Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
Do not Bodies act upon Light at a distance, and by their action bend its
Rays, and is not this action strongest at the least distance?
-Isaac Newton, Opticks, 1704
I. Introduction
which occurs when light from a bright, distant source in space bends around a
Gravitational lenses vary depending on the exact position of the light source
and massive object relative to the observer's perspective. When the source and
massive object are perfectly aligned with the viewer’s line of sight, a bright ring of
light is observed surrounding the massive "lensing" object (see Figure 1). (This
ring.”) If the lensing object is not exactly aligned, the ring disappears and a
the background source may be viewed. When the objects line up well enough
that the true position of the background source falls within the radius of the
lensing object, then multiple images appear, as the two light paths are different
distances around the galaxy and create multiple images (Schneider, 1999). See
Figure 2.`
The bending of light due to the gravitational field of an object was first
listed for further exploration in the conclusion of his classic Opticks in 1704 [1].
The first person known to address the concern in detail was physicist Johann
Soldner, who wrote a mostly ignored paper "On the Deflection of a Light Ray
from its Straight Motion due to the Attraction of a World Body which it Passes
4
light ray passing close to the solar limb would be deflected by an angle of .875
although the lens-like quality of this bending of light was not immediately seized
begun deriving his "basic lensing equation for a point like light source and a point
like gravitating mass" as early as 1912 (Sauer, 2007). This speculation did not
“occur in a vacuum,” however, and once general relativity was published other
physicist Orest Chwolson, who predicted ring-like distortions of light when two
stars were perfectly aligned in the field of view of an astronomer, and "factious
double stars" when the stars were imperfectly aligned within an angle of
maximum deflection (Chwolson, 1924). To Einstein the lensing effect was almost
only expounded upon the idea in published form upon the prodding of an
electrical engineer, Rudi Mandl (Sauer, 2007). As he put it at the end of his 1936
1936).
The following year, physicist Fritz Zwicky aptly speculated that massive
galaxies were more likely to be gravitationally lensed than stars, and that
Although this idea could not be confirmed at the time due to the limitations of
century in 1979 when the "Twin QSO" was observed (Walsh, 1979). This
lensing effects have been observed in over a hundred locations in the observable
universe (Hubble Press Release, 2005) and the phenomenon is being used to
observational astrophysics.
The theory of general relativity reveals that the presence of matter warps
space-time around it, and the more mass is present, the stronger is the “warp.”
For strong distortions of space-time, the path of light that passes through such a
general relativity, which run from mild distortions of light to the impressive
singularities in the cores of black holes from which light can never escape
(2)
(where M is the mass within a radius ξ, provided that the impact parameter ξ is
(3)
(4)
(5)
(6)
and for the case where the source lies exactly behind the lens we obtain
8
(7)
where θ is the angular radius of the image (“Einstein ring”). For an isolated point
source, we get
(8)
which reveals that for the point source, we will obtain two images of the source
magnification as
(10)
(12)
9
reveals the total visible magnification. A Jacobian lens mapping and time delays
can now be calculated, but this is beyond the scope of our introduction.
Much like earthly lenses of glass, gravitational lenses have been used as
may be used to better understand the nature and distribution of luminous and
dark matter in the universe, to infer the distance scale of the universe by aiding in
density, to study lensing effects of black holes with singularities to aid in the
to determine the size and structure of quasars, to study the size of absorbing
extrasolar planets.
Macrolensing
are being used probe information on the distribution of baryonic (light reflecting)
matter and non-baryonic (dark) matter in the universe. There are two kinds of
If the light from a distant object is bent to such a great extent that
we, the observer, can see more than one image of single source, then
use of Einstein rings, arc effects, multiply imaged quasars, and clusters
effects are much more common than the giant arcs and multiple images
associated with strong lensing. There are two major ways in which weak lensing
produces measurable effects. In the first case, background galaxies are weakly
1996). In the second case, weak magnification changes the observed number
11
surface brightness. These cases are often examined for evidence of “cosmic
shear.”
Microlensing
When a light source passes behind an object of compact mass, the focusing
effect on the light leads to a temporary change in the energy flux (brightness) of
the star. The optical effect is not visible as in macrolensing but has been
observed since the early 1990s by monitoring a large number of stars in the
bulge of our Galaxy, in the Magellanic Clouds and in the Andromeda galaxy
Microlensing is used primarily in the search for dark matter in our galaxy and
close neighbors, as such lenses can be used to detect objects that cannot be
are also being used to detect binary star systems, as well as expoplanets as light
from binary stars or stars with exoplanets is lensed differently than light of lone
stars.
