Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
Without
Zen Masters
By
Camden
Benares
Commentary by
Robert
Anton
ZEN
WITHOUT
ZEN
MASTERS
ZEN
WITHOUT
ZEN
MASTERS
By Camden Benares
Commentary By
Robert Anton Wilson
Illustrated by
Deborah M. Cotter
1993
NEW FALCON PUBLICATIONS
PHOENIX, ARIZONA, U.S.A.
Copyright © 1977 Camden Benares
CAMDEN BENARES'S
A HANDFUL OF ZEN
FROM NEW FALCON PUBLICATIONS
PREFACE
Say the magic word and the duck will come down and pay you $100.
—Marx
*Named after Groucho and John, of course. A basic Discordian koan is “Why
don’t we do it in the road?”
( 11 )
and was actually invented by the mischievous Ho Chi Zen.
It does seem fairly well documented that an Erisian
missionary arrived in the Bay Area of California in 1849 and
took the name Norton I, with the title “ Emperor o f the
United States and Protector of Mexico.” Norton was imme
diately recognized as an Illuminated Being by the foremost
occult order in San Francisco, the Ancient and Accepted Free
masons, who granted him a 33° and buried him, at his death
in 1880, in the masonic cemetery.
It is fairly well established that, although a pauper, Nor
ton I was allowed to dine sumptuously in the best restaurants
of San Francisco; although a lunatic, he wrote letters which
were seriously considered by such folk as Abraham Lincoln
and Queen Victoria; and, although a charlatan, he was so be
loved that 30,000 turned out for his funeral.
When the Committee of Vigilance, in an impetuous mood,
set out to burn down Chinatown on one occasion, N orton I
dispersed them by merely standing in the street, head bowed,
praying. As Lao-Tse says, “When the proper man does noth
ing (wu-wei) his thought is felt 10,000 miles.”
Malaclypse the Younger has indicated N orton I’s impor
tance, writing in his infamous Principia Discordia, “ Everybody
understands Mickey Mouse. Few understand Hermann Hesse.
Hardly anybody understands Einstein. And nobody under
stands Emperor N orton.” Mordecai the Foul, High Priest of
the Head Temple of the Bavarian Illuminati, says of Norton
with simple awe, “ Live like him !”
What is the central truth behind Marxism-Lennonism,
Erisianism, Discordianism, Zen Without Zen Masters? On this
point, our leading atheologians are in agreement—and disagree
ment (as might be expected). Mai says, simply, “God is a crazy
woman and Her name is Eris.” Ho says more abstractly and
less figuratively, “Hell is reserved exclusively for them that be-
live in it.” Camden says concisely, “ If we believe enough,
there will be whatamores. Do we really want any?” Mordecai
the Foul merely exclaims “F nord!” and hits you with a stick
if you ask again.
But, seriously, folks (as Bob Hope always says) Zen
Without Zen Masters, like all the other aspects of Operation
Mindfuck, is not a complicated joke disguised as a new form
of Buddhism. It is a new form of Buddhism disguised as a
( 12 )
complicated joke. Guerilla ontology. Epistemological judo.
If you don’t laugh at all, you’ve missed the point. If you only
laugh, you’ve missed your chance for Illumination. As Licht-
enberg said elsewhere, “ This book is a mirror. If a monkey
looks in, no philosopher looks o u t.”
Hail Eris!
OM!
Fnord?
—R obert A n to n Wilson
I. Guides
and Lovable Fools
SOLITARY SYSTEM
( 16 )
MASTERS AND TEACHERS
/
teachings just because I am crazy. I am crazy because they
are true.”
( 18 )
BEN AND THE FANATIC
In his teachings, Ben stressed that Zen was his path be
;rious cause it allowed him to become himself. All the other routes
ously that allegedly lead to cosmic consciousness seemed to put
y it him in conflict with his own nature. He advised all seekers to
examine carefully what each system asked o f the potential
as initiate, keeping in mind three rules:
lese 1. What you are required to believe is what the system
*y cannot prove.
2. Anything that you are asked to keep secret is of
more value to the teacher than to the student.
3. Any practice that is forbidden offers something
that the system cannot successfully replace with an
alternative.
One listener asked, “Don’t you believe that giving up the
pleasures of the senses will produce a different consciousness?”
“My personal experience,” Ben replied, “was that it pro
duced the consciousness o f fanaticism.”
