ETABS Wl^2/8 Envelope ETABS Wl^2/8 Envelope ETABS Wl^2/8 Envelope ETABS Wl^2/8 Envelope ETABS Wl^2/8 Envelope ETABS
Check
Static
moment
245 279 200 97 119 122 415 509 441 163 205 201 178 224 201 245 309 201 kN.m
Wl^2/8
Page 63
ECVL499 Final Design Project Report: EMA Hospital By Group 2
Page 64
ECVL499 Final Design Project Report: EMA Hospital By Group 2
bw Beam 0.60 0.60 0.60 m wd+Self Weight 29.33 47.81 44.31 kN/m
2
wd 3.50 3.50 3.50 kN/m wl 8.10 15.30 15.30 kN/m
2
wl 3.00 3.00 3.00 kN/m wu 48.16 81.85 77.65 kN/m
2
wslab 1.68 1.68 1.68 kN/m Ln 2.20 2.20 5.10 m
2
wrib 2.52 2.52 2.52 kN/m B Column 0.25 0.25 0.25 m
wBeam 5.04 5.04 5.04 kN/m Floor Hight 4.00 4.00 4.00 m
Page 65
ECVL499 Final Design Project Report: EMA Hospital By Group 2
Page 66
ECVL499 Final Design Project Report: EMA Hospital By Group 2
Page 67
ECVL499 Final Design Project Report: EMA Hospital By Group 2
K9 - 10 (X)
Required Required
Required
Wall Reinf Provided Provided Horizontal Provided Shear
flexural
Location thickness Flexural flexural flexural Shear Reinf Horizontal Reinf ratio
Reinf 2 2
[mm] Ratio Reinf Reinf mm Ratio Shear Reinf [mm /m]
[mm^2/m] 2
(ETABS) [mm /m]
2 Layer
Basement 300 0.0182 5610 5800 1650 22 @ 450 1720
(25 @ 175
2 Layer
Second 300 0.0046 1380 1470 750 16 @ 450 884
(13 @ 175)
Page 68
ECVL499 Final Design Project Report: EMA Hospital By Group 2
Figure 46: Final Analytical Model used for Analysis, Source: ETABS
Page 69
ECVL499 Final Design Project Report: EMA Hospital By Group 2
Appendix C
Borehole layout:
Page 70
ECVL499 Final Design Project Report: EMA Hospital By Group 2
SPT test:
Page 71
ECVL499 Final Design Project Report: EMA Hospital By Group 2
Calculation of corrected SPT blow counts and friction angle of the soil:
After obtaining the N values from the SPT test (table8), the corrected SPT blow counts and the friction angle of the soil were calculated, as
shown in table 23, table Figure 27: , and table Figure 27.
The following formulas were used in calculating each entity shown in the tables:
Where:
10
CN = (Liao and Whiteman’s relationship (1986))
·ó av
Where:
CN = correction factor
(N1)60 = CNN60
Where:
Where:
Page 72
ECVL499 Final Design Project Report: EMA Hospital By Group 2
Page 73
ECVL499 Final Design Project Report: EMA Hospital By Group 2
Page 74
ECVL499 Final Design Project Report: EMA Hospital By Group 2
Page 75
ECVL499 Final Design Project Report: EMA Hospital By Group 2
Page 76
ECVL499 Final Design Project Report: EMA Hospital By Group 2
b. Depth Factors:
Df/B < 1
Page 77
ECVL499 Final Design Project Report: EMA Hospital By Group 2
Df/B> 1
c. Inclination Factors:
Page 78
ECVL499 Final Design Project Report: EMA Hospital By Group 2
Settlement calculations:
Since the soil in this project is sand, there will be no consolidations. So the settlement calculations are considered for immediate settlements for
Shmertmann’s method:
Z2
Iz
Se = C1C2 (Q - q) Es Z
0
Where:
Page 79
ECVL499 Final Design Project Report: EMA Hospital By Group 2
IZ = 0.1 at Z = 0
IZ = 0.5 at Z = 0.5B
IZ = 0 at Z = Z2 = 2B
C2 = a correction factor to account creep in soil = 1 + 0.2 log (tyears/0.1), in this case tyears = 5
Page 80
ECVL499 Final Design Project Report: EMA Hospital By Group 2
Page 81
ECVL499 Final Design Project Report: EMA Hospital By Group 2
Page 82
ECVL499 Final Design Project Report: EMA Hospital By Group 2
Appendix D
A. Superstructure:
The volume of the concrete for slabs, shear walls, beams, and columns were obtained from TEKLA as shown in table 18. Then, the volume of
ramp and ribbed were added to slabs, and also the volume of piers to columns. The total volume for each beams, slabs, columns, and shear walls are
Page 83
ECVL499 Final Design Project Report: EMA Hospital By Group 2
Page 84
ECVL499 Final Design Project Report: EMA Hospital By Group 2
B. Earth work:
1. Sheet Piling:
For excavation, there will be sheet piles around the perimeter of the excavation area for 4m depth.
2. Excavation:
The area of excavation is shown in figure 25. The depth of excavation is 4m.
Page 85
ECVL499 Final Design Project Report: EMA Hospital By Group 2
3. Backfill:
C. Masonry:
1. Exterior wall:
2. Interior wall:
The interior wall’s length was estimated to be 10 times the width of the hospital.
D. Roof insulation:
E. Finishes:
1. Wall’s painting:
A = 1550 x 6 = 9300 m2
For the entrances of the building 10m length of 1m wide handicap ramp was estimated.
G. General requirements:
Page 86
ECVL499 Final Design Project Report: EMA Hospital By Group 2
Two offices and storage boxes were estimated to be needed for the construction of the hospital
2. Scaffolding:
1. Doors:
From the architecture plans provided the number of doors needed is equal to 312 doors.
2. Windows:
It was estimated that for every 33 m2 of the exterior wall 1 window would be provided.
1. Asphalt:
The amount of asphalt needed was estimated to be the difference between the total area of the Land, and the area of the building.
The length of the curbs and gutters needed along the road was estimated to be 2000m.
J. Stairs:
From the architectural plans the area of the stairs was estimated to be 1000 m2.
K. Footings:
The layout of the footings and the dimensions of the footings are shown in figures 26, and 1. The thickness of each footing is equal to 1m.
Page 87
ECVL499 Final Design Project Report: EMA Hospital By Group 2
Page 88
ECVL499 Final Design Project Report: EMA Hospital By Group 2
Page 89
ECVL499 Final Design Project Report: EMA Hospital By Group 2
Page 90
ECVL499 Final Design Project Report: EMA Hospital By Group 2
Page 91