12
A Survey of Literature
beyond the scope of this paper, a look into several major categories--
observation and data mining, applications in clusters and galaxy evolution, the
are being undertaken for valuable data mining. These longterm studies and
surveys include projects such as SLACS, CASTLES, MACHO, MOA and OGLE.
microlensing data useful in detecting dark matter, binary systems, dark matter
the Mt. Stromlo & Siding Spring Observatories, the Center for Particle
Astrophysics at the Santa Barbara, San Diego, and Berkeley campuses of the
the primary aim of testing the hypothesis that a significant fraction of the dark
matter in the halo of the Milky Way is made up of MACHOS such as brown
Survey) and SLACS (the Sloan Lens ACS Survey) are making use of recent high
(Falco, 1999). The SLACS surveyors are in the process of identifying and
studying a large and uniform sample of strong gravitational lens galaxies using
Hubble in combination with the recent Sloan Digital Sky Survey (Bolton, 2006).
Via SLACS alone, the number of identified gravitational lenses has quadrupled
(NASA, 2005).
Weak lensing is being used to determine the masses of clusters and other
astronomical objects (Kaiser and Squires, 1993, Bartelmann, 1995). The method
by Kaiser and Squires (Kaiser and Squires, 1993) and has since been refined
(Wambsganns, 2010).
ago can be compared with gravitational lenses today, and it can be determined
whether the distribution of dark and visible mass changes in cosmic time (Ma,
2006). Samples of spiral galaxy lenses have been determined to provide useful
masses and shapes of galactic halo, disk and bulges (Keetan and Kochanek,
2010). Models such as galaxy growth via colllision can furthermore be checked
using simulations and data collected from surveys such as SLACS. Recently,
simulations have been run to test the impact of dry merging on evolution of early-
type galaxies, with results indicating that less than 20% of early-type galaxy
Both binary star systems and planets outside of our solar system are currently
1991; Udalski, 2003; Gould and Loeb, 1992; Wambsganns, 1997; Beaulieu,
2006). Over two hundred planets in over 170 star systems have been found,
including a recently found cool planet of 5.5 earth masses (Beaulieu, 2006).
semi-major axes in the range 1-5 AU. Such planets may be revealed orbiting
enough to distinguish deviations with features lasting just a few hours (Beaulieu,
2006).
15
binaries and planets using microlensing. The procedures are similar. “Of
stars, or first caustic crossing [here “caustic” refers to the envelope of light rays
caustics typically lasts a few hours so it is essential to observe the event every
time scale can also be of the order of hours and again frequent observations of
As a magnifying glass held close to your face distorts more of your field of view
than one held at arm's length, stars in the very near universe lens background
stars more often for earth observers. This effect, dubbed “mesolensing,” was
equal to the Einstein radius. By fortuitous coincidence, the Einstein radius is very
close to the radius of planets orbiting in an area known as the “habitable zone”
(the zone where earthlike life is most likely to evolve). Furthermore, Di Stefano’s
group notes that individual nearby dwarf stars can produce lensing events at
predictable times, and that careful monitoring of these events could reveal
events are unprecedented. (Di Stefano, 2008; Di Stefano and Night, 2008.)
16
matter using weak lensing were developed by Kaiser and Squires in 1993, and
distribution in the Abell 901/902 supercluster, finding maximal peaks in the dark
Some recent results indicate that MACHOs are not as significant a contributor
to dark matter as once thought. Observations made toward the Large Magellanic
Cloud show that there are fewer microlensing events than expected if the halo of
the Milky Way was entirely composed of MACHOs (Gates, 1998). The MACHO
project has found that the maximum likelihood analysis gives a MACHO halo
may also be studied via mass determination using galactic lensing techniques
(Mao, 2001; Rusin, 2005). A 2005 theoretical paper by Rusin, Keeton and Winn
determined that when a central lens is detected, the mass of a black hole can be
Cosmic Principles
constrain, values for certain important physical constants including the Hubble
constant and the cosmological constant (Blandford and Kundic, 1997, Fukugita,
our ability to determine the distance scale and overall shape and ultimate fate of
cosmological constant the optical depth increases rapidly as the source redshift
increases, and the lens distribution has a peak at a substantially deeper redshift
“ultimately every object in the sky is affected by (ever so slight) lensing effects.”
We will close our paper with one last strange and speculative, yet still possible
and a quasar. The galaxy bends the ray of light around itself and splits the image
into two rays. It has been long been known, according to the delayed choice
variation of the double slit experiment developed by John Wheeler, that when we
observe the arrival of a photon which has a choice of paths, we may determine
via measurement by half silvered mirrors which path a photon appears to travel,
. Although a distant quasar may be billions of light years away, this implies that
we can at least appear to force, via measurement, a photon to choose its path to
earth along a certain path billions of years into the cosmic past.