( 19 )
AUDIENCE RESPONSE
( 20 )
A COMMON DISEASE
( 24 )
A RINGING IN THE EARS
If as a
ead
e. I
in the
( 25 )
■
HYPOC’S EARRING
( 26 )
LUCAS’S MEDITATION
imment-
;ed if After learning transcendental meditation, Lucas taught
riably the simple techniques to anyone who expressed an interest.
vear an Unlike many meditation teachers, he charged no m oney, ask
I the ing only that meditators give him something o f value in re
turn for his time. Instead o f an elaborate ritual in a foreign
; sym- language, Lucas gave a quiet talk on the way to em pty the
squator. mind of its chatter while candles burned and incense filled
epre- the room. One learner asked, “Why should I empty my mind?”
of con- Lucas, rephrasing Lao Tse, replied, “Wheels without empty
occult, centers cannot be used to haul, and the empty part o f the
ly he bowl makes it useful for holding food .”
to sleep
OTIS AND THE OLDER STUDENT
( 29 )
THE ZEN TEMPLE ATTENDANT
( 30 )
HO’S FIRST SERMON
( 32 )
ADVANCE FROM THE RETREAT
( 33 )
i
THE ARTIST’S ENLIGHTENMENT
( 34 )
EXPENSIVE ADVICE
VOTING
( 36 )
THE RIGHT TO DIE
( 37 )
OBSTACLES
( 38 )
THE PRIEST
( 39 )
ENLIGHTENMENT OF A SEEKER
( 40 )
His worrying and meditation were disturbed when, as if
in a test o f his faith, effluvium fell from the second floor onto
him. At that time two people walked into the room. The
first asked the second who the man sitting there was. The
second replied “Some say he is a holy man. Others say he is
a shithead.”
Hearing this, the man was enlightened.
( 41 )
PERSONAL WORK
LIVING ZEN
INSTANT ENLIGHTENMENT
t M 8 i»
m K m
( 44 )
You are personally responsible for your con
tinued existence. There are many ways o f focusing
your attention elsewhere, but to really experience
your life, the focus must be on you as the center o f
the perceived universe. You may devote as much time
as you wish to causes as long as you don’t use them
as an excuse for trying to change others instead of
yourself. Anytime that you are doing something that
you think is not for you, re-examine both your think s
ing and your actions. If it isn’t for you, y o u ’re fool a J
ing yourself or doing it wrong. W
CHANGE
IgBpsjj
( 45 )
PRALAYA’S WISDOM
( 47 )
Living in the here and now is concentrating on
the present in accordance with one s own nature. It is
not ignoring the future, but a recognition of the ignor
ance of future events. Rather than an abandonment
of responsibility, it is the full acceptance o f who you
are, where you are and what you are doing. Welcome
to the here and now. Everything that you have exper
ienced has been necessary to get you where you are
now. If you think that you have been in a better
jlace, stop looking backwards.
( 48 )
There is always a choice in your course of action, al
though you may have been conditioned to believe otherwise.
One of the best ways to decide which choice to make is to
list all the alternatives that you can think of while bearing in
mind that nothing is unthinkable. Divide those alternatives
into two categories—direct and indirect. The latter represent
those choices that require getting other people on your trip.
The direct choices need only your action. If you can t find
va direct course of action, rethink the entire situation.
S & m ssfei
-» h'A
m w m * :
( 49 )
JERRY’S RELIGION
( 50 )
TROUBLE-FREE ACTION
( 51 )
PAY AS YOU GO
( 52 )
BOB’S ENLIGHTENMENT
( 53 )
SKILLS AND TALENTS
CHANGING TIMES Λ
You are a process o f change. Your cells renew
themselves periodically, old concepts are replaced by
new and your new being reflects life s experience. ^
Flow with the changes. Be that new being. You don’t
have to make the person-you-used-to-be happy.
'ey.
m m
.
( 54 )
ψ = TAKING RISKS
GOOD VIBRATIONS
( 56 )
middle
erience
SUE’S PATH
but real-
i. AI-
Through m editation, Sue found an inner source of
other,
both, strength and determination. By using these resources, she
changed her life into a series o f events that brought her hap
die class
l to a piness and success. For her there is no conflict between or
t spiri- derliness and her free spirit. As she says, “I find freedom
worldly only through organization.”
iching
I to
t his
( 57 )
THE CIRCLE OF TRUTH
( 58 )
KARMA
( 59 )
i
DOUBLE LEARNING
INNER SPACE
DUAL FALLACIES
( 60 )
NO CREDIT, NO BLAME
r ATTENTION
PAST BURDENS
( 62 )
GEORGE’S TEACHING
DIMENSIONS OF LIFE
( 64 )
MADNESS Λ
The mad are persecuted because so many find it
hard to love them. As for madness itself, it is the feel
ing that we can’t love until we have time. Until we
love, we will never have the time.
