bound in the material world. How the bondage take place is described in the 14th chapter. CCP:-
Although the modes were not talked before
but lord is saying bhuya-againg as the conclusion of the knowledge of the modes - bhakti is talked about previously. This chapter talks how/ why the munis take to the devotional service. Conclusion of this chapter is one should practice the devotional service. By getting the knowledge one will take to the devotional service out of the duty. LINK:- Krishna glorifies this knowledge. VERSE 14.2:-
Knowledge which is not contaminated by the
three modes of nature is called transcendental knowledge. To obtain such knowledge, one must develop all the spiritual qualities. One who thus develops the spiritual qualities is not affected either by the CHAPTER 14 THE THREE MODES OF MATERIAL NATURE creation or by the destruction of the material world. Tad viñëoù paramaà padaà sadä paçyanti sürayaù: the devotees always see the supreme form of Viñëu. (Åg Veda 1.22.20, Gopäla Täpané Upaniñad) CCP:-
Philosophy should also be taken shelter of,
not to be approached in the mood of the controlling. Krishna cannot be conquered by the intellect. One studies to get the release and relief from the material complexities. Spiritual knowledge should not be treated as the crown but as the umbrella to protect from the material suffering, crown cannot protect from the rain but the umbrella can protect so the spiritual knowledge is not for the show off. We fall in love not conquer in love, we want to love the Krishna not conquer him so by the intellect we should surrender to the Krishna not conquer him. Mama sadharmyam means attaining the same nature, that is one will go beyond the CHAPTER 14 THE THREE MODES OF MATERIAL NATURE bodily conception and so there will be no suffering of the birth and the death. VERSE 14.3:-
In order to explain how the contact of the
jéva with the guëas through beginningless ignorance creates bondage, the Lord speaks about the method of appearance of the field and knower of the field. My (Supreme Lord’s) place of impregnation is prakåti, called mahat, because it extends through all place and time continuously. It is called brahma because it is the cause of increase (root is båh). brahma näma-rüpam annaà ca jäyate: this brahma becomes name, form and food, (Muëòaka Upaniñad 1.9) What was called dull prakåti with the words bhumir apo ’nalo vayuù, described as earth, water and other elements, is here called mahad brahman. What was called conscious prakåti with the word itas tv anyäm is here called the garbha, since it is the seed of all living entities. CCP:-
Here the word brahma refers to the material
nature. CHAPTER 14 THE THREE MODES OF MATERIAL NATURE LINK; - same concept with the different emphasis. VERSE 14.4:- CCP:-
Difference in these two verses is that in
14.4 it is said that by the grace of the lord all the living entities take birth and in the 14.3 emphasis was to bring the lord in the picture. BG gives the skeletal outline not the details; here lord is talking about what happens at the creation not about the individual birth. Soul contacts the matter by the insemination of the lord. LINK:- how the modes bind the soul. VERSE 14.5:- CCP:-
Three modes are born from the material
nature. They are eternal they don’t become old, deteriorated. Modes are not just the concepts but they are subtle things. They are ontological things. CHAPTER 14 THE THREE MODES OF MATERIAL NATURE We have to harmonize them by the intellectual understanding. Their existence being subtle we have to perceive them accordingly. They are the subtle reality which causes the interaction of the consciousness and the subtle matter. In passion one acts without thinking much, in ignorance one shrinks. Staircase are the root by which the person will go up and down but it is up to the person where to go similarly the modes once we choose the particular mode the n we are helpless we have to decide which way to act. LINK:- getting introduced to the modes. VERSE 14.6:-
The effect of developing the mode of
goodness in the material world is that one becomes wiser than those otherwise conditioned. This sense of happiness is due to understanding that, in the mode of goodness, one is more or less free from sinful reactions. The difficulty here is that when a living entity is situated in the mode of goodness he becomes conditioned to feel that he is CHAPTER 14 THE THREE MODES OF MATERIAL NATURE advanced in knowledge and is better than others. In this way he becomes conditioned. The association of the jéva with happiness, which is the product of peacefulness, and the association of the jéva with knowledge, which is the product of illumination (prakäçakam), produce the mistaken identity of “I am happy, I am learned.” prakäça-sukha-käraëaà sattvam: the cause of illumination and happiness is sattva. CCP:-
As one chooses the particular mode then
