Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
JURISPRUDENCE
Long Questions & Answers
Ans. The term Jurisprudence is Latin term having meaning ‘Knowledge of Law or Skill
of Law’ (Juris=Law). (Prudence=Knowledge of Law).Jurisprudence study about the
law. and it includes study of the term law, sources of law and legal terminologies, It
has been defined by various authors as follows:-
3. Gray :- According to this author Jurisprudence is study of legal Systems of all the
countries.
Nature of Jurisprudence
1. It is Uncodified Law
2. It is common law in all countries
3. This law has been developed and not enacted by Legislatives.
4. It is also called as legal theory, be those is actual study of the term law in
Jurisprudence.
5. There is no scope for amendment and it is developing out of legal knowledge of the
people.
Scope of Jurisprudence:
There is wide scope of Jurisprudence and it is related with so many other subjects which
can be explained as follows:
Economics is the science of wealth. People commit may illegal activities for the sake
of wealth and law tries to control illegal activities and to punish the criminals same
law is studied in Jurisprudence and therefore Jurisprudence and economics are
correlated.
2. Jurisprudence and Politics:-
Laws are enacted by political parties. Who are elected by people called as
Legislatures. Jurisprudence study law enacted by political parties who are in power
and therefore Jurisprudence is also related with Political Science.
Ethics or morality is base of Law. Many Laws have been enacted by considering
morality. But it is not in all the laws. Therefore law and morality are ethics are also
correlated.
Importance of Jurisprudence:-
7. It is like engine and all subjects are like bhogis and jurisprudence is helpful to
interoperate every law.
Ans:- School means group of the people who believe and support theory relating to law.
In every school different views have been expressed about the term law. All these
theories are subjected to Criticism. These are seven kinds of schools specified in
Jurisprudence which are as follows:-
1. Analytical School
2. Historical School
3. Sociological School
4. Philosophical School
5. Realist School
6. Comparative School
7. Natural Law School.
1. Analytical School :
Criticism:
There are many laws having no command such as Contract Act, Constitutional
Law, Marriage Law, International Law.
2. Historical School :-
Criticism:
Custom is not main source of Law But in modern period Legislation is main source
of law.Many laws found are out dated and it cannot be effective source of law.
3. Sociological School :-
This school is supported by Benthan. According to this school law is social
phenomenon. Law and Society are related and there are two sides of same coin.
Society give birth to law and law cannot give birth to society. Therefore need or
requirement of society is law.
Criticism:
There is no participation of bark of society in law making process. Opinion of
general public is not considered in making the law.
4. Philosophical School :-
This school says that law is nothing but morality or ethics of the people. this school
is supported by Gray. There is morality or ethical values among the people and
because of that they have made rules to govern them self and it is law.
Criticism:
There are many laws which are not based in morality. Such as Vicarious Liability,
Security Laws. For Security of country and the people morality cannot be
considered in all the laws.
5. Realist School :-
Criticism:
Judges cannot be called as law makers and they have to interpret and enforce the
law Powers of judges are limited and they can give remedy if there is law.
6. Comparative School :-
This is school is supported by Henry Maine. According to this school law
developed out of comparison between the countries. Every country adopted same
rules from other country and made the law.
Criticism :
There cannot be comparison between over developed, under Developed and
developing countries. Local conditions and circumstances prevailing in country are
different and they cannot make law by comparison.
7. Natural Law School :- This is school is supported by Aristotes and Plato. Who were
Greek philosopher. According to this school God has give intelligence and wisdom
only to human being and they have made the Law by using it.
Criticism:
There are many laws which are contrary to intelligence for purpose of Security.
Requirement or necessity of society is considered in law making the process by
neglecting intelligence.
---------------
3Q. Define Customs ? And explain essential requisites, Kinds, Merits and demerits of
Customs ?
Ans. There are three main sources of origin and development of law. And these are
Custom, Precedent and Legislation.
1. General Custom
2. Local Custom
3. Legal Custom
4. Conventional Custom.
1. General Custom :
General Customs are followed by all the people or majority of the people in the
country.
