Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
1
Professeur de Théologie Liturgique à l’Institut de Théologie Orthodoxe Saint-
Serge de Paris.
140 Archimandrite Prof. Dr. Job Getcha
2
See his book: G. BARROIS, The Face of Christ in the Old Testament. Crestwood,
NY, 1974.
3
Great Canon, canticle 6:8. [MOTHER MARY - KALLISTOS WARE, The Lenten
Triodion, London, 1978, p. 398]. Cf.: Exod. 17:6, Num. 20:8, 1 Cor. 10:4.
4
Great Canon, canticle 6:9 [MOTHER MARY - KALLISTOS WARE, The Lenten
Triodion, p. 398]. Cf.: Exod. 17:6, Num. 20:8, Jn. 19:34, 1 Cor. 10:4.
5
Great Canon, canticle 5:11[MOTHER MARY - KALLISTOS WARE, The Lenten
Triodion, p. 395]. Cf.: Exod. 14:16.
6
Octoechos, Tone 8, first aposticha of Wednesday matins.
7
Octoechos, Tone 8, second hymn at the Beatitudes on Wednesday morning.
142 Archimandrite Prof. Dr. Job Getcha
Many other hymns from the Octoechos likewise see the figure of the
Cross in such events of the Old Testament as Moses stretching his hands
on high (Exod. 17:10-14)8 or Isaac laying his hands crosswise to bless his
two sons (Gen. 48:14)9.
Saint Andrew of Crete once again uses typological exegesis to
interpret the New Testament when, following the Epistles to the Hebrews,
he sees in Melchizedek a figure of Christ: “Follow the example of
Melchizedek, the priest of God, the King set apart, who was an image of
the life of Christ among men in the world”10.
Our hymnographer also sees the figure of Christ in the person of
Joseph the Patriarch: “As a figure of the Lord, O my soul, the righteous
and gentle Joseph was sold into bondage by his brethren…”11. And he
adds that Joseph was more specifically a figure of the death and
resurrection of the Lord: “Once Joseph was cast into a pit, O Lord and
Master, as a figure of Thy Burial and Resurrection”12. We find the same
interpretation in another canon of Saint Andrew for Holy Monday, where
he says: “Joseph is an image of the Master: he was thrown into a pit and
sold by his brethren, but he suffered all these things with patience, as a
true figure of Christ”13.
Although Andrew, with all the Church Fathers, delights in finding
the face of Christ in the Old Testament, this christocentric reading is not
systematic. In some passages of the Great Canon, he prefers to give a
quite different interpretation of some Old Testament figures than the more
frequent one.
8
Octoechos, Tone 8, Canon of the Cross 3:2 on Friday morning; second sticheron
at Lord, I have cried, for the great vespers of the Exaltation of the Cross [MOTHER MARY
- KALLISTOS WARE, The Festal Menaion, London, 1969, p. 133].
9
Third sticheron at the Lity, for the great vespers of the Exaltation of the Cross
[MOTHER MARY - KALLISTOS WARE, The Festal Menaion, p. 137].
10
Great Canon, canticle 3:22 [MOTHER MARY - KALLISTOS WARE, The Lenten
Triodion, p. 387]. Cf.: Gen. 14:18 and Heb. 7:1-3.
11
Great Canon, canticle 5:4 [MOTHER MARY - KALLISTOS WARE, The Lenten
Triodion, p. 394]. Cf.: Gen. 37:27.
12
Great Canon, canticle 5:5 [MOTHER MARY - KALLISTOS WARE, The Lenten
Triodion, p. 395]. Cf.: Gen. 37:27.
13
Canon 8 :3. [MOTHER MARY - KALLISTOS WARE, The Lenten Triodion, p. 507].
READING THE BIBLE WITH SAINT ANDREW OF CRETE 143
14
Great Canon, canticle 4:6 [MOTHER MARY - KALLISTOS WARE, The Lenten
Triodion, p. 391]. Cf.: Gen. 28:12.
15
Origen, ***.
16
Great Canon, canticle 3:17 [MOTHER MARY - KALLISTOS WARE, The Lenten
Triodion, p. 386]. Cf.: Gen 18:1-15.
17
Great Canon, canticle 5:10 [MOTHER MARY - KALLISTOS WARE, The Lenten
Triodion, p. 395]. Cf.: Exod. 3:1-6.
144 Archimandrite Prof. Dr. Job Getcha
18
Great Canon, canticle 4:13 [MOTHER MARY - KALLISTOS WARE, The Lenten
Triodion, p. 391]. Cf.: Job 2:8-10.
