Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
INOCULATION
THE TECHNOLOGY OF GRAPHITE SHAPE CONTROL
Inoculation is a means of controlling inoculation is inadequate. There are under practical foundry conditions.
the structure and properties of cast several reasons why chilled structures are Due to variations in chemistry, pouring
iron by minimizing undercooling and normally undesirable. Chilled structures temperature, solidification rate, section
increasing the number of nucleation are hard and brittle and interfere with thickness and other conditions, the metal
sites during solidification. An inoculant machining, necessitate additional heat will cool below the eutectic temperature
is a material added to the liquid iron just treatment operations, resulting in non- before the start of final solidification.
prior to casting that will provide a suitable conformance with specifications and, If the undercooling is slight, random
phase for nucleation of graphite during in general, increase the total cost of graphite flakes form uniformly in the iron
the subsequent cooling. Traditionally, production. matrix, see Figure 1. This is known as
inoculants have been based on Type A graphite. As the undercooling
graphite, ferrosilicon or calcium silicide. Inoculation changes the structure of cast increases, the graphite will branch,
Almost exclusively, inoculants today iron by altering the solidification process. forming abnormal patterns. This is known
are ferrosilicon based containing small A look at the solidification process for as Types B, D and E graphite. A further
quantities of active elements such as Al, hypoeutectic grey iron (iron with a carbon increase in undercooling will suppress
Ba, Ca, Sr, Zr and RE. equivalent less than 4.3%) helps in the formation of graphite and results in a
understanding the effect of inoculation: hard white iron carbide structure.
The purpose of inoculation is to assist in
providing enough nucleation sites for the The first metal to solidify in hypoeutectic The role of the inoculant is to produce
carbon to precipitate as graphite rather grey iron is primary austenite. As cooling nuclei in the liquid iron melt which
than iron carbide (cementite, Fe 3C). This continues, the remaining iron grows richer enhance the graphite nucleation with a
is done by preventing undercooling down in dissolved carbon. Eventually, this low degree of undercooling. This will in
to temperatures below the metastable liquid reaches the eutectic composition turn, promote the formation of Type A
eutectic temperature where carbidic of 4.3% carbon equivalent, at which graphite structures in grey cast irons, and
(white) structures are formed. The iron final or eutectic solidification starts a high number of small graphite nodules
solidification mechanism is prone to under equilibrium condition However, in ductile cast irons.
form chilled iron structures when the equilibrium solidification does not occur
- during solidification
- during heat treatment
Foundrisil®, Superseed®, Superseed® Extra, Ultraseed®, Barinoc®, Zircinoc®, Reseed®, SMZ® and Vaxon®
inoculants are registered trademarks of Elkem AS
Preseed™ is a trademark of Elkem AS
The microstructure of an iron casting This review demonstrates that cementite and graphite, with austenite
consists of several phases, each having solidification results in a minimum of playing only a minor role
varying levels of carbon, iron and other two solid phases; and austenite is
elements present. Table 1 shows the present in all the phase combinations.
analysis and specific densities of the solid As the casting cools, the austenite
and liquid phases which take part in the subsequently transforms to pearlite
solidification process. When solidification and/or ferrite at a lower temperature
is complete, the following combination of (eutectoid transformation).
phases may be found:
Of all the solid phases listed above,
1) Austenite + Graphite cementite has the highest hardness (~660 Table 1: Approximate analysis and specific
= GREY structure HB), whilst graphite is a relatively soft densities of phases in the solidification range
2) Austenite + Graphite + Cementite material of low density, which can act as of cast iron with 2.4% Si.