accordingly the way is created- so the goodness is said to be liberating, frees from the sinful reactions. But negative side of the goodness is that it binds by the knowledge and the happiness. This is bondage whether by the iron or the golden chain. VERSE 14.7:-
Rajo-guëa binds up the soul (dehinam) by
attachment (saìgena) to actions, in quest of present and future goals. Attachment to action arises by desire and attachment (tåñëa and saìga). CHAPTER 14 THE THREE MODES OF MATERIAL NATURE Rajas give rise to the desire for sense objects (tåñëa) such as sound, and the desire for association (saìga) with sons, friends and others. CCP:-
Passion brings the attachment to what one
has and the trishna to what one doesn’t have. One becomes bound as he has to work to attain what he wants. Family is the primary impetus for the people to work. The modes will give us the different definition of the success, in passion the success is enjoyment, possession but in the goodness they think about the character, knowledge. A devotee has to live in such society in different understanding of the success. VERSE 14.8:- CCP:-
This is self perpetuating vicious cycle when
we act in the ignorance then it produces more ignorance- mode of ignorance is born of ignorance-like trying to solve the CHAPTER 14 THE THREE MODES OF MATERIAL NATURE difficulty by the drinking-ignorance leading to the ignorance. Mohanam sarva dehinam- mode of ignorance which affects everyone, necessary contact with the ignorance but the aggravation with the ignorance is not good. LINK: - Krishna gives the summary. VERSE 14.9:- CCP:-
In sattva one is bound by the happiness and
in the passion one is bound by the action and in the ignorance one is bound in the carelessness. LINK: - how there is competition between the modes. VERSE 14.10:-
The prominence of some certain mode of
nature is manifested in one's dealings, in his activities, in eating, etc. if one wants, he can develop, by practice, the mode of goodness and thus defeat the modes of ignorance and passion. if one is determined he can be blessed by the mode of goodness, and by transcending the mode of goodness he can be situated in CHAPTER 14 THE THREE MODES OF MATERIAL NATURE pure goodness, which is called the Väsudeva state, a state in which one can understand the science of God. By the manifestation of particular activities, it can be understood in what mode of nature one is situated. The nature of the guëas is that they appear and disappear according to operation or exhaustion of old karmas. CCP:-
Person feels unsteady as the modes are
acting in different way at the different time. Modes are not static they change with the time of the day. Mode of passion creates the restlessness. Mode of ignorance is characterized by the lethargy. Spiritual life is for the relaxation by the purification not by the inaction/deactivation. The conflicts of the modes are the underlying cause of the all conflicts the people face. Thoughtfulness and the dragging of the thing are not the same. CHAPTER 14 THE THREE MODES OF MATERIAL NATURE Goodness is contemplative and active; passion is simply active, not very contemplative ignorance not active and not contemplative. Externally goodness and the ignorance may look the same but internally they are radically opposite. Sometime passion protects one from the ignorance, walking, washing the face helps one to avoid the ignorance. We will have to continuously choose the goodness; accordingly our life will move forward. Our feeling may change but we will have to choose goodness consistently. LINK: - when the particular mode is prominent how the person behaves/acts. VERSE 14.11:-
In the mode of goodness, one can see things
in the right position, one can hear things in the right position, and one can taste things in the right position. One becomes cleansed inside and outside. In every gate there is development of the symptoms of happiness, and that is the position of goodness. CHAPTER 14 THE THREE MODES OF MATERIAL NATURE In every gate there is development of the symptoms of happiness, and that is the position of goodness. CCP:-
When there is light one can see the things
as they are. Knowledge illuminates the things; by the goodness one can understand the things. When senses are illuminated one understands how to act. In mode of passion one eats for the taste. VERSE 14.12:-
One in the mode of passion is never
satisfied with the position he has already acquired; he hankers to increase his position. CCP:-
In passion there is greed which is most
prominent, wanting more when directed to the opposite sex it is lust when directed to the things it is greed. Modes are the matter of both the imposition and the disposition. We are forced to act as we choose to desire. CHAPTER 14 THE THREE MODES OF MATERIAL NATURE We have the choice to choose but once selected then we will be carried by the selected mode. Mode of passion will make us agitated whatever the situation may be. Certain places have particular influence. Today’s world people have the one- dimensional existence they become workaholics and don’t have the time for the other aspect of the life, spiritual life. Work holism indicates that the person is gripped by the mode of passion. Sometime the passion is required but it should not be common practice. In the mode of passion a person is never satisfied with what he has. Things should be planned, not just doing things randomly at the whims of the mind. VERSE 14.13:- CCP:-