19
Great Canon, canticle 8:10 [MOTHER MARY - KALLISTOS WARE, The Lenten
Triodion, p. 407]. Cf.: Jonah 1, 3.
20
For example, John Cassian, Conférences XIV, 8 (SC 54, 189-190). Cf. HENRI
DE LUBAC, Exégèse médiévale. Les quatre sens de l’Ecriture. Paris, 1959, I, p. 155, II,
p. 425-681 ; ID. Histoire et Esprit. L’intelligence de l’Ecriture d’après Origène. Paris,
1950, p. 139-144.
READING THE BIBLE WITH SAINT ANDREW OF CRETE 145
know, among various other forms of teaching, our Lord used parables, a
form which was known not only among Jews but also among other
people. We find about thirty of them in the Gospels. Most of them are
illustrations of the Kingdom of God in familiar earthly things and
incidents. But what is particular in the interpretation given by Saint
Andrew is that he sees in them an illustration not only of the Kingdom to
come, but of the divine economy already realised through the Incarnation
of the Son of God. Behind the figures of the parables, he sees Christ.
For instance, in the parable of the Prodigal Son, he sees in the father
coming to greet the prodigal son a figure of Christ, the Son of God
incarnate, coming to save fallen humanity: “Though I have sinned, O
Saviour, yet I know that Thou art full of loving-kindness. Thou dost see
me weeping and dost run to meet me, like the Father calling back the
Prodigal Son”21. This of course is not a reading particular to Andrew of
Crete, since many other Byzantine liturgical texts suggest such an
interpretation. For an example, we read in the Lenten Triodion, in the
canon at matins of the Sunday of the Prodigal Son: “Open Thine arms, O
Christ, and in loving-kindness receive me as I return from a far country of
sin and passions”22.
Another striking example is the Parable of the Good Samaritan,
very often interpreted in a moralistic way. Here, our hymnographer gives
a soteriological interpretation, seeing in the Good Samaritan a figure of
Christ coming to save and heal human nature: “The priest saw me first,
but passed by on the other side; the Levite looked on me in my distress,
but despised my nakedness. O Jesus, sprung from Mary, do Thou come to
me and take pity on me”23. This kind of interpretation is once again not
unusual with Byzantine hymnographers. If one looks into the Lenten
Triodion, one will find a very ancient canon for matins of the fourth
Sunday of Great Lent, which was initially dedicated to the Good
Samaritan, where we read: “O Christ my Saviour, I have become like the
21
Great Canon, canticle 1,12. Cf.: Luke 15:20.
22
Canon 3:3. [MOTHER MARY - KALLISTOS WARE, The Lenten Triodion, p. 116].
23
Great Canon, canticle 1:15 [MOTHER MARY - KALLISTOS WARE, The Lenten
Triodion, p. 379]. Cf.: Luke 10:31-33.
146 Archimandrite Prof. Dr. Job Getcha
man who fell among thieves, who was wounded and left half dead”24.
“When the priest and the Levite saw me, they could not help me, but
passed by on the other side. But Thou in Thy compassion hast given me
salvation and preserved me”25. This kind of interpretation was in fact very
common for the Church Fathers.
Inspired by the Fourth Gospel, where Christ Himself declares that
He is the Good Shepherd (Jn. 10:11), Saint Andrew of Crete interprets the
parable of the lost sheep in a similar soteriological way: “Thou art the
Good Shepherd: seek me, the lamb that has strayed, and do not forget
me”26. Once more, Andrew is following the pattern of patristic exegesis.
One can, for example, find a similar interpretation of this parable in the
works of Saint Gregory the Theologian: “[Christ] humbled Himself for
your sake, and because He came to seek for that which had wandered, He,
the Good Shepherd, who layeth down His life for the sheep, came upon
the mountains and hills upon which you used to sacrifice, and found the
wandering one; and having found it, He took it upon His shoulders, on
which He also bore the wood [of the Cross] and having borne it, brought
it back to the life above…”27.
The parable of the lost coin is treated by Saint Andrew in
conjunction with the parable of the lost sheep, which immediately
precedes it. He sees in the woman, who lights a lamp to search for the lost
coin, an image of Christ who comes to save humanity: “O Saviour, I am
the coin marked with the King’s likeness, which Thou hast lost of old.
But, O Word, light Thy lamp, Thy Forerunner, and seek and find again
Thine image”28. The interpretation given to this parable by Saint Andrew
is once more typically patristic. Our hymnographer is again inspired by
Saint Gregory the Theologian, who stated: “[Christ] lit the candle, His
own flesh, and swept the house, by cleaning away the sin of the world,
24
I Canon, 1:1. [MOTHER MARY - KALLISTOS WARE, The Lenten Triodion,
p. 357].
