Documenti di Didattica
Documenti di Professioni
Documenti di Cultura
Abstract: This paper presents an engineering study on the Although Venturi tubes are very simple and well known
development of an electronic flow meter based in a Venturi primary elements for flow rate measurements, a complete
tube as primary flow element. The mechanical design of the understanding of fluid flow phenomena trough Venturi tubes
transducer is described with respect to its dimensional and is far from being accomplished. With the improvement of
constructive details, aided by computational flow simulation instrumentation, hardware and software tools, the study on
results for liquids and gases. Some original design Venturi tubes, as in other fields, has produced several recent
characteristics of the transducer are described in the paper publications, staying an active field of research.
such as built in chambers for pressure averaging. A
Flow measurement of two-phase by differential pressure
preliminary electronic design for the Venturi transducer is
elements has motivated different researches [1-4].
also presented in the paper, considering the use of a
Applications such as wet gas flow measurement occurring
commercial transducer for differential pressure
for example in natural gas processing, requires special
measurement, incorporated to the Venturi transducer body.
correlations for the discharge coefficient [5-7].
An experimental planning for static calibration is discussed
in order to determine characteristics related to discharge Even in the case of single-phase flows, the occurrence of
coefficient change with Reynolds number and contraction mixtures, as for instance water-oil, can affect in a significant
ratio. Future application of the proposed Venturi transducer way the performance of a flow meter, requiring an special
will be made for flow rate measurements in actual approach [8]. Another aspect is related to flow
applications both in liquid and gas phases, in order to measurements of gases [9-11].
validate the proposed design as a commercial flow
measurement product. With respect to the dimensional design of primary
differential pressure flow rate elements, such as the Venturi
Keywords: Venturi, Instrumentation, Flow tube, the influence of geometrical and constructive aspects
outside standard definitions has been considered in several
works [12-15].
1. INTRODUCTION
Another aspect of critical importance for accurate
Flow meter devices based on pressure drop elements are measurements is related to the flow conditions upstream the
largely used in several different applications such as natural differential pressure flow element. In this field, researches
gas processing, pipeline transport of multiphase mixtures in are being carried out in order to investigate the performance
the petroleum industry, mixtures of oils, water and gas of different flow conditioners [16-18].
produced from wells, etc. Among the devices available for
However, in spite of all the related research work, two
pressure drop based flow measurements, Venturi tubes
research topics still almost unexplored: flow measurement
represent a simple and cost effective solution. However, in
of refrigerant fluids in refrigeration systems and the
spite of its general application, Venturi elements are still of
engineering design of differential pressure based electronic
limited use, being restricted to application where accuracy is
flow transducers. In the refrigeration field, some aspects
not the main concern.
such as, superheating and subcooling degrees influence in
Recently, with the expansion of natural gas use in Brazil, the persisting existence of liquid drops and gas bubbles and
especially in those regions not served by gas distribution influence of lubricant compressor oil mixed with refrigerant,
network, an important demand on low cost accurate means in flow measurement accuracy [19-20] requires much more
for gas consumption monitoring has occurred. Although investigations.
there are different commercial measurement solutions for
such flow monitoring task in the market, they are all based
in imported technologies and have high relative cost. Then, 2. FLOW MEASUREMENT ASPECTS
there is both a need and opportunity for applied One of the most widely used flow meter principle involves
technological research leading to national flow measurement the use of a fixed are flow restriction in a pipe or duct in
products answering the industry needs. order to cause a pressure drop varying with the flow rate. In
this section, basic considerations related with Venturi tubes fluid – temperature, pressure and density. In this case, Eqs.
for flow measurements are presented. (1) to (2) are modified by the introduction of a new
correction factor to take effects of compressibility into
The choice for a Venturi in the present work is due to the
account. This refers to the use of a compressibility factor ε,
fact that it allow some economical advantage with respect to
introduced in previous equations, to compute mass flow rate
other pressure drop meters (as orifice plates for example) in
as,
measuring larger flow rates, where power losses and
operating costs may be reduced. π ⋅d2 2∆pρ
m& = Cd ⋅ ε ⋅ ⋅ (4)
2.1. Venturi Flow Fundamentals 4 1− β 4
Venturi tubes (Fig. 1) as other pressure drop meters finds A simplified representation of the compressibility factor can
great application, mainly because of its simplicity, its low be obtained by considering ideal gas behavior and an
cost and great volume of data available for predicting its isentropic process between states 1 and 2, which allow to
behavior. write,
1 2 1
kr 2 k 1 − β 4 1 − r (k −1) k 2
Flow ε =
1 − r
(4)
k − 1 1 − β r
4 2k
D d
where, k is the gas isentropic exponent and r is the pressure
ratio defined r=p2/p1.