Eg: There are many festivals which comes under general customs, in Hindu
marriage saptapadi and kanyadan is general custom, in Muslim marriage mehar is
general custom.
2. Local Custom:
It is in particular area or region or community and it is not common among all the
people.
Eg: There are some festivals which are in particular region and become local
Custom, Muta marriage or contract marriage is local custom in Shia group of
Muslims and it is not common all the people.
3. Legal Custom:
There are many customs recognised and adopted by law and it become Legal
custom. Many general customs become legal customs.
Eg: Mehar, Iddat period ,Saptapadi, Kanyadan, Adoption are legal customs.
4. Conventional Custom :
There are many conventional customs which are unwritten and recognised by the
people .
Advantages of Customs:
There are some customs which are social evils such as Saty, Dowry.
There are many customs having no interpretation or explanation and people follow it
Customs waste much time and not convent for developing country
Customs becomes more expensive and poor people face problems
Customs create law and order problem.
4Q. What do you mean by Precedent ? Explain kinds of precedent and its merits and
demerits as a source of law ?
Ans. Precedent is source of law. Precedent means all the judgements given by Supreme
court or High court which are recorded in case law reporters. These judgements
have to be followed by all the courts in similar cases.
Supreme court have power to over rule earlier judgement and declare new
judgement which is followed in Subsequent cases. Supreme court judgement is
binding on all the courts in India. And High court judgement is binding all the
district courts and taluka courts. High court judgement is not binding on supreme
court, but supreme court judgement is binding on all high courts. Therefore
precedent is also called as Judgement Law. Judges are not law makers, but, there
judgements have significance as a source of law. Advocates can produce
judgements of superior courts at the time of arguments in support of there cases
called as citation or case Laws.
Kinds of Precedent :
1. Original precedent:
In original precedent supreme court or high court deliver new judgement first time
in a particular case . if earlier judgement is over ruled then also it is called as
Original precedent. In legal term it is known as ‘Ratio Decidendi ’ . It is applicable
in subsequent cases and not already decided cases. It is stated that ‘Judges are
master of law and not slave of law’. Therefore in interest of justice they can declare
new precedents.
Eg : In Shah banu case supreme court held that Muslim women having no source of
income is also entitled for maintenance from husband. It become new precedent or
original precedent but parliament deleted it by making new amendment in Muslim
personal law.
Eg: Supreme court held that negligence of doctor comes under jurisdiction of
consumer court. Patient is like a consumer who heir services of doctor by paying
the fees. This is Original precedent.
2. Declaratory Precedent :-
In this precedent there is nothing new. But already existing precedent is taken by
Subordinate judges in these judgements when more number of judges approve a
precedent then it becomes strong precedent it is also called as ‘Stare decisis’ it
means ‘ look back and decide’
3. Authoritative Precedent:-
Eg: A.P high court held that Muslim minority is not entitled for 4% reservation in
education and employment supreme court held that they are entitled for
reservation and it became authoritative precedent.
4. Persuasive Precedent :-
5Q. Define Legal Right ? and explain various kinds of legal rights ? how rights and
duties are corelated?
Ans. Legal right is enforceable in the court. It is stated that ‘Some rights are legal but not
moral’ and ‘Some are moral but not legal’. The term legal right has been defined as
follows :-
2. Austin : Legal right is the power vested in a person or persons to control others by
virtue of law of the country.
Eg: Husband divorced wife then it is her legal right to claim maintenance from
husband because of law.
Kinds of Legal Rights:
Corporeal right is on material things or tangible things such as Car, House, Plot,
Furniture. Incorporeal right is an immaterial or intangible things . It is also called as
intellectual property. Such as right or trademark, Copyright, Patent right and design.
In Imperfect right there is some defect such as ‘A’ mortgage his land then he cannot sell
it till repayment of loan amount because his right is imperfect.
Equitable right is recognised under principles of equity such as when there are no heirs
then nearest relatives can make succession on property because they have Equitable
right.
If father mention in gift deed that she will be given gift of the house if she performs
marriage within the caste. This is contingent right . because she cannot claim gift of
property without performing marriage within the caste which is a condition.