25
I Canon 5:3. [MOTHER MARY - KALLISTOS WARE, The Lenten Triodion,
p. 360].
26
Great Canon, canticle 3:6 [MOTHER MARY - KALLISTOS WARE, The Lenten
Triodion, p. 385]. Cf.: Jn 10:11, Luke 15:4-6.
27
GREGORY THE THEOLOGIAN, Second Oration on Pascha, 26.
28
Great Canon, canticle 6:15 [MOTHER MARY - KALLISTOS WARE, The Lenten
Triodion, p. 398]. Cf.: Luke 15:8, Jn. 5:35.
READING THE BIBLE WITH SAINT ANDREW OF CRETE 147
and sought for the coin, the Royal image that was all covered up with
passions; He calls together His friends, the Angelic Powers, at the finding
of the coin, and makes them sharers of His joy, as He had before made
them sharers of the secret of His incarnation”29. We should make two
observations about Andrew’s interpretation of this parable. First, he takes
the example of the coin, which bears an effigy of the emperor, as an
image of human nature created in God’s image and likeness. Secondly,
following the interpretation given by the Fourth Gospel (Jn.5:35), he sees
in the light used by the woman searching for the coin a figure of Saint
John the Forerunner, who in Byzantine hymnography is traditionally
called the Lamp of the Word30.
In the Great Canon, Saint Andrew of Crete makes an interesting
combination of the parable of the ten virgins (Mt 25,1-13) and the parable
of the marriage feast (22:11-13): “I am deprived of the bridal chamber, of
the wedding and the supper; for want of oil my lamp has gone out; while I
slept the door was closed; the supper has been eaten; I am bound hand and
foot, and cast out”31. The Fathers of the Church almost unanimously saw
in the parable of the marriage feast a summary of salvation history and a
figure of the Incarnation of the Son of God as the wedding of Christ and
His Church or the union between God and human souls, just as they saw
in the parable of the ten virgins awaiting the coming of the bridegroom a
figure of believers awaiting the coming of Christ. But this time, the
interpretation given by Andrew is not soteriological but moral. He follows
nevertheless a patristic interpretation of the parable of the ten virgins,
where oil is considered as the symbol of good works, compassion or
almsgiving. We can find a similar interpretation in another canon of Saint
Andrew of Crete for Holy Monday at Compline: “May thy lamp shine
brightly, O my soul; and, like the lamps of the five virgins, may it
overflow with the oil of compassion; and so thou shalt find open before
thee the door of Christ’s bridal chamber”32. But since the Great Canon is
29
Gregory the Theologian, ***.
30
See for example : Canon for June 24 by Saint John of Damascus 5:2 ; Canon
for June 24 by Saint Andrew of Crete 5:4 ; Canon for August 29 by Saint John of
Damascus 7 :3 ; Canon of August 29 by Saint Andrew of Crete 9:3.
31
Great Canon, canticle 4:21 [MOTHER MARY - KALLISTOS WARE, The Lenten
Triodion, p. 392]. Cf.: Mt 25,1-13; 22:11-13.
32
Canon 8 :3. [MOTHER MARY - KALLISTOS WARE, The Lenten Triodion, p. 521].
148 Archimandrite Prof. Dr. Job Getcha
33
Great Canon, canticle 1:6 [MOTHER MARY - KALLISTOS WARE, The Lenten
Triodion, p. 378]. Cf.: Gen 3:23.
READING THE BIBLE WITH SAINT ANDREW OF CRETE 149
34
Great Canon, canticle 2:4 [MOTHER MARY - KALLISTOS WARE, The Lenten
Triodion, p. 381]. Cf.: Mt 14:28-31.
35
O. CLÉMENT, Le chant des larmes. Essai sur le repentir. Paris, 1982, p. 40-41.
150 Archimandrite Prof. Dr. Job Getcha
and repentance. Therefore, he looks into the Bible to find some figures of
great sinners to which he compares his own sins and negative actions:
“Like Cain, O miserable soul, we too have offered, to the Creator of
all, defiled actions and a polluted sacrifice and a worthless life; and so we
also are condemned”36.
“Like David, I have fallen into lust and I am covered with
filth…”37.
Sometimes, he considers himself worse than the great sinners of the
Bible:
“Adam was justly banished from Eden because he disobeyed one
commandment of Thine, O Saviour. What then shall I suffer, for I am
always rejecting Thy words of life?”38.
“David once joined sin to sin, adding murder to fornication; yet
then he showed at once a twofold repentance. But thou, my soul, art more
gravely sick than he, yet thou hast not repented before God”39.