= MOTTLED structure a lubricant. Hardness and machinability
3) Austenite + Cementite of the as-cast structure are, therefore,
= WHITE structure influenced by the relative amounts of
2. Structure Stability
When crystallisation of eutectic cast iron -Grey iron: graphite lamellae start oxide where X can be Ca, Ba, Sr, Ce, Zr
in chilled specimens is studied, a gradual growing from a common centre and stays surrounded by the magnesium sulphide.
advance of the solidification front is in contact with the melt as austenite fills
revealed. Transformation does not take the spaces between the lamellae.
place instantaneously or uniformly over a Lamellar
cross section. Initial solidification occurs -Nodular iron: a graphite nodule forms
at the surface from distinct crystallization first and is surrounded by austenite at a
centres and after some time a solid/ later stage.
liquid interface forms. Other isolated
crystallisation centres are active in the In eutectic nodular iron, the nodule Nodular
remaining melt and initiate the formation number is virtually identical with the
of solid, see Figures 3 and 4. These number of eutectic cells.
isolated areas are called eutectic cells.
The mechanism described is for eutectic
Eventually, cells grow at the expense solidification and is not influenced by the
of the liquid, and a solid cast structure presence of kish (primary) graphite or Figure 3: Eutectic cells for lamellar and nodular graphite
develops. Each eutectic cell consists of austenite dendrites.
graphite and austenite with graphite as
the primary phase. The nuclei substances can be more
easily observed in nodular graphite
Precipitation is initiated by randomly iron than in grey iron, since it is easy to
distributed crystallisation centres, called locate the centre of a graphite spheroid.
nuclei. These nuclei offer favourable sites Measurements have shown that the
for the deposition of carbon atoms and, nuclei are between 0.5 to 2.0 microns
subsequently, precipitation of graphite in diameter, with a bulk chemical
and austenite onto existing graphite composition of magnesium sulphide
continues. The morphology of these cells and magnesium silicate.1 A similar
for grey iron shows a marked difference investigation of nuclei composition for
with that for nodular iron, as can be seen grey iron has shown that the nucleus Figure 4: Solidification of near eutectic iron 2
from Figure 3. has a core of a complex aluminium-X-
5.1 Number of Nuclei About 2.4wt% graphite and 97.6wt% austenite are formed during the crystallization
of eutectic (nodular) cast iron, which corresponds to approximately 8 vol% graphite
and 92 vol% austenite. The mean diameter of graphite nodules is usually between
10-80 microns, although lower and higher values are possible. This leads to
about 3000 to 30,000 nodules per cubic millimetre depending on the section
size (cooling rate) of the casting. The total number of possible nuclei for graphite
(inclusions) will be at least one order of magnitude larger than this graphite nodule
density. This means that the number of inclusions or possible nuclei for graphite
is at least 100,000 per cubic millimetre and that only a small fraction of these
nuclei actually nucleates graphite during solidification1 . Table 3 gives examples of
number densities and mean particle sizes for nuclei and graphite nodules in ductile
cast iron under various inoculation conditions. As can be seen from the table, the
number and mean size of nuclei particles are unaffected by the inoculant addition,
although the nodule characteristics obtained after solidification are strongly
dependent on the type of inoculant used. These findings will be discussed below.
The calculations used to generate these figures contain certain assumptions, but
one can safely conclude that:
- the number of nuclei per volume of melt is extremely high, and approximately one
order of magnitude larger than the number of graphite nodules actually nucleated;
- the ability of the particles to nucleate graphite is strongly affected by the inoculant
addition.
Trials using very pure ferrosilicon as an inoculant have demonstrated that it does not
have any nucleating effect for graphite 1,3,4 , as shown in Table 3.
The nucleant (e.g. Ca, Sr, Ba or Al) only needs a limited presence and it is beneficial
if the nucleant forms an alloy with the carrier. Also, the nucleant must have a limited
solubility in cast iron, and form stable compounds with the other elements forming the
nuclei particles (e.g. sulphur and oxygen). Good nucleation effect may be achieved if
the ferrosilicon contains small but controlled amounts of calcium, strontium or barium
in the range of 0.6 to 2.0%.
5.3 Composition of the Nuclei in Laboratory test results are used in this section to explain the role of calcium as an
Ductile Iron example of a trace element behaving as the nucleant in ferrosilicon. Calcium will
occur in ferrosilicon as a silicide (CaSi 2 ). Calcium has virtually no solubility in iron, and
reacts with components in the melt to form sulphides and oxides.