Fig. 1. Basic Venturi configuration.
In the case of one-dimensional, incompressible, frictionless 2.2. Flow Measurements Standards
fluid flow without heat transfer or elevation changes, energy
International standard ISO 5167-1:1991[22] in its Brazilian
and mass conservations principles applied to the fluid
version NBR ISO 5167-1 [23] are the main code for
between sections 1 and 2, allow to express volume flow rate,
reference in measurement of fluid flow by means of pressure
after some substitutions, as [21],
differential devices, such as orifice plates, nozzles and
π ⋅d2 1 2 ∆p Venturi tubes.
V&th = ⋅ ⋅ (1)
4 1− β 4 ρ With respect to machined classical Venturis (Fig. 2) the
Standard applies for d, β and ReD ranging from 50 to 250
or in terms of mass flow rate, multiplying each side of Eq. 1 mm; 0.40 to 0.75, and 2.105 to 106, respectively. For such
by the fluid density, conditions a standard Venturi can be used assuming a
Cd=0.995, with an uncertainty on this value about 1.0 %.
π ⋅d2 1 Otherwise, the Standard establishes that effects of β, ReD
m& th = ⋅ ⋅ 2 ∆p ρ (2)
and k/D on Cd are not well known.
4 1− β 4
Pressure
where, Taps
p1 p2
V&th theoretical volumetric flow rate [m3/s]
∆p = p1 − p2 pressure drop between sections 1 and 2 [Pa] Flow
0,10
Fig. 3. Mechanical construction of the Venturi transducer.
No Conditioner
Some particular aspects of the design are related to: (1) a Kf Etoile 2D
New Conditioner 2D
three parts construction adopted in order to include two
piezometric chambers for pressure averaging at each section,
0,05
(2) a possible interchangeable of the transducer core,
allowing change of the contraction factor, (3) a built-in
pressure sensor for pressure drop measurement and (4)
flanged connections at both ends for easy mounting at
different installations. 0,00
z/D
0 50 100
3.2. Flow Conditioner Design
One important concern for adequate performance of the 0,10
Venturi flow transducer is related to the strong influence of No Conditioner
Kfm Etoile 2D
the fluid velocity profile on the flow measurement. This is New Conditioner 2D
normally solved with the use of some flow conditioner
device installed upstream the flow meter. Such a flow
0,05
conditioner reduces the effect of flow perturbations such as
swirl, cross-flow, and asymmetry can produce relevant
systematic errors, while allowing more compact
installations.
0,00
Several different flow conditioner devices are available z/D
0 50 100
being classified in two main groups [17]: turbulent mixing
and whirling action conditioners. In this work, a New design
Fig. 5. Flatness efficiency parameters Kf and Kfm [18].
flow conditioner which has shown, from numeric analysis, a
Analyzing the values for parameter Kf, we see that the Etoile (β=50 mm/ 25 mm) and for the above mentioned Reynolds
2D conditioner has a better efficiency after z/D=20D. In number the discharge coefficient is 0.97, resulting in a
terms of the angular momentum Kfm, the New conditioner deviation of about 1,5 %.
presents a better efficiency up to a distance of 35D. With 0,980
respect to axial vortex parameters Kv and Kvm, the New
conditioner presents better efficiency than the Etoile 2D 0,970
conditioner, with a significant vortex reduction at 10D with
the New conditioner. On the other hand, the Etoile 2D 0,960
conditioner has the same swirl number Kvm as the New
Cp
0,950
conditioner after a distance of 40D.
0,940
0,02 Beta 0.3
No Conditioner
Kv Etoile 2D 0,930 Beta 0.5
New Conditioner 2D Beta 0.7
0,920
4000 24000 44000 64000
0,01 Re
P T
AmpOp Filter µC
flow adjustment Discharge valve
R1 R2
valve
Pump Reservoir