Having compare himself to Adam, Cain, David, Solomon, the
Harlot and other sinners of the Bible, he then turns himself to the figures
of the Just, which he takes as models, and exhorts his soul to follow their
good actions:
“Flee, my soul, like Lot, from the burning of sin; flee from Sodom
and Gomorrah; flee from the flame of every brutish desire”40.
“Rise up and make war against the passions of the flesh, as Joshua
against Amalek, ever gaining victory over the Gibeonites, thy deceitful
thoughts”41.
36
Great Canon, canticle 1:9 [MOTHER MARY - KALLISTOS WARE, The Lenten
Triodion, p. 379]. Cf.: Gen 4:5.
37
Great Canon, canticle 2:23 [MOTHER MARY - KALLISTOS WARE, The Lenten
Triodion, p. 382]. Cf.: 2 Sam. 11:2-4.
38
Great Canon, canticle 1:6 [MOTHER MARY - KALLISTOS WARE, The Lenten
Triodion, p. 378]. Cf.: Gen. 3:6.
39
Great Canon, canticle 7:5 [MOTHER MARY - KALLISTOS WARE, The Lenten
Triodion, p. 402]. Cf.: 2 Sam. 11:13.
40
Great Canon, canticle 3:24 [MOTHER MARY - KALLISTOS WARE, The Lenten
Triodion, p. 387]. Cf.: Gen. 19:17-25.
41
Great Canon, canticle 6:11 [MOTHER MARY - KALLISTOS WARE, The Lenten
Triodion, p. 398]. Cf.: Exod. 17:8-13; Josh. 9:3-27.
READING THE BIBLE WITH SAINT ANDREW OF CRETE 151
One can notice in this last passage that Saint Andrew of Crete,
following Origen and all the patristic tradition, gives a spiritual
interpretation of the wars of the Old Testament. Joshua is seen not only as
a figure of Christ, but as well as a figure of our soul called to fight not
Amalek and the Gibeonites, but the passion of the flesh and deceitful
thoughts.
Playing with the theme of imitation, the author of the Great Canon
tries, through a spiritual reading of the biblical text, to wake up his soul,
as well as the soul of each believer, and bring it towards repentance,
towards conversion, which is not only the theme of the Great Canon but
the deep meaning of salvation history.
Conclusion
Speaking of the Bible, Origen once said: “As man is composed, as
we say, of a body, a soul and a spirit, in the same way is composed the
Holy Scripture, given for the salvation of man by God’s generosity”42.
Origen, therefore, usually saw three meanings in each passage of
Scripture: a historical one corresponding to the body, a moral one
corresponding to the soul, and a spiritual one corresponding to the spirit.
In order to speak of Scripture in the Orthodox Church, we have
chosen to read the Bible with Saint Andrew of Crete through his
masterpiece, the Great Penitential Canon. We have seen that our author
was in fact not only a great hymnographer and preacher, but also a
profound interpreter of the Bible. From what we have said, we will retain
three important points.
1. Like most of the Church Fathers, Saint Andrew adopted a
pluralistic interpretation of the Bible. Each biblical passage ought not to
be interpreted not only in one particular manner, let us say historical,
spiritual or moral, but can be interpreted in each of these ways. In his
Great canon, he has of course privileged the spiritual meaning of
Scripture. In a typological reading of the biblical text, where the Old and
the New Testaments are united, everything is recapitulated by Christ and
in Christ.
2. But the typological links do not only unite major figures of the
Old Testament with Christ in a relation of type and antitype; they also
42
ORIGEN, Peri archôn, IV, 2, 4.
152 Archimandrite Prof. Dr. Job Getcha
unite any biblical figure – such as those of the parables – with each one of
us who participates in the liturgical worship of the Church.
3. The hymnographer’s intention is to read the Scriptures in a
spiritual way, and following the path of Saint Paul and of the Church
Fathers, to apply the biblical figures to the believer’s soul. Thereby,
biblical history becomes our personal history; salvation history becomes
indeed the story of our own salvation. The achievements and the failures
of the different biblical characters become figures of our own mistakes or
our own conversion. Through this typological link, one can say indeed
that biblical history recapitulates the history of each human being. The
Bible is not a dead book, but a living one, which speaks to each one of us
today. Lets us therefore, follow Saint Andrew’s invitation to “imitate the
holy acts of the righteous and flee from the sins of the wicked”43.
43
Great Canon, canticle 8:12 [MOTHER MARY - KALLISTOS WARE, The Lenten
Triodion, p. 408].