Kurunandan is used to tell that though you
have strong connection but these modes can affect anyone. Sadism is causing the pain to others and masochism is inflicting pain to oneself. CHAPTER 14 THE THREE MODES OF MATERIAL NATURE In the ignorance even the sex gets perverted. In ignorance there is not only the mohah about ones spiritual identity but about the material things also. LINK: - Krishna describes the different deaths the people go through and the destination one attains thereafter. Effects of the binding by the modes 14- Long term effect. 15- Medium term effect. 16- Immediate effect. VERSE 14.14:-
CCP:-
Pralaya can refer to final destruction at
the end of Brahmas life and it also can mean the death of the individual person. Those who live in knowledge in this life gain further knowledge in the next life. Devatas are in the goodness as compared to the earthly planets but they are not in the goodness as compared to the transcendence. CHAPTER 14 THE THREE MODES OF MATERIAL NATURE Within goodness also there are levels; it is not homogeneous but the spectrum. LINK: - what happens when one lives in the passion and the ignorance. VERSE 14.15:- CCP:-
There are thoughts about the population
increase as they think that the life is only on the earth planet but life is everywhere. Souls may go from one planet to others so increase in the population is not the creation of the new soul. Passion is the spectrum the Ksatriya are in the passion but in the upper side of the passion. Reverse transmigration- the soul from the human being can degrade to the animal species, but there is opinion that it doesn’t happen due to some people tried to integrate with the understanding of the other religion. Reincarnation harmonizes with the idea of the merciful god, single life and then permanent hell is harsh understanding. CHAPTER 14 THE THREE MODES OF MATERIAL NATURE There is no intrinsic connection in the body and the soul but there is intrinsic connection in the soul and the lord. To integrate the understanding of the Christianity and the Hinduism some people came up with the idea of the progressive reincarnation that the soul doesn’t go back to low specie once it comes to the human form but that is not true. They cite the evidence that no has remembered the past life as the animal but they have remembered as being the human always but “the absence of the truth is not the proof of the absence”. Changing from animal or lower species to the human is radical change so they may not remember the past. Vedic view spiritualizes the all living being but in the abrahmic world view they just spiritualizes the human existence and all other are regarded as not having soul, the central idea of the Christian view is that they try to get that the only Jesus will redeem. LINK ;- Krishna gives the intermediate result of living in the various modes. VERSE 14.16:- CHAPTER 14 THE THREE MODES OF MATERIAL NATURE Brähmaëas are the symbol of spiritual education, and cows are the symbol of the most valuable food; these two living creatures, the brähmaëas and the cows, must be given all protection—that is real advancement of civilization. In modern human society, spiritual knowledge is neglected, and cow killing is encouraged. It is to be understood, then, that human society is advancing in the wrong direction and is clearing the path to its own condemnation. A civilization which guides the citizens to become animals in their next lives is certainly not a human civilization. CCP:-
One attains the purification by the action
in the mode of the goodness. The result of one’s action in the particular mode can even be seen in this life also. There is no question of the spiritual advancement in the mode of the passion and the mode of ignorance. As passion causes the increased bodily identification and hankering for the happiness outside. Killing the cows is the most sinful life. CHAPTER 14 THE THREE MODES OF MATERIAL NATURE Question is not what one belief but how one lives. LINK: - now lord talks about the immediate result. VERSE 14.17:-
Even if the majority of the people aren't
happy and prosperous, if a certain percentage of the population develops Kåñëa consciousness and becomes situated in the mode of goodness, then there is the possibility for peace and prosperity all over the world. If one wants happiness at all, his money will not help him; he has to elevate himself to the mode of goodness by practicing Kåñëa consciousness. CCP:-
Krishna is not saying that by the study one