REFERENCES
Abe, F. (The PLANET collaboration), “The MOA Project”, in Ferlet, R., Maillard,
J.P., and Raban, B., eds., Variables Stars and the Astrophysical Returns of the
Microlensing Surveys, Proceedings of the 12th IAP Astrophysics Meeting, July 8
– 12, 1996, Institut d’Astrophysique de Paris, (Editions Frontières, Gif-sur-Yvette,
1997).
Alcock, C., et al. Binary Microlensing Events from the MACHO Project. The
Astrophysical Journal, Volume 541, Issue 1, pp. 270-297. ADS:
http://adsabs.harvard.edu/abs/2000ApJ...541..270A
Alcock, C., et al. The MACHO Project: Microlensing Results from 5.7 Years of
Large Magellanic Cloud Observations. The Astrophysical Journal, Volume 542,
Issue 1, pp. 281-307. (2000)
Bartelmann, M., “Cluster mass estimates from weak lensing”, Astron. Astrophys.,
303, 643–655, (1995).
Blandford, R.D., and Kundić, T., “Gravitational Lensing and the Extragalactic
Distance Scale”, in Livio, M., Donahue, M., and Panagia, N., eds., The
Extragalactic Distance Scale, Proceedings of the ST ScI Symposium, held in
Baltimore, Maryland, May 7 – 10, 1996, Space Telescope Science Institute
Symposium Series, vol. 10, pp. 60–75, (Cambridge University Press, Cambridge;
New York, 1997).
Bolton, Adam, et al. The Sloan Lens ACS Survey. I. A Large Spectroscopically
Selected Sample of Massive Early-Type Lens Galaxies. 2006 ApJ 638 703
Eddington, AS, et al. "A Determination of the Deflection of Light by the Sun's
Gravitational Field, from Observations Made at the Solar eclipse of May 29,
1919". Phil. Trans. Roy. Soc. A 220: 291–333
Einstein, A., “Lens-like action of a star by the deviation of light in the gravitational
field”, Science, 84, 506, (1936).
11. Ferreras, Ignacio;, et al. Mapping the Distribution of Luminous and Dark
Matter in Strong Lensing Galaxies. Dark Galaxies and Lost Baryons,
Proceedings of the International Astronomical Union, IAU Symposium, Volume
244, p. 206-215’
Fukugita, M., Futamase, T., and Kasai, M., “A possible test for the cosmological
constant with gravitational lenses”, Mon. Not. R. Astron. Soc., 246, 24–27, (1990)
Gates, E.I., Gyuk, G., Holer, G.P., and Turner, M.S., “No Need for MACHOs in the Halo”,
Heymans, Catherine, et al. The dark matter environment of the Abell 901/902
supercluster: a weak lensing analysis of the HST STAGES survey. Monthly
Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society. Volume 385 Issue 3, Pages 1431 - 1442
Hu, Wayne. Weak lensing of the CMB: A harmonic approach. Physical Review D
(Particles, Fields, Gravitation, and Cosmology), Volume 62, Issue 4, 15 August
21
Jackson, N., ed., Golden Lenses: The Hubble Constant and Galaxies at High
Redshift, Proceedings of a workshop held at Jodrell Bank, University of
Manchester, June 23 – 25 1997, (Jodrell Bank Observatory, Manchester, 1997).
Kaiser, Nick and Gordon Squires. Mapping the Dark Matter with Weak
Gravitational Lensing. Astrophysical Journal, Part 1 (ISSN 0004-637X), vol. 404,
no. 2, p. 441-450. (1993)
NASA, et al, 2005. Hubble, Sloan Quadruple Number of Known Optical Einstein
Rings. News Release Number: STScI-2005-32
http://hubblesite.org/newscenter/archive/releases/2005/32/
22
Petters, Arlie O., et al. Singularity theory and gravitational lensing. Birkhäuser,
2001
Rusin, D., Keeton, C.R., Winn, J.N. 2005. Measuring Supermassive Black
Holes in Distant Galaxies with Central Lensed Images. Astrophysical Journal
627, L93-L96.
Sauer, Tilman. Nova Geminorum 1912 and the Origin of the Idea of
Gravitational Lensing. Einstein Papers Project, California Institute of Technology.
2007. arXiv:0704.0963v1 [physics.hist-ph]
Soldner, Johann. Ueber die Ablenkung eines Lichtstrals von seiner geradlinigen
Bewegung, durch die Attraktion eines Weltkörpers. Berliner Astronomisches
Jahrbuch auf das Jahr, 1804'
Zwicky, F., “On the Probability of Detecting Nebulae Which Act as Gravitational
Lenses”, Phys. Rev. Lett., 51, 290, (1937).