Right in Persunom is personal right. Such as ‘A’ did not repay loan amount taken from
‘B’ then remedy is available to ‘B’ or his family member Because it is right in persunom.
Right in Rey propria is in own property. Such as to use transfer, sale and destroy the
property.
Right in Reyaliena is in others property. Such as ‘A’ occupied plot belonging to ‘B’ and
continued possession for 20 years or more period. This right is protected as Easement
Right. And it is called as right in reyaliena.
In Positive Rights law allows the people to do certain things called as Lawful act. In
Negative rights there is restriction to do certain things.
Eg : Right to make income is positive right. But to avoid taxes is negative right.
it is positive right to drive vehicle but negative right to drive vehicle without licence.
Municipal rights is relating to laws of the country. All fundamentals rights are municipal
rights.
International rights are given under international law. Such as right to go to other
country for education, employment, tour is a international right.
Rights and Duties are correlated. Every right have corresponding duty. It can be stated
that rights and duties are two sides of same coin.
Eg: Right to perform marriage is private right. But there is duty to pay maintenance to
wife and children. There cannot be right without duty. And there cannot be duty
without right.
6Q. Explain the term possession ? and modes of acquisition of possession and its kind
and legal provisions to acquire possession?
Ans. Possession is material control or physical control over the objects or property .
possession may be legal or illegal. It is stated that ‘Possession is nine points Law’. It
is stated that ‘No possession can be deprived without procedur established under
law’
Kinds of Possession:-
Eg : ‘A’ sends money order to ‘B’ then the possession of post men is mediate possession.
And if ‘A’ pays money to ‘B’ directly then it is immediate possession.
3. Adverse possession:-
When anyone continues possession in contravention of the agreement or by violation of
order the court then it is adverse possession. Owner can claim damages from possessor
when there is adverse possession.
4. Concurrent Possession :-
When two or more persons have possession pf same property then it is called as
concurrent possession.
Eg: A,B and C are partners then they have concurrent possession of property of the firm.
5. Representative Possession:
When any one represent other party and having possession then it is representative
possession. There is limited interest of possessor.
Possession in Law is lawful possession. Such as possession of agent, finder and bailee is
law possessor.
1. By Taking:
Possession can be obtained by taking in this possession there is effort of one person.
Eg : ‘A’ picked coin fallen on the road, he got possession by taking.
Eg : ‘A’ went on the river and catch fishes he got the possession of fishes by taking.
2. By Delivery :
In this method there are at least two persons one person makes delivery and another
person takes it . it is transaction of possession between two persons.
Eg: ‘A’ gives a coin to a beggar he got possession of coin because of delivery.
Eg : ‘A’ shopkeeper gives article to a customer then customer got possession because of
delivery.
3. By Operation of Law:-
When any body gets possession because of order or judgement of the court then this
possession is acquired by operation of law.
Eg : Articles recovered by police from a thief and court gives order to handover articles
to owner . According to procedure owner get possession by operation of law.
Eg : Heir files a partition suit against head of family court gives. Judgement to give
property to the heir he got possession by operation of law.
Possession Ownership
Possession is Defacto Ownership is Dejure (by law)
Possession in having Legal or illegal Ownership is Legal
Possessor is having limited right Owner is having unlimited right
Possession does not include Ownership Ownership generally include
possession.
7Q. What do you mean by Liability ? Explain various kinds of liabilities and
distinguish between civil and criminal liabilities?
Eg: ‘A’ have taken loan from ‘B’ then it is liability of ‘A’ to repay the loan amount.
Therefore rights, duties and liabilities are correlated terms. Because of right there is
duty and because of duty liability arises when duty is not performed.
Kinds of Liabilities: There are six kinds of liabilities
1. Civil Liability
2. Criminal Liability
3. Vicarious Liability
4. Absolute Liability
5. Quasi contractual Liability
6. In nominate Liability.
1. Civil Liability:
Civil Liability arises which is of civil nature and remedy is given by Civil court. This
liability arises because of Law and contracts between the parties.