In magnesium treated cast irons, the inclusions contain mainly magnesium, calcium,
sulphur, silicon and oxygen. These are primary reaction products of the magnesium
treatment. The inclusions are composed of a sulphide core and a faceted outer silicate
shell. The sulphide core contains both MgS and CaS, while the outer shell consists of
complex magnesium silicates (e.g. MgO•SiO2, 2MgO•SiO2). These phases will not act
as potent nucleation sites for graphite during solidification because of a large nucleus/
graphite interfacial energy barrier.
5.4 Composition of nuclei in grey Recent research results have identified a three step nucleation process for generating
iron graphite flakes in grey iron. By means of electron microscope investigations, it has
been revealed that a nucleus for a graphite flake consists of a particle with a body
of manganese- and calcium- sulphide surrounding a nucleus core of complex
Al 2 O3 –XO oxides, see Figure 7. The core oxide contains elements such as calcium,
barium, strontium, zirconium, and rare earth elements. Towards the surface of the
manganese/calcium-sulphide body, even more complex compounds have been
observed on which the graphite has grown.
The hypothesis is that the oxides form as stable elements in the iron melt first.
Secondly, manganese and calcium sulphides grow on these oxides until a desired
size and a more complex faceted compound appears on the surface. The third step
is that the graphite starts to grow on this faceted surface and grows along its base
planes of hexagonal structure.
One interesting observation was that aluminium seems to play a key role in the
nucleation process in conjunction with other elements. Testing of iron with very low
levels of aluminium showed poorer performance than iron with a certain level of
aluminium. It can be concluded that final content of aluminium in grey iron should
be between 0.005 and 0.010% in order to maximise eutectic cell count in grey iron.
This aluminium content range is and has to be less than the 0.015-0.25% Al, as this
range for pin-hole susceptibility influenced by aluminium.
5.5 Specification of Inoculants The chemical composition and reliability of the analysis from lot to lot is important if
a ferroalloy is to be considered as a good and consistent inoculant. Many foundry
men insist on silicon and phosphorus analyses in pig iron, but pay little attention to
the analysis of an inoculant, or vice versa . The preceding paragraphs indicate quite
clearly that the minor constituents in ferroalloys, not the major constituents (usually
silicon), are critical for the performance as inoculants. All the Elkem inoculants are
alloys that have been smelted and alloyed to the quoted specifications, and with the
exception of Ultraseed, no further additions have to be mechanically blended with
the alloy. The analysis guaranteed by the specification ensures consistent inoculant
properties from lot to lot.
The inoculants listed in Table 4 differ by analysis, price and application. The foundry
experts of Elkem can give detailed information on each inoculant and its individual
features, and also suggestions as to the most suitable alloy for a specific foundry
condition.
5.5 Addition Technique Chemical considerations alone will not ensure satisfactory results since equal attention
must be paid to addition technique. For ladle inoculation this means a continuous
addition of inoculant to the stream of iron (normally added between one third and two
thirds of ladle tapping) so that the high turbulence encourages fast and homogeneous
distribution of the alloy. Stream inoculation may be practised, in conjunction with
automatic pouring furnaces, using finer sized grades of the above inoculants at lower
addition rates. Similarly, inoculant fade can be overcome by reducing the time interval
between the inoculant addition and solidification by placing the inoculant piece, or
insert, into the gating system. The reaction with liquid iron occurs within the mould and
this is known as in-mould inoculation.
Fading is the decrease in inoculation effect with increasing time taken to pour
inoculated iron. Elkem inoculants have been assessed against untreated reference
melts and even after 10 minutes the inoculation effect of the treated melt proved to
be good. Provided ladle inoculation has been carried out in a satisfactory way and
the ladle is not delayed for an excessive period before pouring, the need for mould
inoculation can be avoided in most cases.
6.1 Cooling Curves Cooling curves record the drop or increase in temperature with time as a consequence
of a change of energy within the system. A deviation from normal cooling indicates
the occurrence of a source of heat such as the heat of crystallization released by a
precipitating phase. The location of the inversion points on the generally S-shaped
cooling curve in the region of eutectic crystallization indicates the tendency of the
melt to solidify “grey” or “white”. A high level of nucleation promotes a higher arrest
temperature which, by avoiding the white eutectic, will result in less risk of carbide
formation.