gets the knowledge study is not all in all the goodness helps to cultivate knowledge, if we want knowledge then we have to develop the goodness. Passion causes the agitation, dissatisfaction, hankering, greed. CHAPTER 14 THE THREE MODES OF MATERIAL NATURE If one is in the passion then money will not make him happy, as there is no satisfaction, always looking for the things others have. Devotee need not give up the money but the illusion that the money will make him happy. LINK :-Krishna gives the generic understanding. VERSE 14.18:-
In the mode of passion, there is also the
chance of becoming mad in the next life. CCP:-
Krishna doesn’t even call the ignorance but
refers as the jaghanya guna vritti, abominable mode. “Up “here refers to the higher planets and also to the higher consciousness. Down refers to the lower planets and also the lower species of life. VERSE 14.19:-
One can transcend all the activities of the
modes of material nature simply by understanding them properly by learning from the proper souls. CHAPTER 14 THE THREE MODES OF MATERIAL NATURE For one who is able to see things as they are, the influence of material nature gradually ceases. CCP:-
If one understands that the mode are like
the rope which are making the person act like the ropes in the puppeteer strings then he can get liberated. We have to protect ourselves by understanding that the actions are because of the modes, like getting attracted to the opposite sex one has to understand that this is due to passion not me the spirit soul. LINK: - Krishna describes the further element in this. VERSE 14.20:-
Although one is within this material body,
by his advancement in spiritual knowledge he can be free from the influence of the modes of nature. Devotional service in Kåñëa consciousness is the sign of liberation from material entanglement. CCP:- CHAPTER 14 THE THREE MODES OF MATERIAL NATURE When one goes beyond the modes then he goes beyond the miseries of the birth, death, old age and disease which with the body. Amritam here refers to the eternality, immortality. Heavenly nector increases the life span but it doesn’t make one immortal. By transcending the modes one will attain the immortality. LINK; - Arjuna is asking how one can transcend the modes and attain the destination beyond the modes. VERSE 14.21:- CCP:-
Linga means characteristics/ gender here
first meaning applies. Linga is internal characteristics and the acarah is the external behavior. Q. characteristics of one transcended the modes/ his behavior/how one can transcend the modes. VERSE 14.22-25:-
Kåñëa first indicates that a person
transcendentally situated has no envy and does not hanker for anything. CHAPTER 14 THE THREE MODES OF MATERIAL NATURE When one is conscious of the material body, he acts only for sense gratification, but when one transfers the consciousness to Kåñëa, sense gratification automatically stops. CCP:-
Verses 23and the 24 answers the
characteristics of one who has transcended the modes. The person beyond the modes doesn’t resent the effect of the modes when they are present and don’t hanker when they are not present. One observes and understand the appearance of the modes but doesn’t get affected. Krishna is telling to observe our thoughts, to observe inner world. Everything inner doesn’t mean spiritual so a devotee can have the bad thoughts due to previous conditioning. Only when we get excited by the thought then the thought can overcome us, we should just observe the thoughts and say no to them. Just observe the thoughts and let them go with the time they will stop coming. Way to observe our thoughts is to cultivate some goodness. CHAPTER 14 THE THREE MODES OF MATERIAL NATURE By observing the thoughts and the internal status and avoiding the unfavorable we can move forward in the spiritual life. Like observing the external world we can train ourselves to observe the inner world. Observing the thoughts should not lead to the depression, spiritual principles are meant to for flying not to burden ourselves. We should observe the sequence of the thoughts in particular incident, what lead to commit the mistake. If not at the moment we can be observer at later time. To know how the mind is cheating us we should observe thoughts. Observe the thoughts in retrospection if not in the action, we practice we can do it in the action also. Becoming conscious of our thoughts is very helpful, it is being the conscious of our conscious. Ninda and the stuti is what others are speaking and man and apaman is what we perceive. All the duality is created by the material nature and the person beyond the modes is not affected and one who wants to be not affected should try to go beyond the modes. CHAPTER 14 THE THREE MODES OF MATERIAL NATURE VERSE 14.26:-
niraïjanaù paramaà sämyam upaiti: being free
of contamination, he attains similarity with the supreme (Muëòaka Upaniñad 3.1.3) CCP:-
here vyabhichar means distraction.