Eg: ‘A’ have borrowed loan from the bank then there is civil liability to make repayment
of loan amount. Otherwise bank can file recovery suit in civil court.
2. Criminal Liability :
In criminal liability there is provision of imprisonment or penalty or both . when any
body commits crimes or the act which is prohibited under any criminal law then there is
criminal liability.
Eg : ‘A’ have committed murder of ‘B’ then there is criminal liability of ‘A’
Eg : Husband makes harassment of wife for dowry there is criminal liability of husband
under prohibition of dowry act 1961.
3. Vicarious Liability :
This liability is of civil nature which arises under tort. When a tort is committed by one
person and other person is liable to pay damages then it is vicarious liability. This
liability arises because of relationship between the parties.
Eg: Driver of a bus caused accident there is vicarious liability of state transport
corporation which is master or employer to pay compensation to effected persons.
4. Absolute Liability: This liability arises without relationship between parties there is
no need to proof negligence . It is of civil code.
Eg: A is walking on the road and wall of the house collapsed and there is death of ‘A’
owner of the house have absolute liability to pay compensation.
Eg : A postmen enters into the house to deliver letter and a pet dog bites him. Owner of
pet dog have absolute liability to pay compensation.
5. Quasi contractual Liability:
This liability arises with out actual contract between the parties. Quasi Contract is
recognised under law and it is relation as if created between parties.
Eg: Necessaries supplied to minor then there is quasi contractual liability of his father
or guardian to make payment.
Eg : ‘A’ found and article on the road belonging to ‘B’. It is quasi contractual liability of
finder to return article to owner.
6. In Nominate Liability :
Some people create trust or wakf for religious, charitable and pious purpose. It is for
benefit of poor persons widows, handicapped persons, students, if benefit is withdrawn
without any reason then there is in nominate liability of the trust or wakf.
8Q. What are the objects of administration of Justice? Explain Various theories of
punishments and criticism level against it?
Ans. State Government or the Central Government have to carry on social welfare
functions. It includes to provide security to the people and the country called as
Administration of justice. State carry on civil administration and criminal
administration by establishments of courts. State have to provide justice to the
people.
Theories of Punishments:
This theory is generally applied to new offender and not habituated criminals.
2. Deterrent Theory :
According to this theory mind of criminal is polluted and it is difficult to bring change in
his behaviour. Criminal is like a coal and its colour cannot be eliminated . punishment is
given to criminal to teach lesson to like minded people who want to walk on path of
crime. Awareness is brought among them that fruits of crimes are bitter.
This theory does not applied to persons who have adopted crime as a profession.
3. Reformatory Theory:
4. Retributive Theory:
This theory is based on idea of revenge or vengeance. By committing crime he has taken
loan from society and by going to prison he repays it. When criminal have not shown
sympathy while committing crime then society also should not show any sympathy. It is
like blood for blood, hand for hand, some Gulf Countries support this theory.
5. Expiatory Theory :
This theory is based on idea of repentance when a criminal sit in prison then there is
enough leisure time to think about the act. Criminal may think about his act and
understand his mistake and may not commit crime again.
This theory is not much effective because criminals are committing more crimes
and there is no repentance.
Ans. The term law is having broad meaning. Law means any rule of common action. It is
classified as follows.
i. Customary Law :- These laws are based on customs and many customs have no
clarification. Such as Saptapadi, Kanyadan, Idaat period, Mehar.
ii. Scientific Law: These laws are related to science called as physical law or
scientific law. Eg: Newton’s laws of motion, laws of gravitational force.
iii. Practical or Technical law: There are some laws which are practical in nature.
Such as law of Swimming, Typing, Acting, Singing and Dancing.
iv. Moral Laws: Moral laws are based on ethical values. And these are followed by
the people but court may not enforce it. Eg: To take bath everyday, to respect
elders, to pray God.
2Q. Sovereignty ?