THE INMATES
( 66 )
SEX AND NIRVANA
( 71 )
SEX AFTER LIBERATION
( 72 )
CHASTITY AND OTHER PERVERSIONS
( 73 )
WHAT IF EVERYBODY DID IT?
( 74 )
A CURE FOR PARANOIA
( 75 )
JENNY’S LIBERATION IN ACTION
( 77 )
BEN’S ROMANTICISM
( 83 )
ILLUSION AND REALITY
( 85 )
IDENTITY RISK
( 86 )
THE CLOCK
OPEN SECRETS
IMAGINATION
( 88 )
CAUSE AND EFFECT
( 89 )
KEN’S TRUTH
( 90 )
A MYSTICAL EXPERIENCE
( 92 )
SOLVING THE MYSTERY
( 93 )
τ -
( 95 )
INFLATION
( 96 )
V. Meditations
and Exercises
BREATHING MEDITATION
( 98 )
This meditation can teach you to focus attention and to
develop calmness. It can be done anytime during the day for
a period o f twenty to thirty minutes. Once a day is the usual
way. After several weeks of breathing meditation, the results
should be sufficient to tell you whether or not you should
continue breathing meditation.
( 99 )
MOVING MEDITATION
( 100 )
By practicing moving meditation twice a week for a
period of twenty to thirty minutes, most individuals lessen
their muscular tensions and become more at home in their
bodies. It can also be used as an aid in overcoming mental
and physical discomforts produced by stressful situations.
The benefits o f moving meditation will be reflected in
a greater awareness o f the body and eventually a greater ac
ceptance of the physical structure that houses the spirit.
Those who continue the practice will notice that the subjec
tive value o f this meditation changes from time to time. The
practice should be continued as long as the meditator finds
dividends returning from the investment o f time and energy.
WALKING MEDITATION
( 102 )
mantra. With the stomach empty and the mind not under the
influence o f recreational drugs, mentally repeat your mantra
cep- over and over in whatever rhythm seems right to you. Any-
not time that you become aware that you are not saying your
and mantra, return to it.
)r There is no need to try to stop thought. Your thoughts
t are just the way your brain feels when it exercises itself in a
,r certain way. Those thoughts have no more reality than you
d wish to give them. D on’t think about your thoughts—just
raight. note them and let them pass on through. For instance, if
j of you think “What shall I eat for breakfast?” during your morn-
over ing m editation, you can follow that thought with “I am not
eating breakfast now. Now is the time for me to recite my
ra mantra.” Then you mentally recite your mantra again and
,le again until the meditation period ends.
rti- Keep a clock or watch where you can see it. During
the meditation your eyes will be closed, but you may open them
chant to help gauge the time. After a while, clocks will not be es-
tends sential to judging how long you should meditate. When the
•a time is up, arise slowly as if returning from a deep sleep.
Be assured that what happens during meditation is nor
mal for you. When you have quieted the chattering o f the
mind with your mantra, you have gone beyond the conscious
mind and may experience the equivalent o f a dream. Accept
the experience for what it is and for what effect it has on you.
If you feel sleepy after your meditation, sleep unless you
have something more important to do. Frequently you may
find yourself in a place similar to that threshold between wak
ing and sleeping; it is a comfortable spot if recognized as such.
You can meditate alone or in a group. Having others to
reinforce the positive experiences can be an aid in forming
the meditation habit. Don’t slip into the trap o f using your
fects meditation period to control the behavior o f others by mak-
.p ing them feel guilty if they disturb you. You are in charge of
}Ve. yourself and can return to your mantra when the disturbance
n(led is over. If your residence has few periods of quiet, meditate
ition in the morning by awakening earlier and meditate at night
medi- before you sleep.
^ou The values of transcendental meditation have been do-
itinue cumented by scientists, philosophers and religious leaders, but
'tiCe . only you can demonstrate them for yourself. The techniques
e last are simple and readily available. Invest ten hours in yourself
during the next two weeks and see what dividends you receive.