Conversely, when the inversion point is at a low level on the cooling curve, there
will be a tendency for cementite to precipitate in place of graphite giving a “white”
structure. An increased cooling rate, as found in thin sections, will increase the degree
of undercooling which must be balanced by an increased number of active nuclei
to avoid the formation of white iron. In the iron-carbon system there is only a 7ºC
temperature interval between “grey” solidification and sufficient undercooling to cause
“white” solidification. In Figure 8 the cooling curve for an uninoculated reference melt
is compared with a curve from a melt inoculated with 0.25wt% inoculant addition.
The uninoculated melt shows inversion at 1145ºC whereas inversion occurs at 1162ºC
for the inoculated melt. This means that the uninoculated melt is undercooled by
20ºC and the inoculated melt by 3ºC, which gives “white” and “grey” solidification,
respectively.
6.2 Chill Testing The traditional method to determine the tendency of a melt to solidify “grey” and
“white” is by examining chill wedges. The larger the zone of white iron, the fewer the
number of nuclei that were active in initiating a “grey” solidification. Figure 9 shows
chill wedges from a foundry which had an average 11.2mm of chill for a period of two
week on uninoculated cupola iron. By adding 0.2% FeSi (85% Si), the average chill
depth was reduced and with 0.125% Superseed addition, the chill depth was reduced
even further.
6.3 Eutectic Cell Count The number of eutectic cells in grey irons can be determined on etched micro-
specimens. If an effective inoculant has been added to the melt, there will be a large
number of active nuclei to promote graphite precipitation at low undercooling during
solidification. This will be represented on the micro-specimen by a high cell count
for grey irons and a high nodule count for ductile irons. Table 5 shows the result
of cell counts after inoculation. The eutectic cell number increases as the inoculant
addition to the base melt is increased. Other factors, such as over-inoculation leading
to shrinkage proprensity, will influence the optimum inoculant addition.
Table 5: Eutectic cell count
(30mm round bars)
7. Fading of Inoculation
7.1 Principle Effects The effects of inoculation are at a maximum immediately after the addition of the
inoculant. The rate of inoculant fading, which depends upon the composition of the
inoculant and the condition of the iron to which it is added, may be very rapid and
much of the inoculating effect may be lost in the first few minutes after the addition.
The principal effects of fading are:
2) to reduce the number of nodules formed in ductile iron and to cause a deterioration in
their shape. If sufficiently severe, the deterioration in shape may affect the mechanical
properties of the casting;
3) to reduce the number of eutectic cells growing in flake graphite irons resulting in a
less uniform size distribution of graphite in the casting and a reduction in mechanical
properties.
There are some well established facts concerning fading which are of practical
significance:
2) there is no period after inoculation during which fading does not occur. To obtain
the maximum effect, metal should be cast as soon as possible after the addition of
inoculant;
Hence, the fading of inoculation can be explained by this coarsening of the inclusion
population with time. Due to the coarsening, the total number of possible nucleation
sites for graphite during solidification is reduced. Figure 10 shows a plot of the number
density of inclusions in cast iron as a function of holding time after inoculation.
7.3 Effects of Various Inclusions Inoculants lose their ability to reduce chill and nucleate graphite if the metal is held
for extended periods before casting. However, inoculants have different fading
characteristics. The barium-based inoculant Barinoc produces a high initial number of
nucleation sites throughout the holding period, thus making it an excellent inoculant
for ladle treatments. Foundrisil is an effective chill reducer for both low and high
sulphur grey irons as well as ductile irons. Another effective inoculant that maintains
the inoculation effect is the strontium-containing Superseed inoculant. Figure 11
shows the fading characteristics of some inoculants in cast iron.
8.1 Inoculation and Strength Inoculation increases the number of eutectic cells (or nodules) which leads to a finer
structure of the iron, and in particular, this will cause an increase in tensile strength
in hypoeutectic irons. Figure 12 shows the increase in tensile strength by adding an
inoculant.