Ans. Sovereignty means absolute independence of every country. When any country
have sovereignty then no other country can interfere in internal matters of the
country. It includes following points:-
2. Subordinate Legislation:
ii. Judicial legislation: Supreme court makes rules for all courts in India. High court
for all courts in state. Eg : Appointment of staff, holidays in court, transfers,
allotment of work.
iii. Executive Legislation : Executive are superior officers makes rules for respective
dept. binding on people. Eg : Rules of traffic made by traffic commissioner , rules
of DEO for school education, rules of tax commissioner.
iv. Autonomous Legislation: These rules are made by autonomous bodies such as
bank, LIC, university , Railway and Airlines.
5Q. Codification?
Ans. Codification means division of law in sections, sub sections and clauses. It is having
following advantages
1. It brings certainty
2. It is easy to find out relevant law because of codification
3. It is convenient to deliver judgement and make argument when there are particular
sections.
Therefore codification is having recognition and support in legal systems and most
of the laws are Codified.
Ans. Legal person is imaginary person. Unborn person have contingent legal personality
depend on his birth. Without birth unborn person cannot be called as legal person.
Even though he has following rights.
1. Death Sentence:- Any pregnant women cannot be hanged to death for any crime
because law cannot punish unborn child who is likely to take birth.
2. Injury :- When any child caused injury before birth then after birth compensation
can be claimed.
3. Miscarriage or Abortion:- Any miscarriage or abortion with out consent of
pregnant women is a crime under Sec 412 of IPC having 5yrs imprisonment. It is
legal right of women to give birth of the child.
4. Partition:- when there is partition of joint family property among the heirs and after
that child have taken birth it is right of the child to claim his share in the property
by filling suit called as reopening of partition.
7Q. Legal Status of Dead Person?
Ans. Dead person is having rights under the law. But dead person is not a legal person.
These rights are as follows:-
1. Will :- When a person has enacted a will then after his death property is given to
heirs according to will.
2. Disturbance to Dead body :- Anybody who cause disturbance to dead body from
taking to grave yard is a crime U/S 297of IPC having 2yrs imprisonment.
Ans. Obligation means Legal duty. There are two kinds of Obligation.
1. Simple Obligation: In this obligation relevant party have to perform his legal duty.
Eg : ‘A’ have taken loan then it is simple obligation of ‘A’ to repay the loan amount .
After death of debtor it has to be paid by the heirs which is Solidary obligation.
2. Solidary Obligation: In this obligation act is done by one party and there is
obligation from other party.
Eg : ‘A’ have taken loan and made default then there is solidary obligation of surety to
make payment of loan amount.
Eg : Driver caused accident then there is obligation of master to pay the compensation.
9Q. Mensrea?
Ans. Mensrea is mental element which includes bad intention, negligence. There is a
maxim in criminal law ‘Actus Facit Reum Nisi Mens Sit Rea’ it means ‘Act is guilty
when mind is guilty’. Mensrea is considered in deciding criminal cases.
Eg : ‘A’ catch hand of women with bad intention. It is crime u/s 354 called as outraging
modesty of the women. If women fell in river and ‘A’ removed her in any condition
then it is not a crime because there is no mensrea or guilty mind.
Mensrea does not apply in accident cases. There is liability of the person who
caused accident when though there is no mensrea.
10Q. Negligence?
Eg : Driver of a bus is driving bus negligently in which there is accident which resulted
in death of a person u/s 304a of IPC driver is liable for 2yrs imprisonment because
he caused death negligently.
Corporation who is master have to pay compensate under vicarious liability for
negligent act of driver.
In Vested ownership all powers are transferred but contingent ownership is depend on
happening or not happening of the event.
Eg : Father have given gift of the house to daughter then it is vested ownership. If he
mentions that property will be given if she performs her marriage then daughter
have contingent ownership.
Legal ownership is heirs and equitable ownership is of nearest relatives. When there are
no heirs.
11Q. Sanction ?
Ans. Sanction means punishment which is given when any crime is committed.
According to criminal law. Following are the different kinds of sanctions.
1. Death sentence : It is given in rarest of the rare crime which is of serious nature.
2. Life Imprisonment : It is also given in serious crime and mini period is 14 yrs
imprisonment.
Ans. When any one commit crime and abscond then court may order to forfeit his
property and by selling it amount can be deposited in Government Treasury.