Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
https://theintercept.com/2017/12/05/drone-strikes-israel-us-military-isvis/ 1/11
12/23/2017 This Israeli Presentation on How to Make Drone Strikes More “Efficient” Disturbed Its Audience
The presenter of the drone material, Yuval Zak, told the Intercept he
was surprised by the audience reaction and hostile questioning after
his presentation. “The conversation changed from dealing with
visualization and improving information presentation on a … map to
a discussion about the ethical issues of using drones,” he wrote in an
email. “But the focus of the conference and my paper is entirely
https://theintercept.com/2017/12/05/drone-strikes-israel-us-military-isvis/ 2/11
12/23/2017 This Israeli Presentation on How to Make Drone Strikes More “Efficient” Disturbed Its Audience
“What is gained and what is lost in the transition from data, through
images, to insights?” read the ISVIS manifesto. The programming
looked thoughtful and sharp, covering topics from storytelling and
journalism to political activism and aesthetics. One session promised
to explain how “for museum curators it is imperative to learn,
analyze, and understand the behavior patterns of the visitors,” in
part through “recent developments in the field of indoor positioning
systems.”
These were the sorts of urgent, necessary questions that Zak ignored.
His presentation focused on nuts and bolts, presuming that drone
warfare ought to be made more efficient in the first place. His slides
indicated his work was part of a “research collaboration between
Ben-Gurion University,” the Israeli military, and the U.S. Research,
Development, and Engineering Command’s Army Research,
https://theintercept.com/2017/12/05/drone-strikes-israel-us-military-isvis/ 3/11
12/23/2017 This Israeli Presentation on How to Make Drone Strikes More “Efficient” Disturbed Its Audience
https://theintercept.com/2017/12/05/drone-strikes-israel-us-military-isvis/ 4/11
12/23/2017 This Israeli Presentation on How to Make Drone Strikes More “Efficient” Disturbed Its Audience
for the purposes of killing and destruction, a place that you’ve been
transforming by said killing and destruction? Therein lies a main
problem of drone warfare, relying heavily on sensor-laden robots that
are still operated by humans with finite memories and with visual
processing easily confused by rubble and ruin. This is where Zak’s
research comes in. He explained in his remarks that the goal of his
research was “at the end of the day, to improve the efficiency of
unmanned drone operators in the army in their missions.”
The issue at hand, then, boils down to one with which an MBA
candidate or Deloitte consultant might grapple: How can our
organization make sense of an over-abundance of data and increase
employee productivity by leveraging 21st century software
techniques? The only difference here is that the organization in
question is interested in the business of killing, and an increase in
employee productivity means killing more easily. Israel’s record of
civilian deaths in the course of its unmanned drone campaigns is
already well-documented.
The drone operators Zak has been working with, he said, were
particularly tickled by this visualization because there are missions
during which “they follow a vehicle and … sometimes lose it,
because you go into some kind of a cloud, and then they get out of
the cloud, and they want to know ‘OK, we’ve lost the target, and
there was a junction, so where do we look for it?’”
It’s unclear where the data necessary for such a narrow prediction is
coming from, and it’s not the only example of its kind Zak trotted
out. Other visualizations under consideration by the Israeli-American
research team include one for following individuals as they might
flee on foot, in which drone operators would receive a colorful visual
display of “the probability of entering and exiting each door in each
building,” designated by arrows of varying thickness, and a system
for tracking a “permanent target” like Ismail Haniyeh, senior Hamas
leader and former Palestinian Authority head. For people like
Haniyeh, Zak said “we can build a movement grid for him, where the
places where he was and the probabilities are shown via the
thickness of the lines or of those dots.” The “surveillance grid for an
https://theintercept.com/2017/12/05/drone-strikes-israel-us-military-isvis/ 6/11
12/23/2017 This Israeli Presentation on How to Make Drone Strikes More “Efficient” Disturbed Its Audience
Zak quickly lost the crowd.“I think no one in the room really
expected this,” Zer-Aviv told The Intercept. Sure enough, according to
a transcript of the Q&A session following Zak’s talk, the first question
was actually a denunciation: “I’m just saying that when you hurt so
many people, not all of whom are Ismail Haniyeh, for these purposes,
we can look a bit less self-satisfied,” an audience member said. “Not
everything is inherently honorable.”
In his reply, Zak sidestepped the ethical issues, stating that, “In the
big picture, our job is to make the work of a drone operator more
efficient.” He added that his visualization work would not take two
targets and determine “that one has to be destroyed and that one
not.” This role, he said, is made “by people who … view video screens
and evaluate the situation based on that.”
Top photo: A picture shows an Israeli army unmanned aerial vehicle landing in an airfield,
in the Israeli-annexed Golan Heights, on Jan. 20, 2015, two days after an Israeli airstrike
killed six Hezbollah members in the Syrian-controlled side of the Golan Heights.
👆
We depend on the support of readers like you to help keep our
nonprofit newsroom strong and independent. Join Us ⟶
RELATED
https://theintercept.com/2017/12/05/drone-strikes-israel-us-military-isvis/ 8/11
12/23/2017 This Israeli Presentation on How to Make Drone Strikes More “Efficient” Disturbed Its Audience
https://theintercept.com/2017/12/05/drone-strikes-israel-us-military-isvis/ 9/11
12/23/2017 This Israeli Presentation on How to Make Drone Strikes More “Efficient” Disturbed Its Audience
https://theintercept.com/2017/12/05/drone-strikes-israel-us-military-isvis/ 10/11
12/23/2017 This Israeli Presentation on How to Make Drone Strikes More “Efficient” Disturbed Its Audience
https://theintercept.com/2017/12/05/drone-strikes-israel-us-military-isvis/ 11/11