8.2 Inoculation and Machinability Inoculation increases the number of potent nuclei which will promote graphite
nucleation at low undercooling; Improved machinability is achieved by inoculation
suppressing the formation of hard un-machinable white iron structures.Inoculation
also reduces section sensitivity. While uninoculated irons will show a wide variation in
hardness, inoculated grey or nodular cast irons will show more consistent hardness
values over a wide range of sections, Figure 13.
Figure 12: Increasing inoculant
additions improve tensile
strength. The final analyses of
these trial melts are identical
after inoculation.
The solidification of “grey” cast iron Unfortunately, inoculation changes the iron have been held for prolonged times
is characterized by the formation of a mode of solidification in such a way that before addition of the post inoculant.
skin type array of eutectic cells at the the rigidity of the “skin” is decreased. Such long hold times are well known to
mould/metal interface, followed by the Inoculant additions should not become reduce the overall capabilities of the iron
development of eutectic cells ahead of excessive to avoid shrinkage and yet the prior to inoculation resulting in so-called
the advancing solidification front. Newly addition should be adequate to ensure “dead” iron. Ultraseed inoculant will thus
formed graphite compensates partly “grey” solidification. Test specimens, reinstall good nucleation effectiveness
or fully for the liquid iron contraction, Figure 14, show that for an equivalent from reactions with its sulphur and
provided it precipitates within a relatively chill depth, the eutectic cell count will be oxygen content forming new nucleation
rigid “skin” which is characteristic of lower when using Superseed in place of sites.
uninoculated “grey” cast iron. However, inoculating grade ferrosilicon. The
if the mode of solidification is changed, lower cell count reduces the ferro-static Due to the powerful effects of Ultraseed
the good shrinkage characteristics can pressure on the mould and improves the inoculant on raising nodule count and
be jeopardized, especially if a rigid skin tendency to avoid shrinkage defects. improving chill protection, it has been
cannot be developed at the mould/metal found that the tendency to shrinkage
interface leaving the mould directly Since the eutectic cell count for nodular formation is also reduced with this
exposed to ferro-static pressure. cast iron is much higher than for grey iron, inoculant. Especially, the type of shrinkage
Eventually, the mould may yield under one would expect a greater shrinkage that often occurs as small porosities in
the ferro-static pressure from the tendency, and it is interesting to see that hot-spot sections of the complex castings;
remaining liquid, and the increased the solidification pattern is in fact similar appear to be effectively reduced or even
volume of the mould cavity becomes to over-inoculated grey iron. eliminated by Ultraseed inoculant. Figure
too great for compensation by graphite 15 shows an example of micro-shrinkage
precipitation at the end of solidification. Ultraseed inoculant has proven highly porosity that has been minimized by the
Some shrinkage may occur as a result of successful in providing fresh nucleation use of Ultraseed inoculant.
excessive dilation of the mould although sites to ductile irons of long holding time
mould geometry will have an influence. where the base iron or magnesium treated
Figure 14: Comparison of the eutectic cell Figure 15: Example of micro-shrinkage porosity in ductile iron casting that has been minimized by Ultraseed® inoculant (a)
count in 5mm sections at about equal chill compared to Manganese-Zirconium type inoculant (b)
depth (from BCIRA)
Based on a comprehensive understanding Recently, Preseed has been added to provides a sound base for the foundryman
of the mechanisms of inoculation the portfolio as a novel preconditioner to to select the appropriate inoculant for his
described in this brochure,Elkem has, enhance inoculation effect. foundry’s particular requirements.
over the years, evaluated many alternative
alloy analyses to develop the current For further information on Elkem’s
range of inoculants which includes the extensive range of inoculants, please
well established Superseed, Ultraseed, contact your local representative. The
Reseed and Alinoc. Development of new success of Elkem products worldwide
improved alloys goes on continuously. justifies their elaborate development and
References:
Elkem AS
Foundry Products Division
Hoffsveien 65B
P.O. Box 5211
Majorstua
N-0303, Oslo, Norway
Telephone : +47 22 45 01 00
Telefax : +47 22 45 01 52
www.foundry.elkem.com
Revised May 2009 © Copyright Elkem AS