( 103 )
DAILY EXERCISE
ENERGIZING EXERCISE
( 107 )
RELAXATION EXERCISE
( HO )
LIVING EXERCISE
LOVING EXERCISE
( Π1 )
HONESTY EXERCISE
INVITATIONAL EXERCISE
( 112 )
LAUGHING EXERCISE
QUESTIONING EXERCISE
( Π4 )
SEXUAL EXERCISE
( 115 )
GARDEN EXERCISE
( 116 )
GETTING EXERCISE
If you feel that you are not getting what you want out
o f life, this exercise should help you get in touch with the
causes of that feeling and lead you to a more positive state of
mind. List on paper, in any order as they occur to you, all
the things that you want out o f life regardless o f whether they
are concrete or abstract, material or spiritual, emotional or
intellectual.
When the list is as complete as you feel like making it,
start refining it by getting rid o f those items that are not
within your personal sphere of influence. As an example,
world peace might be on your list as something you want for
the world. If it is, draw a line through it because it requires
the entire world to get on your trip. Replace it with some
thing that is personally meaningful—such as a desire to be at
peace with the world or a desire to do all within your power
to add to the amount of peace in the world. Delete all de
sires that require changing the past and substitute goals that
require changing your attitude to what is past or changing
your attitude to present conditions. If neither o f those
changes seems appropriate, list your desire to work toward
changing the existing conditions. Eliminate all those ends
that require specific action by other people because you can
dissipate the energy you need to achieve your goals by ex
pending it attempting to influence others. Next, examine
your material wants, keeping in mind that ownership without
use is material abuse. Free yourself from wanting anything
that would complicate your life without giving you the return
of usefulness.
After you have used your abilities to prune the list of all
that is/inappropriate, put the remaining items down in order
of importance. These are the things you want. Now you
know where to focus your attention and where to expend
your energy.
At whatever intervals seem appropriate, review and re
vise your list. Add any item that you are sure belongs there
and cross o ff those achieved or no longer desired. Maintain
the list for as long as it is useful in helping you get what you
want.
( Π7 )
PAIN-EASING MEDITATION
( 118 )
PLEASURE EXERCISE
SECRET EXERCISE
SILENT EXERCISE
( 119 )
LIBIDO EXERCISE
( 120 )
PHYSICAL EXERCISE
( 121 )
REPROGRAMMING EXERCISE
( 122 )
INVENTIVE EXERCISE
( 123 )
RECOMMENDED READING
( 125 )
HAS BEEN RIGHTEOUSLY ORDAINED AS A PRIEST OF
THE PARATHEO-ANAMETAMYSTIKHOOD OF ERIS ESOTERIC
AND THUSLY ENTRUSTED WITH ALL HOLY DUTIES
AND DIVINE PRIVELEGES OF THIS OFFICE
( 126 )
About the Author..,
C a m d e n B e n a re s h a s b e e n in te r e s te d in Z e n f o r a n u m b e r of
y e a rs. P re f e r r in g th e in fo rm a l a p p ro a c h , h e s o u g h t o u t ex am p le s of
h o w Z e n w o rk e d f o r w e s te r n e r s in a w e s te r n e n v iro n m e n t w h ile
re a d in g e v e r y th in g h e c o u ld fin d a b o u t Z e n . In 1965 h e jo in e d th e
D isc o rd ia n S o ciety a n d o b s e rv e d W e s te rn Z e n in th e a c tio n s of
K e rry T h o rn le y , G re g o ry H ill a n d o th e r D isco rd ian s.* H e th e n
b eg an to h av e experien ces, o b ta in in sig h ts an d g a th e r th e in fo rm a tio n
th a t e v e n tu a lly b ecam e th is book.
In a d d itio n to th e u s u a l v a r ie ty o f o c cu p atio n s: W a ite r, clerk,
te c h n ic ia n , t h e a t e r m a n a g e r, te c h n ic a l w r ite r, a lte rn a tiv e p re ss
e d ito r; C a m d e n h a d th e ty p ical v a rie ty o f m a jo rs in colleges:
e n g in e e rin g , b u s in e s s a d m in is tra tio n , th e a te r a r ts , E nglish. H is
a v o c a tio n list in c lu d e s disc jockey, civil rig h ts a ctiv ist, to a s tm a s te r,
co ffee h o u s e com ic, lyrics w r ite r , p sy c h o d ra m a a c to r, sex u al
lib e ra tio n sp o k e s p e rs o n , Z e n le c tu r e r, a n d m e d ita tio n te a c h e r. H e
lives w ith his w ife in Los A n g e le s w h e r e h e is c u r re n tly d o ing b o th
tech n ical a n d fre e la n c e w ritin g .