This is the only verse in the BG which directly mentions bhakti yoga. This refers to the uninterrupted bhakti but not the bhakti which is unmotivated. For the devotee Krishna is not just the object of the meditation but also the objective of the meditation. For the jnana Krishna is the object of the meditation and the bhakti is the tool to attain the goal. Modes don’t shackle us completely they give some leverage. We may not be able to practice the unbreakable bhakti now only but we can practice as much uninterrupted as possible. LINK: - we are not just meant to attain the understanding of the Brahman but ultimately of the bhagavan VERSE 14.27:- CHAPTER 14 THE THREE MODES OF MATERIAL NATURE the Viñëu Dharmottara, concerning the subject of Naraka Dvädaçé, it is said: prakåtau puruñe caiva brahmaëyäpi ca sa prabhuù yathaika eva puruño väsudevo vyavasthitaù
The Lord, one person, Väsudeva is situated
in prakåti, the jéva and the Brahman. yathäcyutas tvam parataù parasmät sa brahmabhütät parataù parätmä
Just as Acyuta, Paramätmä is superior to all
others, he is superior to Brahman. Viñëu Dharma 26.13. The Lord speaks to Arjuna in relation to bringing back the children of the brähmaëa in Hari Vaàça, Viñëu Parvä 114: tat param paramam brahma sarvam vibhajate jagat mamaiva tad ghanam tejo jnätum arhasi bhärata. yasya prabhä prabhavato jagad-aëòa-koöi- koöéñv açeña-vasudhädi-vibhüti-bhinnam tad brahma niñkalam anantam açeña-bhütaà govindam ädi-puruñaà tam ahaà bhajämi CHAPTER 14 THE THREE MODES OF MATERIAL NATURE I serve the Supreme Personality of Godhead Govinda, the primeval Lord, whose transcendental bodily effulgence, known as the brahmajyoti, which is unlimited, unfathomed and all-pervasive, is the cause of the creation of unlimited numbers of planets, etc., with varieties of climates and specific conditions of life. Brahma Saàhitä 5.40 madéyaà mahimänaàc ca para-brahmeti çabditam vetsyasy anugåhétaà me sampraçnair vivåtaà hådi
You will be thoroughly advised and favored
by Me, and because of your inquiries, everything about My glories, which are known as param brahma, will be manifest within your heart. Thus you will know everything about Me. SB 8.24.38 Madhusüdana Sarasvaté offers his praise to Kåñëa: paräkåta-mano-dvandvaà paraà brahma naräkåti saundarya-sära-sarvasvaà vande nandätmajaà mahaù
I offer my respects to the son of Nanda,
joy personified, the very essence of all CHAPTER 14 THE THREE MODES OF MATERIAL NATURE beauty in human form, the supreme Brahman, devoid of dualities of the mind. raso vai saù, rasaà hy eväyaà labdhvänandé bhavati
The Lord is rasa. Attaining Him, the
embodiment of rasa, one becomes blissful. Taittiréya Upaniñad 2.7.1 CCP:-
Pratishta- means foundation here; lord is
saying that he is the foundation of the Brahman. Here Krishna is clearly explaining that the personal reality is higher than the Brahman reality. Bhaktyanand is higher than the brahmanand as it is the platform of the emotional fulfillment on the level of the transcendence. We don’t just have to know that I’m Brahman but we have to act on that platform and that acting on that platform is devotional service. By coming on the platform of the brahman one understands that I’m spirit.
9780190200718.oxford University Press, Incorporated - Chan Whip Anthology - A Companion To Zen Practice, The - Broughton, Jeffrey L., Watanabe, Elise Yoko - Nov, 2014